KOHEN AVOCATS · PARIS, FRANCE
Ron Howard: When Can a Documentary Use Someone Else’s Photographs?

Hassan Kohen is a Paris-based lawyer admitted to the Paris Bar (Avocat au Barreau de Paris). Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Sources: U.S. court opinions and official U.S. government publications, read for this article

Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Ron Howard: When Can a Documentary Use Someone Else’s Photographs?

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

Ron Howard directed Avedon, a documentary about photographer Richard Avedon that began streaming on November 11, 2026, according to the distributor’s announcement. The announcement says the film draws on the photographer’s archives and was made in association with the Richard Avedon Foundation. The discussion that follows is general in scope: it describes checks useful in comparable situations and makes no finding about the documentary’s permissions.

For a filmmaker, an editor, or a photographer, the practical question is often much narrower than whether a documentary is educational or commercially distributed. Who controls the particular image, what will the film actually do with it, and is that use covered by permission or by a defensible application of federal fair use? A photograph appearing for a few seconds on a screen may still be a meaningful part of the film, a trailer, and a promotional campaign, each presented in a different context.

Federal copyright law supplies both exclusive rights and limits on those rights. Recent federal appellate decisions show why the answer turns on the work, the specific use, the evidence, and the stage of the dispute. The steps below help a production team identify the rights it needs to check, organize a license, and evaluate a proposed fair-use argument without treating a documentary label as an automatic answer.

I. What should a documentary maker check before using a photograph?

A. Identify the image, its author, and the proposed use

Start with the image itself. Record the version that will appear in the film, where the team obtained it, what the surrounding scene says, and whether the image will fill the screen or appear briefly within another shot. A photograph may be shown as a full-frame illustration, displayed in a book being examined on camera, or reproduced behind an interview subject. Those are different factual presentations. A precise record allows the team to discuss the actual proposed use, rather than an abstract idea of including a photograph.

Under federal 17 U.S.C. § 102, copyright protects original works of authorship fixed in a tangible medium, and the listed categories include pictorial works and motion pictures. The section also distinguishes protected expression from an idea, procedure, concept, or discovery. In practical terms, a film may discuss the historical subject or idea conveyed by a photograph without assuming that it can freely reproduce the photographer’s particular expression. Conversely, the mere fact that a picture depicts a famous event does not settle whether this particular image has protectable expression.

Make a separate entry for each image, even when several are in the same box, exhibition catalog, or online gallery. Identify the photographer if known, the source of the digital file or physical print, any copyright notice, the date and context of creation, and the person or organization asserting authority to grant rights. Preserve the source’s identifying information alongside the actual image. A file name such as “archive photo 12” may help an editor, but it is not a substitute for identifying the underlying work when a rights question arises.

Possessing a print, buying a book, or receiving a high-resolution scan does not by itself tell a production what rights the sender can grant. A museum may hold a print while another person holds copyright; an image agency may manage some uses but not others. Those are possibilities to investigate, not conclusions about a particular archive. Ask for the basis of the proposed licensor’s authority and compare it with the work and rights actually being requested. If the record is incomplete, mark the question as unresolved instead of treating the existence of a file as permission.

Federal 17 U.S.C. § 201 supplies an important starting point: copyright initially vests in the author or authors, with a specific rule for a work made for hire. It also permits ownership and particular exclusive rights to be transferred separately. A person who commissioned a photograph is therefore not necessarily its copyright owner simply because that person paid for the session. Review the relevant employment, commission, or transfer documents and the facts of creation before choosing the person from whom to seek authorization.

For a joint or inherited collection, the practical inquiry can be more complicated than finding one name. Determine what the proposed licensor claims to control, whether the grant concerns the photograph or only a particular copy, and whether anyone else’s authorization may be needed for the use proposed. An estate representative, an archive, and a commercial agency may each have a different role. The answer depends on the documentation and applicable federal law; a credit line alone does not resolve a chain of ownership.

Next, map the uses beyond the main edit. The production may want the still in the finished film, a trailer, a festival submission, an advertising image, a clip for social media, or a later educational version. It may also need to crop, animate, color-correct, or place text over the photograph. Write down those intended uses before requesting permission. An authorization broad enough for a single screening should not be assumed to cover every later version or promotion.

Finally, separate copyright from other questions. Depending on the facts, a recognizable person, a privately held document, an agreement restricting access, or another protected element may raise a distinct issue under applicable federal or state law. A copyright permission is useful evidence of what the copyright holder authorized; it is not a universal clearance of every possible issue in the scene. This article addresses the federal copyright question, not the outcome of those separate inquiries.

B. Match the permission to what the production actually needs

A useful license identifies the photograph and the use with enough precision for both sides to understand what is covered. Attach a thumbnail, caption, archive reference, or other reliable identifier and confirm that the described image matches the edit. Ask whether the authorization covers the film only or also approved publicity, excerpts, stills, trailers, and screenings. If the team intends to alter the image, describe those alterations rather than assuming that a general permission to display the original answers every editing question.

