On Thursday 6 November 2026, an Aer Lingus aircraft flying from Dublin to Rome was rerouted to France and escorted by military aircraft to the airbase at Évreux after a suspected bomb threat, The Irish Times reported. The pilot and co-pilot were questioned by French investigators and then allowed to leave, the public prosecutor for Évreux, Rémi Coutin, told the newspaper. Investigators had been informed that the pilot had initially refused a request to land at the military base, and the newspaper added that investigations were still ongoing. The diversion was one episode in a wider wave of bomb threats aimed at European flights and media organisations that same week, which The Guardian followed live, describing European skies on high alert as more airlines received threats.
For the passengers who boarded in Dublin expecting to land in Rome, the questions are immediate and practical. Can you get your money back when the plane lands in another country? Does the airline owe you the fixed European compensation even though a bomb threat is nobody’s fault? Who pays for the hotel, the meals and the missed connection? And what does the French criminal investigation change for you? This article answers each question with the exact texts that apply in France: European Regulation 261/2004, the Montreal Convention of 1999 and the French Criminal Code, each quoted word for word in French and then explained in English. It covers the diversion scenario in general, so it remains useful whatever the outcome of the Évreux investigation.
I. Diverted to a French airbase: what European law gives every passenger
A flight from Dublin to Rome is an intra-Community flight operated by a Community carrier, so European air passenger law applies in full. The key instrument is Regulation (EC) No 261/2004 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 11 February 2004, which sets common rules on compensation and assistance to passengers. The airline involved is what the Regulation calls the transporteur aérien effectif (operating air carrier), the carrier that actually performs the flight. Three sets of rights matter here: the fixed compensation, the refund or rerouting, and the meals and hotel. They do not all obey the same logic when the cause is a security threat, so each must be examined separately.
A. The EUR 250, 400 or 600 payment: why a bomb threat does not automatically erase compensation
The Regulation gives a fixed sum to passengers of cancelled flights: Article 7 provides « 250 euros pour tous les vols de 1500 kilomètres ou moins » (“EUR 250 for all flights of 1,500 kilometres or less”), « 400 euros pour tous les vols intracommunautaires de plus de 1500 kilomètres et pour tous les autres vols de 1500 à 3500 kilomètres » (“EUR 400 for all intra-Community flights of more than 1,500 kilometres”), and « 600 euros pour tous les vols qui ne relèvent pas des points a) ou b) » (“EUR 600 for all other flights”). A Dublin-Rome flight is an intra-Community flight of more than 1,500 kilometres, so the reference amount is EUR 400. But the airline escapes this payment if it proves what the Regulation calls circonstances extraordinaires (extraordinary circumstances). Article 5(3) states: « Un transporteur aérien effectif n’est pas tenu de verser l’indemnisation prévue à l’article 7 s’il est en mesure de prouver que l’annulation est due à des circonstances extraordinaires qui n’auraient pas pu être évitées même si toutes les mesures raisonnables avaient été prises. » (“An operating air carrier shall not be obliged to pay compensation in accordance with Article 7 if it can prove that the cancellation is caused by extraordinary circumstances which could not have been avoided even if all reasonable measures had been taken.”)
A bomb threat looks like a textbook extraordinary circumstance, and the Regulation’s own recitals point that way: recital 14 explains that « De telles circonstances peuvent se produire, en particulier, en cas d’instabilité politique, de conditions météorologiques incompatibles avec la réalisation du vol concerné, de risques liés à la sécurité, de défaillances imprévues pouvant affecter la sécurité du vol, ainsi que de grèves ayant une incidence sur les opérations d’un transporteur aérien effectif. » (“Such circumstances may, in particular, occur in cases of political instability, meteorological conditions incompatible with the operation of the flight concerned, security risks, unexpected flight safety shortcomings and strikes that affect the operation of an operating air carrier.”) A credible bomb alert is a security risk within the meaning of that recital. The French Court of Cassation applies the controlling European test as recalled on 23 September 2026 in case No 25-14.563 (Air France): « Celles-ci sont définies comme des événements qui, par leur nature ou leur origine, ne sont pas inhérents à l’exercice normal de l’activité du transporteur aérien concerné et qui échappent à la maîtrise effective de celui-ci, ces deux conditions étant cumulatives et devant faire l’objet d’une appréciation au cas par cas (CJUE, 11 mai 2023, TAP Portugal, C 156/22 à C 158/22, point 18). » (“These are defined as events which, by their nature or origin, are not inherent in the normal exercise of the activity of the air carrier concerned and are beyond its actual control, these two conditions being cumulative and assessed case by case.”) A hoax threat phoned in from outside the airline satisfies both cumulative conditions: it is not inherent in running an airline, and the carrier does not control it.
