You bought the stone house outside Sarlat fifteen years ago, and the plan has always been simple: when you die, everything goes to your spouse, and the children will inherit what is left later. Then a French notaire tells you that France does not work that way. Children are what French law calls reserved heirs, and with two children only one third of your estate is freely disposable. The rest is locked for them by a rule Americans usually meet for the first time at the worst possible moment. There is, however, a legal tool designed exactly for your situation. Since 2015, a European regulation has allowed anyone who owns property in France to choose the law of their nationality to govern their entire succession, and that choice is available even if you have never lived in France and never intend to. For an American, it means your French house can pass under the law of your home state rather than under the French forced share. This guide explains how that choice works, how to write it so a French notaire will honor it, where its limits lie for your children, and how the French tax bill and the Franco-American estate treaty fit around it. The short version is encouraging but precise: the choice is real, it must be written expressly in your will, it names a specific American state rather than American law in general, and it does not erase French taxes or every protection French law gives your children.
I. Can an American really choose US law for a French house? What the EU succession regulation allows
A. Why French law applies by default to your French house, and how a professio juris displaces it
Start with the default rule, because the choice only makes sense against it. The European Succession Regulation, Regulation (EU) No 650/2012 of July 4, 2012, governs which law applies to successions connected with France for deaths occurring on or after August 17, 2015. Its transitional provision states the date plainly: “This Regulation shall apply to the succession of persons who die on or after 17 August 2015.” The general rule is habitual residence: “Unless otherwise provided for in this Regulation, the law applicable to the succession as a whole shall be the law of the State in which the deceased had his habitual residence at the time of death.” If you retired to Lyon and die there, French law governs everything you own worldwide, including any account left in the United States. If you stayed in Florida and kept the Dordogne house as a second home, the default points to Florida law for the whole succession, French house included, because the old French system that split movable and immovable property between different laws is gone for these deaths.
That default is less comfortable than it looks, for two reasons. First, when the applicable law is designated by habitual residence, the regulation lets the conflicts rules of a non-European state send the question back. American readers should picture the trap: Florida conflicts rules traditionally send immovable property back to the law of the place where the land sits, which would quietly restore French law for the Sarlat house. Second, habitual residence is a facts-and-circumstances test, and globally mobile families argue about it after death. An express choice of law cuts through both problems. The regulation provides that “No renvoi shall apply with respect to the laws referred to in Article 21(2), Article 22, Article 27, point (b) of Article 28 and Article 30.” Because Article 22 is on that list, a valid professio juris in favor of American law means the French notaire applies the designated American state law directly, with no bounce back to French law through conflicts rules.
Two features of the regulation make the choice genuinely available to Americans. First, the chosen law does not have to be the law of a European country: “Any law specified by this Regulation shall be applied whether or not it is the law of a Member State.” A French notaire settling a succession in Périgueux is therefore required to apply the law of New York or California to your estate if that is what you validly chose, just as a French court would apply French law. Second, the choice covers the succession as a whole, and the regulation lists what that includes: the determination of the beneficiaries and their shares, capacity to inherit, disinheritance, and the transfer of the assets to the heirs. On disinheritance and shares, the text provides that the applicable law governs “the determination of the beneficiaries, of their respective shares and of the obligations which may be imposed on them by the deceased, and the determination of other succession rights, including the succession rights of the surviving spouse or partner.” It also governs “disinheritance and disqualification by conduct.” In plain terms, the question whether you may leave the French house entirely to your spouse and nothing to your adult children is answered by the law you chose, not by French forced heirship, subject to the French safety nets examined in Part II.
To understand why France built those safety nets, look at what French courts did before the regulation existed. In a decision of July 4, 2018, the First Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation dealt with a Moroccan father whose rabbinical will, validated by a Moroccan judgment enforced in France, largely excluded one son. The court approved the Paris court of appeal for holding that the French immovables in the estate had to take the forced share into account: “la dévolution successorale desdits immeubles devait tenir compte des règles de la réserve héréditaire, laquelle, d’ordre public interne, ne pouvait être écartée par des dispositions testamentaires établies selon la loi du domicile du défunt et régissant son statut personnel.” That case, appeal number 17-16.515, belongs to the old world in which French immovables always fell under French law. The regulation replaced that automatic outcome with unity of the succession, but France answered in 2021 with a new statutory corrective that follows French property even under a foreign applicable law, as Part II explains.
B. How to write a choice-of-law clause from America that a French notaire will accept
The choice is open to you on one condition that every American satisfies: nationality. The regulation provides that “A person may choose as the law to govern his succession as a whole the law of the State whose nationality he possesses at the time of making the choice or at the time of death.” You may choose American law even if you live in France, and you may equally make the choice from your living room in Texas having never set foot in a French notaire’s office. If you hold two nationalities, the regulation adds that “A person possessing multiple nationalities may choose the law of any of the States whose nationality he possesses at the time of making the choice or at the time of death.” A dual French-American citizen therefore has a genuine option: choose French law and accept the forced share, or choose American law and organize the succession freely. Nothing in the text forces a dual national toward either side.
