Your grandfather has died owning a house in France. Your mother, his daughter, died before him, so you and your sister step into her place in the succession (estate distribution) alongside your uncle. You both live outside France, you have never filed anything with the French tax administration, and the first figure you find online is a €100,000 allowance for children. That figure is real, but it does not work the way most foreign grandchildren expect: where grandchildren take by representation (représentation, taking the place of a parent who predeceased or renounced), the €100,000 belongs to the represented child’s share and is divided between them, it is not granted in full to each grandchild. French inheritance tax, the droits de succession (death duties charged on each beneficiary), is then charged on each person’s net share at the direct-line rates, under a filing deadline that depends on where the deceased died, with late interest and surcharges that run whether or not you knew about the French return. This article works through that position in order: when France taxes a grandchild who lives abroad, how the shared allowance and the rates produce an actual bill on French property, when the déclaration de succession (inheritance tax return) must be filed, and what can still be done about foreign tax on the same assets or about a French assessment that is wrong. The worked example uses a €400,000 French house and the amounts are computed step by step so that you can replace the figures with your own.
I. France inheritance tax for grandchildren: when does France tax a grandchild who lives abroad, and how much is charged?
A. Which assets does France tax when the deceased and the grandchildren live in different countries?
The starting point is territorial, and it has nothing to do with nationality. Article 750 ter of the Code général des impôts (General Tax Code, hereafter CGI) charges droits de mutation à titre gratuit (gift and inheritance transfer duties) in three situations that depend on two connecting factors only: the fiscal domicile (domicile fiscal, tax residence as defined for French income tax) of the deceased, and the location of the assets, with a third situation that looks at the heir’s own fiscal domicile. Nationality, the language of the will and the place where the family lives its everyday life do not appear in the text. A British, American or Australian grandchild is therefore in exactly the same French tax position as a French grandchild living in Lyon if the assets and domiciles line up in the same way, and a French citizen who has lived in Montreal for twenty years is treated as a non-resident heir if his fiscal domicile is in Canada.
The situation that covers most readers of this article is the second one in the article. Where the deceased was not fiscally domiciled in France, France taxes, under Article 750 ter of the CGI, « Les biens meubles et immeubles, que ces derniers soient possédés directement ou indirectement, situés en France » (movable and immovable assets situated in France, whether the immovables are held directly or indirectly), « lorsque le donateur ou le défunt n’a pas son domicile fiscal en France au sens de l’article précité » (where the donor or the deceased does not have his fiscal domicile in France within the meaning of the article referred to). Read together, those two halves mean that a grandfather who lived and was tax-resident in London, Toronto or Sydney until his death still leaves a French inheritance tax bill on the house in the Dordogne, the flat in Paris and the French bank or securities assets that count as French under the same article, and each grandchild pays on the French share he or she actually receives. Assets situated outside France, the house in Kent or the portfolio held with a broker in New York, stay outside the French charge in this second situation. The administrative commentary restates the same three-way division and is the first place to check a borderline asset: see the BOFiP commentary on the territoriality of gratuitous transfer duties, which follows Article 750 ter asset by asset.
The first situation is wider and catches families who assume that living abroad takes the whole estate out of France. Where the deceased did have his fiscal domicile in France, the charge covers movable and immovable assets whether they are situated in France or outside France, « lorsque le donateur ou le défunt a son domicile fiscal en France au sens de l’article 4 B » (where the donor or the deceased has his fiscal domicile in France within the meaning of Article 4 B). A grandmother who retired to Provence and was fiscally domiciled there at her death therefore brings her foreign bank accounts and her foreign shares into the French return as well, even though every grandchild lives abroad and even though the foreign bank will also report the death at home. The third situation works in the opposite direction and matters when the deceased lived abroad but a grandchild has moved to France: assets received from a donor or deceased domiciled outside France are taxed in France in the hands of an heir who is fiscally domiciled in France, but only under a duration condition in Article 750 ter, since « cette disposition ne s’applique que lorsque l’héritier, le donataire ou le bénéficiaire d’un trust a eu son domicile fiscal en France pendant au moins six années au cours des dix dernières années précédant celle au cours de laquelle il reçoit les biens » (this provision applies only where the heir, donee or trust beneficiary has had his fiscal domicile in France for at least six years during the ten years preceding the year in which he receives the assets). A grandchild who moved to Bordeaux three years ago does not, on that text alone, pull a foreign grandfather’s foreign assets into French inheritance tax; a grandchild who has been fiscally domiciled in France for seven of the last ten years does.
