KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Stranded in France as Protests Disrupt Travel: What Foreign Visitors Can Claim for Cancelled Flights, Trains and Hotels

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Stranded in France as Protests Disrupt Travel: What Foreign Visitors Can Claim for Cancelled Flights, Trains and Hotels

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

On Saturday 17 October 2026, France saw one of the largest protest days of the autumn, and foreign visitors watched it unfold in real time on their phones. According to the BBC, an estimated 550,000 people took to the streets across the country in demonstrations over hardship in schools and the cost of living, while the government described an escalation in violence alongside the marches. The same report states that more than 1,200 people were arrested, that 150 police officers were injured according to Prime Minister Sébastien Lecornu, and that buildings were set alight in Paris and other cities. In Limoges, a large fire in the town hall caused part of the roof to collapse; in Lyon, the mayor described the burning of the city’s tourist office as a tragedy for a well-known historic building; in central Paris, fires were lit near the Place de la République, shops were ransacked and at least one restaurant was gutted by fire. Within hours, searches in Britain, the United States, Canada and Australia surged for what was happening in France, whether Paris was safe, and whether flights and trains were running. This article answers the question that follows for anyone holding a ticket, a hotel booking or a package to France: when protests disrupt your trip, what can you actually claim, from whom, and on which French legal basis. The analysis below is written from inside French procedure, for an international reader, and it applies well beyond this single weekend.

I. Your flight or train to France is cancelled during the protests: what can you claim?

A cancelled flight and a cancelled train obey different rulebooks, but they share one logic in French law: the carrier must carry you or give your money back, while extra compensation depends on proving fault or on showing that no extraordinary event explains the disruption. The starting point is therefore practical, not theoretical. Keep your booking confirmation, the cancellation notice with its time stamp, screenshots of the departure board, receipts for every replacement expense, and any written statement by the carrier giving the reason for the cancellation. French civil law places the burden of proof on the party who claims performance of an obligation, and symmetrically requires the party who claims to be released to justify the fact that extinguished the obligation: article 1353 of the Civil Code provides that “Celui qui réclame l’exécution d’une obligation doit la prouver. Réciproquement, celui qui se prétend libéré doit justifier le paiement ou le fait qui a produit l’extinction de son obligation.” That single sentence governs every file below: you prove the contract and the loss, the carrier or organiser proves the event that allegedly released it. Readers who were caught on the other side of the weekend, facing the police rather than the departure board, will find the arrest and custody procedure explained in our companion analysis of foreign nationals arrested during the Paris unrest.

A. Can you get a refund or a replacement flight when the airline cancels?

When the airline itself cancels the flight, the passenger is not left with a voucher as the only option under the European framework that French courts apply daily. The Court of Cassation recalled the architecture of that framework in a ruling of 23 September 2026 on a delayed flight, Civ. 1, 23 September 2026, no. 25-14.563, and the reasoning matters directly for protest-related cancellations. The Court restated the threshold rule in these terms: “En application de l’article 5, paragraphe 3, de ce règlement, un tel retard ne donne pas droit à cette indemnisation si le transporteur aérien est en mesure de prouver que le retard important est dû à des circonstances extraordinaires.” In plain terms, compensation for the delay or cancellation can be refused only if the airline proves extraordinary circumstances caused it. The same ruling then defines those circumstances narrowly: “Celles-ci sont définies comme des événements qui, par leur nature ou leur origine, ne sont pas inhérents à l’exercice normal de l’activité du transporteur aérien concerné et qui échappent à la maîtrise effective de celui-ci, ces deux conditions étant cumulatives et devant faire l’objet d’une appréciation au cas par cas (CJUE, 11 mai 2023, TAP Portugal, C 156/22 à C 158/22, point 18).”

