KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
How Americans Become French Citizens by Naturalization Decree: the Five-Year Residence Rule, the Language Interview, and the Appeals That Save Refused Files

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

How Americans Become French Citizens by Naturalization Decree: the Five-Year Residence Rule, the Language Interview, and the Appeals That Save Refused Files

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

You have lived in France for years. You pay French taxes, your children go to a French school, your daily life runs in French, and every time you land at Charles de Gaulle you queue in the line for foreign passports while your neighbors walk through the European line. At some point the question stops being romantic and becomes practical: can an American actually become French, keep the American passport, vote, stop renewing residence permits, and pass something on to the children? The answer is yes, through a procedure called naturalisation par décret, naturalization by decree: the French government grants you citizenship by an individual decree signed at the highest level of the state, after the administration checks where you really live, how you earn your living, how you speak French, and whether your record is clean. It is not automatic, it is not fast, and the administration says no far more often than applicants expect. This guide explains the rules as written in the Civil Code, what two real court decisions teach about residence abroad and the language interview, how a 2025 ruling of the Conseil d’Etat shows that hiding one fact can cost you citizenship even after the decree is signed, and how refusals are challenged before the administrative court in Nantes. If your situation is different, if your father or mother was French, read first our companion guide on proving French citizenship by descent through a French parent or grandparent, which follows a separate track and does not require five years in France.

I. Can an American living in France qualify for citizenship by decree?

A. Do you meet the five-year residence rule and its exceptions?

The starting point is a single sentence of the Civil Code: “Hors le cas prévu à l’article 21-14-1, l’acquisition de la nationalité française par décision de l’autorité publique résulte d’une naturalisation accordée par décret à la demande de l’étranger.” Everything flows from that sentence: citizenship by decree is a favor of the state granted on request, never a right earned automatically by the calendar. Two companion provisions set the residence test, and both must be satisfied. First, “Sous réserve des exceptions prévues aux articles 21-18, 21-19 et 21-20, la naturalisation ne peut être accordée qu’à l’étranger justifiant d’une résidence habituelle en France pendant les cinq années qui précèdent le dépôt de la demande.” Five years of habitual residence before filing is the default, the stage, and the administration counts real life, not papers: leases, tax notices, school enrollment, and above all physical presence. Second, “Nul ne peut être naturalisé s’il n’a en France sa résidence au moment de la signature du décret de naturalisation.” Even a perfect five-year record fails if you have moved away when the decree is signed, so Americans on international careers should not file and then accept a three-year posting abroad while the file sleeps in a drawer.

The five-year stage is not absolute, and several exceptions matter precisely to Americans. The training period is cut from five years to two for a foreigner who has successfully completed two years of higher education leading to a degree issued by a French university or higher-education institution, for a person who has rendered or can render important services to France through ability and talent, and for a foreigner with an exceptional integration record judged on civic, scientific, economic, cultural, or sporting activity. In plain terms, an American who earns a French master’s degree, or a researcher, founder, or artist whose work demonstrably serves France, can file after two years instead of five, with the link to the statute kept next to the file as the legal basis. A narrower door opens even wider: certain foreigners can be naturalized with no training period at all, including a foreigner who has actually served in a unit of the French army or volunteered in French or allied forces in wartime, a person who has rendered exceptional services to France or whose naturalization presents an exceptional interest for France, decided only after a reasoned opinion of the Conseil d’Etat, and a person recognized as a refugee. These are rare paths, and the refugee path follows its own asylum logic, but American veterans of the French Foreign Legion and Americans decorated for service to France should know the door exists.

For mobile Americans, the most litigated provision is the one that treats some time abroad as time in France. The statute treats as French residence the stay abroad of a foreigner who works, publicly or privately, for the French state or for an organization whose activity presents a particular interest for the economy or French culture, alongside stays in customs-union countries designated by decree, service in a French military unit, and national-service volunteering. Read carefully, because a court decision shows how narrow this shelter is. In a 2023 ruling, the administrative court of appeal of Nantes rejected a man who had grown up and studied in France, earned an engineering diploma and a graduate degree there, then worked from 2014 in Mozambique and South Africa for a United Nations AIDS program, arguing that his public-health research served French interests given migration flows toward Europe. The court answered that his argument “ne suffit pas à le faire regarder comme exerçant une activité professionnelle auprès d’un organisme qui présente un intérêt particulier pour l’économie ou la culture française, au sens des dispositions du 1° de l’article 21-26 du code civil, alors même que la France est membre de cette organisation internationale.” Working for an international organization headquartered or active in France is not enough on its own; the job itself must serve the French economy or French culture in particular. An American posted abroad by a French ministry, a French public agency, or a company genuinely driving French economic or cultural interests stands on firmer ground than an American working for a global body whose connection to France is membership alone. Keep every assignment letter, every proof of who directed the work and for whose account, because the administration reads the employment relationship, not the letterhead.

