You land at Charles de Gaulle with the keys to the stone house in the Dordogne, drive three hours through the countryside, and find strangers living inside. The locks have been changed, your furniture is gone or pushed into a corner, and the people at the door tell you to come back with a judge. Every year a small number of American owners of French second homes live exactly this moment, and almost all of them make the same first mistake: they assume that ownership alone lets them take the house back by force, by changing the locks back, by cutting the power, or by hiring someone to empty the place. French law treats that shortcut as a crime in its own right, and it treats the occupants, even occupants with no lease and no title, as people who can only be removed through one of two formal tracks. The good news is that France built a fast administrative lane precisely for this situation, and that a 2023 statute sharpened every deadline in the owner’s favor. The bad news is that every bill attached to the house keeps running in your name until the occupants are lawfully gone, and that the American instinct to fix the problem with money and speed can create liability on both sides of the Atlantic. Part I walks through the two removal tracks, the criminal complaint that starts both of them, the prefect’s 48-hour decision, and the courtroom fallback with its shortened delays. Part II follows the money: the property taxes that stay yours, the damages you can claim, the insurance questions to settle before anything happens, and the transatlantic tax position to confirm once the house is yours again.
I. Getting the Occupants Out: the Fast Prefect Track and the Courtroom Fallback
French law divides unwanted occupants into two worlds, and everything about speed, paperwork, and winter protection turns on which world you are in. In the first world sit tenants who stopped paying rent or stayed after the lease ended: they entered lawfully, so they leave slowly, with notice periods, a two-month grace period after the order to vacate, and a winter truce that freezes most evictions from November through March. In the second world sit squatters, people who broke in through cunning, threats, force, or coercion and stayed without any right: they entered unlawfully, so the procedures against them are shorter, the grace periods can disappear entirely, and the winter truce does not protect them when the occupied place is someone’s home. Your whole strategy as an absentee American owner consists of proving, with paper, that you are in the second world, and then choosing between the prefect’s administrative lane and the judge. Start the paper trail the day you learn of the occupation, because both lanes demand the same three documents, and gathering them from 4,000 miles away takes longer than you think.
A. The First 72 Hours From America: Police Report, Proof of Ownership, and the Prefect’s 48-Hour Decision
The administrative lane runs through the prefect of the department where the house sits, and it moves fast: once your file is complete, the prefect must decide within 48 hours of receiving the request, a deadline the government’s own citizen-guidance page states in plain terms alongside the full procedure for occupied homes (Que faire quand des squatteurs occupent un logement). Three attachments make the file, and each one has a specific job. First, the receipt for a criminal complaint. Squatting is the crime of home invasion defined by the Penal Code: “L’introduction dans le domicile d’autrui à l’aide de manoeuvres, menaces, voies de fait ou contrainte, hors les cas où la loi le permet, est puni de trois ans d’emprisonnement et de 45 000 euros d’amende” (article 226-4 of the Penal Code). File that complaint for violation de domicile as soon as the occupation is discovered, keep the receipt, and understand why the complaint matters beyond symbolism: the prefect’s file requires it, and the criminal track runs in parallel with everything else, preserving your right to civil damages at the criminal trial later. Second, proof that the house is your home or your property. From abroad, assemble utility bills in your name, French tax assessments, the deed of purchase, and a written statement from a neighbor; if you cannot prove ownership because you no longer have access to the house, the prefect must ask the tax administration within 72 hours to identify the owner, according to the same official guidance page. Third, a formal finding that the house is squatted, drawn up by a judicial police officer, the mayor, or a commissaire de justice, the court officer formerly called huissier, confirming entry by cunning, threats, force, or coercion and continued occupation. A French lawyer can assemble this file and draft the prefect request on your behalf, which is how most American owners bridge the distance; the guidance page notes that counsel may draft the formal demand for you.
Two features of this lane deserve emphasis because both changed recently and both favor second-home owners directly. The first is that a furnished second home counts. The Penal Code provision quoted above closes with a sentence added for exactly your situation: “Constitue notamment le domicile d’une personne, au sens du présent article, tout local d’habitation contenant des biens meubles lui appartenant, que cette personne y habite ou non et qu’il s’agisse de sa résidence principale ou non” (article 226-4 of the Penal Code). A house with your furniture in it is your domicile for criminal purposes even if you sleep there three weeks a year, which is what opens the prefect’s door. The second is the reply clock and the exit clock. The prefect weighs the personal and family situation of the occupants and must rule within 48 hours of receiving the request, giving written reasons for any refusal; if the answer is yes, the formal notice to vacate gives at least 24 hours for an occupied domicile and at least seven days in other cases, and if the occupants still have not left when the clock expires, the prefect must have the house cleared by public force without delay, unless you asked otherwise (official squat procedure page). That sequence, complaint plus proof plus finding, 48-hour decision, 24-hour or seven-day notice, forced clearance, is the fastest lawful path from discovery to recovery, and it exists because Parliament decided in the summer of 2023 that illegal occupation of housing deserved a dedicated statute, the law of July 27, 2023 to protect housing against unlawful occupation (LOI n° 2023-668 du 27 juillet 2023 visant à protéger les logements contre l’occupation illicite), which toughened the penalties and compressed the delays across the codes.
