Your parent died owning a house in France. You live in Ohio, your brother lives in Lyon, and your sister answers your emails once a season. You want to sell the house, pay the taxes, divide the money, and move on. Your brother refuses. He likes the house, or he dislikes you, or he simply does nothing, which comes to the same thing. This is the most common deadlock in Franco-American successions, and French law has a complete answer for it. From the day of death until the final division, the house sits in a legal waiting room called indivision, a form of co-ownership where each heir owns a share of the whole rather than a defined room or floor. Nobody can sell the house alone, but nobody can block the exit forever either. This guide explains what each co-heir can still do without the others, what money the heir who occupies the house owes the rest of the family, and how you force the sale from America when agreement is impossible, including the court-ordered division known as partage, the auction sale called licitation, the 2.5 percent partition tax, and the mechanics of bringing your share back to the United States.
I. My Sibling Refuses to Sell Our French House: What Each Co-Heir Can Still Do Alone
Before reaching for the court, you need an exact map of the waiting room. French co-ownership between heirs runs on a small set of rules that decide who can insure the roof, renew the lease, collect the rent, or live in the house, and which decisions stay frozen until every heir agrees. Knowing these rules also tells you which of your sibling’s moves are valid and which ones a judge will undo.
A. Can a Majority of Heirs Manage or Sell the French House Without the Holdout?
The starting point is a sentence every French succession lawyer knows by heart. Article 815 of the Civil Code provides that “Nul ne peut être contraint à demeurer dans l’indivision et le partage peut toujours être provoqué, à moins qu’il n’y ait été sursis par jugement ou convention.” In plain English, no one can be forced to stay in co-ownership, and any co-owner can demand the division at any time, unless a court judgment or a signed agreement has suspended that right. That single rule is your leverage in every conversation with the sibling who refuses to move: the law is on the side of the exit, not the deadlock. Note the two exceptions, because your sibling may invoke them. A judge can order a temporary stay of the division, and the heirs can sign an agreement to remain undivided for a limited time. Outside those two cases, the right to demand division never expires while the co-ownership lasts, so waiting years changes nothing in your favor or against you (Civil Code, Article 815: division may always be demanded).
While the house remains undivided, ordinary life continues: the roof leaks, the property tax arrives, the tenant’s lease comes up for renewal. Any single heir can take conservation measures, even without urgency, under Article 815-2 of the Civil Code, which states that any co-owner may take the steps needed to preserve the undivided property and may use the co-ownership funds held by that heir for that purpose. If you pay a roofer from your own pocket because the family account is empty, you can force your co-heirs to share necessary expenses with you. This matters from America because it means you do not need your brother’s permission to stop the house from deteriorating; you need receipts.
One level above conservation sits day-to-day management. Article 815-3 of the Civil Code gives the holders of at least two-thirds of the undivided rights the power to perform administrative acts, grant a general management mandate, sell divisible movables to pay the debts of the co-ownership, and sign or renew ordinary leases. So if you and your sister together hold two-thirds, you can hire a management agent, renew the tenant’s lease, and pay the bills without your brother. But the same article draws a hard line that decides most family disputes: “le consentement de tous les indivisaires est requis pour effectuer tout acte qui ne ressortit pas à l’exploitation normale des biens indivis et pour effectuer tout acte de disposition autre que ceux visés au 3°”, which means every act outside normal operation, and every act that disposes of rights in the property, requires the consent of all co-owners. Selling the house is an act of disposition. No majority, however large, can sell the French house over the refusal of one co-heir.
The courts apply that line strictly, and two recent rulings show how far it goes. On July 2, 2026, the Third Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation held that “sauf nécessité de payer les dettes et charges de l’indivision, les actes de disposition relatifs aux biens indivis requièrent le consentement de tous les indivisaires”, meaning that apart from paying the debts and charges of the co-ownership, acts disposing of undivided property require every co-owner’s consent (Cass. 3e civ., July 2, 2026, No. 25-13.188). A year earlier, the same chamber annulled an appeal ruling that had validated a notice to vacate for sale served on a tenant by only some of the co-owners, holding that “sans constater le consentement de chaque indivisaire à la délivrance d’un congé pour vente au locataire, la cour d’appel n’a pas donné de base légale à sa décision”, so a court that validates a sale-related notice without establishing each co-owner’s consent gives its decision no legal basis (Cass. 3e civ., January 23, 2025, No. 23-21.610). If your sibling serves papers, signs promises, or grants rights over the house alone, those acts are vulnerable for exactly this reason, and the same vulnerability applies in reverse to anything you might sign without your sibling.
