KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
US flights grounded: missed train due to flight delay compensation in France

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

US flights grounded: missed train due to flight delay compensation in France

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

On 13 November 2026, a nationwide ground stop interrupted departures from United States airports after a communications problem affected air traffic control centres. CNBC reported that flights already in the air would continue and that inbound international flights would be handled case by case. A national restriction does not, by itself, establish whether any particular flight to France was cancelled, delayed or allowed to depart.

For a traveller connecting to a separately purchased train in France, the next question can be expensive. The plane may arrive too late for a TGV from Paris Charles de Gaulle, Lyon or another station, leaving the passenger to buy another rail ticket or pay for a taxi. Does the airline have to cover that additional cost, even though it did not sell the train ticket?

Sometimes a claim against the air carrier is possible under the Montreal Convention, an international treaty applied by French courts to qualifying international air journeys. The result depends on the journey, the actual delay, the loss and the evidence, as well as any defence available to the carrier. A French judgment awarded the documented cost of a taxi after passengers missed a train; another rejected a claim for rail and transfer costs on the facts before it. Neither decision makes reimbursement automatic. The steps below separate the air ticket from the rail contract and show what a traveller can preserve, calculate and ask the carrier to explain.

I. Missed train due to flight delay: which journey and which loss are being examined?

A. Does the Montreal Convention cover a flight from the United States to France?

Start with the transport agreement, not the general news alert. Keep the original flight confirmation, the dates and airports, the name of the contracting airline, the company that actually operated each flight, and any itinerary issued after the disruption. A reservation may contain a connection before the Atlantic crossing; the relevant documents should show whether the parties treated the flights as one international journey. A train ticket bought separately is another document and may involve another company entirely.

The Montreal Convention applies to qualifying international air carriage under its own conditions. Its first article looks at the points of departure and destination agreed by the parties and at the states concerned. The International Civil Aviation Organization records both France and the United States as parties. The United Nations treaty record also records the United States’ ratification and the convention’s entry into force. This helps identify the treaty to examine for a US–France air journey, but it does not settle every question about a particular multi-flight booking, an intermediate stop or the identity of the carrier against which a claim is made.

French law also directs attention to this treaty in certain cases. Article L. 6421-3 of the French Transport Code refers to the Montreal Convention when addressing the liability of an air carrier holding the operating licence described in that provision. The provision must be read within its own scope: it is not a statement that every airline in the world holds such a licence, and the absence of that licence does not, by itself, answer every question about the treaty.

The loss considered here arises from the delayed air journey. It is not enough to say that the American airspace system experienced disruption: the passenger must establish what happened to the booked flight and how that event led to the missed train. An airport notice, an airline’s changed itinerary and an arrival record answer different parts of that question. A delayed departure may be partly recovered in flight; an itinerary that was changed may arrive later for reasons that require further examination.

The governing principle and its defence appear together in a Toulouse judicial court judgment of 27 March 2026, no. 25/02765, which reproduces article 19 of the convention: « Le transporteur est responsable du dommage résultant d’un retard dans le transport aérien de passagers, de bagages ou de marchandises. » (The carrier is liable for damage resulting from delay in the carriage by air of passengers, baggage or cargo.) The same passage continues: « Cependant, le transporteur n’est pas responsable du dommage causé par un retard s’il prouve que lui, ses préposés et mandataires ont pris toutes les mesures qui pouvaient raisonnablement s’imposer pour éviter le dommage, ou qu’il leur était impossible de les prendre. » (However, the carrier is not liable for damage caused by delay if it proves that it and its employees and agents took every measure that could reasonably be required to avoid the damage, or that taking those measures was impossible.)

That defence matters after an air traffic control restriction. The existence of a government order is important evidence, but the nature of the restriction, its connection to the individual flight and the measures available to the carrier still need examination under the relevant legal basis. Do not treat a headline as proof either that every claim succeeds or that every carrier is automatically relieved of liability. The Toulouse judgment concerned another route and another disruption; it explains the treaty wording, not the outcome of the November US event.