One warning belongs in this section because it is the mistake American owners make most often, and French courts punish it without sympathy: do not take the house back yourself. Changing the locks, moving the occupants’ belongings to the curb, shutting off water or electricity, or paying someone to clear the rooms can constitute the mirror crime of forced eviction without state assistance: “Le fait de forcer un tiers à quitter le lieu qu’il habite sans avoir obtenu le concours de l’Etat dans les conditions prévues à l’article L. 153-1 du code des procédures civiles d’exécution , à l’aide de manœuvres, menaces, voies de fait ou contraintes, est puni de trois ans d’emprisonnement et de 30 000 € d’amende” (article 226-4-2 of the Penal Code). A Paris emergency-ruling from January 2025 shows how badly self-help misfires even when the owner believes the occupant has no rights: after owners changed the locks and access codes on a Paris apartment, the occupant sued for forced re-entry, and the protection-litigation judge dissected the lock change as an alleged voie de fait before ruling, on the full file, that the claimant was an occupant without right or title and rejecting every one of his demands (Tribunal judiciaire de Paris, ordonnance de référé, January 9, 2025, RG 24/11203, full text: “CONSTATONS que M. [L] [M] est occupant sans droit ni titre de l’appartement […] REJETONS l’ensemble des demandes de M. [L] [M]”). Read that outcome from the owner’s side and the lesson is double-edged but clear: the occupant without title lost, yet the lock change still dragged the owners into emergency litigation, cost them months, and exposed them to penalty payments the judge could have imposed. Ownership in France is absolute in principle, “le droit de jouir et disposer des choses de la manière la plus absolue, pourvu qu’on n’en fasse pas un usage prohibé par les lois ou par les règlements” (article 544 of the Civil Code), and the proviso does the real work here: recovery runs through the prefect or the judge, never through your own hands.
B. When the Prefect Says No or the File Does Not Fit: Suing Occupants With No Right or Title Before the Judge
The prefect’s lane is fast but discretionary: the prefect weighs the occupants’ personal and family situation, must justify a refusal, and a refusal ends the administrative shortcut. The judicial lane is slower but as of right, and it starts before the protection-litigation judge, the juge des contentieux de la protection, the trial judge for housing-occupation disputes: “Le juge des contentieux de la protection connaît des actions dont un contrat de louage d’immeubles à usage d’habitation ou un contrat portant sur l’occupation d’un logement est l’objet, la cause ou l’occasion” (article L213-4-4 of the Code of Judicial Organization). In genuine emergencies your lawyer petitions that judge in référé, the fast-track emergency procedure of the statute that opens “Dans tous les cas d’urgence,” and provides that the court “peuvent ordonner en référé toutes les mesures qui ne se heurtent à aucune contestation sérieuse ou que justifie l’existence d’un différend” (article 834 of the Code of Civil Procedure). Occupation by break-in with occupants who hold no lease, no title, and no credible defense is the textbook case for emergency relief: the unlawful disturbance is manifest, the owner’s title is documented, and the judge can order expulsion, authorize assistance of public force, and attach a daily penalty payment for each day of delay. From the United States you will not attend these hearings; your lawyer appears, files the deed, the tax notices, the complaint receipt, and the constat, and answers the two defenses occupants raise most often, that they hold some agreement with a prior occupant or relative, and that winter protects them.
