KOHEN AVOCATS · PARIS, FRANCE
Presumed Innocent: What Does a Federal Criminal Jury Have to Decide?

Hassan Kohen is a Paris-based lawyer admitted to the Paris Bar (Avocat au Barreau de Paris). Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Sources: U.S. court opinions and official U.S. government publications, read for this article

Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Presumed Innocent: What Does a Federal Criminal Jury Have to Decide?

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

In a federal criminal jury trial, the prosecution must prove every element of the charged offense beyond a reasonable doubt. The defendant starts the trial presumed innocent and does not have to prove innocence, testify, or supply a competing account of what happened. If reasonable doubt remains about even one required element, the jury must find the defendant not guilty of that offense. A new teaser for the fictional series Presumed Innocent has brought the phrase back into view. The practical question in an actual courtroom is what jurors have been told to decide and what evidence they can use to decide it.

Start with three documents if you are following a public federal trial: the indictment, the judge’s final instructions, and the verdict form. The indictment identifies the charges. The instructions explain the law the jury applies to the evidence. The verdict form records the jury’s decisions in the format the court requires. An instruction missing from one count, an unanswered question about what a term means, or an assumption about missing evidence can change how those documents fit together. Three federal appeals from the Tenth Circuit show how courts deal with each problem.

I. What must the prosecution prove before a federal jury can convict?

A. Read the charge one element at a time

The federal Constitution supplies the starting point. The Fifth Amendment protects due process and bars compelling a person to be a witness against themselves in a criminal case. The Sixth Amendment guarantees an impartial jury in criminal prosecutions within its scope and gives the accused rights that include notice of the accusation, confrontation of opposing witnesses, and assistance of counsel. At a federal jury trial the judge translates the applicable law into a set of instructions the jurors can use. The jury evaluates the evidence and decides whether the prosecution has carried its burden on the particular charges submitted.

For a concrete example, read the Third Circuit’s model federal criminal jury instructions, §§ 3.06 and 3.07. One instruction explains that the presumption remains with the defendant unless the prosecution overcomes it by proving guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. The other describes the indictment as an accusation and tells jurors to give it no evidentiary weight. These are models prepared for use in federal courts in the Third Circuit. In a particular trial, use the actual instructions the judge gave. The model helps you locate the relevant passages and understand the division between a charge and proof.

An element is a fact the law requires the prosecution to prove for a specific offense. Suppose a hypothetical charge requires proof that someone performed a prohibited act and knew a particular fact when doing it. A recording may establish exactly who performed the act and how it happened. The same recording may say very little about what that person knew at the time. The burden applies to both questions. When reading a federal instruction, write down the act requirement and the knowledge requirement on separate lines. Under each, identify the evidence that supports it, the evidence that cuts against it, and the inference a juror would have to draw to reach a finding. That exercise makes it easier to see when a persuasive story about one requirement carries over into an unsupported assumption about another.

The indictment can help identify which conduct the federal prosecution attributes to each count. It may describe different dates, people, or acts. The final instructions tell you which legal requirements the jury considered for each count, and the trial record supplies the evidence. If an exhibit appears useful to the prosecution, identify what proposition it actually supports. An authenticated timestamp, for example, may show when a device recorded an event. Whether it also shows who controlled the device is a separate question. Check the testimony explaining the exhibit, any qualifications on its use, and whether another piece of evidence connects it to the right person. The same approach applies to a witness whose account covers only part of a sequence.

Federal proof beyond a reasonable doubt is a demanding standard without a numerical threshold. The Third Circuit’s model uses the example of doubt that would cause an ordinary reasonable person to hesitate in an important matter. It recognizes that doubt can arise from the evidence, the absence of evidence, or the nature of the evidence. An imagined possibility unsupported by the record is different from a specific uncertainty revealed by the record. If two witnesses describe sharply different views of an event, consider their opportunities to observe it and whether contemporaneous evidence supports either version. A seemingly small disagreement may become material if it concerns the only testimony connecting the defendant to a required act.

The prosecution’s burden stays with the prosecution throughout the federal trial. That allocation matters even when the defense chooses to introduce exhibits, cross-examine witnesses, or offer its own evidence. A decision to contest a prosecution witness’s account gives the jury more information to work with. It does not require the defense to produce an eyewitness who can tell a more complete story. When the defendant chooses not to testify, review the part of the actual charge dealing with that choice. The Third Circuit’s model instructions address the defendant’s choice about testifying separately from the instruction defining the burden of proof. On a separate question, a defense with its own requirements can have its own instructions. The commentary to § 3.06 illustrates how an instruction can address such a defense while leaving the prosecution’s burden on every element intact.

