KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Your French Rent or Sale Gain Just Got Hit With 17.2% Social Charges: What Americans Owe, How to Reclaim, and How to Credit It in the US

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Your French Rent or Sale Gain Just Got Hit With 17.2% Social Charges: What Americans Owe, How to Reclaim, and How to Credit It in the US

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

You opened your French tax notice and did the math twice. On top of French income tax, France took another 17.2 percent of your rental income, or of the gain on the sale of your French house, under a line labeled social charges. If you live in the United States and pay into the American Social Security system, your first reaction is logical: why am I paying French social security when I will never collect a euro of French benefits? Your second reaction is just as logical: there must be a refund to claim.

This article gives you the honest answer, with the numbers, the court decisions, and the procedures. The short version is uncomfortable. A French appeals court, ruling on exactly your situation, rejected the claim. And in March 2026 the Conseil d’Etat confirmed that even furnished seasonal rents taxed as business profits still bear the French solidarity levy. But two real remedies exist. If you are affiliated to a European social security scheme rather than only the American one, you should have paid 7.5 percent instead of 17.2 percent, and the overcharge is recoverable with interest before a strict deadline. And whatever you paid, the American Internal Revenue Service has recognized since 2019 that the French CSG and CRDS count as creditable taxes under the Franco-American tax treaty, so the 17.2 percent is not lost money on your American return either.

I. Why France Takes 17.2 Percent of Your Rent or Sale Gain Even Though You Live in America

French taxation of property income has two floors, and Americans often discover only the first one before buying. The first floor is income tax: your French rents are taxable in France because the building is in France, and your gain on selling French real estate is taxable in France for the same reason. The tax treaty signed on August 31, 1994 between France and the United States confirms this in its Articles 6 and 13, and organizes relief on the American side in its Article 24. The second floor is the one that shocks: the prélèvements sociaux, the social charges, currently 17.2 percent of the same income. They are computed on the net amount used for income tax purposes, they appear on the same French tax notice, and the notaire withholds them at closing when you sell. Understanding that these charges are a separate tax, with separate legal foundations and separate case law, is the key to everything that follows.

A. The 17.2 Percent Stack: CSG, CRDS, and the Solidarity Levy on French Property Income

Three separate levies add up to the 17.2 percent. First, the contribution sociale généralisée (CSG), the generalized social contribution, at 9.2 percent on property income. The Social Security Code provides that persons not domiciled in France for tax purposes are subject to the contribution on the net amount of the income listed in item (a) of paragraph I of Article 164 B of the General Tax Code, retained for the computation of income tax: The provision brings within the contribution individuals who are not tax-domiciled in France, on the net amount of the income covered by item (a) of paragraph I of Article 164 B of the General Tax Code, as retained for income-tax assessment. And the rate provision states that “sont assujettis à la contribution sociale au taux de 9,2 % : 1° Les revenus mentionnés au a du I de l’article L. 136-6”, which covers your rents and gains. Read those two provisions together through these links: Article L. 136-6 of the Social Security Code and Article L. 136-8 of the same Code. Collection of the CSG on capital income follows the rules of Article L. 136-6, as recalled by Article 1600-0 C of the General Tax Code.

Second, the contribution au remboursement de la dette sociale (CRDS), the social debt repayment contribution, at 0.5 percent. It is established on capital income by reference to Article 15 of the Ordinance of January 24, 1996, as recalled by Article 1600-0 G of the General Tax Code. Third, the prélèvement de solidarité, the solidarity levy, at 7.5 percent. The General Tax Code provides: “Un prélèvement de solidarité sur les revenus du patrimoine”, and adds: “Le taux des prélèvements de solidarité mentionnés au I est fixé à 7,5 %.” See Article 235 ter of the General Tax Code. Nine point two plus zero point five plus seven point five equals 17.2 percent. That is the full stack an American affiliated only to the United States Social Security system pays on French rental income and on French real estate gains.

Run your own numbers. You collect 12,000 euros of net rent on your Paris studio: the social charges are 2,064 euros, of which 1,104 euros of CSG, 60 euros of CRDS, and 900 euros of solidarity levy. You sell your Dordogne house with a taxable gain of 100,000 euros: the social charges withheld through the notaire’s settlement are 17,200 euros, before and besides the capital gains tax itself, which for nonresidents is collected by a separate levy under Article 244 bis A of the General Tax Code while residents fall under Article 150 U of the same Code. These worked examples explain why the line on the notice deserves your full attention: on a sale, the social charges alone often exceed a year of rental income.

