KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
US Denaturalization Wave: Can France Strip You of French Nationality Too?

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

US Denaturalization Wave: Can France Strip You of French Nationality Too?

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

On 5 October 2026, the United States Department of Justice announced that it had filed denaturalization actions against 40 naturalized Americans in a six-week window, calling it the largest single-period filing of its kind. Within days, searches for American denaturalization cases surged across the United States, with one case name jumping 300 percent in a single day. Dual nationals and naturalized citizens on both sides of the Atlantic are asking the same anxious question: if Washington can take citizenship back, can Paris do it too? The short answer is yes — France has three distinct legal doors that lead out of French nationality. The longer answer, the one that matters if you hold a French passport alongside another, is that each door has strict locks: a criminal conviction for the first, proven fraud for the second, a government injunction for the third, and in every case a decree issued after the formal blessing of the Conseil d’État, reviewable by that same court and framed by European human rights law.

This article explains what the American wave actually consists of, then walks through the French mechanisms one by one — déchéance under Articles 25 and 25-1 of the Civil Code, withdrawal of a fraudulently obtained naturalization under Article 27-2, and loss of nationality under Articles 23-7 and 23-8 — with the exact statutory language and the recent Conseil d’État decisions that show how judges apply them. If you are a naturalized French citizen, a dual national living in France, or an expatriate weighing a second passport, this is the French lawyer’s map of where the real risks sit and where the protections hold.

I. Washington’s denaturalization push: what the 40 cases are really about

A. How the United States takes citizenship back: fraud at naturalization, proved before a judge

The Justice Department’s press release of 5 October 2026 is precise about what happened: between 21 August and 2 October 2026, federal prosecutors filed denaturalization complaints in multiple US district courts against 40 individuals accused of serious offenses, including acting as an agent for a foreign government, voluntary manslaughter, and sexual offenses. The Department presents these filings as the largest batch of complaints filed in any single period under the current administration, and the Attorney General described the effort as the largest denaturalization drive in modern history.

American press coverage followed within hours. The Guardian reported on 6 October 2026 that the department had moved to strip citizenship from 40 naturalized citizens, regional outlets in Florida and Arizona detailed local filings within days, and search interest spiked accordingly. But the legal mechanism behind the headlines is narrower than the coverage suggests, and understanding its shape is essential before drawing any comparison with France.

Under the Immigration and Nationality Act, the rule as stated by the Department itself is that a naturalized American can lose citizenship, with the certificate of naturalization cancelled, where the grant was obtained unlawfully or through hiding a material fact or deliberate misrepresentation. Three points in that sentence carry the whole American doctrine. First, denaturalization targets naturalized citizens, not birthright citizens: the constitutional protection of Afroyim v. Rusk keeps the native-born beyond reach of involuntary expatriation. Second, the ground is anchored in the naturalization itself — either the grant was unlawful from the start, or the applicant hid or distorted a material fact to obtain it. A crime committed years after a clean naturalization does not, on its own, reopen the grant. Third, the government must prove its case before a federal judge; citizenship is not cancelled by administrative letter.

The individual complaints illustrate the pattern. In the cases described in the October release, the Department alleges that defendants concealed criminal conduct that predated or surrounded their naturalization — conduct that, had it been disclosed, would have defeated the good moral character requirement for naturalization. One complaint, for example, concerns a person naturalized in 2018 who later admitted involvement in a money-laundering conspiracy that began before citizenship was granted. The theory is always the same: the citizenship was never validly earned because the application rested on lies. Whether each complaint succeeds will be decided court by court, with the defendants entitled to defend themselves and appeal. Announcements are not judgments.

Two structural features of the American system deserve emphasis because they differ sharply from the French one. The United States asks no second nationality as a precondition: denaturalization can leave a person stateless, a consequence American courts have tolerated in this context. And the American debate is overwhelmingly about fraud at the gate — the integrity of the naturalization process — rather than about punishing later disloyalty. Both contrasts matter when we turn to France, which built its system the other way around: statelessness is a hard stop, and the most politically visible French mechanism targets convictions that come after citizenship, not lies told to get it.

B. Why searches for denaturalization cases are surging, and who should actually worry

Search data tells its own story. In the 48 hours before this article was written, American queries around a single denaturalization case grew by roughly 300 percent, with the story carried by national and regional outlets from 6 to 12 October 2026. Readers are not following one docket out of legal curiosity. They are typing case names into search engines because they want to know whether the wave could reach them: naturalized citizens with old criminal records, dual nationals who split their lives between two countries, green-card holders approaching naturalization, and families where one member’s status looks fragile.

