On 17 October 2026, France lived one of its most violent protest days in years. According to The Journal, half a million people took to the streets nationwide against the cost of living, and during the clashes one protester’s hand was blown off by a police crowd-control grenade. The BBC reported violent clashes, looting and buildings set ablaze, with more than 1,000 people arrested. Earlier in the day, the Interior Ministry had put the figure at 400 arrests in Paris, Marseille, Rennes, Toulouse and Angers, and President Emmanuel Macron wrote on X that those who carried out vandalism, attacked offices and businesses or looted would be prosecuted and punished, as reported by RTE.
For an international observer, the pictures raise a blunt question: when French police throw a grenade or fire a rubber-bullet launcher into a crowd and a bystander or a protester loses a hand or an eye, what does French law actually say? Who investigates the officer, who decides whether the shot was lawful, and who pays for a ruined life? This article answers those three questions the way a Paris court would examine them. It starts from the rules that authorise and limit police weapons in street protests, continues with what criminal judges verify after a shot maims someone, and ends with the two practical tracks open to an injured person: the criminal complaint and the claim for State compensation. Every rule below is taken from a statute or a judgment read for this article, with its official source linked beside it.
I. Can French police throw grenades and fire LBD launchers at protesters? The rules on force in street protests
A. Disperse first, shoot only in absolute necessity: summons, authorised weapons and strict proportionality
French crowd control starts with a principle that surprises many foreigners: a gathering on the street cannot simply be charged. Under Article L. 211-9 of the Code de la sécurité intérieure, a crowd that may disturb public order may be dispersed by force only after two orders to disperse have gone unanswered. The same article adds the only exception: officers called to disperse a crowd may use force directly, without prior orders, where violence is used against them or where they cannot otherwise hold the ground they occupy.
The two orders are not informal shouts. Article R. 211-11 of the same Code scripts them word for word over a loudspeaker: first “Première sommation : nous allons faire usage de la force. Quittez immédiatement les lieux”, then “Dernière sommation : nous allons faire usage de la force. Quittez immédiatement les lieux”, each preceded by an announcement starting “Attention ! Attention ! Vous participez à un attroupement. Obéissance à la loi. Vous devez vous disperser et quitter les lieux”. Where a loudspeaker is impossible or plainly useless, each announcement may be replaced or completed by firing a red flare, and where crowd-control firearms must be used, the last order must be repeated.
Once the orders have failed, force remains fenced in by two cumulative conditions. Article R. 211-13 provides that force may be used only where circumstances make it absolutely necessary for keeping order, that the force deployed must be proportionate to the disturbance to be ended, and that its use must stop as soon as the disturbance has ceased. For firearms in particular, Article L. 435-1 allows national police officers and gendarmes to use their weapons only “en cas d’absolue nécessité et de manière strictement proportionnée”, notably where life or physical integrity is attacked or threatened. The ethics code states the same idea in general terms: Article R. 434-18 says an officer uses force only where necessary and proportionately, and uses weapons only in absolute necessity.
The Conseil d’Etat has tested this framework against the most controversial crowd-control weapon of the last decade, the GLI-F4 instant tear-gas grenade. In its judgment of 24 July 2019, no. 429741, published at CETATEXT000038815880, the Court describes the grenade as a non-lethal weapon with an explosive character, because of its tolite content, with a triple tear-gas, deafening and blast effect. It holds that GLI-F4 grenades may be used only where necessary to disperse a crowd, to answer violence committed against officers, or where officers cannot otherwise defend the ground they hold, and that in every case officers may use them only in absolute necessity and in a strictly proportionate manner. The decisive sentence for victims reads: breach of these conditions is capable of engaging the officers’ liability and of grounding criminal prosecution where appropriate. The Court adds that the State must not only refrain from harming the rights protected by Articles 2 and 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights, but must also take the precautions apt to avoid the risk that force and weapons harm them. The request to ban the grenade was rejected, so the weapon stayed lawful, but every irregular throw became a documented fault capable of producing liability and prosecution.
The same judgment maps which weapons may be used at all. Outside the direct-force cases, the firearms available for keeping order are blast-effect grenades and their launchers, authorised by decree, and self-defence and necessity remain reserved alongside. The GLI-F4 is registered as a category A2 firearm usable by the forces of order for keeping order under those provisions. For the foreign reader, the consequence is practical: an injury caused by a weapon that was never authorised for the situation, or used outside the summons and necessity sequence, starts the liability analysis with a documented regulatory breach rather than a debate about split-second judgment.
