U.S. searches for “el nino” jumped this week as news coverage turned to what a strong El Niño winter could mean for California. For homeowners on hillsides, below canyon roads or near slopes that burned in recent fire seasons, the useful question is not meteorological. It is whether a homeowners policy will pay when sustained rain loosens a slope and pushes earth, mud or a tree into the house.
Under California law, the short answer is: usually not for a landslide that rain alone set off, but sometimes yes when a covered cause was the predominant cause of the loss. The homeowners policies in the leading California cases exclude earth movement, and the California Supreme Court has upheld a clause excluding rain that induces a landslide. The same court applies an “efficient proximate cause” rule drawn from the California Insurance Code, and the Legislature added a specific section in 2018 for losses that combine an insured peril with a landslide, mudslide, mudflow or debris flow. Federal flood program rules, for their part, separate a mudflow from a landslide.
That makes the cause of the damage the center of any claim. Before the storms, read the exclusions and decide about flood coverage while the waiting period still works for you. After damage, document the chain of events, ask the insurer which cause and which exclusion it relies on, and track the policy’s deadlines. The decisions below show how California courts have handled homes damaged by rain, mud and failed slopes.
I. Will a California homeowners policy pay when El Niño rain sets off a landslide?
A. Start with the exclusions, then apply California’s efficient proximate cause rule
Many California homeowners policies, including those in the cases discussed below, are written on an “all-risk” or “open peril” basis: they cover direct physical loss unless the policy excludes it. The California Supreme Court has described an open peril policy as one that provides coverage for all losses not expressly excluded. The real fight in a storm claim is therefore rarely about the coverage grant. It is about whether an exclusion applies, and that depends on what caused the damage. Two California statutes govern losses with more than one cause. California Insurance Code section 530 provides: “An insurer is liable for a loss of which a peril insured against was the proximate cause, although a peril not contemplated by the contract may have been a remote cause of the loss; but he is not liable for a loss of which the peril insured against was only a remote cause.”
California Insurance Code section 532 points the other way when read alone. It states that if a peril is specially excepted in the contract and the loss would not have occurred but for that peril, the loss is excepted even though the immediate cause was a peril that was not excepted. Read literally, section 532 would let an insurer deny coverage whenever an excluded event appears anywhere in the chain of causation. California courts resolved that tension decades ago by asking a single question: which cause was the efficient proximate cause, meaning the predominant one?
The leading case is Garvey v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co., 48 Cal.3d 395 (Cal. 1989), decided by the California Supreme Court on March 30, 1989. The homeowners’ house addition had pulled away from the main structure, their policy excluded loss caused by earth movement, and they argued that negligent construction, which the policy did not exclude, caused the damage. The court refused to let first-party property claims be decided under a concurrent-cause approach borrowed from liability insurance, explained that the efficient proximate cause means the predominant cause, and sent the causation dispute to a jury because the evidence supported either earth movement or negligence. In the court’s words, “The task becomes one of identifying the most important cause of the loss and attributing the loss to that cause.” After an El Niño storm, Garvey means the claim turns on which cause was the most important one, so the evidence must address the whole chain of events and not only the mud that reached the house. Garvey is still cited in current California cases: on August 27, 2026, the Court of Appeal of the State of California, Second Appellate District, in Linsao v. First American Property & Casualty Insurance Co., No. B340746 (Cal. Ct. App. Aug. 27, 2026), cited Garvey, 48 Cal.3d 395, 413, for the point that whether negligence or earth movement caused a loss presented jury questions when the evidence supported both possibilities and only one cause was covered.
Garvey also set the order of proof that a homeowner should keep in mind. The court stated that once the insured shows that an event falls within the scope of basic coverage under the policy, the burden is on the insurer to prove that a claim is specifically excluded. It added that exclusionary clauses are interpreted narrowly, while clauses identifying coverage are interpreted broadly. In practice, a homeowner with an all-risk policy does not have to prove the absence of every exclusion at the outset. The insurer that denies the claim has to show that an excluded peril was the predominant cause, and the homeowner’s job is to make sure the record contains credible evidence of any covered cause that may have predominated.
