KOHEN AVOCATS · PARIS, FRANCE
Paul McCartney Billionaire Status: What Should U.S. Songwriters Check About Music Royalties?

Hassan Kohen is a Paris-based lawyer admitted to the Paris Bar (Avocat au Barreau de Paris). Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Sources: U.S. court opinions and official U.S. government publications, read for this article

Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Paul McCartney Billionaire Status: What Should U.S. Songwriters Check About Music Royalties?

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

Paul McCartney billionaire status became a subject of renewed attention after The Guardian reported on November 9, 2026, that Forbes estimated the musician’s net worth at $1.4 billion. The report described a mix of assets, including a music catalog, touring and other holdings. A published estimate is not an accounting of a particular contract, a royalty statement or the value of any one copyright. It does, however, raise a useful question for people who make music: what documents show which rights they actually own and which payments they can expect?

Start with the song, the particular recording and the paperwork for each. A songwriter may have an interest in a composition, while someone else owns or administers the recording. A performer may receive money under a recording agreement or a statutory system without owning the song’s copyright. Those streams can pass through different organizations, carry different identifiers and appear on different statements. The discussion that follows is general in scope and makes no findings about Paul McCartney’s contracts, ownership or personal finances. It focuses on United States federal copyright rules, the actual terms of an agreement and selected court decisions; other countries’ rules and contracts may differ.

I. What should a songwriter or performer identify before counting music royalties?

A. Separate the song, the recording and the people connected to each

A useful first step is to make two rows for every release. In one row put the musical composition: the melody and any lyrics. In the other put the particular sound recording: the recorded performance that listeners hear. Federal 17 U.S.C. § 102 identifies musical works and sound recordings as distinct categories of protected authorship, subject to the statute’s requirements of originality and fixation. The same composition can be embodied in several recordings, each with its own production history. A single title on a streaming screen therefore does not, by itself, identify all the rights connected with that recording.

For the composition row, list every contributor, the title and alternative titles, the version, the publisher or administrator shown in the documents, and any agreed shares. Keep a dated copy of a split sheet or other signed record of the contributors’ understanding. A split sheet is useful evidence of an arrangement; whether it establishes a particular legal interest depends on its language and the surrounding facts. Avoid filling a gap by assuming that the singer, the producer or the person who uploaded the track wrote the song. Credits can be helpful leads, but the underlying agreements and creation records answer a different question.

For the recording row, identify the featured and other performers, the producer, the studio or commissioning party, the recording date, and the person or business identified as the master owner in the relevant agreements. If there are live, remixed and studio versions, give each a separate entry. A recording agreement may deal with an advance, distribution, deductions and accounting in ways that differ from a publishing agreement. Compare those provisions instead of adding every payment described as a royalty into a single unexplained total.

The U.S. Copyright Office’s guidance for songwriters and performers explains the two-work distinction and describes several possible collection routes. It is agency guidance, not a substitute for the statute or the parties’ agreements. It distinguishes musical-work identifiers such as an International Standard Musical Work Code from an International Standard Recording Code for a recording. Those identifiers are tools for matching uses and payments; a code is not, by itself, a court finding that a person owns a particular share.

Build a small evidence file for each work. Save dated drafts, session records, written contributor agreements, registration information and the final audio file or a reliable reference to it. Preserve revisions as well as the final document so that later changes can be traced. If two collaborators use different professional names, record each name beside the same person’s identifying information. A payment may be difficult to match because a title, name or identifier is inconsistent, even when everyone agrees on the economic arrangement. A discrepancy is a reason to investigate, not proof that anyone acted improperly.

Federal 17 U.S.C. § 201 starts with authorship: copyright in a protected work initially vests in its author or authors, and authors of a joint work are coowners. The same section contains a distinct rule for a work made for hire, treating the employer or other person for whom it was prepared as the author, subject to a signed written agreement otherwise. Do not decide the classification from a job title or a label alone. Preserve the engagement documents and facts about how the work was commissioned or created; the statutory definition and the applicable facts matter.

The composition and recording can also have several interested people without everyone holding the same kind of interest. A producer’s contract may promise a share of recording revenue; a writer may own or administer a share of a composition; an administrator may be authorized to collect for an owner. The sensible question for each person is not simply “Am I credited?” but “What right or payment does this document describe, who owes it, and what records should show it?” Keeping these questions separate makes later statements easier to read.

B. Trace a right from its creator to the person who collects

After identifying the work, place the documents in chronological order: original contributor arrangements, publishing or recording agreements, amendments, assignments, administration appointments and any later notices or court orders. Federal § 201 permits copyright ownership to be transferred in whole or in part and permits separate ownership of subdivisions of exclusive rights. That means a person who once held one right may later have transferred some or all of it, while another person may have authority to administer a right without acquiring ownership. Read the operative language rather than deciding from a document’s heading.

