KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Ryanair and easyJet Winter Cancellations: Your EU Flight Compensation Rights Enforced From France

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Ryanair and easyJet Winter Cancellations: Your EU Flight Compensation Rights Enforced From France

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

More than one million seats have been taken out of the winter schedule as Europe’s two biggest budget airlines contend with soaring fuel prices. That is the wave of advance cancellations reported in the British press this week on the back of announcements from the carriers themselves, hitting passengers who booked weeks or months ago: easyJet announced a further 700,000 seats removed from its winter schedule, on top of a similar number cut earlier, taking reported total reductions to around 1.4 million seats, while Ryanair’s chief executive publicly linked his airline’s winter capacity decisions to fuel hedging running thinner than in summer, at a time of weak demand when parking aircraft costs less than flying them at a loss. Search interest in the United Kingdom for winter flight cancellations by the two carriers surged over the forty-eight hours to 15 October 2026, with growth above one thousand percent on an active trend exceeding ten thousand searches. When an airline cancels for commercial reasons of this kind, the legal question is not whether the decision was commercially rational. It is what the airline owes every passenger holding a ticket on a cancelled flight, and where that passenger can force payment when the airline stalls. For anyone departing from France, the answer lies in a European regulation applied daily by the French courts, and the French case law on the subject is abundant, precise and passenger-friendly. This analysis sets out the compensation scale, the refund and rerouting rights, the defences airlines actually raise, and the exact procedural path to make a foreign carrier pay from a French court.

I. Winter schedule cuts: what Ryanair and easyJet owe every cancelled passenger under EU law

Regulation (EC) No 261/2004 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 11 February 2004, available in its consolidated English version on Regulation (EC) No 261/2004, applies to passengers departing from an airport located in the territory of a Member State, and to passengers departing from a third country to a Member State airport where the operating carrier is a Community carrier. Article 3 defines this scope around two situations: departures from an airport in a Member State, and departures from a third-country airport to a Member State airport where the operating carrier is a Community carrier and the passenger has not already received benefits, compensation and assistance in that third country. A Paris, Nice, Lyon, Bordeaux or Marseille departure is therefore covered whatever the airline’s nationality, and a London to Paris flight operated by an EU carrier is covered as well. That territorial hook is what gives the French courts their daily diet of compensation claims, including claims against carriers whose head office sits in Dublin, Luton or Budapest.

A. When an advance cancellation triggers EUR 250, EUR 400 or EUR 600

The starting point is Article 5 of the Regulation. Where a flight is cancelled, the passengers concerned have the rights set out in the Regulation, including the fixed compensation of Article 7, unless one of three situations applies. The Regulation provides that no compensation is due where passengers are warned of the cancellation at least two weeks before the scheduled departure time. That two-week notice is the airlines’ main shield in the current wave of winter schedule cuts: a passenger warned more than fourteen days ahead cannot claim the fixed sum, however annoying the change of plan. The two other exceptions concern late warnings accompanied by serious rerouting. There is likewise no compensation where passengers warned between two weeks and seven days ahead are offered rerouting that brings them to their final destination less than four hours after schedule with a departure no more than two hours early, or where passengers warned less than seven days ahead are offered rerouting with a departure no more than one hour early and an arrival less than two hours late. In plain terms, the later the warning, the narrower the airline’s escape route. A cancellation announced the day before departure with a replacement arriving five hours late opens the compensation right in full.

Where compensation is due, Article 7 fixes it on a distance scale that leaves no room for negotiation. The Regulation fixes that compensation by distance: EUR 250 for flights of 1,500 kilometres or less, EUR 400 for intra-Community flights above 1,500 kilometres and other flights between 1,500 and 3,500 kilometres, and EUR 600 for longer flights. A Paris to Rome or a Bordeaux to Nice cancellation is worth EUR 250. A Paris to Athens or a Lyon to Marrakech cancellation is worth EUR 400. A Paris to New York cancellation on an EU carrier is worth EUR 600. The airline may halve the sum only where it offers rerouting on an alternative flight whose arrival does not exceed the scheduled arrival by two, three or four hours depending on the distance bracket, and the payment must be made in money, by cash, bank transfer, bank order or bank cheque, with travel vouchers or other services accepted only on the passenger’s signed agreement. Vouchers imposed without the passenger’s signed agreement do not discharge the debt. Miles, credits and goodwill gestures do not either.

