KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Cancer Patient: When Can a Travel Insurer Refuse a Claim Over Medical Disclosure?

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Cancer Patient: When Can a Travel Insurer Refuse a Claim Over Medical Disclosure?

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

The phrase cancer patient is being searched in the United Kingdom. For someone arranging a trip after a cancer diagnosis, a practical legal question can arise months after buying cover. If a travel insurer refuses to pay after discovering medical information, what must it show, and when can it reduce the payment rather than refuse it altogether? This article gives general information about personal travel insurance governed by the law of England and Wales. The examples are hypothetical.

Under the Consumer Insurance (Disclosure and Representations) Act 2012, a refusal based on an answer given before the policy was bought or varied depends on the question asked, the care taken in answering and what the insurer would actually have offered if given accurate information. A separate question is whether the policy itself covers the claimed loss. An insurer may raise both points in one letter, and each needs a separate answer.

The most useful records are often the original screening questions, the policy version in force and a short medical chronology tied to the dates when answers were given. This guide shows how to use those records, calculate a possible reduced payment and set out a complaint that addresses the insurer’s stated reasons.

I. When a Medical Answer Can Affect Travel Cover

A. Reconstruct the Question, the Answer and the Date

Sections 1 to 3 of the 2012 Act apply to a consumer buying insurance wholly or mainly outside their trade, business or profession. This guide deals with personal travel policies taken out under the regime in force since 6 April 2013. The statutory duty is to take reasonable care to avoid giving the insurer misleading or inaccurate information before entering into or varying the contract. Section 2 also covers a request to confirm or amend information already supplied. Failure to answer such a request is capable of amounting to a misrepresentation. That matters for annual policies when the insurer carries forward answers from an earlier year.

Start with the date on which the insurer says the answer was given. Write down separately the date of the quote, the date cover was bought, any renewal or agreed change, the date of the relevant medical development and the date of the cancellation or emergency abroad. In a dispute about a pending test, distinguish the day the test was ordered, the day it was carried out, the day the result was recorded and the day the traveller was told. Those dates can support different answers to different questions. A record created after the insurance purchase may explain a later diagnosis while leaving open what the traveller knew at purchase.

Find the exact question and any on-screen help or definitions that appeared with it. A question about a diagnosis during a defined period has a different reach from one about ongoing investigations, specialist referrals or medication. A question about whether treatment ended during the last twelve months differs again from one about whether treatment took place at any time. Identify the period the wording measures and when that period ends. If the insurer relies on a follow-up question that appeared only after another answer, the order in which the site displayed the questions may matter. A generic blank form gives limited evidence about the options the traveller actually saw.

Consider a traveller whose clinician requested a follow-up scan before purchase and communicated a cancer diagnosis only after the policy began. If the application asked solely about a prior cancer diagnosis, the later diagnosis does little by itself to show the answer was inaccurate at purchase. If the form specifically asked whether the traveller was waiting for a scan or the results of a test, the referral and any explanation given at the time become relevant. If the traveller was told the appointment was routine surveillance, the precise wording still matters. A question covering all scans can call for a different answer from a question limited to investigations for unexplained symptoms.

Section 3 requires an assessment in light of all the relevant circumstances. It lists the kind of policy, its intended market, insurer-approved explanatory material and the clarity and specificity of the questions. For unanswered renewal or variation questions, it also points to how clearly the insurer communicated the importance of replying or the consequences of silence. The general standard is that of a reasonable consumer. Particular circumstances of the actual consumer count where the insurer knew or ought to have known about them. A dishonest answer always falls short of reasonable care. An honestly given answer can also fall short if the question was clear and the information was available.

A telephone sale can produce a difference between what the traveller said and what a later confirmation displays. Ask for the recording or a transcript of the relevant exchange and the written record of the answers. For an online sale, ask for the timestamped answers and the version of the screening flow used. Where several people are covered, identify whose medical history the question asked about and who supplied the answer. If an intermediary entered the answers, establish who appointed it and what authority it had. Section 9 and Schedule 2 treat an intermediary as acting for the insurer in specified cases, including where the insurer expressly authorised it to collect the information as its agent. Outside the listed cases the starting presumption, for the purposes of the Act, is that the intermediary acted for the consumer, subject to the circumstances.

A change between purchase and departure needs its own entry in the chronology. An insurer may point to a policy clause asking the traveller to report specified changes in health during the cover period. Identify the wording, when it applied, what triggered it and the consequence the insurer claims follows. If there was an agreed variation or renewal, retain the new screening record too. The statutory test for a statement made before purchase or variation and the effect of a separate policy condition are distinct issues. The date on which the information became known can determine which issue needs to be addressed.

