KOHEN AVOCATS · PARIS, FRANCE
DC News: When Can Families Challenge a Federal Construction Project?

Hassan Kohen is a Paris-based lawyer admitted to the Paris Bar (Avocat au Barreau de Paris). Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Sources: U.S. court opinions and official U.S. government publications, read for this article

Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

DC News: When Can Families Challenge a Federal Construction Project?

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

A family connection to a historic place can provide important evidence about how a federal construction project would affect someone. It does not, by itself, settle whether that person may join a lawsuit, obtain an emergency order, or win on the merits. The practical starting point is to identify the agency decision, the particular place affected, the person’s use of it, and the stage of any existing case.

On November 10, 2026, Rory Kennedy, Maxwell Taylor Kennedy, Christopher G. Kennedy, Kerry Kennedy, Courtney Kennedy, Kathleen Kennedy Townsend, Joseph P. Kennedy II, Joseph P. Kennedy III, and Edward M. Kennedy, Jr., submitted a proposed complaint in the United States District Court for the District of Columbia. It names President Donald Trump, Vince Haley, the Executive Office of the President, Interior Secretary Doug Burgum, the Department of the Interior, and the National Park Service as defendants. In District of Columbia v. National Park Service, No. 26-cv-3838, consolidated with Lemmon v. Trump, No. 26-cv-544, the nine requested intervention. The proposed complaint alleges effects on views and shadows at Arlington National Cemetery; those are allegations, not judicial findings. As of the latest docket check on November 12, the intervention request was awaiting a ruling.

In a separate order dated November 5, the court temporarily restricted specified construction activities for 14 days on the District of Columbia and Virginia’s request. That order did not decide the proposed intervenors’ claims. The discussion that follows is general in scope: it describes checks useful in comparable situations and makes no findings about the proposed parties’ situation.

I. What must a person show when a federal project may affect a historic place?

A. Separate participation in agency review from a lawsuit

First identify who is making the decision and what action is proposed. A project described as federal in a headline may involve a federal land manager, a state transportation agency, a local government, a private applicant, or several of them. The applicable duties depend on the actual federal involvement and the legal authority for the work. A drawing, a funding approval, a permit, a finding about historic effects, and a final decision to proceed are different documents. Collecting them separately helps a reader understand what has been decided and which question remains open.

Federal historic-preservation law provides one possible route for examining the record. Under 54 U.S.C. § 306108, a federal agency with the specified jurisdiction over a proposed federal or federally assisted undertaking, or authority to license it, must take the effect on historic property into account before the expenditure or license described in the statute. The agency must give the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation a reasonable opportunity to comment. The linked Code is the 2024 edition; the D.C. Circuit’s 2026 decision discussed below applies the same provision.

This is a process obligation, not a promise that every historic place will remain unchanged. It also does not mean every construction activity automatically triggers the same full review. The federal regulations instruct the agency to determine whether an activity is an undertaking and whether that type of activity has the potential to affect historic properties. Under 36 C.F.R. § 800.3, an undertaking with no such potential can conclude that part of the process; a program alternative may govern other projects. Ask for the agency’s actual determination and the program agreement, if any, rather than assuming the process from the project’s name.

When the ordinary identification process applies, 36 C.F.R. § 800.4 directs the agency, in consultation with the appropriate preservation officer, to document the area of potential effects, review existing information, and make a reasonable and good-faith effort to identify historic properties. That area need not be understood simply as the patch of ground where a machine will operate. Read the agency’s own map and explanation: the specific project, resource, and asserted effect determine what the record shows. If the official finds that historic properties may be affected, the regulation calls for notice to consulting parties and an assessment of adverse effects.

The people involved in that review do not all have the same role. Under 36 C.F.R. § 800.2, the public may provide views for the agency to consider, while certain individuals and organizations with a demonstrated interest may participate as consulting parties. The same provision gives Indian tribes and Native Hawaiian organizations particular consultation roles when they attach religious and cultural significance to affected historic properties. A family connection can be relevant information about a place; it should not be confused with the distinct federal government-to-government relationship described in the regulation.

A person who wants to contribute can ask the lead agency where it publishes project materials, identify the property and the decision at issue, and explain the nature of the interest in writing. Section 800.3 requires the agency to consider written requests from individuals and organizations to be consulting parties, in consultation with the relevant preservation officer and, where the regulation specifies, an affected tribe. It does not say that every written request must be granted. Keep a copy of the request, the agency’s response, and the version of each document on which the request relies.

Useful comments are concrete. A reader might identify an overlooked route used to reach a memorial, provide dates of visits, point to a relevant map or photograph, or explain why a particular view is part of the experience of the place. Separate what the reader personally observed from what a plan predicts. If a visualization has a scale, viewpoint, or date, preserve that information too. The agency can evaluate a more precise submission more readily than a statement that a project is simply good or bad.

B. A personal connection still needs a connection to a legal injury

Federal Article III standing asks a different question from whether the public may comment. In a federal case, the court examines an injury that is concrete and particularized and actual or imminent, a connection between that injury and the challenged defendant’s conduct, and whether the requested judicial relief is likely to redress it. The needed showing depends on the stage of the case and the particular claim. A shared concern about whether the government obeys the law does not become a personal injury merely because the subject is important.