The El Niño case itself is Julian v. Hartford Underwriters Insurance Co., 35 Cal.4th 747 (Cal. 2005), decided by the California Supreme Court on May 5, 2005. On February 13, 1998, following heavy rains, a slope failed above a home in West Hills, California, and the resulting landslide caused a tree to crash into the house. The insurer’s engineer attributed the landslide to heavy rainfall associated with El Niño conditions. The homeowners’ policy excluded earth movement, including landslide, and excluded weather conditions when they “contribute in any way with” an excluded cause such as earth movement. The court held that the insurer could rely on that weather conditions clause to deny coverage for a loss proximately caused by rain inducing a landslide, and it affirmed the Court of Appeal’s judgment upholding summary judgment for the insurer. The court reasoned that “The peril of rain inducing a landslide is a genuine one, not a mere drafting fiction.” For a California homeowner whose damage came from an El Niño landslide with no other independent cause, Julian is the authority an insurer will cite first, so the weather conditions and earth movement wording of the policy is the first thing to read. Julian remains a working authority: on November 24, 2025, the United States District Court, Northern District of California, in Waytena v. Cincinnati Insurance Co., No. 25-cv-04450-RS (N.D. Cal. Nov. 24, 2025), quoted Julian, 35 Cal.4th 747, for the rule that a loss is covered when the covered risk was the efficient proximate cause and is not covered when the excluded risk was the predominant cause.
Julian is narrower than its result suggests. The court stated that it addressed only the application of the weather conditions clause to a loss occasioned by a rain-induced landslide. It also agreed that applying the same clause to a loss caused 99 percent by weather and 1 percent by earth movement would raise troubling questions under the efficient proximate cause doctrine, and it repeated that policy exclusions are unenforceable to the extent they conflict with section 530. The court noted that the homeowners in that case produced no evidence that a different peril was the efficient proximate cause of their loss. Two practical lessons follow. First, wind-driven rain through a roof, a falling tree in a windstorm or water damage with no slope failure is a different claim from a rain-induced landslide. Second, a homeowner who believes something other than rain started the slope failure needs evidence of that other cause, not just an argument.
B. When a covered cause can still carry the claim: burn scars, broken pipes and section 530.5
The efficient proximate cause rule can also work in the homeowner’s favor. The California Supreme Court’s earlier decision in Sabella v. Wisler, as Julian summarized it, involved a sewer pipe above inadequately compacted fill that broke and leaked, causing the house to settle unevenly and its foundation and walls to crack. The policy excluded settling and cracking, yet the court reversed a judgment for the insurer and adopted the rule that a loss is attributed to the efficient cause, the one that sets the others in motion. A burst pipe, a failed drain or another covered event that saturates a slope is not the same thing as rain alone, even when the final damage looks like earth movement. If the covered event predominated, the earth movement exclusion does not end the claim.
California made that point explicit for slides after the 2018 Montecito disaster. California Insurance Code section 530.5, added by Senate Bill 917 and effective January 1, 2019, provides: “If a loss or damage results from a combination of perils, one of which is a landslide, mudslide, mudflow, or debris flow, coverage shall be provided if an insured peril is the efficient proximate cause of the loss or damage and coverage would otherwise be provided for the insured peril.” The section adds that coverage is provided under the same terms and conditions as would apply to the insured peril. The statute does not make every slide covered. It confirms that a landslide or debris flow in the chain of events does not defeat coverage when an insured peril was the efficient proximate cause and the policy would otherwise cover that peril.
