On 19 October 2026, Air France flight AF99, travelling from Houston, Texas, to Paris-Charles de Gaulle, turned toward Ireland after the crew declared an emergency south of the Irish coast, and landed at Dublin Airport, where the aircraft was met by medical crews. According to the aviation press that tracked the flight, the Boeing 777-300ER had departed Houston the previous afternoon, the crew transmitted the general emergency signal after a passenger fell seriously ill, the aircraft touched down safely in Dublin, resumed its journey the same morning and reached Paris late morning. That much is the news of the day, reported in particular by AIRLIVE and by Dublin Live.
This article answers a different question, the one that decides whether any claim survives at all: how long do passengers of a diverted flight have to act? The answer is a trap for the unwary, because two clocks run side by side. Claims for the European Union’s fixed compensation follow French law and its five-year prescription extinctive (extinctive limitation period), while claims for individually assessed damages under the Montreal Convention die after two years. Confuse the two, wait for the wrong deadline, and the best claim on the merits becomes worthless. What follows explains which clock governs which claim after the AF99 Dublin diversion, when each clock starts, what actually stops it running, and the practical steps that keep every option open.
I. AF99 Dublin diversion: which time limit applies to your claim
The AF99 diversion produces two families of claims, and each family carries its own deadline. The first family is the European Union’s standardized protection: fixed compensation, refund or rerouting, and care while passengers wait. The second family is individually assessed damages for proven loss under the Montreal Convention of 28 May 1999. The two families overlap on the same flight but obey different limitation rules, and the French courts have settled the boundary in a case that also involved Air France.
A. EU flight compensation claims: the French five-year rule
Regulation (EC) No 261/2004 covers AF99 itself. Its scope provision states: “aux passagers au départ d’un aéroport situé dans un pays tiers et à destination d’un aéroport situé sur le territoire d’un État membre soumis aux dispositions du traité, à moins que ces passagers ne bénéficient de prestations ou d’une indemnisation et d’une assistance dans ce pays tiers, si le transporteur aérien effectif qui réalise le vol est un transporteur communautaire” (to passengers departing from an airport in a third country to an airport in a Member State, unless they received benefits or compensation and assistance in that third country, where the operating carrier is a Community carrier). That text is Article 3(1)(b) of Regulation (EC) No 261/2004. Houston is a third-country airport, Paris-Charles de Gaulle is in a Member State, and Air France is a Community carrier, so passengers who received nothing in the United States fall within the Regulation.
The amounts at stake are fixed by distance. Article 7(1) of the Regulation provides: “les passagers reçoivent une indemnisation dont le montant est fixé à: a) 250 euros pour tous les vols de 1500 kilomètres ou moins; b) 400 euros pour tous les vols intracommunautaires de plus de 1500 kilomètres et pour tous les autres vols de 1500 à 3500 kilomètres; c) 600 euros pour tous les vols qui ne relèvent pas des points a) ou b)” (passengers shall receive compensation amounting to: (a) 250 euros for flights of 1,500 kilometres or less; (b) 400 euros for intra-Community flights of more than 1,500 kilometres and all other flights between 1,500 and 3,500 kilometres; (c) 600 euros for all other flights). That is Article 7 of Regulation (EC) No 261/2004. Houston to Paris exceeds 3,500 kilometres, which places AF99 passengers in the 600-euro bracket where compensation is due at all.
Whether compensation is due at all after a medical diversion is a separate merits question, addressed below. The time-limit question was settled by the Court of Justice of the European Union and then by the French Cour de cassation. In its judgment of 22 November 2012 in Moré, case C-139/11, the Court of Justice held that the time limit for actions seeking the fixed indemnity under Articles 5 and 7 of Regulation No 261/2004 is determined by the national law of each Member State, because that indemnity sits outside the Warsaw and Montreal conventions. The French Cour de cassation applied that solution in a ruling that also concerned Air France: First Civil Chamber, 10 October 2019, appeal No 18-20.491. Passengers had claimed the Article 7 indemnity after arriving twenty-four hours late in Pointe-à-Pitre, and Air France argued that the two-year Convention limit barred the claim. The Court rejected the argument, holding that the claim under the European Regulation is autonomous and outside the Convention, and it approved the lower court for having “déduit, à bon droit, que la demande était soumise au délai de prescription quinquennale de l’article 2224 du code civil” (correctly deduced that the claim was subject to the five-year limitation period of Article 2224 of the Civil Code). That ruling is published on the official database at Cour de cassation, First Civil Chamber, 10 October 2019, No 18-20.491.