The form of the choice is where American wills most often fail. The regulation requires that “The choice shall be made expressly in a declaration in the form of a disposition of property upon death or shall be demonstrated by the terms of such a disposition.” An oral statement to your children, a letter kept in a drawer, or a clause in a revocable living trust that a French notaire cannot characterize as a disposition of property upon death will not do the job reliably. The safe instrument is a will that contains an express sentence choosing the applicable law. A model sentence reads: I choose the law of the State of New York to govern my succession as a whole pursuant to Article 22 of Regulation (EU) No 650/2012. Adapt the state, keep the reference to Article 22, and have the clause reviewed before signing, because an ambiguous clause invites exactly the litigation the choice is meant to prevent.
Naming the state, and not just the United States, is essential. Succession law in America is state law, and the regulation anticipates countries with more than one territorial legal system: for nationality-based designations, the reference is construed as pointing to “the law of the territorial unit with which the deceased had the closest connection.” A clause that says American law leaves the French notaire to reconstruct your closest connection among fifty states, while a clause that says the law of the State of Florida, where you are domiciled and vote, answers the question on the face of the document. Name the state whose law you actually live under, keep the clause consistent across every will and codicil you sign afterward, and remember that any later modification or revocation of the choice must meet the same formal requirements as the modification of a will. The regulation confirms that the substantive validity of the act making the choice is governed by the chosen law itself, so draft the clause so that it is valid under both French formal requirements and the requirements of the state you designate.
For the French side of validity, the holographic will remains the simplest instrument an American can sign without traveling. The Civil Code provides that “Le testament olographe ne sera point valable s’il n’est écrit en entier, daté et signé de la main du testateur : il n’est assujetti à aucune autre forme.” Write the entire will by hand, date it precisely, and sign it. A will typed on a computer and merely signed at the bottom is not a holographic will and fails the definition. Because the choice-of-law clause sits inside a will that is formally valid in France, the professio juris survives even if something in the designated American state law were later debated. Send a copy to the French notaire who holds your property file, tell your spouse and your executor where the original is kept, and check that the notaire has recorded the will’s existence so it surfaces when the succession opens. Readers dealing with a parent who died without any findable will face a different procedure, described in our guide for Americans who must search the French wills file, prove the will, and claim the house.
One jurisdictional point completes the picture. Choosing American law decides which substantive rules apply, but it does not by itself decide which country’s courts or notaires handle the paperwork. For an American who dies habitually resident in the United States, the regulation gives the courts of the country where estate assets sit a fallback role limited to those assets: where no member-state court has jurisdiction under the primary rule, “the courts of the Member State in which assets of the estate are located shall nevertheless have jurisdiction to rule on those assets.” In practice, the French notaire settles the French house under the American state law you chose, while an American probate court handles the American assets. Contrast this with the position of a French national who retired abroad: the Court of Cassation held on September 21, 2022, in appeal number 19-15.438, that where the deceased held French nationality and owned property in France, the French courts are competent for the whole succession under the subsidiary jurisdiction rule, and the judge must raise that competence on his own motion. The court quoted the Court of Justice of the European Union’s April 7, 2022 ruling in case C-645/20, under which the subsidiary jurisdiction text “doit être interprété en ce sens qu’une juridiction d’un État membre doit relever d’office sa compétence au titre de la règle de compétence subsidiaire prévue à cette disposition lorsque, ayant été saisie sur le fondement de la règle de compétence générale établie à l’article 4 de ce règlement, elle constate qu’elle n’est pas compétente au titre de cette dernière disposition.” An American with no French nationality does not benefit from that whole-succession jurisdiction, which is one more reason to keep the American and French files coordinated through a single estate plan.
II. What choosing American law changes for your children, your spouse, and your taxes
A. Can your children still claim a forced share? Reserve, reduction, and the 2021 compensatory levy
To measure what the choice gains you, first measure what French law takes without it. The forced share, called the réserve héréditaire, is defined by the Civil Code as “La réserve héréditaire est la part des biens et droits successoraux dont la loi assure la dévolution libre de charges à certains héritiers dits réservataires, s’ils sont appelés à la succession et s’ils l’acceptent.” The reserved heirs are your children, or your spouse if you have no children. The fractions are fixed: “Les libéralités, soit par actes entre vifs, soit par testament, ne pourront excéder la moitié des biens du disposant, s’il ne laisse à son décès qu’un enfant ; le tiers, s’il laisse deux enfants ; le quart, s’il en laisse trois ou un plus grand nombre.” With two children and a French house worth 600,000 euros, gifts and legacies together cannot exceed 200,000 euros, and each child is guaranteed 200,000 euros. A will that leaves everything to your spouse is reduced to fit inside the freely disposable third, and the spouse keeps the rest only through separate mechanisms such as a gift between spouses or a change of matrimonial regime, each with its own conditions.
