KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
My Sibling Won’t Sell Our French House: How an American Co-Heir Forces the Split, Sets the Auction, and Settles the Tax

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

My Sibling Won’t Sell Our French House: How an American Co-Heir Forces the Split, Sets the Auction, and Settles the Tax

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

Your mother died in France owning a small house outside Lyon. You live in Chicago. Your sister lives twenty minutes from the house, and she has decided she will never sell. She does not answer the notaire, she pays no rent, and every proposal ends the same way: silence, or no. You are now paying French property tax on a home you cannot use, cannot sell, and cannot even enter without an argument. This is the most common American co-heir trap in France, and French law has a direct answer for it.

When several heirs own a French estate together before it is divided, they are in what French law calls indivision, a form of co-ownership between co-heirs. Each of you owns a share of the whole, called droits indivis, but nobody owns any specific room. Getting out of that shared ownership is called partage, the partition. This guide explains how an American heir forces that partition from the United States when a sibling refuses, what a French judge can do about a silent or occupying co-heir, how the court divides the house or sends it to auction, and what the split costs in French tax, notaire fees, and American reporting.

I. How Do I Force the Split When My Sibling Refuses to Sell Our French House?

A. Can One American Co-Heir Really Force a French Partition From Abroad?

Yes. The starting rule of French co-ownership is blunt, and it sits in the first article of the section: “Nul ne peut être contraint à demeurer dans l’indivision et le partage peut toujours être provoqué, à moins qu’il n’y ait été sursis par jugement ou convention.” In plain English, nobody can be forced to stay in shared ownership, and any co-heir can trigger the partition at any time, unless a court or a written agreement has ordered a temporary stay. Your sister’s refusal does not create a veto. It only decides whether the partition happens by agreement or by court order.

The friendly route is called partage amiable, the agreed partition. It requires everyone to agree, and when every co-heir is present and legally capable, the Civil Code lets the family divide the property in whatever form they choose: article 835 says the partition may take place in the form and on the terms chosen by the parties, while adding that a partition involving real estate subject to land registration must be drawn up as a notarial deed. In practice that means the French notaire settling the succession drafts a partition deed, everyone signs, the deed is registered at the land registry, and each heir walks away with a lot, plus or minus a cash equalization payment called a soulte. The soulte is simply the check one heir pays another when the lots are unequal in value. If your sister wants the house and you want cash, the deed gives her the house and gives you a soulte for your share. No lawsuit is needed when everyone signs.

Your case is the opposite case: one co-heir refuses the agreed partition, or the heirs fight over how to carry it out. That is exactly what article 840 of the Civil Code is written for. It provides that partition claims go to court where one co-owner refuses the agreed partition, where disputes arise over how to proceed, or where an agreed partition was legally impossible, for example because one heir is missing or under legal protection. A refusal letter, an unanswered notaire, or a sibling who rejects every valuation all point to the same door: the partage judiciaire, the court-ordered partition.

That court is not chosen at random. Article 841 of the Civil Code gives exclusive jurisdiction to the court of the place where the succession opened, meaning the court for the area of your parent’s last domicile in France. If your mother lived in Lyon, the Lyon judicial court hears the partition even if you live in Chicago and your sister lives in Marseille. An American heir sues through a French lawyer, gives a written power of attorney, and almost never needs to fly over for routine hearings. The court then typically appoints a notaire to carry out the accounting, liquidation, and partition operations, and may appoint a supervising judge, the juge commis, to settle disputes as the work progresses. The official Service-Public pages describe the same two tracks, agreement first and court partition when agreement fails, for co-ownership between heirs and for the partition of the estate assets.

Two cross-border points matter before you file. First, the European Succession Regulation No 650/2012, which France applies, makes the law of the deceased’s last habitual residence govern the succession as a whole unless the deceased validly chose the law of their nationality in a will, under Articles 21 and 22 of the Regulation. For a parent who lived their daily life in France, French partition law normally controls the French house regardless of your American passport. Second, the partition judgment is a French judgment on French real estate, so it is enforced in France against the house itself. You do not need an American court to bless it. Your French lawyer records the judgment at the land registry, and it transfers title exactly like a deed.

