KOHEN AVOCATS · PARIS, FRANCE
sf flooding: can you file a claim against San Francisco for flood or sewer backup damage?

Hassan Kohen is a Paris-based lawyer admitted to the Paris Bar (Avocat au Barreau de Paris). Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Sources: U.S. court opinions and official U.S. government publications, read for this article

Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

sf flooding: can you file a claim against San Francisco for flood or sewer backup damage?

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

Searches for “sf flooding” climbed in Google Trends data for the United States on November 18, 2026. That day, the official website of the City and County of San Francisco displayed a flood advisory running through November 20, warning that heavy rain and wind may cause flooding, mudslides, outages, road closures and downed trees. Once the water drains, the question for many owners, tenants and shopkeepers is not meteorological but financial: can the City be made to pay for a flooded basement, ruined inventory or a sewer backup that came up through a floor drain?

Under California law the short answer is yes in some cases, but only through specific doors, each with its own proof and its own clock. A property owner whose damage was caused by the way a public sewer or drainage system was designed, built or maintained may sue for “inverse condemnation” under the state constitution, without first filing an administrative claim. Almost every other damages theory, such as negligence or a dangerous condition of public property, requires a written claim to the public entity within six months or one year, followed by a waiting period before any lawsuit. And the California Supreme Court has made clear that a public sewer is not an insurer of every building connected to it.

The discussion that follows is general in scope: it describes checks useful in comparable situations and makes no findings about the City and County of San Francisco’s sewer and drainage system or its handling of this storm.

I. Can you hold San Francisco responsible for flood or sewer backup damage?

A. Inverse condemnation: when the public sewer system itself caused the damage

The constitutional starting point is article I, section 19, of the California Constitution. Its first sentence, which the Court of Appeal quoted in the Shehyn decision discussed below, provides that “Private property may be taken or damaged for a public use and only when just compensation, ascertained by a jury unless waived, has first been paid to, or into court for, the owner.” The words “or damaged” matter. California courts allow property owners to recover when a public improvement, such as a sewer main or a water delivery system, physically damages private property even though the government never set out to take anything. That lawsuit is called inverse condemnation, because the owner, rather than the government, starts the case. The same section’s own definition of a public work or improvement, written for a different purpose in subdivision (e), expressly includes flood protection as well as water and wastewater facilities and infrastructure, which gives a sense of how broadly the Constitution thinks about public infrastructure.

Inverse condemnation has two features that make it attractive after a flood. First, its test is not the ordinary negligence test: as the Oroville decision below explains, it turns on the inherent risks of the public improvement, although the Supreme Court also asked whether the public entity made reasonable assumptions about its system. Second, California’s claims statute treats it differently from ordinary damages claims. Government Code section 905.1 states: “No claim is required to be filed to maintain an action against a public entity for taking of, or damage to, private property pursuant to Section 19 of Article I of the California Constitution.” The same section adds that the public entity’s board must still process any such claim that is filed. The time limit for this kind of lawsuit is set by Code of Civil Procedure section 338, whose subdivision (j) lists, among the actions that must be brought within three years, “An action to recover for physical damage to private property under Section 19 of Article I of the California Constitution.” The statute sets the length of the period; it does not, in the text read for this article, say on what date the three years begin to run, so an owner should not assume that the clock starts late.

The harder question is what an owner must prove. The leading case on sewage backups is City of Oroville v. Superior Court, No. S243247 (Cal. Aug. 15, 2019), reported at 7 Cal.5th 1091. In December 2009, raw sewage from Oroville’s main backed up into a private sewer lateral and came out of the sinks, toilets and drains of a dental office after a partial blockage that the trial court found was most likely caused by roots. The lower courts held the City liable. The Supreme Court of California reversed, holding that “Public entities are not strictly or otherwise automatically liable for any conceivable damage bearing some kind of connection, however remote, to a public improvement.” To win, the Court explained, an owner must ordinarily show that the damage was substantially caused by inherent risks associated with the design, construction or maintenance of the public improvement. The decisive fact in Oroville was that the building had no backwater valve, a device that a 1984 city ordinance required on private laterals where fixtures sit lower than the next upstream manhole, and experts agreed a working valve could have averted the backup. The Court concluded that “the City did not act unreasonably in expecting private property owners to comply with the law.” The Court of Appeal applied the same test as recently as February 20, 2025, in the Shehyn decision discussed in the next paragraph, which quotes Oroville at length.