In Narragansett Indian Tribe v. McMaster, No. 24-5193 (D.C. Cir. May 22, 2026), the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit held that a tribe had standing to challenge the consultation leading to a second bridge-project agreement, but affirmed judgment for the federal agency on the merits. The court connected the alleged procedural injury to protection of land with cultural significance and identified possible forms of relief, while finding that the consultation actually provided satisfied the applicable requirements. A reader should therefore separate proof of a personal or institutional interest from proof that the agency violated the governing procedure; a favorable answer to the first question does not answer the second.

The facts in that appellate case also limit its use. The claimant was a tribe with a legally recognized consultation role, and the dispute concerned a federally funded Rhode Island bridge and a specific mitigation agreement. The court rejected the argument that the tribe had to be a required signatory on the facts before it, including the absence of tribal land or tribal acquisition or control in the relevant agreement. A family member or neighborhood association cannot assume that the same consultation entitlement or signatory position applies to a different project. The useful comparison is the court’s insistence on identifying the interest, the challenged process, and the possible relief separately.

In Douglas v. National Park Service, No. 26-cv-02016 (D.D.C. Jun. 12, 2026), the United States District Court for the District of Columbia denied emergency relief for a temporary event near federal landmarks because the plaintiffs had not shown a substantial likelihood of standing or irreparable harm on that record. The court distinguished a general objection to the use of a public place from evidence of a sufficiently concrete personal effect at the relevant time. The decision concerned an emergency request in a district court, not a final ruling that no visitor can ever establish an aesthetic injury. The plaintiffs later dismissed that action without prejudice on July 7, 2026.

For an individual, the practical check is to describe actual use rather than relying on a relationship label alone. Where is the person normally present? What does the person do there? How often has the person visited, and what concrete future plans exist? What feature is experienced from which location? If the concern is accessibility, identify the route, its alternatives, and what a change would mean for that individual. If the concern is a view, identify the place from which the view is experienced and the project material supporting the predicted change.

Evidence can include dated photographs, a contemporaneous visit record, a diagram showing a vantage point, correspondence about access, and project plans. It is equally important to identify uncertainty: a preliminary sketch may later change, a photograph may not establish dimensions, and a prediction may depend on assumptions about the final design. A declaration can explain personal experience, but it should distinguish a firsthand observation from an expert conclusion. Do not embellish future plans or adopt another person’s account as firsthand evidence.

The requested remedy matters as much as the injury. If the challenged decision was made by one agency but a separate party controls the effect of concern, the reader should examine how an order against the named defendant could help. In a procedural claim, the question may be whether proper consideration could affect the decision, rather than a guarantee that it would produce the preferred result. The particular theory and the record matter; neither a filing nor a personal connection automatically establishes causation or redress.

II. How can someone assess intervention, the agency record, and possible relief?

A. Decide whether an existing case is the right procedural setting

Joining an existing federal case is called intervention. It is distinct from filing a public comment, submitting an amicus brief, or starting a separate action. Before deciding which route is relevant, read the operative complaint, the orders that define the case, and the current docket. An older news report may describe the original filing but omit an amended complaint, consolidation, a later order, or a change in the requested relief. The named court and case number are the reliable starting points for obtaining those materials.

Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 24 distinguishes intervention of right from permissive intervention. Under the rule, intervention of right can rest on an unconditional federal statutory right or on a qualifying interest in the property or transaction at issue, where disposing of the action may as a practical matter impair the applicant’s ability to protect that interest and existing parties do not adequately represent it. The rule requires a timely motion. Its language describes conditions the court evaluates; a shared view of the project is not a substitute for addressing them.

Permissive intervention follows a different route. Rule 24 allows a court, on a timely motion, to permit intervention when a federal statute gives a conditional right or when a claim or defense shares a common question of law or fact with the existing action. In exercising that discretion, the court must consider whether intervention will unduly delay or prejudice adjudication of the original parties’ rights. The rule also addresses intervention by a federal or state government officer or agency in specified circumstances. Whether one path is available depends on the actual claims, the litigation record, and the court’s assessment.

The rule requires the motion to be served on the parties under Rule 5, state the grounds for intervention, and be accompanied by a pleading setting out the claim or defense for which intervention is sought. A proposed complaint attached to a motion is therefore not necessarily an operative complaint by an admitted party. Check whether the court has granted intervention and, if so, which pleading was accepted or directed to be filed. The proposed pleading’s allegations remain allegations until resolved through the applicable process.

Compare the proposed claim with the existing parties’ claims. Two people may both object to a project yet rely on different interests, evidence, statutes, or requested remedies. Conversely, another party may already present the interest and remedy the applicant wishes to protect. A reader should note the overlap and any genuine difference, rather than assuming that agreement on the desired result answers the representation question. The case record may also reveal whether the proposed participation would introduce new factual issues or affect an existing schedule.

