KOHEN AVOCATS · PARIS, FRANCE
National chicken sandwich day: what can customers check when a food deal is not honored?

Hassan Kohen is a Paris-based lawyer admitted to the Paris Bar (Avocat au Barreau de Paris). Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Sources: U.S. court opinions and official U.S. government publications, read for this article

Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

National chicken sandwich day: what can customers check when a food deal is not honored?

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

National chicken sandwich day can put a tempting restaurant offer in front of a customer who has only a few hours to decide whether to use it. If the discount does not appear at checkout or a restaurant declines the offer, the useful first question is not simply whether an advertisement used a big headline. It is what the offer actually said, which location and ordering channel it covered, what the customer selected, and whether a condition was disclosed before the purchase.

In New York, an advertised food deal can raise questions under the state’s consumer protection and false-advertising laws. A refused offer is not automatically unlawful: a clearly disclosed membership requirement, product limitation, participation condition, or expiration term may explain the difference between the advertised deal and the checkout result. Conversely, a material condition hidden behind a prominent promise may warrant closer examination. Federal Trade Commission pricing guides provide additional context, but they are guidance and do not themselves establish a private right to sue.

This discussion is general in scope. It explains checks useful in comparable situations and makes no finding about any restaurant or advertiser outside the decisions described below. It focuses on New York law; a transaction elsewhere may be governed by different state or local rules. The cases concern other consumer representations, not a particular chicken sandwich promotion.

I. When a food promotion is not honored, what should a New York customer check first?

A. Compare the actual offer with the transaction

Start with the offer as it appeared when you decided to use it. Save the complete advertisement, including the headline, nearby qualifications, any expandable terms, and the place where the offer appeared. A picture of the large discount alone can leave out a qualifying purchase or a location limitation. A picture of only the fine print can miss the impression created by the headline. Both are needed to evaluate what the advertisement communicated as a whole.

Then reconstruct the transaction. Record the date, approximate time, location, item and size, ordering method, price before the advertised discount, and the total actually shown. If an app generated a code or a reward, preserve its text and the account screen showing whether it was available. If an employee gave a reason for declining the offer, write down the explanation in neutral terms. A customer need not assume that the person at a counter controls a national advertisement or an app. The useful point is to identify what was offered, by whom, and what happened when the customer tried to use it.

Look for the words that determine eligibility. A deal may apply only to participating locations, a particular sandwich, an in-store purchase, a delivery order, a first order, or a rewards account. It may require an additional purchase or limit the number of discounted items. Check whether the requirement was visible before payment and whether it matches the reason given for refusal. If an offer excludes a location and that limitation was clear at the outset, the customer may have found the explanation without needing to turn a disappointing visit into a legal accusation.

Availability can also matter. An advertisement that says supplies are limited is different from one that promises a deal without an apparent limit. Preserve the wording about availability and the time of the attempted purchase. A sold-out item, an expired code, and a location that never participated are different explanations, and the evidence needed to assess each is different. The mere fact that an employee cannot provide an item does not establish that the original advertisement was deceptive.

The ordering channel deserves its own check. A restaurant’s in-store menu, its own app, and a third-party delivery platform may show different prices or different promotion terms. Compare the exact offer with the platform on which the order was placed; do not assume a discount displayed in one channel carries over to another. For an online order, keep the itemized cart before payment and the final confirmation. If the app changed the price when an add-on or delivery method was selected, record that change rather than attributing every difference to the base offer.

New York’s General Business Law § 350 declares false advertising in business or commerce in the state unlawful. Section 350-a defines false advertising by reference to advertising that is misleading in a material respect. It directs attention both to what an advertisement says and to material facts it fails to reveal in light of its representations and the relevant conditions. That is why a clear qualification and an undisclosed qualification should not be treated as interchangeable.

Materiality asks about a meaningful part of the deal, not every detail a customer could possibly wish to know. For example, a qualifying purchase, a specific location restriction, or a charge that changes the advertised bargain can matter to the decision to order. The statute does not make every typing error or failed checkout a proven violation. The facts and the advertisement’s full presentation remain important. If the problem is a technical error that is promptly corrected, keep that correction with the original record rather than describing it as proof of an intentional scheme.