Federal 17 U.S.C. § 204 provides that a transfer of copyright ownership, other than by operation of law, is not valid unless an instrument of conveyance or a note or memorandum is written and signed by the owner of the rights conveyed or the owner’s duly authorized agent. This is a rule about a transfer of copyright ownership; it is not a shortcut for deciding every possible license, payment obligation or inheritance issue. Check whose signature appears, what interest is described and whether the document covers this particular work. A missing document calls for further investigation, not a declaration that a transfer did or did not happen.

Look closely at scope. A grant may describe a composition rather than a master recording, a territory rather than the entire world, or specified rights rather than every possible use. An amendment may change a payment rate without changing ownership, or alter the term while leaving other clauses in place. A later document can refer back to a schedule that lists works separately. Keep the schedules, exhibits and amendments with the signed agreement; an isolated signature page or royalty summary often omits the language needed to understand the bargain.

Federal 17 U.S.C. § 106 describes the copyright owner’s exclusive rights, subject to the statutory limitations it identifies. These include reproduction, preparation of derivative works and distribution; it also distinguishes public performance of musical works from the public performance right specified for sound recordings by digital audio transmission. A royalty statement may combine income arising from different uses. Label each line by the work, right, use and reporting period before comparing it with an agreement.

The distinction between a publisher and an administrator is especially useful when reading older paperwork. The Copyright Office’s guidance describes traditional publishing arrangements that may involve an assignment, as well as administration arrangements in which the administrator performs collection and related services for a fee without being assigned the songwriter’s copyrights. Those descriptions are common patterns, not a determination of any particular agreement. A contract can use familiar industry labels while defining its own scope, fee, territories and reporting obligations. Read its definitions and any subsequent amendments together.

In Thomson v. Hodgson, No. 24-2858 (9th Cir. Aug. 20, 2025), the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit decided on August 20, 2025, that the district court had wrongly treated a particular 1977 songwriting and publishing royalty agreement as unilaterally terminable after a reasonable time under California contract law. The court inferred a duration from that agreement’s subject matter and circumstances and ordered judgment for the plaintiffs on liability. For a reader reviewing a royalty contract, the useful check is to preserve the agreement, its surrounding documents and the parties’ payment history; the outcome does not set the duration of every music agreement.

Do not confuse the existence of an ownership interest with the amount currently payable. A person may own a share while an agreement describes how a collector calculates and remits money. Conversely, a contract may promise a payment without transferring every copyright interest. An advance, recoupment provision, fee or deduction may change what a statement shows. To understand the result, match the relevant clause to a line item and ask for the data behind an unexplained number. The answer depends on the arrangement; a headline estimate or public credit cannot replace it.

II. How can musicians check payments and changes to their rights?

A. Match each use to the right statement and the right payee

Start with a specific use rather than a general impression that a song is popular. Identify the recording, platform or venue, country, approximate period and type of use shown by the available records. Then ask which composition statement and which recording statement should be examined for that use. A download, an on-demand stream, a public performance and a use with pictures may involve different rights or licensing arrangements. The relevant contract and applicable federal rules determine the route; no single payment label proves that every route has been accounted for.

For a composition, the Copyright Office’s guidance describes performance-rights organizations, publishers and administrators, as well as the Mechanical Licensing Collective for the digital mechanical system it discusses. The document explains that an organization may need the work’s identity, ownership information and payment details to match and distribute money. The practical task is to verify the actual registrations and the agreement authorizing each organization or administrator to act. Membership with one organization should not be treated as a complete inventory of every right or every source of revenue.

For a sound recording, compare the recording agreement and distributor statements with the collection route applicable to the particular use. The Copyright Office’s guidance distinguishes certain noninteractive digital performances from other uses and describes different roles for copyright owners, featured performers and nonfeatured contributors. The fact that one recording appears on a platform does not establish the amount owed to a specific person. Check the version, the recording identifier, the reported use, the recipient’s role and any contractual split before drawing a conclusion.

A practical reconciliation can be done without pretending that a public database is a complete ledger. Put the title, composition identifier, recording identifier, credited writers, claimed shares, payee and reporting period in one working table. Beside each expected revenue category, identify the source of the expectation: a contract clause, a collector’s statement or an applicable statutory route. Mark missing information as unknown. Compare equivalent periods and currencies, and retain the original statements so that an adjustment, reversal or later correction remains visible.

For example, imagine two writers who agree on a composition split while a separate performer records the song under a recording agreement. A streaming statement may identify the recording but not display the full publishing chain. The writers can compare the composition registration with their split document; the performer can compare the recording statement with the recording contract. If the titles or identifiers do not match, ask the relevant administrator or distributor for the basis of the matching and keep the response. This example describes a way to organize records, not a finding about a particular release.

A license for a video or film is another place to separate the layers. The Copyright Office’s guidance describes a synchronization license for use of the composition with visual material and a corresponding master-use license for the sound recording. A person planning such a use should identify who can authorize each layer and what the actual license permits. A permission for a composition does not, merely by its label, answer what authority exists over a particular recording. Conversely, a recording agreement should be read to see what, if anything, it says about the underlying work.