The airlines’ standard defence is extraordinary circumstances. Article 5(3) exempts the operating carrier where it proves that the cancellation was caused by extraordinary circumstances which could not have been avoided even if all reasonable measures had been taken. The French Cour de cassation applies this defence strictly, following the Court of Justice of the European Union. In its judgment of 12 September 2018, First Civil Chamber, appeal No. 17-11.361, published in the Bulletin and available on the Cour de cassation website (ECLI:FR:CCASS:2018:C100803), the Court recalled that “qu’un transporteur aérien effectif n’est pas tenu de verser l’indemnisation prévue à l’article 7 s’il est en mesure de prouver que l’annulation ou le retard de trois heures ou plus à l’arrivée à destination d’un vol sont dus à des circonstances extraordinaires qui n’auraient pas pu être évitées même si toutes les mesures raisonnables avaient été prises”, citing the Court of Justice judgments in Sturgeon (C-402/07 and C-432/07 of 19 November 2009) and Nelson (C-581/10 and C-629/10 of 23 October 2012), whose full texts are published on the Sturgeon judgments (C-402/07 and C-432/07). The same decision states the test for the defence: “peuvent être qualifiés de circonstances extraordinaires, au sens de ce texte, les événements qui, par leur nature ou leur origine, ne sont pas inhérents à l’exercice normal de l’activité du transporteur aérien concerné et échappent à la maîtrise effective de celui-ci”, citing Wallentin-Hermann (C-549/07 of 22 December 2008), published on the Wallentin-Hermann judgment (C-549/07). In that 2018 case, the aircraft waiting at Bordeaux-Merignac airport had been struck by lightning, and the proximity court was entitled to treat the strike as extraordinary. Fuel prices, conversely, are inherent in the normal exercise of an airline’s activity and within its commercial control: hedging decisions, however costly, are management choices, not external events. A winter schedule cut motivated by unhedged fuel exposure and weak demand cannot seriously be dressed up as an extraordinary circumstance, and no French court has ever accepted such an argument. Technical faults are treated the same way: the Cour de cassation recalls that events intrinsically linked to the operating system of the aircraft, citing van der Lans (C-257/14 of 17 September 2015), do not qualify. The burden is entirely on the carrier, which must show that “même en mettant en oeuvre tous les moyens en personnel ou en matériel et les moyens financiers dont il disposait, il n’aurait manifestement pas pu, sauf à consentir des sacrifices insupportables au regard des capacités de son entreprise au moment pertinent, éviter que les circonstances extraordinaires auxquelles il était confronté ne conduisent à l’annulation du vol ou à un retard de ce vol égal ou supérieur à trois heures à l’arrivée”. An airline that simply parks aircraft to save fuel will never meet that standard.

Two practical consequences follow for the current wave. First, passengers cancelled with more than two weeks’ notice lose the fixed sum but keep everything else: refund, rerouting and care. Second, passengers cancelled inside fourteen days with a poor replacement keep the full compensation, because fuel economics is not an extraordinary circumstance. Airlines know this, which is why schedule-cut emails systematically offer the refund button first and stay silent about the compensation: every passenger who clicks refund and walks away saves the carrier EUR 250 to EUR 600.

B. Refund, rerouting or a later flight: the choice belongs to the passenger, not the airline

Cancellation opens a three-way choice under Article 8, and the choice belongs to the passenger. The carrier must offer reimbursement within seven days, through the same monetary means, of the full price paid for the unused parts of the journey, and for the parts already flown where the flight no longer serves any purpose in the original travel plan, together where relevant with a return flight to the first point of departure at the earliest opportunity. The alternative is re-routing to the final destination at the earliest opportunity under comparable conditions, or re-routing at a later date at the passenger’s convenience subject to seat availability. That third option is the one shrewd travellers use: a December cancellation can become a Christmas-week seat at the airline’s expense, where fares are normally far higher. The Regulation forbids any waiver of these rights: Article 15 provides for the exclusion of waiver, so a clause in the general conditions of carriage purporting to limit rerouting to the airline’s own flights is unenforceable.