That passage decides the argument most travellers will face at the airport. An airline cannot defeat a claim by pointing at the word protests on a television screen; it must show, file by file, that the event was outside its normal activity and outside its effective control, and the assessment is made case by case. The September 2026 ruling adds a second layer to the carrier’s burden: the ruling further requires the airline to show that the event could not have been avoided by measures adapted to the situation, including measures that were technically and economically bearable, and that the carrier deployed the staff, equipment and financial resources at its disposal to limit the impact on the flight concerned. The airline must therefore demonstrate both that the event was unavoidable by adapted measures and that it deployed the available resources to limit the impact on the flight concerned. A flight cancelled because the crew could not reach the airport through a blocked Paris, a flight cancelled because air traffic control restricted movements, and a flight the airline chose to cancel for commercial convenience while others operated are three different files, and the Court’s test treats them as three different files.

French contract law reinforces the refund position for standalone tickets outside any package. Article 1218 of the Civil Code defines force majeure in contract matters as follows: “Il y a force majeure en matière contractuelle lorsqu’un événement échappant au contrôle du débiteur, qui ne pouvait être raisonnablement prévu lors de la conclusion du contrat et dont les effets ne peuvent être évités par des mesures appropriées, empêche l’exécution de son obligation par le débiteur.” The same article draws the consequence: “Si l’empêchement est temporaire, l’exécution de l’obligation est suspendue à moins que le retard qui en résulterait ne justifie la résolution du contrat. Si l’empêchement est définitif, le contrat est résolu de plein droit et les parties sont libérées de leurs obligations dans les conditions prévues aux articles 1351 et 1351-1 .” A flight that will never operate is a definitive prevention, so the contract is resolved and each side is released. Article 1351 of the Civil Code confirms the mechanism: “L’impossibilité d’exécuter la prestation libère le débiteur à due concurrence lorsqu’elle procède d’un cas de force majeure et qu’elle est définitive, à moins qu’il n’ait convenu de s’en charger ou qu’il ait été préalablement mis en demeure.” The traveller who paid for carriage that never happened therefore has a restitution claim for the price, while damages for the delay or cancellation remain governed by the fault and extraordinary-circumstances tests above: article 1231-1 of the Civil Code states that “Le débiteur est condamné, s’il y a lieu, au paiement de dommages et intérêts soit à raison de l’inexécution de l’obligation, soit à raison du retard dans l’exécution, s’il ne justifie pas que l’exécution a été empêchée par la force majeure.” Refund on the one hand, additional damages on the other: the two claims follow different paths, and only the second can be blocked by a proven extraordinary event.

For rail journeys, including cross-border services into Paris, the applicable framework is designated by French statute: article L2151-1 of the Transport Code provides that “Le règlement (UE) 2021/782 du Parlement européen et du Conseil du 29 avril 2021 sur les droits et obligations des voyageurs ferroviaires s’applique aux voyages et services ferroviaires pour lesquels une entreprise doit avoir obtenu une licence conformément à la directive 2012/34/UE du Parlement européen et du Conseil du 21 novembre 2012 établissant un espace ferroviaire unique européen modifiée.” In practice, the operator’s general conditions then set out the rerouting, assistance and repayment mechanics for each cancelled service. Travellers should note that disruption patterns differ sharply between operators and days: Eurostar’s live travel updates during the autumn of 2026 listed trains cancelled on the French network on specific dates for engineering works, while press coverage of the strike wave indicated that international services such as Eurostar were not expected to be affected in the same way as domestic lines, and that the Paris metro was disrupted during mobilisation days. The lesson is operational: check the status of your exact train rather than assuming a network-wide shutdown, keep the operator’s cancellation message, and claim under the conditions attached to your ticket.

B. Do street protests automatically count as an extraordinary event for carriers?

The short answer is no, and a French appellate ruling on an earlier protest wave explains why carriers cannot wave the word riots like a pass. After the gilets jaunes blockades on the island of Réunion, a film distributor argued that the movement constituted force majeure and released it from its promotion and screening commitments. The Versailles Court of Appeal rejected the shortcut in a line of reasoning French courts still apply, stated by the Versailles Court of Appeal on 11 May 2023 (no. 21/06713): the judges refused to infer from the mere occurrence of the gilets jaunes movement that the distributor had been unable to promote or screen the film, even on the assumption that the movement met the force majeure criteria. The court required proof of a genuine impossibility to perform, and it found that proof missing because the venues had reopened and the distributor could not explain why it had not performed once performance became possible again. Transposed to air and rail travel, the principle is identical: a protest movement in the headlines does not prove that your specific flight or train could not operate. The carrier must connect the general event to your service with documents such as a closure notice for the airport or station, an air traffic restriction, a crew positioning failure, or a prefectural order closing access, and it must show that no reasonable alternative existed.

