KOHEN AVOCATS · PARIS, FRANCE
Matthew Farwell guilty verdict: how federal law reaches a local police killing and what the unborn-child count adds

Hassan Kohen is a Paris-based lawyer admitted to the Paris Bar (Avocat au Barreau de Paris). Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Sources: U.S. court opinions and official U.S. government publications, read for this article

Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Matthew Farwell guilty verdict: how federal law reaches a local police killing and what the unborn-child count adds

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

On November 10, 2026, newsrooms covering the federal trial in Boston reported that a jury found former Stoughton, Massachusetts, police officer Matthew Farwell guilty on all counts in the killing of Sandra Birchmore, a young woman whose death in February 2021 had first been treated as a suicide. The verdict closed the trial phase of a case the federal government built around two counts: killing a witness or victim to prevent a report to law enforcement, under 18 U.S.C. Section 1512(a)(1)(C), and causing the death of her unborn child through that same conduct, under 18 U.S.C. Sections 1841(a)(1), (a)(2)(A) and (a)(2)(C). The charging instrument is a superseding indictment filed on October 28, 2025, in Criminal No. 1:24-cr-10259-DJC in the United States District Court for the District of Massachusetts, and its allegations describe strangulation on February 1, 2021, in Canton, Massachusetts, followed by staging the apartment to look like a suicide, at a time when Ms. Birchmore was eight to ten weeks pregnant. Readers should keep the boundary clear: the indictment alleged, and the jury has now found, but sentencing had not been reported as of the verdict date, and post-trial proceedings can still shape the final outcome. The discussion that follows is general in scope: it describes checks useful in comparable situations and makes no findings about Mr. Farwell’s situation.

I. How can a killing investigated by local police end up as a federal murder case?

A. The federal charge starts with a blocked report, not with a federal crime scene

Federal criminal law rarely punishes an ordinary homicide as such. What brings a local killing into federal court is a federal interest attached to it, and in the Birchmore prosecution that interest was witness tampering. Count One of the superseding indictment charges that Matthew Farwell “did kill Sandra Birchmore, a person known to the Grand Jury, with malice aforethought, willfully, deliberately, maliciously, and with premeditation, and with the intent to prevent the communication by any person to a law enforcement officer of information relating to the commission or possible commission of a federal offense.” The possible federal offenses the grand jury named were deprivation of rights under color of law, in violation of 18 U.S.C. Section 242, coercion and enticement, in violation of 18 U.S.C. Section 2422(b), and wire fraud, in violation of 18 U.S.C. Section 1343. Those three offenses matter here only as the information the killing allegedly aimed to suppress; the indictment does not charge Mr. Farwell with committing them, and no reader should treat them as proven crimes. The case is United States v. Farwell, Criminal No. 1:24-cr-10259-DJC, in the United States District Court, District of Massachusetts. That passage states allegations, not judicial findings; the jury’s later verdict is what converted accusation into conviction at trial. The defendant now stands convicted on all counts on November 10, 2026, awaiting sentencing. They are the alleged motive for silencing a witness, and the government still had to prove the killing and the silencing intent at trial.

The statute behind Count One punishes whoever kills another person with intent to “prevent the communication by any person to a law enforcement officer or judge of the United States of information relating to the commission or possible commission of a Federal offense.” That quoted language comes from 18 U.S.C. Section 1512(a)(1)(C), and the same subsection provides that “in the case of a killing, the punishment provided in sections 1111 and 1112” applies, which are the federal murder and manslaughter provisions. The practical consequence is straightforward: once the government proves a killing committed to stop a report about a possible federal crime, the killing itself is punished as a federal killing even though the underlying conduct, a sexual relationship between an officer and a young program participant, an alleged civil-rights violation, or an alleged fraud, might otherwise have stayed in state court. For families and employers watching a comparable situation, the first check is therefore about channels: a tip or complaint that reaches, or credibly could reach, federal law enforcement changes the forum, and internal reports that stay inside a department do not keep the matter local by themselves. Contemporaneous notes of who was told what, and when, matter because the charge turns on what the victim might have communicated and to whom.