Wildfire is the insured peril that matters most in an El Niño year. On February 4, 2025, the California Department of Insurance issued Bulletin 2025-3 to insurers writing homeowners and commercial property coverage in California wildfire areas. The bulletin is agency guidance, not a statute or a court decision, but it states the Department’s reading of existing law: insurers may not exclude losses caused by flooding, mudflow, debris flow, mudslide, landslide or similar events if the facts establish that a wildfire, a covered peril, was the efficient proximate cause of the event. It describes the Court of Appeal decision in Howell v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co. (1990), where a fire destroyed vegetation on a slope the summer before heavy rains and a landslide, and it explains that section 530.5 was enacted after the Montecito mudslides. The bulletin ends with a direct instruction: “insurance companies should not deny such claims before diligently investigating the cause of loss and carefully considering the facts.” For an owner below a burn scar, the practical step is to put the fire history of the slope, the loss of vegetation and any geotechnical opinion linking the fire to the slide into the claim file from the first day.
The limits of the doctrine are just as important, and the Court of Appeal’s 2026 decision shows them. In Linsao v. First American Property & Casualty Insurance Co., No. B340746 (Cal. Ct. App. Aug. 27, 2026), the Court of Appeal of the State of California, Second Appellate District, decided on August 27, 2026, and certified for publication on September 23, 2026, reviewed a Sherman Oaks home at the bottom of a ravine. During a December 2019 storm, runoff streamed along an unfinished retaining wall at a construction site upslope, formed a gully, and sent water, mud and debris over the homeowners’ own retaining wall and into the house, which became uninhabitable. The all-risk policy excluded weather conditions, acts or decisions of any person or government body, faulty or inadequate construction on or off the residence premises, and earth movement such as mudslides. The court affirmed summary judgment for the insurer. It held that an insurer can meet its burden by establishing that every possible efficient proximate cause is excluded, even if a dispute remains over which one predominated; that a neighbor’s complaint that led to the construction pause was not an efficient proximate cause because a but-for cause alone is insufficient; and that an incomplete retaining wall was inadequate construction under the plain policy language, without proof of negligence. The lesson for a homeowner below a construction site is concrete: before arguing which cause came first, check whether the policy excludes each candidate cause, including construction and planning that took place off the insured property.
Taken together, these authorities give a homeowner a workable test. List every event that contributed to the damage: the rain, the slope failure, any fire on the slope, any broken pipe or drain, any construction or grading upslope, any decision by a public body. For each event, find the policy clause that covers or excludes it. Then ask which event was the predominant cause and what evidence shows it. If the predominant cause is covered, section 530 and, for slides, section 530.5 support coverage. If every plausible predominant cause is excluded, Linsao shows that the claim is unlikely to succeed under the homeowners policy, and the realistic routes are a flood policy, a claim against a responsible third party, or both.
II. What should a California homeowner check before and after El Niño storms?
A. Before the storms: map the exclusions and decide about flood coverage
Start with the declarations page and the exclusions section of the current policy, not with a summary or a marketing page. In Linsao, the court rejected a fraud claim built on the insurer’s website, reasoning that general statements about available coverage could not be understood as statements about the specific policy the homeowners bought. The policies reviewed in Julian, Linsao and Waytena show the clauses to look for: an earth movement exclusion that lists landslide, mudflow and earth sinking or shifting; a weather conditions clause that applies when weather combines with an excluded cause; a water damage exclusion; an exclusion for faulty, inadequate or defective planning, design, construction, grading or maintenance, sometimes extending to property off the residence premises; and an ensuing loss provision that restores coverage for some losses that follow an excluded event. Note each clause and the exact words, because California courts decide these disputes on the plain language of the policy as a reasonable insured would read it.
Next, decide whether flood coverage makes sense for the property. Under the federal flood program, the definitions in 44 CFR 59.1 treat as flooding a general and temporary inundation of normally dry land from, among other causes, the unusual and rapid accumulation or runoff of surface waters, and mudslides (mudflows) proximately caused by that kind of flooding and akin to a river of liquid and flowing mud. The same federal regulation defines a mudslide as a river, flow or inundation of liquid mud down a hillside, usually resulting from a loss of brush cover followed by an accumulation of water on the ground after unusually heavy or sustained rain. It then draws the line that matters for slopes: a mudflow occurring while a landslide is in progress “will be recognized as such by the Administrator only if the mudflow, and not the landslide, is the proximate cause of damage that occurs.” A federal flood policy is therefore relevant to mudflow below a burn scar, but a homeowner should not assume it answers a slope failure. The exact coverage depends on the federal Standard Flood Insurance Policy itself, which should be read alongside these definitions.