B. What criminal judges verify after a shot blinds or maims: necessity, distance, orders and confusion
When a projectile fired by the police blinds or maims someone at a demonstration, the criminal file is usually opened for voluntary violence resulting in mutilation or permanent infirmity, an offence punished by Article 222-9 of the Code pénal with ten years’ imprisonment and a 150,000 euro fine, rising to fifteen years’ criminal imprisonment where aggravating circumstances apply under Article 222-10. The officer then relies on the two classic defences of the Code pénal: Article 122-4, which removes criminal responsibility from whoever performs an act prescribed or authorised by statute or regulation, or ordered by legitimate authority unless the act is manifestly illegal, and Article 122-5, which removes it from whoever, facing an unjustified attack on himself or another, acts at the same time out of the necessity of self-defence, unless the means used are disproportionate to the gravity of the attack.
The Cour de cassation showed on 5 February 2025, in judgment no. 23-81.356 (ECLI:FR:CCASS:2025:CR00134), how concretely these defences are tested. The facts, as stated by the Court, were that on 28 April 2016, on the margins of a demonstration, a man was struck by a projectile that cost him the sight of his left eye, that the flagrance investigation established the projectile came from a rubber-bullet launcher, and that a judicial investigation was opened against persons unknown for voluntary violence resulting in mutilation or permanent infirmity by a person holding public authority. The investigating judge closed the case with a non-lieu, and the parties civiles appealed.
The chambre de l’instruction confirmed the non-lieu, and the Cour de cassation rejected the victims’ appeal, for reasons that read like a checklist every future file will be measured against. The shot had come after the orders to disperse had been given and while demonstrators were using prohibited devices. A major had earlier ordered launchers not to be fired toward the riverbank where the victim stood, but the situation had then turned more violent: several rockets had been fired from that bank, one setting fire to an awning just above the officers, and an incendiary rocket fired from a mortar is capable of gravely, even irreversibly, harming whoever it hits. From this the judges deduced that when he acted, the officer was in absolute necessity of stopping the rocket fire. They added that a rubber-bullet launcher is not a lethal weapon, so using it against a man firing incendiary rockets was a proportionate use of force. They verified the technical envelope: the weapon may be used up to 40 metres, and here the shot was fired at 36.35 metres, so the conditions of use appeared respected. Finally, they noted the victim stood near the rocket firer and wore a mask against tear gas, which was capable of causing confusion. Conclusion: there were not sufficient charges that the officer had acted outside the legal framework that lends legitimacy to voluntary violence by a holder of public authority, and the absolutely necessary and proportionate character of the launcher use was established, so that the conditions of Article 122-4 were met.
Three lessons follow for anyone injured on 17 October 2026 or in a future demonstration. First, the summons record is decisive: force after two unanswered orders starts lawful, force without them starts suspect. Second, proportionality is measured against the precise threat at the precise minute, including what the officer could see, such as masks and proximity to violent individuals. Third, a dismissal is not the end of the story for the victim: it can be attacked, and the administrative compensation track can succeed even where the criminal track stalls, as the second part shows.
II. Injured at a protest in France: the criminal complaint track and the State compensation track
A. The criminal track: filing a plainte, the IGPN investigation and becoming partie civile
The first reflex after hospital care is evidence, because a protest case is won or lost on proof within days. The medical certificate describing the wounds and the days of total incapacity for work, photographs of the scene and the injuries, the clothes worn, videos from phones and nearby cameras, names of witnesses, and any recording of the summons orders form the file. Keep everything, including the exact time and place of the shot, since the lawfulness of force is judged minute by minute.
The complaint itself is filed with the public prosecutor or a police or gendarmerie service, and the inspection bodies for the police and the gendarmerie are routinely seized in parallel. Where the prosecutor files the complaint away without prosecution, French procedure offers a second door that protest cases regularly use: the complaint with constitution de partie civile before the investigating judge. Article 85 of the Code de procédure pénale opens this door to anyone claiming to be harmed by a felony or misdemeanour, but it is admissible only where the complainant shows either that the prosecutor has told him no prosecution will be brought, or that three months have passed since the complaint was lodged with the prosecutor. Filing early therefore matters twice: it triggers the investigation, and it starts the three-month clock toward the investigating judge.
An instructive warning comes from Toulouse. On 9 May 2018, during the aftermath of a student occupation evacuation, an officer carrying a disencirclement hand grenade in his trouser pocket arrested a young man, both fell to the ground, and the grenade exploded, wounding the arrested man, who suffered a haemopneumothorax and a fractured rib with fifteen days of incapacity. His complaint was closed without prosecution on 22 March 2019 for absence of offence. When he later sued the State for the malfunctioning of justice, the cour d’appel de Toulouse, in its judgment of 22 January 2025, RG 22/04518, noted that he had neither asked the prosecutor general to re-examine the dismissal nor filed a complaint with constitution de partie civile before the senior investigating judge, and that without exercising these legal avenues he could not establish a denial of justice. The practical moral is plain: a filed-away complaint must be followed by a request for re-examination and then by a partie civile complaint, or later arguments about denied access to a judge will fail.
