KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Most Wanted List: Is It a Crime in Canada to Help, Hide or Shelter a Wanted Fugitive?

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Most Wanted List: Is It a Crime in Canada to Help, Hide or Shelter a Wanted Fugitive?

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

By Hassan Kohen, lawyer at the Paris Bar.

“Most wanted list” is being searched in Canada. This article describes no person named on any list and no investigation. It answers the legal questions that a published wanted list raises for ordinary members of the public in Canada: is it an offence to give a wanted person a bed, money or a lift; what is the risk for a relative or friend who keeps quiet or lies about where that person is; what happens to someone who sends the police a false tip; and may a member of the public arrest a person recognised from a wanted notice? The answers come from the federal Criminal Code, which applies throughout Canada. Provincial rules and police policies on wanted notices, rewards and anonymous tips are not analysed.

The method set out here is of general scope. In any real situation, several facts remain to be established: what the person helping actually knew, what was done and when, for what purpose, whether the wanted person was in fact a party to an offence, and what the police asked or said. This is information on Canadian criminal law, written by a lawyer who practises in France and not in Canada. The texts discussed are the consolidated versions published on the official Justice Laws Website of the Government of Canada, as consulted on 19 November 2026; amendments that were not in force on that date are not analysed.

I. Helping a wanted person: the offences that can apply

A. The accessory after the fact

Police services publish wanted lists because they want information from the public. The same lists create a legal risk for people close to the person sought. The central provision is the offence of being an accessory after the fact, defined in section 23 of the Criminal Code.

The definition in section 23(1) reads: “An accessory after the fact to an offence is one who, knowing that a person has been a party to the offence, receives, comforts or assists that person for the purpose of enabling that person to escape.”

The definition contains three elements, and all three must be proved. The first is knowledge: the helper must know that the person has been a party to an offence. Suspicion, rumour or a vague feeling that something is wrong is not the same thing as knowledge, although a court assesses knowledge from all the circumstances, including what the helper was told, what he or she saw, and whether a wanted notice had been widely published. The second element is an act: receiving, comforting or assisting the person. In everyday terms, this can cover giving a place to stay, food, money, a vehicle, a telephone, clothing or a change of appearance. The third element is purpose: the act must be done for the purpose of enabling the person to escape. Help given for a different purpose, for instance driving the person to a police station to surrender, does not match the wording of the offence.

Timing also matters. The accessory offence concerns help given after the offence, to a person who “has been” a party to it. Help given before or during the commission of an offence is governed by different rules on parties to an offence, found in section 21 of the Code, which this article does not analyse. A wanted notice, for its part, records that the police are looking for someone in connection with an offence; it does not establish that the person committed it. Whether a helper knew that the person had been a party to the offence is a question of evidence in each case, and the published notice is only one element of that evidence.

This structure explains a point that worries many families. Section 23(1) punishes acts of assistance done for a particular purpose. Knowing where a wanted person is, without doing any of the acts listed and without that purpose, is not, as the provision is worded, an act of receiving, comforting or assisting. The position changes as soon as the knowledge is combined with help: a mother or father who learns that an adult son is wanted and then lets him stay so that the police will not find him moves into the territory of section 23.

Families sometimes assume that the law makes an exception for close relatives. The current text of section 23 contains no such exception. Its subsection (2) appears in the consolidated Code as repealed in 2000, and nothing in the remaining text distinguishes between a stranger, a friend, a partner or a relative. The relationship may be relevant to what the person knew or intended, and to the sentence, but it is not a defence written into the section.

A further provision closes a possible gap. Under section 23.1, sections 21 to 23 apply to an accused even if the person who was assisted cannot be convicted of the offence. A helper cannot therefore escape liability merely because the person sought is never tried, is acquitted on a technical point or cannot be prosecuted for another reason, provided the elements of section 23 are proved against the helper.

The penalty depends on the offence committed by the person who was helped. Section 463 sets the general rules. An accessory after the fact to an indictable offence punishable by imprisonment for life is liable to imprisonment for a term not exceeding fourteen years. An accessory after the fact to an indictable offence punishable by fourteen years or less is liable to one-half of the longest term to which a person guilty of that offence is liable. An accessory after the fact to an offence punishable on summary conviction is guilty of an offence punishable on summary conviction. Where the original offence can be prosecuted either by indictment or summarily, the accessory is liable on indictment to a term not exceeding one-half of the longest term for that offence, or may be prosecuted summarily.

Section 463 itself states that these rules apply “except where otherwise expressly provided by law”. The most important exception concerns murder. Under section 240, every one who is an accessory after the fact to murder is guilty of an indictable offence and liable to imprisonment for life. Wanted lists often include people sought for the most serious offences. For someone who shelters such a person, the potential consequence is therefore not a fraction of a sentence but the same maximum as the offence itself.