Now compare two practical examples. In the first, an advertisement clearly limits a two-sandwich deal to one participating store and a customer presents it at a different location. The reason for refusal may be visible in the offer itself. In the second, the headline promises a discount at a location, while an additional purchase requirement appears only after the customer has committed to an order. That sequence raises a more focused question: whether the presentation of the condition materially changed the impression created by the advertisement. Neither example establishes liability without the actual facts.

Federal guidance reinforces the value of recording the complete promotion. The Federal Trade Commission’s Guide Against Deceptive Pricing, 16 C.F.R. § 233.4, discusses bargain offers tied to a purchase, including two-for-one promotions. It explains that conditions should be clear at the outset and that an increased required-purchase price, reduced quantity or quality, or additional strings may mislead consumers. This federal guide is interpretive guidance; it does not by itself decide a New York customer’s individual claim.

The separate FTC guide at 16 C.F.R. Part 251 addresses offers describing additional merchandise as free. It discusses clear and conspicuous disclosure of conditions close to the offer and the relationship between the offer and the regular price of the required purchase. A practical check is therefore to compare the complete advertised package with the amount charged for the item that had to be bought. A customer should not invent an earlier price or assume a price increase from a single receipt; older menus, dated screenshots, or a written explanation may supply a basis for comparison.

B. Distinguish an unmet expectation from a misleading representation

Three recent decisions help show why the wording and presentation matter. They arose from other products and services, so they are illustrations of the courts’ analysis, not rulings on a restaurant promotion. Their procedural posture also matters: a decision on a motion to dismiss evaluates the pleaded case at that stage; it does not necessarily establish that the allegations have been proved.

In Harbord v. A.J. Richard & Sons, Inc., No. 2023-09752 (N.Y. App. Div. May 6, 2026), the Supreme Court of the State of New York Appellate Division: Second Judicial Department allowed New York consumer protection claims concerning alleged representations about appliance installation to proceed past a motion to dismiss, while dismissing other claims. The court was considering allegations, not deciding that the representations had been proved false. For a food promotion, the useful comparison is to identify the particular representation and the alleged difference between that representation and what the customer received.

In Sciortino v. Drink LMNT, Inc., No. 25-CV-3126 (E.D.N.Y. Aug. 14, 2026), the United States District Court Eastern District of New York allowed some New York consumer claims based on alleged dietary suitability representations to proceed, but dismissed claims based on other representations. The court evaluated the challenged statements in context at the pleading stage; it made no final finding of liability. For a promotion, preserve the particular statement seen before ordering and its surrounding conditions, because different statements in the same campaign can receive different treatment.

In Ross v. Barebones Ventures, LLC, No. 2:25-cv-3929 (E.D.N.Y. September 22, 2026), the United States District Court Eastern District of New York dismissed food-label claims with prejudice after adopting an analysis of federal preemption of the particular nutrient-labeling theory. The decision concerned protein labeling and federal food-label requirements, not a restaurant’s coupon. For a customer comparing a price offer, the useful lesson is to examine the full presentation and the governing rule rather than assuming that every perceived inconsistency establishes a state-law claim.

Those decisions illustrate different outcomes. In one, sufficiently pleaded claims concerning a service representation survived; in another, the court separated viable and nonviable theories about the same product; in the third, a particular labeling theory was dismissed. The federal district court decisions decide those cases and are not binding precedents for every New York court. The New York Appellate Division decision is a state appellate decision in the Second Department. None decides whether the actual terms of a different promotion were deceptive.

Pay attention to the difference between a promise and a description of enthusiasm. An exact statement such as a specified discount on a named item under stated conditions is more concrete than a general statement that a restaurant offers a great deal. A customer can compare the former with the cart and receipt. That comparison does not mean every concrete statement is legally actionable; it provides a clearer factual question for assessing the advertisement under New York law.

It is equally important to distinguish what a customer saw from what appeared elsewhere. If a promotional email linked to a full terms page, save both the email and the page as they appeared. If a notice appeared only after an order was placed, preserve the order in which the screens appeared. If a qualification was presented prominently before checkout, include it even if it weakens the customer’s position. A reliable record should allow another person to understand the entire sequence rather than only the portion favorable to one side.

