You are an American married couple and you just bought a stone house in the Dordogne, or an apartment in Paris you plan to keep for decades. The notaire hands you the keys, and one question keeps surfacing on the flight home: if one of us dies first, does the survivor keep the house, and what does France take in tax? The answer surprises most Americans. French law already hands the surviving spouse a protected package with no will at all: a choice between full use of every asset or outright ownership of a quarter of them, a free year in the family home, a possible life interest in that home, and a complete exemption from French death tax. A single extra document signed during your lifetime, the gift between spouses known as the donation au dernier vivant, can widen that package to everything in use or three quarters in use plus one quarter owned outright. And if you hold American citizenship, your will can designate American law to govern the whole succession. This guide walks through each layer in that order, with the exact statutes, two recent and older Court of Cassation rulings that set hard deadlines, the Franco-American death-tax treaty articles that decide which country taxes the house, and a worked tax computation, so the surviving spouse is protected before grief makes paperwork unbearable.
I. What French law hands your spouse automatically, with no will at all
A. A share of the estate, a free year in the house, and zero French death tax
Start with the share. When the first spouse dies leaving children, the survivor does not split everything fifty-fifty with them. Article 757 of the Civil Code gives the surviving spouse a personal choice: “le conjoint survivant recueille, à son choix, l’usufruit de la totalité des biens existants ou la propriété du quart des biens” (C. civ., art. 757). Usufruit, the French life interest, means the right to live in the house or collect its rent for life while the children hold only the bare ownership underneath. Most American widows and widowers with young children pick the total usufruit, because it keeps them in the home and preserves the income, and most with grown, financially settled children pick the outright quarter, because it gives them capital they can sell or spend freely. Where there are no children but the deceased leaves a father or mother, the survivor takes half outright and the parents split the other half; where neither children nor parents survive, the spouse takes everything. That statutory share vests by operation of law on the day of death, before any will is read, and it applies to the French house whoever paid for it, because France taxes and transmits the property, not the money trail behind it.
The second automatic gift is time in the home. If the surviving spouse was actually living in the house as the main home when death occurred, article 763 of the Civil Code provides that “il a de plein droit, pendant une année, la jouissance gratuite de ce logement, ainsi que du mobilier” (C. civ., art. 763). One full year, rent-free, furniture included, as a direct effect of the marriage itself, and the statute closes with a sentence that matters enormously in blended families: “Le présent article est d’ordre public.” No will, no family vote, and no demand from the children can shorten that year, and where the home was rented rather than owned, the estate must reimburse a year of rent as it falls due. For an American widow who needs months to arrange a move, sell, or decide whether to keep the house, that year is breathing room the children cannot bill her for.
The third automatic gift is fiscal, and it is total. “Sont exonérés de droits de mutation par décès le conjoint survivant et le partenaire lié au défunt par un pacte civil de solidarité.” (CGI, art. 796-0 bis). The surviving spouse pays zero French death tax on whatever passes from the deceased, whatever the amount. An American husband who inherits his wife’s half of a 900,000-euro Paris apartment owes France nothing on that transfer, and the partner bound by a PACS enjoys the same exemption. Note the boundary: the exemption wipes out the tax, it does not enlarge the share. A PACS partner pays no tax on what the will gives, but without a will the partner inherits nothing, because the statutory share of article 757 belongs to the époux, the married spouse, alone. Marriage remains the only status that delivers both the share and the exemption automatically. Readers weighing marriage against a PACS for French purposes will find the broader marriage mechanics in the companion guide on marriage, citizenship, and divorce for Americans in France.
