By Hassan Kohen, lawyer at the Paris Bar.
“Weather forecast snow” is being searched in the United Kingdom. If you slipped on an icy public pavement in England or Wales, the first thing to establish is the precise spot where you lost your footing. A pavement beside a road, a crossing and the paved approach to a building can look like one continuous surface. The distinction matters when you are trying to identify who had responsibility for the place where you fell. Even where the highway authority is responsible, the presence of ice alone gives an incomplete picture of whether it breached its duty.
The law of England and Wales requires highway authorities to take reasonably practicable steps to protect safe passage against snow and ice on highways maintainable at public expense. A claim for damages turns on the circumstances at the location and time of the fall, including the condition of the surface, what the authority could reasonably have known or done, and what caused the injury. This article sets out a general method for preserving evidence, checking the maintenance boundary and reading the records for the relevant winter treatment route. It describes the law as checked on 18 November 2026 and makes no factual claim about any current weather event or accident.
I. Establish where you fell and who maintained it
A. Mark the point of the slip before investigating responsibility
The place where you came to rest may be several steps from the place where your foot slipped. Start with the earlier point. Identify the side of the street and the direction you were walking. If you can recall it, record whether your foot was near a kerb ramp, a drain, a dropped crossing or a change in paving. Mark the point on a simple sketch. An address can give the right block while leaving the most important question open. A map pin with a short description of your direction of travel may make it possible to distinguish the pavement from the next surface.
If it is safe to do so, take a wide photograph looking back along your route and a closer photograph of the surface. Use a fixed feature such as a lamppost, a crossing island or a joint in the paving as a reference. Photograph that feature in relation to the patch and, where possible, to both ends of the section of pavement. If a witness took the pictures, record where they were standing and when they took them. Preserve the original files and make a separate copy for any annotations. A screenshot sent through a messaging app can be helpful at first, but the original may retain the time and more detail about the conditions.
Record what you saw at the time separately from what you saw later. Ice can melt, harden again or be covered with fresh snow. A picture taken two hours later can still show the layout, the slope or the position of a drain. Mark its time so nobody mistakes it for an image immediately after the fall. If the surface appeared wet, record that observation rather than assigning a cause you could not see. If someone else saw ice before you arrived, ask them to record what they saw in their own words and where they were looking from. Compare their description with the sketch before assuming that both accounts concern the same patch.
An incident near a shop entrance illustrates the boundary problem. A continuous row of paving slabs can run from a road crossing past several frontages and onto a forecourt. A store employee may write that the fall happened outside the shop. That gives a landmark, but it may leave open whether the person stepped off publicly maintained pavement before slipping. A photograph showing a threshold, a change in level or a row of bollards can help locate the spot. The legal status of the land still needs to be checked. The markings you can see may reflect the design of the street rather than the extent of the public maintenance duty.
Start that check with section 36 of the Highways Act 1980, which sets out categories of highways maintainable at public expense and requires the councils specified in subsection (6) to keep a list of the streets in their area that fall into that category. Subsection (7) provides for inspection of the list. Ask the relevant highways team to identify the road and the extent of the publicly maintained surface at the marked point. Supply the sketch or relevant photographs. A street appearing in the list is a reason to check the maintenance boundary against the precise location, especially where several surfaces meet.
Terminology can make a difference when searching for records. Section 329 of the Highways Act 1980 distinguishes a footway, which forms part of a highway that also includes a carriageway and carries a right of way on foot only, from a footpath as separately defined in the Act. If you are describing the pavement running next to a road, asking about the footway can help the highways team identify the asset. Use both the street name and the type of surface in the enquiry. If the authority says the place was outside its maintenance boundary, ask for the basis of that answer and any plan showing where its responsibility ends.
B. Identify what the snow and ice duty required at that spot
Section 41 of the Highways Act 1980 places the maintenance duty for a highway maintainable at public expense on the authority for that highway, subject to the statutory qualifications. Subsection (1A) specifically requires the authority, so far as reasonably practicable, to ensure that snow or ice does not endanger safe passage. This duty was inserted by section 111 of the Railways and Transport Safety Act 2003, which came into force on 31 October 2003. These provisions are the starting point when a claim in England or Wales concerns ice on an adopted pavement.
