KOHEN AVOCATS · PARIS, FRANCE
Layla Clark Thunderstruck: Can a School Post a Marching Band Video Featuring a Copyrighted Song?

Hassan Kohen is a Paris-based lawyer admitted to the Paris Bar (Avocat au Barreau de Paris). Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Sources: U.S. court opinions and official U.S. government publications, read for this article

Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Layla Clark Thunderstruck: Can a School Post a Marching Band Video Featuring a Copyrighted Song?

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

According to a notice on the Thomas Jefferson High School website, a video of West Jefferson Hills Marching Band senior percussionist Layla Clark performing “Thunderstruck” went viral on social media. The performance raises a practical question for a different school considering its own video: what rights should it check before a recording of a band playing a copyrighted song is posted online?

Federal copyright law separates the musical composition from a particular sound recording and gives copyright owners a set of distinct rights, subject to statutory limits. A license for a live performance, permission to arrange sheet music, and authorization for an online video can cover different activities. A school should read the actual permissions and the platform terms instead of assuming that a single permission covers every step. Fair use and specific educational limitations may matter, but their application depends on the use and its circumstances.

The discussion that follows is general in scope: it describes checks useful in comparable situations and makes no findings about Layla Clark, her school, its video, or the permissions in place. The federal decisions below address different records and courts. A Pennsylvania reader should distinguish a Supreme Court rule, an applicable Third Circuit decision, and Ninth Circuit decisions that are persuasive outside that circuit.

I. What should a school check before posting a band performance?

A. Separate the song, the performance, the recording, and the video

Start with what is actually in the file. A band can perform a melody and lyrics itself, or it can play along with an existing commercial recording. It can use a published arrangement, an arrangement prepared for the school, or music written by its own members. A video might show the entire performance, an excerpt, or several songs edited together. It may be available publicly, sent only to a defined group, or used in a school promotion. Each of these details helps identify the rights to investigate.

Under federal 17 U.S.C. § 106, the copyright owner’s exclusive rights include reproduction, preparation of derivative works, distribution, and public performance for specified categories of works, subject to limitations in the statute. The first practical step is to match the proposed activity to the right it may implicate. Buying printed music, arranging it, recording a performance, and making a video available online are not necessarily the same activity. The terms of the relevant permission matter.

The U.S. Copyright Office’s guidance for musicians distinguishes the underlying musical work from a particular sound recording. The composition is the music and any accompanying words; a sound recording fixes a series of sounds. They can have different owners and licenses. A new recording of students playing a piece does not by itself copy a commercial recording, but the underlying composition still needs to be considered. If the file also includes a commercially recorded track, ask separately about the rights in that track.

Make a small inventory before asking for permission. Identify the song and arrangement, the source of any sheet music, the people who will perform, any recorded accompaniment, the person who will make the video, and each proposed destination. Keep the document that came with the music and any written permission from an owner or representative. Note whether the file is intended for an internal classroom, a public school account, a fundraiser, or a wider distribution. A permission that describes one use may or may not extend to another.

For example, a school may have authorization for an in-person concert and still need to check whether that document covers recording the concert and posting it on a public page. It may have purchased an arrangement for its ensemble and need to check whether adaptations or a video are within the agreement. A venue, event organizer, music publisher, recording owner, or platform may each have different agreements. Do not infer the scope of a particular agreement from the name of a licensing organization alone; read the text and ask the person responsible for the agreement what it covers.

The distinction also matters when a parent makes the video. The parent and school may have different roles and different documents. The school can identify who controls the account, who made the recording, and what permissions the account holder has obtained. If several accounts intend to repost the same file, the plan should specify that distribution. A permission to post one file on a particular account should not be silently treated as permission for every participant to upload an edited copy elsewhere.

As a separate federal registration point, the Copyright Office explains in its musical compositions and sound recordings guidance that the two are separate works, even where they are registered together under the conditions the Office describes. That distinction helps a school organize its questions; the registration page does not itself grant a license. The name printed on a score, a label on a recording, and a platform’s automated response may provide clues, but they do not replace the actual authorization for the intended use.

A useful rights worksheet has a row for each activity: making an arrangement; performing at the event; making the audiovisual recording; posting it on a named platform; and any later edit or repost. For each row, record the source of authority, who gave it, what material it covers, where the use is allowed, and any restrictions. If a row is unresolved, identify the exact question rather than writing simply that the song is cleared. A written answer limited to a school concert can be valuable evidence of that permission while leaving a separate public video question open.

B. Check educational uses and fair use without assuming either is automatic

Federal 17 U.S.C. § 110 contains specific limitations for certain performances and displays in teaching and other settings. For example, § 110(1) addresses a performance or display by instructors or pupils in the course of face-to-face teaching activities of a nonprofit educational institution, in a classroom or similar place devoted to instruction, subject to the section’s conditions. The section has other provisions with their own requirements. A public upload is a different act and should be assessed on its own facts; the fact that a school is involved does not establish that every copy or public transmission meets an educational exception.

