KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Buying a French House Together as Americans: How the Tontine Clause Gives the Survivor Everything — and Where It Breaks Down

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Buying a French House Together as Americans: How the Tontine Clause Gives the Survivor Everything — and Where It Breaks Down

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

Picture two Americans, married or not, signing the purchase deed for a stone house in the Dordogne. The French notaire — the public officer who alone can transfer real estate in France — suggests adding a clause they have never seen in any American closing: a pacte tontinier, or tontine clause. In one paragraph, the deed will say that the first buyer to die is deemed never to have owned anything, and the survivor is deemed to have owned the entire house from day one. No probate fight, no forced sale, no stepchildren claiming a share of the roof over the survivor’s head. For couples buying together, that promise sounds like the French version of joint tenancy with right of survivorship, only stronger.

It is stronger, and that strength has a price. The survivor pays transfer tax on the windfall. Children of the first buyer to die can ask a court to reclassify the bargain as a disguised gift and pull it back into the estate accounting. And since April 2026, buyers who hide the tontine inside a two-person property company face something worse than tax: the company itself can be declared void. This guide explains how the clause works, what it costs, where courts let it stand, and the structures that hold up for American buyers.

I. How the tontine clause makes the surviving American the sole owner of the French house

A. What the survivorship bargain promises and why American buyers sign it

A pacte tontinier, also called a clause d’accroissement (accrual clause), is a provision written directly into the acquisition deed — the acte authentique signed before the notaire — by which two or more buyers agree that the survivor of them will own the whole property alone. The Poitiers Court of Appeal gives the textbook definition: “Le pacte de tontine ou ‘clause d’accroissement’ est une clause par laquelle deux ou plusieurs personnes achètent un bien, en stipulant que le survivant d’entre elles sera seul propriétaire de son intégralité.” That definition comes from the Poitiers Court of Appeal ruling of 17 April 2025, published on the Court of Cassation website. The mechanism is a legal fiction with retroactive effect. As the notaires of France explain in their tontine guide, the buyer who dies first is treated as if that buyer never purchased, so the house never enters that buyer’s estate and the deceased buyer’s heirs take no right in it. In plain terms, the first buyer to die is treated as if that buyer never owned the house, so the house never enters that buyer’s estate, and the deceased buyer’s heirs have no claim on it.

American buyers sign this clause for one reason above all: it neutralizes indivision. Indivision is the default French regime of joint ownership, and it is far more fragile than American co-ownership. Any co-owner can force a partition sale, an occupant can owe an occupation payment to the others, and a disagreement between heirs can freeze the property for years. The national chamber of notaires presents the clause on exactly this ground in its buyer guide: for a two-buyer purchase it avoids the pitfalls of joint ownership and secures the whole property for the survivor. For an American couple buying a vacation home that neither set of children will occupy, that guarantee is the whole point: the survivor keeps the house, period.

The resemblance to the American joint tenancy with right of survivorship is real but incomplete, and the differences matter at the closing table. A joint tenancy is a form of title; the tontine is a contract with a gamble built in. French courts treat the clause as a contrat aléatoire, a contract whose outcome depends on chance — here, the chance of who dies first. That gambling character is a validity condition, not decoration: “Cet acte pour être valide doit présenter un caractère onéreux et aléatoire.” That sentence from the Poitiers Court of Appeal (Poitiers, 17 April 2025) sets the test. Onerous means each buyer must actually pay a share of the price with that buyer’s own money. Aleatory means that, on the day of signing, it must be genuinely uncertain who will survive the other. The notaires’ practical summary is blunt: as a contract based on chance, a tontine purchase must meet the gamble requirement, with each buyer funding part of the property and buyers having comparable life expectancy — failing which, the purchase can be reclassified as a gift. Reclassification as a donation — a gift — is the doorway through which every later challenge walks, as Part II explains.