Two safety valves soften the unanimity rule without breaking it. First, Article 815-3 recognizes a tacit mandate: “Si un indivisaire prend en main la gestion des biens indivis, au su des autres et néanmoins sans opposition de leur part, il est censé avoir reçu un mandat tacite, couvrant les actes d’administration mais non les actes de disposition ni la conclusion ou le renouvellement des baux.” If one heir openly manages the property and the others do not object, that heir is deemed to hold an implied mandate for administrative acts only, never for selling or for signing leases. Silence therefore authorizes management, never the sale. Second, where urgency exists, the president of the judicial court can order protective measures, appoint an administrator or a receiver, and, since the reform of April 2026, “Il peut également autoriser un indivisaire à conclure seul un acte de vente d’un bien indivis.” A judge can now authorize one co-owner to sign the sale of an undivided property alone (Article 815-6 of the Civil Code, as amended by Law No. 2026-248 of April 7, 2026). That judicial authorization is the narrow door through which a sale can pass despite a holdout, and your lawyer in France requests it from the court, with evidence that the common interest requires the sale.
Practical consequence for the American heir: stop trying to sell around your sibling, because buyers and notaires will demand every signature, and start documenting everything instead. Keep the death certificate, the title deed, the property tax bills, the insurance policy, and every message in which your sibling refuses the sale or ignores your proposals. If you advance conservation expenses, pay by bank transfer with a clear reference and keep the invoices. If you hold two-thirds with another heir, use that majority openly for management acts and notify the holdout in writing, because decisions taken without informing the other co-owners cannot be held against them. Readers who want the full picture of what a French succession costs before the division even starts can review the detailed breakdown of what the notaire charges an American heir and how to check the bill.
B. My Sibling Lives in Our French House Without Paying Rent: What Is the Occupation Indemnity?
The second most frequent grievance after the blocked sale is the occupied house. One heir moves into the French property, changes the locks, enjoys the summers in Provence, and pays nothing to the others. French law answers with a precise mechanism: any co-owner may use the undivided property consistently with its purpose and compatibly with the others’ rights, but the co-owner who enjoys it privately owes the co-ownership an indemnity unless the family agreed otherwise. Article 815-9 of the Civil Code states that “L’indivisaire qui use ou jouit privativement de la chose indivise est, sauf convention contraire, redevable d’une indemnité.” The payment is called the indemnité d’occupation, and it is not rent under a lease; it is compensation owed to the co-ownership for private enjoyment of the common house.
Three features of that indemnity decide real cases. First, the money belongs to the co-ownership, not to you personally. On June 15, 2017, the First Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation held that “il résulte de l’article 815-9 du code civil que l’indivisaire qui jouit privativement d’un bien indivis est redevable d’une indemnité”, and added that this indemnity, which compensates the harm caused to the co-ownership by that private enjoyment, “est due à l’indivision et doit entrer pour son montant total dans la masse active partageable”, meaning it is owed to the co-ownership and must enter in its full amount into the divisible pool of assets (Cass. 1re civ., June 15, 2017, No. 16-23.646). In that case the Court approved throwing out a claim brought by one heir for his sole benefit, for lack of standing, because the indemnity feeds the common pot that is divided at the partage. Do not sue your sibling to be paid the indemnity directly into your American account; ask the court or the notaire to credit it to the co-ownership so it increases everyone’s share, including yours.
Second, judges quantify the indemnity as a monthly amount comparable to rental value, adjusted for the occupier’s own share. French courts routinely fix sums per month for the period of private occupation, as illustrated by a 2010 ruling in which the Court of Cassation left standing a monthly indemnity set by the trial judges for the occupation of a formerly common home (Cass. 1re civ., March 31, 2010, No. 08-19.186). From America, you establish the amount with a local rental valuation, utility records showing continuous occupation, and, where the occupant denies living there, dated photographs, neighbor statements, or a report by a commissaire de justice, the sworn officer formerly called huissier de justice who draws up enforceable factual findings.
Third, the indemnity interacts with the rest of the accounting at the partage. The occupant’s debt to the co-ownership is set against that heir’s share, which means the sibling who lived in the house for three years without paying will receive correspondingly less cash when the house is sold and divided. Where the occupant is a surviving spouse rather than a sibling, different protective rules can apply, including rights over the family home that change the analysis entirely, as explained in the guide on what the American surviving spouse receives and how to remain in the home. Identify who occupies before choosing your weapon: sibling occupant means indemnity, sale pressure, and division math; spouse occupant means checking protective housing rights first.
II. How Do I Force the Sale of an Inherited French House From America?
Management rules and occupation indemnities keep the waiting room livable, but they do not open the door. When your sibling will neither agree to a price nor buy you out, French law offers a staircase with three steps: a formal demand to divide, a court action for partage before the court of the place where the succession opened, and, where the house cannot be physically split, a sale by auction whose price is divided. Each step can be taken from America through a lawyer admitted in France, and each step leaves a paper trail that strengthens the next one.
