KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Your French Rental Is Rated G and You Live in America: The 2025 Rental Ban, the Works You Must Order From Abroad, and What Your Tenant Can Force a Judge to Do

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Your French Rental Is Rated G and You Live in America: The 2025 Rental Ban, the Works You Must Order From Abroad, and What Your Tenant Can Force a Judge to Do

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

Your Paris property manager writes that the new diagnostic de performance énergétique — the DPE, France’s mandatory energy-performance rating — puts your rental apartment in class G, the worst grade on the French scale. The tenant’s lease ends in three months, the manager says no new lease can be signed, and the tenant is already talking about a lawyer. You live in Chicago, the apartment is 6,000 kilometers away, and every participant in the conversation seems to assume you know what a class G means under French law. This article explains exactly where you stand: why a G rating blocks you from putting the apartment back on the rental market since January 1, 2025, what your tenant can and cannot force a French judge to order while you are abroad, and the two practical paths — renovate from America or sell with the mandatory energy audit — with the court decisions, statutes, verified figures, and tax reporting that each path requires.

I. Why a G Rating Freezes Your Rental Business in France

A. How American Owners Discover That a G Rating Blocks Any New Lease

The DPE is not an American-style home inspection. Under Article L.126-26 of the Code de la construction et de l’habitation, “Le diagnostic de performance énergétique d’un bâtiment ou d’une partie de bâtiment est un document qui comporte la quantité d’énergie effectivement consommée ou estimée, exprimée en énergie primaire et finale, ainsi que les émissions de gaz à effet de serre induites, pour une utilisation standardisée du bâtiment”. In plain terms, a certified technician feeds the apartment’s insulation, windows, heating, and hot-water equipment into a standardized software model and the apartment comes out with two grades — energy use in kilowatt-hours per square meter per year and greenhouse-gas emissions — combined into a single letter from A (best) to G (worst). The scale itself is fixed by Article L.173-1-1 of the same code, which lists the classes from “Extrêmement performants Classe A” down to “Extrêmement peu performants Classe G”, with the numerical thresholds set by ministerial order (“Un arrêté des ministres chargés de la construction et de l’énergie définit les seuils”).

Since the 2021 reform the DPE is legally enforceable against the person who ordered it, which is why a wrong grade can cost tens of thousands of euros, as the Le Mans case below shows. And since January 1, 2025, dwellings rated G — the passoires thermiques, or “thermal sieves” — can no longer be offered for rent. A March 2026 French court decision states the rule bluntly: “Ces logements sont interdits à la location depuis le 1er janvier 2025” (Tribunal judiciaire du Mans, referee order of March 20, 2026, RG No. 25/00519, full decision on courdecassation.fr). The next step of the calendar is already set: reporting in the French press confirms that class F dwellings will face the same rental ban in January 2028, and the statute already provides that “A compter du 1er janvier 2028, le niveau de performance… des bâtiments ou parties de bâtiment à usage d’habitation est compris entre les classes A et E” (Article L.173-2 of the Code de la construction et de l’habitation). The official Service-Public notice confirms the policy: “Les passoires thermiques les moins bien isolées ne peuvent plus être mises en location” (service-public.gouv.fr, actualité A17975).

Three consequences follow for an American owner. First, the ban applies to signing a new lease: when the current tenant gives notice or the lease ends without renewal, you cannot re-let the apartment as a G. Second, the lease already running continues — the tenant keeps the right to stay under the existing contract, and it is you, not the tenant, who must solve the problem. Third, the DPE must appear in the technical file handed to the tenant at signing; a missing or expired DPE is itself a ground for a court order, as the Alès judgment below demonstrates. Check the date on your DPE today: ratings issued before the 2021 reform expired, and a rating based on old bills rather than the current software model may understate or overstate the grade. If the grade looks wrong — for example a stone building with new heating rated G on questionable inputs — order a counter-diagnosis from a different certified diagnostician before spending on works; the Le Mans case shows that diagnosticians answer for their errors in euros.