Consider whether the problem concerns the offer itself, its implementation, or both. A correctly described reward may fail to load because of an app problem. An offer may be correctly implemented according to terms that were hard to find. An employee may apply the wrong product code even though the published conditions are clear. Those situations call for different checks. A written explanation or correction can resolve the practical issue without answering every legal question about the campaign.

II. What evidence and remedies matter if the price still looks wrong?

A. Build a useful record and calculate the difference

Make a simple comparison of the promised transaction and the actual one. Write down the items and prices shown before the discount, the discount that the offer appeared to provide, and any charge or fee that changed the total. Separate the price of the qualifying item from the price of extras. Tax, delivery, tips, and optional modifications may be displayed separately; a receipt and the offer terms are needed before concluding whether a particular charge was included in the promotion.

For example, if an offer describes a second sandwich at no additional item price after purchase of a first, compare the two item lines and any promotion line. Do not treat the whole order total as the loss without accounting for other food, tax, delivery, or extras. If the second item was omitted entirely, record that as an item not received rather than automatically describing its menu price as money paid. If an advertised percentage discount was applied to a different base than expected, preserve the cart showing both the original base and the resulting calculation.

A comparison with an earlier price may matter if the advertisement claims a reduction from a regular or former price. The FTC’s federal former-price comparison guide, 16 C.F.R. § 233.1, discusses whether an advertised former price is a bona fide price used in the regular course of business rather than a fictitious comparison. This is guidance about advertising, not a finding that any particular promotion involved an inflated price. A single customer may not know a seller’s price history, so preserve what is actually available and distinguish it from assumptions.

If you paid more than the displayed eligible price, retain a receipt or payment confirmation showing the amount charged. If you abandoned the transaction before paying, preserve the cart and the reason for leaving, but do not record an amount as paid when it was not. If a refund or adjustment arrives, record its amount and date alongside the original charge. This makes it possible to separate a corrected billing problem from an unresolved difference. The customer should retain any written response explaining the adjustment as well.

New York’s General Business Law § 349 declares unfair, deceptive, or abusive business practices unlawful and defines unfair and abusive practices in the current text. Its private-action subsection, § 349(h), expressly addresses a person injured by a deceptive act or practice made unlawful by the section. It permits a qualifying person to seek an injunction, actual damages or $50, whichever is greater, or both; it also describes possible discretionary increases and attorney’s fees under its stated conditions. The existence of the statute does not establish that a particular person has satisfied its requirements.

The New York Senate page identifies the current revision of § 349 as beginning April 3, 2026. The consumer decisions discussed above concern their own records and do not establish how every aspect of the revised wording applies to a later restaurant transaction. In particular, the fact that the current statute also addresses unfair and abusive practices should not be read as automatically extending § 349(h)’s expressly worded private remedy to every practice a customer calls unfair. The legal theory and the injury must be examined under the applicable text.

For false advertising, New York General Business Law § 350-e(3) describes a private action by a person injured by a violation of § 350 or § 350-a. It provides for an injunction, actual damages or $500, whichever is greater, or both, and describes discretionary increases and attorney’s fees in specified circumstances. These amounts are statutory provisions, not a promise that a customer will receive a particular award. Whether a violation occurred and whether the person was injured are separate questions.

Keep the evidence organized by source. A useful folder contains the original advertisement, the complete terms, the product and location selected, the cart before payment, the receipt, the explanation given for refusal, and any subsequent correction. Note whether each item is a screenshot, an email, a paper receipt, or a written message. When an offer appears in a scrolling app, capture consecutive screens so the relationship between the headline and conditions remains visible. Avoid changing file dates or adding explanatory text to a screenshot; a separate note can identify when and how it was obtained.

Privacy matters even for a small purchase. A screenshot may include a payment card number, account identifier, home address, or unrelated order history. Keep an unaltered original securely and prepare a version that hides unnecessary sensitive information when sharing the record. If a redaction covers a price or condition relevant to the dispute, explain that limitation. The goal is to preserve reliable evidence without distributing details that do not help explain the transaction.

When asking the seller to review the matter, a concise factual account is usually more useful than an accusation. Identify the specific advertisement, the transaction, the condition you understood to apply, and the amount or item in dispute. Include the seller’s stated reason and any term that might explain it. Ask for a correction or an explanation of the applicable condition. The response may reveal that a different product or location was selected, or it may clarify the remaining disagreement.