What the children receive, and what France takes from them, follows a separate arithmetic the survivor should understand, because it prices every planning choice below. Each child deducts 100,000 euros from his or her share before any rate applies: “il est effectué un abattement de 100 000 € sur la part de chacun des ascendants et sur la part de chacun des enfants vivants ou représentés par suite de prédécès ou de renonciation” (CGI, art. 779). Above the allowance, the progressive direct-line scale of article 777 climbs from 5 percent to 45 percent, with 60 percent reserved for non-relatives: “Entre parents au-delà du 4e degré et entre personnes non-parentes 60” (CGI, art. 777). Take a concrete American family: two children inherit their mother’s half of an 800,000-euro house, so 400,000 euros each, plus 50,000 euros each from a bank account, for 450,000 euros per child. After the 100,000-euro allowance, 350,000 euros remain taxable, producing roughly 68,000 euros of French death tax per child at the direct-line rates. The surviving spouse, who takes the usufruit of everything under article 757, owes nothing. And where the usufruit itself must be valued, for instance to split duties between a surviving spouse and children who sell, article 669 of the Tax Code fixes the price by age: “la valeur de la nue-propriété et de l’usufruit est déterminée par une quotité de la valeur de la propriété entière” (CGI, art. 669), so that a 65-year-old widow’s life interest counts for 40 percent of full ownership and the children’s bare ownership for 60 percent.
Two cross-border rules frame all of this for Americans. First, France taxes the house because it sits in France, wherever the deceased lived: the territoriality article reaches “Les biens meubles et immeubles, que ces derniers soient possédés directement ou indirectement, situés en France” (CGI, art. 750 ter). Second, the 1978 Franco-American estate-tax treaty gives France the primary right to tax French-situs real estate under its article on immovable property, and its credit article then requires France to subtract the American tax paid on the same transfer, so the same value is not taxed twice (1978 France-United States estate and gift tax treaty, arts. 5 and 12). The filing clock runs fast: “De six mois, à compter du jour du décès, lorsque celui dont on recueille la succession est décédé en France métropolitaine” and “D’une année, dans tous les autres cas” (CGI, art. 641). An American heir who misses the six-month or twelve-month return faces late interest and penalties before the file is even examined, which is why the notaire opens the succession within weeks. The full treaty-credit mechanics, with American-side filing, are detailed in the companion guide on French death taxes and the 1978 treaty credit for American heirs.
B. A life interest in the family home that only an authentic will can remove
Beyond the free year, the surviving spouse who lived in the home can hold it for life. Article 764 of the Civil Code provides that the qualifying spouse “a sur ce logement, jusqu’à son décès, un droit d’habitation et un droit d’usage sur le mobilier” (C. civ., art. 764). This is not ownership and not the article 757 usufruit: it is a personal right to live in the house until death, with use of the furniture, which cannot be sold or seized by the spouse’s creditors in the way an usufruit share could be leveraged. It stacks on top of the statutory share rather than replacing it, so a widow can hold both the usufruit of the whole estate and the life occupancy of the house, and the children who own the bare walls underneath cannot force a sale while she lives. Where the marriage was unhappy or the house was promised elsewhere, the deceased can block this right in advance, but the bar is deliberately high, and that bar is where Americans must pay attention before writing anything down.
The two Court of Cassation rulings every blended American family should know both concern this life interest, and both punish informality. First, the right must be claimed within a strict year. On March 2, 2022, the First Civil Chamber restated the rule without ambiguity: “le conjoint survivant dispose d’un an à partir du décès pour manifester sa volonté de bénéficier de son droit viager au logement.” (Cass. 1re civ., 2 Mar. 2022, no. 20-16.674). In that case a widow who had simply stayed in the house argued that remaining in the rooms was itself the claim. The Court quashed the appeal ruling and held that while the expression of intent “peut être tacite, elle ne peut résulter du seul maintien dans les lieux.” Staying put is not claiming. A letter to the notaire, a declaration in the succession file, or conclusions filed in court within the year will do; silence plus occupancy will not. An American survivor who assumes the house is simply hers because she never left can discover, thirteen months after the funeral, that the life interest has lapsed and the children can partition. Calendar the anniversary of death the way you calendar a tax deadline, and put the claim in writing through the notaire within the first months.