The rerouting right deserves emphasis because it is the most valuable and the least honoured. Press reports describe readers moved to a different day with no alternative offered apart from a refund, yet the position of the regulators is that where another airline flies to the same destination significantly sooner, the passenger may have the right to be booked onto that alternative transport instead. Under EU law the point is stronger than a discussion: re-routing at the earliest opportunity means the earliest possible arrival, including on a competing carrier, and the cancelling airline pays the ticket. Accepting a refund extinguishes the rerouting right, so passengers who still want to travel should never click refund before securing the replacement.

Care under Article 9 comes on top: meals and refreshments in reasonable relation to the waiting time, hotel accommodation where an overnight stay becomes necessary, transport between the airport and the hotel, and two telephone calls or equivalent communications. These are owed regardless of the extraordinary-circumstances defence. A passenger stranded by a cancelled evening flight is entitled to a hotel even where the cancellation itself was caused by a storm. Receipts must be kept, because care is reimbursed on proof of reasonable expense where the airline fails to provide it directly.

Delay doctrine completes the picture for passengers whose flight is not cancelled but arrives hours late after the schedule reshuffle. Since the Court of Justice judgment in Sturgeon, recalled in both Cour de cassation decisions cited here, a flight arriving three hours or more late gives the same fixed compensation as a cancellation. The Cour de cassation confirmed the mechanics in its judgment of 17 February 2021, First Civil Chamber, appeal No. 19-21.362, available on the Cour de cassation website: “peut bénéficier de l’indemnisation prévue à l’article 7 le passager d’un vol qui a atteint sa destination finale avec un retard de trois heures ou plus par rapport à l’heure prévue initialement et cette destination finale est définie comme étant celle figurant sur le billet présenté au comptoir d’enregistrement ou, dans le cas des vols avec correspondance, la destination du dernier vol.” In that case, a Vueling passenger ticketed to Orly had been landed at Roissy-Charles de Gaulle, and the Court quashed the judgment that had refused compensation, adding that “Il résulte du dernier de ces textes qu’il incombe au transporteur aérien de démontrer qu’il s’est acquitté de ses obligations.” The operating carrier bears the burden of proving compliance, and a ministerial decision banning night use of Orly airport beyond a certain hour was held not to be an extraordinary circumstance. Passengers diverted to another airport, rebooked via connections, or arriving past midnight because of the reshuffle should therefore measure the delay at the ticketed final destination, door to door of the journey, and claim where it reaches three hours.

II. Making a foreign airline pay from France: jurisdiction, procedure and proof

Rights on paper are worthless without a court that will enforce them. Here France offers the international passenger a remarkably effective forum: French courts accept these claims against foreign carriers on a daily basis, the jurisdictional rules allow suing at the place of departure, the procedure for small sums is streamlined, and the limitation period is generous. The four steps below reflect how these files are actually won.

A. Which court can order Ryanair, easyJet or any foreign carrier to pay

The first question is jurisdiction, and the answer depends on where the defendant airline is domiciled. Within the European Union, the Brussels I bis Regulation (Regulation (EU) No 1215/2012, published on the Brussels I bis Regulation (Regulation (EU) No 1215/2012)) governs, and the Court of Justice held in Rehder (C-204/08 of 9 July 2009), published on the Rehder judgment (C-204/08), that in air transport both the place of departure and the place of arrival count as places of performance of the service. A passenger departing from Paris may therefore sue an EU-domiciled carrier before the French courts, even where the airline’s seat is in Dublin or Luton. That is the jurisdictional basis for the thousands of French judgments condemning Irish, British, Spanish and Hungarian carriers each year.

