KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Prestation Compensatoire in a French Divorce: How the Judge Sets the Amount, How It Is Paid, and How Expats Can Challenge It

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Prestation Compensatoire in a French Divorce: How the Judge Sets the Amount, How It Is Paid, and How Expats Can Challenge It

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

You are getting divorced in France, and your spouse is asking for a prestation compensatoire — or you believe you are the one who should receive it. The sums at stake are often the largest figure in the entire divorce after the family home: tens of thousands of euros, sometimes far more. Yet most English-speaking spouses discover this creature of French law only when the procedure is already under way, and confuse it with child support, with alimony as understood in London or New York, or with a reward for good behaviour during the marriage. It is none of those things.

A prestation compensatoire (literally a “compensatory payment”) is the sum one ex-spouse may be ordered to pay the other to compensate, as far as possible, the gap in living standards that the divorce itself creates. It is fixed once and for all by the family judge — the juge aux affaires familiales, the dedicated divorce and children judge who sits in each tribunal judiciaire — and it is paid in principle as a lump sum of capital, not as a monthly allowance. This guide explains, for expatriates divorcing in France, how the judge decides whether anything is due and how much, why the lump sum comes first, how payment is secured, and how the award can later be revised, suspended or converted — including when one ex-spouse lives outside France. Our general walk-through of the French divorce tracks, courts and timelines for expats sets the procedural scene; this article deals with the money.

I. Will the French divorce judge order a prestation compensatoire, and how much will it be

A. How the judge measures the gap in living standards that the divorce creates

The starting point is article 270 of the Civil Code, which lays down the principle in these terms: « L’un des époux peut être tenu de verser à l’autre une prestation destinée à compenser, autant qu’il est possible, la disparité que la rupture du mariage crée dans les conditions de vie respectives. Cette prestation a un caractère forfaitaire. Elle prend la forme d’un capital dont le montant est fixé par le juge. » (in English: One spouse may be required to pay the other a payment designed to compensate, as far as possible, the disparity that the breakdown of the marriage creates in their respective living conditions. This payment is fixed as a lump sum. It takes the form of capital, the amount of which is set by the judge.) Three ideas in that paragraph govern everything that follows. First, only the disparity created by the divorce counts — not a comfortable or uncomfortable situation that already existed before. Second, the award is forfaitaire, meaning fixed once and for all rather than adjustable month by month. Third, the natural form of the award is capital, a lump sum, whose amount the judge sets. The divorce also puts an end to the devoir de secours, the duty of financial support spouses owe each other during the marriage, which is why the assessment is made at the moment the marriage ends.

To measure that disparity, article 271 of the Civil Code instructs the judge as follows: « La prestation compensatoire est fixée selon les besoins de l’époux à qui elle est versée et les ressources de l’autre en tenant compte de la situation au moment du divorce et de l’évolution de celle-ci dans un avenir prévisible. » (in English: The compensatory payment is set according to the needs of the spouse to whom it is paid and the resources of the other, taking account of the situation at the time of the divorce and how it is likely to develop in the foreseeable future.) For this purpose the judge must consider, in particular: the length of the marriage; the age and state of health of each spouse; their qualifications and professional situation; the consequences of the career choices one spouse made during the marriage — to raise the children and the time still needed for that, or to advance the other spouse’s career at the expense of their own; the current and foreseeable assets of each spouse, in capital and in income, after the matrimonial property regime is wound up; their existing and foreseeable rights; and their respective pension positions, estimating as far as possible how far the career sacrifices just mentioned may have reduced the future retirement rights of the spouse claiming the payment. The official page on the prestation compensatoire confirms the framework and adds a point expats often miss: only divorcing spouses can claim it. A couple who merely lived together, or partners in a Pacs (the French registered civil partnership), cannot — the equivalent comparison table between pension alimentaire and prestation compensatoire states this expressly.

For an international couple, the career-sacrifice criterion is frequently decisive. The trailing spouse who resigned from a position in London, New York or Dublin to follow the other to Paris, who worked part-time or not at all while the children settled into a French school, or who supported the other’s expatriate career at the cost of their own, is describing exactly what article 271 lists: choices made during the marriage for the children or to favour the other spouse’s career to the detriment of their own, with consequences for qualifications, current income and future pensions. Document that history early — employment contracts, resignation letters, pay slips before and after the move, pension statements in each country — because the judge can only compensate what the file proves.