Second, a handwritten American-style will cannot strip the life interest away. On December 15, 2010, the same chamber held that “le conjoint survivant ne peut être privé du droit d’habitation du logement servant d’habitation principale et d’usage du mobilier le garnissant que par la volonté du défunt exprimée dans un testament authentique reçu par deux notaires ou par un notaire assisté de deux témoins” (Cass. 1re civ., 15 Dec. 2010, no. 09-68.076). Read that twice if your estate plan was drafted in California or New York. A typed, witnessed, or holographic document that validly distributes an American portfolio does not meet the French form for this one purpose: only the solemn authentic will, dictated to two notaires or to one notaire with two witnesses, counts, because “Le testament par acte public est reçu par deux notaires ou par un notaire assisté de deux témoins” (C. civ., art. 971). A father who wants his French house to go to children of a first marriage free of any occupancy should therefore execute that authentic will at a French notaire’s office rather than adding a paragraph to his American living trust.
Two practical corollaries close the picture. The life interest is flexible in old age: where the house no longer fits the survivor’s needs, the statute lets the spouse rent it out for non-commercial use to fund new housing, and the heirs can demand an inventory of furniture and a condition report of the property so everyone’s rights are documented. And the one-year free use of article 763, being a matter of public policy, survives even a valid deprivation of the life interest: the children can defeat the decades-long occupancy with an authentic will, but they cannot bill the widow for the first twelve months. For Americans, the operational lesson is one sentence long. Within weeks of death, tell the notaire in writing that the survivor claims both the article 763 year and the article 764 life interest; within the year, confirm the claim; and if the deceased wanted the opposite, check today whether an authentic will in the article 971 form exists, because anything less leaves the life interest intact.
II. What you can add during your lifetime: the gift between spouses and the choice of American law
A. The donation au dernier vivant: three ways to enlarge the survivor’s share
The statutory share of article 757 is a floor, not a ceiling. While both spouses are alive, either can sign a donation entre époux, commonly called the donation au dernier vivant, that takes effect at the first death and pushes the survivor’s portion above the default. Article 1094-1 of the Civil Code offers exactly three upgrades to choose from: the donor “pourra disposer en faveur de l’autre époux, soit de la propriété de ce dont il pourrait disposer en faveur d’un étranger, soit d’un quart de ses biens en propriété et des trois autres quarts en usufruit, soit encore de la totalité de ses biens en usufruit seulement” (C. civ., art. 1094-1). In plain terms, the survivor can receive the largest share a stranger could receive, or one quarter owned outright plus the life interest in the remaining three quarters, or the life interest in absolutely everything. The second formula is the workhorse of French-American planning: the widow owns a quarter she can sell tomorrow and controls the other three quarters for life, while the children’s forced shares attach only to what remains beneath her rights. Ask the notaire handling your purchase or your succession file to prepare the deed, because the choice among the three formulas is made once in the document and exercised by the survivor at the first death, and the wrong formula for your family map can lock the survivor into capital she cannot touch or income she does not need.
The same article hides a flexibility clause Americans love once they understand it. “Sauf stipulation contraire du disposant, le conjoint survivant peut cantonner son émolument sur une partie des biens dont il a été disposé en sa faveur.” (C. civ., art. 1094-1). Cantonnement means the survivor can accept the gift on only some assets and let the rest fall back into the ordinary succession. A 70-year-old widow who was given the usufruit of everything can keep the life interest in the Paris apartment she occupies and release the Dordogne rental house to the children outright, so they can sell it immediately without her signature on the deed and without pricing her usufruit under the article 669 scale. The statute adds that “Cette limitation ne peut être considérée comme une libéralité faite aux autres successibles” (C. civ., art. 1094-1), so the tax office cannot recharacterize her restraint as a taxable gift to the children. Used well, cantonnement turns a rigid deed signed twenty years earlier into a bespoke settlement negotiated after death, with the notaire computing each variant in euros before the survivor elects.