Both standard defenses fail against squatters more often than occupants expect, because the 2023 statute rewrote the two grace mechanisms that slow ordinary evictions. Start with the two-month breathing period. After a court orders expulsion, enforcement against an inhabited dwelling normally waits for a two-month period following the formal order to vacate: “elle ne peut avoir lieu qu’à l’expiration d’un délai de deux mois qui suit le commandement, sans préjudice des dispositions des articles L. 412-3 à L. 412-7” (article L412-1 of the Code of Civil Enforcement Procedures). But the same article withdraws that shelter from precisely your adversaries: “Le délai prévu au premier alinéa du présent article ne s’applique pas lorsque le juge qui ordonne l’expulsion constate la mauvaise foi de la personne expulsée ou que les personnes dont l’expulsion a été ordonnée sont entrées dans les locaux à l’aide de manœuvres, de menaces, de voies de fait ou de contrainte” (article L412-1 of the Code of Civil Enforcement Procedures). Ask the judge to record forced entry in the order itself, and the two months collapse. Turn to the winter truce, the rule that suspends unexecuted evictions from November 1 each year until the following March 31: “il est sursis à toute mesure d’expulsion non exécutée à la date du 1er novembre de chaque année jusqu’au 31 mars de l’année suivante, à moins que le relogement des intéressés soit assuré dans des conditions suffisantes respectant l’unité et les besoins de la famille” (article L412-6 of the Code of Civil Enforcement Procedures). Squatters in a domicile are carved out by the very next paragraph: “ce sursis ne s’applique pas lorsque la mesure d’expulsion a été prononcée en raison d’une introduction sans droit ni titre dans le domicile d’autrui à l’aide de manœuvres, de menaces, de voies de fait ou de contrainte” (article L412-6 of the Code of Civil Enforcement Procedures). The official citizen guidance confirms the practical consequence: once the court officer has served the order to vacate, squatters get no grace period, and if they stay, the officer asks the prefect for public-force assistance to remove them (official squat procedure page). Winter changes nothing for a forced entry into your furnished house; it remains decisive protection for lawful tenants, which is exactly why proving the break-in character of the entry, through the constat and the complaint, controls the entire timetable.
A June 2025 criminal ruling adds a precision that American owners should understand before framing their case, because it cuts both ways. The Court of Cassation recalled that only a place where someone, whether they live there or not, “has the right to call home” counts as a domicile for home-invasion purposes, whatever the legal basis of occupation, since the statute does not generally guarantee real estate against usurpation: “Seul constitue un domicile, au sens de ce texte, le lieu où une personne, qu’elle y habite ou non, a le droit de se dire chez elle, quels que soient le titre juridique de son occupation et l’affectation donnée aux locaux, ledit texte n’ayant pas pour objet de garantir d’une manière générale les propriétés immobilières contre une usurpation” (Court of Cassation, criminal chamber, June 3, 2025, no. 23-81.916, full text). In that case a former owner expelled after a foreclosure auction twice broke back into the adjudicated house, and the high court quashed the home-invasion conviction for the first re-entry because the new auction buyer had not yet received the keys and had never occupied the property, so the buyer could not yet claim it as the place she had the right to call home. Apply that reasoning to your file and two consequences follow. First, keep your furniture, utility contracts, and tax records in the house’s name continuously, because the furnished character of the dwelling is what makes an absent owner’s second home a domicile under article 226-4 even when you are in America eleven months a year. Second, frame the criminal complaint around the domicile you maintained, not around bare ownership: the complaint that mirrors the statute, entry by cunning, threats, force, or coercion into your furnished home plus continued occupation, is the complaint that unlocks the prefect’s lane and survives appellate review.
II. The Money: Property Taxes That Stay Yours, Damages You Can Claim, and the Transatlantic Position
Removal answers the urgent question, but the expensive question runs underneath it: who pays for the months the house was occupied, the damage left behind, and the taxes assessed while strangers slept in your bedrooms. French law answers with a split. The public bills stay with the owner regardless of occupation, the private losses travel with a damages claim against the occupants, and the American tax position sits on top of both, governed by residence rules and the bilateral treaty rather than by anything the squatters did. Map all three before you act, because the order in which you pay, claim, and declare determines how much of the episode is recoverable and how much becomes a dead loss.
A. The Bills That Stay in Your Name and the Losses That Travel With a Damages Claim
Start with the property tax, because it surprises American owners every time. The French property tax on buildings is assessed annually on every built property in France, “établie annuellement sur les propriétés bâties sises en France à l’exception de celles qui en sont expressément exonérées” (article 1380 of the General Tax Code), and it is imposed in the name of the current owner, since “toute propriété, bâtie ou non bâtie, doit être imposée au nom du propriétaire actuel” (article 1400 of the General Tax Code). Squatters do not become taxpayers by occupying; you remain the person the tax office bills, the person liable for late penalties if the assessment goes unpaid while you fight over access to the mailbox, and the person whose French tax account accrues the debt. Pay the foncière on time even while the house is occupied, keep the assessments as exhibits proving continuous ownership for the prefect’s file, and treat any secondary-home housing tax assessment the same way until the tax office corrects it. The same continuity logic governs insurance: notify your homeowner insurer the week you learn of the occupation, confirm in writing what the policy covers for break-in damage, vandalism, and third-party liability while the house is unlawfully occupied, and do not let coverage lapse on the theory that an empty-looking house costs nothing to insure. An insurer that learns of a year-long undeclared occupation after a fire will dispute the claim; an insurer warned in writing during the first week has far less room to maneuver.