Ask how the authority decided whether to treat the location, and what could have been done before the fall. A forecast may influence that decision, but a broad forecast supplies limited information about any particular stretch of pavement. A shaded ramp, an exposed bridge and an open length of road can behave differently. Local observations, forecasts available at the relevant time, previous reports and the characteristics of the route help give the conditions a history. Look for records made before the fall. A later report may show where the danger was found, but it could have been the first time anybody notified the authority.
A winter service plan may prioritise certain roads or pedestrian routes. Obtain the version that applied on the date of the fall and check whether it covers footways as well as carriageways. Read the map and the written rules together. A line representing treatment of the road may say little about whether the adjacent pavement was scheduled separately. The plan might also distinguish the main pedestrian approach from a ramp or crossing. Check which layer of the map you are reading, what its symbols mean and whether it reflects the route used that winter.
Timing is as important as coverage. Establish when the authority received the information it used, when a decision was made, when a treatment crew set out and when it reached the relevant stretch. Where an operation was logged after a fall, check whether the record shows the time of the operation or the time the operator entered the information. If a route was planned for several hours before the fall but the first operation at the relevant spot happened later, the gap needs an explanation. An equipment fault, a change in the forecast or a higher priority incident may be in the record. Equally, the crew could have treated the carriageway while the pedestrian route was dealt with separately.
An authority may say that its response was reasonable in the circumstances. Section 58 of the Highways Act 1980 sets out a special defence in claims for damage resulting from failure to maintain a publicly maintainable highway, where applicable. The statute directs attention to matters including the kind of highway and expected traffic, the appropriate maintenance standard, what danger the authority knew or could reasonably have known about and what warnings were displayed where earlier repair could not reasonably have been expected. For the defence, contracting out work alone is insufficient unless the authority also proves that proper instructions were given and carried out. Keep the authority’s explanation and compare it with the contemporaneous records relevant to the snow and ice duty.
II. Compare the authority’s records with the accident and the injury
A. Request the records that show what happened on the route
Ask for records that can be matched to the time and point of the fall. A useful enquiry gives the road, the side, the nearest fixed landmark, the surface and the approximate time. Ask whether the point falls within the publicly maintained highway, which pedestrian treatment route covered it if any, and what records support the answer. A request for every winter service document for the entire area is harder to use. A map for the relevant date, the version of the priority policy then in force and the records for the treatment round covering that place provide a place to start.
The operational records to ask about may include decisions to mobilise, the treatment order issued for the route, timestamps, route plans, operator logs and records of missed or interrupted work. If the authority can identify vehicle tracking for that route, ask whether it shows where the equipment was actively treating the surface or only where the vehicle travelled. A track showing a vehicle passing at a given time does not tell you unaided whether it spread material, which side of the road it treated or whether the relevant path needed separate equipment. A manual log can supply detail a map does not show. Compare both with the instructions in force.
Ask about complaints or reports for the same spot and the hours before the fall. Note what the report actually described. A warning about a nearby road junction may concern a different surface. A report about repeated freezing at a particular kerb ramp may be closer to the point you are investigating. If the authority refers to a warning it displayed, ask for the location, the wording or type of warning, and when it was put out or taken down. Compare that with the direction you approached from. A sign at one end of a long path may be relevant to some users and may have been out of sight to others.
Consider a hypothetical fall shortly after eight in the morning at a crossing beside shops. The authority sends a log showing it treated the street before six. The street is marked on a carriageway route, and a separate pedestrian route starts at nine. If the fall was on the kerb ramp, identify which route included the ramp and whether the pedestrian treatment instruction covered it. A report from a witness at seven might describe ice near the crossing, while a photograph after nine could show a treated surface. The documents are compatible with several accounts of what happened. Comparing the precise times and the treatment boundary helps establish which account the records support.
Sometimes the reply will say there is no record of treatment. Ask whether that means the location was outside all scheduled routes, a round was cancelled, a log is missing or the records are held by a contractor. Those possibilities have different implications. A route plan shows what was intended. A treatment record may show what was done. A decision log can explain why work was deferred or why a route was omitted. If the authority says it had no report before the accident, keep the time of the first report and ask what other information it used to assess the risk. The statutory question concerns what was reasonably practicable in the circumstances, which can include whether the risk was apparent without a public report.
Where the pavement was scheduled for treatment, match the planned direction of travel to the point shown in your photographs. If the crew approached from the opposite end, a time recorded for the start of the round may be a poor estimate for when it reached the place you fell. A route with a long gap between two recorded stops can be checked against the sequence of streets, rather than assuming all stops occurred at evenly spaced intervals. The same applies if the route was diverted. Ask for the instruction or record showing where the crew resumed the planned round. An accurate sequence can help test whether a claimed omission could have affected the surface before the accident.
