KOHEN AVOCATS · PARIS, FRANCE
FAA Ground Stop: When Can Passengers Get a Refund?

Hassan Kohen is a Paris-based lawyer admitted to the Paris Bar (Avocat au Barreau de Paris). Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Sources: U.S. court opinions and official U.S. government publications, read for this article

Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

FAA Ground Stop: When Can Passengers Get a Refund?

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

A ground stop can leave a passenger staring at a departure board, a prepaid itinerary and several competing offers. The first refund question is not simply whether air traffic was interrupted. It is what happened to the passenger’s own covered flight, whether the passenger accepted a replacement or another form of compensation, and which business processed the payment. Under federal rules, a covered cancellation or significant change can trigger a refund even for a nonrefundable ticket when the passenger does not accept the covered alternatives. A temporary hold, by itself, does not establish that the ticket qualifies.

Start by saving the original itinerary, the updated schedule, notices and the payment statement. Compare the scheduled arrival at the final destination, not just the time spent waiting at the departure gate. Then decide whether to take an offered flight or seek the refund. A carrier and a ticket agent have different roles under federal regulations; the name on a booking screen is not always the merchant of record. The court decisions discussed below illustrate how a dispute may turn on the contract and the forum as well as the disruption. The discussion that follows is general in scope: it describes checks useful in comparable situations and makes no findings about the present circumstances of any party named in those decisions.

I. When does a disrupted flight qualify for a refund?

A. Compare the original flight with what the carrier actually offers

A ground stop and a canceled flight are different descriptions. An air traffic restriction can delay departures while an airline still intends to operate a flight. Some affected passengers may reach their destinations close to schedule; others may receive a materially different itinerary or learn that the original flight will not operate. The passenger should check the reservation for the specific flight and each connection rather than assume that a national headline resolves the status of every booking.

Under 14 C.F.R. § 260.2, a covered cancellation concerns a specific flight number scheduled for an origin and destination and published in the carrier’s reservation system when the ticket was sold, but not operated by the carrier. The same federal section defines covered flights as scheduled service operated or marketed by a covered carrier to, from, or within the United States, subject to the definition’s treatment of certain foreign stopovers. Keep the original flight number and the carrier’s notice. If the status screen changes, save the updated screen with the time it was viewed; an airline’s later record may use a different description.

The definition has a practical wrinkle. In its July 7, 2026 enforcement notice, the U.S. Department of Transportation extended until July 7, 2027 a limited enforcement pause for a flight that is merely renumbered when the passenger is rebooked and experiences no significant change or delay. That notice describes enforcement discretion, not a repeal of the refund rules. It also says the usual refund mandates remain enforceable when a renumbering comes with a significant disruption. Compare the whole itinerary before treating a new number alone as the end of the analysis.

For a delay or change that is not a cancellation, compare the itinerary with the federal definition. Federal § 260.2 includes a scheduled departure at least three hours earlier for a domestic itinerary or six hours earlier for an international itinerary, and a scheduled arrival at the destination at least three hours later domestically or six hours later internationally. A different origin or destination airport, additional connection points, or a downgrade in class of service can also be a significant change under that definition. For a passenger with a disability, certain changes involving connecting airports or needed accessibility features on a substitute aircraft are specifically addressed.

The difference between departure and arrival matters. Suppose a domestic connection leaves late but the revised arrival at the destination is only one hour later. That delay alone does not meet the three-hour arrival measure, although another listed change or a contract term may matter. Conversely, a replacement itinerary that arrives three hours or more after the original scheduled arrival may satisfy that measure even if the first aircraft left after a shorter wait. Compare the times displayed on the original itinerary and the changed itinerary, and retain any later notice showing what was actually offered.

For a round trip with multiple passengers, write down which segments are affected and whether the travelers intend to continue. The relevant refund amount can depend on the unused transportation, any separate ancillary charges and the applicable arrangements. Do not assume that an unused outbound segment, a flown return segment and a separately purchased seat fee are interchangeable entries. The payment record and the carrier’s description of what remains available provide the information needed to ask for a breakdown rather than a single unexplained figure.

The federal carrier rule in 14 C.F.R. § 260.6 addresses a full refund of airfare, including taxes and ancillary fees, in the covered circumstances. It also distinguishes the roles of carriers and ticket agents. A refund for the ticket is a separate question from whether a passenger can recover a hotel bill, meals, lost wages or the price of a new ticket; the ticket-refund rule alone does not establish those additional payments. Keeping the ticket transaction and other expenses separate makes an accounting easier to verify.

It is also useful to distinguish an airline announcement from a passenger’s confirmed options. A screen showing an estimated departure can change more than once. A notice that a flight was canceled may be followed by a rebooking offer, while a flight marked delayed may later be canceled. Record each change rather than deleting the earlier message. If the flight is still scheduled and the passenger decides independently not to go, the cancellation or significant-change provisions should not be treated as automatically satisfied merely because the airport was affected by a ground stop.

