The search for AI generated most wanted images has drawn attention in Canada to a practical question. If a digital likeness appears in a wanted notice, what could it actually prove in a criminal case? A picture may look like a photograph while being an illustration made from one or more reference files. A screenshot can record how a notice appeared at a particular time. An original camera file can show what a camera recorded. Each of these items answers a different question, even when they look similar on a phone screen.
In a Canadian criminal case, start by asking what the party offering the image says it is and what that party wants the judge or jury to infer from it. The federal rules for electronic documents address how the file is identified and how its recording or storage can be established. Proving that a file accurately records a published notice leaves open whether the likeness identifies the right person. Someone who has been confused with a person in a notice can also have a separate records problem to address.
This is general information on Canadian federal law as of 22 November 2026, by Hassan Kohen, a lawyer at the Paris Bar in France. The examples are hypothetical and describe how to preserve evidence, how to read a claim about an image, and what options may be available if the identification is disputed.
I. How to Recognize Fake AI-Generated Images
A. How can you tell whether an image is an original or a recreation?
Start with the claim attached to the image. Is it offered as a copy of what a website displayed, an illustration made from reference material, or a record of a real scene? Write that claim in one sentence. A sentence such as This screenshot shows the notice I viewed on Friday describes a different item from This image shows the person who was in the shop on Friday. The second statement requires a connection to a person and a scene. The first calls for evidence of what was on the page. An image that looks equally convincing in either setting can be far more informative in one setting than the other.
Section 2 of the Canada Evidence Act sets out the application of the part of the Act that contains these provisions, including criminal proceedings. The definition in section 31.8 includes data stored by or in a computer system and the display, printout or other output of that data. A file saved from a website can therefore be an electronic document. So can a display or a printout derived from the data. If a dispute concerns an image created from another image, the input, output and public display can be distinct documents. Keeping their labels separate makes it possible to explain what each one records.
Section 31.1 puts the burden of proving authenticity on the person seeking to admit the electronic document. That person must offer evidence capable of supporting a finding that the document is what it is claimed to be. A person who saved a page can explain when and how they saved it and what their copy includes. A person who operated an image tool can explain the input they used, what they asked the tool to produce, which output they selected and whether they changed that output again. Those accounts relate to different steps. Even a complete account of how an illustration was made leaves questions about the accuracy of its features.
For example, suppose an illustration is created from a five-year-old photo, with software filling in the current appearance of the face. The original photo may help explain why some features resemble a particular person. The new file may show what the software produced after processing that original. A viewer may think a detail in the new file was captured in the old photo when it was generated by the tool. If the detail is a scar, a mark or an apparent change in age, ask whether it is present in the source photo, whether the creator deliberately added it, and whether independent evidence puts that detail on the person in question. A face can appear plausible even where a particular detail has no source outside the software.
The answer often begins with practical checks. A label explaining that an image is a recreation helps identify what the publisher intended people to see. A reachable original page can indicate where the copy came from. A version saved before a later edit may show that the label or wording changed. Metadata, when available, can help record where a file came from or when a device handled it. These clues carry more weight when someone can explain how they were obtained. A missing creation date can result from an ordinary download or export, and a date in a copy can refer to that copy. Keep any conclusions about the underlying file proportional to the evidence available.
B. What should you save if a likeness could identify the wrong person?
Preserve the first version you saw. Save the page address, the date and time with the time zone, and the words that surrounded the image. Capture the whole notice, including the headings and any captions, labels or warnings. Where a download is available, keep that file separately from the screenshot. If the image changes when it is played, save enough of the sequence to show what you actually saw. Note whether you reached the original page or a repost. A repost can lose the context that explains an illustration, and an anonymous forwarded copy gives you fewer ways to establish where the picture came from.
Keep an untouched copy and use a separate working copy if you need to mark an area. A helpful file log has four entries for each item: what it is, where you got it, when you got it and anything you did to it. Record simple steps such as taking a screenshot, saving a download, exporting a message or making a redacted copy. If another person sent the material, record that separately from the time you first saw the public post. An original message can show whether a warning or a caption travelled with the file. Storing those items together helps someone reconstruct how an apparent identification reached you.
If the concern is that your own face resembles the picture, write down precisely what was said and who said it. A message naming you, a report of a match, and your own concern about resemblance are three different things. Record any specific practical outcome, such as receiving an inquiry or having an account of your whereabouts challenged. Keep independent records that could verify a location or date if either becomes relevant. Possible examples include an original booking, a dated work record, or a message sent at the time. A note saying how you obtained each item is often more useful than a collection of cropped pictures without context.