That is not the end of the analysis, for two reasons. First, the burden of proof lies entirely on the airline: it must prove both the extraordinary circumstance and that it took all reasonable measures. A carrier that reroutes passengers late, leaves them without information, or fails to organise onward travel promptly may lose the exemption even though the threat itself was extraordinary. Keep every document that shows what the airline did and when: boarding passes, diversion notices, the actual arrival time at the final destination, and receipts. Second, the legal category of the disruption matters. A diverted aircraft that lands somewhere other than the ticketed destination is generally treated as a cancellation for the passengers concerned, and even a mere delay opens the same fixed right once it reaches three hours. The French courts apply exactly that rule: on 23 September 2026, in case No 25-14.563, the First Civil Chamber recalled that « les passagers de vols retardés bénéficient du droit à indemnisation prévu à l’article 7 de ce règlement lorsqu’ils atteignent leur destination finale trois heures ou plus après l’heure d’arrivée initialement prévue par le transporteur aérien (CJCE, 19 novembre 2009, Sturgeon e.a., C-402/07 et C-432/07). » (“Passengers on delayed flights are entitled to the compensation provided for in Article 7 of that Regulation where they reach their final destination three or more hours after the arrival time originally scheduled by the air carrier.”) A flight forced down at Évreux instead of Rome fits this framework all the more clearly: as the Vueling ruling examined below explains, an aircraft that lands at the wrong airport has not reached the ticketed final destination.
French courts apply this two-step test strictly, and two recent decisions of the First Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation show how. On 23 September 2026, in case No 25-14.563 (Air France), the Court accepted that a passenger’s sudden illness requiring disembarkation « peut caractériser pour le transporteur aérien une circonstance extraordinaire au sens de l’article 5, paragraphe 3, du règlement n° 261/2004 » (“may constitute an extraordinary circumstance for the air carrier within the meaning of Article 5(3) of Regulation No 261/2004”), because such an event is neither inherent in operating an airline nor within its effective control — the same reasoning that covers a hoax bomb threat phoned in from outside. But the same judgment demands exacting proof: the carrier must show both that the event could not have been avoided by measures suited to the situation and that it deployed every available means. The same judgment then examines the carrier's proof just as strictly. Earlier, on 17 February 2021, in case No 19-21.362 (Vueling), the Court ruled on a Milan-Paris flight diverted from Orly to Roissy that the final destination is the airport named on the ticket, not the one where the aircraft actually landed, and that the burden lies with the airline, quashing a judgment that had required the passenger to prove a three-hour delay. The same decision holds that a permanent night-flight ban « ne saurait constituer une circonstance extraordinaire » (“cannot constitute an extraordinary circumstance”). The lesson for Évreux is direct: landing in France is not arriving in Rome, and the airline proves its defence or pays. French civil law states the underlying principle in general terms: Article 1353 of the Civil Code provides « Celui qui réclame l’exécution d’une obligation doit la prouver. Réciproquement, celui qui se prétend libéré doit justifier le paiement ou le fait qui a produit l’extinction de son obligation. » (“Anyone who claims performance of an obligation must prove it. Conversely, anyone who claims to be discharged must prove payment or the fact that extinguished the obligation.”)