Procedurally, both sides must give the judge the raw material for this calculation. Article 272 of the Civil Code provides that « les parties fournissent au juge une déclaration certifiant sur l’honneur l’exactitude de leurs ressources, revenus, patrimoine et conditions de vie. » (in English: the parties provide the judge with a declaration certifying on their honour the accuracy of their resources, income, assets and living conditions.) This sworn statement of means covers the divorce itself and any later request for revision. Treat it with the seriousness it deserves: file complete bank, tax, property and pension evidence for France and abroad, and update it if your situation changes during the proceedings, since the judge assesses needs and resources at the date of the divorce and in the foreseeable future.

Two recent rulings of the Cour de cassation, the supreme court for civil matters, show how strictly the courts apply these principles — and both are gifts for the spouse claiming the payment. In a judgment of 10 December 2025 (pourvoi no. H 24-13.557, decision of the First Civil Chamber), a wife married under separation of property had been refused any payment on the ground that the gap in living standards already existed when the marriage began, given each spouse’s income, age and established career, and that she had not sacrificed her own career. The Cour de cassation quashed that reasoning, holding: « Il s’en déduit, d’une part, que la différence de situation professionnelle ou de rémunération patrimoniale existant entre les époux antérieurement au mariage ne peut être un critère de refus d’octroi de la prestation compensatoire puisque celle-ci vise à maintenir la parité qu’assurait l’union matrimoniale, et, d’autre part, que c’est au moment du prononcé du divorce, qui met fin au devoir de secours, que le juge doit se placer pour la fixer. » (in English: It follows, first, that a difference in professional situation or wealth that already existed between the spouses before the marriage cannot be a ground for refusing the payment, since the payment aims to preserve the balance the marriage provided, and, second, that the judge must place himself at the date the divorce is pronounced, which ends the duty of support, to set it.) In plain terms: a wealthy spouse cannot defeat the claim by showing the other was already poorer on the wedding day, and the photograph the judge examines is taken on the day of the divorce, not the wedding day.

Three years earlier, the same chamber had already warned judges against offsetting the claim with temporary advantages enjoyed during the proceedings. In its judgment of 13 April 2022 (pourvoi no. 20-22.807, decision of the First Civil Chamber), a court of appeal had refused the payment because the wife had lived rent-free in the former family home for nearly seven years. The Cour de cassation quashed that decision too: « la cour d’appel, qui a pris en considération l’avantage constitué par la jouissance gratuite du domicile conjugal accordée à l’épouse au titre du devoir de secours pour apprécier l’existence d’une disparité créée par le divorce dans les conditions de vie respectives des époux, a violé les textes susvisés. » (in English: by taking into account, in assessing whether the divorce created a disparity in the spouses’ respective living conditions, the benefit of free use of the family home granted to the wife by way of the duty of support, the court of appeal violated the above provisions.) Free occupation of the home while the divorce is pending flows from the duty of support between spouses; it cannot be counted against the spouse when the judge measures the lasting gap the divorce will leave behind. For the expat spouse still living in the Paris flat while the case runs, that ruling matters directly.

The same article 270 sets the only two escape routes for the debtor spouse: « Toutefois, le juge peut refuser d’accorder une telle prestation si l’équité le commande, soit en considération des critères prévus à l’article 271 , soit lorsque le divorce est prononcé aux torts exclusifs de l’époux qui demande le bénéfice de cette prestation, au regard des circonstances particulières de la rupture. » (in English: The judge may, however, refuse to grant such a payment if fairness so requires, either in light of the criteria in article 271 or where the divorce is pronounced on the exclusive fault of the spouse claiming the payment, given the particular circumstances of the breakdown.) Refusal on fairness grounds is the exception, not the rule, and it must be reasoned against the article 271 criteria set by article 270 of the Civil Code — length of marriage, needs, resources, health, pensions — not decreed from a vague sense that the claimant “manages well enough”. Where the divorce is granted on the exclusive fault of the claimant, for example after serious misconduct established in a fault-based divorce, the judge weighs the circumstances of the breakdown before deciding. Fault alone does not automatically extinguish the right; the statute asks the judge to look at the particular circumstances.