Fiscal domicile itself is defined by Article 4 B of the CGI. A person is treated as fiscally domiciled in France if, among the alternative tests in the article, he or she counts among « Les personnes qui ont en France leur foyer ou le lieu de leur séjour principal » (persons who have their home or their main place of stay in France), exercises a professional activity in France other than on an accessory basis, or has the centre of his or her economic interests in France. The article then subordinates those domestic tests to treaty residence, in terms every cross-border family should read before assuming that days counted in France settle the question: « Les personnes qui satisfont à l’un au moins des critères fixés aux a à c du présent 1 ne peuvent toutefois pas être considérées comme ayant leur domicile fiscal en France lorsque, par application des conventions internationales relatives aux doubles impositions, elles ne sont pas regardées comme résidentes de France. » (Persons satisfying at least one of the criteria in (a) to (c) of paragraph 1 cannot, however, be regarded as fiscally domiciled in France where, under international double taxation conventions, they are not regarded as residents of France.) In practice the family should therefore establish two facts with documents, not impressions, before any calculation is attempted: where was the deceased fiscally domiciled at death under Article 4 B as corrected by any applicable treaty, and which assets are situated in France under Article 750 ter. Everything else in this article follows from those two answers.
The location test has traps that catch grandchildren who think in terms of land alone. Article 750 ter of the CGI deems certain intangible assets to be French even though no stone sits in France: « Sont considérées comme françaises les créances sur un débiteur qui est établi en France ou qui y a son domicile fiscal au sens du même article ainsi que les valeurs mobilières émises par l’Etat français, une personne morale de droit public française ou une société qui a en France son siège social statutaire ou le siège de sa direction effective, et ce quelle que soit la composition de son actif. » (The following are treated as French: claims against a debtor established in France or fiscally domiciled there, and securities issued by the French State, a French public-law body or a company whose registered office or effective management seat is in France, whatever the composition of its assets.) Shares in a French société civile immobilière (SCI, a civil company commonly used to hold French real estate) that owns the family house are therefore French assets in the grandchildren’s hands, and the same article looks through chains of companies where the deceased, alone or with a defined family group, held more than half of the shares of an entity owning French real estate, with a carve-out for buildings used in that entity’s own industrial, commercial, agricultural or professional business. A grandchild who is told that grandfather “only held company shares abroad” should not close the file at that point: unlisted shares in a foreign company whose assets consist mainly of French land or property rights are also treated as French in proportion to those French assets. Conversely, a portfolio of foreign shares held through a foreign broker, foreign bank deposits and a foreign holiday home are not French assets in the second situation described above, and listing them on a French return in that situation overstates the bill.
One confusion must be cleared away at once, because it produces expensive mistakes in both directions. The law that decides who inherits, whether a will is valid and whether grandchildren can take their late parent’s place is not the law that decides the tax. For successions with a European connection, Regulation (EU) No 650/2012 makes the law of the deceased’s habitual residence at death the law applicable to the succession as a whole (Article 21(1)), and allows a person to choose instead the law of a State whose nationality he possesses when making the choice or at death (Article 22(1)). A grandfather could therefore choose the law of his nationality to govern who gets what. That choice does not choose the tax: Article 1(1) of the same Regulation excludes revenue, customs and administrative matters from its scope. The civil law of the succession and the French tax charge under Article 750 ter run on separate tracks: the first track tells the notaire (notary, the public officer who settles most French successions involving real estate) how to divide the house, the second tells each grandchild what France charges on the French share received. A will that validly leaves outright shares to grandchildren under a foreign civil law still leaves each of them to be taxed in France under the French relationship scale that fits the way he or she takes, which is the subject of the next section.