This article concerns a loss following delayed air travel. A traveller whose flight never operates and who decides not to travel may have a different claim concerning the unused air ticket. Refunds, assistance during a disruption and other passenger rights can have their own requirements. They should be examined separately from a demand for the price of a missed train or the reasonable cost of reaching the same rail destination.

B. Was the train bought separately, and what has actually been lost?

Look at the confirmation emails and the payment statement. A separate rail purchase commonly has its own order number, fare conditions and seller. A combined air–rail product may instead describe an integrated itinerary and provide particular rebooking arrangements. Do not assume that a single website, a shared account or an itinerary displayed on one screen necessarily answers the contractual question. Read what was sold, by whom, and on which terms.

When French civil law governs the contract in question, article 1103 of the Civil Code states: « Les contrats légalement formés tiennent lieu de loi à ceux qui les ont faits. » (Contracts lawfully formed have the force of law for those who made them.) Article 1199 adds: « Le contrat ne crée d’obligations qu’entre les parties. » (A contract creates obligations only between its parties.) These provisions have their own context and qualifications; identifying the parties remains essential. A rail company is not automatically bound to change an independent ticket merely because a flight operated by someone else arrived late.

That distinction does not make the airline claim disappear. The proposed claim is not that the airline promised to operate the separate train. It is that a proven delay in the air carriage caused an identifiable financial loss, such as the cost of a replacement journey, and that the carrier should answer for that loss under the applicable air-carriage rules. The air carrier may contest the causal link, the amount, the applicable law or its liability. Each of those questions deserves a separate answer.

A useful example is the Lyon judicial court judgment of 2 June 2026, no. 25/01967. The passenger arrived late after an international flight, missed the train needed to continue the journey and took a taxi. The court found that the delay prevented use of the train and awarded €176.75 for the taxi on the basis of the invoice produced. It rejected the passenger’s attempt to obtain an additional €600 simply by borrowing a fixed figure from a different passenger-rights regime. The judgment assessed the facts and evidence before it; it did not declare that every taxi after every late flight is recoverable.

Another decision demonstrates why the facts cannot be flattened into a promise. In a judgment of 10 October 2025, no. 25/04867, the Aulnay-sous-Bois proximity court rejected claims for train and transfer expenses in a different disrupted air journey. The court considered the legal basis and the circumstances of those expenses, including whether they were known or foreseeable when the contract was made. That case was not the same as the Lyon taxi claim and did not decide this US ground stop. Together the judgments show why the traveller must identify both the particular loss and the rule invoked, instead of assuming that the presence of a rail receipt resolves liability.

For illustration, imagine a passenger who paid €70 for a non-exchangeable train from the airport and then paid €95 for a later train. The financial position is not necessarily €165. If the first fare was later refunded, the refund must be taken into account. If the replacement ticket was for a materially different service, the passenger should explain the choice and retain the offers available at the time. These figures are examples, not a tariff or an amount guaranteed by law.

The same careful accounting applies to a taxi. A receipt can show the fare, but a carrier may ask why another train, a bus or a rebooking was not a practical option. Save the relevant timetable, the time of arrival, information about the last available service and any message asking the airline or seller for help. If several passengers shared a car, record who paid and how the cost was divided. The aim is a clear account of the actual loss, not an estimate based only on the inconvenience of a late arrival.

II. Flight delay compensation for a missed train: how can a passenger support and pursue the claim?

A. Which documents show that the delayed flight caused the extra cost?

Build a timeline from documents created before and during the journey. The original booking should show the scheduled air arrival; the rail confirmation should show the train booked for that itinerary. Preserve the carrier’s delay or rebooking notices and a reliable record of the actual arrival. A revised boarding pass, airport message or written airline response may help, but keep the complete document rather than an isolated cropped time. Note the time zone used in each record so that an American departure notice is not accidentally compared with a French arrival time as though both were local.