The practical sequence from the United States therefore looks like this. You ask a French lawyer to send your sibling a formal written demand to agree to the partition, with a valuation by an independent local agent. If she still refuses, your lawyer files the partition action before the court of the place where the succession opened, asks the court to appoint the notaire already handling the file, and requests the protective measures described below so the house does not rot, get secretly rented out, or get stripped of value while the case runs. Refusal is the beginning of the procedure, not the end of your rights.

B. What If My Sibling Stalls, Goes Silent, or Lives in the House Rent-Free?

Blocking heirs use three classic tactics: doing nothing, living in the house for free, and vetoing every management decision. French co-ownership law answers each one separately, and you should know all three before you negotiate, because each answer changes what your demand letter says.

Start with the veto on daily management. You do not need unanimity for everything. Article 815-3 of the Civil Code lets the co-owners holding at least two-thirds of the undivided rights take administration decisions together: routine management acts, a general management mandate given to one co-owner or a third party, selling movable property to pay the debts of the co-ownership, and signing or renewing ordinary leases. The same article requires the majority to inform the other co-owners, and decisions taken without that notice cannot be held against them. So if you and a brother together hold two-thirds, you can insure the house, hire a gardener, renew a normal residential lease, and sell your late father’s car to pay the property tax, provided your sister is properly informed. What the two-thirds majority cannot do is sell the house itself or give it away. Disposing of the real estate needs either everyone’s agreement or a judge.

When a necessary consent is refused and that refusal endangers the common interest, the Code lets one co-owner go to court for permission to act alone. Article 815-5 of the Civil Code states: “Un indivisaire peut être autorisé par justice à passer seul un acte pour lequel le consentement d’un coïndivisaire serait nécessaire, si le refus de celui-ci met en péril l’intérêt commun.” In other words, a co-heir may be authorized by the court to carry out alone an act that needed the other’s consent, where the refusal puts the shared interest at risk, and an act done under that authorization binds the holdout. The Cour de cassation polices this tool strictly. In a case where co-owners had obtained a non-adversarial court order to sue a tenant and expel them, the Third Civil Chamber quashed the appeal ruling with this reasoning: “alors que l’autorisation d’agir ne pouvait résulter d’une ordonnance sur requête et sans rechercher si le refus de Mme Marie-Line Y… de s’associer à l’action entreprise par les consorts X… mettait en péril l’intérêt commun de l’indivision, la cour d’appel n’a pas donné de base légale à sa décision” (Cass., 3rd Civ., Nov. 28, 2012, appeal No. 11-19.585). Two lessons for your file: the authorization must come from a proper adversarial proceeding, not a one-sided request, and your lawyer must prove with evidence that the refusal genuinely threatens the shared property, for example a roof about to collapse, an insurer threatening to cancel coverage on an empty house, or a buyer walking away. Judges do not authorize solo acts as a punishment for being difficult.

For genuine emergencies there is a faster door. Article 815-6 of the Civil Code lets the president of the judicial court order or authorize any urgent measure the common interest requires: authorizing a co-owner to collect money owed to the co-ownership to meet urgent needs, appointing one co-owner as administrator with security if needed, or naming a sequestrator. If the house is flooding, squatted, or about to lose its insurance, this is the provision your lawyer invokes, and it does not require waiting for the full partition trial.

Now the free-riding occupant. French law lets each co-owner use the shared property consistently with its purpose and with the rights of the others, and the president of the court settles provisional use when they disagree. But the occupant pays for exclusivity. Article 815-9 of the Civil Code provides that a co-owner who privately uses and enjoys the undivided property owes an indemnité, an occupancy payment, unless the family agreed otherwise. Your sister can live in the house during the partition, but she owes the co-ownership a monthly indemnity, typically set near rental value, and your share of that indemnity is credited to you in the final accounts. Relatedly, rents and harvests of the shared property accrue to the co-ownership unless the family agreed on divided use, each co-owner takes profits and bears losses in proportion to their rights, and the same article 815-10 scheme adds that no claim about fruits and revenues is admissible more than five years after the date they were or could have been collected. So you can recover your cut of hidden rents, but the meter has a five-year limit running from when each rent was or could have been collected, which is one more reason not to let silence drag on for years.