Spouses who agree can also fix the payment themselves rather than let the judge decide. In a divorce by mutual consent without a judge — the divorce par consentement mutuel par acte sous signature privée contresigné par avocats, where each spouse has their own lawyer and the agreement is filed with a notary — the amount and terms appear in the agreement. In a divorce by mutual consent with a judge, and in judicial divorces that settle, the approved agreement (convention homologuée) « a la même force exécutoire qu’une décision de justice. » (in English: has the same enforceable force as a court judgment.), as article 279 of the Civil Code puts it. Whatever the track, have the agreement state the amount, the form, the timetable, the indexation and any agreed revision or termination events with the same precision a judgment would use, because the tax treatment and the later revision rules depend on what the paper says. Our guide to divorce by mutual consent in France without a judge walks through that procedure step by step.

B. Why the lump sum comes first, and when the judge allows instalments or a life annuity

Because the award is forfaitaire — fixed once — the judge’s first reflex is the immediate capital payment: a single transfer that closes the account between the ex-spouses. But the statute offers a whole menu of capital forms. Article 274 of the Civil Code provides that « Le juge décide des modalités selon lesquelles s’exécutera la prestation compensatoire en capital parmi les formes suivantes : 1° Versement d’une somme d’argent, le prononcé du divorce pouvant être subordonné à la constitution des garanties prévues à l’article 277 ; 2° Attribution de biens en propriété ou d’un droit temporaire ou viager d’usage, d’habitation ou d’usufruit, le jugement opérant cession forcée en faveur du créancier. » (in English: The judge decides how the capital payment is to be carried out, choosing among the following forms: 1. payment of a sum of money, with the pronouncement of the divorce capable of being made conditional on setting up the guarantees in article 277; 2. transfer of property in full ownership, or of a temporary or lifelong right of use, occupation or usufruct, the judgment operating as a forced transfer to the creditor.) The judgment itself transfers the asset: no further deed is needed for the transfer to occur, though registration and tax formalities follow. One safeguard matters for international families: « l’accord de l’époux débiteur est exigé pour l’attribution en propriété de biens qu’il a reçus par succession ou donation. » (in English: the agreement of the debtor spouse is required for the transfer in ownership of property received by inheritance or gift.) A Paris flat inherited from a French parent cannot be handed to the ex-spouse in ownership without the heir’s consent — though a temporary right of use over it can still be ordered.

Where the debtor genuinely cannot pay the capital at once in one of those forms, article 275 of the Civil Code organises staggered payment: « le juge fixe les modalités de paiement du capital, dans la limite de huit années, sous forme de versements périodiques indexés selon les règles applicables aux pensions alimentaires. » (in English: the judge sets the terms of payment of the capital, within a limit of eight years, in the form of periodic payments indexed under the rules applicable to maintenance payments.) The eight-year ceiling runs from the divorce, the instalments are indexed like child support (the pension alimentaire paid for the children’s needs, a different animal from the compensatory payment between ex-spouses), and « Le débiteur peut demander la révision de ces modalités de paiement en cas de changement important de sa situation. » (in English: The debtor may ask for these payment terms to be revised if his or her situation changes significantly.) Only by a specially reasoned exceptional decision may the judge authorise payment over more than eight years in total, the debtor may clear the indexed balance early at any time, and once the matrimonial property has been wound up the creditor may go back to the judge to claim the indexed balance. Mixed formulas are expressly allowed: article 275-1 adds that « Les modalités de versement prévues au premier alinéa de l’article 275 ne sont pas exclusives du versement d’une partie du capital dans les formes prévues par l’article 274 . » (in English: The payment terms in the first paragraph of article 275 do not prevent part of the capital being paid in the forms provided in article 274.) Part of the award can therefore arrive as an immediate transfer — a flat, a portfolio share — with the remainder staggered over up to eight years.