Next, show the link between the arrival and the train. The fact that a plane landed late does not automatically establish that a passenger could not reach a platform. Explain the route from the arrival terminal to the rail station, any border or baggage formalities actually encountered and the scheduled train departure. If the connection was already exceptionally tight before the disruption, disclose that fact. An airline may argue that the passenger’s own arrangements contributed to the loss; the answer will depend on the evidence, not simply on a label attached to the itinerary.

Preserve the original train’s conditions and the seller’s response. A fare may permit an exchange, a refund, a partial credit or neither, depending on the contract and the circumstances. Ask the seller what can be done and retain the answer. If a voucher is offered, record its amount and conditions before treating it as equivalent to cash. A refusal should be kept in writing where possible. A passenger should not claim a fully lost fare if the amount was subsequently repaid.

For the replacement journey, retain the invoice and proof of payment as well as the ticket. If a taxi was shared or paid by another person, explain the payment. If the passenger chose a replacement train, retain the booked class and time and any available alternatives that informed the decision. If the carrier or rail seller provided a replacement at no additional charge, identify that arrangement rather than claiming a cost that was not incurred. A bank transaction alone may show payment without explaining what service was bought; a ticket plus a receipt is more informative.

Evidence is also needed when the claimed loss is not another transport ticket. A prepaid appointment, accommodation or a business expense may require a different contract and its own proof. The traveller should identify the expense, the person who bore it, any refund or credit, and how the air delay affected the expense. The existence of a delay is not a substitute for those documents. Do not attach someone else’s personal or commercial records unless they are needed to support the claim and can properly be shared.

The contrast between two Lyon decisions is useful. In the taxi case, the court identified both the missed train and the paid replacement. In the judgment of 5 May 2026, no. 25/02979, a different passenger relied on a confirmed reservation but did not supply sufficient particulars or supporting material to establish the claimed loss; the court rejected the Montreal Convention claim. That judgment does not mean that emotional or financial harm can never be compensated. It shows the consequence in that case of failing to substantiate the harm relied upon.

French procedural law gives a practical reason for assembling the file carefully when the claim is pursued before a French court. Article 9 of the Code of Civil Procedure states: « Il incombe à chaque partie de prouver conformément à la loi les faits nécessaires au succès de sa prétention. » (Each party must prove, in accordance with the law, the facts necessary for its claim to succeed.) Article 1353 of the Civil Code states: « Celui qui réclame l’exécution d’une obligation doit la prouver. » (A person claiming performance of an obligation must prove it.) Its second sentence also concerns the person claiming to have been released. These provisions do not erase the convention’s specific allocation of proof for the carrier’s defence.

It is sensible to keep the carrier’s explanation as carefully as the passenger’s receipts. A message stating “air traffic control” may identify a broad cause without describing the flight’s position, the operational restriction, subsequent rebooking or measures taken to prevent the claimed loss. Ask the carrier to explain the disruption affecting the booked flight and the steps it considered. The carrier may have records the traveller cannot obtain from a public departure board. A passenger can challenge a conclusion with the available evidence without claiming to know the contents of internal operational records.

There may also be a difference between the cause of the flight delay and the cause of the financial loss. Suppose a flight is held for safety reasons, arrives late, and the airline then offers a connection that reaches the train station in time. The passenger’s decision to decline that option may matter. Conversely, where no suitable onward option is offered and a necessary replacement is documented, the argument for a causal connection can be stronger. Neither example decides whether the carrier has established the treaty defence; that assessment remains specific to the proven facts.

B. How should a passenger request compensation and respond to a refusal?

Address the request to the carrier identified in the air contract and, where the operating company is different, identify that company as well. A ticket agent may hold documents or payment information, but the name on a booking platform is not always the name of the airline that performed the flight. Ask each business to identify its role if the documents are unclear. For a dispute involving a contracting carrier and an actual carrier, the applicable treaty and the booking arrangements may need closer examination; do not assume that a commercial flight number alone settles the question.

