Searches for NFL Sunday Ticket climbed across the United States on Sunday, November 22, 2026, and the legal question readers type next is blunt: is there a payout from the Sunday Ticket lawsuit, and how much per person? The short answer is that no money is payable today. On October 30, 2026, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit decided Ninth Inning Inc. v. National Football League, Inc., Nos. 24-5493 and 24-5691. It reversed the 2024 judgment that had wiped out the subscribers’ jury win, directed the trial court to reinstate the jury’s liability verdict, and upheld the order for a fresh trial on the amount of damages. The case was remanded for a new trial on damages, which means the multibillion-dollar figure chosen by the first jury no longer stands.
The defendants have denied wrongdoing throughout: the court-approved notice in the case states that they contend their actions promoted competition. That notice website, which had not yet been updated for the October 30 ruling when we read it on November 22, 2026, tells class members that they do not need to do anything right now. An appellate opinion is also not always the final step, because federal rules allow further review before the case returns to the trial court.
The discussion that follows is general in scope: it describes checks useful in comparable situations and makes no findings about the NFL’s situation. It explains what the October 30 decision changed, why the only per-person number in the record is not a payout, who belongs to the certified classes, and the federal procedural road that any recovery would still have to travel.
I. Is there a payout per person after the Ninth Circuit ruling?
A. What the October 30, 2026 decision actually changed
The case began in 2015. According to the Ninth Circuit’s 2026 opinion, subscribers sued the National Football League and DirecTV, alleging that three “interlocking agreements” violated Sections 1 and 2 of the Sherman Act: the teams’ pooling of their telecast rights, the league’s contracts with CBS and Fox for local Sunday games, and an exclusive arrangement that let DirecTV sell out-of-market games as a separate paid package. Section 1, codified at 15 U.S.C. § 1, declares illegal every contract, combination or conspiracy in restraint of interstate trade; Section 2, printed in the same official edition, targets monopolization and conspiracies to monopolize. The federal Sports Broadcasting Act, 15 U.S.C. § 1291, exempts league agreements covering the “sponsored telecasting” of games. The 2026 panel explained that the Ninth Circuit reads that phrase as free over-the-air broadcasts supported by advertising, and that the exemption does not reach paid cable or satellite packages.
The legal theory survived an early challenge. In 2019, a Ninth Circuit panel reversed the dismissal of the subscribers’ complaint in In re NFL’s Sunday Ticket Antitrust Litigation, decided August 13, 2019, holding that the plaintiffs had plausibly alleged an injury to competition under the rule of reason. We cite that ruling here as part of this case’s own history, as the 2026 panel did, not as a freestanding statement of current law. After that remand, the district court certified a residential class and a commercial class, and the case went to trial in 2024. The subscribers relied on two economists: one built a “yardstick” comparing the NFL with college football after the Supreme Court’s 1984 decision opening up college telecasts, and the other estimated how much subscribers were overcharged. According to the 2026 opinion, the jury found the NFL liable on every element of the antitrust claims and awarded $4.6 billion to the residential class and $96 million to the commercial class.
The trial judge then changed course. Acting on a renewed motion under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 50, the court excluded both experts’ trial testimony as unreliable under Federal Rule of Evidence 702, held that without it no reasonable jury could find class-wide injury, and entered judgment as a matter of law for the NFL. It also ruled, in the alternative, that the damages award itself was irrational and that a new damages trial would be needed if the judgment were ever reversed. That alternative ruling is not unusual: under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 50(c), a court that grants judgment as a matter of law must also rule conditionally on any motion for a new trial, and if the judgment is reversed, “the new trial must proceed unless the appellate court orders otherwise.”
In Ninth Inning Inc. v. National Football League, Inc., No. 24-5493 (9th Cir. Oct. 30, 2026), a Ninth Circuit panel of Circuit Judges Holly A. Thomas and Anthony D. Johnstone, joined by District Judge Joan H. Lefkow sitting by designation, held that the trial court abused its discretion by excluding the subscribers’ experts. Writing for the panel, Judge Johnstone stated that “opinions are neither unfounded nor unreliable merely because they are impeachable,” and that whether college football was a fair comparison for the NFL telecast market was a question for the jury, not the judge. Because the judgment rested on those exclusions, the court reversed it. At the same time, the panel held that the trial court acted within its discretion in ordering a new trial on damages, and it remanded “for the district court to reinstate the jury’s liability verdict and hold a new damages trial.” For a class member, the practical result of Ninth Inning is that the finding of liability is back in place, but the dollar amount must be decided again by a new jury before anyone can be paid.