Article 2224 of the French Civil Code states: “Les actions personnelles ou mobilières se prescrivent par cinq ans à compter du jour où le titulaire d’un droit a connu ou aurait dû connaître les faits lui permettant de l’exercer” (Personal and movable actions are time-barred after five years from the day on which the holder of the right knew or ought to have known the facts enabling its exercise). That is Article 2224 of the Civil Code. For an AF99 passenger, the facts were known on the day of the diversion itself, 19 October 2026, so the five-year clock for the European fixed-compensation claim runs from that date. The practical consequence is generous but not infinite: a passenger who files nothing for five years loses the 600-euro claim entirely, while a passenger who mistakes this claim for a two-year Montreal claim may give up three years early for no reason.
B. Montreal Convention damages: the two-year guillotine
The second family of claims covers individually proven loss: the hotel night a passenger paid for in Paris and could not use, the business meeting missed, the wages lost, the baggage that went astray during the confusion at Dublin. These claims live under the Convention for the Unification of Certain Rules for International Carriage by Air, signed in Montreal on 28 May 1999, which French law incorporates directly. Article L.6421-3 of the French Transport Code provides: “La responsabilité du transporteur aérien titulaire d’une licence d’exploitation délivrée en application du règlement (CE) n° 1008/2008 du 24 septembre 2008 établissant des règles communes pour l’exploitation de services aériens dans la Communauté est soumise, en ce qui concerne le transport aérien de passagers et de leurs bagages, aux dispositions du règlement (CE) n° 889/2002 du 13 mai 2002 modifiant le règlement (CE) n° 2027/97 relatif à la responsabilité des transporteurs aériens en cas d’accident et aux stipulations de la convention pour l’unification de certaines règles relatives au transport aérien international signée à Montréal le 28 mai 1999” (The liability of an air carrier holding an operating licence issued under Regulation (EC) No 1008/2008 is governed, for the carriage of passengers and their baggage, by Regulation (EC) No 889/2002 and by the Convention signed at Montreal on 28 May 1999). That is Article L.6421-3 of the Transport Code.
Every airline selling tickets in the European Union must hand passengers a notice summarising these Convention rules, and the official notice states the deadline without ambiguity: “Toute action en dommages et intérêts doit être intentée dans les deux ans suivant la date d’arrivée de l’avion, ou suivant la date à laquelle l’avion aurait dû atterrir” (Any action for damages must be brought within two years of the date of arrival of the aircraft, or of the date on which the aircraft should have landed). That sentence is the annexed passenger notice to Regulation (EC) No 889/2002. Two features make this deadline harsher than the French five-year rule. First, two years is short: for AF99, which reached Paris on 19 October 2026, a Montreal damages action must be brought before the second anniversary of that arrival. Second, the starting point is fixed by the flight itself, not by the passenger’s knowledge: the date the aircraft arrived, or should have arrived. A passenger who discovers a consequential loss months later gains no extra time.
The two regimes can stack on the same passenger, and the Regulation organises their coexistence. Its Article 12(1) states: “Le présent règlement s’applique sans préjudice du droit d’un passager à une indemnisation complémentaire. L’indemnisation accordée en vertu du présent règlement peut être déduite d’une telle indemnisation” (This Regulation shall apply without prejudice to a passenger’s right to further compensation. The compensation granted under this Regulation may be deducted from such compensation). That is Article 12 of Regulation (EC) No 261/2004. In practice, an AF99 passenger may pursue the 600-euro fixed sum within five years and, separately, proven additional loss within two years, with the fixed sum deducted from the further award. But the converse error is fatal: invoking the generous five-year period for a Montreal damages claim, or the strict two-year period against a European fixed-compensation claim. The Cour de cassation drew the line expressly, recalling that the Court of Justice had ruled that “la prescription biennale fixée à l’article 29 de la convention de Varsovie et à l’article 35 de la convention de Montréal ne saurait être considérée comme s’appliquant aux actions introduites, en particulier, au titre de ces textes” (the two-year limitation set by Article 29 of the Warsaw Convention and Article 35 of the Montreal Convention cannot be regarded as applying to actions brought in particular under those provisions), citing Moré C-139/11 and Nelson C-581/10 and C-629/10. The same ruling is Cour de cassation, First Civil Chamber, 10 October 2019, No 18-20.491. Each claim must therefore be matched to its own clock before anything else.
II. How to stop the clock running out on an AF99 claim
Knowing the deadline is only half the battle. Limitation periods run in the background while passengers negotiate with the airline, and French law recognises only a closed list of events that stop them. A polite exchange of emails with customer service is not on that list. This second part states when each clock starts, what genuinely interrupts it, and the file an AF99 passenger should assemble now.