Two practical consequences follow for Americans before anyone signs. First, the money trail must show a real fifty-fifty payment. Each buyer should wire that buyer’s half of the price and costs from a personal account, keep the wire confirmations, and record the origin of funds in the deed’s declaration. If one partner funds the entire purchase while both names go on the deed, a court will later read the clause as a gift of half the house from the funder to the other, with all the estate consequences that label carries. Second, the health and age picture must be balanced at signing. A large age gap alone does not kill the clause, but a large gap combined with a known serious illness can. Buyers who sign at very different life expectancies should have the notaire record that both entered the bargain with eyes open, and should keep medical privacy in mind while documenting nothing false. Paper signed today is evidence examined ten or twenty years later: in a July 2026 ruling on a tontine dispute, the First Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation reminded courts that “la partie à laquelle on l’oppose peut désavouer son écriture ou sa signature. Les héritiers ou ayants cause d’une partie peuvent pareillement désavouer l’écriture ou la signature de leur auteur, ou déclarer qu’ils ne les connaissent. Dans ces cas, il y a lieu à vérification d’écriture.” Heirs can disavow the deceased’s signature on side agreements about who paid what, which forces a handwriting verification. Keep bank records from institutions that will still exist, not private IOUs. The governing text on proof of writings is Article 1373 of the Civil Code, and the decision is Cass. 1re civ., 1 July 2026, no. 24-15.452, available on the Court of Cassation website.

One more feature draws Americans in: during the buyers’ lifetimes, nobody can force an exit. Unlike ordinary co-ownership, where the maxim says no one can be forced to remain in indivision, the tontine locks the door. The notaires’ guide states that the buyers cannot force a court-ordered partition or demand a sale of the home. If the couple splits up or the friends fall out, only unanimous agreement — a joint sale or a buyout — ends the arrangement. That lock-in protects the survivor’s future but punishes buyers whose plans may change, so unmarried partners and friends should weigh it with particular care.

B. How the survivor is taxed when the first buyer dies

Ownership passes to the survivor free of any claim by the deceased’s heirs, but it never passes free of tax. For tax purposes, France treats the survivor’s windfall as a gift from the first buyer to die. The statute is Article 754 A of the General Tax Code: “Les biens recueillis en vertu d’une clause insérée dans un contrat d’acquisition en commun selon laquelle la part du ou des premiers décédés reviendra aux survivants de telle sorte que le dernier vivant sera considéré comme seul propriétaire de la totalité des biens sont, au point de vue fiscal, réputés transmis à titre gratuit à chacun des bénéficiaires de l’accroissement. Cette disposition ne s’applique pas à l’habitation principale commune à deux acquéreurs lorsque celle-ci a une valeur globale inférieure à 76 000 €, sauf si le bénéficiaire opte pour l’application des droits de mutation par décès .” Three lessons sit inside that paragraph. First, the half of the house the survivor absorbs is deemed transferred gratuitously — taxed like a gift or inheritance share. Second, the only escape is narrow: a shared main home worth less than 76,000 euros in total, which covers almost no American purchase. Third, the tax office’s own doctrine confirms the principle: the BOFiP guidelines on successions state that gratuitous-transfer duties are in principle due on property received under an accrual or tontine clause in a joint acquisition contract.

The rate then depends on the legal bond between the two buyers, measured on the value of the half the survivor absorbs. According to the notaires’ scale, the surviving buyer still pays succession duties computed on the kinship link with the deceased and the value of the absorbed share: nothing between spouses and PACS partners, and 60 percent between unmarried partners after a 1,594-euro allowance. Married spouses and PACS partners — PACS being the French civil partnership, a registered union with fewer effects than marriage — pay nothing on the accretion. Unmarried partners, the concubins, face the top rate of 60 percent after a small allowance of 1,594 euros. Readers should have the notaire confirm the current allowance at signing, since scales move, but the structure is stable: marriage or PACS makes the tontine cheap at the first death, while an unmarried purchase makes it expensive. For American couples buying before any French marriage or PACS, that 60 percent figure should dominate the decision. Siblings, parent-child pairs, and friends are taxed on their own kinship scales between those poles.

