On November 10, 2026, thousands of Americans typed two words into Google: spectrum outage. Some wanted to know whether the internet was down in their neighborhood. Others wanted to know something more practical: if the service disappeared for hours, does the company owe them money, and what happens to the people who cut the lines in the first place.
The second question became concrete in early November 2026 in California, where local press reported that fiber and telephone lines had been cut across Amador and San Joaquin Counties and that suspects were in custody. Those reports describe arrests, not convictions, and no court has decided what happened there as of this writing. But they raise exactly the legal question behind the search spike: when an outage is caused by vandalism, two tracks open at once. Customers ask about credits and refunds. Prosecutors ask about prison and restitution. This guide explains both tracks under the law that actually governs them: federal communications law and the law of California, where the November incidents were reported.
I. Can you get money back when the internet goes down?
A. No federal rule orders automatic outage credits, so ask in writing
Many customers assume that a federal agency guarantees a refund whenever broadband or phone service goes dark. No statute or rule read for this article says that. What federal law does impose on providers is a duty to report significant disruptions to the Federal Communications Commission under 47 CFR Part 4, the federal disruption-reporting rules, available at https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-47/chapter-I/subchapter-A/part-4. Those rules tell providers when and how to notify the Commission about outages. They are a regulatory reporting system, not a customer compensation fund, and they do not promise any individual subscriber a credit.
Likewise, the Federal Communications Commission publishes a consumer guide on home phone protections, available at https://www.fcc.gov/sites/default/files/consumer_protections_for_home_phone_service.pdf. That guide is useful but narrow: it explains that telephone companies cannot stop, reduce, or change traditional home phone service, including as part of network transitions or bankruptcy, without giving proper notice and adequate replacement options. It addresses discontinuance of service, not compensation for an outage that has already happened. The honest consequence is that credits for a dead afternoon of internet service come from somewhere else: the provider’s own policy and the customer’s contract, plus state consumer remedies described below.
There is one more federal document worth understanding for what it does not promise. Providers file outage reports with the Commission, and the Commission publishes aggregate communications-status data during disasters, but none of the material read for this article converts a reported outage into money for the subscriber. That gap is deliberate in the federal design: Washington polices the integrity of the networks, while the bill for a lost afternoon is settled between the customer, the contract, and, when necessary, a state regulator or a court. Customers who call the provider expecting a federally mandated refund will be disappointed; customers who call with dates, ticket numbers, and a written complaint tend to get the credit the policy manuals already allow.
That means the first practical check is contractual. The company’s published materials describe a 30-day money-back guarantee, but that promise covers new accounts and service upgrades within the first 30 days, not outage credits for established customers. For an outage, the standard industry practice, described across the company’s published policy pages, is that the customer must contact the provider and request a bill credit for the down period; credits are generally not applied automatically. Because that practice comes from company policy rather than a published federal refund rule, the request itself is the trigger: call or message customer service, state the exact dates and duration of the outage, ask for a prorated credit, and keep a written record with a confirmation number. If the outage cost money beyond the bill itself, such as a day of remote work lost, say so in the same written complaint and keep receipts, because documented economic loss is what later remedies, including restitution discussed in Part II, require.
B. In California, escalate from the company to the state
California gives telephone and communications customers a defined escalation path. The California Attorney General’s office explains that telephone services in the state are generally regulated by the California Public Utilities Commission and points consumers to the Commission’s telecommunications resources, as stated at https://oag.ca.gov/consumers/general/telephone. The same office advises customers to read every phone bill, to challenge unauthorized third-party charges, known as cramming, and unauthorized carrier switches, known as slamming, and to demand reversal of charges they did not authorize. An outage credit is a different animal from cramming, but the method is the same: dispute in writing, demand correction, and escalate when the company says no.
The escalation point is the Commission itself. Its complaint portal, available at https://www.cpuc.ca.gov/consumer-support/file-a-complaint, lets a customer file an informal utility complaint after customer service fails to resolve the problem, and then a formal complaint through which the Commission can order the utility to take corrective action on various formal complaints. A formal complaint is not small claims court and it is not a lawsuit for damages, but it puts a regulator with enforcement power between the customer and the provider, which is exactly where an individual complaint about repeated or long outages belongs.
The Attorney General’s guidance goes further into everyday bill defense. It urges customers to ask carriers about blocking third-party charges entirely, to understand exactly what any billed application or service does before agreeing to it, and to treat every unexplained monthly fee or minimum usage fee as a question the carrier must answer. Those habits matter in outage season too, because the same bills that carry an outage credit may also carry new fees, and a customer who has learned to contest one line item can contest them all. The office also describes payment-plan negotiation and service-restart assistance for customers whose phone service is shut off or at risk over unpaid bills, including a dedicated helpline, which shows the broader California philosophy: the state expects carriers to keep people connected and to negotiate before disconnecting, a posture that strengthens any customer’s complaint about being charged for service that was never delivered.