A. Will the French Court Order the Sale at Auction When the House Cannot Be Divided?
Always start with a documented attempt at agreement, because the court will ask what you tried, and because agreement remains cheaper at every stage. The official service-public guidance on dividing succession property explains that where amicable division is impossible, for example where one co-owner objects, the heirs may petition the court of the place where the succession opened, and it warns that the petition must describe the property to be divided, state your intentions for allocating the assets, and show your efforts to divide amicably (service-public.fr, division of succession property). In practice, your lawyer sends the holdout a formal demand by commissaire de justice proposing either a sale at an appraised price, a buyout of your share, or a voluntary division, with a deadline to answer. Silence or refusal after that letter becomes your first exhibit. The same guidance notes that where an heir refuses to take part, the others can require that heir, through a commissaire de justice, to appoint a representative for the division, which prevents a purely passive sibling from freezing the paperwork.
The court action itself rests on Article 840 of the Civil Code, which sends cases to court “lorsque l’un des indivisaires refuse de consentir au partage amiable, s’il s’élève des contestations sur la manière d’y procéder ou de le terminer”, that is, where one co-owner refuses amicable division or where disputes arise over how to conduct or complete it. Jurisdiction is exclusive and simple: “Le tribunal du lieu d’ouverture de la succession est exclusivement compétent pour connaître de l’action en partage”, so the action for division belongs exclusively to the court of the place where the succession opened, generally where the deceased last lived (Article 841 of the Civil Code). An American heir therefore sues in France, in the city of the parent’s last French domicile, represented by a French avocat; there is no way to move the French house into an American probate court. File where the succession opened, and address every filing to that court.
Once seized, the court chooses between dividing the property in kind and selling it. Article 1361 of the Code of Civil Procedure provides that “Le tribunal ordonne le partage, s’il peut avoir lieu, ou la vente par licitation si les conditions prévues à l’article 1378 sont réunies.” A single house shared by siblings who no longer speak cannot be cut in two, so the court orders licitation, the auction sale of the undivided property, and each heir receives money instead of walls. The auction is public, and Article 1378 of the Code of Civil Procedure adds a rule families often miss: “Si tous les indivisaires sont capables et présents ou représentés, ils peuvent décider à l’unanimité que l’adjudication se déroulera entre eux. A défaut, les tiers à l’indivision y sont toujours admis.” Only a unanimous decision of capable co-owners present or represented can confine the bidding to the family; otherwise outside buyers are always admitted, which usually raises the price and protects the American heir who feared a sale at a friendly discount. For complex estates the court appoints a notaire to conduct the division operations and a supervising judge to oversee them, and since the April 2026 reform (Law No. 2026-248 of April 7, 2026) the supervising judge holds reinforced powers over those operations, with a decree still to detail the new judicial division procedure (service-public.fr, judicial division reform). One co-heir may also ask for preferential allocation of certain assets, which the judge decides case by case, for instance where a sibling genuinely farmed the land or ran the family business from the property.
Budget the action honestly before filing. The service-public schedule lists regulated notaire fees for succession divisions as a sliding scale on the gross assets, currently 4.837 percent before tax up to 6,500 euros, 1.995 percent from 6,500 to 17,000 euros, 1.330 percent from 17,000 to 60,000 euros, and 0.998 percent above 60,000 euros, plus disbursements, lawyers’ fees, and court costs (service-public.fr, cost of judicial division). Those fees come out of the estate, not from your pocket alone. After the division, the law still offers two narrow challenges, and their time limits run from the date of the partage itself: you have five years from the division to seek annulment where consent was extracted by violence or deception, where a mistake was made about the shares or the assets, or where an heir was forgotten, and you have two years from the division to claim a supplement where your lot falls short by more than one quarter of what you should have received (service-public.fr, challenging the division). Calendar both dates the day the division deed is signed. And remember that the judicial route never locks permanently: the co-heirs may abandon the court proceedings at any time and return to an amicable division where its conditions are met, which is exactly what Article 842 of the Civil Code guarantees when it provides that “A tout moment, les copartageants peuvent abandonner les voies judiciaires et poursuivre le partage à l’amiable si les conditions prévues pour un partage de cette nature sont réunies.” Filing suit often produces the settlement that letters could not, because the holdout finally faces a real auction date.
B. Who Pays the Partition Tax and How Do I Bring My Share Back to America?
Winning the division or the auction fixes who gets what, but two fiscal layers still stand between the judgment and the money in your American account: the French registration tax on the division, and the declaration of the proceeds on both sides of the Atlantic. Both are manageable once you see how the pieces fit.