The enforcement tool is the action in reduction, and its standing rules matter for blended families. The Civil Code provides that “La réduction des dispositions entre vifs ne pourra être demandée que par ceux au profit desquels la loi fait la réserve, par leurs héritiers ou ayants cause : les donataires, les légataires, ni les créanciers du défunt ne pourront demander cette réduction, ni en profiter.” Only the reserved heir, or someone standing in his place, can sue. The same article sets the clock: “Le délai de prescription de l’action en réduction est fixé à cinq ans à compter de l’ouverture de la succession, ou à deux ans à compter du jour où les héritiers ont eu connaissance de l’atteinte portée à leur réserve, sans jamais pouvoir excéder dix ans à compter du décès.” It also imposes a duty on the notaire who spots the problem during settlement to warn each affected heir individually of the right to seek reduction before any partition. American families should read this as a litigation calendar: a child who learns three years after the death that the French house went entirely to the stepmother still has time to act, and the notaire is required to hand that child the information needed to do so.
Now apply your professio juris. If the designated American state law lets you leave everything to your spouse, the French forced share as such does not apply, because shares are determined by the chosen law. France’s answer since 2021 is the compensatory levy, the prélèvement compensatoire, written into the final paragraph of Article 913: “Lorsque le défunt ou au moins l’un de ses enfants est, au moment du décès, ressortissant d’un Etat membre de l’Union européenne ou y réside habituellement et lorsque la loi étrangère applicable à la succession ne permet aucun mécanisme réservataire protecteur des enfants, chaque enfant ou ses héritiers ou ses ayants cause peuvent effectuer un prélèvement compensatoire sur les biens existants situés en France au jour du décès, de façon à être rétablis dans les droits réservataires que leur octroie la loi française, dans la limite de ceux-ci.” Read the eligibility condition twice, because it decides many American cases. The levy requires that the deceased or at least one of the children be a European Union national or habitually resident in the Union at the time of death. A Florida family with no European nationality and no European residence falls outside the provision entirely, and the French house passes under the chosen American law without this corrective. A family where one child studies and lives in Paris, or where the deceased also held an Irish passport, falls inside it, and each child can take from the French-situated assets enough to restore the French reserved share.
Beyond the levy sits the general safety valve of European conflicts law, and its threshold is deliberately high. The regulation provides that “The application of a provision of the law of any State specified by this Regulation may be refused only if such application is manifestly incompatible with the public policy (ordre public) of the forum.” The word manifestly does real work: a French court does not set aside the chosen American law merely because it differs from French law or because it disappoints a child. The provision must shock the forum’s fundamental values in the concrete case. American planners should therefore treat the ordre public exception as catastrophic-risk insurance rather than as a likely outcome, and focus their drafting energy on the levy, whose conditions are mechanical and predictable.
For spouses, the choice has a clean upside worth stating precisely. A universal legacy is defined as “Le legs universel est la disposition testamentaire par laquelle le testateur donne à une ou plusieurs personnes l’universalité des biens qu’il laissera à son décès.” Where no reserved heir stands against it, the Civil Code gives the universal legatee immediate possession: “Lorsqu’au décès du testateur il n’y aura pas d’héritiers auxquels une quotité de ses biens soit réservée par la loi, le légataire universel sera saisi de plein droit par la mort du testateur, sans être tenu de demander la délivrance.” Combine a valid professio juris with a universal legacy to your spouse in a childless couple, and the surviving spouse is seized of the French house by operation of law at death, with no delivery request to file. Where children exist and the levy or the reduction action applies, the same universal legacy is simply cut back to the disposable portion, and the notaire computes the shares. Either way, the will should say in the same instrument both the choice of law and the universal legacy, so the notaire never has to assemble your intention from scattered papers.
B. Who taxes the French house after death, and how the treaty credit and the notaire timeline work
Choosing American law changes which private law governs the succession. It changes nothing about which tax authority gets paid. France taxes the French house because it sits in France, regardless of where you lived, what passport you held, or which law your will chose. The Tax Code provides that the estates of persons not domiciled in France for tax purposes still face French transfer duties on French-situated property: Article 750 ter of the Tax Code taxes worldwide property where the deceased was domiciled for tax purposes in France, and taxes property situated in France, held directly or indirectly, where the deceased was not. An American domiciled in Florida who dies owning the Sarlat house falls under the second paragraph: the house is taxable in France. Note the phrase directly or indirectly. A house held through a French property company or a foreign entity does not escape the net, and the statute extends the French characterization to shares in unlisted companies whose assets consist mainly of French real estate. Holding structures change the computation, not the principle.