Finally, the heir who simply vanishes. Article 836 covers the co-owner who is presumed absent, far away, or under legal protection, with cross-references to the guardianship regimes. Article 837 covers the one who is merely defaulting, unresponsive without a legal excuse: article 837 lets a co-heir serve a formal extrajudicial demand to be represented at the agreed partition, and where the defaulting heir has appointed no agent within three months of that demand, a co-heir may ask the judge to appoint a qualified person to represent the defaulter through completion of the partition, with that representative able to consent to the partition only with the judge’s authorization. In short, going silent for three months after a bailiff’s demand does not freeze the file. It hands the judge the power to appoint someone who will sign in the silent heir’s place, under supervision.

II. How Will the French Judge Divide or Sell the House, and What Will It Cost Me on Both Sides of the Atlantic?

A. Will the Court Hand the House to One of Us or Send It to Auction?

Once the court opens judicial partition operations, the appointed notaire draws up the accounts, values the assets, composes the lots, and proposes who gets what, with cash equalization where needed. The court’s strong preference is to divide in kind or to allot, not to auction. Allotment with a soulte is the everyday solution: your sister receives the house in her lot and pays you a soulte equal to your share of its appraised value, or the house goes to you and you pay her. The judge can also grant a preferential allotment, the attribution préférentielle, in the situations the Code lists. Article 831 of the Civil Code allows a surviving spouse or any co-owner heir to request preferential allotment, against soulte if needed, of a family business they actually work or worked in, and article 833 extends those provisions to statutory heirs whether they own in full or bare ownership, as well as to universal testamentary heirs except for one farm-specific rule. For an ordinary Paris apartment or vacation house with no business attached, the mechanism that matters most is the simple one: lots plus soulte, so the sibling who keeps the roof compensates the sibling who gives up their bricks.

Auction, called licitation, is the fallback, and the courts treat it as one. The procedural rule sits in article 1377 of the Code of Civil Procedure: “Le tribunal ordonne, dans les conditions qu’il détermine, la vente par adjudication des biens qui ne peuvent être facilement partagés ou attribués.” The court orders sale by auction, on terms it sets, only for property that cannot be easily shared or allotted. A single house owned by two siblings who both want cash is the textbook example, because you cannot cut a house in half. A large estate with several apartments that can be grouped into equal lots points the other way.

The Cour de cassation enforces that hierarchy firmly, and a February 2025 ruling is the reference your lawyer will cite. After a creditor had co-owners summoned for partition and auction of several jointly owned buildings, the appeal court ordered licitation essentially because the co-owners disagreed on how to proceed. The First Civil Chamber quashed that part of the ruling, holding: “Il résulte de ce texte que la licitation des immeubles indivis ne doit être ordonnée que s’ils ne peuvent être facilement partagés en nature.” It added: “En se déterminant ainsi, sans rechercher, comme il lui incombait, si les biens indivis étaient ou non commodément partageables en nature, la cour d’appel n’a pas donné de base légale à sa décision.” (Cass., 1st Civ., Feb. 5, 2025, appeal No. B 21-15.932, decision No. 87 F-B). Disagreement alone does not justify an auction. The judge must investigate, and say on the record, whether the buildings could conveniently be divided in kind. For your file this cuts both ways. If your sister demands the auction be skipped and claims the house can be shared, she must show a workable in-kind division. If you want the auction because no allotment is realistic, your lawyer shows the appraisal, the single-dwelling layout, and the failed buyout attempts, so the judge can lawfully find the house not conveniently divisible.

When licitation is ordered, the judgment sets a starting price, the mise à prix, based on the appraisal, and the sale follows the judicial auction process for real estate, with advertising and bidding at the court. Anyone can bid, including either sibling, which means your sister can buy out your share at auction if she finds financing, and you can bid through your lawyer if you want the house. The price is then divided according to each heir’s rights after the debts, charges, occupancy indemnities, and equalization accounts are settled. One more brake exists: article 820 of the Civil Code lets the court, at a co-owner’s request, stay the partition for up to two years where an immediate partition risks harming the value of the undivided property or where a co-owner needs that time to take over a family business dependent on the succession. A two-year stay is the exception, it must be justified by value or by a business takeover, and it delays rather than cancels the partition. And nothing forces the family to stay in court to the bitter end: article 842 lets the co-heirs abandon the judicial track at any moment and finish by agreement where the conditions for an agreed partition are met. Many American files settle exactly there, once the appraisal and the draft auction terms focus everyone’s mind.

