KOHEN AVOCATS · PARIS, FRANCE
LaKesha Womack: can a pending felony charge keep a congresswoman-elect from taking her House seat?

Hassan Kohen is a Paris-based lawyer admitted to the Paris Bar (Avocat au Barreau de Paris). Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Sources: U.S. court opinions and official U.S. government publications, read for this article

Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

LaKesha Womack: can a pending felony charge keep a congresswoman-elect from taking her House seat?

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

LaKesha Womack won North Carolina’s 14th congressional district in the November 2026 midterm election, defeating incumbent Tim Moore, according to election-night reporting from national outlets. She did so while facing a pending Class H felony charge in Mecklenburg County connected to a 2019 rental car that, according to a criminal summons first issued in January 2020 and served on October 11, 2026, she allegedly failed to return. Court records obtained through a public-records request, reported by the Carolina Journal with confirmation from the Mecklenburg County clerk’s office that the file is viewable on the state courts’ portal, identify the matter as case number 20CR201748-590 and describe a 2019 Toyota Corolla, valued at $20,000, that was due back on October 23, 2019; the next court appearance is scheduled for November 10, 2026. A summons records an allegation, not a judicial finding: no court has determined guilt, and the charge remains pending. The discussion that follows is general in scope: it describes checks useful in comparable situations and makes no findings about LaKesha Womack’s situation. The useful questions are concrete: can a representative-elect with a pending charge be seated when the new Congress convenes, what would change after a conviction, and what exactly must North Carolina prosecutors prove? Federal qualifications law answers the first two; North Carolina theft statutes answer the third.

I. Can a pending felony charge keep a representative-elect out of the House?

A. The House can only judge the Constitution’s three qualifications

The Constitution sets exactly three qualifications for a Representative. As the Constitution Annotated on Congress.gov states the text: “been seven Years a Citizen of the United States, and who shall not, when elected, be an Inhabitant of that State in which he shall be chosen” The provision says nothing about pending charges, indictments, or convictions. That silence is not an oversight the House may fill on its own, and the leading decision proves it. In Powell v. McCormack, 395 U.S. 486 (1969), decided June 16, 1969, the Supreme Court of the United States considered a House resolution that refused to seat a duly elected member over misconduct findings. The Court stated: “we hold that, since Adam Clayton Powell, Jr., was duly elected by the voters of the 18th Congressional District of New York and was not ineligible to serve under any provision of the Constitution, the House was without power to exclude him from its membership.” Powell supplies the seating rule for this story: a House majority cannot add a clean-record requirement and refuse to seat a member-elect who meets the Constitution’s three qualifications of age, citizenship, and inhabitancy.

The reasoning behind that result matters as much as the result. The House argued that Article I, Section 5 gives it broad power to decide who is fit to serve, including the power to set qualifications beyond the constitutional three. The Court rejected that reading after a long historical survey running from English election disputes through the Constitutional Convention: the precedents showed that exclusion had historically required an expulsion first, and that by the founding era the arbitrary power to exclude a duly elected person the majority deemed unfit had been repudiated. The opinion therefore drew the line that still governs: judging elections, returns, and qualifications means verifying the three standing qualifications, not grading character, conduct, or pending legal trouble. A member-elect who is twenty-five, has been a citizen for seven years, and inhabits the state of election clears the constitutional bar at the door, whatever else appears in a court file.

The principle still draws citations. In United States v. Rahimi, No. 22-915 (2024), decided June 21, 2024, Justice Kavanaugh’s concurring opinion in the Supreme Court of the United States invoked Powell v. McCormack, 395 U.S. at 546-547, for the rule that history contrary to clear constitutional text is not followed. Rahimi shows the text-controls logic of Powell at work in 2024: where the Constitution speaks plainly, later practice cannot rewrite it — the same reason a House majority cannot add qualifications the constitutional text does not contain.