The indictment adds texture that explains why federal investigators took the lead. It alleges that Mr. Farwell served as a Stoughton police officer and as an instructor in the Stoughton Police Explorers Academy, a vocational program for local youth; that Sandra Birchmore joined that program at age twelve; that sexual contact began before she turned sixteen and continued into early 2021; that she told Mr. Farwell in December 2020 that she was pregnant and that he was the father; that a friend’s call to the department in January 2021 reported the relationship; and that a department employee relayed the call to Mr. Farwell shortly afterward. Each of those allegations had to be proved to the jury, and the reported verdict indicates the jury accepted the government’s account. The lesson for comparable cases is procedural rather than moral: when an internal complaint about an officer’s conduct exists and the complainant or a witness is then harmed, investigators will reconstruct every internal relay of that complaint, because the relay can supply the silencing motive that federal law requires.

B. Prosecutors must still prove the victim might have talked to federal officers

A killing motivated by fear of exposure is not automatically a federal witness killing. The Supreme Court of the United States set the test in Fowler v. United States, 563 U.S. 668 (2011), decided on May 26, 2011, a case about a Florida bank-robbery crew and a local officer who stumbled onto it. The Court held that, beyond a broad intent to prevent communication, “the Government must show that there was a reasonable likelihood that a relevant communication would have been made to a federal officer.” That sentence is the whole federal-nexus inquiry in one line: not certainty, not an actual filed report, but a reasonable likelihood that someone would have carried the information to a federal officer. In Fowler itself the underlying crimes were state-law robberies, yet the federal charge survived because bank robbery is routinely investigated federally and the jury could find the likelihood. Applied to a prosecution built on this witness-silencing theory, the question for the jury is parallel: was there a reasonable likelihood that information about possible civil-rights violations, enticement, or fraud by a local officer would have reached federal law enforcement? The indictment’s answer was yes, pointing to the friend’s January 2021 call to the department and the seriousness of the alleged misconduct, and the jury’s guilty verdict shows that theory carried.

That the Fowler test remains the working standard, not a historical curiosity, was confirmed this year. In United States v. Ritter, No. 24-4576 (4th Cir. Feb. 18, 2026), a published opinion of the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit, decided on February 18, 2026, the court held that “Fowler’s reasonable-likelihood standard therefore governs our interpretation” of neighboring witness-tampering language in 18 U.S.C. Section 1512(b)(3). The Ritter prosecution concerned threats and intimidation rather than a killing, yet the Fourth Circuit reached back to Fowler, 563 U.S. at 678, to frame how likely a blocked federal communication must be. For the reader, the application is direct: fifteen years after Fowler, federal appeals courts still measure Section 1512 cases with its yardstick, and defense challenges still attack the likelihood link rather than the legal standard. Anyone assessing a comparable federal threat, as a potential witness, a supervisor, or counsel, should therefore focus evidence on the realistic federal destination of the information: prior federal investigations in the area, the federal character of the suspected offense, and any step, however small, that pointed the information toward federal officers.

Two practical checks follow from the Fowler-Ritter line. First, preserve the paper trail of reporting options: a victim who researched federal complaint portals, spoke with someone who urged federal reporting, or dealt with conduct already under federal scrutiny strengthens the nexus, while a purely internal grievance with no federal path weakens it. Second, separate the two intents the government must prove: intent to kill and intent to block communication. A killing without a proven silencing purpose stays outside Section 1512(a)(1)(C) even when the victim knew damaging information, which is why staged-crime evidence, here the alleged rearrangement of the apartment to suggest suicide, matters twice: it supports premeditation and it suggests consciousness of what an investigation would uncover. None of this guarantees how any future jury will vote; it maps the exact ground on which such cases are won and lost.

II. What the unborn-child count adds, and whether Massachusetts can still prosecute

A. A separate federal offense that rides on the underlying crime

Count Two of the superseding indictment charges that, through the same February 1, 2021 conduct that violated Section 1512, Matthew Farwell caused the death of a child in utero, then eight to ten weeks gestational age, in violation of 18 U.S.C. Sections 1841(a)(1), (a)(2)(A) and (a)(2)(C). The Unborn Victims of Violence Act of 2004, Public Law 108-212, created this structure: “Whoever engages in conduct that violates any of the provisions of law listed in subsection (b) and thereby causes the death of, or bodily injury (as defined in section 1365) to, a child, who is in utero at the time the conduct takes place, is guilty of a separate offense under this section.” The phrases to notice are “thereby causes” and “separate offense.” Section 1841 does not criminalize the killing of an unborn child in the abstract; it attaches a second punishment when conduct that already violates one of the listed federal laws causes that death or injury. In the Birchmore prosecution the listed provision is Section 1512, so Count Two stands or falls with Count One: if the jury had rejected the witness-killing theory, the unborn-child count built on it would have collapsed as well. The reported guilty verdict on all counts means the jury accepted both layers.