The practical consequence for the Dublin-Rome passengers is therefore a two-step test. If the airline proves a genuine external security threat and irreproachable handling, the EUR 400 fixed sum is not due. If it fails on either point, the compensation stands despite the bomb scare. Beyond the fixed sum, proven individual loss follows a second track, and the carrier's diligence is judged strictly: in case No 25-14.563 the Court of Cassation held that « il incombe au transporteur aérien d’établir […] que ces circonstances exceptionnelles n’auraient pas pu être évitées par des mesures adaptées à la situation » (“it is for the air carrier to establish […] that those extraordinary circumstances could not have been avoided by measures appropriate to the situation”). A carrier that reroutes passengers late, leaves them without information, or fails to organise onward travel promptly may therefore fail this test even though the threat itself was extraordinary. For the rest of the loss — a missed connection, a prepaid hotel night in Rome, a lost working day — French case law draws the boundary precisely: on 10 October 2019, in case No 18-20.491, the Court of Cassation held that the autonomous fixed-sum claim « ne constitue pas une demande d’indemnisation complémentaire liée à un préjudice particulier soumis à la convention de Montréal et […] il s’agit d’une demande autonome entreprise sur le fondement du règlement européen qui se situe en dehors du champ d’application de cette convention » (“is not a claim for complementary compensation linked to specific loss governed by the Montreal Convention and […] is an autonomous claim brought under the European Regulation, which falls outside the scope of that Convention”). Proven individual loss is therefore claimed on the separate Convention track, with invoices and proof, on top of or instead of the fixed sum.
B. Refund within seven days or rerouting, plus meals and hotels: the help the airline must keep providing
Unlike the fixed compensation, assistance and rerouting do not depend on who caused the disruption. When the flight cannot continue as planned, Article 8 of the Regulation offers each passenger a choice between « le remboursement du billet, dans un délai de sept jours, selon les modalités visées à l’article 7, paragraphe 3, au prix auquel il a été acheté, pour la ou les parties du voyage non effectuées et pour la ou les parties du voyage déjà effectuées et devenues inutiles par rapport à leur plan de voyage initial » (“Reimbursement within seven days of the full cost of the ticket at the price at which it was bought, for the part or parts of the journey not made, and for the part or parts already made if the flight is no longer serving any purpose in relation to the passenger’s original travel plan”), and rerouting to the final destination at the earliest opportunity or at a later date at the passenger’s convenience. A passenger diverted to Évreux who no longer wants to travel can therefore demand the ticket price back within seven days for the unused part, including the return leg of a round trip that has become pointless.
While passengers wait, the airline owes what the Regulation calls prise en charge (care): Article 9 provides that « les passagers se voient offrir gratuitement: a) des rafraîchissements et des possibilités de se restaurer en suffisance compte tenu du délai d’attente; b) un hébergement à l’hôtel aux cas où: – un séjour d’attente d’une ou plusieurs nuits est nécessaire, ou – lorsqu’un séjour s’ajoutant à celui prévu par le passager est nécessaire; c) le transport depuis l’aéroport jusqu’au lieu d’hébergement (hôtel ou autre). » (“Passengers shall be offered free of charge: (a) meals and refreshments in a reasonable relation to the waiting time; (b) hotel accommodation in cases where a stay of one or more nights becomes necessary; (c) transport between the airport and place of accommodation”), plus « la possibilité d’effectuer gratuitement deux appels téléphoniques » (“two telephone calls free of charge”). This duty has no financial ceiling and no time limit, even when the disruption comes from an extraordinary event. The wording of the Regulation itself confirms this asymmetry: Article 9 lists the meals, hotel, transport and telephone calls without any exception for extraordinary circumstances, while Article 5(3) excuses only the Article 7 fixed payment. A bomb threat works exactly that way: it may excuse the fixed payment, never the meals, the hotel, or the rerouting.
In practice, passengers diverted to a military base far from Paris should therefore do four things in order. First, ask the airline in writing for rerouting and for written confirmation of the new arrival time, because the three-hour Sturgeon threshold is measured at the final destination. Second, keep every receipt for food, accommodation and transport if the airline fails to provide them directly; these sums are recoverable. Third, file the compensation and expenses claim with the airline, citing Regulation 261/2004 and the Montreal Convention, and keep proof of dispatch. Fourth, if the airline refuses or stays silent, escalate: the French civil aviation authority handles enforcement for incidents on French territory, and the courts remain open, as explained below. Readers who want the general method for contesting a refusal will find it set out step by step in our guide to delayed and cancelled flights in France: EU261 compensation, refunds and how to sue,
II. When France investigates: the criminal case and what it changes for you
The aircraft landed on French soil, so France investigates under French criminal law while European passenger law continues to protect the travellers. The two tracks are independent: the criminal case punishes whoever sent the threat, and it does not take away a single passenger right. Understanding the French side matters all the same, because it explains the questioning of the crew at Évreux, the possible trial that passengers may be asked to follow, and the forum where a full damages claim can be brought.