This fact-by-fact approach also governs the traveller’s own conduct on the day. A passenger who abandons a journey that could still have been performed, or who books a luxury replacement without giving the carrier a chance to reroute, weakens the claim for additional costs, because the carrier will argue that the loss flows from the traveller’s choice rather than from the cancellation. The strong file is built in the first hours: ask the airline or rail operator in writing for rerouting, keep the refusal or the proposed alternative with its schedule, photograph the information screens, save the text messages announcing the cancellation, and pay by card so that every replacement cost is traceable. Where the disruption strands you overnight, keep hotel and meal receipts separately from the ticket file, because assistance and compensation are examined under distinct headings. Finally, remember the allocation of proof recalled above: the carrier that invokes protests as its defence carries the burden of establishing the extraordinary character of the event and the reasonable measures it took, while you carry the burden of proving the contract, the cancellation and the amounts you claim. Files are won on paper, and protest weekends produce more paper than ordinary ones, which helps the traveller who collects it and harms the one who discards it.

II. Your package, hotel or travel insurance is hit by the unrest: who pays?

Many foreign visitors do not hold a standalone ticket but a combination: flight plus hotel, a tour with transfers, or a city break assembled by an online platform. French law treats that combination as a package once it matches the statutory definition, and the package regime is markedly more protective than the law of isolated services, because the organiser answers for the whole trip. The scope provision is article L211-1 of the Tourism Code, which brings within the chapter the professionals who develop and sell package travel as well as those who sell transport, accommodation, vehicle rental or other travel services they do not produce themselves. If your confirmation shows a single trader taking responsibility for the trip, or linked online bookings presented as one journey, you are likely inside this protective regime, and the paragraphs below describe how it operates when the destination descends into unrest of the kind seen on 17 October 2026.

A. Can you cancel a package to France without fees and get a full refund?

Yes, where the unrest genuinely affects the destination, and the text that grants this exit is article L211-14 of the Tourism Code. Its second paragraph gives the traveller a termination right without termination fees: “Le voyageur a le droit de résoudre le contrat avant le début du voyage ou du séjour sans payer de frais de résolution si des circonstances exceptionnelles et inévitables, survenant au lieu de destination ou à proximité immédiate de celui-ci, ont des conséquences importantes sur l’exécution du contrat ou sur le transport des passagers vers le lieu de destination. Dans ce cas, le voyageur a droit au remboursement intégral des paiements effectués mais pas à un dédommagement supplémentaire.” Three conditions must coincide: exceptional and unavoidable circumstances, located at the destination or in its immediate vicinity, with significant consequences either for the performance of the contract or for carrying passengers to the destination. A weekend of burning barricades around the Place de la République, a gutted town hall in Limoges where your hotel stands, or a prefectural closure of the station serving your resort can satisfy that test; distant unease about travelling, without concrete consequences for your trip, cannot. Where the test is met, the outcome is binary and protective: full refund of sums paid, no termination fees, but no additional damages either. The symmetry is deliberate, because the organiser may face the same event from its side: the third paragraph provides that the organiser or retailer may also terminate and refund in full, without additional compensation, where it is prevented from performing by exceptional and unavoidable circumstances after notifying the traveller as soon as possible before the start of the trip.

The Court of Cassation confirmed this reading in a July 2025 ruling on a cancelled cruise package, Civ. 1, 9 July 2025, no. 24-10.623, where it approved judges who had identified “l’existence de circonstances exceptionnelles et inévitables au sens de l’article L. 211-14, III, 2, du code du tourisme”. The interest of that ruling for protest-stranded travellers lies in what followed: the tribunal’s finding opened a right to repayment of the sums collected for services never performed, without additional compensation, and the Court added that the retailer who had refunded the traveller could recover from the tour operator the sums received for unperformed services. The chain therefore runs in the traveller’s favour: traveller against retailer, retailer against organiser, with each link confined to restitution rather than punishment.

