KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Renouncing US Citizenship From France: The Paris Oath, the Certificate of Loss, and the American Exit Tax

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Renouncing US Citizenship From France: The Paris Oath, the Certificate of Loss, and the American Exit Tax

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

You live in France, you file a tax return on two continents every year, and every French bank hands you extra American paperwork before it will even open an account for you. At some point many long-term residents ask the same blunt question: would giving up the American passport make life simpler, and what would it really cost? The answer has two halves that have nothing to do with each other. On the American side, only a formal oath before a consular officer, approved in Washington with a Certificate of Loss of Nationality, ends citizenship, and the tax code may send a final bill on the way out. On the French side, almost nothing changes by itself: French nationality is never lost automatically, French tax residence does not depend on your passport, and your right to stay in France follows completely different rules. This guide walks through both halves in order, so you can decide with full knowledge of the procedure, the exit tax, and the French consequences.

I. How an American living in France renounces: the oath, the file, and the certificate

A. Where do I go and what happens at the appointment: Paris, the oath, and the Certificate of Loss of Nationality?

American law lists several acts that can cost a citizen their nationality, but for someone living in France only one route matters in practice: the formal oath of renunciation made abroad. The statute provides that a United States national, whether by birth or naturalization, loses nationality by voluntarily performing certain listed acts with the intention of relinquishing it, and the act that matters here is making a formal renunciation before an American diplomatic or consular officer in a foreign state, in the form prescribed by the Secretary of State, as recalled on the State Department page dedicated to the oath of renunciation under INA 349(a)(5). Two elements in that sentence do all the work: the oath must be made in person before an American consular officer outside the United States, and it must be made with the intention of giving up nationality. Mailing a letter, letting a passport expire, or simply telling a bank you are done does not renounce anything.

In France the competent post is the Consular Section, in Paris for most residents, with a parallel track in Marseille, and the process starts on paper long before you raise your right hand. The Paris post publishes, on its page for relinquishing United States citizenship, a sequence in four visible steps: print and complete an initial information session letter, complete and submit an online questionnaire to request a loss-of-nationality appointment, send back by email the scanned documents the post asks for, and then, if the file is complete, receive an appointment slot. Expect the exchange to take weeks or months before a date is offered, and use that waiting time to put your American tax filings in order, as explained in Part II, because the consular interview is a poor moment to discover five years of missing returns.

The core form is the DS-4079 questionnaire on loss of nationality. For an oath renunciation the Paris instructions ask for Part I-A, the background questionnaire and attestations, and Part I-B, the oath section itself, and they add one instruction in capital letters that applicants get wrong surprisingly often: complete the requested sections but do not sign anything, because the signature is given in front of the consular officer. Bring original civil-status documents and proof of any name change, such as a marriage certificate or court order, plus a second passport or a credible statement of the foreign nationality you hold or expect to obtain, since statelessness, discussed below, is the first substantive point the officer will probe. A consular fee applies to the service; the post confirms the current amount and the accepted payment method when it handles your file, so check the instructions attached to your appointment rather than relying on figures quoted on forums.

At the appointment the officer verifies identity, reviews the file, discusses consequences, and administers the oath. Nationality is described by the State Department as a status personal to the individual, and the same page states plainly that it cannot be renounced by a parent or a legal guardian under any set of circumstances, so a parent cannot give up a child’s citizenship alongside their own, and each adult applicant must appear and decide for themselves. Once the oath is taken the file travels to Washington, and this is the point most people misunderstand: swearing the oath is not yet the legal end of citizenship. The State Department recalls that, pursuant to Section 358 of the Immigration and Nationality Act, the renunciation of United States nationality does not result in expatriation until the Department approves a Certificate of Loss of Nationality of the United States, known as the CLN, as explained on the State Department renunciation page. Keep your American passport safe until the CLN arrives, ask the post what travel document to use in the meantime, and keep copies of everything, because the CLN becomes the single most important paper of your post-American life: banks, tax authorities, pension funds, and border officers will all want to see it.

B. Renunciation or relinquishment, second nationality, and life after: what is really irrevocable?

Renunciation by oath is the deliberate, forward-looking route, but American law also recognizes relinquishment through an earlier act performed with the intention to give up citizenship, such as naturalizing in another country with that intent or taking a foreign oath of allegiance with that intent. Someone who became French years ago and clearly intended at the time to abandon American nationality may be able to document that past event and obtain a CLN recording the earlier loss date instead of swearing a new oath. The distinction matters mostly for the date written on the certificate, which in turn fixes the tax expatriation date, so anyone who naturalized French long ago and always behaved as exclusively French should raise the history at the first contact with the post rather than defaulting to a fresh oath. In both cases the legal standard is identical, a voluntary act plus the intention to relinquish, and the certificate is what makes the loss official.

