KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Tate Brothers’ November Extradition Hearings in Miami: What France Does When Two Countries Claim the Same Person

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Tate Brothers’ November Extradition Hearings in Miami: What France Does When Two Countries Claim the Same Person

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

On 19 and 20 November 2026, a federal court in Miami will hold the final extradition hearings of Andrew and Tristan Tate, whom the United Kingdom wants to try on dozens of charges including rape, assault and facilitating trafficking for sexual exploitation. According to Forbes, which reported the court order on 9 October 2026, Andrew Tate’s hearing is set for 19 November and his brother’s for the following day, both at 10 a.m. EDT, and the judge has refused to consolidate the two cases because of what she called material differences in the allegations against each brother. The men have been held in the Special Housing Unit of the federal detention center in Miami since their arrest on 18 July, after the United Kingdom submitted its formal extradition requests, and a magistrate judge denied them bail in September, calling them quintessential flight risks. Romania, where the brothers also face criminal proceedings for human trafficking, had already agreed in March 2024 to a British extradition request while postponing any handover until its own trials are over. This article does not prejudge any of these cases: every charge described here is an allegation, the brothers deny wrongdoing through their lawyers, and only the courts seized will decide. What follows uses this transatlantic triangle to answer the questions an international reader actually asks a French lawyer: when two countries claim the same person, who gets priority, and once a person is surrendered, what stops a second prosecution for other facts.

I. When two countries claim the same person, who gets priority?

A. How does France rank competing extradition requests?

French law answers the competition question with a ranking rule that every requested person should know. Article 696-5 of the Code of Criminal Procedure provides that where extradition is requested concurrently by several States for a single offence, it is granted by preference according to two criteria: « elle est accordée de préférence à l’Etat contre les intérêts duquel l’infraction était dirigée, ou à celui sur le territoire duquel elle a été commise » (art. 696-5 du code de procédure pénale). The State whose interests were attacked comes first, then the State on whose territory the offence was committed. Where the concurrent requests concern different offences, there is no automatic winner: « il est tenu compte, pour décider de la priorité, de toutes circonstances de fait, et, notamment, de la gravité relative et du lieu des infractions, de la date respective des demandes, de l’engagement qui serait pris par l’un des Etats requérants de procéder à la réextradition » (art. 696-5 du code de procédure pénale). Relative gravity, place, date of each request and any promise of onward surrender all weigh in the balance, and that last criterion, re-extradition, is often decisive: a requesting State that undertakes to hand the person on to the second claimant jumps the queue.

Applied to the Tate configuration, the rule shows why the calendar matters as much as the charges. The United Kingdom moved first in time for the British allegations, with a Bucharest court of appeal approving the British request back in March 2024, as Reuters reported at the time, while postponing surrender until the Romanian proceedings finish. The United States then arrested the brothers in Miami on 18 July 2026 on the British request, and the formal British requests were recorded on the Miami federal docket on 9 September 2026. If France were the requested State in a comparable triangle, the government would weigh exactly the factors of Article 696-5: which State’s interests were attacked, where each set of facts was committed, the respective dates of the requests, and whether London or Bucharest offered to surrender the person onward once its own case was done. No requesting State owns the person by filing first; the ranking is reasoned, and the defence can argue every one of these factors before the investigating chamber.

A second French mechanism often decides these triangles before any ranking: when the requested person is already being prosecuted or has been convicted in France for a different offence, surrender waits. Article 696-7 of the Code of Criminal Procedure states that « la remise n’est effectuée qu’après que la poursuite est terminée, et, en cas de condamnation, après que la peine a été exécutée » (art. 696-7 du code de procédure pénale). The same article allows the person to be sent temporarily to stand trial before the requesting State’s courts, on the express condition that they are returned as soon as the foreign court has ruled. Romania used the same logic in substance when it approved the British request while keeping the brothers for its own trials first. For a defence team in Paris, this deferral is a concrete lever: a pending French prosecution for distinct facts suspends any handover, and even a temporary surrender comes back, by law, with a return ticket.