A. When time starts running and why an email to the airline is not enough
For the European fixed-compensation claim, Article 2224 starts the five years on the day the passenger knew or ought to have known the facts. A diverted passenger knows everything material on arrival day: the flight number, the diversion to Dublin, the late arrival in Paris. For AF99, that day is 19 October 2026, so the five-year period expires five years later, and a prudent passenger treats the anniversary as an absolute backstop rather than a target. For a Montreal damages claim, the notice quoted above fixes the start objectively: the date the aircraft arrived, or should have arrived, with AF99 arriving in Paris on 19 October 2026 and the two-year guillotine falling on the second anniversary.
Between the start and the expiry, French law allows only three kinds of interruption, and each must be proved. First, the carrier’s own acknowledgment: “La reconnaissance par le débiteur du droit de celui contre lequel il prescrivait interrompt le délai de prescription” (Acknowledgment by the debtor of the right of the person against whom the limitation period was running interrupts the period). That is Article 2240 of the Civil Code. A letter in which the airline admits it owes compensation therefore restarts the clock, which is why any admission should be kept in writing. Second, legal proceedings: “La demande en justice, même en référé, interrompt le délai de prescription ainsi que le délai de forclusion. Il en est de même lorsqu’elle est portée devant une juridiction incompétente ou lorsque l’acte de saisine de la juridiction est annulé par l’effet d’un vice de procédure” (A claim brought before a court, even in summary proceedings, interrupts the limitation period as well as the time limit for bringing proceedings. The same applies where the claim is brought before a court lacking jurisdiction or where the initiating document is annulled for a procedural defect). That is Article 2241 of the Civil Code. Even a filing before the wrong court preserves the claim. Third, enforcement: “Le délai de prescription ou le délai de forclusion est également interrompu par une mesure conservatoire prise en application du code des procédures civiles d’exécution ou un acte d’exécution forcée” (The limitation period is also interrupted by a protective measure taken under the enforcement-proceedings code or by an act of forced enforcement). That is Article 2244 of the Civil Code.
A complaint email to the airline is none of those three. It is not an acknowledgment by the carrier, it is not a court filing, and it is not an enforcement measure. Months of correspondence in which the airline repeats that the file is “under review” change nothing to either clock, and a passenger who waits for customer service to finish its review can wake up time-barred on both fronts. The rule is brutal but clear: negotiate if you wish, but file in court before the anniversary if the airline has not paid or has not acknowledged the debt in writing. For Montreal claims the trap is even tighter, because the Convention’s two-year period is consistently treated as extinguishing the action itself rather than merely barring the remedy, so courts apply it strictly and from the flight date.
B. AF99 claim checklist: papers, proof and filing before the deadline
The first item on the checklist is proof that the passenger was on the flight at all. The Regulation protects only passengers with a confirmed reservation who present for check-in, and the Cour de cassation enforces that condition strictly. In the same 10 October 2019 Air France ruling, the Court quashed the lower decision on the fixed-compensation award precisely because the judges had relied on a barely legible electronic ticket and a boarding pass for the rerouted flight, holding that these reasons were “impropres à établir que les consorts A…-F… s’étaient présentés dans les délais impartis à l’enregistrement du vol initialement programmé” (unsuitable to establish that the passengers had presented within the prescribed time for check-in of the originally scheduled flight). The lesson for AF99 passengers is concrete: keep the booking confirmation for the Houston to Paris flight, the original boarding pass, any rerouting boarding pass issued at Dublin, and every receipt for money spent while stranded. Screenshots of the airline application showing the diversion, photographs of departure boards, and the names of staff who gave information all help years later, when memories fade and the airline’s records are harder to obtain. French procedure places that burden squarely on the claimant: “Celui qui réclame l’exécution d’une obligation doit la prouver. Réciproquement, celui qui se prétend libéré doit justifier le paiement ou le fait qui a produit l’extinction de son obligation” (A person who demands performance of an obligation must prove it. Conversely, a person who claims to be discharged must prove payment or the fact that extinguished the obligation). That is Article 1353 of the Civil Code, mirrored in procedure by the rule that “Il incombe à chaque partie de prouver conformément à la loi les faits nécessaires au succès de sa prétention” (Each party must prove, in accordance with the law, the facts necessary to the success of its claim), Article 9 of the Code of Civil Procedure. Digital documents should be backed up outside the airline’s application, because access to a booking reference can disappear once the file is closed.