Two features of Section 1841 surprise most readers, and both cut in the same direction here. First, the punishment for the separate offense “is the same as the punishment provided under Federal law for that conduct had that injury or death occurred to the unborn child’s mother,” which means the unborn-child count can carry the weight of a homicide sentence rather than a lesser add-on. Second, and more counterintuitive, “An offense under this section does not require proof that (i) the person engaging in the conduct had knowledge or should have had knowledge that the victim of the underlying offense was pregnant.” Knowledge of the pregnancy is therefore not an element the government must prove; the death of the child in utero, caused by the qualifying federal violation, suffices. The indictment alleged that Ms. Birchmore had told Mr. Farwell of the pregnancy weeks earlier, which a jury may find compelling, but as a matter of federal law the count did not depend on that conversation. For families dealing with violence against a pregnant relative, the check is correspondingly stark: document the pregnancy through medical records early, because the statute protects the unborn child whether or not the person who caused the harm claims awareness.

The statute’s limits matter as much as its reach, and the federal courts have policed them. In United States v. Flute, 929 F.3d 584 (8th Cir. July 5, 2019), the United States Court of Appeals, Eighth Circuit, confronted a mother’s prenatal drug use that caused her child’s death after a live birth, and the district court had borrowed Section 1841’s mother-exception to block even the manslaughter charge. The appeals court reversed, explaining that the words “Nothing in this section” confine Section 1841’s exceptions to Section 1841 itself: “any limitations or exceptions in § 1841 apply only to § 1841 and cannot be used as a basis to impose a limitation on other, unrelated statutory provisions.” The exception at issue, 18 U.S.C. Section 1841(c)(3), provides that “Nothing in this section shall be construed to permit the prosecution … of any woman with respect to her unborn child,” alongside exceptions for consented abortion and reasonable medical treatment. Those shields protect a pregnant woman, a provider performing a consented abortion, and a clinician giving reasonable care, from Section 1841 itself; they do not shelter a third party who kills the mother and thereby the unborn child. That distinction is exactly why a Section 1841 count fits a prosecution built on these facts, where the alleged killer was not the mother and the conduct was not medical care. Flute was decided in 2019 and later courts have invoked it mainly for pleading standards, so this article relies on it only for what Section 1841’s exceptions cover, not as a forecast of any future ruling.

Flute remains working law in the charging-indictment context. In United States v. Branscum, No. 6:25-cr-03158 (W.D. Mo. June 3, 2026), a Report and Recommendation of the United States District Court for the Western District of Missouri, the court cited United States v. Flute, 929 F.3d 584, 587 (8th Cir. 2019) for the rule that an indictment that “tracks the statutory language” will generally suffice. The Branscum prosecution concerned alleged threats, not an unborn child, but the citation shows how Flute functions today: as standing authority on testing federal charging instruments, while its Section 1841 analysis preserves the separate-offense structure described above. The application for the reader is that Section 1841 arguments in future cases will be won on text, the list of predicate offenses, causation, and the exception clauses, not on broad claims about what the law should cover. Counsel in a comparable matter should therefore read subsection (b)’s predicate list first, because conduct outside that list cannot support a Section 1841 count no matter how tragic the outcome.

B. A federal conviction does not use up the state’s case, or the reverse

The Birchmore killing happened in Canton, Massachusetts, and Massachusetts has its own homicide laws, yet the case was tried in federal court in Boston. Readers often assume one government gets a single shot; American double-jeopardy law says otherwise. In Gamble v. United States, 587 U.S. 678 (2019), decided on June 17, 2019, the Supreme Court of the United States reaffirmed the dual-sovereignty doctrine: “an act denounced as a crime by both national and state sovereignties is an offense against the peace and dignity of both and may be punished by each.” A federal witness-killing conviction therefore does not legally bar Massachusetts from pursuing its own homicide charges for the same death, and a state prosecution would not have barred the federal case. Each sovereign vindicates its own authority, and the Double Jeopardy Clause, which shields against repeated prosecution by the same sovereign, does not merge the two.