In Shehyn v. Ventura County Public Works Agency, No. B337452 (Cal. Ct. App. Feb. 20, 2025), the Court of Appeal of the State of California, Second Appellate District, reversed a judgment that had thrown out an avocado grower’s inverse condemnation claim against a county water district at the pleading stage. The grower alleged that the district’s water delivery system, working as designed, sent far more sediment to his orchard than to other customers and permanently damaged his irrigation pipes. Quoting Oroville, the court restated that a cause of action lies where damage to real property is “substantially caused by an inherent risk presented by the deliberate design, construction, or maintenance of [a] public improvement.” It refused to read an earlier decision “as limiting inverse condemnation to damages caused by flooding,” and it held that whether the owner caused or contributed to the problem “goes to the merits of the claim, not its viability at the pleading stage.” For a San Francisco owner, the application is direct: a complaint that ties the water in the basement to the way the public sewer or drainage system was built or maintained, and that explains why this property bore more of that risk than others, can survive an early motion to dismiss even if the City argues that the owner shares the blame. The owner’s own conduct still matters at trial, as Oroville shows.

Two practical consequences follow. The first is that the backwater valve question is not a technicality. San Francisco’s Public Utilities Commission tells owners that the upper sewer lateral is their responsibility; its sewer laterals guidance states that “The upper sewer lateral is an extension of your home, even if you can’t see it, which means you’re fully responsible for it,” and that owners must also maintain the lower lateral by clearing and inspecting it. That guidance is not a statute and does not decide liability, but it shows the kind of facts a public entity can be expected to raise if a backup came through a private lateral. An owner who wants to pursue inverse condemnation should find out early whether a backwater valve was installed, whether it worked, and what condition the lateral was in. The second consequence is that inverse condemnation in California is not limited to sewers. A separate English guide on this site explains how the same constitutional theory has been used when utility equipment starts a fire, which helps show why courts focus on the risks built into a public improvement rather than on the weather alone.

What inverse condemnation does not do is compensate every loss that happens near public infrastructure. Street flooding from rain that simply overwhelms every system in a neighborhood, water that entered because a private drain was blocked, or a backup that a required device would have stopped may all fall outside the theory as Oroville describes it. That is why most owners also look at the second route.

B. Negligence and dangerous-condition claims: what the Government Claims Act requires first

California’s Government Claims Act, which begins at Government Code section 810, governs most damages claims against cities, counties and districts. One of the main liability provisions for physical conditions is Government Code section 835. It makes a public entity liable for injury caused by a dangerous condition of its property if the plaintiff establishes that the property was in a dangerous condition at the time of the injury, that the condition proximately caused the injury, that it created a reasonably foreseeable risk of the kind of injury that occurred, and either that an employee’s negligent or wrongful act or omission created the condition or that the entity had actual or constructive notice of it in time to take protective measures. A clogged storm inlet that a public entity knew about for weeks, a damaged drain structure, or a sewer main with a recurring blockage could, depending on the evidence, be argued under this section. Whether any particular condition was “dangerous” within the meaning of the statute is a question decided on the evidence of each case.

The price of using these theories is procedural. Government Code section 905, in the words the McCurdy court quoted, requires presentation, under the Act’s claim chapters, of “all claims for money or damages against local public entities,” except listed categories such as tax refunds, wage claims of public employees, workers’ compensation and public assistance. Property damage from a flood is not among those exceptions, while section 905.1, quoted above, separately removes the claim requirement for an inverse condemnation action. The key enforcement rule is Government Code section 945.4. It provides that, except as provided in sections 946.4 and 946.6, no suit for money or damages may be brought against a public entity on a cause of action for which a claim is required until a written claim has been presented and the entity’s board has acted on it or is deemed to have rejected it. Harland, discussed next, summarizes the same rule together with the 45-day period of section 912.4. In plain terms, the claim comes first and the lawsuit comes second, and a court will dismiss a case that reverses the order.

The cost of moving too fast is illustrated by Harland v. City of West Hollywood, No. B343375 (Cal. Ct. App. June 2, 2026), decided by the Court of Appeal of the State of California, Second Appellate District, Division Eight. A pedestrian who fell on a West Hollywood sidewalk on October 8, 2022 mailed her claim on April 5, 2023, two days before the six-month deadline, and filed suit on April 7, 2023, before the City had even received the claim. After she dismissed that case and refiled, the trial court dismissed the second lawsuit with prejudice, and the Court of Appeal affirmed. The court explained that “Suing a public entity before presenting it with a claim defeats this function,” that “It is immaterial the City later denied Harland’s claim,” and that claimants must comply “even if the entity had actual knowledge of the circumstances surrounding the claim.” Applied to flood damage in San Francisco, the lesson is to wait for the written denial or the end of the 45-day period before filing any lawsuit on a claim that requires presentation, and not to treat a 311 report or a conversation with a City crew as a substitute for the claim form.