North Carolina adds a disclosure duty of its own, and its wording matters. N.C.G.S. Sec. 163-106(e) requires every candidate to file a statement answering the question: “Have you ever been convicted of a felony?” A candidate who answers yes must supply the offense, the conviction date, the date citizenship rights were restored, and the county and state of conviction. Two limits in that same statute matter here. First, the question asks about convictions, not pending charges: a summons or an unresolved allegation is not a conviction to disclose. Second, the form itself must explain that “a prior felony conviction does not preclude holding elective office if the candidate’s rights of citizenship have been restored.” A charge, in other words, neither adds a qualification nor triggers the disclosure duty that a conviction would.

B. Removal takes two-thirds, and states cannot add disqualifications

Seating and removing are different powers, and the Constitution treats them differently. The same Article I, Section 5 that provides that “Each House shall be the Judge of the Elections, Returns and Qualifications of its own Members” also provides that each house may, “with the Concurrence of two thirds, expel a Member.” Exclusion happens at the door, by majority vote, and Powell confines it to the three constitutional qualifications. Expulsion happens after seating and requires a supermajority. A November 7, 2023 report of the Congressional Research Service, published by the Library of Congress as guidance rather than as law itself, explains the distinction and notes the historical record: “To date, 20 Members of Congress have been expelled: 5 in the House and 15 in the Senate.” The report, Expulsion of Members of Congress: Legal Authority and Historical Practice, adds that a large majority of those expulsions rested on conduct deemed disloyal at the outset of the Civil War, while the two most recent expulsions at the time of writing followed members’ convictions on public corruption charges. The practical consequence is a two-step test for anyone asking whether a conviction ends service: a conviction alone does not vacate a seat, and only the House itself, by a two-thirds vote, can expel a seated member.

The Congressional Research Service report presses one subtlety that readers often miss. Powell bars the House from adding qualifications through exclusion, yet the opinion kept exclusion and expulsion analytically separate: what the House cannot do by majority vote at the door, it may do by a two-thirds vote once the member is seated. That formalism is deliberate, because expulsion carries its own supermajority safeguard and its own political accountability. History bears out how rarely the power is used. After the Civil War-era expulsions for disloyalty, the modern pattern ties expulsion to convictions, and each case required the House to assemble two-thirds of its members behind removal. The lesson for a pending charge is therefore double: the charge itself supplies no exclusion authority under Powell, and only a seated House acting by supermajority could convert even a later conviction into removal.

Short of expulsion, the House polices its own through conduct rules that carry moral and political weight but operate as internal guidance. The House Code of Official Conduct provides that a member who has been indicted for or otherwise formally charged with a felony for which a sentence of two or more years’ imprisonment may be imposed “should resign from any standing, select, joint or ad hoc committee” and step aside from party leadership posts until acquittal, dismissal, or reduction below a felony. After conviction of such an offense, the same code says the member should refrain from committee participation and from voting on the floor until the presumption of innocence is reinstated through judicial or executive proceedings or until reelection. These are “should” rules of the institution, not criminal statutes, and they confirm the larger pattern: the system answers a conviction with internal restriction and possible expulsion, never with automatic forfeiture of the seat.

Federal law also blocks the other tempting shortcut: asking a state to do what the House will not. In Trump v. Anderson, No. 23-719 (2024), decided March 4, 2024 and reported at 601 U.S. 100, the Supreme Court of the United States reversed a state court’s exclusion of a federal candidate from the ballot, holding: “Because the Constitution makes Congress, rather than the States, responsible for enforcing Section 3 against federal officeholders and candidates, we reverse.” Anderson supplies the enforcement boundary: a state cannot enforce its own disqualification against a federal officeholder or candidate, because the Constitution assigns that enforcement role to Congress. A 2026 decision shows courts applying that boundary to dismiss bare disqualification suits. In Newcomb v. Gray, 2026 WY 20 (Wyo. 2026), decided February 13, 2026, a voter asked a Wyoming court to declare a state officer removed from office under Section 3 of the Fourteenth Amendment, invoking Trump v. Anderson, 601 U.S. 100, 110-11 (2024). The Wyoming Supreme Court affirmed dismissal, opening: “Concluding Mr. Newcomb failed to state a claim on which relief can be granted, we affirm.” Newcomb shows the practical bite of Anderson in 2026: courts treat the federal-enforcement framework as the gate, and allegations alone do not open it. For a reader tracking a North Carolina federal race, the combined lesson is symmetrical: neither a state prosecution nor a state court can keep a qualified member-elect out of the House, and neither can manufacture a federal disqualification the Constitution does not contain.