The United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit, whose jurisdiction covers Massachusetts and therefore any future state-federal overlap here, restated the rule this year. In Rodriguez-Mendez v. United States, 134 F.4th 1 (1st Cir. Apr. 8, 2025), No. 20-1360, the court wrote that “A state and the federal government, as separate sovereigns, may successively try a defendant for the same offense without violating double jeopardy.” The opinion cites Gamble v. United States, 587 U.S. 678, 681 (2019) as describing the “dual-sovereignty” doctrine. The Rodriguez-Mendez dispute itself involved Puerto Rico, which the court treated as the same sovereign as the United States for these purposes, but the court stated the state-federal rule without qualification before drawing that contrast. That Gamble remains working authority was confirmed this year. In Ellingburg v. United States, No. 24-482 (Jan. 20, 2026), a decision of the Supreme Court of the United States, decided on January 20, 2026, the Court quoted Gamble v. United States, 587 U.S. 678, 724 (2019) for the warning that multifactor balancing tests invite policy-driven, arbitrary discretion. The contrast is the point for Massachusetts readers: states are separate sovereigns, so a state prosecution following this federal verdict would face no double-jeopardy bar. The application is that Massachusetts prosecutors remain legally free to evaluate state homicide charges tied to the February 2021 killing regardless of the federal verdict, subject to their own charging judgment, evidence, and any state-law constraints, while the federal judgment stands on its own. Successive prosecution is permitted, not required, and practical coordination between offices often means one case proceeds while the other waits.

For people adjacent to a comparable tragedy, three checks capture the dual-sovereignty reality. First, do not assume a federal investigation ends local exposure or the reverse; preserve evidence, medical findings, and communications for both forums, because each sovereign builds its own record. Second, understand that an acquittal in one forum does not compel an acquittal in the other, since each jury applies its own statutes and burdens to its own charges; the reported Birchmore verdict is a federal jury’s answer to federal counts. Third, track post-trial stages separately: sentencing, appeals, and any state charging decision each follow their own calendars and standards, so a development in one forum, a federal sentencing date or a state declination, does not automatically move the other. Only a court can finally fix criminal responsibility, and only the docket of each filed case shows where that case stands.

The punishment cross-reference inside Section 1512 also deserves a plain reading. Because a killing under subsection (a)(1)(C) draws the punishment provided in Sections 1111 and 1112, the federal murder and manslaughter provisions, the sentence for the witness-killing count can match a federal homicide sentence rather than sitting below it as a mere obstruction add-on. Combined with the separate Section 1841 count, which carries the same punishment as if the fatal injury had been inflicted on the mother, a single strangulation can thus generate two homicide-weight federal counts from one course of conduct. That stacking is deliberate: Congress designed Section 1841 to add protection for the unborn child on top of the underlying offense, not to merge into it. Anyone evaluating exposure in a comparable federal investigation should therefore count each potential predicate separately, confirm whether each appears in Section 1841(b)’s predicate list, and treat causation evidence, medical findings on pregnancy and cause of death, as the bridge the government must build between the two counts.

Conclusion

The federal verdict in this Massachusetts case rests on two connected moves: a local killing reached federal court because the government proved it was committed to stop word of possible federal offenses from reaching law enforcement, and the same conduct supported a separate unborn-child count because federal law punishes the resulting death of a child in utero without requiring proof the killer knew of the pregnancy. Fowler’s reasonable-likelihood test, confirmed this year in Ritter, frames the first move; Section 1841’s text, Flute’s confinement of its exceptions, and Zielinski’s textual discipline frame the second; and Gamble and Rodriguez-Mendez explain why Massachusetts retains its own sovereign interest whatever the federal judgment becomes after sentencing and any appeal. What remains unestablished as of the verdict date is the sentence, the outcome of post-trial motions, and whether state authorities will bring their own case. Readers facing anything comparable should secure contemporaneous records of reporting paths, medical facts, and official communications, and measure every option against the statutes and decisions above rather than against headlines.

📄 Official circular