Conditions can also change after treatment. In a case where a crew reached the spot before the fall, look for evidence of what happened in between. If a witness describes water running across the pavement, record where it appeared to come from and whether it was visible before or only afterwards. Identify any later inspection and whether the records show time for a further response. Separate an allegation that the authority failed to treat the route from an allegation that it failed to respond to a renewed hazard. Different documents will bear on those two questions. A log that resolves the first may leave the second open.
Keep a chronology with separate columns for the document, the time it records and what it establishes. Put your own observations on the same timeline without merging them into the authority’s records. If the authority says it used a forecast and you kept a screenshot of a public forecast, record the source and issue time of each. Different services can issue updates at different times. In a civil claim, a disagreement may concern a short interval between a warning and the fall. Keeping issue times and observation times distinct makes it easier to see whether the parties are talking about the same conditions.
B. Link the condition of the pavement to the injury and check the deadline
A failure to take reasonably practicable steps and an injury at the location are separate matters to establish. The account of the fall should explain how the condition of the pavement caused the slip and what happened next. Record where your foot made contact and what you observed about the surface. If your foot caught on a raised edge, record that as well. If you are unsure because the incident happened quickly, state what you remember and what comes from somebody else’s account. A witness who saw the fall and a witness who later examined the surface may both have useful evidence about different points.
Preserve the initial incident report and early medical records. Check whether they identify the injury, the time of the incident and the account given at the first opportunity. An initial appointment may focus on immediate symptoms, while later assessment records a fuller diagnosis or a longer period of recovery. Put the records in date order. If a record contains a mistake about the location or the mechanism, keep it and any correction. A chronology can show how information developed over time. It can also help distinguish treatment related to the fall from treatment for an existing condition.
Keep receipts, details of lost earnings and any other record of expenses you attribute to the injury. Put those documents alongside the relevant period of medical recovery. If you missed work, note the dates, the effect on pay and any other reason for an absence during the same period. If you incurred travel costs for treatment, keep the appointment and travel records together. These documents help identify the financial impact if liability can be established. They also make it possible to explain which amounts are evidenced and which are provisional.
Check the limitation date while seeking the records. Section 11 of the Limitation Act 1980 generally gives three years for a personal injury claim of the kind it covers, starting on the date the cause of action accrued or the injured person’s later statutory date of knowledge. In a straightforward fall where the injury and its cause are apparent, begin by checking the date of the accident. Keep a calendar record and check the date before relying on any later event. Reporting the fall, requesting documents or receiving a claims reference is distinct from bringing the action within the statutory period.
Section 14 of the Limitation Act 1980 defines the date of knowledge for these purposes. It addresses knowledge of matters such as the significance of the injury, whether it was attributable wholly or partly to the act or omission alleged, and the identity of the defendant. It also covers knowledge a person might reasonably have been expected to acquire. Discovering a further item of evidence, or later learning that the law may recognise a claim, does not by itself establish a new starting date. Section 33 of the Limitation Act 1980 provides a discretionary power in certain circumstances. Its application depends on the facts, including the prejudice to each side. Take the ordinary statutory limit as the starting point when organising the chronology.
Put the paperwork in an order that allows somebody unfamiliar with the street to follow it. Begin with the map and image showing the exact point, then add the answer about public maintenance. Follow with the winter policy and the operational record for the pavement. Place the witness and incident accounts in time order before the documents showing injury and financial loss. Keep the authority’s written explanation next to the underlying entries it relies on. The Paris law firm’s English-language practice page describes its work in France. The statutory duties and claim periods discussed here apply in England and Wales.
Conclusion
A claim after a slip on an icy pavement starts with the exact point of the slip. Check whether that point was maintainable at public expense and identify the highway authority responsible for it. Then compare the applicable winter service policy with the decisions, instructions, reports and treatment records for the time and place of the fall. A map showing that a nearby road was gritted leaves open what happened on the pavement. The conditions at the location, the authority’s response and the cause and consequences of the fall still have to be established.
Preserve the evidence while it is available and check the limitation date while correspondence is ongoing. The records that matter most are those that connect the maintenance boundary and treatment decisions to the surface where you lost your footing, and those that connect the fall to the injury and losses you claim.