Behind that procedure sits California’s unfair competition law, which defines unfair competition to include any unlawful, unfair or fraudulent business act or practice, as stated in Business and Professions Code section 17200 at California Business and Professions Code section 17200. That definition matters because a systematic refusal to honor advertised credit policies, or billing for service never delivered, could be treated as an unlawful or unfair practice, which only a court can finally decide. The statute does not create an automatic right to an outage refund either, and no honest guide should claim otherwise. What it creates is a cause of action that makes the paper trail from part A of this section valuable: dates, durations, written requests, written denials, and bills showing charges for dead service.
II. Cutting the lines is a crime, and the victims can be repaid through the criminal case
A. Federal and California law punish line-cutting severely
Cutting communications lines can be a federal crime when the lines fall within the federal statute. Section 1362 of Title 18 of the United States Code punishes whoever willfully or maliciously injures or destroys the works, property, or material of any radio, telegraph, telephone or cable line, station, or system operated or controlled by the United States or used for military or civil defense functions, and whoever willfully or maliciously interferes with the working or use of such a line or system, with a fine, imprisonment of not more than ten years, or both, as stated at https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCODE-2023-title18/pdf/USCODE-2023-title18-partI-chap65-sec1362.pdf. The statute reaches attempts and conspiracies as well, and a 2013 amendment applied its current scope to conduct on or after January 2, 2013. Ordinary commercial cable and internet lines are usually prosecuted under state law, but the federal charge is available where federal, military, or civil defense communications are involved, and federal prosecutors have used comparable charges aggressively when communications infrastructure is attacked.
The starkest American example involved an insider, not a thief. According to a release from the United States Attorney’s Office for the Northern District of Illinois, available at https://www.justice.gov/usao-ndil/pr/naperville-engineer-sentenced-12-12-years-prison-cutting-communication-cables-and, Brian Howard used wire cutters to sever multiple telecommunication cables at the Chicago Air Route Traffic Control Center in Aurora on September 26, 2014, disabling communications with data centers and in-flight aircraft, then set fire to the equipment. United States v. Howard is not the caption of a published opinion, because Howard pleaded guilty, but the prosecuted facts show the scale of punishment available: a federal judge sentenced Howard to 150 months in prison and ordered him to pay $4,502,361 in restitution to the Federal Aviation Administration. He pleaded guilty to willfully damaging an air navigation facility and to using fire to commit a federal felony. The lesson for customers elsewhere is not that every cut cable draws twelve years, but that the criminal system treats attacks on communications infrastructure as serious felonies with victim repayment built into the sentence.
California prosecutes the same conduct under its own statutes. Penal Code section 591 punishes a person who unlawfully and maliciously takes down, removes, injures, disconnects, cuts, or obstructs a line of telegraph, telephone, or cable television, or any line used to conduct electricity, as stated at California Penal Code section 591. The current version is a wobbler: county jail not exceeding one year, a fine not exceeding $1,000, or both, or imprisonment for 16 months, two or three years plus a fine of up to $10,000. Alongside it, Penal Code section 594 punishes vandalism, meaning maliciously defacing, damaging, or destroying property belonging to another, with punishment scaled to the amount of damage, as stated at California Penal Code section 594. Damage of $400 or more can be charged as a felony. A fiber cut that blacks out two counties will have no trouble crossing that threshold, which is why the November 2026 California arrests, if charges follow, could involve felony counts rather than misdemeanors. As of this writing, however, only arrests have been reported in the press, and every person arrested is presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty in court.
Section 594 adds texture that matters for infrastructure cases. It covers graffiti, damage, and destruction of any real or personal property belonging to another, and it creates a permissive inference, for property of a public entity or the federal government, that the defendant neither owned the property nor had permission to damage it. Punishment turns on the dollar amount: damage of $400 or more opens the door to felony treatment, and convictions for defacement can carry cleanup, repair, or replacement orders on top of fines and jail time. For cut fiber, stripped copper, smashed cabinets, and drained backup batteries, prosecutors can therefore mix section 591 for the line itself with section 594 for the surrounding destruction, and each damaged site can add to the total. The Howard case illustrates the same stacking logic at the federal level, where one night of cable-cutting plus arson produced two felony counts, a 150-month sentence, and a multimillion-dollar restitution order, after the defendant admitted in his plea agreement that he meant to disrupt air travel and shut the facility down.
How broadly section 591 reaches was settled in People v. Kreiling, 259 Cal. App. 2d 699 (California Court of Appeal, February 29, 1968), available at https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2216305/people-v-kreiling/. Kreiling, a former telephone company repairman, used a special key to rig a pay telephone so that deposited coins were returned while he placed a long-distance call without paying. He argued that section 591 covered only damage to lines, not tampering with an instrument, and that only the misdemeanor of telephone fraud applied to him. The court disagreed on both points: the act of maliciously obstructing telephone apparatus violates section 591 even without damage to a line, and the misdemeanor fraud statute did not preempt the felony because fraud requires intent to defraud while section 591 turns on malice. The judgment is affirmed. Decided in 1968 under an older version of the statute, which the Legislature rewrote in 2014, this decision is used here only as historical background on what section 591 covers, not as a statement of the penalties that apply today. Applied to the reader’s problem, Kreiling shows that prosecutors are not limited to cut wires: disabling, obstructing, or tampering with communications equipment can support the same charge as severing a cable, which matters when vandals damage cabinets, batteries, or relay equipment rather than the fiber itself.
