KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
France Confirms World’s First Shamonda Death: Can British, Irish and American Visitors Cancel, Get Refunded or Get Care?

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

France Confirms World’s First Shamonda Death: Can British, Irish and American Visitors Cancel, Get Refunded or Get Care?

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

On 22 October 2026, France announced the first human infection with Shamonda virus ever recorded in the world: a severely immunocompromised patient in his sixties, hospitalised in Lyon for an unrelated serious disease, who died in early October. The French health authorities said they saw no risk to the general population at this stage, the World Health Organization described an isolated human case unlikely to lead to wider spread at this time, and the European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control said it was carefully monitoring the situation. No travel ban, no border closure and no quarantine order for travellers has been announced. This article is written for British, Irish, American and other foreign visitors who already hold bookings for France or fall ill during a stay: it explains when a package trip can be cancelled free of charge under French law, what happens to separate flights and hotel bookings, how travel insurance epidemic clauses are judged by the Cour de cassation, how to get medical care in France with a European Health Insurance Card, a UK Global Health Insurance Card or private insurance, and which public powers could be activated if the health picture changed.

I. Before departure: cancelling a trip to France and getting your money back

French law treats package holidays very differently from flights or hotel nights booked separately. The distinction decides almost everything: whether you can walk away free of charge, who must refund you, and within what time.

A. Package holidays: the free termination right when extraordinary circumstances strike the destination

A traveller who bought a package within the meaning of French tourism law holds a powerful weapon. Article L. 211-14, II, of the Code du tourisme provides that the traveller has the right to terminate the contract before the start of the trip without paying any termination fee where unavoidable and extraordinary circumstances occurring at the place of destination or in its immediate vicinity significantly affect performance of the package or the carriage of passengers to the destination. The exact wording is worth keeping, because organisers sometimes pretend it says something else: “Le voyageur a le droit de résoudre le contrat avant le début du voyage ou du séjour sans payer de frais de résolution si des circonstances exceptionnelles et inévitables, survenant au lieu de destination ou à proximité immédiate de celui-ci, ont des conséquences importantes sur l’exécution du contrat ou sur le transport des passagers vers le lieu de destination. Dans ce cas, le voyageur a droit au remboursement intégral des paiements effectués mais pas à un dédommagement supplémentaire.” Termination fees that the contract would otherwise impose, which Article L. 211-14, I, allows the seller to claim when the traveller simply changes his mind, fall away entirely once that threshold is met.

Three cumulative conditions therefore decide the dispute: the circumstances must be exceptional and unavoidable, they must occur at the destination or in its immediate vicinity, and they must have significant consequences either for the performance of the package or for carrying passengers to the destination. A virus circulating in French livestock, however worrying the headlines, does not by itself satisfy this test today. The French authorities state that there is no alert and no crisis, the head of the national health directorate told reporters that from a medical and public health point of view there is no alert and no crisis, and the WHO calls this an isolated case. With no restriction on movement, no closure of accommodation or transport, and no warning against travel to France from the British, Irish or American authorities at the date of writing, an organiser asked for a free cancellation can lawfully answer that the contract must run its course or be terminated only against the contractual fees, and a court would likely agree. The assessment can change in days if the authorities order closures, restrict gatherings, or advise against non-essential travel: that is precisely the moment to re-read the provision, because the right then crystallises.

Where the threshold is met, the refund mechanics are strict and favour the traveller. Article R. 211-10 of the same code provides that refunds owed to the traveller must be made without undue delay and in any event no later than fourteen days after termination of the contract: “Ces remboursements au profit du voyageur sont effectués dans les meilleurs délais et en tout état de cause dans les quatorze jours au plus tard après la résolution du contrat.” No compensation on top of the refund is owed in that scenario, but no deduction either. The symmetry matters: the rule also protects the organiser. Article L. 211-14, III, 2, allows the organiser or retailer to terminate the contract and refund the traveller in full, with no additional compensation, where it is prevented from performing because of unavoidable and extraordinary circumstances and notifies the traveller as soon as possible before departure.