Start with the declaratory effect, the rule that gives the partage its tax logic. Article 883 of the Civil Code provides that “Chaque cohéritier est censé avoir succédé seul et immédiatement à tous les effets compris dans son lot, ou à lui échus sur licitation, et n’avoir jamais eu la propriété des autres effets de la succession.” Each heir is deemed to have inherited alone and immediately everything in that heir’s lot, including property acquired at the auction, and never to have owned the rest. The division does not transfer property between heirs; it declares what each heir has owned since the death. That fiction has hard edges the courts police. On November 4, 2020, the First Civil Chamber held that “Il résulte de ce texte que l’efficacité de la cession, par certains indivisaires, de leurs droits indivis dans un des biens dépendant de l’indivision successorale, est subordonnée au résultat du partage.” A sale of undivided rights by some co-owners only takes effect subject to the outcome of the division: if the final lots put the house elsewhere, the buyer loses, which is why no serious buyer touches undivided shares without a completed partage (Cass. 1re civ., November 4, 2020, No. 19-13.267). And on July 13, 2023, the Third Civil Chamber added that “le partage a un effet déclaratif et non constitutif, qui confère au titulaire du lot dont le bien fait partie l’ensemble des actes valablement accomplis sur ce bien depuis son entrée dans l’indivision”, so the division confirms valid acts performed on the property since it entered co-ownership but cannot revive an expired or lapsed commitment, such as an acceptance of a purchase offer that had already become void (Cass. 3e civ., July 13, 2023, No. 22-17.146). Do not sign side promises assuming the division will bless them later; complete the division first, then contract.
Because the division is declaratory rather than translative, Article 748 of the General Tax Code provides that qualifying divisions “ne sont pas considérés comme translatifs de propriété dans la mesure des soultes ou plus-values”, and the tax is computed on the net value of the divided assets without deducting equalization payments. The rate then comes from Article 746 of the same code, which provides that “Les partages de biens meubles et immeubles entre copropriétaires, cohéritiers et coassociés, à quelque titre que ce soit, pourvu qu’il en soit justifié, sont assujettis à un droit d’enregistrement ou à une taxe de publicité foncière de 2,50 %.” For a succession division between siblings, budget 2.5 percent of the net estate value for the droit de partage, collected through the notaire. The reduced 1.10 percent rate that same article mentions applies only to divisions following separation, divorce, or the breakup of a civil solidarity pact, not to successions, so do not let anyone promise you the lower rate on an inheritance file. Where one heir keeps the house and pays the others an equalization payment called a soulte, that payment adjusts the lots without changing the declaratory nature of the operation, and heirs who received lifetime gifts from the deceased should expect those gifts to be accounted for in the final reckoning, a mechanism detailed in the guide on gifts of money for a French apartment, gift tax, and the hotchpot rule.
Finally, move the money home cleanly. The notaire handling the licitation or the division pays the French taxes and the creditors, then distributes the net proceeds to each heir, usually by wire to the account each heir designates. Give the notaire complete and consistent identity documents, plus proof of your foreign address and tax residence, because banks and notaires apply strict anti-money-laundering checks to cross-border transfers and any mismatch freezes the file for weeks. On the American side, the proceeds of a French inheritance and the gain realized on a later sale are reported on your United States return under United States rules, with the France-United States income tax treaty available to relieve double taxation; the treaty text is published by the Internal Revenue Service (France-United States tax treaty, IRS official text), and the French tax administration explains how foreign-source income is taxed and credited on its English-language pages (impots.gouv.fr, taxation of foreign-source income). Keep every French assessment, every notaire statement of account, and every dollar of wire confirmation, because the treaty credit is only as good as its paperwork. Where the deceased left a will that promised you nothing, a separate remedy may exist alongside the division, and the guide on reclaiming a forced share through the action for reduction explains when disinherited American children can still recover.
Conclusion
A sibling who refuses to sell an inherited French house holds a delaying position, not a veto. While the indivision lasts, two-thirds of the heirs can manage the property, any heir can fund conservation, the occupant owes the co-ownership an occupation indemnity that feeds the common pool, and no majority can sell without everyone. When agreement fails, the court of the place where the succession opened orders the partage or the auction sale, outside buyers are admitted unless every capable heir unanimously agrees otherwise, the division declares each heir owner retroactive to the death, the partition tax takes 2.5 percent of the net value, and the notaire wires each heir the net share with a full paper trail for both tax administrations. Start with a formal written proposal, calendar the five-year and two-year challenges from the division date, and push each step in order: demand, court, auction, distribution. The house will be sold, the accounts will be settled, and the ocean between the heirs will no longer matter.