Two worked sketches show the stakes. Take an unmarried American couple buying a 400,000-euro house in equal shares with a tontine clause. At the first death, the survivor absorbs a 200,000-euro half and, on the notaires’ scale, owes roughly 60 percent of that half minus the small allowance — about 119,000 euros — within months of losing a partner. The same house bought by a married couple, or by partners who registered a PACS before signing, produces zero accretion tax at the first death. The lesson is not that every buyer must marry; it is that the couple should price the clause before choosing it, and should ask the notaire to model the first-death bill in euros on the actual purchase price, not in percentages.

The American side of the ledger needs equal attention, because the two systems do not mirror each other. The United States taxes its citizens on worldwide transfers, and a bilateral estate-and-gift tax convention between France and the United States allocates taxing rights and offers credits, but the French fiction — the first buyer deemed never to have owned — has no exact American equivalent, so basis and timing can mismatch. The surviving American may owe French tax on a half interest that American law views differently for cost-basis purposes at a later resale, and any foreign tax credit must be claimed correctly on the American return. Nothing in this article replaces that filing analysis. Before signing, each buyer should have the French notaire’s tax computation reviewed by an American tax preparer experienced with French property, so the household sees both bills in advance.

II. Where the tontine fails American families: children who sue and the company wrapper courts now void

A. When the children of the first buyer to die reclaim the house as a disguised gift

The tontine’s promise — the deceased deemed never to have owned — holds only while the clause keeps its contractual character. When the gamble was hollow from the start, courts strip the contract label and reveal the gift underneath. The Poitiers Court of Appeal states the test this way: “L’absence d’aléa, qui permet de caractériser l’intention libérale, peut résulter de ce que l’une des parties a financé l’acquisition en totalité ou dans une proportion très supérieure à la moitié, ainsi que d’une différence d’âge significative ou d’états de santé différents.” That formulation comes from the Poitiers Court of Appeal (Poitiers, 17 April 2025). Total or heavily unequal funding, or an age and health gap that made the order of deaths predictable, converts the tontine into a donation indirecte or donation déguisée — an indirect or disguised gift. Once relabeled, the half-house falls back into the succession accounting of the first buyer to die, through three Civil Code mechanisms that American heirs must understand: rapport, imputation, and réduction.

Rapport — the duty to return — is stated in Article 843 of the Civil Code: “Tout héritier, même ayant accepté à concurrence de l’actif, venant à une succession, doit rapporter à ses cohéritiers tout ce qu’il a reçu du défunt, par donations entre vifs, directement ou indirectement ; il ne peut retenir les dons à lui faits par le défunt, à moins qu’ils ne lui aient été faits expressément hors part successorale.” Gifts made to an heir are presumed advances on that heir’s share and must be notionally returned to the pot before division. Imputation is the parallel rule for the surviving spouse. Article 758-6 of the Civil Code provides: “Les libéralités reçues du défunt par le conjoint survivant s’imputent sur les droits de celui-ci dans la succession. Lorsque les libéralités ainsi reçues sont inférieures aux droits définis aux articles 757 et 757-1 , le conjoint survivant peut en réclamer le complément, sans jamais recevoir une portion des biens supérieure à la quotité définie à l’article 1094-1 .” And Article 758-5 frames the computation: “Le calcul du droit en toute propriété du conjoint prévu aux articles 757 et 757-1 sera opéré sur une masse faite de tous les biens existant au décès de son époux auxquels seront réunis fictivement ceux dont il aurait disposé, soit par acte entre vifs, soit par acte testamentaire, au profit de successibles, sans dispense de rapport.” Réduction — reduction — is the remedy of last resort for protected heirs: gifts that exceed the freely disposable share, the quotité disponible, are cut back. Article 913 of the Civil Code fixes the ceiling: “Les libéralités, soit par actes entre vifs, soit par testament, ne pourront excéder la moitié des biens du disposant, s’il ne laisse à son décès qu’un enfant ; le tiers, s’il laisse deux enfants ; le quart, s’il en laisse trois ou un plus grand nombre.” Children are réservataires, forced heirs with a minimum reserved share, the réserve héréditaire, that no gift and no will can defeat.