The threshold question comes even earlier, and it is purely Franco-French: no extradition without dual criminality. Article 696-3 of the Code of Criminal Procedure lists the offences that can ground extradition, all crimes under the requesting State’s law and correctional offences carrying at least two years’ imprisonment, or, for convicted persons, a sentence of at least two months, and then adds the lock: « En aucun cas l’extradition n’est accordée par le gouvernement français si le fait n’est pas puni par la loi française d’une peine criminelle ou correctionnelle » (art. 696-3 du code de procédure pénale). Attempt and complicity follow the same test in both laws. Sexual violence, trafficking and assault as described in the British and American filings plainly have French criminal equivalents, so this lock would not save the Tates in a French courtroom, but in cases built on purely foreign regulatory offences or on speech criminalised only abroad, dual criminality remains the first wall. Readers facing a parallel American mega-prosecution file will find the same comparative method applied to conspiracy and fraud charges in our analysis of what France would do with an extradition file like Kim Dotcom’s.

B. Can the requested person force their home country to take the case instead?

Inside the European Union, the requested person has a card that does not exist in Miami: their State of nationality can claim them first. The Court of Justice held on 6 September 2016 in Petruhhin, case C-182/15, that when a Member State receives an extradition request from a third State concerning an EU citizen who is a national of another Member State, it must inform that home State and, if the home State asks, surrender the citizen to it under the European Arrest Warrant, provided the home State can prosecute extraterritorial facts. The French Court of Cassation applies this weekly. On 11 October 2022, ruling on an American extradition request targeting a Luxembourg national arrested in France on a New York judge’s warrant for wire-fraud and money-laundering conspiracy, the criminal chamber recalled the Petruhhin information duty word for word before checking whether Luxembourg had been given its chance (Cass. crim., 11 oct. 2022, n° 22-80.654). Luxembourg answered that it did not intend to take over the American prosecution and would send no European Arrest Warrant to France, and only then could the French court proceed with the American request. The lesson for any EU citizen sought by a third State while in France is practical: instruct counsel in your home State immediately, because a home-State arrest warrant plus a credible will to prosecute can displace the third-State request entirely.

The duty to inform is not a courtesy email; it is an adversarial obligation the defence can police. On 3 September 2025, the criminal chamber quashed a Bordeaux investigating chamber’s favourable opinion in a Swiss extradition case concerning a Portuguese national, because the file never showed that Portugal had received the full case, and the chamber had relied on a letter from the suspect’s own Portuguese lawyer instead of a State-to-State transmission (Cass. crim., 3 sept. 2025, n° 24-86.757). The Court restated the rule in operational terms the defence can plead: the requested State must send the home State not only the existence of the request but the whole file received from the third State, law and facts alike, so that the home State can decide whether to claim its national (Cass. crim., 3 sept. 2025, n° 24-86.757). Everything the requesting State sent, law and facts alike, must travel to the home State, and under the 17 December 2020 By judgment, case C-398/19, the requested State must also report any later change in the person’s situation relevant to a possible home-State warrant. If the home State, duly informed, stays silent for a reasonable time, surrender to the third State may proceed, but silence must be real and documented, not assumed. The contrast with Miami is stark: the Tates’ lawyers fight detention and treaty interpretation before an American judge, with the final word belonging to the State Department, whereas in Paris an EU national’s lawyers would first mobilise the nationality State, with the case file itself as their weapon.

France’s own nationality shield is even stronger, and it is absolute. Article 696-4 of the Code of Criminal Procedure opens its list of refusal grounds with nationality: « Lorsque la personne réclamée a la nationalité française, cette dernière étant appréciée à l’époque de l’infraction pour laquelle l’extradition est requise » (art. 696-4 du code de procédure pénale). France never extradites its own nationals to third States, full stop, and assesses nationality at the time of the facts. Had the Tate brothers been French nationals arrested at Roissy instead of American citizens arrested at Miami airport, no British or Romanian request could have removed them from French soil; France would either prosecute them itself or surrender them only within the European Arrest Warrant system under the guarantee-of-return mechanism. That is the mirror image of the American configuration, where citizenship offers no equivalent shield and the Secretary of State signs the final order. Anyone arrested in Paris on a foreign warrant should therefore make nationality the very first check, before specialty, before bars, before procedure, as explained in our guide to surrender under a European Arrest Warrant when France is asked to hand someone over.