The 1978 Franco-American estate and gift tax convention confirms the allocation and then organizes the relief. Its real-property rule is one sentence: “Les biens immobiliers sont imposables par un Etat contractant si ces biens sont situés dans cet Etat.” France therefore taxes the Dordogne house, and the United States taxes the worldwide estate of its citizens and domiciliaries under its own law. Double taxation is avoided not by exempting the house in one country but by credits each country grants under its own legislation. The convention states the method in general terms: “A moins que la présente Convention n’en dispose autrement, chaque Etat contractant perçoit son impôt et accorde les exonérations, abattements, crédits et autres déductions, conformément à sa législation.” For a decedent domiciled in France, the text is concrete: “La France impose l’intégralité de l’actif successoral faisant partie de la succession, y compris ceux qui sont imposables aux Etats-Unis conformément aux dispositions de la présente Convention, et accorde, sur cet impôt, une déduction d’un montant égal à l’impôt payé aux Etats-Unis au moment de la transmission des biens qui, à l’occasion du même événement, sont imposables aux Etats-Unis.” For a decedent domiciled in the United States, the mirror applies on the American return for the French tax paid on the French house, within the limits each country’s law sets. The practical consequence is a coordination task, not a choice between two tax bills: the notaire computes and collects the French duties, the American executor reports the worldwide estate to the Internal Revenue Service, and each file references the other so the credit is actually claimed. Families who leave the two files to two professionals who never speak to each other are the families who pay twice and discover it too late.
Married couples get one additional treaty protection that is easy to overlook. Where property acquired for consideration during the marriage passes to the surviving spouse, the convention treats it as community property for computing the French tax unless the spouses expressly opted for a different regime: “Les biens (autres que les biens de communauté) qui ont été acquis durant le mariage à titre onéreux par une personne physique qui, au moment de son décès ou à celui auquel elle a effectué une donation, était domiciliée aux Etats-Unis ou possédait la citoyenneté américaine, et qui sont transmis au conjoint de cette personne physique, sont considérés comme s’ils étaient des biens de communauté pour déterminer l’impôt français, à moins que les conjoints aient expressément choisi de se placer sous un régime autre que celui de la communauté de biens prévu par le droit civil français.” Combined with the complete exemption from French succession duties between spouses in domestic law, this assimilation usually means the surviving American spouse takes the house with no French transfer tax on the transmission, while the children’s later inheritance is where the tax computation bites. Verify the matrimonial regime before counting on it: spouses married under a separation-of-property regime who never changed it do not benefit from community treatment, and the treaty assimilation follows the same boundary.
The calendar is the last trap, and it runs from the day of death. The Tax Code provides that “Les délais pour l’enregistrement des déclarations que les héritiers, donataires ou légataires ont à souscrire des biens à eux échus ou transmis par décès sont : De six mois, à compter du jour du décès, lorsque celui dont on recueille la succession est décédé en France métropolitaine; D’une année, dans tous les autres cas.” An American who dies in the United States gives the heirs one year to file the French declaration and pay the duties. A year sounds comfortable until you list what must cross the Atlantic in that time: the death certificate with authentication and certified translation, the will and its choice-of-law clause, proof of the content of the designated American state law for the notaire’s file, family records establishing each heir’s identity and relationship, valuations of the French property, and the American estate file needed to compute the treaty credit. Late filing draws interest and penalties that no treaty credit reimburses. Open the French file within weeks of the death, not months, and give the notaire the American executor’s contact details on the first day so the two computations move in parallel. Readers facing the full post-death sequence will find the step-by-step treatment in our guide for Americans whose parent died owning a house in France, covering the succession, the tax, and the treaty credit from the American side of the Atlantic.
Conclusion
An American owner of a French house is not condemned to the French forced share. The European Succession Regulation lets you choose the law of your nationality for your succession as a whole, that choice reaches the French house even though you live in America, and no renvoi sends the question back to French law once the choice is validly made. Write the choice expressly into a will, name the American state whose law you live under rather than American law in the abstract, and keep the will in a form France recognizes on its face, wholly handwritten, dated, and signed. Expect two boundaries to hold. On the civil side, children protected by the 2021 compensatory levy can still take from the French assets where the eligibility conditions are met, and the action in reduction runs on its five, two, and ten-year clocks. On the fiscal side, France taxes the house because it stands in France, the 1978 convention allocates the taxing rights and organizes the credits, and the declaration must be filed within a year of an American death. Done in that order, choice first, spouse protected, children measured, taxes coordinated, the professio juris turns a collision between two legal worlds into a succession the notaire can actually settle.