The life annuity — the rente viagère, a sum paid periodically until the recipient dies — is the last resort, not an option on equal footing. Article 276 of the Civil Code states: « A titre exceptionnel, le juge peut, par décision spécialement motivée, lorsque l’âge ou l’état de santé du créancier ne lui permet pas de subvenir à ses besoins, fixer la prestation compensatoire sous forme de rente viagère. » (in English: Exceptionally, the judge may, by a specially reasoned decision, where the age or state of health of the creditor does not allow him or her to provide for his or her own needs, set the compensatory payment in the form of a life annuity.) Think of the spouse in their sixties with no pension rights of their own after decades devoted to the household: capital alone would be consumed, while an indexed annuity tracks their needs for life. The annuity is indexed like maintenance, and article 276-3 caps any later revision so that it « ne peut avoir pour effet de porter la rente à un montant supérieur à celui fixé initialement par le juge. » (in English: may not raise the annuity above the amount initially set by the judge.) — the annuity can go down or stop, never up beyond its starting point.

Money form and tax form interact, and France rewards the clean break. According to the tax administration’s guidance on deducting the prestation compensatoire, a payment made in one go within twelve months of the divorce judgment becoming final opens a tax reduction of 25 percent of the sums paid, capped at 7,625 euros on a maximum base of 30,500 euros. The same 25 percent reduction applies where capital or annuity instalments are spread over a maximum of twelve months, and the recipient is not taxed on the receipt. Where the judgment spreads payment over more than twelve months, the sums are instead deductible from the debtor’s income, treated like maintenance, while instalments spread over more than twelve months outside any court-ordered timetable give neither reduction nor deduction.

For the expat debtor taxed in France, scheduling payment within the twelve-month window can therefore be worth several thousand euros; for the recipient, the capital received escapes French income tax. Cross-border tax residents should still check the other country’s treatment of the receipt, since France’s exemption does not bind a foreign tax authority.

II. Paying, securing, revising or ending the payment when expats divorce in France

A. How the capital is paid and secured, and what happens when the debtor dies

A judgment ordering 150,000 euros is worth little if the debtor moves to Dubai or stops paying from London. French law therefore lets the judge bolt guarantees onto the award from day one. Article 277 of the Civil Code provides that « le juge peut imposer à l’époux débiteur de constituer un gage, de donner caution ou de souscrire un contrat garantissant le paiement de la rente ou du capital. » (in English: the judge may require the debtor spouse to provide a pledge, to give a surety, or to take out a contract guaranteeing payment of the annuity or the capital.) In addition, article 274 allows the pronouncement of the divorce itself to be made conditional on setting up those guarantees. Where the debtor spouse is leaving France, where their assets are portable, or where instalments will run for years, asking the juge aux affaires familiales — in Paris, the family chamber of the tribunal judiciaire de Paris on the Île de la Cité, which handles the capital’s divorces — for a pledge over a bank account, a surety, or a charge over the Paris property is not hostility; it is the normal use of articles 274 and 277, and it should be requested before the judgment, not after the first missed payment. Keep every payment traceable by bank transfer with the judgment reference, so that proof of payment — or of default — is immediate.