Be especially careful with statements made at different stages of a federal case. An opening statement describes what a lawyer expects the evidence to show. A closing argument asks jurors to draw inferences from the trial record. Under the Third Circuit’s model general instructions, lawyers’ statements and arguments are outside the evidence the jury weighs. When a report says that a fact was established at trial, check whether the underlying reference is a witness’s answer, an admitted exhibit, an agreed fact, or a lawyer’s description. Even a witness’s statement can have a specific purpose under the court’s instructions. That distinction matters if someone relies on the statement as substantive proof of a disputed element.

B. Decide what an evidentiary gap actually affects

Missing evidence matters most when you can describe the bridge it would have provided. Imagine that witnesses place a person near a package and one witness says the person picked it up. An unrecorded camera angle could bear on whether the person touched the package, whether the contents were visible, or neither. Each possibility concerns a different inference. The useful question is which proposition the prosecution needs the jury to accept and what evidence besides the missing item supports it. If a witness claims a direct view, consider distance, obstructions, the time available to observe, and whether the account changed. If an exhibit confirms only the setting or time, identify the remaining inference separately.

In United States v. Eddings, No. 24-2118 (10th Cir. October 31, 2025), the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit affirmed two federal firearm and ammunition convictions. The appeal challenged the proof of possession on one count and an instruction explaining that the government did not have to use particular investigative techniques. The court held that the evidence permitted the jury to find knowing possession on the disputed count. It also found no plain error in the challenged use of the investigative instruction alongside the other instructions, which left the burden of proof with the government. If a video misses the decisive moment, identify what the testimony and other evidence actually establish about the disputed element and read the investigative instruction together with the judge’s instructions on proof.

That federal appeal illustrates a distinction with practical consequences. Counsel can question whether the proof establishes the required fact without assuming the prosecution has a categorical duty to produce a particular photograph, test, or recording. In the Third Circuit, the same model chapter gives jurors a separate instruction, § 3.05, on all possible evidence and witnesses. Its commentary discusses when a more specific instruction about investigative techniques may be considered. The Tenth Circuit’s decision addressed the combination of instructions and objections in a particular case. If your issue involves different wording or a different circuit, check what the judge actually said and the authorities that govern there before using the outcome as a prediction.

When examining a gap, give it a sentence precise enough to disagree with. For instance, a missing photograph might leave a witness’s account of what was visible at a key moment uncorroborated. The testimony could still be evidence on that point, while an earlier photograph might corroborate only the location. A second witness might have seen the object during a different part of the episode. Those distinctions allow a fair assessment of which pieces bear on the required fact. They also help separate an argument about the reliability of existing proof from a request that the court require investigators to take a particular step.

A federal judge’s ruling on the legal sufficiency of the proof is a separate part of the process. Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 29 directs the court, on the defendant’s motion after the government closes its evidence or after the close of all evidence, to enter a judgment of acquittal for any offense for which the evidence is insufficient to sustain a conviction. The rule also provides for a motion after verdict or discharge. The motion and ruling help identify a legal dispute about whether the evidence can sustain a conviction. A federal court of appeals reviewing sufficiency, as in the Eddings opinion, considers the evidence and reasonable inferences in the light most favorable to the government. The jurors at trial do their own work of assessing the evidence under the instructions they received.

II. What if an instruction leaves out a defense or a jury asks what a term means?

A. Compare the proposed instructions, the final charge, and the verdict form

Start with the instruction connected to the specific count. A general explanation of reasonable doubt may accurately describe the government’s burden, yet an instruction on a particular count can still leave unclear what the burden covers. A legal definition may appear elsewhere in the packet, or a defense may appear in instructions the jury is directed to consider only after resolving a more serious charge. Track cross-references and read the order of decisions the jury is asked to make. If the instructions tell jurors to stop when they answer a question one way, check what legal issues they will have had a chance to consider at that point.

In United States v. Maryboy, No. 23-4117 (10th Cir. May 29, 2025), the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit reversed and remanded after finding plain error in a federal prosecution for second-degree murder and a related firearm offense. The instructions did not tell the jury that the government had to disprove the sufficiently raised theory of imperfect self-defense beyond a reasonable doubt to obtain a murder conviction. The panel separately found error in expert testimony on mental state. If an instruction about a mitigating defense appears only under a lesser offense, trace the verdict form to see whether the jury can consider that defense before it decides the greater charge.

In that case the federal jury was told to consider the lesser charge only after acquitting on murder or being unable to agree on murder after reasonable efforts. The greater charge and its verdict question therefore mattered as much as the fact that the packet mentioned the defense somewhere. The decision concerned the particular federal murder charge, evidence, and instructions before the Tenth Circuit. The right comparison in a different case is between the actual charge and the applicable law on what the government has to prove or disprove. A defendant who argues that the prosecution failed to prove intent raises a different kind of issue from a defendant invoking an affirmative defense with a separate burden assigned by applicable law.

Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 30 governs requesting and objecting to jury instructions. It allows written requests at the close of evidence or at an earlier time reasonably set by the court. The judge must tell the parties before closing arguments how the court intends to rule on requested instructions. The rule also requires a party objecting to an instruction or omission to identify the specific objection and grounds before the jury retires to deliberate. It expressly preserves the possibility of review under Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 52(b) when that requirement was missed. The important points for reading the record are the exact wording requested, what counsel said was wrong with the proposed wording, and what the judge delivered.

If the immediate issue is trouble communicating with the attorney who would raise these points, the procedure for asking a federal court to replace appointed counsel is a separate question.

An order listing the proposed instructions can make those distinctions easier to follow. A set filed jointly by both parties can still differ from the final set. Earlier wording may explain where an issue came from, but the operative trial record includes the instructions actually given and any additional instructions or answers sent to the jury. Likewise, a transcript of counsel talking with the court outside the jury’s hearing may show a dispute the jurors never heard. Compare those materials before drawing a conclusion from a brief docket entry saying an instruction was requested or discussed.

B. Read a jury’s question alongside the court’s answer

A written question during deliberations can identify the exact place where jurors struggled to apply the instructions. The question may ask for a legal definition, clarification about the form, or help locating particular evidence. Start by reading it verbatim in the trial record, then compare it with the written instructions and the court’s response. If the question raises an ambiguity about a required element, identify how each reading would change the fact the jury needed to find. A single exhibit can look decisive under one definition and leave a substantial factual gap under another.

In United States v. Kirby, No. 24-7070 (10th Cir. December 16, 2025), the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit vacated a federal involuntary manslaughter conviction and remanded. The jury asked whether the presence of intoxicants was enough or whether they had to impair safe driving. For the Oklahoma offense underlying the federal theory submitted to the jury, the required finding concerned incapacity to drive safely. Referring jurors back to their instructions left that central uncertainty unresolved, and the panel found the error was not harmless. If jurors ask what a required term means, compare their competing readings with the governing definition and examine whether the court’s actual answer resolved the difference.

The federal appellate court weighed the particular jury note, record, and verdict in that case. A direction to consult existing instructions can be adequate when those instructions supply an answer to the question the jury actually asked. The Kirby concurrence emphasized that the circumstances here were unusual. The Oklahoma impairment definition entered the analysis because it was part of one theory of the federal charge in that case. It is useful to check whether the federal instruction in the case you are following incorporates state law, and if it does, which state and which provision it incorporates. A ruling about one state’s legal definition does not supply the definition for other states.

A transcript also lets you check the sequence. A question may follow a supplemental instruction or a request for an exhibit. Find the exact materials the jury had at that point, because a later clarification could address an uncertainty that the original instructions left open. Distinguish a court’s account of what the law requires from a party’s proposal for answering the question. In the federal Kirby appeal, the different proposed answers and the actual reply mattered because they pointed to different possible findings. A headline that says only that the jury was confused leaves out the question that determines whether its confusion had a legal consequence.

If the dispute concerns whether a charge was properly explained, locate the pages covering the judge’s discussion with the parties. Preserve the distinction between a proposed correction, a specific objection and its grounds, and a later challenge in an appellate brief. The Tenth Circuit’s Eddings decision shows how an objection made at trial can differ from the more specific argument raised on appeal. A short summary saying that counsel objected can therefore obscure a part of the case that affected the reviewing court’s approach.

The next document is the verdict itself. Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 31 requires a unanimous verdict returned in open court and addresses partial verdicts when the jury agrees on some counts but cannot agree on all of them. The rule distinguishes counts the jury resolved from counts on which it could not reach a verdict. A general verdict often gives the conclusion without explaining which witness or inference the jurors accepted. Maryboy shows why restraint is warranted in reading one. The panel could see what charge the jury decided, but the form did not show which of two routes to rejecting complete self-defense the jurors took. The instructions and verdict form define what can responsibly be inferred.

For a practical federal case review, take one disputed count and put its charge, element instructions, any relevant defense instruction, and verdict question together. Add any supplemental instructions the judge gave and any ruling that addresses sufficiency on that count. Mark statements from lawyers separately from findings made by the court or jury. If there was an appeal, read the disposition carefully. An opinion vacating a conviction and remanding returns the matter for further proceedings. An opinion affirming under plain-error review tells you how the particular challenge fared with that standard and record. Those procedural outcomes can shape what readers learn from the opinion even when the underlying question about reasonable doubt sounds similar.

Conclusion

In a federal jury trial, the presumption of innocence keeps the burden of proof on the prosecution. To see how the burden works in an actual case, identify the count, read the judge’s definition of each element, and match the trial evidence to those requirements. Read the final charge alongside any jury questions and replies, and check which decisions the verdict form records. Missing evidence, an instruction attached to the wrong part of the charge, and an unanswered question about a legal definition call for different checks. Those checks show where the case turned and what the available record leaves unresolved.

📄 Official circular