The current version of Federal Rule of Evidence 702, in the December 1, 2025 edition we read, allows expert testimony only if the proponent shows the court that it is more likely than not that the testimony will help the jury, rests on sufficient facts or data, uses reliable principles and methods, and reflects a reliable application of those methods to the case. The Ninth Circuit did not lower that bar for the subscribers. It held that the trial court went beyond checking methods and data and instead weighed the experts’ conclusions, which is the jury’s job.
A companion memorandum disposition filed the same day, which is not precedent except as Ninth Circuit Rule 36-3 provides, settled two more points. It affirmed the certification of the damages classes under Rule 23(b)(3), rejecting the cross-appeal on that question. It also reversed the judgment against the subscribers on their claims for injunctive and declaratory relief under Section 16 of the Clayton Act, 15 U.S.C. § 26, which lets a private party seek an injunction against threatened loss or damage from an antitrust violation. The panel asked the trial court to reconsider whether those injunctive class claims are moot now that the NFL-DirecTV contract has expired. That issue had been pressed on appeal by the United States, which filed an amicus brief on January 17, 2025 arguing that the trial court dismissed the injunctive claims without ever analyzing threatened loss. The brief states the government’s position as a friend of the court; it is not a ruling.
The weight of expert proof in federal court explains why this appeal mattered so much, and a different Ninth Circuit case shows the other side of the same rule. In Engilis v. Monsanto Co., No. 23-4201 (9th Cir. Aug. 12, 2025), the Ninth Circuit affirmed the exclusion of an oncologist’s opinion that exposure to a weed killer caused a plaintiff’s blood cancer, because the expert had not reliably ruled out obesity as an alternative cause. The court stressed that there is no presumption in favor of admitting expert testimony and that the proponent must establish each Rule 702 requirement by a preponderance of the evidence. Since the excluded opinion was the only proof of causation, the court affirmed summary judgment for the manufacturer. Read together with the Sunday Ticket ruling, Engilis shows that the retrial on damages will again turn on whether the subscribers’ expert models clear Rule 702, because a claim whose only proof of an element is excluded ends without any recovery. The 2026 Sunday Ticket panel itself relied on Engilis repeatedly; the difference in outcome came from what the trial court did, not from a different standard.
B. Why the $191.26 figure is not your check
Most online answers to the “payout per person” question start from the first verdict. The Ninth Circuit’s opinion shows why that is a mistake. The jury awarded exactly $4,610,331,671.74 to the residential class and $96,928,272.90 to the commercial class. As the trial court noted and the appeals court accepted, those totals almost certainly came from multiplying the number of class members the court described, 24,105,049 residential subscribers and 506,788 commercial subscribers, by the same figure: $191.26. That number equals the difference between the 2018 and 2019 residential list price of the package, $294, and one expert’s disputed estimate of the average price residential subscribers actually paid over the class period, $102.74.
So $191.26 was, in effect, a per-member number. It is also exactly the number the courts threw out. The jury had been instructed that the proper measure of damages was an overcharge: the difference between what subscribers actually paid and what they would have paid without the challenged agreements. The Ninth Circuit explained that the jury instead used the gap between a list price and a lower average price actually paid, which reflects a discount subscribers may have received, not an overcharge they suffered. The method also ignored what commercial subscribers paid, which on average was an order of magnitude higher than residential prices. That is why the panel held that the trial court was entitled to order a new damages trial. Anyone quoting $191.26 per subscriber, or a trebled total built on the first verdict, is quoting a calculation that no longer exists.
What remains is the evidence the next jury will hear. According to the opinion, the subscribers’ overcharge expert presented a “direct-to-consumer” model predicting that the package price would drop by 49.7% if just one more distributor were licensed, and he calculated that the exclusive arrangement cost residential class members $2.81 billion and commercial class members $670 million. Under an alternative model built on the subscribers’ “NFL Tax” theory, he estimated that the package price would have been 24.6% lower. These are one side’s estimates, now ruled admissible, not findings. The defense will be free to attack them again before a new jury, and that jury may accept them, reduce them or reject them.