II. Once surrendered, what stops a second prosecution for other facts?

A. What does the specialty rule actually forbid after surrender?

Specialty is the promise that extradition buys only the case it names. Article 696-6 of the Code of Criminal Procedure states it without nuance: « l’extradition n’est accordée qu’à la condition que la personne extradée ne sera ni poursuivie, ni condamnée pour une infraction autre que celle ayant motivé l’extradition et antérieure à la remise » (art. 696-6 du code de procédure pénale). A surrendered person may be tried and sentenced for the facts that justified surrender, and for later facts, but not for other earlier facts the requesting State kept in its pocket. The person is told so at the very start: within two days of arrest, the prosecutor general must notify the person of the file, of the simplified-consent option and of the right to waive specialty, with nullity as the sanction for silence. In the Tate triangle this matters twice: Romania postponed rather than abandoned, and the British charges grew from 21 to more than three dozen while the men sat in Miami, so each requesting State’s exact perimeter, warrant by warrant, will decide what later prosecutions remain open.

The French courts enforce specialty even against a second requesting State, as a 2 December 2020 decision shows. A man handed by Belgium to France under a European Arrest Warrant was then claimed by Morocco; the Douai investigating chamber gave an unfavourable opinion, and the Court of Cassation upheld it, recalling that « lorsque le ministère public qui a délivré un mandat d’arrêt européen a obtenu la remise de la personne recherchée, celle-ci ne peut être extradée vers un Etat non membre de l’Union européenne sans le consentement de l’autorité compétente de l’Etat membre qui l’a remise » (Cass. crim., 2 déc. 2020, n° 19-87.428). The Belgian file contained no consent, only a letter in which the Belgian ministry said it wanted the French chamber to rule first, which is not a consent. Onward extradition after a European surrender therefore needs the first executing State’s green light, and the same logic runs through Article 695-21 of the Code of Criminal Procedure for onward surrender between Member States (art. 695-21 du code de procédure pénale). Transposed to our triangle: if Romania one day surrendered the brothers to the United Kingdom under a European instrument, London could not simply pass them on to a third State for earlier facts without the executing State’s consent, and any American follow-on case for pre-surrender conduct would have to cross that wall.

Europe’s newest word on specialty narrows the defence’s hopes, and honesty requires saying so. On 23 April 2026, in case C-528/24 Boothnesse, the Court of Justice held, on a reference from the Irish Supreme Court about three fraud defendants sought by the United Kingdom, that a possible future breach of specialty by the issuing State does not in itself entitle the executing judge to refuse surrender. As the eucrim report of the judgment summarises it, a merely possible future breach of specialty by the issuing State does not in itself entitle the executing judge to refuse surrender. The Irish objection had been that the British warrant, drawn for fraud, could not cover a six-month contempt-of-court imprisonment imposed for breaching restraint orders, which London classified as civil rather than criminal. The Court answered that the term offence needs an autonomous, Bonda-style assessment, and that guarantees can cure a real risk, but a hypothetical breach is not a refusal ground. The practical consequence is a shift of battle: the fight moves from blocking surrender to policing, after surrender, what the issuing State actually prosecutes, with waiver, consent and re-extradition requests as the tools. France’s Article 696-8 channels every request through diplomatic transmission with the judgment or warrant, the precise facts and their date, and the applicable legal texts (art. 696-8 du code de procédure pénale), so the perimeter is written down, and written perimeters can be enforced later.

B. When must France refuse to hand anyone over, whatever the requesting State?

Some bars are absolute, and the defence should plead them first because they end the case. Article 696-4 lists eight, and three dominate international files. Nationality, already seen, is one. Political character is another: extradition is refused where the offence is political or the request pursues a political purpose, a ground the Tates’ American lawyer is already testing in the press by calling the case political kidnapping and comparing it to a witch hunt, labels a French chamber would examine against the file, not the cameras. A third is the fair-trial tribunal: « Lorsque la personne réclamée serait jugée dans l’Etat requérant par un tribunal n’assurant pas les garanties fondamentales de procédure et de protection des droits de la défense » (art. 696-4 du code de procédure pénale). Add territoriality, final French judgment, time-bars under either law, penalties contrary to French public order, and military offences, and the chamber has a full checklist before it ever reaches the merits. Our analysis of the Versailles opinion procedure before any surrender decree walks through how each ground is argued in the Paris region.