B. Decide what to do with an unresolved promotion

If the explanation does not resolve the issue, identify the business that made the representation and the business that completed the transaction. They may be the same, or the advertisement, ordering platform, and restaurant may involve different entities. The relevant documents can help distinguish them: look at the advertiser’s name, the merchant on the receipt, and any ordering-platform confirmation. The presence of different entities does not by itself determine who is legally responsible.

Also identify the particular decision you want reviewed. Is the question whether a discount should have been applied to an eligible order, whether a material condition was disclosed, or whether a stated former price accurately described the bargain? These are related but different questions. A clear description helps a reviewer avoid treating a technical checkout error as proof about an entire campaign, or treating a disclosure problem as merely a mistaken button press.

A customer may bring a complaint to a relevant consumer protection agency and may consider an individual action where the applicable legal requirements are met. New York’s § 349 also gives the state attorney general authority to pursue specified relief. An agency’s decision whether to investigate is separate from a customer’s private claim, and an individual complaint does not itself establish a violation or guarantee reimbursement. Keep any agency reference number and correspondence with the underlying record.

Before pursuing a payment dispute with a card issuer or another payment provider, compare the provider’s written process with the receipt and the seller’s response. A payment dispute is not the same thing as a court finding about false advertising. Describe the amount and transaction accurately, including any partial refund. Do not claim that an authorized purchase was unauthorized simply because the discount calculation is disputed.

For an app or rewards offer, preserve the exact version of the reward that appeared in the account. An offer may be redeemed once, tied to a specific product, or limited to a particular channel. If the screen shows that the reward was already used, record that fact and any available transaction history. If the reward disappeared before use, preserve the last confirmation and the subsequent screen. These checks can identify a practical account problem, but they do not establish whether an advertisement was lawful without the rest of the context.

For a third-party delivery order, compare the offer on the platform with the order’s itemized totals and the restaurant’s own menu only where those materials actually concern the same transaction. Different prices across channels are not automatically proof of deception. A platform may display a promotion that depends on a minimum order, a subscription, a service area, or another stated condition. The decisive evidence is the offer and the checkout sequence the customer encountered, including any qualifications disclosed before payment.

For an in-person order, a photograph of the menu board or printed coupon can help establish the terms, while the receipt shows the transaction completed. If the customer was told that the location did not participate, check whether the advertisement identified participating locations or made a broader statement. A franchise or independently operated location may have its own role in a promotion; the ownership label alone is not enough to answer whether the advertisement or transaction was misleading. Record the location and the actual wording instead.

Do not assume that a small dollar amount eliminates every remedy, or that a statutory minimum guarantees one. The New York private-action provisions quoted above tie their remedies to a qualifying violation and injury. They also distinguish relief directed at stopping a practice from a monetary award. A customer should keep the amount actually paid, the value of any correction, and the unresolved difference separate so that the requested remedy matches the evidence.

Likewise, an advertisement’s use of a cheerful holiday theme does not itself create a legal duty to provide a particular sandwich. The relevant questions are the representations made, the conditions communicated, the customer’s transaction, and the applicable New York provisions. A missed deal can be disappointing without being deceptive; a clear account of the transaction is the starting point for distinguishing disappointment from a potentially material advertising problem.

The best-supported account is often short: identify the advertisement and its conditions; describe the selected item, location, and ordering channel; show the promised and actual amounts; and preserve the response. Where the materials conflict, keep both versions and identify which one appeared before the transaction. If key information is missing, state what is unknown rather than filling the gap with a guess about intent or responsibility.

Conclusion

When a food promotion is not honored, first compare the complete offer with the item, location, timing, and ordering channel used. Preserve the advertisement, its qualifications, the cart or receipt, and any explanation or correction. New York’s consumer and false-advertising provisions make the substance and presentation of a material representation important, while the FTC guides provide additional context for conditional bargains. The decisions discussed above show why the exact words, the full presentation, and the procedural stage matter. They do not decide the outcome of a different promotion. A clear record of the offer and any actual financial difference gives the customer the strongest basis for deciding what to do next.

📄 Official circular