A concrete calculation shows how the rules interact. Escaping from lawful custody, discussed below, is punishable on indictment by up to two years. Under section 463, a person who knowingly helps an escaped prisoner to remain out of reach, for the purpose of enabling that escape, faces on indictment up to one-half of that term, that is, one year, or a summary prosecution. For a person sought for an offence carrying ten years on indictment, the corresponding figure for an accessory prosecuted on indictment is five years.

B. Obstruction, false information and public mischief

The accessory offence is not the only one. People who never give a wanted person shelter can still commit an offence by the way they deal with the police.

The first relevant provision is section 129. Under paragraph (a), every one who resists or wilfully obstructs a public officer or peace officer in the execution of his duty, or any person lawfully acting in aid of such an officer, commits an offence. Under paragraph (b), every one who omits, without reasonable excuse, to assist a public officer or peace officer in the execution of his duty in arresting a person or in preserving the peace, after having reasonable notice that he is required to do so, also commits an offence. The maximum on indictment is two years. Paragraph (b) is narrow: it applies only after a member of the public has received reasonable notice that an officer requires assistance in an arrest or in preserving the peace. It does not, as worded, oblige anyone to come forward on their own initiative.

The second provision is broader and more serious. Section 139 creates the offence of obstructing justice.

Under section 139(2), the offence is committed by every person who “intentionally attempts in any manner other than a manner described in subsection (1) to obstruct, pervert or defeat the course of justice”.

The words “in any manner” give the provision a wide reach, and the maximum penalty on indictment is imprisonment for a term of not more than ten years. Depending on the facts, conduct such as giving the police a false account of where a wanted person is, warning that person so that he or she can leave before officers arrive, or destroying items that would help locate the person, may be examined under this provision. The required mental element is intention: the person must intentionally attempt to obstruct, pervert or defeat the course of justice.

The third provision targets false information. Under section 140, every one commits public mischief who, with intent to mislead, causes a peace officer to enter on or continue an investigation by making a false statement that accuses some other person of having committed an offence, by doing anything intended to cause some other person to be suspected of an offence that the other person has not committed or to divert suspicion from himself, or by reporting that an offence has been committed when it has not been committed. The maximum on indictment is five years. Wanted lists generate many tips. A tip given in good faith that turns out to be wrong does not match the wording of section 140, which requires an intent to mislead. A deliberately false tip, for example one designed to send officers after a rival who is falsely said to be the wanted person, or to draw attention away from the real location, does.

These provisions share a common feature. They punish acts of obstruction or deception, not silence as such. None of the provisions reviewed for this article makes it an offence simply to know where a wanted person is, and section 129(b) only applies after a specific request from an officer. That does not make silence risk-free in every situation, since silence is often combined with other conduct, but it explains why the line between keeping quiet and lying matters so much.

II. What members of the public may and may not do

A. Citizen’s arrest and the use of force

A wanted notice can tempt a member of the public to act directly. The Criminal Code gives private persons a limited power of arrest, and the limits are strict. They appear in section 494, which allows any one to arrest without warrant a person whom he finds committing an indictable offence, or a person who, on reasonable grounds, he believes has committed a criminal offence and is escaping from and freshly pursued by persons who have lawful authority to arrest that person.

The second limb is the one that most often matters when a person recognises someone from a wanted list. It requires that the person “is escaping from and freshly pursued by persons who have lawful authority to arrest that person”, as section 494(1)(b) puts it.

Read together, the two limbs leave little room for a citizen’s arrest based only on a wanted notice. A person recognised in a shop or on a train from a photograph published weeks earlier is not, on that fact alone, found committing an indictable offence. Nor is he or she, on that fact alone, escaping from and freshly pursued by persons with lawful authority to arrest. The power in section 494(1) is designed for situations unfolding in front of the person making the arrest, or for a pursuit already under way by the police or others with authority to arrest. Section 494(2) adds a separate power for owners and persons in lawful possession of property, which concerns offences committed on or in relation to that property and is not a general power to arrest wanted persons.

Even where an arrest is lawful, the person who makes it has an immediate obligation.

Section 494(3) provides: “Any one other than a peace officer who arrests a person without warrant shall forthwith deliver the person to a peace officer.”

The use of force is governed by section 25. A private person who is authorised by law to do something in the administration or enforcement of the law is, if acting on reasonable grounds, justified in doing what he or she is authorised to do and in using as much force as is necessary for that purpose. Section 494(4) confirms that a person authorised to make an arrest under section 494 is a person authorised by law for the purposes of section 25. The protection is therefore conditional: it exists only where the arrest itself is authorised and only for force that is necessary. Section 25(3) adds that force intended or likely to cause death or grievous bodily harm is not justified unless the person believes on reasonable grounds that it is necessary for self-preservation or the preservation of anyone under his or her protection from death or grievous bodily harm. The wider protection in section 25(4) is reserved to peace officers and persons lawfully assisting them.