B. Why Your American Social Security Coverage Changes Nothing in France

The exemption that Europeans invoke comes from one precise paragraph. By derogation, the Social Security Code relieves persons who, under European Union Regulation 883/2004 on the coordination of social security systems, are subject for sickness insurance to legislation governed by those provisions and are not covered by a compulsory French scheme: By way of derogation, the Code relieves persons who, under European Union Regulation 883/2004 on social-security coordination, are covered for sickness insurance by legislation governed by those provisions while not being covered by a compulsory French scheme. That exemption is European coordination law. It covers a person insured in Germany, the Netherlands, Ireland, or Switzerland. It does not cover a person insured only in the United States, because the United States is not party to that Regulation. This is the hinge of the whole subject: the question is never whether you pay social contributions somewhere, but whether you are covered by a scheme the French statute recognizes.

The courts have answered that question for Americans, and the answer is no. In a decision of June 30, 2020, the Marseille Administrative Court of Appeal ruled on a United States resident who asked for discharge of the social charges paid on a French real estate gain realized in 2015. The court first recalled that the European Regulation applies to persons subject to the legislation of one or more Member States, extended only to the European Economic Area and Switzerland, so that the claimant, who relied solely on his situation as a United States resident, could not invoke it. Then it examined the Social Security Agreement of March 2, 1987 between France and the United States, and held: “Ni cette stipulation, ni aucune autre de l’accord franco-américain n’établissent un principe d’unicité de la législation applicable en matière de sécurité sociale comparable à celui existant en application de l’article 11 du règlement du 29 avril 2004.” In other words, the bilateral agreement creates no single-legislation shield comparable to the European one. The court added that nothing in the agreement prevents French capital income from bearing the French social contributions, and it rejected the claim: the request was dismissed and the 2015 charges stood. Read the full official text here: CAA Marseille, June 30, 2020, No. 19MA01207.

One more foundation matters before turning to remedies: these charges attach to the French source of the income, not to your residence. The General Tax Code treats as French-source income “Les revenus d’immeubles sis en France ou de droits relatifs à ces immeubles”, see Article 164 B of the General Tax Code. If the building sits in France, the rent or gain is French-source, and the social charges follow it. That is why moving back to Florida, holding the property through an American revocable trust, or collecting the rent on an American bank account changes nothing about the French charge itself. What can change the amount is the subject of the second part: a European affiliation that drops the bill to 7.5 percent, a reclaim procedure with interest when France overcharged, and the American foreign tax credit that absorbs what France keeps.

II. Pay Less or Get It Back: the 7.5 Percent Cases, the French Reclaim, and the American Credit

Three doors, in order of value. Door one: you are affiliated to a European scheme, so France should only have taken 7.5 percent, and every point above that is recoverable. Door two: France took 17.2 percent and keeps it, but the overcharge was a plain error, so you file a formal claim with interest before the deadline kills it. Door three: France keeps the money lawfully, and the United States gives it back to you as a foreign tax credit. Most American readers will walk through door three; readers working in London, Berlin, Dublin, or Geneva with a French rental on the side will walk through door one. Here is each door with its paperwork.

A. When Only 7.5 Percent Is Due and How to Reclaim the Overcharge From France

The reduced rate belongs to taxpayers who, under Regulation 883/2004, are subject for sickness insurance to the legislation of a European Union or European Economic Area State or Switzerland, and are not covered by a compulsory French scheme. The same relief, under the withdrawal agreements, covers taxpayers affiliated to British social security who are nationals or legal residents of France, the United Kingdom, or another European Union State. In that case, only the solidarity levy of 7.5 percent is due, because it funds the State budget rather than the social security system, while the 9.2 percent CSG and the 0.5 percent CRDS drop away. On the 12,000-euro rent of the earlier example, the bill falls from 2,064 euros to 900 euros: a 1,164-euro recoverable overcharge for a single year.

France applies the reduced rate in two ways. Prospectively, you tick boxes 8SH for the first declarant and 8SI for the second in section 8 of return 2042-C, and you report only the income that remains subject to the solidarity levy, with supporting affiliation evidence. The tax administration requires the affiliation to be effective on December 31 of the year the income was received or the gain realized. The official procedure is described on the public tax portal: Non-resident: am I liable for social contributions (impots.gouv.fr). Retroactively, if the 17.2 percent was already assessed, you file a contentious claim, the réclamation contentieuse, through the secure messaging of your personal online account or by letter to the Non-Residents Individual Tax Department, attaching the assessment showing the charges and the proof of your European affiliation. The claim must arrive no later than December 31 of the second year following the year of collection or of the event giving rise to the claim: “Pour être recevables, les réclamations relatives aux impôts autres que les impôts directs locaux et les taxes annexes à ces impôts, doivent être présentées à l’administration au plus tard le 31 décembre de la deuxième année suivant celle, selon le cas : a) De la mise en recouvrement du rôle ou de la notification d’un avis de mise en recouvrement”. See Article R*196-1 of the Tax Procedures Book. Miss that date and the overcharge becomes final, however well founded the claim. Win, and the sums already collected are refunded with late-payment interest: “les sommes déjà perçues sont remboursées au contribuable et donnent lieu au paiement d’intérêts moratoires dont le taux est celui de l’intérêt de retard”, see Article L. 208 of the Tax Procedures Book.