B. France inheritance tax grandchildren: why the €100,000 allowance is shared, and a step-by-step calculation on a €400,000 house
France does not charge one tax on the estate as a pot. Article 777 of the CGI opens with the sentence that governs every calculation in this section: « Les droits de mutation à titre gratuit sont fixés aux taux indiqués dans les tableaux ci-après, pour la part nette revenant à chaque ayant droit » (gratuitous transfer duties are set at the rates shown in the following tables, on the net share falling to each beneficiary). Each grandchild is therefore computed separately: net share received, minus the allowance that attaches to that share, then the rate scale for the relationship between that grandchild and the deceased. Two consequences follow that foreign families regularly miss. First, splitting a house between several grandchildren splits the computation, so the number of takers changes the total French bill even where the house value does not move. Second, the relationship is assessed taker by taker, so a grandchild taking by representation, a child taking in his own name and an unrelated legatee named in the same will can face three different allowances and three different rate scales on shares of the same property.
The allowance that dominates grandchild cases is in Article 779(I) of the CGI: « il est effectué un abattement de 100 000 € sur la part de chacun des ascendants et sur la part de chacun des enfants vivants ou représentés par suite de prédécès ou de renonciation » (an allowance of €100,000 is made on the share of each ascendant and on the share of each child, living or represented following predeath or renunciation). The words to hold on to are “représentés par suite de prédécès ou de renonciation”: the €100,000 is granted on the represented child’s share. The next sentence of the article then divides it: « Entre les représentants des enfants prédécédés ou renonçants, cet abattement se divise d’après les règles de la dévolution légale. » (As between the representatives of children who predeceased or renounced, this allowance is divided according to the rules of legal devolution.) Two grandchildren who together step into their late mother’s place therefore share one €100,000 allowance between them in the same proportions as they share her portion of the estate; they do not each receive €100,000. Three grandchildren representing the same child share the same €100,000 three ways. The error in the other direction exists as well: grandchildren sometimes file with no child allowance at all because a website told them that grandchildren only get a small allowance, which overpays the tax where they genuinely take by representation. The correct question is never “what is the grandchild allowance in France?” in the abstract. It is: does this grandchild take as representative of a predeceased or renouncing child, in which case a divided share of that child’s €100,000 applies, or does he or she take in another capacity, for example as a direct legatee under a will while his or her own parent is alive and also inherits? In that second capacity Article 779 grants no separate €100,000 to the grandchild, and the fallback in Article 788(IV) of the CGI is the only general allowance left in the texts cited here: « A défaut d’autre abattement, à l’exception de celui mentionné au III, un abattement de 1 594 € est opéré sur chaque part successorale. » (Failing any other allowance, other than the one mentioned in paragraph III, an allowance of €1,594 is made on each share in the succession.) The gap between a shared €100,000 and €1,594 is the single largest computational fork in a grandchild file, and it turns on the civil-law capacity in which the grandchild takes, which is why the notaire’s devolution must be settled before the tax arithmetic starts.
Two related allowance points complete the picture for the families who read this article with several generations on the kitchen table. First, the surviving spouse or civil partner of the deceased is outside the charge altogether under Article 796-0 bis of the CGI: « Sont exonérés de droits de mutation par décès le conjoint survivant et le partenaire lié au défunt par un pacte civil de solidarité. » (The surviving spouse and the partner bound to the deceased by a civil solidarity pact are exempt from death duties.) Where a grandmother survives and takes a share or a usufruct (usufruit, a right to use property and take its income for life), her position is not computed with an allowance and a scale; she is exempt on what she receives by death, and the grandchildren are computed on their own shares. Second, previous gifts eat the allowance and the lower bands. Article 784 of the CGI requires earlier gifts by the deceased to the same taker to be brought back into the computation, « à l’exception de celles passées depuis plus de quinze ans » (except those made more than fifteen years earlier), and provides that allowances already used on those earlier gifts are taken into account. A grandfather who gave his daughter €80,000 ten years before his death has therefore already consumed most of the €100,000 allowance that her children now expect to share by representation, and a return that ignores a declarable earlier gift understates the bill in a way the administration can rebuild from its own gift records. Grandchildren living abroad should ask, before filing, what registered gifts the deceased made to their parent and to themselves inside the fifteen-year window, and obtain the dates and amounts rather than guessing.
