KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Resort Downgrade Before Departure: How to Claim a Price Reduction on a Package Holiday

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Resort Downgrade Before Departure: How to Claim a Price Reduction on a Package Holiday

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

People in the United Kingdom are searching for “resort”. One question worth asking before a package holiday starts is what happens if the organiser moves you to a different property. A replacement can have the same star rating and still give you materially less than you booked. It might be farther from the beach, offer breakfast in place of half board, or lack a room feature that the organiser agreed you needed. Whether you can end the contract without a fee or travel at a reduced price depends on what was promised, what the organiser is changing and how you respond.

This article gives general information about the law applicable to package holiday disputes in England and Wales as at 20 November 2026. It focuses on changes proposed before the package starts, including how to estimate a reduction when you want to keep the trip. It also explains what to record if you arrive and the replacement fails to match the amended booking. The examples are hypothetical. The same booking notice can raise separate questions about the right to refuse, the value of the replacement and any expenses you later incur. Keeping those questions separate makes it easier to state what you want and explain the figure you are asking for.

I. Establish what your package organiser agreed to provide

A. Identify a package and recover the original booking terms

The Package Travel and Linked Travel Arrangements Regulations 2018 identify a package by how different types of travel service for the same trip are combined or sold. The Regulations generally took effect on 1 July 2018. Regulation 2 covers, among other cases, accommodation and passenger transport chosen at one point of sale before you agree to pay, or offered together at an inclusive price. You may have a package even if different companies perform the services or there are separate contracts. The sequence of the booking, including when you selected each service and when you agreed to pay, can matter more than the brand on the accommodation voucher.

Start with the confirmation, the booking invoice and the payment record. Look for statements identifying the organiser and the services covered by the package. A flight and a hotel that you sourced and paid for independently will generally need to be considered under their separate contracts. Some transactions involving separate selection and payment may instead be linked travel arrangements under regulation 2. Even a hotel and an activity purchased together need closer examination. The statutory definition has limits where the other tourist service is of modest value and is neither advertised as nor otherwise an essential feature, or is selected and bought only after the main travel service has started. A hotel room with breakfast does not become a package simply because the booking page describes the rates as a deal.

The distinction determines where to start. A covered traveller can rely on the package rules examined here. Someone who booked only a room may need to look at the terms of that booking and the Consumer Rights Act 2015. Section 50 can make statements about a service binding where the consumer took them into account when deciding to book or when making a later decision about the service, subject to qualifications and expressly agreed changes. For a fixed-date room, regulation 28(1)(h) of the Consumer Contracts (Information, Cancellation and Additional Charges) Regulations 2013 excludes the ordinary cancellation right for distance and off-premises contracts for accommodation. Regulation 6(1)(g) separately excludes package travel contracts from those Regulations. An online booking on its own supplies no general 14-day cooling-off right in either example.

Next, reconstruct the holiday as sold. Regulations 5 and 6 of the package rules and Schedule 1 make specified pre-contract information part of the package agreement when provided. For accommodation, the relevant information includes its location, main features and, where applicable, its tourist category at the destination. The destination, dates, nights and included meals are also relevant. Regulation 7 requires the contract to set out the full content of the package and generally requires confirmation on a durable medium when the contract is concluded or without undue delay afterwards. Under regulation 8, in a civil dispute about compliance with the information duties in that part of the Regulations, the relevant organiser or retailer has to show compliance.

Collect the version of the description you received before you paid. Booking sites can change later. A confirmation email, attachment, screenshot or exchange of messages can show that a detail appeared in the offer for your booking, on your dates and for your room type. Keep the surrounding words. A photograph of a sea view may illustrate only some rooms, while a room category described as having a sea view is much clearer. The timetable for the included transfer and the terms on meals can establish promises that the headline hotel description leaves out. Keep a dated copy of any subsequent offer next to the original so the differences are visible.

Special requirements deserve a separate line in that record. Schedule 5 paragraph 1 covers special requirements that the organiser has accepted, and regulation 7 requires that information in the contract. A traveller who asks for a roll-in shower should look for confirmation that the organiser agreed to provide one, as distinct from a message saying the request was passed on to the hotel. Schedule 1 paragraph 10 addresses information about suitability for travellers with reduced mobility, including precise suitability information on request. A dispute about a particular feature can turn on who answered, what they actually confirmed and whether that confirmation applied to the room reserved. A self-contained email exchange can therefore be more useful than a folder of general accessibility descriptions.

B. Test the replacement against the contractual promise

Regulation 11 draws three distinctions. An organiser can unilaterally make an insignificant non-price change only where the contract permits it and the organiser gives clear, comprehensible and prominent notice on a durable medium. A notice in an email the traveller can retain may satisfy the medium requirement. The presentation and content still matter. Where circumstances beyond the organiser’s control constrain it to alter a main characteristic significantly, regulations 11(4) to (11) apply. They also apply if the organiser cannot fulfil a special requirement covered by Schedule 5 paragraph 1, or proposes a qualifying price rise over 8% under regulation 10. This article focuses on accommodation rather than price rises on an otherwise intact booking.