The Cour de cassation drew the full consequences of this architecture in a 9 July 2025 judgment that every cross-border traveller file should contain. Ruling on a Mediterranean cruise cancelled in October 2020 after the Covid-19 outbreak, the First Civil Chamber held, in pourvoi no. 24-10.630, that where services are cancelled because of unavoidable and extraordinary circumstances, both the retail travel agency and the trip organiser must refund the sums paid by the traveller: “en cas d’annulation des prestations en raison de circonstances exceptionnelles et inévitables, tant l’agence de voyage que l’organisateur du voyage sont tenus de rembourser la somme versée par le voyageur.” The Court added that a pandemic such as Covid-19 is capable of falling within the notion of extraordinary and unavoidable circumstances under Article 12 of Directive 2015/2302 on package travel, following the approach of the Court of Justice of the European Union in its 8 June 2023 UFC-Que Choisir judgment, which the Cour de cassation expressly relays in this ruling. For a British or Irish reader, the reasoning travels well: a health crisis can qualify, but it is the concrete consequences on the trip or on transport to the destination, not fear alone, that open the free-termination door.

The same judgment settled a question that matters whenever the agency that sold the package and the company that operates it point at each other. The Court held that the retailer which has refunded the traveller can recover from the organiser what the organiser received for services never performed, plus any damages owed to the traveller for late notification of the cancellation, and that this recourse is no longer conditional on proving the organiser’s fault: “en cas d’annulation du voyage en raison de circonstances exceptionnelles et inévitables, l’agence de voyage ayant désintéressé le voyageur peut obtenir de l’organisateur de voyage le remboursement : – des sommes que l’organisateur a reçues au titre de prestations qu’il devait assurer et qui n’ont pas été exécutées ; – le cas échéant, des sommes dues au voyageur à titre de dommages et intérêts en cas de notification tardive de l’annulation par l’organisateur.” In practice, this means a foreign visitor does not have to chase an Italian cruise line, a Spanish hotel group or an insolvent local operator: the French-law seller answers for the whole package. Article L. 211-16, I, of the Code du tourisme states that principle in plain terms, imposing on the professional who sells the package liability as of right for the performance of the services provided for in the contract, whether performed by itself or by other suppliers: “le professionnel qui vend un forfait touristique mentionné au 1° du I de l’article L. 211-1 est responsable de plein droit de l’exécution des services prévus par ce contrat, que ces services soient exécutés par lui-même ou par d’autres prestataires de services de voyage, sans préjudice de son droit de recours contre ceux-ci.” Sue the seller, in France, and let the seller sort out its own suppliers.

Two practical consequences follow for anyone holding a French package booking today. First, do not terminate in a way that waives rights: notify the organiser or retailer in writing, ask expressly whether it maintains the trip, keep every message, and pay nothing presented as a penalty without checking whether the free-termination conditions are met on the day you cancel, not the day you booked. Second, once services start, report any failure promptly, because Article L. 211-16, II, requires the traveller to inform the organiser or retailer of any lack of conformity as soon as possible in the circumstances. A visitor who spends a week in a hotel next to a farm placed under sanitary restrictions without ever complaining weakens the price-reduction and damages claim he could otherwise have brought.

B. Flights and hotel nights booked separately: the contract, the airline’s duties, and the insurance policy decide

Outside a package, there is no general French-law right to cancel free of charge because a health story dominates the news. A flight-only ticket and a hotel-only reservation are each governed by their own terms, by European air passenger law where it applies, and by the travel insurance policy if one was taken out. Each layer must be checked in order, because visitors often stop at the first refusal and leave money on the table.

When the airline itself cancels the flight, European air passenger law steps in regardless of nationality or ticket price. Every passenger departing from an airport in the European Union must be offered the choice between rerouting to the final destination and reimbursement of the ticket cost, together with assistance such as meals, communication and hotel accommodation while waiting for rerouting. None of this helps the passenger who cancels on his own initiative out of anxiety: a non-refundable fare stays non-refundable unless the fare conditions or the insurance say otherwise. None of this helps the passenger who cancels on his own initiative out of anxiety: a non-refundable fare stays non-refundable unless the fare conditions or the insurance say otherwise. That asymmetry surprises many American visitors used to airline credit vouchers, but it is the structure of the European text: the carrier’s duties are triggered by the carrier’s decision, not the passenger’s fears.