A. Hoax bomb threats and the questioning of the crew in Évreux: the French rules that applied that day
French criminal law has a dedicated offence for exactly this conduct, often called fausse alerte (false alarm). Article 322-14 of the French Criminal Code provides: « Le fait de communiquer ou de divulguer une fausse information dans le but de faire croire qu’une destruction, une dégradation ou une détérioration dangereuse pour les personnes va être ou a été commise est puni de deux ans d’emprisonnement et de 30 000 euros d’amende. » (“Communicating or disclosing false information in order to make people believe that dangerous destruction, damage or deterioration affecting persons is about to be or has been committed is punished by two years’ imprisonment and a EUR 30,000 fine.”) The same penalties apply to false information suggesting a disaster that triggers a needless emergency response. A bomb threat against an airliner, once its author is identified, falls squarely within this definition and would expose that person to two years’ imprisonment and a EUR 30,000 fine. A related provision punishes threats themselves: Article 322-12 states « La menace de commettre une destruction, une dégradation ou une détérioration dangereuses pour les personnes est punie de six mois d’emprisonnement et de 7 500 euros d’amende lorsqu’elle est soit réitérée, soit matérialisée par un écrit, une image ou tout autre objet. » (“Threatening to commit dangerous destruction, damage or deterioration affecting persons is punished by six months’ imprisonment and a EUR 7,500 fine where it is either repeated or set out in writing, an image or any other object.”) At the date of writing, no author of the threats had been publicly identified, and the Évreux prosecutor indicated that investigations were continuing; the penalties above therefore describe what the law provides, not a sentence against any named person.
The questioning of the pilot and co-pilot follows the ordinary French framework for hearing a person suspected of possibly having committed an offence. The procureur de la République (public prosecutor) directs the investigation, and the Code of Criminal Procedure provides for the audition libre (free hearing) of a suspect who is not in custody. Article 61-1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure requires that such a person « ne peut être entendue librement sur ces faits qu’après avoir été informée » of several rights, including (“may be heard freely about those facts only after being informed”) « Du droit de quitter à tout moment les locaux où elle est entendue » (“of the right to leave the premises where she is being heard at any time”), the right to an interpreter where needed, « Du droit de faire des déclarations, de répondre aux questions qui lui sont posées ou de se taire » (“of the right to make statements, to answer questions or to remain silent”), and, where the offence carries imprisonment, the right to be assisted by a lawyer. The published facts — the crew were heard on Thursday and then allowed to leave France — are consistent with this free-hearing framework rather than with detention, but the investigation continues and no conclusion about anyone’s criminal responsibility can be drawn from a hearing alone. Under French law, as in every rule-of-law state, a person heard as a suspect is presumed innocent unless and until a court convicts.
B. Claiming your full loss in France: the courts you can use and the two clocks
Passengers do not have to choose between the European fixed sums and their real, proven losses: they can combine them. The fixed EUR 250, 400 or 600 under the Regulation compensates standardised inconvenience, while the Montreal Convention compensates the actual damage each passenger proves — the Rome hotel night paid for nothing, the connecting flight bought twice, the business meeting lost. The carrier's only escape on the Convention track is proving diligence. The strictness with which French courts assess such defences is illustrated above: an unavoidable event, appropriate measures, and every available means deployed.
Suing in France for a diversion onto French soil is not an abstraction. In the Vueling diversion dispute, the French courts heard the case at first instance and, after quashing that judgment, the Court of Cassation sent the parties back « devant le tribunal judiciaire de Paris » (“before the Paris judicial court”), in case No 19-21.362. For Dublin-Rome passengers, the practical consequence is to file promptly in an available forum rather than wait for the criminal case: the criminal track and the civil claims run separately, each with its own clock, recalled below. Readers who want the general method for contesting a refusal will find it set out step by step in our guide to delayed and cancelled flights in France: EU261 compensation, refunds and how to sue, which complements this article on the specific bomb-threat diversion scenario.