B. What Your Tenant Can Force a Judge to Order While You Are Abroad

A French tenant who learns the apartment is a G — or who never received a DPE at all — does not need you to be in France to sue you. The competent court is the juge des contentieux de la protection (JCP), the specialized housing judge of the local tribunal judiciaire, and the tenant files near the apartment while you defend through a French lawyer, by written submissions, without boarding a plane. A decision handed down on March 16, 2026 by the Tribunal judiciaire d’Alès (RG No. 25/01928, full judgment on courdecassation.fr) shows precisely how these cases play out and where the limits lie.

In that case the tenant asked the judge for three things: production of the missing DPE, suspension of all rent until the DPE was produced plus repayment of every euro of rent paid since October 2024, and installation of a ventilation unit in the bathroom. The judge granted the first demand and rejected the other two. The operative part of the judgment orders the landlords “à produire… le dossier de diagnostic technique prévu par l’article 3-3 de la Loi n° 89-462 du 6 juillet 1989, comprenant notamment le diagnostic de performance énergétique prévu à l’article L. 126-26 du code de la construction et de l’habitation”. On the rent claim, the court held that “les défauts du logement… et l’absence de production du DPE ne justifient pas que la locataire soit relevée de son obligation de payer le loyer”, because suspension of payment requires proof that the tenant cannot use the dwelling at all: “l’exception d’inexécution n’est possible que lorsque le preneur est dans l’impossibilité d’utiliser les lieux loués conformément à la destination du bail”. The ventilation unit was refused on the same ground, since the file did not prove the apartment was uninhabitable as it stood.

For an American landlord, the practical reading of Alès is threefold. First, produce a valid DPE immediately — it is the cheapest court order you will ever receive, and refusing it burns credibility with the judge who will decide the rest. Second, a tenant cannot simply stop paying rent because the DPE is missing or the grade is bad; if your tenant suspends payment unilaterally, the Alès reasoning supports your claim for the arrears, and the standard recovery path — formal demand, then court action to recover arrears and ultimately terminate the lease — remains available to nonresident owners (see our guide on recovering arrears from a non-paying tenant as an American owner). Third, and most important, the tenant’s heavier weapons survive: under Article 6(a) of the July 6, 1989 housing law, quoted in the judgment, “le bailleur est obligé de délivrer au locataire le logement en bon état d’usage et de réparation”, and a tenant in a G-rated dwelling can ask the judge to order energy-renovation works within a deadline under penalty (astreinte), award damages for excess energy bills and discomfort, and in serious cases reduce the rent or authorize the tenant to have urgent works done at the owner’s expense. None of these measures requires your presence in France; they require your lawyer’s response and your money. Ignoring a tenant’s registered letter (mise en demeure) while you are in the United States is the single fastest way to turn a manageable works program into a court-ordered one with damages on top.

One more warning comes from the Le Mans file. There, the owner bought a house in October 2023 for 166,500 euros on the strength of a DPE rating the dwelling class D. The tenants she installed in December 2023 left within weeks, citing poor insulation; a second audit in April 2024 rated the house class G — banned from rental since January 1, 2025 — and the renovation quotes ran to tens of thousands of euros. The owner sued the diagnostician, and the referee judge granted two provisions: “TRENTE-HUIT MILLE HUIT CENT DIX-SEPT EUROS ET SOIXANTE-NEUF CENTIMES (38.817,69 €) à valoir sur les travaux énergétiques à réaliser” and “NEUF MILLE SIX CENT SOIXANTE-CINQ EUROS ET QUATRE-VINGT CENTIMES (9.665,80 €) pour la perte de revenus locatifs sur la période du 1er janvier 2025 au 20 mars 2026”. Two lessons for Americans: verify the DPE before you buy or re-let, because a wrong grade destroys both the rental income and the resale value; and if a French professional’s wrong certificate caused the loss, French courts make the professional advance the money — but you must prove the error with a counter-expertise and quantified quotes, from America, through a lawyer, before the limitation clock runs.