The honest answer for the American side is differentiated. If your naturalization application was complete and truthful, later conduct — even a later conviction — is not a denaturalization ground under the statute the Department invokes. The exposure sits with applications that contained false statements, concealed arrests or convictions, sham marriages, or hidden affiliations. That is a serious but bounded population, and each case still requires the government to carry its burden of proof in federal court. The surge in searches reflects fear broader than the legal risk, which is precisely why explanation matters more than reassurance alone.

For readers with a French connection, the question flips. France does not need to copy Washington: it already possesses its own nationality-stripping toolkit, older and structured differently. A naturalized French citizen reading American headlines should ask three concrete questions instead. First, was my French nationality obtained cleanly, with no lie about identity, family situation, or criminal history? Second, have I since been convicted of terrorism or of an offense striking at the fundamental interests of the Nation? Third, do I hold another nationality, and have I kept real ties with France? The rest of this article maps each of those questions onto the exact French provisions, so that worry can be replaced with verification.

II. Can France strip your French nationality? Three doors with strict locks

A. Déchéance for terrorism and threats to the Nation: Article 25 under judicial control

The flagship French mechanism is déchéance de nationalité, governed by Article 25 of the Civil Code. Its wording deserves to be read in full: “L’individu qui a acquis la qualité de Français peut, par décret pris après avis conforme du Conseil d’Etat, être déchu de la nationalité française, sauf si la déchéance a pour résultat de le rendre apatride : 1° S’il est condamné pour un acte qualifié de crime ou délit constituant une atteinte aux intérêts fondamentaux de la Nation ou pour un crime ou un délit constituant un acte de terrorisme ; 2° S’il est condamné pour un acte qualifié de crime ou délit prévu et réprimé par le chapitre II du titre III du livre IV du code pénal ; 3° S’il est condamné pour s’être soustrait aux obligations résultant pour lui du code du service national ; 4° S’il s’est livré au profit d’un Etat étranger à des actes incompatibles avec la qualité de Français et préjudiciables aux intérêts de la France.” Four cumulative locks appear immediately. Only a person who acquired French nationality is exposed — someone born French cannot be stripped under this article. A criminal conviction is required; suspicion, intelligence files, or administrative unease are not enough. The decree needs the avis conforme, the binding favorable opinion, of the Conseil d’État. And the measure is barred outright if it would leave the person stateless.

The time limits in Article 25-1 of the Civil Code add a fifth lock: “La déchéance n’est encourue que si les faits reprochés à l’intéressé et visés à l’article 25 se sont produits antérieurement à l’acquisition de la nationalité française ou dans le délai de dix ans à compter de la date de cette acquisition. Elle ne peut être prononcée que dans le délai de dix ans à compter de la perpétration desdits faits. Si les faits reprochés à l’intéressé sont visés au 1° de l’article 25, les délais mentionnés aux deux alinéas précédents sont portés à quinze ans.” In practice, for terrorism and offenses against the fundamental interests of the Nation, the facts must fall within fifteen years before or after the acquisition of nationality, and the decree must come within fifteen years of the facts. A decades-old conviction against a long-naturalized citizen cannot support déchéance; the clock matters as much as the crime.

The terrorism ground leans on the criminal definition in Article 421-2-1 of the Criminal Code: “Constitue également un acte de terrorisme le fait de participer à un groupement formé ou à une entente établie en vue de la préparation, caractérisée par un ou plusieurs faits matériels, d’un des actes de terrorisme mentionnés aux articles précédents.” Membership in a terrorist conspiracy — association de malfaiteurs terroriste — is therefore the standard gateway fact in the recent case law, and the Conseil d’État’s recent docket shows exactly how the control works.

Take Conseil d’État, 2nd chamber, 30 November 2023, No. 474300. The applicant had been stripped by a decree of 13 March 2023 taken on the basis of Articles 25 and 25-1: “Par un décret du 13 mars 2023 pris sur le fondement des articles 25 et 25-1 du code civil, M. A… B… a été déchu de la nationalité française au motif qu’il a été condamné par un jugement du tribunal de grande instance de Paris en date du 23 octobre 2017 pour avoir participé à une association de malfaiteurs en vue de la préparation d’un acte de terrorisme, jugement confirmé par un arrêt de la cour d’appel de Paris en date du 4 octobre 2018, devenu définitif.” The court verified each lock — the final conviction, the applicable texts, the procedure — and ended: “Article 1er : La requête de M. A… B… est rejetée.” A companion ruling handed down the same day, Conseil d’État, 30 November 2023, No. 474304, rejected a parallel challenge to another decree of 13 March 2023 in identical terms: “Article 1er : La requête de M. B… A… est rejetée.”