Timing deserves a precise distinction. Rule 24 requires a timely motion, but it does not give every applicant a single number of days after an announcement. Do not borrow a deadline from a different proceeding or treat a news date as the legal start of a universal clock. Read the orders in the relevant case, record when the person learned of the decision and its effect, and check what has already occurred in the litigation. The court evaluates timeliness under the applicable law and circumstances.

Intervention is also not the same as an immediate order stopping work. A party may request temporary or preliminary relief, but the court considers that request separately under the governing standards and on the evidence presented. An existing temporary order has its own parties, terms, scope, and duration; read the order before assuming it protects every location or prohibits every activity. A scheduled hearing or briefing notice is not itself a judgment on the legal merits.

If a case has been consolidated, check both the original docket and the lead docket for instructions about where later submissions must be filed. Compare the names of the parties and the exact project described in each case. Consolidation can organize related proceedings without making every allegation in one pleading a finding in another. A docket entry can identify an available motion or order, but the document itself is needed to understand what it actually says.

B. Test the agency’s explanation and distinguish temporary relief from a final result

The administrative record is often the center of a federal challenge to an agency decision. Start with the decision document and work backward to the materials it cites: the project description, maps, environmental or historic-property assessments, relevant agreements, comments, and the agency’s responses. A record may include conflicting evidence. The useful question is not merely whether a document exists, but whether it addresses the decision, the resource, and the effect that matter to the legal claim.

Federal 5 U.S.C. § 706 directs a reviewing court, when the relevant issue is presented, to set aside agency action found arbitrary, capricious, an abuse of discretion, or otherwise unlawful. It also identifies other grounds of review and instructs the court to examine the whole record or the cited parts, with due account for prejudicial error. A disagreement with the agency’s preferred design is not itself proof that this standard has been met. The record must be evaluated against the particular statutory duty and the explanation the agency gave.

In Washington Area Bicyclist Association v. Burgum, No. 26-0988 (D.D.C. Apr. 21, 2026), the United States District Court for the District of Columbia vacated and remanded a federal decision to remove a National Mall bicycle facility after finding inadequate reasoned analysis and an inadequately explained environmental exclusion. The court relied on the particular administrative record, including the treatment of safety information, and did not order a permanent injunction. For a reader examining another project, the useful check is whether the agency addressed the relevant evidence and explained the connection between that evidence and its decision, not whether the two projects look alike.

That decision concerned a bicycle route, not a cemetery or a determination under the commemorative-works statute. It illustrates how a court examined a federal agency’s explanation; it does not decide the outcome of another construction dispute. The available docket later recorded resolution of the attorney-fee matter. A district-court decision is also different in authority from a D.C. Circuit decision, and a record in another federal circuit or state may require a different analysis.

For a historic-resource issue, compare the agency’s identification of properties with its assessment of effects. A map can show the boundary used for review; a separate assessment may explain what the agency thought would change. Look for the date and authorship of each, whether later drawings changed the relevant assumptions, and whether the document identifies a program alternative or agreement. If a public comment identifies a factual error, keep the original comment and any agency response together. The presence of a response is not the same question as its legal adequacy.

If a family or organization has evidence that was not in the agency materials, label it carefully. A personal photograph can show what the photographer saw on a particular day, but it may not prove where a new structure will cast a shadow. A professional study may depend on the dimensions and location supplied to its author. Preserve the underlying assumptions and ask whether the study addresses the current plan. Avoid describing an anticipated effect as an established fact when it has not yet occurred or has not been determined.

Emergency relief and final relief solve different problems. A temporary restraining order can preserve a defined situation while the court considers further proceedings; its actual effect depends on its language and any later order. A preliminary injunction is assessed at an earlier stage than a final judgment and requires its own showing. A final decision setting aside an agency action may send the matter back to the agency for further proceedings, as in the bicycle-lane decision. It should not be described automatically as a permanent ban on every future version of a project.

When reading a court order, note who requested it, the acts it covers, its duration if stated, and whether the court reserved another issue. Then check for later modifications or appellate orders. Do not infer that an agency has lost on every claim merely because some work was temporarily restricted. Equally, a request for an injunction does not establish that work may lawfully proceed. Those questions depend on the precise order and subsequent proceedings.

A practical file can be organized around four separate questions: the agency action, the person’s affected interest, the procedural path, and the relief requested. Place the relevant decision and plans under the first; dated observations and supporting documents under the second; the docket, current pleadings, and any intervention materials under the third; and the precise orders or requested remedies under the fourth. This organization exposes missing facts without assuming that any particular person is entitled to participate or that a court will grant relief.

Finally, check the jurisdiction at each step. Section 106, Rule 24, and the Administrative Procedure Act are federal authorities; local permits, state property rules, and a different court’s procedural rules may introduce separate questions. The D.C. Circuit and District of Columbia district-court decisions above show how particular federal courts handled their own records. They do not replace examination of the court, agency, property, and documents involved in another dispute.

Conclusion

A meaningful challenge begins with a specific federal action and a documented connection between that action and the person or resource affected. Agency participation, standing, intervention, emergency relief, and the merits are separate questions. Read the current project record and the current court orders, identify what is known and what remains alleged, and match each proposed step to the rule that actually governs it.

📄 Official circular