Timing is the reason to decide now rather than when the first storm is forecast. Federal law in 42 U.S.C. § 4013(c), as printed in the 2023 edition of the United States Code, provides that, except as provided in paragraph (2), new flood coverage and modifications to existing coverage under the federal program “shall become effective upon the expiration of the 30-day period beginning on the date that all obligations for such coverage (including completion of the application and payment of any initial premiums owed) are satisfactorily completed.” The statute lists exceptions in paragraph (2): an initial purchase in connection with making, increasing, extending or renewing a loan; an initial purchase within one year after notice of certain flood map revisions; and an initial purchase for private property that the Administrator determines is affected by flooding on Federal land resulting from or exacerbated by post-wildfire conditions, if the coverage was purchased not later than 60 days after the fire containment date determined by the appropriate Federal employee. The 30 days run from completion of the application and payment of the initial premium, not from a first inquiry. For a step-by-step look at what a federal flood policy covers and how a flood claim is documented, see our guide on what federal flood insurance covers after a flood.
Layered coverage is common in hillside cases. The homeowners in Linsao, according to the opinion, held both an all-risk homeowners policy and a separate flood and water or mud intrusion policy from another carrier, and they made a claim under each. The opinion also records that they filed a separate lawsuit against the City, the construction company and other parties allegedly associated with the upslope work. Those are separate routes with separate rules. A homeowners policy turns on its exclusions and the efficient proximate cause rule; a flood policy turns on federal or private flood definitions; a claim against a neighbor, contractor or public entity turns on tort or other liability rules not discussed here. Before the storms, gather what each route will need: the full policies and endorsements, recent photographs of the slope, drainage and retaining walls, any prior geotechnical or grading reports, and records of fires, repairs and nearby construction.
Finally, do the simple preventive work that also strengthens a later claim. Clear drains and gutters, photograph the condition of the slope and walls before the season, and keep receipts for maintenance. Some policies, like the one in Linsao, exclude loss from faulty or inadequate maintenance, and a dated record showing that the property was maintained helps answer that exclusion if the insurer raises it. None of this guarantees coverage, but it means the claim file will contain facts rather than reconstructions made after the damage.
B. After the damage: prove the causal chain, track the deadlines and read the denial
When rain gets in through a building defect rather than through a slope failure, the ensuing loss clause can decide the claim. In Waytena v. Cincinnati Insurance Co., No. 25-cv-04450-RS (N.D. Cal. Nov. 24, 2025), the United States District Court, Northern District of California, in an order dated November 24, 2025, applied California law to a home that took on water when intense winter storms hit San Francisco in late December 2022 and early January 2023. The water damage was traced in part to defective construction, including failed waterproofing and improperly sealed fasteners around balcony railings. The all-risk policy excluded faulty or defective construction but contained an ensuing loss provision restoring coverage for an ensuing physical loss not precluded by another provision. The court granted the homeowners’ motion for partial summary judgment and held that interior rainwater damage entering a home through a construction defect was a covered ensuing loss under that policy, along with related fungal damage, while finding that which cause was the efficient proximate cause remained a disputed fact question. When an El Niño storm drives water through a defect, a denial that cites only faulty workmanship is not the end of the analysis: read the ensuing loss clause and ask whether the rain itself is excluded anywhere else in the policy. The order is a federal trial court ruling, not a published California appellate decision, so it persuades rather than binds other courts.
Claims handling has its own clock. In Waytena, the court described California’s fair claims regulation, Cal. Code Regs. tit. 10, § 2695.7(b) and (c), as requiring the insurer to alert the insureds within 40 days of its coverage decision or, if it required more time to make a final decision, to send update letters, including written notice of the need for additional time and details of the additional information needed, every 30 days until a final decision was made, as stated in the Waytena order. A homeowner should note those intervals, ask the insurer in writing which date it is counting from, and keep every letter. If the insurer asks for more information, provide it in writing and keep proof of delivery, because the regulation, as the court described it, ties the update letters to the information the insurer says it still needs.