The human-rights bar has teeth of its own, and a January 2021 cassation proves it. The Chambéry investigating chamber had approved surrender to Albania of a man holding subsidiary protection granted precisely because of a proven risk of torture or inhuman treatment; the Court of Cassation quashed without remand, holding that « la chambre de l’instruction qui constate que la personne réclamée encourt, en cas d’extradition vers son pays d’origine, le risque d’être soumise à un traitement inhumain et dégradant, doit donner un avis défavorable » and that such a risk is established while subsidiary protection lasts (Cass. crim., 13 janv. 2021, n° 20-81.359). Protection status plus Article 3 of the European Convention equals a mandatory unfavourable opinion. The United Kingdom and Romania are Convention States with functioning courts, so this bar would rarely bite in a London-bound file, but it bites hard on requests from States with documented torture practices, and the defence must file the protection decision and country evidence early, because the chamber must seek the risk itself once alerted and cannot look away.

Procedure, finally, is where extraditions are won and lost in Paris, and the 9 September 2026 criminal chamber decision is the freshest reminder. Turkish authorities had issued a red notice, the Limoges prosecutor placed the man under extradition detention, then released him when the international warrant and formal request did not arrive in time; re-arrested months later in the Versailles jurisdiction after Turkey’s formal request, he argued Limoges remained seized. The Court of Cassation disagreed, recalling that « la mise en liberté de la personne visée par la demande d’arrestation provisoire ne s’oppose pas à une nouvelle arrestation et à son extradition si la demande d’extradition parvient ultérieurement » and that « le procureur général compétent est celui du lieu d’arrestation de l’intéressé » (Cass. crim., 9 sept. 2026, n° 25-88.255). Release for want of papers ends that round but never the match, and each new arrest restarts the case where the person stands. The parallels with Miami are instructive: bail denied there, release ordered in Limoges here, opposite interim outcomes under opposite systems, yet the same structural truth that provisional detention is only the antechamber. In France the antechamber has clocks: appearance before the investigating chamber within ten working days of presentation to the prosecutor where consent is refused, a reasoned opinion within one month, and, where the opinion is definitively unfavourable, no extradition at all, with immediate release if no other detention ground exists (art. 696-15 du code de procédure pénale; art. 696-17 du code de procédure pénale). Anyone in extradition detention must be brought within forty-eight hours before the territorially competent prosecutor general, informed in a language they understand, with a lawyer, on pain of nullity (art. 696-10 du code de procédure pénale).

If the opinion is favourable, the file leaves the judges for the government: surrender is authorised by decree of the Prime Minister on the Justice Minister’s report, and if the requesting State’s agents have not collected the person within one month of notification, the person is released as of right except in force majeure and can never be claimed again for the same cause; the action against the decree must, on pain of foreclosure, be brought within one month, and a prior informal appeal does not stop that clock (art. 696-18 du code de procédure pénale). Release can be requested at any time from the investigating chamber, which rules within twenty days, or fifteen where the request came within forty-eight hours of detention. These are the levers a Paris defence team pulls while the Miami hearings run their course across the Atlantic: check nationality first, force the home State into the triangle second, lock the specialty perimeter third, plead the absolute bars fourth, and count every procedural day, because in extradition, as the Limoges-Versailles relay of September 2026 shows, a missed paper or a wrong courthouse can restart, or end, the whole case.

Conclusion

The Miami hearings of 19 and 20 November will decide, under American law and with the State Department’s final word, whether Andrew and Tristan Tate are sent to Britain to answer charges they deny. Nothing in this article predicts that outcome. What the French lens adds is a method that travels: rank concurrent requests by the interests attacked, the place of the facts, their dates and any promise of onward surrender; invite the nationality State into the triangle before it closes; write down the specialty perimeter and enforce it against the next requesting State; plead nationality, political purpose, unfair tribunal and inhuman-treatment risk as absolute bars; and audit the procedure paper by paper, from the forty-eight-hour presentation to the one-month decree challenge. Two courts, two fugitives, three jurisdictions: the triangle will close somewhere, and the side that mastered these five moves will be ready wherever it closes.

📄 Official circular