Because inverse condemnation is exempt from the claim requirement and the tort theories are not, an owner who is unsure which theory fits should not choose between them by default. Filing a timely claim keeps the negligence and dangerous-condition routes open, and section 905.1 itself contemplates that the board will process a claim even when the constitutional theory does not require one. Tenants and businesses face a further point: section 905.1 and section 338(j) speak of private property, while the personal-property categories of the claims statute described below expressly cover belongings such as furniture, equipment, inventory or a car parked in a flooded street. For those losses, the claim deadline is the one to watch.

II. What must you do, and by when, after the water recedes?

A. Filing the claim: the six-month and one-year deadlines, the content and the 45-day wait

The basic deadlines are in Government Code section 911.2. Subdivision (a) provides that “A claim relating to a cause of action for death or for injury to person or to personal property or growing crops shall be presented as provided in Article 2 (commencing with Section 915) not later than six months after the accrual of the cause of action.” A claim relating to any other cause of action must be presented not later than one year after accrual. San Francisco’s official claim page, read for this article on November 18, 2026, applies that division in practical terms: claims for personal injury, personal property damage, death or loss, or damage to crops within six months of the incident, and all other claims, including claims for damage to real property, within one year of the incident. A homeowner whose walls and floors were damaged therefore looks at the one-year period for that part of the loss, while the same homeowner’s damaged sofa, appliances or car fall under the six-month period. Tenants, whose losses are usually personal property, should assume the six-month period applies to them.

When does the clock start? The claims statute ties accrual to the general law of limitations. In McCurdy, discussed below, the Court of Appeal quoted the Supreme Court’s explanation that accrual for purposes of the claims statute “is the date of accrual that would pertain under the statute of limitations applicable to a dispute between private litigants.” The statutes and decisions read for this article do not fix a special accrual date for flood damage, and San Francisco’s own page measures both periods from “the incident.” The prudent course is to treat the day the water came in as the starting point and to file well before six months have passed from that day.

The contents of the claim are set by Government Code section 910. The claim must show the claimant’s name and post office address, the address for notices, the date, place and other circumstances of the occurrence that gave rise to the claim, a general description of the injury, damage or loss as far as it is known, the names of the public employees who caused it if known, and the amount claimed if it is less than $10,000. If the amount exceeds $10,000, no dollar figure is included, but the claim must say whether it would be a limited civil case. For a flood, those circumstances should include the exact address, the time the water entered, the path it took (street, storm inlet, sewer cleanout, floor drain, toilet), what the claimant saw in the street or public sewer, and any service request number. A vague claim can create problems later, because courts compare the facts in the lawsuit with the facts in the claim.

San Francisco’s claim page describes the mechanics. It offers a claim form for injury, property damage or loss, and it states that the original completed form must be mailed or hand-delivered to the Controller’s Office Claims Division at 1390 Market Street, 7th Floor, San Francisco, California 94102, and that emailed or faxed claim forms are not accepted. Claims against other public entities, for example the State of California, follow their own presentation rules; section 911.2(b) explains, for claims presented to the state Department of General Services, that the presentation date is generally the date the claim is submitted with a twenty-five dollar filing fee or a fee-waiver affidavit. The claimant bears the burden of sending the claim to the right entity, as Harland repeats, so the first task after a flood is to identify who owns the street, inlet, pipe or channel involved.

Once a claim is presented, Government Code section 912.4 gives the board 45 days to act, a period the claimant and the board may extend by written agreement. If the board fails or refuses to act within that time, the claim is deemed rejected on the last day of the period in which the board had to act; Harland describes the same alternative, an outright denial or a failure to act within 45 days. San Francisco’s page likewise tells claimants to allow up to 45 days and lists the possible responses: a notice that the claim is late, a request for more information, a postponement, a formal denial or a settlement offer.

The next clock is the deadline to sue, set by Government Code section 945.6. If the entity gives written notice of rejection in accordance with section 913, suit must be filed “not later than six months after the date such notice is personally delivered or deposited in the mail.” If no written notice is given, the suit must be filed within two years from accrual. San Francisco’s page is consistent with this framework: it says a denial letter will state the deadline to sue, and that if a timely claim is not denied, the claimant has two years from the date of the incident to settle or file suit. A written denial is therefore not the end of the matter, but it starts a short and unforgiving period; the date it was mailed should be calendared the day it arrives.

