KOHEN AVOCATS · PARIS, FRANCE
USC Basketball: Are College Game Prediction Contracts Legal in California?

Hassan Kohen is a Paris-based lawyer admitted to the Paris Bar (Avocat au Barreau de Paris). Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Sources: U.S. court opinions and official U.S. government publications, read for this article

Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

USC Basketball: Are College Game Prediction Contracts Legal in California?

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

A fan looking up USC basketball may see predictions, odds, or an invitation to buy a contract tied to a college game. Those are not interchangeable. Reading a prediction is different from putting money on an outcome, and calling a paid position a prediction contract does not by itself answer whether it is permitted where the customer is located. USC Athletics announced on November 9, 2026, that the men’s team was scheduled to play California in Berkeley on November 11. The legal question below concerns a general type of offer that a fan might encounter, not a claim that either team offered one.

For someone physically in California, begin with the actual transaction: who offers it, what value is at risk, what event determines payment, and where the customer is when participating. California’s Penal Code addresses specified wagering conduct. Federal rules and recent Ninth Circuit decisions add a separate layer for event contracts, including an important dispute involving activity on tribal lands. A federal designation or a polished app is not, alone, an answer for every product and place.

The court examples below concern the records and parties in those cases. The discussion that follows is general in scope: it describes checks useful in comparable situations and makes no findings about any company’s situation. The practical aim is to identify what the offer and the relevant law actually say before money is committed, and what to retain if a transaction is later disputed.

I. Can a California fan buy a contract on a college game?

A. What is the difference between a prediction and a transaction?

Start by separating information from an agreement. A commentator can predict a winner without taking a position with an operator. A page can display a price without accepting an order. A customer who pays for a position with a return dependent on the game is looking at a different arrangement. The practical legal question concerns the terms and conduct of that arrangement, not the existence of a discussion about basketball.

Under California Penal Code § 337a, specified conduct includes bookmaking, receiving or recording certain wagers, and laying, making, offering, or accepting a bet or wager on the result of a contest of skill, speed, or endurance. The section also says it applies to a person who engages in a specified act in a single instance as well as to a business or occupation. Its text contains an exception referring to § 336.9 and separate provisions about prior convictions. Whether a particular transaction satisfies the statute, and whether another rule affects its application, requires the actual facts and applicable law.

That statutory wording is a reason to look beyond a product label. A screen might ask a user to choose whether one team wins, whether a score exceeds a stated number, or whether a player reaches a statistic. For each offer, write down what the user would give up, what the user could receive, and the event that triggers payment. If the offer is an unpaid opinion with no value at risk, record that difference. If it requires money or another valuable stake, identify precisely how the proposed payment depends on the result. The same screen may also contain advertising or links that are not themselves an accepted transaction.

Identify the legal entity on the offer and the capacity in which it acts. An account interface, a market, a clearing service, and a payment provider may have different names and different roles. Read the contract or market rules rather than assuming that the brand at the top of a page is the counterparty. Check whether the product is a cash-settled position, an ordinary wager, a promotional entry, or something else according to its own documents. Those descriptions are useful starting points; they do not settle the legal classification.

Next, identify place and time. The location of a college, the location of a game, the customer’s home address, and the place from which a device is used are distinct facts. A California resident traveling outside the state should not infer that California law alone answers a transaction made elsewhere. Likewise, a visitor in California should not assume that rules advertised for the visitor’s home state automatically authorize the same activity in California. Keep the jurisdictional facts with the offer, including any location information the service actually provided.

Do not infer acceptance from an odds page. A quote may change, an order may be rejected, or an account may show that a proposed position is still pending. Read the final confirmation and compare it with the amount, selection, and price previously displayed. If the customer has not received a clear confirmation, the useful question is what the service actually accepted, not what an earlier screen appeared to promise. An account statement and an order confirmation may each show a different part of the same sequence.

These distinctions also make the question easier to investigate after a problem. Preserve the offer as displayed, the market name and identifier, the complete rules attached to it, the confirmation if any, and the account entry showing the transaction. Record the date, time zone, and physical location as facts, without recreating a screen and presenting it as an original. Mask passwords and unnecessary payment-card details when making a working copy. A clear record of what happened is more useful than an assumption that every sports-related position is the same product.

B. What do federal event-contract rules and the Ninth Circuit decision add?

On August 28, 2026, the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit decided KalshiEX, LLC v. Assad, No. 25-7516 (9th Cir. Aug. 28, 2026), affirming in part an order dissolving a preliminary injunction against enforcement of Nevada gaming rules as to the sports event contracts before it. The panel concluded that the operator had not shown a likelihood that the federal Commodity Exchange Act preempted those Nevada rules as applied to those contracts; it remanded the election-contract issue. For a California reader, the useful application is to examine the particular contract and location rather than treat a federal market label as a complete answer to state law. The decision arose under Nevada law and concerned preliminary relief, not a final California ruling on every product.