Avoid circulating the notice further while trying to resolve it. A fresh repost can spread the suspected association and remove the details that explain the image. If you have a factual correction, keep the wording focused on the error you can identify and the records that support it. If a witness is asked what they saw, preserve their original account before they look at a new version of the picture where possible. The date on which they first saw the image matters because a person may later combine their memory of the original event with details learned from the notice. Let each person record their own account in their own words.
Section 31.5 of the Canada Evidence Act allows evidence of relevant standards, procedures, usage or practice for recording or storing electronic documents when admissibility is at issue. It directs attention to the enterprise that used, recorded or stored the material and the nature and purpose of the document. For an illustration, a useful description might identify which file was used as input, how outputs were selected, what changes were made and how the final file was retained. For a screenshot, the explanation may be simpler. The person who made it can describe the device, the page and whether they altered the picture after capture.
II. Can an AI-Generated Image Be Used as Evidence in a Canadian Criminal Case?
A. What does the court check before it can rely on a digital image?
Authenticity is the first question to isolate. Consider a person who copied a page and can show that the copy accurately records what the page displayed on a certain afternoon. That evidence supports the claim that the copy records the display. If the copy is then offered to prove that someone was present when a crime took place, the proponent needs a reason why the pictured material bears on that event. A recreation can provide a clear record of the creator’s work while leaving that inference uncertain. Ask the person offering it to specify the claimed link, so the issue can be assessed on its own terms.
The difference is particularly important when two witnesses point to the same image. One might have seen the person directly and later looked at the image. Another might know the person only from the notice and repeat the first witness’s description. If each statement is described as an independent identification, ask when each witness first saw the document and what information each person already had. A timeline with short entries for the original observation, the first viewing of the notice, and the later report can expose a shared source. It can also show when a witness supplied something that can be checked independently.
A separate question concerns the best evidence rule. Under section 31.2(1) of the Canada Evidence Act, for an electronic document that rule can be satisfied by proof of the integrity of the system in or by which it was recorded or stored, or by an applicable evidentiary presumption established under section 31.4. Subsection 31.2(2) deals specifically with a printout. In the absence of evidence to the contrary, the rule can be satisfied where the printout was plainly or consistently acted on, relied on or used as a record of the information stored or recorded in it. The provision gives a route for proving a record. Reliability as evidence of a real-world event depends on how the information in that record was produced and what else supports it.
Section 31.3 sets out alternative ways to establish system integrity in the absence of evidence to the contrary. One uses evidence capable of supporting a finding that the system operated properly at all material times, or that a fault did not affect the integrity of the document and there are no other reasonable grounds to doubt the system. Another concerns an electronic document recorded or stored by a party adverse in interest to the party seeking to introduce it. A third concerns material recorded or stored in the ordinary course of business by a non-party outside the introducing party’s control. The route matters because each route calls for different facts. A service could faithfully retain a generated file from the moment it was uploaded and still be unable to explain anything about the accuracy of the face it depicts.
Under section 31.6, some of these matters may be proved by affidavit, including points under section 31.3 and section 31.5 and the best evidence treatment of a printout under section 31.2(2). Once an affidavit of that kind has been introduced in evidence, a party may cross-examine the person who swore it as of right if that person is an adverse party or under an adverse party’s control. For other people who swear such an affidavit, leave of the court is required. Consider what the person can actually explain from their own knowledge: Did they see the original file used as input, did they oversee the generation, or did they only retrieve the output from an archive? Each answer limits what their account can establish.
Finally, read these rules in their setting. Section 40 applies the evidence law in force in the province where proceedings under Parliament’s legislative authority take place, subject to the Canada Evidence Act and other federal Acts. The use of a digital file can raise questions beyond the selected federal provisions. A party can challenge the claimed connection between the image and the person, the relevance of a generated feature, the evidence of when and how the file was created, or the weight the decision maker should give the image. When several versions exist, identify exactly which one is in issue. The criminal allegation remains an allegation until it has been proved in the legal process.