That distinction can affect an ordinary workflow. A teacher may use a work during a qualifying lesson, a band may later perform at an event, and someone may then publish an edited recording. Instead of assigning a single label to all three steps, identify the applicable provision or permission for each one. Where the relevant exception depends on the nature of the institution, the setting, the audience, or another stated condition, preserve the facts that show whether the condition is met. A general educational aim is helpful context, but it is not a substitute for those conditions.

Federal 17 U.S.C. § 107 sets out the fair use framework. It calls for consideration of the purpose and character of the use, the nature of the copyrighted work, the amount and substantiality used in relation to the work as a whole, and the effect on the potential market for or value of the work. These factors are considered together. A nonprofit educational purpose can matter, but it does not automatically resolve the whole analysis. A short excerpt also is not automatically fair merely because it is short.

In Campbell v. Acuff-Rose Music, Inc., 510 U.S. 569 (1994), the Supreme Court of the United States held on March 7, 1994, that the commercial character of a parody did not make it presumptively unfair and remanded for further analysis. The Court did not finally decide that every use of the song was fair. In ASTM v. UpCodes, Inc., No. 24-2965 (3d Cir. Apr. 7, 2026), the Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit cited Campbell on April 7, 2026, in its fact-specific fair use analysis and affirmed the denial of a preliminary injunction concerning technical standards. For a school evaluating a video, the useful check is the purpose, content, audience, and market context of the particular use rather than a single label such as nonprofit.

In Tresona v. Burbank High Vocal Music, 953 F.3d 638 (9th Cir. 2020), the Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit held on March 24, 2020, that an educator’s use of a limited, rearranged portion of a song in a nonprofit school choir showpiece was fair use on the record before it. In Simpson v. MiTek, Inc., No. 20-cv-06957-VKD (N.D. Cal. May 16, 2024), the United States District Court for the Northern District of California cited Tresona on May 16, 2024, when considering the degree of success in a discretionary attorney-fee analysis, and declined fees on its own record. A school can compare the use at issue with the proposed arrangement and video, while recognizing that the Ninth Circuit decision is not a blanket ruling that every school performance or public upload is fair use.

The comparison should be concrete. Is the music the main attraction of the proposed video, or is it incidental to another purpose? Is the school copying a complete piece, a recognizable passage, or a small part needed for a particular educational project? Does the edit add a distinct purpose, and who will have access to it? Could the post substitute for a licensed recording or another relevant market? Those questions do not produce an automatic score. They identify facts that can make the legal analysis different from a choir arrangement or a parody considered in a published opinion.

The Copyright Office’s musician guidance also cautions that there is no fixed minimum amount of music that is always safe to use without permission where permission is needed. Avoid treating a number of seconds, a credit line, or a lack of advertising revenue as a universal clearance. Credit can identify a creator, but it is not itself a grant of the relevant rights. If a school relies on an exception, it should keep the reasons and supporting facts with the same care it would use for a written license.

Where a school wants a more predictable route, it can ask for permission that describes the actual project. The request can identify the composition, the arrangement, whether any existing recording is included, the length of the clip, the account and platforms, and any planned reuse. The response should be checked against that request. If permission is restricted to a particular event or account, the school can narrow the posting plan or seek an additional authorization before extending it. Whether an exception applies remains a separate question.

II. What should the account holder do if the platform flags or removes the video?

A. Identify the type of notice and preserve the record

First, read what the platform actually sent. A platform’s automated match, a contractual restriction, and a statutory takedown notice are not necessarily identical. Save the message, the account name, the file and edit that were posted, the address of the post, and any attachments. Record whether access was blocked, sound was muted, revenue was affected, or the file was removed. Do not infer a final court finding from a platform’s action alone.

Federal 17 U.S.C. § 512 sets out, among other provisions, a notice-and-takedown framework and conditions for certain service-provider limitations on liability. Section 512(c)(3) describes the elements of a qualifying notification, including identification of the work and the material claimed to be infringing, information reasonably sufficient to locate that material, and the required statements. The account holder should identify whether the message is a statutory notification or another platform process before deciding which response mechanism is relevant.

In Lenz v. Universal Music Corp., 815 F.3d 1145 (9th Cir. 2016), the Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit held on March 17, 2016, that a copyright holder must consider fair use before sending a statutory takedown notice and affirmed the denial of the parties’ cross-motions for summary judgment. In Athos v. YouTube, Inc., No. 23-13156 (11th Cir. Jan. 7, 2026), the Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit cited Lenz on January 7, 2026, while describing notice elements and affirmed a service-provider safe-harbor judgment on its own record. A person receiving a notice should compare the identified material, the asserted right, and any fair use facts; the notice itself does not determine whether a particular video is infringing.