B. What French Tax, Notaire Bill, and US Reporting Follow the Split?

The partition itself is taxed, even before anyone talks about capital gains. Article 746 of the General Tax Code provides: “Les partages de biens meubles et immeubles entre copropriétaires, cohéritiers et coassociés, à quelque titre que ce soit, pourvu qu’il en soit justifié, sont assujettis à un droit d’enregistrement ou à une taxe de publicité foncière de 2,50 %.” In current practice the partition duty on successions stands at 2.5 percent of the net partitioned value, with the reduced 1.1 percent rate reserved for partitions following divorce, separation, or PACS breakup, which does not cover siblings dividing an inheritance. Budget the 2.5 percent on the net assets plus the notaire’s fees for the partition deed, the land-registry publication tax, and, where the partition was judicial, the lawyer’s fees and auction costs. A detailed walkthrough of how a French succession notaire builds and prices the bill, with a worked example on a house, is set out in our guide to what the notaire charges an American heir and how to check the bill, which you should read before approving any fee quote.

Where the partition sends the house to auction, or where one sibling sells their allotted share to a third party, capital gains enter the picture. French tax on real estate gains sits in article 150 U of the General Tax Code, which makes gains on the sale for consideration of built or unbuilt buildings, or rights in them, subject to income tax under the mechanisms of articles 150 V to 150 VH. The taxable gain is broadly the sale price minus the acquisition value, and for an inherited house the acquisition value is normally the value declared in the succession, so keeping the succession valuation file matters enormously. French law then applies its own relief schedule, durations, and surtaxes, and nonresident sellers face a French withholding collected through the notaire. The full mechanics, with the American foreign tax credit on the other side, are covered in our guide to selling a French second home as an American. Read it before accepting any buyer deadline, because the French tax is computed and paid through the notaire at closing, long before your American return is filed.

The American side follows two separate tracks: income tax and information returns. The United States taxes its citizens and residents on worldwide income, so the French sale proceeds, rents collected during the co-ownership, and any interest earned while funds sit in a French account all go on the American return. The France-United States income tax treaty then decides which country taxes what first and how the other relieves double taxation, usually through a foreign tax credit for income-type taxes paid to France, within American limits and baskets. Keep every French tax receipt, every notaire settlement statement, and every occupancy-indemnity calculation, because the credit is only as good as its paperwork. Where a surviving parent’s spouse also holds rights in the house, the usufruct mechanics change both the French lots and the American characterization, and our guide to the surviving spouse’s usufruct choice explains that overlapping layer.

Information returns are the second American track, and they punish inattention more than they punish tax due. Money landing in a French bank account in your name can trigger French and American account-reporting duties at the same time. France requires residents to declare foreign accounts on form 3916, while Americans file the FBAR and IRS Form 8938 above their respective thresholds and timelines, and an inheritance received from a foreign person can trigger its own bequest information return. Our walkthrough of FBAR, Form 8938, and French form 3916 for Americans lists what to file, what a missed year costs, and how to fix it. Tell your American preparer the moment the partition deed or auction judgment exists, not the following April, so the returns match the French documents from the start.

A final practical note on money and timing. The soulte your sister owes you bears interest from the partition where the deed says so, auction proceeds are distributed only after creditors, charges, and occupation accounts clear, and currency movement between the euro price and your dollar life is real: a three-month auction delay can move your net by thousands of dollars. Many families bridge the gap with a written interim agreement fixing who pays the insurance, the property tax, and the gardener, who may enter the house and when, and what monthly indemnity the occupant pays, all credited in the final accounts. Put that agreement in writing through the lawyers even while the partition case runs. It converts a year of resentment into a line item.

Conclusion

No sibling can hold your French inheritance hostage forever. French law starts from the rule that nobody stays in co-ownership against their will, routes a refused agreement into a court partition before the court of the succession’s opening place, equips the family with two-thirds management, court-authorized solo acts, urgent measures, occupancy payments, and representation for the silent heir, and ends with allotment plus equalization or, only where the property cannot be conveniently divided in kind, auction. The price of freedom is the 2.5 percent partition duty, the notaire’s priced work, any capital gains on a later sale, and disciplined American reporting of the same money. Start with a formal demand and an independent valuation, file where the succession opened if refusal persists, and secure the house, its insurance, and its accounts from day one. The partition will happen. The only open question is whether your family pays for an agreement or for a judgment.

📄 Official circular