Where the carrier is domiciled outside the European Union, French law takes over. Article 6(1) of Brussels I bis provides that jurisdiction is then governed by the law of each Member State, and the Cour de cassation drew the consequences in its judgment of 9 November 2022, First Civil Chamber, appeal No. 21-11.304, available on the Cour de cassation website. Tunisian carrier Tunisair had challenged the jurisdiction of the French courts seized by passengers departing from France, arguing that the aviation code provisions reproducing the Montreal Convention applied. The Court rejected the objection, holding that “si le défendeur n’est pas domicilié sur le territoire d’un État membre, la compétence est, dans chaque État membre, réglée par la loi de cet État membre”, and that “le règlement n° 261/2004 instaure un régime de réparation standardisée et immédiate des préjudices que constituent les désagréments dus aux retards, lequel s’inscrit en amont de la Convention de Montréal et, partant, est autonome par rapport au régime issu de celle-ci.” The Montreal Convention provisions of the transport code, namely Article L. 6422-2 of the Code des transports, under which the liability of the air carrier of goods is governed by the Montreal Convention of 28 May 1999, and Article L. 6421-3 of the same code for passenger carriage, were therefore inapplicable to a claim founded on Regulation 261/2004. Instead, the Court applied the extension to the international order of the domestic territorial jurisdiction rules of Article 46 of the Code of Civil Procedure, under which “Le demandeur peut saisir à son choix, outre la juridiction du lieu où demeure le défendeur : – en matière contractuelle, la juridiction du lieu de la livraison effective de la chose ou du lieu de l’exécution de la prestation de service”. The place of boarding in France is a place of performance of the carriage service, so the court of the French airport of departure has jurisdiction over the foreign carrier. The default rule of Article 42 of the same code, domicile of the defendant, remains available as an alternative, but no passenger departing from France needs to sue in Tunis, Doha or New York.

Within France, the competent court for these modest sums is the tribunal judiciaire, seized by declaration at the registry for the smallest claims, and the territorial options above point to the court of the departure airport or the court of the passenger’s domicile in contractual matters. Before any filing for a sum not exceeding EUR 5,000, an attempt at amicable resolution is mandatory: Article 750-1 of the Code of Civil Procedure provides that “la demande en justice est précédée, au choix des parties, d’une tentative de conciliation menée par un conciliateur de justice, d’une tentative de médiation ou d’une tentative de procédure participative, lorsqu’elle tend au paiement d’une somme n’excédant pas 5 000 euros”, on pain of inadmissibility that the judge may raise of his own motion. In practice this means a documented written complaint to the airline, followed if necessary by a conciliateur de justice or a consumer mediator, before the court filing. Consumers also hold a direct right to consumer mediation: Article L. 612-1 of the Consumer Code states that “Tout consommateur a le droit de recourir gratuitement à un médiateur de la consommation en vue de la résolution amiable du litige qui l’oppose à un professionnel.” Airlines operating in France must designate such a mediator, and the air-travel mediator’s opinion, while not binding, settles a large share of files.

Passengers who bought a package, a flight bundled with a hotel or a tour, hold an additional debtor. Article L. 211-16 of the Tourism Code makes the professional selling a package strictly liable for performance: “est responsable de plein droit de l’exécution des services prévus par ce contrat, que ces services soient exécutés par lui-même ou par d’autres prestataires de services de voyage, sans préjudice de son droit de recours contre ceux-ci.” The tour operator or travel agency that sold the package is strictly liable for the cancelled flight segment, subject only to proof that the damage is attributable to the traveller, to an unrelated third party, or to exceptional and unavoidable circumstances. Suing the French-established seller is often simpler than pursuing the foreign carrier, and the seller’s recourse against the airline is not the passenger’s problem.

B. Deadlines, evidence and the damages beyond the fixed sum

The limitation period is five years. Article 2224 of the Civil Code provides that “Les actions personnelles ou mobilières se prescrivent par cinq ans à compter du jour où le titulaire d’un droit a connu ou aurait dû connaître les faits lui permettant de l’exercer.” A passenger cancelled this winter may therefore still sue in 2030 or 2031, and there is no reason to let the file sleep: airlines change claims handlers, booking records fade, and early action produces faster payment. The five-year period also means that passengers cancelled in earlier schedule culls who never claimed can still act, a point worth checking for anyone who accepted a bare refund in past years without knowing about the compensation.