Where the trip has started and services are performed badly or not at all, two further provisions take over. First, the organiser answers for the whole package as a matter of strict liability: article L211-16 of the Tourism Code states that “Le professionnel qui vend un forfait touristique mentionné au 1° du I de l’ article L. 211-1 est responsable de plein droit de l’exécution des services prévus par ce contrat, que ces services soient exécutés par lui-même ou par d’autres prestataires de services de voyage, sans préjudice de son droit de recours contre ceux-ci.” The organiser cannot hide behind its airline, hotel or local agency; it answers first and recovers afterwards. The Court of Cassation recalled the narrow exits in a February 2021 ruling, Civ. 1, 17 February 2021, no. 19-18.819: the professional may be exonerated only by proving that non-performance is attributable to the buyer, to the unforeseeable and insurmountable act of a third party unconnected with the contractual services, or to force majeure. The same article, in the wording verified for this article, allows the professional to escape liability in whole or in part only “en apportant la preuve que le dommage est imputable soit au voyageur, soit à un tiers étranger à la fourniture des services de voyage compris dans le contrat, soit à des circonstances exceptionnelles et inévitables.” Second, the price follows the services actually delivered: article L211-17 of the Tourism Code grants “une réduction de prix appropriée pour toute période de non-conformité des services fournis dans le cadre d’un contrat, sauf si l’organisateur ou le détaillant prouve que la non-conformité est imputable au voyageur”, while damages for harm suffered through non-conformity are available unless the organiser proves attribution to the traveller, to an unforeseeable or unavoidable third-party act, or to exceptional and unavoidable circumstances: “Le voyageur n’a droit à aucune indemnisation si l’organisateur ou le détaillant prouve que la non-conformité est imputable soit au voyageur, soit à un tiers étranger à la fourniture des services de voyage compris dans le contrat et revêt un caractère imprévisible ou inévitable, soit à des circonstances exceptionnelles et inévitables.” A hotel unusable because its street is under curfew, excursions cancelled because museums closed by prefectural order, transfers impossible because roads are blocked: each non-conforming period reduces the price owed, and only a proven external cause removes the damages claim.

Travellers already in France when trouble erupts hold one more card that is often overlooked. Article L211-17-1 of the Tourism Code imposes a duty of assistance: “L’organisateur d’un voyage ou séjour ou le détaillant apporte dans les meilleurs délais eu égard aux circonstances de l’espèce une aide appropriée au voyageur en difficulté, y compris dans les circonstances mentionnées au VII de l’ article L. 211-16.” An organiser who leaves clients without information, without rerouting help and without accommodation assistance during a night of urban violence breaches an express statutory duty, and that breach is actionable independently of the refund debate. In practice, call the retailer’s emergency line first, record the time of each call, ask in writing for the assistance you need, and keep every receipt: assistance costs advanced by the traveller because the organiser defaulted feed directly into the price-reduction and damages analysis above.

Standalone hotel bookings outside any package fall back on ordinary contract law. If the hotel cannot accommodate you because the authorities closed the area, or because the building itself was damaged as the Limoges town hall and the Lyon tourist office were on that October weekend, the force majeure analysis of article 1218 applies as described above, with resolution and restitution where prevention is definitive. If instead you choose not to travel while the hotel remains able to receive you, the hotel may retain the price or apply its cancellation scale, because the prevention affects your journey, not its performance. The distinction matters enormously in protest contexts: check whether your hotel actually closed or remained open, obtain written confirmation of either, and only then decide whether to invoke termination or to negotiate a postponement. Our analysis of the Limoges town hall fire and the criminal charges facing alleged rioters details what happens on the criminal side of the same events for foreign nationals caught up in them.