The leading illustration for blended American families is Cass. 1re civ., 12 January 2022, no. 20-12.232, published on the Court of Cassation website. A man bought an apartment with his wife under a tontine clause shortly before his death, and his two children from a prior marriage challenged the widow’s windfall. The courts qualified the clause as a disguised gift from the husband to his wife, and the Court of Cassation approved bringing that gift into account through the spouse’s special mechanism: “Il résulte de la combinaison de ces textes que le conjoint survivant est tenu à un rapport spécial en moins prenant des libéralités reçues par lui du défunt dans les conditions définies à l’article 758-6.” The widow did not lose everything — imputation in less-taking means the gift counts against her succession rights rather than being physically returned — but the children recovered value. For an American with children from a first marriage buying in France with a second spouse or partner, this decision is the one to read twice: the tontine shields the survivor from outside creditors and from distant relatives, not from the deceased’s own children armed with the réserve.

The counterweight comes from Poitiers, 17 April 2025, RG 23/02749, available on the Court of Cassation website. There, the children of a man who had bought property with his third wife under a 1998 tontine clause attacked it on both classic grounds: unequal funding and a twenty-year age gap. The court rejected both, after a close look at the bank records. The wife proved she had paid her half — part in cash from savings, part through a documented loan from her husband that she repaid in monthly installments over years and then refinanced and repaid in full. Assertions that the husband must have secretly fed her accounts failed for lack of proof. On age, the court held: “La différence d’âge de 20 ans entre les époux dans un acte avec stipulation d’une clause d’accroissement n’est pas en soit exclusive de l’aléa que constitue la date de pré-décès de l’un d’eux sauf pour le cas ou une différence d’âge significative s’accompagne d’une différence de leur état de santé ou de circonstances spécifiques réduisant l’aléa.” A twenty-year gap, without a matching health gap or special circumstance, leaves the gamble intact. So the clause survived and the widow kept the property. The practical moral for Americans is symmetrical with the 2022 case: equal, documented, traceable funding plus balanced life expectancy makes the tontine nearly unassailable, while one-sided money plus a predictable order of deaths makes it a gift waiting to be reduced.

American buyers should convert those rulings into a signing checklist. Each buyer wires half from a personal account and keeps the confirmations permanently. The deed records the fifty-fifty funding and the notaire verifies it. Neither buyer signs while under a diagnosis that makes early death highly likely without disclosing the risk analysis to counsel. Each buyer coordinates the clause with a will, because the tontine governs only this house while the rest of the estate follows the succession law — and Americans living in France who want American law to govern should make that choice expressly in a compliant will. And every buyer with children, from this union or an earlier one, asks the notaire to compute the réserve impact of a reclassification before signing, so the household knows the worst case in euros. Readers weighing a tontine against a property company should also review how a family company is built and taxed, as explained in this guide to buying a French house through an SCI as an American family.