The rate scale for grandchildren taking in the direct line is Table I of Article 777, the tarif applicable en ligne directe (scale applicable in the direct line). On each taker’s taxable share after allowance, the bands in the version of the article read for this article are: 5% on the slice up to €8,072; 10% on the slice between €8,072 and €12,109; 15% on the slice between €12,109 and €15,932; 20% on the slice between €15,932 and €552,324; 30% on the slice between €552,324 and €902,838; 40% on the slice between €902,838 and €1,805,677; and 45% above €1,805,677. These are band rates on successive slices, not a flat rate on the whole share: a taxable share of €50,000 is not taxed at 20% throughout, it pays 5%, 10% and 15% on the first slices and 20% only on the part above €15,932. By contrast, the same article taxes brothers and sisters at 35% up to €24,430 and 45% above that threshold, relatives up to the fourth degree at 55%, and more distant relatives and unrelated persons at 60%, which is why a will that bypasses the direct line changes the French bill so sharply; readers dealing with a stepchild rather than a blood grandchild should read the separate analysis of French inheritance tax for stepchildren, the 60% rate and the adoption exception instead of transposing the figures below.
The worked example can now be computed without any hidden step. Take a French house valued, net of deductible amounts as declared, at €400,000. The deceased grandfather was fiscally domiciled outside France, so only the French house is in the French charge under the second situation of Article 750 ter. He leaves a son, who takes one half in his own name, and two grandchildren, the children of his predeceased daughter, who together take the other half by representation in equal shares. No earlier gift inside fifteen years has consumed any allowance, and there is no surviving spouse taking a share in this example. The son receives €200,000, deducts his own €100,000 allowance under Article 779(I), and is taxed on €100,000: €8,072 at 5% gives €403.60; the next €4,037 (up to €12,109) at 10% gives €403.70; the next €3,823 (up to €15,932) at 15% gives €573.45; and the remaining €84,068 at 20% gives €16,813.60; his French bill is €18,194.35. Each grandchild receives €100,000, but the allowance is their late mother’s €100,000 divided between the two representatives, so each deducts €50,000 and is taxed on €50,000: €403.60 plus €403.70 plus €573.45 on the first three slices as above, plus 20% of the remaining €34,068, which is €6,813.60, for a bill of €8,194.35 each. The family’s total French inheritance tax on the €400,000 house in this example is therefore €34,583.05. Had each grandchild wrongly deducted a full €100,000, each would have filed and paid nothing on a €100,000 share, understating the family’s French tax by €16,388.70 before interest and surcharges; had they wrongly been given only the €1,594 fallback, each would have overpaid by several thousand euros. Replace the house value, the number of representatives and any earlier gifts with your own figures and run the same four operations in the same order: identify the French assets, fix each taker’s civil capacity, deduct the allowance that truly attaches to that share, then apply the bands slice by slice.
II. Filing the French return from abroad: deadline, late penalties, foreign tax credit and how to challenge an assessment
A. When must the déclaration de succession be filed, and what does filing late cost?
The deadline is the point on which grandchildren living abroad most often lose money without any dispute about the tax itself, because the French clock starts at the death and runs while the family is still dealing with probate, a Grant, an Erbschein or a home-country estate return that works to a different timetable. Article 641 of the CGI fixes the periods for registering the declarations that heirs, donees and legatees must file for assets passing to them by death in these terms: « De six mois, à compter du jour du décès, lorsque celui dont on recueille la succession est décédé en France métropolitaine; D’une année, dans tous les autres cas. » (Six months from the day of death where the person whose succession is being collected died in metropolitan France; one year in all other cases.) Two features of that sentence decide most real files. First, the trigger is the place of death, not the heir’s address and not the location of the house: a grandfather who was tax-resident in Ireland, died in Dublin and left a house in Brittany gives his grandchildren the one-year period, while the same grandfather dying during a stay in metropolitan France gives them six months even though every heir lives abroad. Second, the period runs from the death itself; the BOFiP commentary on the periods for filing the inheritance return treats the Article 641 period as a strict period running from the day of death and then lists the special starting points it recognises, for example where devolution is contested in court or where no heir was known at the death, none of which a family should assume in its own case without checking the conditions in that commentary. The practical consequence is blunt: the date of death and the place of death should be written at the top of the file on day one, and the French deadline should be diarised from those two facts before the home-country probate timetable is allowed to set the pace.
