KOHEN AVOCATS · PARIS, FRANCE
Moss Landing Shooting: How California Victims Can Seek Restitution

Hassan Kohen is a Paris-based lawyer admitted to the Paris Bar (Avocat au Barreau de Paris). Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Sources: U.S. court opinions and official U.S. government publications, read for this article

Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Moss Landing Shooting: How California Victims Can Seek Restitution

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

After the Moss Landing shooting, people affected by the incident may face medical bills, lost income, funeral costs, damaged belongings, or the sudden expense of finding a safe place to stay. KSBW reported on November 2, 2026, citing the Monterey County Sheriff’s Office, that multiple people were killed and others injured near Jetty Road. The sheriff’s office said an investigation was continuing. The information available at the time of writing does not establish the outcome of that investigation, whether any person will be charged or convicted, or whether a restitution order will be available in this incident.

For a person dealing with costs now, California has two distinct paths worth understanding. A criminal court may order restitution from a defendant when the legal requirements are met; the California Victim Compensation Board also considers applications for qualifying crime-related expenses. The board’s program and a court order have different rules, and neither makes payment automatic. Start by preserving records of each loss and identifying other payments that may cover it. This article explains the California framework through statutes and decided cases. It does not predict the outcome of the Moss Landing investigation or establish anyone’s responsibility.

I. What financial help can a California victim or family consider first?

A. Separate a compensation application from criminal restitution

The most useful first distinction is who decides the request and where the money comes from. In a California criminal case, direct restitution is an order made by a court requiring a defendant to reimburse qualifying losses. It is different from a restitution fine, which is a separate part of the California sentencing scheme. An order for a particular person should identify the victim, the loss and the amount, to the extent possible. A fine paid into a fund should not be mistaken for an itemized order payable to the injured person.

California Penal Code § 1202.4, as amended effective January 1, 2026, describes direct victim restitution, the restitution fine, the losses a court can address, and the hearing at which a defendant can contest the amount. The statute’s direct-restitution framework generally concerns losses caused by a defendant’s criminal conduct in a criminal case. A report of an incident alone does not establish that a particular defendant has committed a crime, that charges will be filed, or that a court can issue an order in that case.

The California Victim Compensation Board’s guidance for victims describes a separate state compensation process. The board identifies itself as a payer of last resort after other available sources of reimbursement and recovery. Its guidance says applications may be made online, on paper, or with assistance from county victim-witness advocates. It lists potentially covered categories such as medical treatment, mental health services, income loss, funeral and burial expenses, relocation, and security, subject to the program’s rules and limits.

Do not assume that every expense fits both paths. The board says its program cannot pay for lost, stolen, or damaged property. By contrast, California Penal Code § 1202.4 expressly addresses the value of stolen or damaged property in an appropriate direct-restitution order. The board’s description is guidance about its program; the statute governs the court’s restitution authority. For a damaged vehicle, for example, keep repair estimates and insurance correspondence even if the board’s property restriction means that this particular program does not pay the property loss.

A family can begin organizing information without waiting for a criminal case to reach sentencing. Make a private list of bills received, amounts actually paid, payments expected from insurance or another source, and the balance still in dispute. Save explanations of benefits as well as invoices: a provider’s initial charge, an insurer’s adjustment and the amount a patient owes may be different numbers. Keep the underlying documents, not just a final total. If the board or a court later needs clarification, the sequence is easier to reconstruct.

For compensation, the board recommends including copies of crime reports, bills, receipts and related documents with the application, and sending crime-related bills to the relevant insurance or other benefit provider. If a report is not yet available, record the information you have and ask the assistance program what can be supplied later. The board’s guidance describes advocates who can help with applications and connect people with emergency resources. The existence of a possible application is not an assurance that a particular person or expense is eligible.

Keep urgent care and documentation in proportion. A person does not need to produce a perfect spreadsheet before seeking medical attention or a safe place to stay. When possible, retain discharge instructions, pharmacy receipts, travel receipts and any written explanation of a related expense. If someone else pays a bill, note who paid and preserve the receipt. Those records can help distinguish the patient’s unpaid balance from a payment made by a relative, insurer or public program.

B. Identify whose loss is being claimed and how the case is progressing

California’s restitution statute defines victims for that section to include the immediate surviving family of an actual victim and certain other people who sustain economic loss and satisfy the statute’s specified relationships or circumstances. It also identifies other categories. Being related to an injured person does not by itself answer every question about a particular expense. Record the relationship, who incurred or paid the expense, and why the expense is connected to the conduct at issue. Separate entries for different family members can prevent an amount paid once from being counted twice.

People v. Giordano, 42 Cal. 4th 644 (California Supreme Court 2007), decided November 26, 2007, held that a direct restitution order could include a surviving spouse’s future loss of economic support caused by a death. The court considered evidence and a method of calculation; it did not announce a fixed award for every survivor. A family seeking support losses should therefore preserve evidence of the support actually received and the basis for any projection rather than assume a standard amount. In People v. Sinay, No. B331391 (Court of Appeal of the State of California 2025), decided May 19, 2025, the court cited Giordano when explaining the restitution mandate in a case involving an injured child and her family. The later decision illustrates the rule’s continued use; the facts and award in that case do not determine an award in another case.