An earlier ruling shows the human-rights layer of the review. In Conseil d’État, 2nd and 7th chambers combined, 10 February 2023, No. 458130, the applicant challenged a decree of 28 July 2021 stripping his French nationality. The court recalled the statutory frame, then turned to Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights: a deprivation decree “est par lui-même dépourvu d’effet sur la présence sur le territoire français de celui qu’il vise, comme sur ses liens avec les membres de sa famille, et n’affecte pas, dès lors, le droit au respect de sa vie familiale.” Nationality and residence are legally distinct: losing the passport does not by itself remove the right to stay. The court continued: “un tel décret affecte un élément constitutif de l’identité de la personne concernée et est ainsi susceptible de porter atteinte au droit au respect de sa vie privée. Au cas présent, eu égard à la gravité des faits commis par le requérant et à l’ensemble des circonstances de l’espèce, le décret attaqué n’a pas porté une atteinte disproportionnée au droit au respect de sa vie privée garanti par l’article 8 de la convention européenne de sauvegarde des droits de l’homme et des libertés fondamentales.” The challenge was therefore rejected: “M. B… n’est pas fondé à demander l’annulation pour excès de pouvoir du décret qu’il attaque.”

The European Court of Human Rights confirmed this architecture in Ghoumid and Others v. France, 25 June 2020. Five formerly dual-national men, convicted of participation in a criminal conspiracy to commit terrorism and released in 2009 and 2010, had been stripped of French nationality in October 2015. They argued a breach of their right to respect for private life and called the measure a disguised second punishment. The Court found no violation of Article 8: the deprivation had not had disproportionate consequences for their private life, terrorist violence is itself a grave threat to human rights, the men kept another nationality so they were not left stateless, and loss of French nationality did not automatically entail deportation — with full remedies available if removal were ever ordered. The Court added that deprivation under Article 25 of the Civil Code is not a criminal sanction, so the double-punishment complaint failed. For dual nationals, the message is two-sided: the Convention tolerates French déchéance for terrorism, but only within the proportionality review that French judges actually perform, case by case.

B. Fraud at the gate, foreign allegiance and loss: Articles 27-2, 23-7 and 23-8, plus the European ceiling

The second French door is the closest cousin of the American wave: withdrawal of a naturalization obtained by lies. Article 27-2 of the Civil Code provides: “Les décrets portant acquisition, naturalisation ou réintégration peuvent être rapportés sur avis conforme du Conseil d’Etat dans le délai de deux ans à compter de leur publication au Journal officiel si le requérant ne satisfait pas aux conditions légales ; si la décision a été obtenue par mensonge ou fraude, ces décrets peuvent être rapportés dans le délai de deux ans à partir de la découverte de la fraude.” Two features stand out against the American model. The ordinary window is short — two years from publication — and only fraud extends it, running two years from discovery of the deception. And like déchéance, withdrawal requires the binding opinion of the Conseil d’État plus a full adversarial procedure with one month to submit observations in defense.

Conseil d’État, 2nd chamber, 30 April 2019, No. 424752 shows the mechanism in motion. A Sudanese applicant “a déposé une demande de naturalisation le 6 août 2015, par laquelle il a indiqué être célibataire. Au vu de ses déclarations, il a été naturalisé par décret du 27 mai 2016. Toutefois, par courrier reçu le 31 août 2016, le préfet du Rhône a informé le ministre chargé des naturalisations que M. A…B…avait épousé au Tchad, le 11 mars 2016, une ressortissante soudanaise résidant au Tchad.” The response followed the statutory path: “Par décret du 30 juillet 2018, le Premier ministre a rapporté le décret du 27 mai 2016 prononçant la naturalisation de M. A…B…au motif qu’il avait été pris au vu d’informations mensongères de l’intéressé sur sa situation familiale.” The court upheld every step — the notification of the grounds, the binding opinion of the Conseil d’État’s interior section, and the starting point of the two-year clock at the date the administration actually learned of the marriage — and closed with “Article 1er : La requête de M. A…B…est rejetée.” A hidden marriage, discovered a year after the decree, erased a naturalization two years later. For naturalized readers, the practical lesson is blunt: family status declared at naturalization must be exact, and any change must be declared honestly, because the administration cross-checks civil records for years.