Filing late costs money under two separate mechanisms that are frequently confused, and the confusion matters because only one of them rewards putting the return in quickly once the delay is discovered. The first is late interest, the intérêt de retard. Article 1727(III) of the CGI provides: « Le taux de l’intérêt de retard est de 0,20 % par mois. » (The rate of late interest is 0.20% per month.) Article 1727(IV) then provides that « L’intérêt de retard est calculé à compter du premier jour du mois suivant celui au cours duquel l’impôt devait être acquitté jusqu’au dernier jour du mois du paiement. » (Late interest is computed from the first day of the month following the month in which the tax should have been paid until the last day of the month of payment.) Interest at that monthly rate is compensation for late payment of a sum that was due; it is computed by reference to when the tax should have been paid, so discovering the French obligation a year after a death abroad does not restart the interest clock at the date of discovery. On the €8,194.35 bill of each grandchild in the example above, every month counted under that rule adds 0.20% of the unpaid tax, about €16.39 per month per grandchild before any surcharge is considered, a figure that looks small in isolation and stops looking small when it has run for two or three years across an entire family.
The second mechanism is the surcharge for late filing, and for inheritance returns the general surcharge article contains a special timetable that must be read instead of the headline rates quoted for other taxes. Article 1728(2) of the CGI provides, for the declarations covered by Article 800 of the CGI, which include the déclaration de succession, that « la majoration de 10 % est applicable à partir du premier jour du septième mois suivant celui de l’expiration des délais de six mois et de vingt-quatre mois prévus respectivement aux articles 641 et 641 bis » (the 10% surcharge is applicable from the first day of the seventh month following the month in which the six-month and twenty-four-month periods provided for in Articles 641 and 641 bis respectively expire). The same paragraph of Article 1728 then raises the stakes once the administration has formally demanded the return: « La majoration de 40 % s’applique lorsque cette déclaration n’a pas été déposée dans les quatre-vingt-dix jours suivant la réception d’une mise en demeure d’avoir à la produire dans ce délai. » (The 40% surcharge applies where the return has not been filed within the ninety days following receipt of a formal demand to produce it within that period.) Two lessons follow for a grandchild who opens French post, or a letter forwarded by the notaire, long after the death. The first is that the surcharge position deteriorates in steps, so the date on which any mise en demeure (formal demand) was received is a document to preserve and count from, not a letter to leave in a drawer while the family discusses valuations. The second is that paying money on account does not cure the absence of a return: the BOFiP commentary cited above states that, failing regularisation within ninety days of notification of a formal demand, persons who have not presented a regular inheritance return within the legal period are assessed ex officio (taxées d’office), and that interim payments made on account do not change that analysis. A family that cannot yet finalise a valuation should still take advice on filing a return that can later be supplemented, rather than treating silence as neutral; silence is the posture that the surcharge and ex officio machinery is designed to tax.
None of this requires the grandchildren to move to France or to solve the whole succession before the French deadline. It requires a short sequence of concrete acts, in this order. Establish the death date, the place of death and the resulting Article 641 period, and record any formal demand already received with its date of receipt. Instruct the notaire who is settling the French real estate, or take French advice where there is no real estate, so that the devolution is fixed in writing: who takes, in what capacity, and in what fractions, including whether each grandchild takes by representation. Value the French assets asset by asset and keep the valuation evidence with the return file, because the value of the house is the figure the administration is most likely to test later and the figure on which interest and surcharges will be computed if it is raised. List every earlier gift by the deceased to each taker inside the fifteen-year window of Article 784, with dates, so that allowances and bands are not claimed twice. Compute each taker separately under Articles 779 and 777 as in Part I, then file and pay with a record that proves both the filing date and the payment date. Families who follow that order usually discover that the French return is a finite piece of work; families who reverse it, by arguing about who should keep the house for a year before anyone looks at Article 641, pay for the same return plus interest.