II. What does the North Carolina charge itself require?

A. Larceny or unauthorized use: the charge label controls the exposure

North Carolina draws a sharp line between stealing property and misusing a vehicle, and the reported charge sits on the serious side of it. Under N.C.G.S. Sec. 14-72(a), “Larceny of goods of the value of more than one thousand dollars ($1,000) is a Class H felony.” A rental car valued at $20,000, as the summons papers describe, clears that threshold by an order of magnitude, which matches the reported Class H classification. The neighboring statute covers the lesser wrong. Under N.C.G.S. Sec. 14-72.2, a person commits unauthorized use of a motor-propelled conveyance by taking or operating another’s motor vehicle without express or implied consent, but for ordinary vehicles the offense is a Class 1 misdemeanor; only unauthorized use of an aircraft is a Class H felony. The charging choice therefore decides the case’s weight before any evidence is heard: larceny theory means felony exposure, while unauthorized-use theory would mean a misdemeanor.

The distinction is not academic wordplay, and North Carolina’s highest court has enforced it strictly. In State v. Robinson, 368 N.C. 402 (N.C. 2015), decided November 6, 2015, the Supreme Court of North Carolina considered a defendant who kept a roommate’s car beyond the permission he claimed he had. The court held: “We hold that unauthorized use of a motor vehicle is not a lesser-included offense of possession of a stolen vehicle because the former offense contains an essential element that is not an essential element of the latter offense.” Robinson supplies the charging-line lesson for rental-car cases: unauthorized use and larceny-type vehicle offenses turn on different elements, so the label on the charge sheet matters more than the mere fact that a car is involved. Readers should treat this November 2015 decision as historical background only, because later North Carolina decisions and current charging practice may refine how prosecutors distinguish larceny from unauthorized use, so anyone facing such a charge should confirm the current elements with North Carolina counsel. The boundary matters concretely for an unreturned rental: prosecutors proceeding on a larceny theory must prove the taking element of larceny, including the intent the statute requires, while the unauthorized-use path centers on the absence of consent. A renter who missed a return date during a documented emergency and a renter who sold the car present different evidentiary pictures, and the statute sorts them into different offenses with very different consequences.

The facts of Robinson show why consent disputes dominate these cases. The defendant said his roommate lent him a Lexus in exchange for drugs and agreed he could leave it near a restaurant the next day; the roommate said he never gave permission at all. The court did not resolve that credibility fight in the abstract; it resolved the legal question underneath it, namely which offense fits which version of events. That is the same structure a rental-car file presents: the rental agreement proves initial lawful possession, the due date proves when permission expired, and everything after that date tests whether the state can prove a larcenous taking with the required intent or only an unauthorized use without consent. Delinquency alone does not pick the theory; the evidence of intent does, and the two statutes price the theories an order of magnitude apart.

What the charge can cost is calibrated, not fixed. Felony punishment in North Carolina runs through a structured chart: N.C.G.S. Sec. 15A-1340.17 sets punishment for each class of offense by prior record level, so the same Class H conviction produces different ranges for a first offender and for someone with an extensive record. News accounts describe the exposure for this Class H charge as ranging from about four months to more than three years, depending on record and circumstances. That spread is the reason the record-level mechanism deserves attention: two defendants convicted of the identical offense can face very different sentences, and prior convictions, their number, and their timing all feed the calculation. Separately, the disclosure lesson from Section I bears repeating in statutory terms. Because N.C.G.S. Sec. 163-106(e) asks only “Have you ever been convicted of a felony?”, a pending charge answers nothing on that form. If a conviction ever followed, the disclosure duty and the citizenship-rights-restoration paperwork would attach at that point, exactly as the statute provides.