B. What can you do if the police or a federal record links you to the wrong image?
If the police contact you, start by finding out whether they are asking for information or making an arrest. Record the date, the reason given, any reference number and any documents you are given. Section 29 of the Criminal Code imposes duties, where feasible, to have the process or warrant when executing it and to produce it if asked, and to give notice of the process or warrant or the reason for the arrest. Section 29(3) limits what follows from a failure to comply. If a document is available, preserve it. If all you have is an oral explanation, write it down accurately as soon as you can and keep it distinct from anything other people subsequently tell you.
For a peace officer acting without a warrant, section 495 of the Criminal Code sets out the circumstances in which a warrantless arrest can occur. These include reasonable grounds to believe that a person has committed or is about to commit an indictable offence, finding a person committing a criminal offence, and reasonable grounds to believe a specified warrant is in force in the territory where the person is found. Subsection 495(2) limits arrest without a warrant for the categories it lists if the public interest can reasonably be satisfied without arrest and there are no reasonable grounds to believe the person will fail to attend court. Identifying which authority is being relied on is more informative than assuming a resemblance to a wanted picture explains the legal reason for the arrest.
A mistaken public association can also lead to a records question even when there is no arrest. If a federal government institution may hold personal information about you, identify it and describe the particular record you seek. Section 12 of the Privacy Act gives Canadian citizens and permanent residents a right, subject to the Act, to request access to their personal information in a personal information bank and to other personal information under a federal institution’s control if it is reasonably retrievable from the details supplied. Subsection 12(3) allows extension of access rights by order. A request is easier to locate if it identifies the file or notice at issue and the dates or references you have, subject to how the institution handles identification and sensitive records.
Section 12(2) supplies a particular route to seek a correction where a person was given access under paragraph 12(1)(a) and the information has been, is being or is available to be used for an administrative purpose. If the correction is declined, the person can require a notation of the requested correction. The provision also provides for notification to recipients meeting its terms, including a two-year lookback for disclosures for an administrative purpose. Describe the exact entry to be corrected and submit the records that support the change. A precise request, such as correction of a record linking a specific photograph to your name, makes it possible to assess the response entry by entry.
For example, suppose a record lists your name next to a photo from an unrelated inquiry. Identify the particular field and the document in which you saw it. Explain why you believe it is wrong, such as an original caption that identifies the photo differently or dated records that put the image somewhere else. Keep copies of the original material and of the correction request. If a face simply resembles yours and you have no reason to think an institution has connected it to your name, the first question is whether a relevant record about you exists. That question can be explored without repeating the suspected association in public.
Keep the scope of that route in mind. A private publisher or a provincial body can have a different records process. A federal investigative record can be subject to refusal under section 22 of the Privacy Act. The section includes grounds relating to law enforcement and investigations and a separate rule for certain provincial or municipal policing records in federal hands. Under section 14, the federal institution generally has 30 days after receipt of a section 12(1) access request to give written notice and, if access is granted, provide it, subject to section 15. Save the submission and any receipt so that you can work from the recorded receipt date.
Section 16 deals with refusal notices and treats failure to give access within the statutory time limits as a refusal. Section 29 of the Privacy Act covers complaints to the Privacy Commissioner, including certain access refusals and disputes over the correction rights in section 12(2). Keep the refusal notice, the specific part of the request that was refused, and a copy of what you sent. A privacy complaint concerns the institution’s handling of the records. Questions about the use of an image in a pending prosecution need to be addressed in that proceeding, with its own timetable.
The firm’s English-language overview of legal practice in Paris explains the French practice context for this foreign-law note. For the Canadian questions discussed here, the critical materials are the precise records and the Canadian legal provisions that govern them. Separate the publisher’s copy, the creator’s source material and the documents that show whether authorities took action. The same file may be relevant to several issues, and keeping a clear record of its origin makes it easier to discuss each one without confusing their different legal consequences.
Conclusion
In Canada, a generated likeness may be relevant to show what a publisher displayed or how a digital file was made. A claim that it identifies someone involved in a criminal offence calls for evidence that supports that particular inference. Save the version you saw, its source, its caption and the time you encountered it. Keep any file you edit apart from the original. A face that looks familiar gives you a reason to check those details carefully.
If an image is offered in a criminal proceeding, focus first on what the proponent says the file is, then on the evidence about its recording or storage, and finally on what the proposed inference requires. If an institution holds an incorrect record about you, identify who controls it and use the access or correction route that applies to that record. These steps make it easier to explain the exact disagreement whether it concerns a misleading public copy, an investigative record or a contested identification in a criminal case.