A lawyer admitted in France can file each of these steps for the victim, including from abroad under a signed mandate. Once an investigating judge is seized, the case follows the ordinary path: expert medical and ballistic reports, hearing of the officers, possible placement under assisted-witness or examined-witness status, and at the end either committal for trial or a non-lieu that can be appealed to the chambre de l’instruction and then to the Cour de cassation, exactly as in the 2025 rubber-bullet case. Expectations must stay realistic: the officer benefits from the Article 122-4 and 122-5 defences, and the victim must be ready to show, point by point, which condition of lawful force was breached.
B. The money track: making the State pay before the administrative or the judicial judge
Compensation follows a different logic from punishment, and choosing the right judge is the step foreigners most often get wrong. Where the injury was caused during a dispersal or crowd-control operation, the operation belongs to administrative policing and the claim goes to the tribunal administratif. Where it was caused during an arrest or another judicial-police operation, the claim for malfunctioning of justice goes to the civil courts against the Agent judiciaire de l’Etat. The Toulouse grenade case illustrates the second path: the arrest having been made as a judicial-police act, the courts applied Article L. 141-1 of the Code de l’organisation judiciaire, under which the State must repair damage caused by defective functioning of the justice public service, a liability incurred only through gross negligence or denial of justice.
The Toulouse court found gross negligence in the carrying and transport of the weapon. It recalled that gross negligence means any deficiency characterised by one or more facts showing the justice service’s inability to fulfil its mission, and it listed a pile-up of breaches: the grenade had been carried without its dedicated pouch, although the unit’s own captain admitted pouches were short for 73 officers; the officer had gone into a judicial-police arrest while carrying a weapon whose use is allowed only in self-defence, necessity, or crowd dispersal; and he had performed a violent arrest, bringing the young man down with a chokehold, while carrying a dangerous explosive in his trouser pocket. The court of appeal confirmed the liability in full and removed the 50 percent reduction for victim fault that the first judges had applied, holding the State solely responsible for all the harm suffered. The file also shows the causal bridge judges require: the forensic doctor concluded the skin wounds, haemopneumothorax and rib fracture were compatible with a disencirclement-grenade explosion in the position described by the two officers.
Before the administrative judge, the method is the mirror image, built on the Conseil d’Etat’s grenade ruling: identify the breached condition, such as missing or inaudible summons, disproportionate weapon choice, or firing after the disturbance ended, and link it to the wound through medical evidence. In both courts, procedure is strict. A money claim against the administration is admissible only after the administration has decided on a prior written demand, and the court must then be seized within two months of notification of that decision, as Article R. 421-1 of the Code de justice administrative provides. Where silence counts as an implied rejection, Article R. 421-2 gives two months from the birth of that implied decision to bring the case, unless an express rejection restarts the clock. Miss the demand or the two months and the best file in the world is inadmissible.
On quantum, French courts reason head by head: temporary incapacity and suffering, permanent functional deficit rated by the expert in percentage terms, disfigurement, loss of earnings and of professional opportunity, and the cost of care and assistance. The Toulouse file shows the method working from a complete medical chain, from emergency care through the forensic report to the final expert assessment, with each document dated and each wound tied to the blast. Gaps in that chain are where compensation leaks away, which is why treatment abroad must be recorded with the same rigour as treatment in a Paris emergency ward.
Foreign victims should add one cross-border reflex. Medical treatment in France, repatriation, and later expert examinations abroad must be documented in a single chain, with every foreign-language document translated, because French judges assess permanent infirmity, disfigurement, lost earnings and pain through court-appointed experts working from the complete file. And where the injury follows a foreign national’s arrest rather than a simple presence in the crowd, the arrest file should be read alongside the injury file: if custody or the dispersal orders were irregular, each irregularity feeds both the criminal defence and the compensation claim. Readers arrested at a demonstration will find that custody side of the story in our companion analysis of arrest, garde à vue and trial risks for foreigners at French protests, available at France protest arrest of foreigners: custody, trial and visa consequences.
Conclusion
The night of 17 October 2026, with its burnt buildings, its thousand-plus arrests and, according to The Journal, a protester whose hand was torn off by a police grenade, will generate two kinds of cases: prosecutions of alleged looters and vandals, and claims by people hurt by the policing itself. French law treats the second kind with a demanding but readable method. Force after two unanswered summons can be lawful; any weapon may be used only in absolute necessity and strict proportionality; and since the Conseil d’Etat’s 2019 grenade ruling, every breach of those conditions can engage liability and ground prosecution. The Cour de cassation’s 2025 rubber-bullet judgment shows how high the criminal bar stands, with summons, distance, threat and confusion weighed together, while the Toulouse grenade judgment shows that the State can still be held solely liable for the same kind of weapon when its agents carry and use it in breach of their own safety rules. For the injured person, the path is therefore threefold and urgent: preserve medical and video evidence from day one, file the criminal complaint and, if it is buried, pursue re-examination and partie civile within the procedural gates, and run the compensation claim in parallel with its mandatory prior demand and two-month court deadline. Handled this way, even a file born in the chaos of a Paris crossroads becomes a case a judge can decide.