The defining feature of the CLN is that it cannot be undone on second thoughts. The State Department warns that if the Department approves a request for a Certificate of Loss of Nationality under INA 349(a)(5), the determination is irrevocable, except as provided in Section 351(b) of the INA, and cannot be cancelled or set aside absent a successful administrative or judicial appeal. Put plainly, once the certificate is issued the oath cannot be taken back and nationality is not suspended but ended. A future change of heart, a sick parent in Ohio, or a job offer in New York does not reopen the file; the only path back would be immigrating and naturalizing like any other foreign national, with no credit for the decades previously spent as a citizen. Treat the months between the first questionnaire and the oath as a reflection period, because after approval there is no administrative regret button.

The second warning, just as serious, concerns statelessness. The State Department cautions that persons contemplating renunciation should be aware that they will experience great hardship unless they already possess a foreign nationality or are assured of acquiring another nationality shortly after completing their renunciation, adding that without a second nationality they would become stateless, without the protection of any government and probably without a passport from any country. For an American in France this means the safe sequence is French nationality first, American renunciation second. Dual French-American citizens renounce from a position of safety; sole American citizens with only a French residence permit renounce into a residence status that depends entirely on that permit, with no consulate obliged to take them back. Never swear the oath while a French naturalization is merely hoped for; wait until the French decree or declaration is final and the French passport or national identity card is in hand.

Daily life after the CLN looks ordinary until you cross a border or sign a form. Travel to the United States now requires a visa like any other foreign visitor, and a past renunciation can complicate the application, since former citizens found ineligible for a visa can be barred, as the State Department notes on the same page. Voting in American federal elections ends with citizenship, service in the American military and jury duty end with it, and American consular protection ends with it: if you are arrested abroad or caught in a crisis, the embassy that once would have visited you now treats you as a French national. Just as important is what renunciation does not erase. The State Department states that renouncing has no effect on tax or military service obligations already accrued, does not allow escape from prosecution for crimes committed as a citizen, and does not erase financial obligations such as child support. Old debts, old charges, and old tax years follow you across the CLN date, which is why the tax cleanup described below must be taken as seriously as the oath itself.

II. What renunciation costs in American tax and what it changes in French law

A. Will I owe the American exit tax: covered expatriate tests, Form 8854, and the mark-to-market bill?

The most expensive sentence in this entire area sits on the IRS expatriation tax page: individuals who renounced citizenship or ended long-term resident status for tax purposes after June 3, 2004 are required to certify to the IRS that they have satisfied all federal tax requirements for the 5 years prior to expatriation, and failure on that single certification makes the person subject to the expatriation tax provisions even if none of the money thresholds are met, according to the IRS expatriation tax guidance. Read that twice. You can own almost nothing and still become a covered expatriate, the category of former citizen hit by the exit tax, purely because a few years of returns or information forms are missing or wrong. The practical consequence is a strict order of operations: fix the five prior tax years first, swear the oath second. The five-year cleanup means filed and correct federal income tax returns, paid balances or arranged payment plans, and filed information returns such as the FBAR and Form 8938 for every year the thresholds required them, because certification on Form 8854 covers all federal tax obligations, not just the income tax return. The IRS announced in September 2019 simplified relief procedures for certain former citizens of modest means who wish to come into compliance and avoid covered-expatriate treatment, described on the same IRS page, so anyone behind on filings should check those procedures with a qualified preparer before concluding the situation is hopeless.

Assuming compliance is in order, three alternative tests decide covered status, and meeting any one of them is enough. The 2025 Instructions for Form 8854 state them plainly: your net worth was 2 million dollars or more on the date of expatriation; your average annual net income tax liability for the five tax years before expatriation exceeds the indexed figure, which the 2025 instructions set at 206,000 dollars; or you fail the five-year certification described above. The instructions add that the net-worth test looks at the expatriation date itself, while warning that large asset movements during the preceding five years must be explained on an attached statement, so last-minute gifts to slide under the threshold are reported, not hidden. Narrow exceptions exist for certain dual citizens from birth and certain minors who expatriate young, and the instructions devote a full section to them; check the current criteria line by line rather than assuming you qualify, because the age, residence, and tax-history conditions are cumulative.