II. How to Fix a G-Rated Rental From America Without Flying Over

A. The Renovation Path: Audit, Quotes, Votes, and Works Ordered by Email

Renovation is usually the right choice when the apartment sits in a building or neighborhood where post-works value and rental demand justify the spend — central Paris, Lyon, Bordeaux — and when the works are technically feasible inside your lot and the common areas. The sequence below is the one French lawyers and property managers actually follow, adapted for an owner who signs everything from the United States.

Start with an energy audit (audit énergétique), not with a contractor’s quote. The DPE tells you the grade; the audit tells you which works change the grade, in which order, and for what money: insulation of walls or roof, window replacement, ventilation, heating and hot-water modernization. In the Le Mans case the audit prescribed exactly that bundle — “des travaux d’isolation, de remplacement de menuiseries, et de modifications des systèmes de chauffage et ventilation” — to lift the house from G to D. Get the audit from a qualified professional (bureau d’étude or certified auditor), keep the written report, and ask for a projected post-works DPE class in writing: that projection is the document your property manager, your lender, and if needed your judge will all read.

Then get at least two detailed quotes (devis) from insured French firms — ten-year garantie décennale coverage is mandatory for structural and energy-envelope works — and give your Paris property manager (administrateur de biens) or a project supervisor (maître d’œuvre) a written mandate (mandat de gestion de travaux) that states who may sign, up to what amount, and how progress is documented with photos and invoices. If the works touch the common areas — façade insulation, roof, collective heating, ventilation shafts — nothing happens without the co-ownership association (copropriété): the syndic puts the resolution on the agenda of the general meeting (assemblée générale), the co-owners vote, and you vote by correspondence or proxy from America within the stated deadlines. Miss the deadline and the project waits a year. Our guide on copro charges, works votes, and how to challenge them walks through that procedure, and Article L.173-1 of the Construction Code itself contemplates insulation works during façade and roof overhauls.

French statute even anticipates energy works piggybacking on facade and roof overhauls: Article L.173-1 of the Construction Code provides that “Lors de travaux importants de ravalement ou de réfection de toiture sur des bâtiments existants, des travaux d’isolation thermique sont réalisés”. In practice this means a co-ownership that already plans a facade renovation is the ideal vehicle for your insulation project: the scaffolding is shared, the vote covers both, and your American proxy vote counts the same as a neighbor’s. Ask the syndic for the building technical diagnosis and the multi-year works plan before the meeting, so your correspondence vote targets the resolution that actually moves the building and your apartment out of class G.

Calendar discipline matters doubly for Americans: French co-ownership notices arrive by registered mail or electronic registered delivery, and a notice you open three weeks late from Chicago is still deemed received.

Money follows paperwork. On the French tax side, energy-renovation expenses on a rented dwelling generally reduce your French rental income under the régime réel, and any excess — the déficit foncier — can under conditions offset your other French income up to 10,700 euros per year, the mechanism anchored in Article 156 of the Code général des impôts, which defines how net taxable income absorbs property-related deductions. The detailed playbook, including the nonresident traps and the three-year re-letting condition that claws the deduction back if you stop renting, is set out in our déficit foncier guide for American landlords. On the American side, the same euros must be reported to the IRS — rents as income, works as expenses or basis adjustments depending on their nature — with the France-U.S. treaty organizing relief so the same euro is not taxed twice; keep every French invoice, the audit, and the before-and-after DPEs in one file, because both tax offices will ask for them in different years. Subsidies (MaPrimeRénov’, energy certificates, reduced VAT) exist but most are reserved for primary residences or have owner-occupancy conditions; assume as a nonresident lessor that you fund the works yourself, and treat any subsidy actually obtained as a bonus, not as the plan.