Discuss distribution in concrete terms. A producer should know whether the agreement covers streaming, theatrical presentation, television, festivals, educational screenings, and distribution through intermediaries, as relevant to the planned release. The geographic scope and the period of the grant should match the actual distribution plan. If a proposed agreement leaves a use outside its stated scope, the practical choices include requesting a broader grant, changing that use, or evaluating a separate legal basis for it. The signed terms matter more than an informal description of the project.

Keep the permitted use distinct from a transfer of ownership. Under federal 17 U.S.C. § 204, a transfer of copyright ownership, other than by operation of law, is not valid unless an instrument of conveyance or a note or memorandum of the transfer is in writing and signed by the owner of the rights conveyed or the owner’s duly authorized agent. This requirement concerns a transfer of copyright ownership as defined by federal law. A production should read the actual grant to understand whether it seeks ownership or permission for specified uses, rather than calling every authorization a purchase of copyright.

Clarify the parties and the grantor’s authority on the document itself. An agreement naming a collection but failing to identify the person granting rights can leave a practical gap. If an agent signs, record the basis on which the agent acts for the relevant rights holder. Keep correspondence, license schedules, and attachments together with the final agreement so that a later distributor can understand which image and which version were cleared.

Other commercial terms can change the production’s decision. The agreement may specify a fee, credit, approved caption, approval procedure, restrictions on alteration, or responsibilities if a third party raises a claim. Read those provisions together rather than extracting only the grant sentence. If the production cannot meet an approval requirement or needs a different caption for a short clip, the point should be resolved in the agreement or the proposed use changed. Do not assume that credit alone replaces permission where permission is needed.

Consider timing as an editorial issue rather than a legal shortcut. An archive may need to locate the image, identify the rights holder, and check the requested use. Beginning that process while the edit is flexible gives the team room to replace an image or revise a sequence if the necessary grant is unavailable. The absence of a response is not a reason to invent the scope of a license. Record unanswered questions and revisit them before the relevant version is distributed.

A clear internal rights table is simple but valuable: one row per image, the source file, the intended scenes, the person asserting authority, the permission obtained or the reason another legal basis is being considered, and a link to supporting documents. Mark a separate line for publicity if its visual treatment differs from the film. The table does not decide the law, but it makes omissions visible when an edit changes or a new distribution channel is added.

II. When might federal fair use cover the use, and how should the decision be documented?

A. Apply the four factors to the particular use

Federal 17 U.S.C. § 106 gives a copyright owner specified exclusive rights, subject to statutory limitations, including rights concerning reproduction, distribution, derivative works, and public display where applicable. Federal 17 U.S.C. § 107 provides that fair use is not infringement and identifies four factors for the analysis: the purpose and character of the use, the nature of the protected work, the amount and substantiality used, and the effect on the potential market for or value of the work. The factors are considered in context; no single description of the project answers all four.

For the first factor, articulate what the particular sequence does with the image. Is the image itself being analyzed or criticized, or is it primarily being used to illustrate a point that another image could illustrate just as well? A commentary can have a different purpose from the original photograph, but adding narration or placing an image inside a longer film does not automatically establish a fair use. A commercial purpose is part of the statutory inquiry, not a stand-alone rule that either defeats or establishes the defense.

The second factor asks about the nature of the underlying work. The analysis can differ for a highly creative portrait and a work assembled primarily to convey factual information. Publication status is also relevant to the statutory language, but federal § 107 expressly says that a work’s unpublished status does not itself bar fair use when the required factors are considered. The producer should identify what the actual image is and how it was used, instead of assuming that every old, archival, or publicly accessible photograph falls into the same category.

The third factor concerns both the amount taken and its significance in relation to the original work. With a single photograph, showing the entire image can be central to the inquiry. Sometimes showing the whole image may be relevant to the point a sequence is making; in another sequence it may be more than the purpose calls for. A short screen time or a small number of photographs is useful information, but neither supplies a universal federal safe harbor. Preserve the edit and explain why the portion and duration chosen serve the stated purpose.

The fourth factor concerns the effect on the potential market for or value of the original. Ask whether the proposed use could function as a substitute for a licensed photograph or an existing use, and what evidence supports the answer. Also distinguish a critical discussion that may affect someone’s reputation from a use that competes in the relevant market for the work. The point is not to declare harm merely because a license is available, or to declare no harm merely because the film comments on a public subject. The record should show what is being compared.

In Romanova v. Amilus Inc., No. 23-828 (2d Cir. May 23, 2025), the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit reversed the dismissal of a photographer’s claim and remanded with instructions to enter a default judgment. The court concluded on the complaint’s facts that publishing the photograph with a general statement about online pet photography did not justify the copying as fair use. A documentary team should therefore identify what its particular use adds and why the photograph itself is needed, rather than relying on a general subject label. The defendant had not appeared, and the decision’s procedural setting matters.