Two warnings keep the gift inside its legal rails. First, a gift of future property between spouses during the marriage is fragile by design: “La donation de biens à venir faite entre époux pendant le mariage est toujours révocable.” (C. civ., art. 1096). Either spouse can revoke it silently at any time before death, and divorce or a new contradictory will can undo it, so the protection lasts exactly as long as the marriage’s intent lasts; review the deed after every separation scare, every divorce filing, and every remarriage. Second, no gift between spouses can erase the children’s forced shares. “La réserve héréditaire est la part des biens et droits successoraux dont la loi assure la dévolution libre de charges à certains héritiers dits réservataires, s’ils sont appelés à la succession et s’ils l’acceptent.” (C. civ., art. 912), and the disposable portion is brutally quantified: “Les libéralités, soit par actes entre vifs, soit par testament, ne pourront excéder la moitié des biens du disposant, s’il ne laisse à son décès qu’un enfant ; le tiers, s’il laisse deux enfants ; le quart, s’il en laisse trois ou un plus grand nombre.” (C. civ., art. 913). With three children, everything above one quarter of the estate reserved for free disposal can be clawed back by reduction, gift included. Where the children grew up under a foreign law with no forced heirship at all, French law since 2021 even lets them reach into French-situs assets to top up their French shares: “chaque enfant ou ses héritiers ou ses ayants cause peuvent effectuer un prélèvement compensatoire sur les biens existants situés en France au jour du décès, de façon à être rétablis dans les droits réservataires que leur octroie la loi française, dans la limite de ceux-ci.” That compensatory levy is the reason an American will that leaves everything to the spouse, valid under Texas or Florida law, can still be partially unwound against the French house. The full mechanics of disinheritance attempts, the European choice-of-law clause, and the levy are mapped in the companion guide on forced heirship, the choice of American law, and the 2021 compensatory levy.
B. Choosing American law in your will, and where France still says no
Citizenship opens a door most Americans do not know exists. Under the European Succession Regulation, which France applies to every cross-border succession opened on its territory, EU rules let a person choose the law of the country of nationality to govern the whole inheritance, whether or not that country is in the EU (Your Europe, EU official portal, planning a cross-border inheritance). An American citizen can therefore write into a will that American law governs the whole succession, including the French house, instead of the default law of habitual residence. The portal adds that the choice should be expressed explicitly and clearly in a will or a separate declaration, and naming the State whose law you mean, Texas, New York, California, avoids the threshold fight over which of the fifty American laws applies. For couples who married and lived under American expectations of testamentary freedom, this professio juris clause is the single highest-value sentence a French notaire can add to the file, and it costs nothing to insert while both spouses are alive and competent.
But the choice has documented limits, and this is where American optimism must yield to French statute. First, the compensatory levy of article 913 quoted above applies by its own terms whenever the applicable foreign law “ne permet aucun mécanisme réservataire protecteur des enfants” (C. civ., art. 913), and it attaches to the assets physically located in France, which is precisely the house: choosing Texan freedom does not move the bricks out of France. Second, the treaty and tax analysis does not move with the chosen law either. France still taxes the French-situs house under article 750 ter and treaty article 5, still grants the article 12 credit against American tax, and still exempts the surviving spouse under article 796-0 bis, because those are tax rules, not succession rules, and a choice of succession law changes none of them. Third, form still matters in France for the acts the choice travels in. A choice of American law buried in a document that France does not recognize as a valid will fails with the document, and as the 2010 ruling showed, specific French protections like the article 764 life interest demand the authentic form of article 971 regardless of what the chosen law would allow. The safe architecture is therefore layered: an American will (or living trust for American assets) carrying the article 22 choice of a named State’s law, plus a French holographic or authentic will covering the French house consistently, plus the donation au dernier vivant for the spouse, all three reading the same way. Where no French will can be found at all, the search procedure through the national wills file is explained in the companion guide on finding, proving, and claiming under a missing French will.
Conclusion
An American who owns a house in France and wants the spouse protected should sequence four moves while both partners are alive. Confirm the marriage delivers the article 757 choice, the article 763 free year, the article 764 life interest, and the article 796-0 bis tax exemption, and put the article 764 claim procedure on the survivor’s written instructions. Sign a donation au dernier vivant with the formula that fits the family’s ages and assets, remembering it stays revocable and stays capped by the children’s réserve. Insert an express article 22 choice of a named American State’s law for the whole succession, accept that the article 913 compensatory levy can still reach the French bricks, and keep the French and American wills consistent. File the succession return within the article 641 six-month or twelve-month window and claim the treaty article 12 credit on both sides. Done in that order, the French house shelters the survivor for life and costs the spouse nothing in French death tax; done out of order, the life interest lapses unclaimed, the gift exceeds the disposable portion, or the house passes under a law nobody chose.