Evidence of support may take several forms: pay records, business records, transfers, household contributions and information about the family’s actual financial arrangements. A projected amount should be labeled as a projection, with its assumptions visible. It is also useful to identify information that is unavailable rather than silently replacing it with a guess. Giordano involved a spouse’s economic loss and a particular calculation. It should not be read as a promise that every expected contribution will be accepted or that the same formula suits every family.

The progress of a criminal investigation and the progress of a compensation application are different questions. A family may want the investigating agency’s report number, the relevant victim-witness program and a way to receive case updates. When contacting an agency, keep a record of the date, the office, the subject discussed and any next step the office identifies. If a person receives conflicting information, a written record helps the next person understand what was requested and what remains unresolved.

California Penal Code § 679.02 lists statutory rights of crime victims and witnesses. Among other provisions, it addresses notice of sentencing proceedings and the opportunity for a victim, a minor victim’s parent or guardian, or a deceased victim’s next of kin to appear and express views as specified by law. It also provides that a victim or witness may request information from the prosecutor about the final disposition of a case. The exact notification and participation provisions depend on the proceeding and the person’s role.

When a case reaches a stage where a prosecutor or victim-witness office is collecting loss information, submit an organized record through the channel that office specifies. Identify the claimant and the expense, describe the available supporting document and explain which amount remains unpaid. If safety or privacy is a concern, raise it with the office before sharing sensitive material broadly. A list of expenses and a statement about the personal impact of an offense serve different purposes; keeping them distinct makes each easier to understand.

Questions about timing should be answered for the particular route. A board application, a criminal restitution hearing and a possible civil claim are not interchangeable procedures. The sources discussed here do not establish a single deadline covering all three. Note the date and wording of any notice actually received, and check the requirements of the specific program or proceeding rather than assuming that a deadline for one path controls another.

II. How can a victim document losses for a possible restitution order?

A. Connect each amount to evidence and to the crime at issue

Start with a simple loss ledger. For each entry, note the date, the person affected, the type of expense, the amount billed, the amount paid, the payer and the document that supports it. Add a short description of the connection to the incident, without treating the ledger itself as proof of who committed a crime. Keep estimates separate from final bills. A proposed repair cost is not the same thing as an invoice for completed work, and an unpaid bill is not the same as a payment made out of pocket.

California Penal Code § 1202.4 lists medical and mental health counseling expenses and certain lost wages among the losses that may be included in a direct restitution order. It also lists the replacement cost of like stolen or damaged property, or actual repair cost when repair is possible. The list is not a guarantee that every item submitted will be awarded: the court must address the actual loss and the connection to the defendant’s conduct in the case before it. Preserve the full bill and the page showing what insurance paid or rejected.

People v. Prosser, 157 Cal. App. 4th 682 (California Court of Appeal 2007), decided December 4, 2007, affirmed restitution for stolen jewelry based on the owners’ testimony even though they lacked receipts or appraisals for the gifts. The court treated the owners’ descriptions and estimates as evidence, while recognizing the defendant’s opportunity to challenge the amounts. A missing receipt is therefore a reason to explain how a value was estimated, not a reason to invent a receipt or abandon the record. In People v. Curtis, No. B348135 (Court of Appeal of the State of California 2026), decided September 17, 2026, the court cited Prosser when reviewing testimony and other evidence about a stolen motorcycle. Curtis was not published and its use as precedent is restricted under California’s court rules; it is mentioned here as a later observed citation, not as controlling authority.

For a possession without a receipt, describe the item accurately: its make or type, age, condition and any distinctive features. A dated photograph, warranty record, prior appraisal, bank record or comparable item may help explain an estimate. If a replacement is not truly comparable, say how it differs. Keep the source and date of a price quote. A court may accept some evidence and reject other evidence; the practical goal is to make the basis of a number reviewable, not to ensure a particular result.

For lost wages, preserve a schedule showing time missed, usual pay and payments received during the absence. An employer statement or pay history may help explain the calculation. A self-employed person may need records showing the basis of profits claimed and distinguishing revenue from expenses. If the evidence is incomplete, label the amount as an estimate and explain what remains to be confirmed. Do not present the same missed work both as an unpaid wage loss and as a separate cost without explaining whether the entries overlap.

Relocation is especially fact-specific. California Penal Code § 1202.4 includes certain expenses incurred by an adult victim in relocating away from a defendant. The provision requires verification by law enforcement that the expenses are necessary for the victim’s personal safety, or by a mental health treatment provider that they are necessary for the victim’s emotional well-being. Record the actual expense and the reason for the move; a housing bill alone may not answer the statute’s verification requirement.