Do not rely on oral assurances. In Linsao, the homeowners presented evidence that claims staff told them the loss would be covered, and the insurer paid an advance for living expenses before denying the claim. The Court of Appeal accepted that the evidence raised a triable question about those statements, but held that they could not change the outcome: “Estoppel cannot be used to create coverage under an insurance policy where such coverage did not originally exist.” The court also held that, absent coverage, an alleged bad faith or inadequate investigation did not support an implied covenant or emotional distress claim. The practical rule is to ask for every coverage position in writing, to read any reservation of rights carefully, and to avoid irreversible financial decisions on the strength of a phone call. If a loan or other expense is incurred in reliance on a statement, document why.
Watch the policy’s own deadlines from the first day. California’s standard form fire insurance policy, set out in Insurance Code section 2071, requires the insured to give written notice of a loss without unnecessary delay and, within 60 days after the loss, unless the time is extended in writing by the insurer, to render a signed and sworn proof of loss. Its suit clause bars an action on the policy unless all policy requirements have been complied with and the suit is “commenced within 12 months next after inception of the loss,” and it adds that if the loss is related to a state of emergency, as defined in subdivision (b) of section 8558 of the Government Code, “the time limit to bring suit is extended to 24 months after inception of the loss.” Section 2071 is the statutory form for fire insurance; whether and how a comparable clause in a particular homeowners policy applies to a landslide or water claim depends on that policy’s wording, which none of the sources discussed here decides. Read the conditions section of your own policy, note every time limit it states, and ask the insurer in writing to extend the proof of loss period if the cause is still under investigation.
Build the causal record as if a jury will read it, because under Garvey it may. Photograph the damage and the slope before cleanup, keep samples of debris where practical, and record rainfall dates and any evacuation orders. Obtain the insurer’s engineering report and, where the stakes justify it, an independent geotechnical opinion addressing each candidate cause: rain, slope failure, prior fire, broken pipes or drains, and construction or grading upslope. Ask the adjuster to identify, in writing, which cause the insurer considers predominant and which exclusion it relies on for each candidate cause. Under Linsao, a denial can succeed if every plausible cause is excluded; under Garvey and section 530, a homeowner’s answer is evidence that a covered cause predominated; and under section 530.5 and the Department’s bulletin, a prior wildfire on the slope is a cause that must be investigated rather than ignored.
Read a denial letter against the policy, clause by clause. If it relies on the earth movement exclusion, ask what evidence shows that earth movement, rather than a fire, a burst pipe or another covered event, was the predominant cause. If it relies on the weather conditions clause, compare the facts with Julian: was this a rain-induced landslide, or was there an independent covered cause? If it relies on a construction exclusion, check whether the ensuing loss provision restores coverage for water that entered after the defect, as in Waytena, and whether the construction at issue falls within the plain words of the exclusion, as in Linsao. Each of these questions has a documentary answer, and a homeowner who assembles it early is in a much stronger position at the appraisal, complaint or litigation stage.
Conclusion
An El Niño winter does not change California insurance law, but it tests it. A homeowners policy will usually exclude a landslide that rain alone set in motion when its weather conditions and earth movement clauses are written like the ones the California Supreme Court enforced in 2005. Coverage remains possible when a covered cause, such as a prior wildfire on the slope or a broken pipe that saturated the soil, was the predominant cause, under Insurance Code sections 530 and 530.5 and the efficient proximate cause rule. A 2026 Court of Appeal decision shows the other side: when every plausible cause is excluded, the homeowners policy will not respond, and assurances from claims staff do not create coverage. Federal flood coverage can help with mudflow, but federal rules distinguish mudflow from landslide, and new coverage generally starts only after a 30-day waiting period. The homeowners who fare best read their exclusions before the storms, decide about flood coverage in time, and, after any damage, document every link in the causal chain and every deadline in writing.