Covered expatriates face the mark-to-market regime of section 877A of the Internal Revenue Code: almost everything owned the day before expatriation is treated as sold at fair market value, and the net gain goes onto the final tax computation. The 2025 instructions quantify the cushion: for 2025, if you are a covered expatriate, the net gain that you must otherwise include in your income is reduced by 890,000 dollars. Gains above that exclusion are taxed at the rates that would have applied to real sales, losses are allowed only as the Code otherwise permits, and wash-sale games are expressly disregarded. Two asset families follow special tracks instead of the deemed sale. Deferred compensation, such as American pensions and stock-based pay, and interests in specified tax-deferred accounts, such as traditional retirement accounts, are handled through withholding or continued taxation mechanics set out in the instructions rather than through the mark-to-market computation, which means cashing out a 401(k) the month before the oath does not necessarily dodge the charge and can even accelerate it. Map every American account, pension, option grant, and trust interest before choosing the expatriation date, because the composition of the portfolio matters more than its headline total.

The paperwork that proves all of this is Form 8854, the Initial and Annual Expatriation Information Statement, and it is not optional. The IRS states that anyone who has expatriated must file Form 8854 with its instructions, that the form also satisfies the annual reporting duties under section 6039G where applicable, and that a 10,000 dollar penalty may be imposed for failure to file when required, as the IRS page for Form 8854 confirms. File the initial statement with the timely final return for the year of expatriation, as the Instructions for Form 8854 direct, keep proof of filing forever alongside the CLN, and calendar any annual statements the instructions require in later years for deferred items. One more charge survives expatriation and surprises families: if a covered expatriate later gives gifts or leaves bequests to American citizens or residents, the recipients may owe a special transfer tax under section 2801, and the giver is presumed covered unless tax-return disclosure is authorized to the recipient, as the 2025 instructions explain. American children who stayed American and expect an inheritance from a parent who renounced should understand this tax before the family reorganizes its estate plan.

The final American tax year itself is a hybrid. Income earned before the expatriation date is generally reported as a citizen or resident, income after that date as a nonresident alien to the extent American-source rules still reach it, and the French house, French salary, and French accounts mostly fall out of the American base going forward, subject to the sourcing and treaty rules that apply to any nonresident. File the FBAR and Form 8938 for the final year if the thresholds are met, close the years cleanly, and only then enjoy the genuine simplification renunciation brings: one tax system instead of two, no more worldwide American reporting on French savings products, and no more American tax on French-source income that the treaty had merely relieved rather than exempted.

B. Does France care that I am no longer American: nationality, tax residence, residence papers, and bank accounts?

Start with the reassurance that matters most to dual citizens: giving up American citizenship does not touch French nationality in any way. French law never strips nationality automatically when a citizen voluntarily acquires or loses a foreign one. The Civil Code states that “Toute personne majeure de nationalité française, résidant habituellement à l’étranger, qui acquiert volontairement une nationalité étrangère ne perd la nationalité française que si elle le déclare expressément, dans les conditions prévues aux articles 26 et suivants du présent titre.”, under article 23 of the Civil Code. The logic runs identically in reverse: renouncing the American side performs no French legal act at all, so there is nothing to declare, nothing to register, and no French authority to notify about the oath itself. French loss of nationality always requires its own dedicated procedure, either a voluntary declaration or a government decree. The decree route on request is set out in article 23-4 of the Civil Code, which provides that “Perd la nationalité française le Français, même mineur, qui, ayant une nationalité étrangère, est autorisé, sur sa demande, par le Gouvernement français, à perdre la qualité de Français. Cette autorisation est accordée par décret.” A second decree route exists for French citizens who effectively behave as nationals of another country, since article 23-7 of the Civil Code states that “Le Français qui se comporte en fait comme le national d’un pays étranger peut, s’il a la nationalité de ce pays, être déclaré, par décret après avis conforme du Conseil d’Etat, avoir perdu la qualité de Français.” None of these texts is triggered by swearing an American oath in Paris; they would only matter if you later decided you no longer wanted French nationality either.

The mirror situation is worth knowing because many readers naturalized French before reading this guide. A French citizen who voluntarily acquires an American or any other foreign nationality and wishes to shed French nationality must act within a strict window: the declaration of loss may be filed starting from the application for the foreign nationality and no later than within the year following the acquisition date, as the service-public.fr page on voluntary loss of French nationality explains. Miss that one-year frame and the declaration route closes for that acquisition, leaving only the decree route. Declarations of nationality are otherwise received by the registrar of the court or by the consul, in forms set by decree, with a receipt issued once the supporting documents are complete, under article 26 of the Civil Code.