B. Late claims, evidence and the backwater valve question

Missing the six-month deadline is not always fatal, but the escape route is narrow. Under Government Code section 911.4, a person who missed a six-month claim may make a written application to the public entity for leave to present it. The application must be presented, in the statutory words that McCurdy quotes, “within a reasonable time not to exceed one year after the accrual of the cause of action,” must state the reason for the delay, and must attach the proposed claim. If the entity denies the application, Government Code section 946.6 allows a petition to the superior court for relief from the claim requirement. Subdivision (b) requires the petition to be filed within six months after the application to the board is denied or deemed denied. Under subdivision (c), the court must grant relief if, among other conditions, the failure to present the claim was through mistake, inadvertence, surprise or excusable neglect, unless the public entity shows it would be prejudiced, or if the claimant was a minor or physically or mentally incapacitated during the relevant period, as the statute details.

McCurdy v. County of Riverside, No. D083420 (Cal. Ct. App. Nov. 21, 2024), shows how strictly courts police those windows. The California Court of Appeal, Fourth Appellate District, Division One, affirmed the denial of a petition for relief brought by a man whose claim against Riverside County was presented about 11 months after the date on which he argued his claim had accrued. The court held that his claim sounded in personal injury and fell under the six-month period of section 911.2 rather than the one-year period, and it found no abuse of discretion in refusing relief because the showing of excusable neglect was thin; it quoted the rule that “the preference for a trial on the merits does not warrant relief if based on a perfunctory recital of diligence in support of excusable neglect.” Even though three lawyers had allegedly told him the one-year period applied, the court observed: “At a minimum, the attorneys should have been aware that the six-month period might apply and therefore should have presented a protective claim within that period.” For a flooded household or business in San Francisco, the application is simple: when it is unclear whether a loss falls in the six-month or the one-year category, present a protective claim within six months, measured from the date of the flooding as the City’s own claim page does.

Evidence decides most of these cases, and it disappears quickly. Useful records include dated photographs and video of the water outside and inside, showing the street, the nearest storm inlet or manhole, and the point where water entered; the 311 service request number and any response; plumber’s invoices and reports, including any camera inspection of the lateral; proof of whether a backwater valve existed and whether it worked; receipts, inventory lists and repair estimates; and names of neighbors who were flooded the same day. That last item can matter under Shehyn, where the grower’s theory was that his property received a disproportionate share of the burden of a public system. A list of affected and unaffected properties on the same block, with their elevations relative to the street, can help show whether water came from an inherent risk of the public system or from a private failure.

The backwater valve issue deserves particular attention because it decided Oroville. An owner whose fixtures sit below the street and who has no working valve should expect the public entity to argue, as the City of Oroville did, that the device would have prevented the loss. That argument goes to inverse condemnation and may also be raised against negligence theories. The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission offers a Floodwater Grant that, in its own words, “is for San Francisco property owners who experience flooding from the public right-of way or backflow events from the sewer system during heavy rains.” The program’s page explains that an interest form serves as written documentation of the flood event and that a site visit follows. A grant application is not a claim under the Government Claims Act and does not stop any deadline, but the documentation it requires overlaps with what a claim needs, and installing protection after a first event can reduce the risk that a later loss is attributed to the owner.

Insurance runs alongside these steps rather than replacing them. In Oroville, the dentists first filed claims with their insurer and then sued the City of Oroville for losses they said were not covered, and their insurer joined the case. Coverage depends on the policy wording, which may treat surface water, flood and sewer backup differently, and a separate English guide on this site discusses how California homeowners insurance treats coastal flooding and what to compare when a written coverage decision arrives. An insurance claim does not satisfy the Government Claims Act, and an insurer that pays may itself pursue the public entity, so the owner should tell the insurer about any claim filed against a public entity and keep copies of everything sent and received.

Finally, the facts that support a claim should be checked against the law before money is spent on repairs that destroy evidence. Photographs of a damaged lateral taken before replacement, the removed section of pipe, and a plumber’s written explanation of what caused the blockage can be decisive. If the owner suspects the public main rather than the private lateral, a request that the utility inspect the connection, made through official channels and documented, creates a record that helps whichever legal route is chosen.

Conclusion

Flood damage in a California city can lead to compensation from the government, but only if the owner or tenant chooses the right route and respects its clock. Inverse condemnation requires no prior claim and has a three-year limitation period, yet it succeeds only when the damage was substantially caused by an inherent risk of the public system as designed, built or maintained, and the absence of a required backwater valve can defeat it. Negligence and dangerous-condition claims require a written claim within six months for personal property and personal injury, or one year for other losses such as damage to real property, followed by a 45-day wait before suit and a six-month window after a written denial. Courts enforce those steps strictly, even when the public entity already knew about the problem. The safest sequence is to document the water’s path immediately, identify the public entity that owns the infrastructure involved, present a complete claim well inside six months, coordinate with any insurer, and wait for a written decision or the 45-day deadline before going to court.

📄 Official circular