Whatever number a new jury eventually finds would not be the end of the arithmetic. Section 4 of the Clayton Act, 15 U.S.C. § 15(a), provides that a person injured by an antitrust violation “shall recover threefold the damages by him sustained, and the cost of suit, including a reasonable attorney’s fee.” The same subsection lets the court add simple interest on actual damages for the period after the plaintiff’s pleading was served, but only on a prompt motion and only if the court finds the award just in the circumstances, based on factors the statute lists. Federal law therefore triples a damages verdict in an antitrust case, yet the tripled figure still has to survive post-trial motions and any appeal before it becomes collectible.
Even then, a class-wide total does not translate automatically into equal checks. The residential and commercial classes paid very different prices; the opinion notes that residential list prices ranged from $200 to nearly $400 per season, while commercial subscribers such as bars paid from thousands to more than one hundred thousand dollars per season depending on the size of the establishment. How a recovery is divided among subscribers who bought different numbers of seasons at different prices is decided later, under the court’s supervision. Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23(d)(1)(B) lets the court order notice to class members of any step in the action and of the proposed extent of the judgment. Until those steps happen, a per-person payout figure for this case is a guess, not a legal entitlement.
II. Who is in the class, and what has to happen before any money moves?
A. Who counts as a class member and what to do now
The Ninth Circuit describes the class period as running from June 2011 to February 2023, and its memorandum affirmed the certification of the damages classes. The court-approved notice in the case gives the exact definitions. The residential damages class covers all DirecTV residential subscribers who purchased NFL Sunday Ticket at any time between June 17, 2011 and February 7, 2023. The commercial damages class uses the same dates for DirecTV commercial subscribers, such as bars and restaurants. Two injunctive classes use the same definitions. According to the notice, the court certified the classes on February 7, 2023. If you bought the package through DirecTV in that window, you are probably a member of one of the classes; if you only watched games in a bar, or bought out-of-market games after February 7, 2023, you fall outside these definitions.
The notice also states that the deadline to exclude yourself from the damages classes passed on October 8, 2023. That date matters in two directions. A subscriber who asked to be excluded cannot request a payment if money is later awarded, but kept the right to bring a separate lawsuit. A subscriber who did nothing remains in the class and, as the notice explains, is bound by the outcome whether the judgment is for or against the defendants. Federal law builds this binding effect into every damages class: under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23(c)(2)(B) and (c)(3), the notice to a Rule 23(b)(3) class must explain how to request exclusion and the binding effect of a class judgment, and the judgment, favorable or not, must describe the members who received notice and did not opt out. There is no form to fill out today to “join” this lawsuit; membership follows from the class definition and from not having opted out.
Practical steps are modest but useful. Keep any DirecTV statements, emails or account records that show Sunday Ticket charges during the class period, together with the account number and the service address; for a bar or restaurant, keep the commercial account documents and invoices, because commercial prices varied with the size of the establishment. If you have moved since you subscribed, the notice website is the place to watch for updates, since the notice administrator states there that more information will be posted after all appeals are complete. Treat with caution anyone who asks for a fee to sign you up or promises a fixed amount per subscriber; nothing in the October 30 decision creates a claims process. The same distinction between a lawsuit and a payout comes up in other cases readers ask about, such as the questions we answered on whether there is a claim form or payout in the Dollar General price case, and the way a class is defined decides who can share in any recovery, as our guide on who is in an investor class action explains for securities cases.
Finally, keep the scope of the case in mind. The claims are federal antitrust claims under the Sherman Act and the Clayton Act, brought in federal court in California but on behalf of subscribers nationwide. State consumer laws, refund policies of the current distributor, or individual billing disputes are separate questions that this class case does not decide.
B. From appellate opinion to payment: rehearing, mandate, Supreme Court, retrial or settlement
An appellate opinion does not send a case back to the trial court the day it is filed. Under federal Federal Rule of Appellate Procedure 40(d)(1), in the December 1, 2025 edition we read, a petition for panel rehearing or rehearing en banc must be filed within 14 days after judgment is entered, unless an order or local rule shortens or extends that time; the longer 45-day period applies in a civil case only when the United States, a federal agency or a federal officer is a party. In this appeal the United States appeared as an amicus curiae. Rule 40 also says that rehearing en banc is not favored and ordinarily will be allowed only when a panel decision conflicts with other decisions or the case involves a question of exceptional importance. We could not read the appellate docket for this article, so we cannot confirm whether any petition was filed or whether the time was extended.