A March 2026 ruling widens the 7.5 percent logic to income many owners assumed was outside it. The Conseil d’Etat held that nonresident individuals are subject to the solidarity levy on rents from French property whatever their income-tax category, stating: “Constituent des revenus d’immeubles au sens de ces dispositions les loyers issus d’immeubles situés en France, quelle que soit la catégorie d’imposition dont ils relèvent.” The case concerned Swiss residents taxed on seasonal furnished rents falling under commercial profits rather than rental income, and the court rejected their appeal in full. For you the lesson cuts both ways: furnished-rental income does not escape the solidarity levy, but by the same reasoning it cannot be pushed into a higher charge on category grounds either. Read the decision here: Conseil d’Etat, March 13, 2026, No. 503496. If your French rental is taxed as a furnished business, check the assessment line by line: the solidarity levy applies, the CSG and CRDS apply or not according to your affiliation, and any 17.2 percent assessment on a European-affiliated owner is a reclaim waiting to happen.

B. The American Remedy That Works: Crediting the French Charges Against Your United States Tax

For the American affiliated only to the United States system, the French courts offer no refund, but the American return offers a credit, and since 2019 that credit expressly covers the French charges at issue. The French tax administration itself explains that, under the tax treaty of August 31, 1994 between France and the United States, the terms of Article 24, which set how the United States computes the credit against American income tax, had once led the American administration to treat the CSG and the CRDS as outside the scope, and that this position has since been abandoned: In an official publication dated July 19, 2019, the American Internal Revenue Service recognized the CSG and the CRDS as taxes falling within the scope of the tax treaty, and not as social-security contributions. The administration adds: Since then, the CSG and the CRDS enter into the computation of the credit against American income tax granted both to American residents receiving French-source income and to French residents subject to American tax by reason of their American nationality. Both passages come from the official doctrine of the French tax administration: BOI-INT-DG-20-20-100, paragraph 140 (BOFiP).

The American side confirms it in plain English on the public IRS website. In 2019 the two countries recorded through diplomatic communications the understanding that the CSG and CRDS are not social taxes covered by the Social Security Agreement between them: In 2019, the two countries recorded through diplomatic communications their shared understanding that the CSG and CRDS are not social taxes covered by the bilateral Social Security Agreement. Consequence: The IRS accordingly does not challenge foreign tax credits for CSG and CRDS payments on the ground that the Social Security Agreement would apply to those taxes. Individuals claim the credit on Form 1116, Foreign Tax Credit, filed with the return. Those who paid the charges in earlier years without claiming the credit can file amended returns: Taxpayers amending prior returns are instructed to mark the words French CSG/CRDS Taxes in red at the top of Form 1040-X and to attach Form 1116 completed per its instructions. And the window is generous: taxpayers generally have ten years from the day after the regular due date of the return for the year the foreign taxes were paid or accrued to claim the refund. Source: IRS, Foreign Tax Credit (official page).

Put the two systems together on one timeline. Year one: you declare the French rent on the French return, or the notaire withholds on the sale price, and the 17.2 percent is assessed. If you are European-affiliated, you tick the 8SH or 8SI box immediately or file the French contentious claim before December 31 of year three, recovering the 9.7-point spread with interest. Either way, you report the same French income on the American return and you compute the foreign tax credit on Form 1116, attaching the French assessment as proof of payment. The credit cannot exceed the American tax attributable to the same income, so excess French charges may carry forward rather than refund immediately, and the treaty relief article governs the computation year by year. Readers managing the full cycle, French declaration plus American credit, will find the companion guides useful: how French rental income is declared and credited under the treaty (French rental income of an American owner: declaration and treaty credit), and how a sale gain is computed, withheld, and credited (Selling a French second home: capital gains tax, notaire, and American credit). A related decision on the pension side of the same CSG and CRDS question is analyzed here (American retiree: United States pension, CSG and CRDS, challenge and refund).

Conclusion

France is entitled to charge social levies on income whose source is French soil, and for an American covered only by the United States system that charge is the full 17.2 percent: 9.2 percent CSG, 0.5 percent CRDS, and 7.5 percent solidarity levy. The Marseille court confirmed in 2020 that neither the European Regulation nor the 1987 Franco-American agreement spares the United States resident, and the Conseil d’Etat confirmed in March 2026 that furnished rents bear the solidarity levy whatever their tax category. Do not spend money relitigating those two points. Spend it instead on the two remedies that the sources above establish. If you are affiliated to a European, Swiss, or British scheme, verify whether France took 17.2 instead of 7.5, tick the correct boxes going forward, and file the contentious claim with affiliation proof before December 31 of the second following year, with interest running in your favor. In all cases, carry the CSG and CRDS onto the American return through the foreign tax credit, amending prior years where the ten-year American window is still open and marking the amended return as the IRS instructions require. Calculate first, reclaim where the statute allows, credit everything else: that is the complete American strategy for French social charges.

📄 Official circular