Death does not make the debt vanish; it moves it onto the estate. Article 280 of the Civil Code states: « A la mort de l’époux débiteur, le paiement de la prestation compensatoire, quelle que soit sa forme, est prélevé sur la succession. » (in English: On the death of the debtor spouse, payment of the compensatory payment, whatever its form, is taken from the estate.) The burden falls on all the heirs, who are not personally liable beyond the estate’s assets and, if the estate is short, on the specific legatees in proportion to their gifts. Where capital was being paid in article 275 instalments, the indexed balance becomes immediately due; where an annuity had been ordered, it is replaced by an immediately payable capital sum calculated under the regulatory conversion scale. The Cour de cassation confirmed the reach of this machinery for old awards in its judgment of 21 June 2023 (pourvoi no. 21-17.077, decision of the First Civil Chamber): « Selon l’article 280 du code civil, à la mort de l’époux débiteur, le paiement de la prestation compensatoire, quelle que soit sa forme, est prélevé sur la succession. Le paiement est supporté par tous les héritiers, qui n’y sont pas tenus personnellement, dans la limite de l’actif successoral. Lorsque la prestation compensatoire a été fixée sous forme de rente, il lui est substitué un capital immédiatement exigible. » (in English: Under article 280 of the Civil Code, on the death of the debtor spouse, payment of the compensatory payment, whatever its form, is taken from the estate. It is borne by all the heirs, who are not personally liable for it, within the limit of the estate’s assets. Where the payment was set as an annuity, it is replaced by an immediately payable capital sum.) The heirs are not without choices: article 280-1 lets them unanimously decide to keep the existing payment terms by binding themselves personally, but « A peine de nullité, l’accord est constaté par un acte notarié. » (in English: On pain of nullity, the agreement must be recorded in a notarial deed.) — an informal family arrangement is worthless. For the expat recipient, the practical lesson is failure-proof the award during the divorce: guarantees under article 277 protect against both disappearance and death, because a secured creditor does not depend on the goodwill of heirs met for the first time at the succession.

One final structural point helps international families read their judgment correctly. Article 281 of the Civil Code provides that « Les transferts et abandons prévus au présent paragraphe sont, quelles que soient leurs modalités de versement, considérés comme participant du régime matrimonial. Ils ne sont pas assimilés à des donations. » (in English: The transfers and surrenders in this section, whatever their payment terms, are deemed part of the matrimonial property regime. They are not treated as gifts.) The payment is the settlement of the marriage’s economics, not a present — which is why it escapes the gift-tax logic and why, in an international succession, it ranks with the matrimonial settlement rather than with lifetime generosity.

B. How to seek revision, suspension or substitution, and what changes when an ex-spouse lives abroad

Because the lump-sum capital is forfaitaire, a change of fortune after the divorce does not reopen it: the debtor who later earns far more cannot be asked for a supplement, and the debtor whose fortunes collapse cannot ask the judge to trim a capital sum already fixed — only the terms of staggered capital payments may be revisited on a significant change, as article 275 allows. Revision, suspension and cancellation belong to the annuity. As article 276-3 of the Civil Code provides: « La prestation compensatoire fixée sous forme de rente peut être révisée, suspendue ou supprimée en cas de changement important dans les ressources ou les besoins de l’une ou l’autre des parties. » (in English: A compensatory payment set as an annuity may be revised, suspended or cancelled where the resources or needs of either party change significantly.) Either side can apply: the debtor whose income has collapsed, or the creditor whose needs have grown — subject always to the ceiling that revision can never lift the annuity above its initial amount. And the annuity debtor is never locked in for life: article 276-4 states that « Le débiteur d’une prestation compensatoire sous forme de rente peut, à tout moment, saisir le juge d’une demande de substitution d’un capital à tout ou partie de la rente. » (in English: The debtor of an annuity compensatory payment may at any time apply to the judge to substitute capital for all or part of the annuity.) The creditor can make the same request by showing that the debtor’s changed situation allows it, particularly once the matrimonial property is wound up, and the judge who refuses the swap must give specially reasoned grounds.

The Cour de cassation’s 21 June 2023 judgment, cited above, is also the leading reminder that even very old annuities can be reopened. The Court held in its judgment of 21 June 2023: « Il résulte de la combinaison de l’article 33, VI, de la loi n° 2004-439 du 26 mai 2004 et de l’article 276-3 du code civil, issu de cette loi, que la révision des rentes viagères attribuées à titre de prestation compensatoire avant l’entrée en vigueur de la loi n° 2000-596 du 30 juin 2000, qu’elles aient été fixées par le juge ou par convention des époux, peut être demandée par le débiteur ou ses héritiers, soit lorsque leur maintien procure au créancier un avantage manifestement excessif au regard des critères définis à l’article 276 du code civil, soit en cas de changement important dans les ressources ou les besoins de l’une ou l’autre des parties. » (in English: It follows from article 33, VI, of the Act of 26 May 2004 combined with article 276-3 of the Civil Code that revision of life annuities granted as a compensatory payment before the Act of 30 June 2000 — whether set by the judge or by the spouses’ agreement — may be sought by the debtor or the heirs, either where keeping the annuity gives the creditor a manifestly excessive advantage measured against the article 276 criteria, or where the resources or needs of either party have changed significantly.) An annuity granted in the 1990s can therefore still be revised or ended today. Applications go to the juge aux affaires familiales, with a fresh sworn declaration of means under article 272 and evidence of the change — new tax notices, proof of retirement, medical certificates, or proof of the creditor’s remarriage or improved circumstances, which the judge weighs without any automatic rule.