B. Decide whether to fly, accept a credit, or reject the alternatives

The operative choice is set out in 14 C.F.R. § 260.6. For a covered carrier that is the merchant of record, the rule requires a full and prompt refund in the specified circumstances when a consumer with a nonrefundable ticket on a canceled or significantly changed flight chooses not to fly on the changed flight, accept an alternative flight, or accept a voucher, credit or other compensation offered in place of a refund. The rule describes automatic-refund situations, including rejection of the offered alternatives and certain situations in which the consumer does not respond.

A passenger can prefer to get to a destination rather than abandon the trip. Before accepting a rebooking, check the new departure and arrival airports, final arrival, connections, cabin and passenger names. Check whether everyone on the reservation is included and whether paid services have been carried over. If the replacement is acceptable, keep the confirmation showing the new itinerary. If it is not acceptable, communicate the decision clearly and preserve the response. A traveler who takes the changed or alternative flight should not assume that the same unused-ticket refund is still due for that flight; the Department of Transportation’s refund guidance explains this distinction.

Silence and a definite rejection are not the same event. Under federal § 260.6, an automatic refund is due in the specified no-response situations when an offered changed or alternative flight departs without the consumer, or when the consumer does not respond to an offer of a voucher or other compensation by the relevant departure date described in the rule. The rule also covers a canceled flight for which no alternative flight or other compensation is offered. A dated rejection gives the passenger a clearer record of the choice; it should not be confused with a statement that an express request is always a condition for an automatic refund.

A credit may have value to a traveler who expects to use it, but it is not cash simply because its face value matches the original fare. Under federal § 260.6(c), a carrier offering a voucher, credit or other compensation as an explicit alternative to a required refund must give clear and conspicuous notice of the offer’s terms and the consumer’s right to a full refund. The same federal provision requires the alternative to remain valid and redeemable for at least five years from issuance, with notice of its expiration date. Read the actual offer and ask whether there are restrictions, who can use it and what happens to any unused balance before making a choice.

Keep a copy of the screen before selecting a button. A traveler may see one option to accept a new flight, another to accept a travel credit and a separate option to seek a refund. Those selections are not interchangeable. If a button’s effect is unclear, ask for an explanation in writing before treating it as a choice. Save the terms available at the time, including any conditions associated with the replacement, rather than relying only on a later general policy page.

For an individual with a disability, § 260.6(b) provides a refund on notification that the individual does not want to continue travel because of the listed accessibility-related downgrade, connecting-airport change or substitute-aircraft change. It also addresses companions on the same reservation who do not want to continue without that individual. Record the feature needed, the feature available on the original aircraft and the change communicated. That evidence is more useful than describing the entire journey simply as inconvenient.

Travelers should separate the ticket refund from other assistance. A carrier may make customer-service commitments about meals, hotels or rebooking, and the applicable contract may contain additional terms. Whether a particular expense is reimbursable depends on the source and circumstances; a ground stop does not by itself establish every claimed expense. Save itemized receipts and the message offering any assistance, but do not exchange a refund choice for a broader release without reading what the offer says.

II. Who should handle the refund, and what if the answer is disputed?

A. Identify the merchant of record and build a clear payment trail

Begin with the statement for the original payment. Federal § 260.2 defines the merchant of record by reference to the entity responsible for processing the consumer’s payment, as shown on a financial charge statement. That entity may be a carrier or a ticket agent. The website used to compare fares, the carrier operating the aircraft and the name on the payment statement can be different. Preserve the confirmation number for each entity and the transaction date, amount and payment method.

If the carrier is the merchant of record, the carrier provisions in § 260.6 govern the automatic-refund situations described above. If a ticket agent is the merchant of record, 14 C.F.R. § 399.80(l) addresses its duty to make a prompt refund upon request in the covered circumstances. That federal provision distinguishes the agent’s credit-card timing from the carrier’s general definition: for a credit-card purchase, it describes seven business days after the agent receives the specified information from the carrier; for cash, check, debit card or other purchases, it describes twenty calendar days after the refund becomes due. Ask both businesses to identify the status of the carrier’s eligibility information if the payment was processed by the agent.

For a covered carrier’s refund, federal § 260.2 defines prompt as within seven business days for credit-card purchases and twenty calendar days for cash, check, debit card or other forms of purchase, measured from the earliest date the refund was requested as set out in § 260.6(a)(2). The automatic-refund events in federal § 260.6(a)(2) matter when identifying that date. These are refund-processing rules, not a general deadline for filing a lawsuit. The linked DOT guidance contains conflicting wording on cash timing in one passage, so the period stated here follows the regulation’s text.

When the agent is the merchant of record, § 260.6(d) says the carrier must inform the agent without delay whether the consumer is eligible after receiving a refund request through that agent. Section 260.6(e) addresses the carrier’s prompt transfer of funds when the agent is responsible for the refund but does not possess the consumer’s funds. These provisions make it useful to ask for the date the request was transmitted and the date eligibility was communicated. They do not justify assuming that a transfer has already occurred in a particular transaction.