A concise first request can set out the original flight and rail itinerary, the actual arrival, the missed train and the amount claimed. Attach the flight confirmation, rail ticket, delay evidence, replacement receipt and the rail seller’s response. State whether any fare, replacement or credit has already been received. A useful calculation has one line for each item: original train fare, refund or credit, replacement travel cost, and the net amount still claimed. Explain any unusual expense in a sentence and keep copies of the attachments.

For example, a passenger might write: My confirmed flight arrived after the departure of my separately booked train. I attach the original itinerary, the train ticket, the arrival notification and the receipt for the replacement journey. The rail seller has confirmed that the original fare was not refunded. Please explain whether you will reimburse the attached net expense and, if you refuse, the factual and legal reasons for your decision. The wording is a model for organising the facts. It does not assert that the airline was at fault or that the requested sum is automatically due.

If the airline offers a flight refund or credit, read what the offer covers before accepting. The unused air fare, assistance while waiting, a substitute train and an additional financial loss are different entries. An offer can resolve one issue without necessarily resolving all others, depending on its wording and the applicable law. If a document asks the passenger to settle the entire dispute, check the scope of the proposed settlement and retain a copy before deciding. Do not add the same loss twice merely because two different rules are mentioned in correspondence.

If the refusal relies on the ground stop, compare its explanation with the actual itinerary. Did the restriction affect the passenger’s departure airport and scheduled flight? Did the carrier describe a delay, a cancellation or a later change of aircraft? What alternatives were offered, and when were they available? Ask for clarification where the answer is unclear. The Montreal rule reproduced in the Toulouse decision requires attention to measures that could reasonably have been taken to avoid the damage, or their impossibility; a passenger should not confuse that test with a different test under another passenger-rights regime.

Where a carrier argues that the cost of the independent train was not within its contractual responsibility, the response should identify the precise legal basis rather than merely repeating that the train was missed. The Aulnay-sous-Bois decision discussed a different case in which the court considered the foreseeability of rail and transfer expenses. The text of article 1231-3 of the Civil Code concerns foreseeable contractual damages under the conditions it states. Its application cannot simply be assumed for every international air claim: the treaty and the legal basis actually invoked must be examined. Equally, the Lyon taxi judgment cannot be turned into a guarantee that every separate expense will be paid.

If direct correspondence does not resolve the dispute, a consumer may examine whether a relevant mediation scheme and a French forum are available for the particular carrier and transaction. Article L. 612-1 of the French Consumer Code describes access to consumer mediation within its scope. Article L. 612-2 lists situations in which a consumer mediator cannot examine a dispute, including the absence of a prior written attempt to resolve it directly with the professional. The mediator’s competence and the other statutory conditions must be checked; a passenger should not presume that a French mediator can hear every dispute involving a foreign airline.

Keep a dated record of the request, attachments, replies and any mediation filing. The appropriate court, the persons who may be sued and the time allowed for a particular action depend on the route, the treaty, the parties and the claim. They should be checked from the applicable sources for the individual journey rather than inferred from an airline’s customer-service response. A discussion with a carrier should not be assumed to alter those rules.

For a traveller who wants to understand the distinction between the flight claim and other travel arrangements, the site’s French aviation law page provides the broader context. The practical task remains the same: establish the contractual itinerary, identify the documented loss and ask the correct business for a reasoned response. A complete file makes it easier to assess both the passenger’s argument and the carrier’s explanation.

Conclusion

A US ground stop does not determine the fate of every flight to France. If a delayed flight causes a passenger to miss a separately purchased French train, a claim for an actual additional expense may be available under the Montreal Convention when its conditions are met. The Lyon taxi judgment shows what a documented loss can look like; the Aulnay-sous-Bois decision and the convention’s carrier defence show why a favourable result cannot be assumed. Preserve both tickets, the delay record, the replacement receipt and any refund or refusal, then calculate the net loss and identify the legal basis for each request.

📄 Official circular