Families with old French roots should also know about the fifty-year rule, because renunciation is sometimes the moment people dig out grandparents papers. The Civil Code allows a court to record the loss of French nationality where a French person by filiation has neither possession of French status, meaning the lived and documented condition of being treated as French, nor habitual residence in France, and where the ancestors who transmitted nationality have themselves had neither French possession of status nor residence in France for half a century, as article 23-6 of the Civil Code states in full: “La perte de la nationalité française peut être constatée par jugement lorsque l’intéressé, français d’origine par filiation, n’en a point la possession d’état et n’a jamais eu sa résidence habituelle en France, si les ascendants, dont il tenait la nationalité française, n’ont eux-mêmes ni possession d’état de Français, ni résidence en France depuis un demi-siècle.” The matching evidence rule in article 30-3 of the Civil Code bars proof of French nationality by filiation where the individual and the transmitting parent both lacked possession of French status while the line stayed abroad for over fifty years. Recent case law softens the trap for families who went to court in time: on March 25, 2026 the First Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, appeal number 24-17.442, published in the Bulletin, quashed an appeal ruling and held that disuse cannot be opposed to a person whose parent had French nationality recognized by a court decision rendered before the fifty-year period expired, in a judgment available on the Court of Cassation website. The lesson for dual nationals is practical rather than theoretical: keep French identity documents, voter registration, consular registration, and certificates of French nationality current, because documented possession of French status is the shield that defeats the fifty-year rule.

French income tax is equally indifferent to the passport change. Tax residence turns on home, professional activity, and center of economic interests, and the statute lists the tests without a single mention of citizenship: “1. Sont considérées comme ayant leur domicile fiscal en France au sens de l’article 4 A : a. Les personnes qui ont en France leur foyer ou le lieu de leur séjour principal ;”, under article 4 B of the General Tax Code. Someone living year-round in Lyon stays fully French-tax-resident the day after the CLN exactly as the day before, continues filing the same French returns, and keeps the same French social charges and property taxes. What changes is the American overlay: no more worldwide American taxation, no more treaty tie-breaker analysis for the French home, and a cleaner qualification for treaty benefits as a French resident who is no longer an American citizen. Anyone holding French real estate through an American revocable living trust or owning American retirement accounts should revisit those structures after expatriation, since the treaty articles that once protected them assumed an American taxpayer who no longer exists.

Residence rights deserve a cold-eyed paragraph, because this is where a badly sequenced renunciation hurts. If you are French, nothing changes: citizens cannot be expelled from their own country and need no permit. If you are solely American with a French residence permit, renouncing American citizenship does not cancel the permit, but it removes the safety net underneath it, since losing the permit later would leave you with no country of return and no consulate obliged to receive you. Secure a long-term status before the oath, ideally the multi-year or permanent card your years in France allow, and remember that first permits in France generally require a long-stay visa, because “Sous réserve des engagements internationaux de la France et des exceptions prévues aux articles L. 412-2 et L. 412-3, la première délivrance d’une carte de séjour temporaire ou d’une carte de séjour pluriannuelle est subordonnée à la production par l’étranger du visa de long séjour mentionné aux 1° ou 2° de l’article L. 411-1.”, under article L. 412-1 of the Code on Entry and Residence of Foreigners. Long absences can also silently kill permanent cards: a resident card expires after more than three consecutive years outside France, as article L. 411-5 of the same Code provides. Anyone planning to leave France after renouncing should therefore check the permit clock before booking a one-way flight.

Banking usually improves, but the French paperwork does not vanish. American citizens in France are expensive customers for banks because of FATCA reporting, and some institutions limit their product range for United States persons; after the CLN, hand the bank a copy of the certificate, update the self-certification from American to French tax residence, and ask in writing which products reopen. French reporting duties, however, follow residence rather than citizenship: individuals domiciled in France must declare foreign accounts alongside their yearly income return, since “Les personnes physiques, les associations, les sociétés n’ayant pas la forme commerciale, domiciliées ou établies en France, sont tenues de déclarer, en même temps que leur déclaration de revenus ou de résultats, les références des comptes ouverts, détenus, utilisés ou clos à l’étranger.”, under article 1649 A of the General Tax Code. Keep filing the foreign-account statement for any American accounts retained after expatriation, and keep the final-year American information returns consistent with the French ones, because the two files tell the same life story to two administrations that increasingly compare notes.

Conclusion

Renouncing American citizenship from France is a sequenced operation, not a single appointment. Confirm a second nationality first, clean five years of American tax filings, build the Paris consular file with patience, swear the oath with full understanding that the certificate is irrevocable, file Form 8854 with the final return, and let French law continue exactly as before around nationality, tax residence, and daily life. Taken in that order, the decision delivers what most readers seek: one passport, one tax system, and a settled French life no longer administered from across the Atlantic.

📄 Official circular