Put the original and replacement promises side by side. Compare the precise location, room type, nights, sleeping arrangements, meal plan, transport and any included services you can no longer use. Check whether the organiser made the offer for the same travellers and dates. If you need a specific room feature, ask whether it is confirmed for that room and for the entire stay. A general assurance that a property is accessible may leave unanswered whether the route to the room is step free, whether a particular doorway is wide enough, or whether the alternative room has the shower arrangement already agreed.

Location works the same way. Replacing one property with a neighbouring property of similar quality, with the promised facilities and meal plan intact, may produce an insignificant change if the other statutory conditions are met. Moving a traveller from a property within walking distance of the beach to an inland hotel may affect a main characteristic, even within the same resort area. The evidence is stronger if the original confirmation specified the location, the move affects ordinary access throughout the stay and the replacement arrangements fail to provide an equivalent. A replacement shuttle with limited hours can change how much of the day the traveller can use. An equivalent service with frequent departures can reduce the practical effect. Compare the actual arrangements on offer.

Differences can matter together. A longer transfer might have little effect by itself. Add the loss of dinner, a different room category and the need to pay for a regular ride, and the proposal may be materially different as a whole. Conversely, a reduction in one feature may come with a genuine improvement somewhere else. Explain the loss and any offset in concrete terms. There is no numerical threshold in regulation 11 for how far away another hotel must be, how many facilities must change, or how many stars must be lost. The 8% figure concerns a qualifying increase in the package price under regulation 10.

Failure to provide an accepted special requirement has its own trigger. For example, if the organiser agreed to a room with a roll-in shower and then says the replacement has only a bath, the issue can fall under regulation 11(3)(b) regardless of whether the alternative hotel is cheaper or otherwise rated lower. If a feature was only requested, preserve the evidence about what you were told and consider whether removal of the feature also changes a main characteristic. A complaint based solely on a personal preference expressed after booking will be harder to establish than a complaint tied to the agreed package.

Ask why a significant change is needed. Regulation 11(3)(a) refers to circumstances beyond the organiser’s control. The fact that a different room is available at a better rate to the organiser does not, by itself, give it the statutory power to rewrite the agreement. If the organiser says a term allows any substitution it chooses, compare that wording with regulation 11(2). Ask whether the original package can still be provided and how the organiser says its proposal is authorised. Record the reason given and the time you received it, even if you are willing to take an acceptable replacement. A dispute about an unauthorised change may require a contract analysis distinct from the statutory notice procedure.

II. Choose a remedy and document its value

A. Respond within the stated period and separate a refund from a reduction

For a proposal within regulation 11(3), the organiser must give notice without undue delay, on a durable medium and in a clear, comprehensible and prominent way. Under regulation 11(4), the notice must explain the proposed change and, where appropriate, its effect on the price. It must state a reasonable period for your decision, the consequences of missing it, and details and price of any substitute offered. The statute envisages an equivalent or higher quality substitute if possible. It does not promise that the organiser can find an equivalent room on the same dates. Check whether the response deadline gives you enough time to obtain information about any facility on which your ability to travel depends.

Under regulation 11(5), the traveller can accept the proposed change or terminate the contract without paying a termination fee within the reasonable period specified. Someone who terminates may take a substitute package if one is offered under regulation 11(6). Either a change accepted under the original package or a substitute can give rise to an appropriate price reduction under regulation 11(7) if the result is a package of lower quality or cost. If you choose to travel, put in writing whether you are accepting a change to the existing booking or taking a substitute, and separately record that you are asking for a reduction and why. Ask the organiser to confirm the revised terms and the revised price before you agree to any wording that purports to settle the price dispute.

If you terminate under regulation 11(5)(b) and do not take a substitute, regulation 11(8) requires repayment of all payments for the package made by you or on your behalf, without undue delay and within 14 days after termination. Confirm the date of termination in writing and keep proof of delivery. You may decline a substitute that does not work for you. A refund of the payments for the package and a claim for additional financial loss are different issues. Regulation 11(9) applies parts of regulation 16 where regulation 11(8) applies. Any separate claim needs its own legal and factual basis, including evidence of loss and causation, and may face the defences in regulation 16. The refund rule alone does not establish that the organiser must pay for replacement travel you buy elsewhere.

Reply before the deadline even if you only have part of the information you need. Ask for any necessary extension and keep any agreement to it. Under regulation 11(10) the organiser must repeat the prescribed notification if you fail to make a choice within the specified period. Continued silence after the second notice can allow the organiser to terminate, with a refund under regulation 11(11). Silence is therefore a poor way to preserve a holiday you still want. Retain both notices and record any deadline change. If you are replying through a booking account, save a copy including the timestamp and keep any acknowledgement.