The panel examined the specific sports contracts under the federal definition of a swap and concluded that the contracts before it were sports bets rather than qualifying swaps. It also considered the federal rule on certain event contracts and rejected the preemption theories presented at that stage. A court’s reasoning about an identified product is not a universal classification of every prediction, contest, or market. For a different offer, the terms and the relevant jurisdiction still have to be matched to the rule under consideration.

Federal 17 C.F.R. § 40.11 prohibits a registered entity from listing for trading or accepting for clearing specified agreements or contracts based on a defined excluded commodity when they involve, relate to, or reference enumerated activities, including gaming. It also describes a Commission review process for certain submissions. The definition and conditions in the regulation matter: this is not a rule that every sentence containing a prediction or every kind of financial contract is prohibited. The Ninth Circuit applied the regulation in the context of the particular record described above.

The rule should be read alongside the route by which a product is listed. Federal 17 C.F.R. § 40.2 sets submission requirements for a designated contract market or swap execution facility listing a product by certification, including the entity’s certification of compliance and an explanation of the product and its terms. That is a certification by the registered entity. A customer should not read a claim of self-certification as the same thing as a court judgment resolving every question about a particular transaction under state, federal, or tribal law.

For a concrete document check, look for the exact product name and market identifier, the entity that lists the product, and the version of the terms presented when the customer acts. A general statement that a marketplace is federally regulated can describe the marketplace without resolving whether a particular product fits each condition of the rules discussed above. If the offer points to a submission or public notice, keep the specific document and compare its description with the actual market on the screen. Do not substitute a broad headline for the terms of the contract at issue.

The distinction is especially useful when the possible outcome is framed as a yes-or-no position. Consider a hypothetical contract that pays a fixed amount if a named team wins and a different amount if it does not. Identify the purchase price, whether the position can be sold before the game ends, how an official result is determined, and what the rules say about a canceled or postponed contest. Those details may matter to the economic arrangement and to any later dispute. Their presence does not itself establish that the contract is lawful or unlawful.

There is also a difference between the scope of a decision and the breadth of a marketing claim. A Ninth Circuit opinion has authority within the federal judicial system in the circuit and must be read with its actual holding and procedural posture. A decision on Nevada enforcement does not turn California Penal Code § 337a into Nevada law, and it does not provide a product-by-product California authorization. Conversely, an unresolved question about a particular product is not proof that a particular customer or operator committed an offense. Use the court’s reasoning to frame the next check, then identify the governing provisions and transaction facts.

The decisions discussed here were issued in 2026. Their preliminary posture matters: a court considering whether to grant or dissolve preliminary relief may evaluate likelihood of success and other factors without finally deciding every claim. Before relying on an offer, compare the current documents and current official decisions with the proposition being asserted. A screenshot of a legal conclusion can omit the court, date, jurisdiction, and stage that give the statement its meaning.

II. What changes with location or a disputed account?

A. Why do tribal lands and other states require a separate check?

On September 16, 2026, the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit decided Blue Lake Rancheria v. Kalshi, Inc., No. 25-7504 (9th Cir. Sept. 16, 2026). The panel held that the two tribes were likely to succeed on their Indian Gaming Regulatory Act claims concerning the sports event contracts on their lands, reversed the denial of preliminary relief in part, and remanded for the remaining injunction factors; it affirmed the denial of relief on the separate advertising claim. A person considering a transaction on tribal lands should identify the land, product, and governing tribal framework rather than infer that a marketplace’s federal designation resolves that separate question. The decision did not enter a final injunction or decide every transaction on every tribe’s land.

The panel’s reasoning distinguished the federal framework for covered derivatives from the separate federal framework governing class III gaming on Indian lands. In that record, users entered into the contracts from the tribes’ territory, and the court considered the tribes’ governing procedures and ordinances. Those details explain the result at the preliminary stage. A customer should not replace them with an assumption that a server’s location, an app’s availability, or an advertisement settles every territorial question.

Federal 25 C.F.R. § 502.4 defines class III gaming to include sports betting and parimutuel wagering among other listed activities. That definition is one part of the framework; it does not supply the terms of every tribal ordinance, compact, or federal procedure. When tribal land is involved, identify the governing instruments and the particular activity rather than treating the regulation’s examples as a complete authorization analysis.

Location can be more complicated than the name on a device’s home screen. Someone may live in California, attend a game in another state, and use an account while traveling. Those are separate facts. A transaction on tribal land also raises a distinct inquiry from an identical-looking transaction elsewhere. Note the place where the person actually acted and the place described in the applicable documents; do not attempt to conceal or falsify a location to bypass a service’s restrictions. The question is which conditions apply to the real transaction.

A comparison with another state can show why a single national answer is unreliable. The separate guide to Wisconsin sports-betting location and account checks discusses a Wisconsin statutory exception with its own conditions. Those Wisconsin conditions do not establish a California exception. A reader moving between the two states should compare the actual location, operator, market, and applicable texts instead of transferring a conclusion from one state to the other.