B. From summons to sworn in: the checks that still matter

The next procedural fact is the least dramatic and the most misunderstood: a court date is not a trial. The representative-elect was charged by criminal summons rather than arrest warrant, with service in October 2026 on papers first issued in January 2020 and returned unserved the next month, according to the dated reporting on the clerk-confirmed file. Two Charlotte-area criminal lawyers told the Charlotte Observer in a November 5, 2026 report that charging a felony by summons is extraordinarily unusual and that they expect dismissal or reduction, while cautioning that prosecutors may first ask for time to review stale evidence and locate witnesses. Those are defense lawyers’ assessments of one case, not predictions any reader should bank on, but they identify the real pressure points in an aging rental-car file: proof of willfulness, the paper trail of notices and demands from the rental company, and the whereabouts of records and witnesses seven years later. On willfulness, the same reporting notes the central evidentiary fight: prosecutors would need to establish that the car was willfully kept rather than lost to circumstances, a distinction that turns on documents and testimony, not on the fact that a due date passed. Anyone in a comparable situation should preserve every rental agreement, receipt, notice, message, payment record, and piece of travel or medical documentation from the rental period, because each one speaks to consent, notice, or intent.

Local practitioners also map the realistic exits. One former public defender cited in the November 5, 2026 reporting said the representative-elect could negotiate a reduced misdemeanor charge, a deferred-prosecution agreement, or a conditional discharge, outcomes that can allow a defendant to avoid a permanent conviction after meeting court-ordered conditions. The same reporting notes the human context she has offered publicly: she has said she was experiencing homelessness around the time of the alleged offense and has described a past medical emergency that required intensive care and disrupted her financial stability, though she has not directly tied those circumstances to the rental dispute. None of that context is a legal defense by itself, but each piece feeds the willfulness inquiry or a negotiation posture, which is why preserving records and statements from the period matters more than public commentary about the case.

Three further checks complete the picture. First, track the docket, not the headlines: the Mecklenburg County clerk’s office has confirmed the summons file is viewable on the state courts’ portal under case number 20CR201748-590, and the file, not commentary, shows whether the November 10 appearance produces a continuance, a dismissal, a reduction, or a plea. Second, separate the criminal track from the congressional track. Even if the case ended in conviction, the seat would not empty by operation of law; the House conduct rules described above would then govern committee service and floor voting as internal guidance, and only a two-thirds expulsion vote could remove a seated member. The presumption of innocence that the House code itself references when it describes reinstating that presumption after proceedings end applies with full force while the charge is pending: an allegation in a summons is something the state must still prove. Third, mind the calendar interaction. A continuance past the January seating would leave both tracks running at once: service in Congress under the qualifications rule of Powell, and defense of a state felony case under the elements and sentencing rules of Raleigh. Neither track decides the other, and confusing them is the costliest mistake a reader can make.

Conclusion

A pending charge and a congressional seat run on separate rails. Federal law seats every member-elect who meets the Constitution’s three qualifications of age, citizenship, and inhabitancy, and only a two-thirds vote of the House can expel a seated member. North Carolina law, in turn, punishes larceny of high-value property as a Class H felony while treating ordinary unauthorized use of a vehicle as a misdemeanor, calibrates any felony sentence to the defendant’s record, and asks candidates only about convictions. The remaining work in any comparable matter is evidentiary and procedural: test willfulness against the documents, watch the docket entry by entry, and measure every consequence against the statute or rule that actually imposes it rather than against assumption.

📄 Official circular