The wording of the reply matters when the organiser’s booking account uses a generic cancellation button. If you are terminating because of a qualifying change, identify the organiser’s notice, the proposed change and the reason you are invoking regulation 11(5)(b). Keep that response distinct from a change-of-mind cancellation under regulation 12, which may carry an appropriate and justifiable fee. A traveller who changes their mind can ask for the organiser’s justification for the amount under regulation 12(6). Where the organiser insists that the move is insignificant, set out the reasons you disagree and keep copies of its position. A label in a booking system does not resolve the underlying legal question. For context on the author’s practice in France, see the firm’s English-language overview of its Paris legal practice.

B. Price the lost features and preserve any separate claim after arrival

Start a price-reduction calculation by identifying which part of the package changed. Record the total paid, any reliable breakdown between services, the affected dates, and any adjustment the organiser has already offered. If outward and return flights stay the same, a quote for a completely different holiday may say little about the loss in accommodation value. Seek contemporaneous prices for comparable accommodation on the same dates, for the same number of travellers, with similar cancellation and meal terms. Save the quotes with the date and the details visible. If dates or inclusions differ, explain how that affects the comparison before relying on a number.

Consider a hypothetical seven-night package. Assume that two comparable dated quotes value the booked half-board accommodation at £840 and the replacement room with breakfast at £630, with travel unchanged. The £210 difference gives a possible starting point for explaining a reduction. If the organiser offers £90, you can ask it to explain the remaining £120 difference using its comparison. The figures are evidence to discuss, not a statutory formula. If the £210 already reflects the difference between half board and breakfast, adding the full estimated cost of dinner for the same nights risks counting the missing meals twice. If the quotes are for the same meal terms and differ only in room quality, the lost meal plan may need to be valued separately.

The available price evidence is often imperfect. Some rooms are exclusive to package organisers and have no directly comparable public price. Prices may have risen since booking, or the original hotel may now show no vacancies. A difference between last year’s advance booking rate and a current last-minute rate may mostly reflect timing. In those cases, use several comparisons and say how they differ. Ask the organiser to explain how its offer accounts for both cost and quality. Evidence of a downgrade can also come from features that have no separate advertised price, such as step-free access to the dining room or a location close to an included activity. Describing what was lost and who could use it helps establish why a nominal reduction may be inadequate. If the replacement cannot meet a basic accepted requirement, a discount may leave the central problem unresolved.

Distinguish the price reduction for the package as changed before departure from a claim that the replacement failed to deliver what you accepted. For example, if the agreed amended booking explicitly provides breakfast only, it would be difficult to treat the missing dinners on arrival as a fresh failure to deliver the amended terms. The lower meal plan belongs in your pre-departure valuation. If the organiser confirms step-free access for the replacement but the only usable entrance has steps, that is a separate performance question. Keep the amended confirmation, photos documenting the actual route, messages to the organiser and a record of when a suitable solution became available.

Regulation 15 makes the organiser responsible for performance of package services, including services delivered by another provider. Tell the organiser without undue delay when you discover a shortfall during the holiday. Unless remedy is impossible or entails disproportionate costs, the organiser must put it right within a reasonable period that you set. If it refuses or the situation requires an immediate solution, regulation 15(6) can allow you to remedy the problem yourself and recover necessary expenses. That is a narrower basis than reimbursement of any replacement you choose. Preserve evidence of urgency, options and prices, and keep receipts. Under regulation 17 you can also send performance-related messages or complaints to the retailer through which you bought the package. For time limits, receipt by that retailer counts as receipt by the organiser for messages covered by that regulation.

Regulation 16 distinguishes an appropriate reduction for the period of non-conformity from compensation for damage caused by it. The organiser can resist the price reduction if it proves the non-conformity was attributable to the traveller. The compensation provision has additional defences, including unavoidable and extraordinary circumstances proved by the organiser. If the promised room became available after two nights, record the two affected nights and any expense that remained after the move. Keep separate totals for a pre-travel downgrade, a failure during the stay and out-of-pocket costs. Explain overlaps and deduct anything already paid for the same loss. This makes the claim easier to assess and avoids asking twice for the same shortfall.

For an unresolved dispute in England and Wales, send the organiser a short chronology and itemised request with the contract, both offers, your response and any records from the trip. For a straightforward claim founded on a simple contract, section 5 of the Limitation Act 1980 generally sets a six-year period from accrual of the cause of action. That is a limit on bringing that kind of claim, distinct from the short period in a change notice and from the duty to report problems during the trip without undue delay. Other types of claim can have different limits. Keep the record while it is still easy to show which promise, notice and payment each part of the dispute concerns.

Conclusion

For a package holiday governed by the law discussed here, compare the replacement with the terms and features the organiser actually agreed. A qualifying change before the package begins can give you a choice between accepting the change and ending the contract without a fee. If you terminate on that basis and decline a substitute, the organiser must refund the package payments within 14 days of termination. An accepted change or substitute that results in a lower-quality or lower-cost package can entitle you to an appropriate reduction. Dated comparisons and a record of agreed requirements are more persuasive than a star rating alone. Keep a separate record for problems arising after arrival, so that any claim reflects what the organiser promised as amended and what it actually delivered.

📄 Official circular