The next marker is the mandate, the formal order that returns jurisdiction to the trial court. Under the same Rule 41(b), the mandate must issue 7 days after the time to file a petition for rehearing expires, or 7 days after an order denying a timely petition, whichever is later, and it is effective when issued. Rule 41(d) lets a party move to stay the mandate while it seeks Supreme Court review, but only by showing that the petition would present a substantial question and that there is good cause; such a stay must not exceed 90 days unless extended for good cause or unless the court is told that a petition has been filed, in which case it continues until the Supreme Court disposes of it. On the Supreme Court side, Supreme Court Rule 13, in the rules effective March 16, 2026, makes a petition for certiorari timely if filed within 90 days after entry of the court of appeals’ judgment, runs that period from the denial of rehearing when a timely rehearing petition was filed, and lets a Justice extend the time by up to 60 days for good cause.
Once the mandate issues, the case returns to the Central District of California for the damages retrial that both courts have now ordered. Federal appeals courts give real weight to a jury’s antitrust findings when the evidence behind them is admissible, as another recent Ninth Circuit case shows. In Epic Games, Inc. v. Google LLC, No. 24-6256 (9th Cir. July 31, 2025), the Ninth Circuit affirmed a jury verdict that Google had unlawfully monopolized markets for Android app distribution and in-app billing, together with the three-year injunction the district court entered. The court held that the trial judge did not abuse his discretion in sending the claims to a jury or in framing the rule-of-reason instruction, and that the injunction was supported by the jury’s verdict and the court’s own findings. Epic shows how much weight a federal appeals court gives a jury’s antitrust findings once the evidence behind them is admissible, and the Sunday Ticket panel likewise restored the jury’s liability finding, so the retrial concerns only the amount of damages. The contrast is instructive: in Epic the remedy flowed from findings the appeals court left intact, while in the Sunday Ticket appeal the liability findings were restored but the damages calculation was not.
A damages retrial is not the only possible route to money. Parties to a certified class action can settle, but under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23(e) the claims of a certified class may be settled only with the court’s approval. The court must direct notice to the class members who would be bound, hold a hearing, and find the proposal fair, reasonable and adequate after considering, among other things, the effectiveness of the proposed method of distributing relief, including how class-member claims are processed, and the terms of any proposed attorney’s fee award. Rule 23(e)(4) adds that when a class was previously certified under Rule 23(b)(3), the court may refuse to approve a settlement unless it gives class members a new opportunity to request exclusion, and Rule 23(e)(5) lets any class member object. Nothing in the public record we read on November 22, 2026 indicates a settlement in this case; the point is that any per-person figure produced by a settlement would come with notice, a hearing and a court-approved distribution method, not from a headline.
The injunctive side of the case follows its own track. The memorandum disposition reinstated the Section 16 claims and asked the trial court to decide whether the injunctive classes still present a live controversy after the end of the NFL-DirecTV contract. That question affects future distribution practices, not past overcharges, and it does not produce individual payments. For a subscriber asking about money, the damages retrial, post-trial motions, any further appeal and any court-approved distribution plan are the steps to watch.
Conclusion
The October 30, 2026 appellate ruling is a real turn in the subscribers’ antitrust case: the jury’s liability verdict is back, and the expert evidence behind it has been held admissible. It is not a payout. The only per-member number in the record, $191.26, is the figure the courts rejected as a measure of damages, and a new jury must decide the amount before federal law triples it and before any court-approved plan divides it among residential and commercial class members who paid very different prices.
For a reader who bought the package through the satellite provider between June 17, 2011 and February 7, 2023, the useful checks are concrete: confirm that your purchases fall inside the class dates, remember that the exclusion deadline passed in October 2023, keep your billing records, and follow the court-approved notice for any claims process. Before any check can exist, the federal steps described above still have to run their course: a possible rehearing petition, the mandate, a possible Supreme Court petition, the damages retrial or a settlement approved after notice and a hearing.