The second item is a written claim sent early, drafted with both clocks in mind. The letter should identify the flight, the date, the booking reference, the delay on arrival in Paris, and the exact sums sought: the fixed compensation under Article 7 of Regulation (EC) No 261/2004, reimbursement of out-of-pocket care expenses, and, where relevant, individually assessed loss under the Montreal Convention. Sending it early costs nothing and starts the paper trail, but as explained above it does not interrupt either limitation period, so the letter should also request an explicit written acknowledgment of the debt, which would trigger Article 2240. If the airline pays the fixed sum, keep the proof of payment: under Article 12 it will be deducted from any further Convention award, and double recovery is excluded.
The third item is an honest assessment of the extraordinary-circumstances defence, because it determines whether the fixed-compensation claim is worth pursuing to court. The Regulation exempts the carrier where it proves the cancellation was caused by extraordinary circumstances unavoidable even with all reasonable measures: “Un transporteur aérien effectif n’est pas tenu de verser l’indemnisation prévue à l’article 7 s’il est en mesure de prouver que l’annulation est due à des circonstances extraordinaires qui n’auraient pas pu être évitées même si toutes les mesures raisonnables avaient été prises” (An operating carrier shall not be obliged to pay compensation under Article 7 if it can prove that the cancellation was caused by extraordinary circumstances which could not have been avoided even if all reasonable measures had been taken). That is Article 5(3) of Regulation (EC) No 261/2004. The Regulation itself frames the defence around safety: “Tout comme dans le cadre de la convention de Montréal, les obligations des transporteurs aériens effectifs devraient être limitées ou leur responsabilité exonérée dans les cas où un événement est dû à des circonstances extraordinaires qui n’auraient pas pu être évitées même si toutes les mesures raisonnables avaient été prises. De telles circonstances peuvent se produire, en particulier, en cas d’instabilité politique, de conditions météorologiques incompatibles avec la réalisation du vol concerné, de risques liés à la sécurité, de défaillances imprévues pouvant affecter la sécurité du vol, ainsi que de grèves ayant une incidence sur les opérations d’un transporteur aérien effectif” (Just as under the Montreal Convention, the obligations of operating carriers should be limited or carriers exonerated where an event was caused by extraordinary circumstances which could not have been avoided even if all reasonable measures had been taken. Such circumstances may occur in particular in cases of political instability, weather incompatible with the flight, security risks, unexpected flight-safety shortcomings, and strikes affecting the carrier’s operations). That is recital 14 of Regulation (EC) No 261/2004. A passenger falling seriously ill mid-flight, forcing a 7700 emergency diversion to the nearest suitable airport, sits far from the carrier’s normal operations and entirely outside its control, so Air France would be well placed to invoke the defence for AF99, and no court has yet ruled on these exact facts. That uncertainty affects only the fixed sum. The rights to care and to refund or rerouting are unconditional: Article 9 requires meals, hotel accommodation where an overnight stay becomes necessary, transport between airport and hotel, and communication facilities, free of charge, under Article 9 of Regulation (EC) No 261/2004, while Article 8 offers the choice between ticket refund within seven days, rerouting at the earliest opportunity, or rerouting at a later date at the passenger’s convenience, under Article 8 of Regulation (EC) No 261/2004. The broader landscape of delay and cancellation rights is mapped in our guide to delayed, cancelled and overbooked flights, which AF99 passengers can use alongside this deadline-focused analysis.
The fourth item is the calendar. Count five years from 19 October 2026 for the European fixed-compensation and care-reimbursement claims, and two years from the Paris arrival for any Montreal Convention damages claim, then work backwards: set a personal deadline at least six months earlier to allow for a final formal demand and, if needed, filing before the court. Court filing is the only unilateral act that is certain to interrupt the period under Article 2241, and it remains effective even before a court that turns out to lack jurisdiction. Passengers who live outside France should also check how a French judgment would be enforced where they live before spending money on proceedings, and passengers who travelled on duty should inform their employer promptly, since business losses claimed through the employer follow the same two-year Convention clock.
Conclusion
The AF99 diversion to Dublin was a textbook medical emergency: a Houston to Paris flight, a seriously ill passenger, a 7700 squawk, a safe landing in Dublin and an arrival in Paris the same morning. The law that follows is less dramatic but more decisive. European fixed-compensation claims live for five years under Article 2224 of the Civil Code, as the Cour de cassation confirmed against Air France itself on 10 October 2019. Montreal Convention damages claims die after two years from arrival, as the official passenger notice states. Only a written acknowledgment by the carrier, a court filing, or an enforcement measure stops either clock; correspondence alone stops nothing. Passengers who keep their travel documents, claim in writing now, assess the extraordinary-circumstances defence honestly, and diary both anniversaries preserve every right the diversion gave them. Those who wait for the airline to finish reviewing their file may discover, two or five years later, that time has decided the case instead of the judge.