The third door is loss of nationality for behavior showing allegiance elsewhere. Article 23-7 of the Civil Code states: “Le Français qui se comporte en fait comme le national d’un pays étranger peut, s’il a la nationalité de ce pays, être déclaré, par décret après avis conforme du Conseil d’Etat, avoir perdu la qualité de Français.” And Article 23-8 adds: “Perd la nationalité française le Français qui, occupant un emploi dans une armée ou un service public étranger ou dans une organisation internationale dont la France ne fait pas partie ou plus généralement leur apportant son concours, n’a pas résigné son emploi ou cessé son concours nonobstant l’injonction qui lui en aura été faite par le Gouvernement.” Note the architecture: Article 23-8 does not strike by surprise — the government must first order the person to quit the foreign post, with a deadline of fifteen days to two months, and only disobedience triggers the loss decree. Serving a foreign army or administration without answering that injunction is the paradigm case, and it speaks directly to expatriates tempted by foreign public employment while keeping French nationality.

Two transversal protections cap the whole edifice. First, Article 27-1 of the Civil Code recalls that nationality decrees “n’ont point d’effet rétroactif”: a withdrawal or deprivation decree operates for the future and does not rewrite the validity of acts — marriages, children’s filiations, contracts — accomplished while the person was French. Second, European Union law adds a proportionality ceiling wherever loss of French nationality also means loss of EU citizenship. In Rottmann (C-135/08), the Court of Justice accepted that a Member State may withdraw a naturalization obtained by fraud even where statelessness and loss of EU citizenship follow, but only subject to a proportionality review weighing the gravity of the fraud against the consequences for the person and family. In Tjebbes (C-221/17, 12 March 2019), the Court extended that logic to loss of nationality by operation of law: the scheme must allow an individual examination of the consequences, including for family and professional life, with the possibility of recovering nationality. France’s system of reasoned decrees, binding Conseil d’État opinions, and full judicial review fits that frame — but the frame means no French loss-of-nationality decision affecting an EU citizen is ever purely automatic.

What happens the day after a decree? Losing French nationality makes the person a foreigner overnight, and foreigner status opens the removal toolbox — but it does not trigger removal by itself. The Conseil d’État said so expressly in the 2023 rulings, and Strasbourg confirmed it in Ghoumid. Any expulsion must follow its own procedure and its own grounds: Article L. 631-1 of the Code on the Entry and Residence of Foreigners and Asylum allows expulsion only where “sa présence en France constitue une menace grave pour l’ordre public,” with reinforced protections for settled foreigners, and each removal decision can be challenged before the administrative courts, where arguments about private and family life — and, where relevant, an order annulling an earlier refusal — get a full hearing, as recent litigation over refused residence permits followed by removal orders demonstrates. The decree takes the passport; a separate, challengeable decision is needed to take the residence.

Conclusion

The American denaturalization wave and the French déchéance regime look alike from a distance and differ up close. Washington’s October 2026 filings target fraud at naturalization and must be proved case by case before federal judges; Paris can also revisit fraud through Article 27-2, but its most prominent weapon, Article 25, punishes later convictions for terrorism and offenses against the Nation’s fundamental interests within strict fifteen-year clocks. Both systems keep judges at the center — federal courts in the United States, the Conseil d’État plus the European Court of Human Rights in France — and both leave the vast majority of citizens untouched: the native-born in America, the born-French and the single-nationality naturalized in France, and everywhere the applicants whose files were truthful.

For dual nationals and naturalized French citizens, the checklist that emerges from the statutes and the recent rulings is practical rather than alarming: verify that nothing in the naturalization file was false or incomplete, because fraud discovered years later can still reopen the decree within two years of discovery; understand that a terrorism conviction within fifteen years of acquisition exposes a dual national to déchéance, with statelessness as the absolute barrier and proportionality as the judicial test; answer any government injunction about foreign public employment within the deadline; keep proof of real ties with France; and treat every registered letter from the administration as the one-month starting gun it legally is. Citizenship, in both republics, turns out to be a contract whose fine print is written in court decisions — and the fine print, read carefully, protects far more people than it threatens.

📄 Official circular