Spouses who divorced by mutual consent live under a stricter lock. Article 279 provides that their approved agreement « ne peut être modifiée que par une nouvelle convention entre des époux, également soumise à homologation. » (in English: may only be modified by a new agreement between the spouses, likewise submitted for approval.) Revision by the judge is available only if the spouses had the foresight to write it in, as article 279 allows: « Les époux ont néanmoins la faculté de prévoir dans leur convention que chacun d’eux pourra, en cas de changement important dans les ressources ou les besoins de l’une ou l’autre des parties, demander au juge de réviser la prestation compensatoire. » (in English: The spouses may nevertheless provide in their agreement that either of them may, where the resources or needs of either party change significantly, ask the judge to revise the compensatory payment.) The administration confirms the same freedom: the agreement may set the conditions for revision or cancellation, and the parties may provide that payments will stop when a specified event occurs, for example remarriage, according to the official guidance on the prestation compensatoire Anyone signing a mutual-consent agreement in France should therefore insist on a revision clause tied to a significant change in resources or needs, plus agreed termination events — without that sentence, the capital figure is frozen even if both lives are transformed.

When one ex-spouse lives abroad, three practical consequences follow. First, secure payment before the border matters more than chasing it afterwards: guarantees under article 277, a charge over the French property, or payment of the capital before the divorce becomes final all travel better than an unsecured promise. Second, check the enforcement route for your countries while the case is still open. Within the European Union, Council Regulation (EC) No 4/2009 of 18 December 2008 on jurisdiction, applicable law, recognition and enforcement of decisions and cooperation in matters relating to maintenance obligations (Regulation 4/2009 (CELEX:32009R0004 on EUR-Lex)) organises the cross-border circulation of maintenance decisions, and beyond the Union the Hague Convention of 23 November 2007 on the International Recovery of Child Support and Other Forms of Family Maintenance (2007 Hague Maintenance Convention) connects France with a wide network of states, including the United States. Whether a French capital award or its staggered instalments can ride those instruments in your specific configuration — debtor in London, creditor in Paris; both ex-spouses in Singapore with a Paris flat as security — depends on fact, form and forum, so have the enforcement path mapped before the judgment is final rather than after the first missed transfer. Third, keep the French court reachable: revision applications, substitution requests and claims for the indexed balance all go back to the juge aux affaires familiales that divorced you, or that approved your agreement, and they all require the article 272 sworn declaration with worldwide means. An address for service in France, a lawyer who holds the file, and indexed, transfer-traced payments turn a cross-border award from a diplomatic incident into an administrative routine.

Conclusion

The prestation compensatoire rewards preparation, not grievance. The judge compensates the measurable gap the divorce creates in living standards — needs against resources at the date of the divorce and in the foreseeable future — using the article 271 checklist of marriage length, age, health, qualifications, career sacrifices, assets, rights and pensions. Pre-marriage inequality is no defence, temporary use of the home during the case is no offset, and only a reasoned fairness analysis or the claimant’s exclusive fault can defeat the claim. Capital paid at once is the norm, in cash, in property, or in rights of use; genuine inability to pay opens staggered instalments of up to eight years, and only age or health that prevents self-support justifies the exceptional life annuity. Guarantees should be built into the judgment, death transfers the debt to the estate rather than cancelling it, and only the annuity — never the fixed capital — can later be revised, suspended, cancelled or swapped for capital. For expats, the winning file is the documented one: the trailing spouse’s sacrificed career, the worldwide sworn declaration, the revision clause in the mutual-consent agreement, and the secured, indexed, traceable payment that survives a move abroad.

📄 Official circular