B. Check What the Insurer Says It Would Have Offered

Section 4 of the 2012 Act requires the insurer to show that it would have declined cover altogether or offered cover on different terms if the consumer had complied with the duty. The insurer needs a basis for that conclusion in addition to identifying an inaccurate answer given without reasonable care. A useful refusal explanation connects the original question and the answer the insurer says should have been given to the decision the corrected information would have produced when cover was arranged.

Ask which outcome the insurer relies on. A refusal to write any policy, an exclusion for claims connected with one condition and an increase in premium are different outcomes. The relevant evidence can include the screening criteria in use on the date of purchase, the version of the rating rules and the result of applying those rules to the corrected answers. For a manual referral to an underwriter, ask for an explanation of how that referral would have been decided. A general statement that a diagnosis affects risk leaves the financial outcome unresolved. An illustration made using today’s prices may also leave unanswered what the insurer would have charged on the original date.

Check the exact product. An annual multi-trip plan and a single-trip plan can have different acceptance rules even when they are sold under one general label. Destination, length of trip and the chosen level of cover may affect the comparison. A quote from another insurer can illustrate that cover was available somewhere, but section 4 asks what the insurer that wrote the policy would have done. Similarly, a later offer from the same insurer can prompt a question about the original decision. Its value depends in part on whether it used the same product and the same risk criteria.

The claim decision might cite both an inaccurate screening answer and an exclusion already written into the contract. Ask the insurer to identify the exact policy version, clause and facts it says engage that clause. For example, if a clause excludes losses resulting from a defined pre-existing condition, examine the policy’s definition and the reason the trip was cancelled. A medical certificate about the cause of cancellation may matter to the exclusion. The original screening record answers a different question about what was represented and what cover would have been offered. A traveller can dispute either ground and should address both where both appear in the refusal.

The wording also matters when a consumer policy term is open to more than one meaning. Section 69 of the Consumer Rights Act 2015 generally favours the meaning most favourable to the consumer when a term or notice can bear different meanings. Section 62 provides the general fairness test and the effect of an unfair term, subject to the scope of the Act. Ask first what the ordinary words mean in the context of the whole policy. A term can define the limits of cover, and a disagreement alone does not establish ambiguity or unfairness. For an application answer, section 10 of the 2012 Act also prevents a term from putting the consumer in a worse position on the statutory rules about pre-contract or pre-variation answers and the remedies available for them.

This article forms part of the English-language legal information published by the Paris practice. Its insurance examples concern contracts governed by the law of England and Wales.

II. What the Insurer Can Pay and How to Dispute the Decision

A. Work Out Which Remedy Fits the Evidence

Section 5 and Schedule 1 of the 2012 Act distinguish deliberate or reckless qualifying misrepresentations from careless ones. For the deliberate or reckless category, the consumer must have known that the answer was untrue or misleading, or been indifferent to that, and must have known that the subject was relevant to the insurer, or been indifferent to its relevance. The insurer must show that classification. Section 5 also contains rebuttable presumptions about the knowledge of a reasonable consumer and the relevance of a matter covered by a clear and specific question. An incorrect answer supports an inquiry into those elements. The question asked, the circumstances and any explanation still matter.

With a deliberate or reckless qualifying misrepresentation at purchase, the insurer may avoid the contract and refuse all claims. It may keep the premiums except to the extent retaining them would be unfair to the consumer. For a careless qualifying misrepresentation, the position follows the cover that would actually have been offered. If the insurer shows that it would have offered no policy on any terms, it may avoid the contract and refuse claims, but it must return the premiums paid. Where the insurer says it has avoided the policy, ask it to state the classification, the grounds and whether it has returned or retained any premium.

If the insurer would have offered different non-price terms, Schedule 1 allows it to treat the policy as if it included those terms. Suppose that accurate screening would have led to an exclusion limited to losses caused by a particular cancer. For a claim arising from a broken wrist on the trip, that hypothetical exclusion would require examination of the actual cause of the loss. For a cancellation prompted by treatment for the excluded condition, the same wording could yield a different outcome. Obtain the wording that would have applied, rather than assuming that any alternative offer would have excluded every medical or cancellation claim.

If the insurer would have covered the risk at a higher price, paragraphs 7 and 8 permit a proportionate reduction. Divide the premium actually charged by the higher premium that would have been charged and apply that ratio to the amount otherwise payable. Suppose the consumer paid £90, the correct premium for the same terms would have been £150 and the amount otherwise payable after the relevant excess and policy limits is £1,200. The ratio is 60 per cent, giving a payment of £720. On those assumptions the difference is £480. If the insurer substitutes a different figure for the higher premium, ask for the screening result or price calculation supporting it.