Hotel-only and holiday-rental bookings turn on the wording of the rate. A flexible rate can be cancelled within the stated window; a prepaid non-cancellable rate cannot, subject to two French-law correctives worth raising in any complaint letter. First, unfair terms control: Article L. 212-1 of the Code de la consommation deems unfair, in contracts between professionals and consumers, terms whose object or effect is to create a significant imbalance between the parties’ rights and obligations: “sont abusives les clauses qui ont pour objet ou pour effet de créer, au détriment du consommateur, un déséquilibre significatif entre les droits et obligations des parties au contrat.” A clause allowing the hotel to keep the full price while reselling the room, or imposing a penalty grossly disconnected from any loss, is the classic target. Second, force majeure under Article 1218 of the Civil Code almost never helps the guest who simply stays away, because the provision requires an event beyond the debtor’s control, which could not reasonably have been foreseen when the contract was concluded and whose effects cannot be avoided by appropriate measures, and which prevents performance of that debtor’s own obligation: “Il y a force majeure en matière contractuelle lorsqu’un événement échappant au contrôle du débiteur, qui ne pouvait être raisonnablement prévu lors de la conclusion du contrat et dont les effets ne peuvent être évités par des mesures appropriées, empêche l’exécution de son obligation par le débiteur.” The guest’s obligation is to pay and to show up; unease about a virus does not prevent either, so tribunals reject the argument in the overwhelming majority of no-show cases. The provision helps, if at all, the hotel prevented from receiving guests by an administrative closure order, not the guest who preferred to stay home.

That leaves travel insurance, which is where most cross-border cancellation disputes are actually won or lost, and where the Cour de cassation’s epidemic case law bites. French insurance law starts from a protective default: Article L. 113-1 of the Code des assurances provides that fortuitous losses and damage, including those caused by the insured’s own fault, are borne by the insurer, except for formal and limited exclusions contained in the policy: “Les pertes et les dommages occasionnés par des cas fortuits ou causés par la faute de l’assuré sont à la charge de l’assureur, sauf exclusion formelle et limitée contenue dans la police.” Insurers therefore draft epidemic and pandemic exclusions, and travellers assume those clauses settle everything. A 1 December 2022 judgment of the Second Civil Chamber, pourvoi no. 21-19.341, shows the analysis is finer. The Court recalled that an exclusion clause must satisfy the formal-and-limited test of Article L. 113-1, censuring reasoning that treated the clause as unwritten for want of a contractual definition of the word epidemic, yet it quashed the appeal ruling that had gone too far the other way: where the cover promises operating losses following an administrative closure ordered after a contagious disease, murder, suicide, epidemic or poisoning, an exclusion targeting only a defined subset of those closures leaves the rest of the guarantee intact and does not empty it of substance, so it can stand. The lesson for a visitor reading a cancellation policy over breakfast is concrete: an epidemic exclusion is not automatically void, and a vague one is not automatically valid. The exact trigger matters word by word. Does the clause exclude all epidemics, or only epidemics declared by the WHO, or only travel to destinations under an official advisory? Does it exclude cancellation, or only curtailment, medical expenses, or scheduled-airline failure? A policy that excludes cancellation where the Foreign Office, the Irish Department of Foreign Affairs or the US State Department advises against travel, while no such advisory exists for France, still covers a voluntary cancellation for other insured reasons, and the insurer which refuses to pay must point to the precise words, not to the general atmosphere.

Visitors should therefore assemble the file before writing the claim: the booking confirmations showing whether the trip is a package or a stack of separate contracts, the fare and rate conditions, the insurance policy with its definitions and exclusions pages, screenshots of any official advisory in force on the cancellation date, and every written exchange with the organiser, airline or hotel. Claims notified late or by telephone without written trace are the single most common reason solid files fail, across all nationalities.

II. During the stay: medical care, reporting duties, and the powers the authorities hold in reserve

Once in France, the questions change. A visitor who develops a fever after walking near livestock, a parent whose child was bitten by midges on a farm stay, or a business traveller ordered by his employer to keep attending meetings in a rural department needs to know where to be treated, who pays, whether the case must be reported, and what the prefect or the minister could order if the situation deteriorated.