The procedural posture matters. The Ninth Circuit left a factual issue for further proceedings in the dispute before it; the decision did not declare every family or school video a fair use. The Eleventh Circuit decision addressed a service provider’s position under § 512(c), not a general promise that every upload will remain online. Both opinions are federal decisions, but neither is binding Third Circuit precedent merely because a Pennsylvania account holder can read it. The statute and any controlling decision for the relevant court remain important.

If the notice identifies a particular segment, compare it with the original file and the posted version. An event recording can contain several works, and an edited version may add a track that was not audible at the event. Locate the score, license, correspondence, and the terms that applied at the time of posting. If an organizer supplied permission, check whether it covered the account holder and the platform concerned. If the message identifies the wrong file, preserve the original message and the evidence of the mismatch.

Do not assume that a platform match identifies the owner of every right in a file. It may identify a sound recording, a composition, or a part of a longer video. The relevant document may also describe a restriction that comes from the platform’s own terms. Separate these questions before responding: what was matched, what right is asserted, who sent the notice, and what does the account holder know about permission or an exception? A response should address the actual reason given rather than making a broad claim about all school music.

A school may decide to remove or replace a passage, use a different recording, restrict an audience, or seek clarification. Those are practical choices, not proof that the original use was unlawful. Equally, restoring or leaving a file online does not establish that all rights are cleared. Keep the original version and the notice so that any later review can distinguish the initial file from an edited replacement. If a permission depends on the distribution channel, compare the proposed replacement with its actual terms.

B. Evaluate a counter-notification and future posting plan carefully

Federal 17 U.S.C. § 512(g) describes a counter-notification process for material removed or disabled under the statute’s framework. It specifies required information, including identification of the removed material and its former location, a statement under penalty of perjury of a good-faith belief that removal or disabling resulted from mistake or misidentification, and other required contact and jurisdiction statements. The person signing should read the complete provision and the platform’s instructions and should make only statements that are true. A counter-notification is a formal statement, not merely a request for a second automated review.

Federal 17 U.S.C. § 512(g)(2) states conditions for the service provider’s limitation on liability: after a qualifying counter-notification, it must promptly forward a copy and then replace the material or cease disabling access no sooner than 10 and no later than 14 business days after receipt, unless its designated agent first receives notice that the person who submitted the original notification has filed an action seeking a court order to restrain the subscriber from infringing activity relating to that material. Those conditions do not govern every platform dispute or automated match. Read the notice and the statute together, and do not treat a pending counter-notification as a guarantee of restoration.

Before signing, the account holder can organize the evidence into four groups. First, identify the version of the file and the exact passage at issue. Second, collect any permissions and read their scope. Third, document facts relevant to an asserted exception, including purpose, audience, amount used, and the file’s relationship to the original. Fourth, preserve the platform’s communications and identify any factual mistake. These steps do not replace the legal requirements for a counter-notification, but they make it easier to assess whether the required statements can honestly be made.

Privacy and copyright are separate parts of the posting decision. A school may need to check its own policies and the permissions it has obtained for showing students, while also examining rights in music and recordings. The copyright sources discussed here do not establish a universal rule for student image consent. A responsible posting plan identifies who may approve the image, who controls access, and how a school will handle a request to change a post, without assuming that copyright clearance resolves those questions.

For future performances, build the check into planning rather than waiting for a notice. The music director can identify the works and arrangements; the event organizer can locate performance permissions; and the person managing the school account can describe the intended video distribution. Store each answer next to the use it covers. If a later edit adds recorded music, changes the platform, or turns an internal video into a public promotion, revisit the affected permissions and any claimed exception.

Different versions of a performance should be tracked separately. A full concert recording, a short highlight, a livestream, and a promotional clip may have different audiences and purposes. A document granting a specific use may have geographic, platform, duration, or editing limits. Note those conditions as written, including any unresolved question, instead of assuming that the broadest proposed use has been approved. When a project includes more than one song or recording, repeat the inventory for each one.

Finally, make the decision readable for the next person who inherits the account. Keep the score source, the version posted, the permissions, the platform message, the action taken, and the reason for that action in a single record. A future teacher or administrator can then see what was actually authorized and what remains to be checked. The best practical answer depends on the particular music, the particular video, and the available evidence, rather than a rule that all school performances are automatically permitted or forbidden online.

Conclusion

Before posting a band video, identify the composition, any arrangement, any existing sound recording, and the way the file will be distributed. Read the permissions for each relevant activity, then consider any federal educational limitation or fair use on its actual facts. If a platform sends a notice, preserve the file and documents, identify the process being used, and check the facts before making a formal response. These steps give the account holder a clear record for deciding how to share the performance.

📄 Official circular