The winning file is built on four documents. First, the booking confirmation and the ticket showing the ticketed final destination, which fixes the distance bracket and, for connecting flights, the relevant arrival point. Second, the cancellation notice with its date, which determines whether the two-week shield applies. Third, the replacement offered and actually taken, with boarding passes and arrival records establishing the delay at the final destination. Fourth, every receipt for substitute transport, meals, hotel nights and communications, which founds the care and additional-damage claims. Screenshots of the airline’s emails, the refund actually received, and any voucher imposed without signed agreement complete the picture. Where the airline pleads extraordinary circumstances, it must prove them; the passenger’s task is simply to show the cancellation, the notice date and the loss. The 2021 Vueling judgment confirms that the carrier bears the burden of proving it performed its obligations.

Beyond the fixed sum, further loss is recoverable under ordinary French civil liability. Article 1231-1 of the Civil Code provides that “Le débiteur est condamné, s’il y a lieu, au paiement de dommages et intérêts soit à raison de l’inexécution de l’obligation, soit à raison du retard dans l’exécution, s’il ne justifie pas que l’exécution a été empêchée par la force majeure”, and Article 1240 of the same code states that “Tout fait quelconque de l’homme, qui cause à autrui un dommage, oblige celui par la faute duquel il est arrivé à le réparer.” A missed connection causing a lost hotel night, a prepaid tour or a business meeting can therefore be claimed on top of the EUR 250 to EUR 600, on proof of the expense and the causal link. The Court of Justice accepts this articulation: the fixed compensation standardises the inconvenience itself, while proven individual loss follows national law. Non-material loss is harder but not hopeless where the disruption demonstrably ruined the purpose of the trip, and French courts award it sparingly on documented facts rather than bare assertion.

The administrative track runs in parallel. In France, the body designated under Article 16 of the Regulation, which obliges each Member State to appoint an enforcement body for flights from its airports and for incoming third-country flights, is the DGAC, and the official service-public.fr guide for cancelled flights, published on service-public.fr (Voyage en avion : vol annulé), sets out the sequence. It instructs passengers to send their complaint by recorded-delivery letter to the airline’s customer service. Where the airline is a signatory of the mediation charter, the guide directs passengers to the Tourism and Travel mediator where compensation is refused or where no answer arrives within two months. Where the carrier refuses compensation or the passenger finds it insufficient, the guide points to the tribunal judiciaire. A report to the DGAC remains possible alongside these steps, with supporting documents attached. The sequence is therefore: written complaint to the operating carrier first, conciliation or mediation, DGAC report after two months without a satisfactory answer, and court filing where the carrier still refuses. Each step creates a paper trail that strengthens the next.

Conclusion

The winter schedule cuts reported this week change nothing in the law and everything in its application. A cancellation announced more than two weeks ahead defeats the fixed compensation but leaves the refund, the rerouting at the earliest opportunity including on competing carriers, and the care fully intact. A cancellation inside fourteen days with a makeshift replacement preserves the EUR 250, EUR 400 or EUR 600 in full, because unhedged fuel and thin winter demand are commercial realities, not extraordinary circumstances, and the Cour de cassation has defined that defence narrowly, from the lightning strike accepted in the 2018 easyJet case to the night-flight ban rejected in the 2021 Vueling case. From France, the enforcement forum is secured: Rehder jurisdiction at departure or arrival for EU carriers, Article 46 of the Code of Civil Procedure extended to the international order for the others, as the 2022 Tunisair judgment confirms, with a five-year limitation period and a streamlined small-claims path once the mandatory amicable attempt is documented. Passengers holding a winter ticket on Ryanair, easyJet or any other carrier should therefore read the cancellation email as the opening of a file, not the end of the trip: keep the notice, note its date, refuse the bare refund where travel is still wanted, demand the earliest rerouting, keep every receipt, complain in writing, and let the French courts do the rest.

📄 Official circular