A. How foreign visitors get treated and who pays the bill

Access to care in France does not depend on nationality. Article L. 1110-3 of the Code de la santé publique opens with a rule that surprises many visitors and reassures them at once: no one may face discrimination in access to prevention or care: “Aucune personne ne peut faire l’objet de discriminations dans l’accès à la prévention ou aux soins.” Emergency departments receive everyone, and a person who believes he was refused care unlawfully can refer the matter to the director of the local health insurance body or to the president of the territorially competent professional council, a referral that counts as filing a complaint. In the Paris region, where most long-haul visitors land, the large public hospitals routinely admit foreign patients; the practical difficulty is never admission, it is always payment and reimbursement afterwards, so the insurance position must be checked before the invoice arrives rather than after.

For visitors from the European Union, Iceland, Liechtenstein, Norway and Switzerland, the mechanism is the European Health Insurance Card. Article 19 of Regulation (EC) No 883/2004 on the coordination of social security systems entitles an insured person staying temporarily in another Member State to benefits in kind that become necessary on medical grounds during the stay, taking into account the nature of the benefits and the expected length of stay, on the same basis as persons insured in that State under Article 19 of Regulation (EC) No 883/2004 on the coordination of social security systems, which covers medically necessary state-provided healthcare during a temporary stay. The card is presented directly to the French healthcare professional or hospital, and treatment deemed medically necessary cannot be refused pending clarification of coverage. Planned treatment sought specifically in France falls outside this mechanism and needs prior authorisation, a distinction that matters for anyone tempted to combine a holiday with a medical check-up linked to the virus scare.

British visitors carry the post-Brexit equivalent, the UK Global Health Insurance Card, which gives access to necessary state-provided healthcare in France on the same footing, while visitors from the United States, Canada, Australia and other non-European countries have no reciprocal cover at all and rely entirely on private travel insurance, employer assistance contracts, or their own funds. American travellers in particular should confirm three points before departure: that the policy covers medical expenses abroad and not only cancellation, that it includes advances or direct payment to hospitals rather than reimbursement months later, and that epidemic-related care is not carved out by a clause mirroring the cancellation exclusions discussed above. French hospitals bill foreign patients without local cover at full rates and may ask for a deposit or a guarantee from the assistance company before a non-urgent admission; emergency care is never withheld for lack of payment, but scheduled follow-up, imaging and repatriation are organised only once the payer is identified. Keeping the insurance certificate, the assistance telephone number and a passport copy on paper as well as on the telephone avoids the most frequent hospital-administration deadlock.

Anyone who falls ill should also protect the later file. Keep the boarding passes proving the dates of the stay, the accommodation invoices, photographs of the area visited where relevant, the names of the doctors and laboratories seen, every prescription and invoice, and the written exchanges with the insurer’s assistance platform. If the trip was a package and illness ruined its purpose, copy the organiser promptly under the Article L. 211-16 duty to report non-conformity without delay, because a price-reduction claim brought months later from abroad starts with a handicap. Readers dealing with the consequences of the Lyon death for a relative may also need the analysis of family claims against the State and the employer published alongside this piece, which examines the liability routes open to close relatives after a first fatal case: France’s first Shamonda death and the family-claim routes under French law.

B. Reporting, monitoring, and what the State could order if the picture changed

The current official position is restraint, and visitors should understand exactly what that means in law. The health ministry’s line, relayed by the international press, is that this is an isolated human case with no risk to the general population, that investigations into whether the virus caused or contributed to the patient’s death and into how the infection was acquired are ongoing, and that there is no alert and no crisis. The WHO, contacted by the French authorities, stated that based on current information and knowledge of the transmission of closely related viruses, this is an isolated human case and it is unlikely to lead to wider spread at this time. The ECDC, for its part, is carefully monitoring the situation after the French announcement. None of this creates duties for travellers; it describes a surveillance phase.

That surveillance phase has a precise legal skeleton, and it helps to know where a visitor stands inside it. First, reporting is a duty of doctors and laboratories, not of patients. Article L. 3113-1, I, of the Code de la santé publique requires physicians and the heads of public and private medical biology services and laboratories to notify the regional health agency of cases of diseases requiring urgent local, national or international intervention, and the national public health agency of cases of diseases requiring particular surveillance: “Les médecins et les responsables des services et laboratoires de biologie médicale publics et privés signalent : 1° A l’agence régionale de santé les cas de maladies nécessitant une intervention urgente locale, nationale ou internationale ; 2° A l’Agence nationale de santé publique les cas de maladies exigeant une surveillance particulière pour la protection de la santé de la population.” A decree fixes the list of diseases subject to such notification, and at the date of writing no official source consulted for this article places Shamonda on a notifiable-disease list applicable to travellers. The visitor’s only duty is therefore the ordinary one: consult promptly, describe symptoms and exposure precisely, and mention stays near livestock so the physician can decide whether the signal must be escalated. Withholding relevant exposure history from the doctor, by contrast, can complicate both treatment and any later insurance or liability file.