B. Can you credit inheritance tax paid abroad against the French bill, and how do you challenge a French assessment that is wrong?
Double taxation is the second fear in every cross-border grandchild file, and French domestic law answers it more narrowly than most families expect. The credit mechanism is Article 784 A of the CGI, which provides in full: « Dans les cas définis aux 1° et 3° de l’article 750 ter , le montant des droits de mutation à titre gratuit acquitté, le cas échéant, hors de France est imputable sur l’impôt exigible en France. Cette imputation est limitée à l’impôt acquitté sur les biens meubles et immeubles situés hors de France. » (In the cases defined in 1° and 3° of Article 750 ter, the amount of gratuitous transfer duties paid, where applicable, outside France is creditable against the tax payable in France. That credit is limited to the tax paid on movable and immovable assets situated outside France.) Every word of the limitation matters. The credit exists in the first and third situations of Article 750 ter, the situations in which France taxes worldwide assets because the deceased was fiscally domiciled in France or because the heir is fiscally domiciled in France for the required duration, and it is limited to foreign tax paid on assets situated outside France. It follows from the text that the credit does not, by itself, solve the most common grandchild complaint in the second situation: grandfather domiciled abroad, grandchildren abroad, French house taxed in France and the same house also brought into charge at home under a foreign estate or inheritance tax. In that second situation Article 784 A grants no French credit for the foreign tax on the French house, because neither its opening words nor its limitation cover the case. Relief for that overlap, where it exists, must be found in an applicable inheritance or estate tax treaty or in the foreign system’s own credit for French tax paid on French-situs property, and those instruments differ sharply by country pair, which is why the country-specific guides must be read alongside this general analysis: for an heir taxed in Ireland on the same French house, see French inheritance tax and the Irish heir’s foreign tax credit on a French house, and for United States citizens, see French inheritance tax for US citizens under the 1978 US-France estate treaty, instead of assuming that an income tax treaty, which does not govern death duties, has already solved the problem.
Where Article 784 A does apply, its scope has been litigated on a point that matters to any family whose foreign tax was computed on a different base from the French tax, for example on full ownership abroad against bare ownership (nue-propriété, ownership stripped of the usufruct) in France. The BOFiP commentary on the credit for taxes paid outside France first narrows what counts as creditable tax: only the foreign death or gift duties strictly so called can be credited, to the exclusion of the penalties, fines and late interest to which they may have given rise. Foreign penalties and foreign late interest therefore do not reduce a French bill even where the foreign duty itself does. The Paris Court of Appeal then answered the base question in favour of the taxpayer in a gift case governed by the same Article 784 A mechanism (CA Paris, pôle 5, chambre 10, 26 May 2025, No 22/17215). The administration had reduced the creditable Swiss tax in proportion to the French bare-ownership value, because the canton had taxed full ownership while France taxed only the bare ownership given to the children. The court rejected that reduction, holding that « l’application de ce texte justifie de prendre en compte, pour l’imputation, le montant de l’impôt acquitté en raison même de la mutation des biens situés à l’étranger indépendamment de ses modalités de calcul » (the application of this text warrants taking into account, for the credit, the amount of tax paid by reason of the very transfer of the assets situated abroad, independently of the way in which it was computed), and ordered the additional refund claimed in that case; the full text is available on the Cour de cassation open data portal, decision 683547217e87f966fe0214f6. Grandchildren should read that decision for what it decides and no more: it construes the existing Article 784 A credit where that article applies, it does not create a credit in the second situation of Article 750 ter, and it does not dispense with proof. The BOFiP commentary requires the claim to be documented, with a dedicated form (imprimé n° 2740) delivered by the non-residents’ tax office and supporting evidence of the foreign duty actually paid, so foreign assessments, receipts and exchange-rate evidence should be gathered while the foreign file is still open, not reconstructed years later from bank statements.