Ohio courts have recently confirmed that theft prosecutors can stack vandalism and theft charges for the same copper-stealing conduct, and that value decides the grade of the offense. In State v. Sines-Riley, No. 22CA3984 (Court of Appeals of Ohio, Fourth Appellate District, July 24, 2024), available at https://www.supremecourt.ohio.gov/rod/docs/pdf/4/2024/2024-Ohio-2860.pdf, the defendant broke into a county fairground and a business storage yard and stole catalytic converters from trucks and RVs. The court held that the State had to prove the converters reached the $1,000 fair market value at which misdemeanor theft rises to a fifth-degree felony, sustained the defendant’s value-related claims in part, and held that the trial court erred when it failed to merge the vandalism offense with the theft offense for the trucks where one course of conduct produced both. Several convictions were vacated and the case was remanded for resentencing. For readers, the application is direct: when thieves cut lines or strip equipment to sell the metal, prosecutors can charge both the taking and the breaking, but courts police double-counting through merger, and the dollar value of what was taken or destroyed sets the severity of the charge, which is another reason to document the cost of every outage hour.
B. Restitution: the criminal sentence can repay the victims
A conviction does more than punish. In California, the Legislature has declared its intent that a victim of a crime who incurs an economic loss as a result of the commission of a crime shall receive restitution directly from a defendant convicted of that crime, and the court must order the defendant to pay restitution to the victim or victims, enforceable as if the order were a civil judgment, as stated in Penal Code section 1202.4 at California Penal Code section 1202.4. The order covers economic loss caused by the crime, which for an outage can include the price of service never delivered and documented out-of-pocket costs. Federal law works the same way in practice, as the $4,502,361 restitution order in the Aurora case shows. Restitution is not guaranteed in any particular case, because it depends on conviction, on proof of loss, and on the defendant’s ability to pay, but it is a right the victim must affirmatively claim, not a favor the court grants on its own motion.
The follow-up decision in the Ohio theft case shows how seriously courts take that claim process, and how easily it is lost. In State v. Sines-Riley, No. 24CA4097 (Court of Appeals of Ohio, Fourth Appellate District, September 3, 2025), available at https://www.supremecourt.ohio.gov/rod/docs/pdf/4/2025/2025-Ohio-3200.pdf, the same defendant returned to appeal his new sentences, arguing among other things that the trial court should not have ordered him to pay restitution to two victims. The court overruled the claim: it was barred by res judicata and invited error, because he had failed to challenge the restitution order in his first appeal and had stipulated to the amounts owed at sentencing. The court affirmed the judgment, including consecutive sentences and the restitution orders. Applied to the reader’s situation, the message is unforgiving but useful: agree to nothing about loss amounts without advice, object to restitution figures you dispute at the first opportunity, and put every dollar of outage loss in writing early, because a stipulation or a missed appeal can freeze the number forever.
California’s restitution scheme has a second layer worth knowing. Alongside direct restitution to victims, the court must impose a separate restitution fine in every case unless it states compelling and extraordinary reasons on the record, and both the fine and the direct order follow the defendant after sentencing. The direct order is the one that pays the outage victim, and the statute makes it enforceable as a civil judgment, which means it survives the criminal case and can be collected like any other money judgment. That collection prospect is exactly why documentation matters from day one: a judge can only order repayment of losses the record proves, and the record is built from the bills, receipts, and written complaints the customer assembled while the outage was still fresh.
For a customer sitting in a dark house in November 2026, the checklist that follows from these decisions is short. First, report the outage to the provider in writing and request the credit the same day, because the contract track rewards the customers who ask. Second, if the outage looks like vandalism rather than weather, file a police or sheriff’s report and keep the report number, because a criminal case with identified defendants is the only path to court-ordered restitution. Third, preserve every receipt: the bill for dead service, the mobile hotspot charges, the lost business income with invoices to back it up. Fourth, if the provider stonewalls, file with the California Public Utilities Commission and, for billing abuse, consult the unfair competition remedy with a lawyer. None of these steps assumes that the November 2026 California arrestees committed any crime; they are checks any customer can run in any outage, and only a court can decide who broke the law.
Conclusion
A spectrum outage is an inconvenience, but when lines are deliberately cut it becomes two legal matters at once. On the civil side, no federal rule examined here orders automatic credits, so customers must invoke the provider’s policy and, in California, the Public Utilities Commission complaint process, with Business and Professions Code section 17200 behind them if billing practices turn abusive. On the criminal side, federal law punishes attacks on protected communications lines with up to ten years, California punishes malicious line-cutting and vandalism as wobblers and felonies scaled to the damage, and courts from Los Angeles in 1968 to Ohio in 2025 show that disabling equipment counts, value sets the grade, and restitution must be claimed carefully or not at all. Ask for the credit in writing, document every dollar, report suspected vandalism to the police, and let the courts, not the comment sections, decide who cut the lines.