Second, at European level, Regulation (EU) 2022/2371 on serious cross-border threats to health provides the framework under which such signals are notified between States and assessed with ECDC support, which is the mechanism behind the ECDC monitoring reported by the Irish farming press under Regulation (EU) 2022/2371 on serious cross-border threats to health. Travellers will never invoke this text directly, but they benefit from understanding it: as long as the European assessment remains at monitoring, no border measure follows; if the assessment changed, coordinated measures could include targeted advice, reinforced surveillance or transport-related recommendations rather than the blanket closures of 2020, whose legal regime has in any event expired.

Third, within France, the heavy powers exist but are dormant. Article L. 3131-1, I, of the Code de la santé publique allows the health minister, where a serious health threat calls for emergency measures, including the threat of an epidemic, to prescribe by reasoned order, in the interest of public health and for the sole purpose of preventing and limiting the consequences of the threat, regulatory or individual measures concerning the organisation of the health system, as well as quarantine or isolation placement and maintenance under the conditions of Articles L. 3131-12 and L. 3131-13: “En cas de menace sanitaire grave appelant des mesures d’urgence, notamment en cas de menace d’épidémie, le ministre chargé de la santé peut, par arrêté motivé, dans l’intérêt de la santé publique et aux seules fins de prévenir et de limiter les conséquences de cette menace sur la santé de la population, prescrire : 1° Toute mesure réglementaire ou individuelle relative à l’organisation et au fonctionnement du système de santé ; 2° Des mesures de mise en quarantaine ou de placement et de maintien en isolement, dans les conditions prévues au I des articles L. 3131-12 et L. 3131-13.” The minister can authorise the territorial State representative to take implementing measures, including individual ones. Nothing of the sort has been ordered for Shamonda: no quarantine for contacts, no isolation orders for travellers, no restricted departments, no border health checks announced. The rule for visitors is therefore simple to state and important to respect in both directions. As long as no order exists, no one can lawfully confine you, refuse you boarding on health grounds outside the carrier’s own conditions of carriage, or require a test or certificate linked to this virus; and if an order appears, it must be reasoned, published, time-limited and challengeable before the administrative courts, starting with interim relief where liberty is at stake.

Farm stays, equestrian tourism and agricultural visits deserve a final practical word, because the virus circulates in animals and the first French detections in the summer of 2026 concerned cattle. Avoiding midge bites at dusk near livestock, keeping children from straying into barns and handling areas, and seeking medical advice for any unexplained fever after such exposure are ordinary precautions, not legal duties, and they create no right to cancel a booking that can otherwise proceed normally. Employers sending staff to French farms, veterinary practices or equestrian centres should update their risk assessment and instructions in writing, since the posted-worker quarantine analysis published alongside this piece shows how quickly presence orders and employer duties can interact once the authorities move: the factual setting is different, but the reflex is the same, which is to document instructions given before departure rather than reconstruct them afterwards.

Conclusion

France’s first recognised Shamonda infection is a scientific first, not a travel ban. The patient died in Lyon, the authorities speak of an isolated case with no risk to the general population, the WHO agrees at this stage, and the ECDC monitors. For visitors, the legal picture follows the booking, not the headlines. Package travellers hold a conditional but powerful card: free termination with a full refund within fourteen days where unavoidable and extraordinary circumstances at the destination significantly affect the trip, a threshold today’s official position does not meet but tomorrow’s orders could. Holders of separate flight and hotel bookings are bound by fare and rate conditions, European air passenger rights when the carrier cancels, unfair-terms control, and above all the precise wording of their insurance policy, where epidemic exclusions stand or fall on being formal and limited. Visitors who fall ill in France will be treated without discrimination, will pay through the European card, the British card or private insurance according to their status, will have their case reported by their doctor if the criteria require it, and face no quarantine or isolation measure that has not been ordered in writing. Keep every document, notify in writing, check advisories on the day you act, and measure each decision against the official position in force that day rather than the noise around it.

📄 Official circular