B. The Exit Paths: Selling a G Dwelling, Challenging a Wrong DPE, and Managing the Lease End

Selling is the rational exit when the works cost approaches the apartment’s post-works value, when the co-ownership will never vote the collective works, or when distance has made landlording miserable. French law does not forbid selling a G-rated dwelling — the ban targets rentals, not sales — but it forces transparency on the seller. Under Article L.126-28-1 of the Code de la construction et de l’habitation, “Lorsque sont proposés à la vente des bâtiments ou parties de bâtiment à usage d’habitation… qui appartiennent aux classes D, E, F ou G… un audit énergétique est réalisé par un professionnel” and communicated to the buyer under the standard sale-file rules. Expect the buyer’s notaire to demand that audit before signing the preliminary contract, expect the buyer to price the quoted works into the offer, and expect your American-side reporting to treat the sale as a French taxable event with U.S. credit mechanics — the full sequence is covered in our seller’s guide to the energy audit and price negotiation. Order the sale audit yourself, early, from your own professional: the seller who hands over a clean, complete file negotiates the discount instead of suffering it.

Challenging a wrong DPE is the third path, and the Le Mans figures show why it matters: 38,817.69 euros advanced on the works and 9,665.80 euros for fourteen months of lost rent, charged provisionally to the diagnostician whose class-D certificate the owner had relied on. If your G looks technically implausible — recent boiler, double glazing, insulated roof, yet a G — commission a second DPE from another certified firm, then a full audit, then have a lawyer put the first diagnostician on formal notice with both reports and the quotes. Since the 2021 reform the DPE is enforceable against its author, and courts grant provisions where the error is documented and the loss quantified; where the first DPE came with the purchase, the seller’s file and the sale price may also support a claim against the seller for a hidden energy defect, though that is a separate action with its own deadlines. Do not let the file sleep: diagnostic liability, sale-related claims, and tenant claims all run on different clocks, and the American owner who “waits until the next trip to Paris” is the one who discovers that the strongest claim expired first.

Managing the lease end from abroad is the thread that runs through all three paths. When the tenant gives notice, inspect through your manager with dated photos, compare against the entry inventory (état des lieux d’entrée), and return the deposit (dépôt de garantie) within the legal deadlines with itemized deductions — deposit disputes are the most common post-tenancy litigation in France and the easiest to lose by sloppiness. When the lease renews by tacit extension (reconduction tacite), remember that you keep an occupied G dwelling you cannot re-let to anyone else: negotiate a works schedule with the sitting tenant in writing, including temporary rent arrangements during heavy works, access dates, and the target post-works class, rather than letting the tenant’s lawyer set that schedule for you in court. If the tenant stops paying during the dispute, act on the arrears immediately through the standard recovery procedure instead of linking payment to the energy dispute — Alès confirms judges keep the two issues separate, and an owner who confuses them loses both. Every step — the audit, the quotes, the co-ownership votes, the formal notices, the deposit accounting — should be executable by your manager under a written mandate and reportable to you by email, because the legal system you face does not pause for transatlantic flights.

Conclusion

A class G rating does not take your French apartment away, but since January 1, 2025 it takes away your ability to re-let it, and it hands your tenant a documented path to a French courtroom where you will defend from another continent. The owners who come through this well do four things in order: they secure a valid, preferably double-checked DPE; they answer the tenant’s formal letters through a French lawyer instead of ignoring them; they choose deliberately between funded renovation — audited, quoted, voted in co-ownership, and tax-tracked on both sides of the Atlantic — and a transparent sale with the mandatory energy audit; and they keep every document, because in these files the paper wins. The two 2026 decisions in this article draw the map: Alès shows that judges order the missing DPE but refuse to cancel rent without proof the dwelling is unusable, and Le Mans shows that a wrong energy certificate converts into tens of thousands of euros of provisions once the error is proven with a second audit and priced quotes. Start the file this week, while all options are still open.

📄 Official circular