B. Why the tontine must stay out of a two-person property company after the April 2026 ruling

Some buyers, advised to combine flexibility with protection, place the house in a société civile immobilière — a SCI, the French non-trading property company whose shares the family holds instead of holding the walls directly — and then insert a tontine or accrual clause over the company’s shares, so the survivor absorbs all the shares at the first death. Since 9 April 2026, that construction is a trap when the company has only two members and the clause covers all the shares. On that date the Third Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, in case no. 25-12.992, struck at the combination. The Court first defined the object: “La clause de tontine ou d’accroissement stipulée dans les statuts d’une société civile est celle qui attribue au dernier survivant, de manière rétroactive, la propriété des parts incluses dans le pacte tontinier.” It then described the effect: “Lorsqu’elle porte sur l’ensemble des parts, elle emporte leur réunion en une seule main au décès de l’avant-dernier tontinier.” And it drew the consequence under Article 1832 of the Civil Code — “La société est instituée par deux ou plusieurs personnes qui conviennent par un contrat d’affecter à une entreprise commune des biens ou leur industrie en vue de partager le bénéfice ou de profiter de l’économie qui pourra en résulter. Elle peut être instituée, dans les cas prévus par la loi, par l’acte de volonté d’une seule personne. Les associés s’engagent à contribuer aux pertes.” Because the accrual works retroactively to the company’s formation, not as a later buyout during its life, the ordinary rescue rule of Article 1844-5 of the Civil Code — “La réunion de toutes les parts sociales en une seule main n’entraîne pas la dissolution de plein droit de la société. Tout intéressé peut demander cette dissolution si la situation n’a pas été régularisée dans le délai d’un an.” — does not apply. The holding is categorical: “Il en résulte que, lorsqu’elle porte sur l’ensemble des parts d’une société civile, la clause statutaire d’accroissement ou de tontine est contraire à la disposition imposant que la société soit instituée par deux ou plusieurs personnes.” And the sanction is not a deletion of the clause but death of the company: “Une telle clause entraîne ainsi la nullité de la société.” The full ruling is published on the Court of Cassation website.

Nullity of the company is the worst possible outcome for a survivor. A void SCI must be liquidated, the property’s title chain is thrown into doubt, lenders and insurers react, and the deceased member’s heirs gain leverage they would never have had against a clean direct tontine. Note what the Court did not say: it did not condemn every accrual clause touching company shares. A clause over part of the shares, or a company with more members than the clause covers, sits outside this holding — but those are narrow corridors, and drafting a two-person family vehicle to thread them invites litigation. American couples who already own a French house through a two-member SCI whose articles contain an accrual clause should have those articles reviewed now, before the first death turns a latent defect into an open dispute. Couples choosing between a marriage contract and a company structure should also read how the marriage property regime decides who owns a French house bought by an American couple, since the regime and the clause interact.

The structures that hold up are simpler. First, the direct purchase with a tontine clause in the deed, funded fifty-fifty, between buyers of comparable life expectancy — the configuration every court in this article upheld when those facts were present. Second, a convention d’indivision, the contract by which co-owners organize their joint ownership: Article 1873-1 of the Civil Code states that “Ceux qui ont des droits à exercer sur des biens indivis, à titre de propriétaires, de nus-propriétaires ou d’usufruitiers peuvent passer des conventions relatives à l’exercice de ces droits.” Such an agreement can allocate use, costs, and decision rules for a fixed, renewable term, and it pairs naturally with cross-wills for the succession side. Third, a SCI without any tontine, combined with tailored wills and, for spouses, the gifts the matrimonial toolkit allows. Fourth, marriage or PACS itself: beyond the zero accretion tax noted above, the regimes give the survivor statutory rights that need no gamble. Each option should be modeled for three scenarios — harmony, separation, and first death — with the euro amounts written down. The tontine wins the third scenario and loses the second; the convention d’indivision balances the first two; the company serves management and transmission but must never carry the accrual clause over all its shares.

Conclusion

The tontine clause does exactly what its one paragraph promises: at the first death, the survivor owns the whole French house and the deceased’s heirs own nothing in it. That power rests on a genuine gamble — each buyer paying half, with the order of deaths truly uncertain — and the tax office prices the survivor’s winnings as a gift, free between spouses and PACS partners and steeply taxed between unmarried buyers. When the gamble was real, courts enforce the clause even against disappointed children, as the 2025 Poitiers decision shows; when the money was one-sided or death was predictable, courts reclassify the clause as a disguised gift and bring it back into the estate through return, imputation, and reduction, as the 2022 Court of Cassation decision requires. And since the April 2026 ruling, the clause must never cover all the shares of a two-person property company, on pain of voiding the company itself. Americans buying together should therefore sign the tontine only with equal documented funding, balanced life expectancy, a modeled first-death tax bill on both sides of the Atlantic, wills that coordinate with the clause, and — where children from an earlier union exist — a computed worst case for the reserved share. Built that way, the survivor keeps the house. Built any other way, the clause is litigation waiting for a death.

📄 Official circular