Do not mistake a venue for the customer’s place. A California team can play outside California, and an out-of-state team can play in California. The game’s site may be relevant to the product description, but it does not by itself identify the law governing a customer’s conduct from a device elsewhere. Write down both locations separately. If the offering has a location notice, preserve the notice and the conditions it identifies; if the notice is missing or inconsistent, treat that as a question to resolve before acting.

Similarly, a contract’s settlement rule is not a territorial authorization. A rule may explain which score source determines the winning outcome, what happens when a match is interrupted, and whether a position can be closed early. Those are useful commercial terms. They answer different questions from whether an offering or a customer’s participation fits the applicable state, federal, and tribal rules. Keep both sets of questions visible when comparing an offer.

B. If the account or a position is disputed, what should the customer keep?

On June 15, 2026, the United States District Court, District of Oregon, decided Reynolds v. Kalshi Inc., No. 3:26-cv-00336-YY (D. Or. June 15, 2026), granting transfer of a putative consumer action concerning sports event contracts to the Southern District of New York. The court weighed convenience and judicial efficiency alongside related litigation; it did not decide the pleaded legality allegations or certify a class in that order. A customer should retain the account agreement, transaction records, and any dispute notices because the forum and the issues to be decided can differ from the location of the original transaction. This Oregon transfer decision is an example of procedure, not a California merits ruling.

Begin the record with the actual agreement. Save the account terms and the market-specific rules, including version identifiers or dates if supplied. Preserve the screen on which the customer was asked to accept terms and the confirmation of the action actually taken. A later copy of a webpage can help identify the present terms, but label it as a later copy unless there is evidence that it is the version presented at the relevant time. Do not merge separate versions into a document that appears contemporaneous.

Then build a short chronology. Record the proposed selection, purchase or stake, any confirmation, any sale before settlement, the published outcome used by the service, and the resulting account entries. Note which facts come from a document and which are a person’s recollection. Keep original messages and exported files where available. If the user received a notice about the position, retain the entire notice, including attachments and the date received. A notice that a request was received is different from a decision that the request was successful.

For a pricing disagreement, compare the price displayed before submission with the accepted price, quantity, fees, and total shown on the confirmation. If a market can be resold, a sale price before the outcome is a different figure from the amount payable on settlement. For a canceled game or an altered result, locate the rule for that specific market and the service’s explanation of how it applied the rule. Avoid assuming that all markets use the same result source or the same treatment of an interruption.

For an account-access issue, distinguish a platform’s access criteria from a promise that any particular person may trade any product. Federal 17 C.F.R. § 38.151 requires a designated contract market to apply the specified impartial-access requirements to members, persons with trading privileges, and independent software vendors, and to establish rules governing certain denials, suspensions, and revocations of access. The provision identifies the persons and privileges it addresses. It does not by itself establish that a particular customer qualifies for access or that a particular position is permitted.

For a settlement issue, preserve the contract description and the service’s actual settlement entry along with any explanation it supplied. If the record shows a reversal or adjustment, save both the original and later entries. An entry showing that a balance changed does not by itself establish why it changed. The relevant comparison may involve the market rules, a fee disclosure, a transaction confirmation, or an account-specific notice. Keeping those materials together helps distinguish a calculation question from a disagreement about the rule itself.

If there is a dispute, read the agreement’s process carefully: which entity receives a request, what identification it asks for, and what documents are incorporated by reference. The applicable agreement may also discuss a forum or a procedure for resolving disputes. Those provisions are not all interchangeable, and the court that ultimately handles a dispute depends on the governing law and the circumstances. The Oregon transfer order shows that a filed consumer action can move to another federal district; it does not establish that every customer must litigate in the same place.

Keep the record proportionate and protect sensitive information. A transaction identifier, market name, confirmation, and relevant balance entry may be enough to locate a disputed position. A password, full card number, or unrelated medical or financial information is usually unnecessary for that initial comparison. Make a copy of the unaltered record and a separate redacted working copy so that the context can be preserved without sharing more personal information than needed.

Finally, separate the reader’s own situation from the procedural history of the published opinions. An appellate ruling about an injunction, an order transferring a civil action, a platform’s response to a customer, and a final judgment on a claim are different events. Each may answer a different question. The most useful next step is to match the question to the document: legality of a proposed position, acceptance of an order, calculation of a settlement, access to an account, or the forum for an existing dispute.

Conclusion

A college game prediction becomes a different legal and practical question when a customer is asked to risk value on its outcome. In California, examine the actual transaction against the state statute and the applicable federal and tribal framework, taking account of the customer’s real location. Recent court decisions make the product, jurisdiction, and procedural stage essential to the analysis. Preserve the offer, terms, confirmation, and settlement record so the next question can be answered from evidence rather than from the name of an app or an advertisement.

📄 Official circular