In Music Choice v. Copyright Royalty Board, No. 25-1039 (D.C. Cir. Aug. 18, 2026), the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit dismissed a petition on August 18, 2026, because the particular Copyright Royalty Board interpretive ruling was not a reviewable, binding determination under the court’s statutory review provision. The dispute concerned royalties for a business background-music service, and the court did not decide the underlying gross-proceeds calculation. A reader comparing recording income should therefore identify the actual service, license and procedural decision before assuming that an agency interpretation resolves a specific payment dispute.

When a statement differs from the agreement, write down the precise discrepancy. Is the work missing entirely, attributed to a different contributor, assigned an unexpected share, or present with an unexplained deduction? Request an explanation that identifies the reporting period and the records used. Keep the request and response with the statement, and avoid editing the original files. A missing line may reflect an identification problem, a reporting convention or a substantive disagreement; the records are needed to distinguish them.

Check any audit or information provisions in the applicable agreement before deciding what additional records to request. Those provisions may specify the records available, the person authorized to inspect them and how adjustments are handled. Their effect depends on the wording and governing law. It is useful to retain invoices, contracts and transaction reports in their original form, with a separate note explaining what each item appears to show. An organized file allows an accountant or other qualified professional to follow the calculation without treating a rough estimate as a verified balance.

B. Review termination, later documents and disputes without assuming the result

A grant of copyright and an agreement to pay royalties are related questions, but they are not interchangeable. Start by asking what was granted, by whom, when and to whom. Then identify any provision dealing with the duration of the agreement, the continuation of payments, and later amendments. Separately check whether a statutory termination provision could apply. A document described as a termination notice deserves careful comparison with the grant and the applicable law; neither the name of the notice nor a change in a database alone explains every consequence.

Federal 17 U.S.C. § 203 addresses termination of certain grants executed by an author on or after January 1, 1978, other than by will, for works other than works made for hire. It specifies who may act, the effective period, advance notice, service and recordation requirements, and limits on the effect of termination. Its text also distinguishes the treatment of an authorized derivative work prepared before termination. A reader should assemble the grant, publication history and any notices before attempting to decide whether the provision applies. The provision does not establish a universal rule for pre-1978 grants or every contractual payment.

Federal § 203 sets out specific timing conditions, including an alternative calculation when a grant covers the right of publication. The relevant dates and the character of the grant therefore matter; an execution date alone may not settle the calculation. The statute also describes who can exercise interests after an author’s death. Record the facts and documents needed to apply those conditions rather than copying a generic date from another work. The text of the statute, related rules and the facts of the particular grant must be read together.

In Livingston v. Jay Livingston Music, Inc., 142 F.4th 433 (6th Cir. 2025), the United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit affirmed dismissal on July 7, 2025, of challenges to particular termination notices and an asserted state-law royalty claim. The court considered the effect of an earlier California probate judgment and the allegations actually pleaded; it did not hold that termination automatically extinguishes every contractual royalty. The practical lesson is to assemble prior judgments, grant documents and the claimed payment basis together when assessing a particular dispute.

Later in the same proceeding, Livingston v. Jay Livingston Music, Inc., No. 3:22-cv-00532 (M.D. Tenn. Sept. 28, 2026), the United States District Court, Middle District of Tennessee referred to the Sixth Circuit decision on September 28, 2026, while deciding a later request for attorney’s fees. The district court granted fees in part after considering the circumstances of that litigation, including both sides’ contributions to expense and the plaintiff’s financial circumstances. This later fee decision is not a new ruling that every disputed royalty agreement has the same result.

If a prior court order appears in the file, obtain the actual order and identify the parties, the property or rights addressed and the decision it makes. A summary in a spreadsheet or a message saying that a dispute was resolved may omit an important limitation. Likewise, a later amendment may refer to a prior agreement by date or attach an updated work schedule. Keep the complete documents together and distinguish a party’s position from what a court actually decided. Different courts and governing laws may reach different questions.

When dealing with an estate, make a separate map of the interests shown by the documents and the people acting in each capacity. A person may appear as an individual, a trustee, an administrator or a statutory successor, and those descriptions should not be casually merged. An old royalty statement can show a payment history without resolving the present owner of a copyright or the effect of a later notice. Compare the relevant agreement, estate documents and any court order before changing the record of who should receive what.

Finally, keep uncertainty visible. If the work has no signed split document, identify what evidence exists and what remains unresolved. If a royalty is collected through an administrator, distinguish the administrator’s authority from ownership and from the obligation to account. If a notice or order changes the analysis, record its source and scope rather than assuming it governs unrelated works or other countries. A short, accurate description of an open issue is more useful than a complete-looking table built on guesses.

Conclusion

A music catalog can generate several kinds of income, but the figure that matters for a particular creator is the amount attributable to the rights and agreements that actually apply. Identify the composition and each recording, trace the relevant interests through the documents, match uses and identifiers to the correct statements, and keep prior notices or judgments with the file. Where an item remains unclear, preserve that uncertainty alongside the evidence. The result is a practical record that can be checked, corrected and updated as reliable information becomes available.

📄 Official circular