The consequence of getting it wrong is serious. Force applied to another person without consent is an assault within the meaning of section 265, and assault is an offence under section 266, punishable on indictment by up to five years. A person who seizes someone recognised from a wanted list, outside the conditions of section 494, may find that he or she is the one who has committed an offence, and the risk is aggravated if the person recognised turns out not to be the person sought. For these reasons, the course that the texts reviewed here make safest for a member of the public is to note the time, place and description, keep a safe distance and inform the police, rather than intervening.

The information that is most useful to officers is usually factual and precise: the exact time and place of the sighting, the direction of travel, the vehicle and its registration if one was used, clothing and any distinctive features, and whether the person appeared to be alone. A member of the public who passes on such information in good faith, even if it later proves to concern someone else, is not within the wording of section 140, which requires an intent to mislead. What the texts discourage is not reporting but improvisation: following the person, confronting him or her, or posting the sighting publicly in a way that may warn the person or expose others to danger.

B. Persons at large, failures to appear and the position of relatives

Wanted lists do not only concern people sought for a fresh offence. Many people are wanted because they escaped, did not return to custody, or failed to comply with a release order or to attend court. The Criminal Code treats those situations as offences in their own right.

Under section 145(1), every person who escapes from lawful custody, or who is at large in or outside Canada without lawful excuse before the expiration of a term of imprisonment to which he or she was sentenced, is guilty of an offence punishable on indictment by up to two years, or on summary conviction. Section 145(2) to (5) create further offences for a person who is at large on a release order and fails, without lawful excuse, to attend court, who fails to surrender in accordance with an order, who fails to appear as required by an appearance notice or summons, or who fails, without lawful excuse, to comply with a condition of an undertaking or release order.

Two consequences follow for relatives and friends. First, a person who is wanted for having failed to attend court, or for being at large, is wanted for an offence, so that the accessory rules in sections 23 and 463 can apply to someone who knowingly helps that person avoid being found. Second, the penalties attached to these offences are lower than those for the most serious crimes, so that the accessory exposure calculated under section 463 is also lower. That does not make assistance lawful; it changes the scale of the risk.

For a relative or friend who learns that someone close to them appears on a wanted list, the texts reviewed here point to a few practical distinctions. Encouraging the person to surrender, or accompanying him or her to the police, is not assistance for the purpose of enabling an escape. Providing shelter, money, transport, a phone or false information so that the person can stay out of reach can be. Lying to officers about the person’s whereabouts, or warning the person before an arrest, may be examined as obstruction under section 129 or section 139(2). Sending a deliberately false tip about someone else is public mischief under section 140. Where a person is unsure whether what he or she has already done crosses one of these lines, the safest step is to stop any further assistance and to obtain advice from a criminal lawyer qualified in the province concerned before speaking to the police.

Rewards, anonymous tip lines and the publication of wanted notices themselves are governed by police policies and programme rules rather than by the Criminal Code provisions discussed here, and they are not analysed. The same is true of the rules that apply when a wanted person is located outside Canada, which raise questions of international cooperation beyond the scope of this article.

Evidence in these cases turns largely on knowledge and purpose. Messages, call records, bank transfers, travel bookings and the content of any contact with the police will be examined to establish what the helper knew and why he or she acted. A person who wishes to show that help was given for a lawful purpose, for instance to arrange a surrender, is in a stronger position if that purpose can be shown from contemporaneous messages or from the involvement of a lawyer. Conversely, deleting messages or disposing of items after learning of a police search may itself be examined under the obstruction provisions.

This analysis concerns Canadian federal criminal law. The author’s English-language criminal law practice in Paris operates under French law, in a different jurisdiction. A situation arising in Canada has to be assessed under the texts that govern it, on the basis of the actual facts, dates and communications described above.

Conclusion

In Canada, helping a person who appears on a wanted list can be a criminal offence, but only when the conditions written into the Criminal Code are met. Under section 23, an accessory after the fact is one who, knowing that a person has been a party to an offence, receives, comforts or assists that person for the purpose of enabling an escape; the current text contains no exception for relatives, and section 23.1 applies the rule even if the person helped cannot be convicted. Penalties follow section 463, generally up to one-half of the maximum for the original offence, or fourteen years where that offence carries life, while section 240 provides life imprisonment for an accessory after the fact to murder. Obstructing an officer under section 129, obstructing justice under section 139(2), with up to ten years on indictment, and public mischief under section 140, for deliberately false reports, complete the picture.

Members of the public who recognise someone from a wanted notice have only a narrow power of arrest under section 494, which requires either finding the person committing an indictable offence or a fresh pursuit by persons with lawful authority, followed by immediate delivery to a peace officer; force is justified under section 25 only where the arrest is authorised and only as far as necessary. Escaping custody and failing to attend court are offences under section 145, which also matters for anyone helping a person sought for those reasons. In any particular case, the facts remain to be established: what the person helping knew, what was done, when and for what purpose. Until those facts are known, no conclusion can be drawn about criminal liability in an individual situation.

📄 Official circular