People v. Mearns, 97 Cal. App. 4th 493 (Court of Appeal, Second District, Division Five 2002), decided April 5, 2002, upheld a restitution award for a victim’s relocation costs on the particular evidence after an attack in her home and threats concerning her child. The court described the safety and emotional circumstances and the factual basis for the amount. A person considering a relocation claim should preserve evidence of both the need to relocate and the cost, rather than assume that every move following a crime is reimbursable. In People v. Jimenez, No. F087827 (Court of Appeal of the State of California Fifth Appellate District 2025), decided December 29, 2025, the court cited Mearns when discussing the need for a factual and rational basis for a restitution amount. The portion of Jimenez containing that discussion was not certified for publication, so it is not presented here as precedent.

The same care applies to counseling and other treatment. An invoice can show the service, provider, date and charge, while an insurance statement can show what was covered. Medical records may contain highly private information, so distinguish a financial record needed to support an amount from a complete treatment file. Ask the receiving program or office what documentation it needs and how sensitive material will be handled. Do not omit a relevant payment merely because it makes the calculation more complicated.

California’s statute also includes specific provisions for certain noneconomic losses in identified offenses. It would be inaccurate to say that every form of emotional harm is always recoverable in a criminal restitution order, or that noneconomic losses are excluded in every California case. The relevant offense, statutory language and facts matter. Keep bills for counseling and other economic expenses distinct from a request concerning noneconomic harm, and identify the authority and evidence for the latter before treating it as an amount due.

B. Prepare for a hearing, an unfinished calculation, and collection

A restitution submission is easier to evaluate when another person can follow the arithmetic. Group records by claimant and category, then show the calculation from beginning to end. For example, list a medical bill, a payment by an insurer, an amount paid personally and any remaining balance as separate figures. If a reimbursement arrives later, record it and notify the appropriate recipient rather than leaving an outdated amount uncorrected. The question is what loss is supported under the governing procedure, not simply how large the original bill was.

California Penal Code § 1202.4 gives the defendant a hearing before a judge to dispute the amount of restitution. The court can modify the amount on its own motion or on the motion of the prosecutor, a victim or the defendant. Where a modification motion is made, the section requires notice to the victim at least ten days before the proceeding to decide it. The statute also addresses live, two-way audio and video testimony at a restitution or modification hearing if that technology is available at the court.

For a hearing, arrange each supporting item so that its connection to an entry in the ledger is clear. A short cover page can state the total requested, but the underlying records should show how the total was reached. Bring or retain a copy of what was submitted, and make a note of missing evidence and why it is missing. If a figure is disputed, the distinction between a document’s face amount, the actual payment and a reasonable estimate becomes particularly important.

Some losses cannot be calculated at sentencing. California Penal Code § 1202.46 addresses retained court jurisdiction when a victim’s economic losses cannot be ascertained at sentencing under § 1202.4, and it also addresses a request to correct a sentence invalid because a required restitution order or fine was omitted. This is a rule with conditions; it is not a statement that every claim may be raised whenever a person chooses. If future treatment is uncertain, identify what is known, what remains unknown and what the court or prosecutor says is needed in the particular case.

After an order is entered, obtain a copy and check the name of each payee, the listed losses and the amount. An order and actual payment are different events. California Penal Code § 1202.4 says that a restitution order under subdivision (f) is enforceable as if it were a civil judgment and gives it priority over specified fines, assessments and fees imposed on the defendant. The same statute says a defendant’s inability to pay is not a consideration when determining the amount of the restitution order. Neither provision guarantees that the full amount will be collected immediately.

Keep a payment history after an order: date received, amount, source, the loss to which it relates and any remaining balance. Save notices about changes to the order. California Penal Code § 1202.4 also addresses the relationship between actual restitution collected, the Restitution Fund and other judgments for the same losses. Because those interactions depend on what was paid and to whom, retain both the board’s compensation records and the court’s order instead of assuming the same loss can be collected twice.

If a criminal proceeding does not produce an order, that fact does not by itself answer whether a state compensation application or a separate civil remedy is available. California Penal Code § 679.02 includes a right for victims to receive information about civil recovery and the opportunity to seek compensation from the Restitution Fund as provided by law. Those routes have their own requirements. In particular, do not infer a civil filing period, the date a claim begins, or an exception to a filing period from the criminal restitution provisions discussed above.

A practical file can be maintained in three parts: case and agency notices; expense and payment records; and correspondence about applications or orders. The first shows the procedural stage, the second supports individual amounts, and the third records what has been submitted and what remains open. Store copies securely, particularly records concerning children, health treatment or a new address. Update the file as reliable information arrives, while keeping uncertain information marked as uncertain.

Conclusion

California crime-victim compensation and criminal restitution are distinct routes. The state board considers qualifying applications under its program rules; a criminal court can order direct restitution when the requirements for the case and the loss are met. Neither an investigation nor an application guarantees an award or collection. A useful first step is to preserve bills, payment records and explanations of each loss, then keep track of the agency or court process that applies. For future costs and disputed amounts, distinguish documented facts from estimates and retain the information needed to explain both.

📄 Official circular