B. Will travel insurance cover protest disruption in France?

Travel insurance is where many protest-stranded visitors lose valid claims, not because the cover excludes riots, but because they never read the exclusion the way French courts read it. The governing text is article L113-1 of the Insurance Code, which places accidental losses and losses caused by the insured’s fault on the insurer “sauf exclusion formelle et limitée contenue dans la police”. An exclusion must therefore be both formal, meaning stated in precise terms requiring no interpretation, and limited, meaning confined to defined hypotheses rather than sweeping the whole cover away. A clause excluding civil unrest, riots, strikes or their consequences can satisfy that test where it is drafted precisely, but a vague reference to troubled events or to any consequence of demonstrations does not, and the insurer that relies on loose wording litigates uphill.

A September 2026 ruling of the Court of Cassation reshaped this battlefield weeks before the October protests, and travellers should know its outcome before accepting a refusal. In Civ. 2, 17 September 2026, no. 25-12.441, the Court reconsidered what happens when a single clause lists several exclusions and only one of them is defective. It held that formal character is assessed exclusion by exclusion: “lorsqu’une clause d’un contrat d’assurance énumère plusieurs cas d’exclusion de garantie, leur caractère formel s’apprécie en considération de chacun d’entre eux, et non au regard de l’ensemble des exclusions visées par la clause. Il en résulte que la nullité d’une exclusion non formelle n’entraîne pas celle de l’ensemble de la clause, sauf lorsqu’elle en affecte la compréhension.” The practical consequence cuts both ways. An insurer can no longer see its entire clause collapse because one listed hypothesis was loosely drafted, but neither can it save a vague riot exclusion by pointing to a precise pandemic exclusion sitting beside it in the same clause: each exclusion stands or falls on its own wording. When your insurer refuses cover for protest-related losses, demand the exact clause in writing, identify precisely which listed hypothesis it invokes for your loss, and test that hypothesis alone against the formal-and-limited standard. A refusal letter citing the whole clause without naming the applicable hypothesis is, under this new case law, a weak refusal letter.

Beyond the exclusion debate, insurance files turn on three practical duties that French law enforces strictly. First, notify the insurer promptly through the channel the policy designates, usually an online declaration followed by supporting documents, and keep proof of the date of notification. Second, mitigate the loss: French insurers routinely challenge replacement costs they consider excessive, so choose reasonable rerouting and accommodation, keep every invoice, and note why each expense was necessary on the day. Third, assemble the causal chain between the insured event and each amount claimed: the policy covers consequences of the covered event, not the general inconvenience of a tense weekend, so link each receipt to a specific cancellation, closure or order. Photographs of closed stations, the carrier’s cancellation message, the prefectural order where one exists, and the hotel’s written confirmation that it could not receive you are the documents that convert a narrative into a payable file. Where the insurer maintains its refusal, the file as assembled above is also the file a court will examine, because judges apply the same allocation of proof recalled at the opening of this article: you prove the contract, the loss and its amount, while the insurer proves the formal and limited exclusion it invokes.

One final practical layer concerns visitors who need help rather than money: consular assistance, alternative travel documents after a loss or theft during the unrest, and information for relatives. Contact your consulate in France early, keep a digital copy of your passport separate from the original, and file a police report for any theft or loss, since insurers and airlines both request it. These steps create no legal entitlement to compensation by themselves, but they unlock the documents on which every compensation claim depends.

Conclusion

The October 2026 protest weekend confronted foreign visitors with the full spectrum of travel disruption: cancelled departures, closed stations, unusable hotels, and nights reorganised around curfews and cordons. French law answers that spectrum with a coherent set of tools rather than a single remedy. The package traveller holds an exit with full refund and without termination fees where exceptional and unavoidable circumstances at the destination significantly affect the trip, the organiser answers strictly for the services promised and owes assistance to travellers in difficulty, the air passenger benefits from a narrow judicial reading of extraordinary circumstances assessed case by case, the rail passenger travels under a designated European framework applied through French statute, the hotel guest relies on force majeure and restitution where performance became truly impossible, and the insured traveller faces exclusions that must be formal and limited, now tested exclusion by exclusion under the September 2026 case law. None of these tools operates automatically: each requires the paper the weekend generated, collected in the first hours and organised around the contract, the cancellation and the amounts. Travellers who keep that paper hold claims that French courts know how to enforce; those who discard it hold memories that no court can price.

📄 Official circular