In Santos v. Kimmel, No. 24-2196-cv (2d Cir. September 15, 2025), the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit affirmed dismissal of copyright claims involving personalized videos used in television commentary; its opinion was amended on October 6, 2025. The court found fair use on the complaint and the works before it, including a different commentary purpose and no market substitution on those facts. For a filmmaker, the useful comparison is to explain the function of the actual excerpt and the evidence about the market, while recognizing that the case concerned videos rather than a documentary photograph.

In Sedlik v. Von Drachenberg, No. 24-3367 (9th Cir. January 2, 2026), the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit affirmed a judgment after a jury found six works were not substantially similar to a protected photograph. The opinion explains that the appeal concerning fair use for four separate process images was addressed in a separate memorandum disposition. A documentary maker should keep the question whether protected expression was copied distinct from the separate question whether a particular copying is fair use; this published opinion does not itself decide the appellate fair-use issue for those process images.

These decisions arise from different uses and procedural records. The Second Circuit’s decisions concern the facts presented to courts in that circuit, while the Ninth Circuit opinion addresses a jury verdict and the review of that record. A production should identify where a dispute would be heard and evaluate the applicable authorities there. The decisions offer practical comparisons, not a mechanical test that converts a photograph into fair use merely because the image appears in a documentary.

A useful exercise is to compare two proposed edits of the same image. In the first, the narrator discusses a particular choice of framing and the image is shown while the viewer is invited to examine that choice. In the second, the same image accompanies a broad account of a period without discussing the photograph. The two versions may present different purposes and amounts of use, and the market analysis may differ. Neither description alone guarantees an outcome; the team must assess the full context and the remaining statutory factors.

B. Build a record for the film and each later version

For each photograph that is not covered by an identified permission, write a short, image-specific fair-use analysis. Describe the original, the source, the exact segment of the film, its purpose, the amount shown, and the expected distribution. Address each statutory factor using the evidence available. If the rationale depends on commentary about the image, preserve the surrounding narration and the version of the edit that contains it. A later editor may otherwise retain the picture while removing the context on which the analysis depended.

Keep the factual record separate from the conclusion. A statement that the scene is “transformative” is a legal characterization; the record should explain what a viewer sees and hears, what the image contributes, and how the use differs from the original. A statement that a market is unaffected should be supported by what the team actually knows about the original and the proposed distribution. Unknown facts should remain identified as unknown. This makes a later review more useful than a spreadsheet containing only a yes-or-no label.

Test the proposed rationale against the practical alternatives. Could the sequence use a photograph created for the film, an appropriately licensed image, or a smaller excerpt while still making its point? Would a different edit omit visual detail essential to the commentary? These questions do not replace the federal four-factor analysis, and a possible alternative does not decide every case. They can, however, expose whether the production’s explanation corresponds to the work actually on screen.

Treat a trailer, poster, or social clip as its own use for review. A scene that comments on an image in a full film may be presented without that commentary in a short promotion. The selection, size, accompanying words, audience, and commercial function may change. Compare the contemplated promotional version with the license and, where fair use is being considered, evaluate that version on its own facts. Do not simply copy the film’s conclusion into every distribution record.

Plan for changes after the first cut. An image may move from a brief background shot to a title sequence; narration may be shortened; a distributor may request a different territory or promotional package. Each change can affect the scope of a grant or the factual basis of the analysis. Keep version numbers and approval records with the relevant image entry so that the team can see which version was reviewed and what actually went out.

Photographers and rights holders can use the same structure from the other side. Identify the image, preserve a copy of the version used and its context, locate any agreement or correspondence, and distinguish a permission to use a file from the ownership of copyright. Compare what was authorized with what was actually distributed. If a use is disputed, the federal fair-use inquiry remains specific to that use and its facts; the existence of a disagreement does not itself establish infringement.

When information is missing, make the consequence concrete. If the identity of the rights holder cannot be established, a proposed license may need more verification. If an agreement covers the film but not a planned advertisement, the promotional team may need a separate grant, a changed image, or a separately supported analysis. If the context for a fair-use explanation disappears in a recut, the team should review the new sequence. These are production checks, not declarations that any particular use is unlawful.

Finally, keep the decision file proportionate to the use. A central photograph reproduced in a prominent promotional campaign deserves a more detailed record than an image whose planned treatment is fully and unambiguously covered by a specific written license. For either, the record should let another person trace the source, the authorized or analyzed use, and the final edit. Good documentation does not predetermine what a court would decide, but it helps the people responsible for the release identify the issue they actually need to resolve.

Conclusion

A documentary can use a photograph when the relevant use is authorized or a federal limitation such as fair use applies on the facts. The reliable starting point is the particular image and the particular version of the film: identify the rights holder, compare the planned uses with the grant, and analyze any proposed fair use under all four statutory factors. Keep promotional material and later edits in view, because their context and permissions may differ from the main feature.

📄 Official circular