Your recoverable losses run through two channels that feed each other. Civilly, every harm the occupation caused, from a smashed door and stripped copper to a year of lost use and the court officer’s fees, supports a fault-based damages action under the general principle stated by the Civil Code: “Tout fait quelconque de l’homme, qui cause à autrui un dommage, oblige celui par la faute duquel il est arrivé à le réparer” (article 1240 of the Civil Code). Document everything the day you recover possession: the court officer’s inventory, dated photographs, repair invoices, and any valuation of lost seasonal rental value if the house was previously let. Criminally, join the proceedings as a civil party, partie civile, so that the criminal court that convicts for home invasion also rules on your compensation in the same judgment, as criminal courts routinely do on civil interests alongside the sentence. The June 2025 home-invasion ruling discussed above illustrates the combined structure: conviction and prohibition on entering the premises on the criminal side, civil interests decided alongside (Court of Cassation, criminal chamber, June 3, 2025, no. 23-81.916, full text). Be realistic about collection: occupants ordered to pay often have no seizable assets, so weigh the cost of the damages suit against the symbolic and practical value of an enforceable order, and prioritize the claims that matter, repair costs and officer fees first, moral damages second. Owners who hold their French house year after year will recognize the companion question this episode raises, how the annual French carrying costs of a second home work in a normal year without squatters, a subject this site covers in its guide to the yearly taxes, treaty credit, and second-home charges American owners face.
B. Holding the House From 4,000 Miles Away: Guardianship, Paper, and the American Tax Position
Once the house is yours again, the strategic question is how it gets occupied a second time, and the answer is almost always the same: an empty house with no local eyes on it. Three arrangements, in ascending order of cost, cover most American situations. The cheapest is a neighbor with a key, a written instruction to call you and the mayor at the first sign of intrusion, and a small annual payment that makes the arrangement reliable rather than friendly. The middle option is a local property manager, gardien or concierge service, under a written contract covering weekly walk-throughs, mail collection, meter readings, and emergency call-outs, with photographs sent to you after each visit; those dated visit reports double as evidence that any later occupation began after a specific date, which sharpens both the complaint and the prefect’s file. The strongest option for high-value houses is an alarmed and remotely monitored property with a maintenance contract, plus the manager’s physical visits, because an alarm log showing the exact night of a break-in converts the constat from a reconstruction into a timestamp. Whichever layer you choose, keep one file, physical or digital, holding the deed, the last three foncière and housing-tax assessments, the insurance policy and its occupation-declaration letters, the manager’s contract and visit logs, and the contact details of your lawyer and court officer. That file is what turns the next discovery, if there is one, from a transatlantic panic into a 48-hour prefect request assembled in a day.
Close the episode on the American side with the tax position, because the squat year creates mismatches that surprise owners at filing season. The United States taxes its citizens on worldwide income wherever they live, and France taxes French land and buildings at source; the allocation between the two systems for income and wealth taxation runs through the 1994 France-United States tax treaty, whose consolidated text the French tax administration publishes (consolidated France-United States convention on income and wealth taxes). Three practical consequences follow for the year of the occupation. First, repair costs, legal fees, and unreimbursed losses from the episode belong in your records with French invoices attached, because their treatment on each side of the Atlantic depends on documentation you assemble now, not at filing time. Second, any compensation the occupants or an insurer eventually pay is income to characterize deliberately in the year of receipt, not an afterthought. Third, confirm the filing position with a professional who works both systems before the return goes out, since treaty mechanics turn on the facts of each year, residence, the nature of each payment, and the ordering of credits, and a squat year scrambles all three. The house recovered fastest is the house whose owner filed the complaint first, fed the prefect a complete file, refused the temptation of self-help, and kept paying the taxes while the law did its work.
Conclusion
An occupied second home feels like an emergency that justifies any response, and French law agrees with the first half of that sentence only. It agrees that break-in occupation is a crime punishable by three years’ imprisonment and a 45,000-euro fine, that a furnished house you visit once a year is still your domicile, and that the prefect must decide your clearance request within 48 hours. It disagrees, absolutely, that ownership lets you take the house back with your own locksmith: forced self-recovery is its own three-year crime, and even successful owners who tried it paid for the lesson in emergency litigation. Work the two lawful lanes in order, criminal complaint with receipt, proof of ownership, formal constat, prefect’s 48-hour decision with its 24-hour or seven-day exit notice, and the protection-litigation judge in référé with no two-month delay and no winter truce when the order records forced entry without right or title. Keep the property taxes current in your name while the procedure runs, build the damages file from the day of recovery, and close the year with a treaty-aware American filing. Handled that way, the worst week of your French ownership becomes a recoverable incident; handled with a changed lock and a cut power line, it becomes a second case in which you are the defendant.