Request an itemized accounting. The fare, taxes and ancillary charges can be recorded separately, and a ticket agent’s separately disclosed service fee requires its own review. Section 399.80(l) permits an agent to retain a fee for issuing the original ticket only within the conditions stated there, including that the service is more than processing payment for a flight the consumer found and that the fee’s existence, amount and nonrefundable character, if applicable, were clearly and prominently disclosed at purchase. Compare the receipt with the disclosure instead of deducting a fee from memory.

Organize the record as a short sequence: original itinerary and payment, carrier notice, replacement or credit offer, the passenger’s response, and subsequent communications. Add the date and source of each item. If two businesses point to one another, preserve both replies and ask each to identify its role in the transaction. State the amount sought and whether it includes a charge paid separately. If a refund appears on a card statement, compare the amount and transaction with the original payment before concluding that every part of the request has been resolved.

Federal regulation and an airline’s contract are related but distinct sources of obligations. A contract of carriage may explain the carrier’s procedures and other commitments. Booking-agent terms may address the relationship with the intermediary. Save the versions supplied at purchase and the version attached to any new offer. If a policy page changes after the disruption, the saved purchase documents help distinguish the original agreement from a later communication.

B. Read the contracts and understand what the courts actually decided

In Herrera v. Cathay Pacific Airways Ltd., 94 F.4th 1083 (9th Cir. 2024), amended June 14, 2024, No. 21-16083, the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit reversed the denial of a motion to compel arbitration in a canceled-flight refund dispute and directed a stay pending arbitration. The court applied California contract law to the relationship between the airline claim and the booking intermediary’s agreement; it did not decide whether the passengers were entitled to the refund on the merits. The practical lesson is to save both the carrier contract and the booking intermediary’s terms because the applicable dispute process can depend on their relationship.

In Nutanix, Inc. v. Tessell, Inc., No. 24-cv-01729-AMO, the United States District Court Northern District of California on March 12, 2025 cited Herrera’s arbitration reasoning while compelling arbitration of specified claims in a different employment-agreement dispute. The later opinion illustrates an observed application of the earlier reasoning, not a decision about airline refunds. For a passenger, the comparison reinforces the need to read the relevant agreement and the claims together before assuming where a dispute will be heard.

Federal 14 C.F.R. § 253.10 limits a carrier’s ability to impose a contract-of-carriage choice-of-forum clause that attempts to preclude a claim in a court of competent jurisdiction, including a court within the passenger’s U.S. residence when the carrier does business there. In the linked Ninth Circuit opinion, the court distinguished that carrier-contract provision from enforcing a separate arbitration agreement with a third party when applicable law permits it. The distinction is specific: a booking intermediary’s clause should be read in its own text and context, rather than assumed valid or invalid solely because an airline is also involved.

In Vargas v. Expedia, Inc., No. 23-cv-06338-HSG, the United States District Court Northern District of California on November 14, 2024 dismissed the plaintiff’s claims under the particular federal aviation regulations pleaded in that case because the court found no implied private right of action, and declined supplemental jurisdiction over the remaining state claims without prejudice. That ruling does not decide whether every later federal refund provision creates a private remedy. It shows why identifying the precise legal basis and forum is a separate question from documenting a refund request.

In Yakub v. Qatar Airways Group, No. 25-cv-04142-CRB, the United States District Court for the Northern District of California on August 19, 2025 treated the alleged cancellation of an international return flight as a contract claim rather than the asserted Montreal Convention delay claim, and dismissed the federal action without prejudice to state claims in a competent court. The decision is a district-court ruling on its own allegations, not a national rule for every international itinerary. It is useful to distinguish a failure to provide contracted transportation from a claim based on delay and to keep documents that show which problem occurred.

These decisions do not turn a government refund requirement into a guaranteed court outcome. The Ninth Circuit decision is an appellate ruling, while the two Northern District of California decisions are district-court decisions addressing their own records. The recent citing decision shows that a later court used part of the arbitration analysis in a different setting; it is not a complete review of subsequent treatment. State contract law, the relevant federal provision, the agreements and the requested remedy must be assessed on their own terms.

If an explanation remains incomplete, a traveler can present a concise record to the merchant of record and ask for the written basis of the response. Federal DOT guidance on consumer complaints says the department directs the identified airline or ticket agent to respond, but does not investigate every air-travel service complaint. Provide the original and revised itineraries, the decision on alternatives, the payment statement and the request history. Keep personal account information limited to what is necessary for the recipient to locate the transaction.

A passenger considering a card dispute, an agency complaint or litigation should keep those routes distinct. The federal airline rules cited here do not by themselves establish the separate rules or time limits for a card issuer’s process, the availability of an individual court action under every provision, or the amount recoverable under a particular state contract claim. Read the applicable terms and authority for the route being considered. An agency complaint and a private claim need not ask the same decision-maker to apply the same remedy.

Conclusion

For a disrupted trip, compare the original and revised itineraries first. A covered cancellation or significant change, the passenger’s decision about alternatives and the identity of the merchant of record determine the next refund checks under the federal rules. Preserve the notices, payment statement, offer and response; then ask for a clear accounting of the fare and any separately charged services. The contract and the specific legal basis matter if the parties disagree about the refund or the place where a dispute should be resolved.

📄 Official circular