The last question is what to do when the French bill itself is wrong: a house valued too high, a foreign asset wrongly treated as French, a full €100,000 refused where representation genuinely applies, an allowance already consumed by a gift that is in fact more than fifteen years old, or a surcharge applied from the wrong date. French tax procedure channels that dispute through a claim before it reaches a judge. Article L. 190 of the Livre des procédures fiscales (Book of Tax Procedures, hereafter LPF) places within contentious jurisdiction claims « lorsqu’elles tendent à obtenir soit la réparation d’erreurs commises dans l’assiette ou le calcul des impositions, soit le bénéfice d’un droit résultant d’une disposition législative ou réglementaire » (where they seek either the correction of errors made in the base or the computation of the taxes, or the benefit of a right arising from a legislative or regulatory provision). A grandchild’s claim should therefore be drafted as an error-correction exercise tied to identified texts, not as a general plea that French tax is high: identify the asset wrongly included or the allowance wrongly refused, cite the article that governs it, attach the valuation or gift-date evidence, and recompute the share band by band so that the administration is asked to substitute a specific figure for a specific figure. If the claim does not produce full satisfaction, jurisdiction for registration duties is judicial rather than administrative. Article L. 199 of the LPF provides: « En matière de droits d’enregistrement, d’impôt sur la fortune immobilière, de taxe de publicité foncière, de droits de timbre, de contributions indirectes et de taxes assimilées à ces droits, taxes ou contributions, le tribunal compétent est le tribunal judiciaire. » (In matters of registration duties, real-estate wealth tax, land publicity tax, stamp duties, indirect contributions and taxes assimilated to those duties, taxes or contributions, the competent court is the judicial court.) Inheritance duty litigation, including the Article 784 A litigation described above, is therefore argued before the tribunal judiciaire (judicial court) and on appeal before the cour d’appel, as the Paris decision itself illustrates, and not before the administrative courts that hear most income tax disputes. Families should not wait for a dispute to become urgent before assembling the claim file: the documents that win these cases are mundane and perishable, namely the death certificate showing the place of death for Article 641, the devolution showing representation for Article 779, dated valuation evidence for the house, the gift deeds and dates for Article 784, and the foreign assessment and proof of payment for Article 784 A.
Conclusion
A grandchild who lives abroad and inherits French property is taxed in France neither because he or she is French nor because the family failed to choose the right law in a will, but because Article 750 ter charges French-situs assets, and in defined cases worldwide assets, by reference to fiscal domicile and asset location. The bill is then personal to each grandchild: the €100,000 direct-line allowance belongs to the represented child’s share and is divided between the grandchildren who represent that child, the direct-line bands of Article 777 apply slice by slice to what remains, earlier gifts inside fifteen years consume allowances and lower bands, and a grandchild who takes otherwise than by representation falls back to the €1,594 allowance in the texts examined here. On a €400,000 French house shared between a son and two representing grandchildren, that machinery produces €18,194.35 for the son and €8,194.35 for each grandchild, a total of €34,583.05, and each of those figures can be checked in four operations from the articles cited. The return that carries those figures must be filed within six months of a death in metropolitan France or one year in other cases, late interest then runs at 0.20% per month, the inheritance-return surcharge has its own stepped timetable, and formal demands must be counted from the date they are received. Foreign tax on the same wealth is creditable in France only inside Article 784 A, for the worldwide-taxation situations and for assets situated outside France, with penalties and interest excluded; the common case of foreign tax on the French house itself must look to a treaty or to the foreign system’s own relief. Where the French assessment misstates the assets, the allowance, the valuation or the dates, the route is a documented claim for correction followed, if necessary, by proceedings before the judicial court. Grandchildren who establish the domicile and situs facts first, fix the devolution second and compute third will usually find that French inheritance tax, however unwelcome, is at least predictable; grandchildren who start from a remembered €100,000 figure and a home-country timetable are the ones who pay interest to learn the French rules in the wrong order.