Passengers are also victims in the criminal sense, and French procedure says so expressly. Article 10-2 of the Code of Criminal Procedure requires investigators to inform victims of their rights, including « D’obtenir la réparation de leur préjudice, par l’indemnisation de celui-ci ou par tout autre moyen adapté » (“to obtain compensation for their loss, by damages or by any other appropriate means”) and « De se constituer partie civile soit dans le cadre d’une mise en mouvement de l’action publique par le parquet, soit par la voie d’une citation directe de l’auteur des faits devant la juridiction compétente ou d’une plainte portée devant le juge d’instruction » (“to become a civil party, either where the prosecution is set in motion by the public prosecutor, or by directly summoning the perpetrator before the competent court, or by complaint to the investigating judge”). The complaint to the investigating judge carries a timing condition worth noting now: Article 85 provides that « la plainte avec constitution de partie civile n’est recevable qu’à condition que la personne justifie soit que le procureur de la République lui a fait connaître […] qu’il n’engagera pas lui-même des poursuites, soit qu’un délai de trois mois s’est écoulé depuis qu’elle a déposé plainte devant ce magistrat » (“a complaint constituting civil-party status is admissible only if the person shows either that the public prosecutor has told her that he will not prosecute, or that three months have elapsed since she complained to that prosecutor”). In practice, victims report first to the prosecutor or the police and use the investigating-judge route if needed — alongside, not instead of, the airline claims described above, which obey their own two-year clock.
Two clocks run in parallel and both must be diarised. For the Convention track, the Court of Cassation recalls in case No 18-20.491 « la prescription biennale fixée à l’article 29 de la convention de Varsovie et à l’article 35 de la convention de Montréal » (“the two-year limitation laid down in Article 29 of the Warsaw Convention and Article 35 of the Montreal Convention”). But it holds that this two-year rule « ne saurait être considérée comme s’appliquant aux actions introduites, en particulier, au titre de ces textes » (“cannot be regarded as applying to actions brought, in particular, under those provisions”) — the fixed-sum actions under Articles 5 and 7 of the Regulation — for which « le délai dans lequel les actions ayant pour objet d’obtenir le versement de l’indemnité prévue aux articles 5 et 7 du règlement n° 261/2004 doivent être intentées, est déterminé par le droit national de chaque Etat membre » (“the time limit for bringing actions for the payment of the compensation provided for in Articles 5 and 7 of Regulation No 261/2004 is determined by the national law of each Member State”). In France, that national clock is Article 2224 of the Civil Code: « Les actions personnelles ou mobilières se prescrivent par cinq ans à compter du jour où le titulaire d’un droit a connu ou aurait dû connaître les faits lui permettant de l’exercer. » (“Personal and movable actions are time-barred after five years from the day the holder of a right knew or ought to have known the facts enabling its exercise.”) This is the correction the Évreux passengers need: five years in France for the fixed European sum, two years for any Convention damages action. Concretely: send the airline a written claim now with the ticket, the diversion notice, the actual arrival details and all receipts; count both deadlines from the disruption; and do not let an unanswered complaint drift past either. No criminal development — identification of the hoaxer, a trial in Évreux, or an acquittal — merges these two civil tracks: each keeps its own clock.
Conclusion
The Aer Lingus diversion to Évreux condenses the whole law of disrupted flights into a single evening: a security threat nobody on board caused, a military escort, a criminal investigation on French soil, and hundreds of passengers asking who pays for the night. The answers divide cleanly. The fixed European compensation of up to EUR 600 may fall away if the airline proves a genuine external threat handled with all reasonable measures, but it survives whenever the carrier fails that proof, and landing at the wrong airport is not arriving, while a three-hour late arrival counts the same way. The refund within seven days, the rerouting, and the meals, hotel and transport never fall away, even for a bomb scare: extraordinary circumstances excuse the bonus, never the care. Behind the passengers, French criminal law treats the hoax itself as a serious offence punished by two years’ imprisonment and a EUR 30,000 fine, with the Évreux investigation running its course under the presumption of innocence. And in front of the passengers, the Montreal Convention keeps the door open for every proven euro of loss, before the court of their choice, provided the action is brought in time. Two clocks protect two claims: five years in France for the fixed European sum, two years for proven loss on the Convention track. Keep the tickets, keep the receipts, claim in writing, and watch both clocks: neither forgives delay.