Both a different term and a higher premium can apply if the insurer demonstrates that it would have imposed both. Suppose the policy covers a mixed claim for which £2,000 would initially be payable. A term the insurer would have imposed removes a £750 item, leaving £1,250 as the amount otherwise payable on those terms. If the original premium was £100 and the correct premium £125, the ratio is 80 per cent and the payment is £1,000. The calculation starts with the amount due under the applicable terms. It then applies the ratio. Check every line against the actual breakdown, including any excess and recovered amounts.

An unrelated loss can help test the insurer’s reasoning. In the broken wrist example, an exclusion confined to the cancer would leave the wrist claim to be assessed under the remaining terms. If the insurer instead establishes that it would have declined the entire policy, Schedule 1 can allow it to refuse even that unrelated claim. Likewise, if the higher premium remedy applies, the percentage can affect a claim for a different insured loss. Ask which of these grounds the insurer is using before paying for evidence about the medical cause of the loss. A clinical explanation of the injury can answer a question about a condition-specific exclusion. It has a different role in a dispute about whether cover would have been offered at all.

A dispute over a later change to the policy can affect a smaller part of the cover. Schedule 1, Part 2 asks whether the subject of an agreed variation can reasonably be treated separately from the remainder of the contract. For example, a mid-year agreement to add cover for a particular trip may call for a different analysis from a change affecting the whole annual policy. Keep the original and amended schedules. Where the cover comes from a group policy, such as a benefit provided under a separate arrangement, section 7 and Schedule 1, Part 3 may apply if their conditions are met. Identify who contracted with the insurer, who supplied the information and whose part of the cover the insurer says is affected.

B. Build the Complaint Around the Refusal Letter

Organise the complaint by ground of refusal. For a disputed screening answer, provide the question as it appeared, the recorded answer and the date. Explain which information was available to the traveller at the time. Where that information is contested, a short letter clarifying when a finding was communicated or why a test was ordered can be more precise than a complete set of clinical notes. If two records appear inconsistent, show what each date represents. A later date of communication and an earlier date of entry in a clinical record can both be correct. Supply the portions relevant to the disputed question and identify any missing records.

For a policy exclusion, give the clause number and the policy edition, then set out the facts on which the claim turns. Keep the date and wording of any medical advice to cancel or postpone the trip. Retain the original booking record, the cancellation statement and evidence of refunds or credits alongside the amount claimed. If the insurer alleges an alternative term or a higher premium, include its explanation and identify the missing step, such as a failure to account for the type of policy or a difference between the amount initially paid and the premium used in the calculation. Separate any disputed excess or limit so the insurer can respond to the arithmetic on its own.

Ask for a specific outcome. Depending on the grounds and evidence, the request may be to reconsider the claim on the original terms, explain and recalculate a reduced payment, or return the premiums if the insurer relies on avoidance for careless misrepresentation. For a part payment, identify the amount already paid and the extra sum sought. Keep a copy of the complaint and the date it was submitted.

The statutory financial ombudsman scheme established under section 225 of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 is an independent route for certain disputes. Check eligibility and the applicable referral deadline using the instructions that come with the final response. For a complaint within the compulsory scheme, section 228 calls for a decision on what is fair and reasonable in the circumstances. The written determination gives reasons and states the date for accepting or rejecting it. An accepted determination is final and binding on both sides. Missing the specified date generally counts as rejection, subject to the limited statutory provision for late acceptance. Read the decision and consider the effect of accepting it before replying.

Track the time for any contract action separately from the complaint timetable. Section 5 of the Limitation Act 1980 sets the ordinary six-year period for an action founded on simple contract in England and Wales, measured from when the cause of action accrued. Working out that date depends on the particular obligation and facts. The refusal date alone may give an incomplete picture. If there are several possible dates, preserve the records for each and check the earliest potentially applicable one before relying on any longer period. In a complaint, use dates and amounts that can be traced back to the policy, medical information or booking documents.

Conclusion

A travel insurance refusal after a cancer diagnosis can turn on a small number of documents. The screening record shows what the insurer asked and what the traveller knew at the relevant date. The insurer’s underwriting evidence shows what would have changed if a qualifying misrepresentation had been corrected. The policy and the reason for the loss show whether any existing or alternative exclusion applies. Keeping those questions separate makes it possible to check the outcome, including whether the insurer can refuse the claim, should repay the premium or has grounds only for a lower payment. A complaint built around the actual questions, dates, terms and figures gives the reviewer a clear account of what is disputed and what would resolve it.

📄 Official circular