B. How do you prove assimilation: French language, values, and clean record?

Residence gets you through the door; assimilation decides whether you stay in the room. “Nul ne peut être naturalisé s’il ne justifie de son assimilation à la communauté française, notamment par une connaissance suffisante, selon sa condition, de la langue, de l’histoire, de la culture et de la société françaises, dont le niveau et les modalités d’évaluation sont fixés par décret en Conseil d’Etat, et des droits et devoirs conférés par la nationalité française ainsi que par l’adhésion aux principes et aux valeurs essentiels de la République.” Three ideas sit inside that sentence, and each is tested separately. Language first: the statute sets the principle and sends the level to a decree, so check the current official guidance before filing, because only the decree in force on your file counts. To see how courts apply it, read what the Nantes court recalled when it upheld a refusal: “Pour l’application de l’article 21-24 du code civil: 1° Tout demandeur doit justifier d’une connaissance de la langue française caractérisée par la compréhension des points essentiels du langage nécessaire à la gestion de la vie quotidienne et aux situations de la vie courante ainsi que par la capacité à émettre un discours simple et cohérent sur des sujets familiers dans ses domaines d’intérêt. Son niveau est celui défini par le niveau B1, rubriques ‘écouter’, ‘prendre part à une conversation’ et ‘s’exprimer oralement en continu’ du Cadre européen commun de référence pour les langues.” That case, decided in 2020, concerned a Syrian-born applicant whose prefecture interview showed she could not follow an ordinary conversation or talk about familiar subjects, and the court confirmed the refusal. The lesson for Americans is blunt: the interview is a real examination, graded on a grid, not a friendly chat. Prepare to understand questions about your family life, your work, and your daily affairs, and to answer in coherent French; bring proof of courses and diplomas, but know that paper alone does not survive a failed interview. Practice out loud, with a person, under mild pressure, because that is the format.

Values come second, and they are tested at the same interview. The statute requires adherence to the essential principles and values of the Republic, and at the end of the assimilation check the applicant signs the charter of the rights and duties of the French citizen, which restates those principles, values, and symbols. The prefecture interview reviews your knowledge of French history, culture, and society, the rights and duties of citizenship, and your visible attachment to republican principles. The official service-public guide describes this sequence: a civic examination plus the prefecture interview to verify assimilation, proof of language knowledge, and professional integration as an essential condition, meaning you must show stable means of living in France. Read that guide before anything else at the official English-language naturalization page of service-public.gouv.fr, which walks through each step and the documents to bring in original. Third comes character. “Nul ne peut être naturalisé s’il n’est pas de bonnes vie et moeurs ou s’il a fait l’objet de l’une des condamnations visées à l’article 21-27 du présent code.” And the referenced provision bars anyone convicted of crimes against the fundamental interests of the Nation or terrorism, anyone sentenced to six months or more of unsuspended imprisonment for any offense, anyone under a live expulsion order or an unexecuted ban from French territory, and anyone whose stay in France is irregular. An American with a stateside conviction should never assume it is invisible: foreign convictions may be set aside only by a decision taken with the conforming opinion of the Conseil d’Etat, so disclose, document rehabilitation or expungement, and take advice before filing rather than after a refusal. Polygamy, forced marriage in the household, or a demonstrated rejection of republican values can also sink a file on the values ground even with a clean criminal record, which is why the interview preparation must cover how you live, not only how you conjugate.

II. How does an American file, fight a refusal, and keep both passports?

A. What happens after filing at the prefecture, and how do you challenge a refusal or adjournment?

Filing starts where you live: the prefecture of your home department receives the file, checks completeness, runs inquiries with police and tax authorities, and summons you to the assimilation interview described above. If the file is incomplete you get a request for more papers; if the conditions are not met the prefect can declare the request inadmissible or propose refusal or adjournment, and the minister of the interior decides. Three outcomes matter. Inadmissibility means a legal condition is missing on its face, for example residence too short. Rejection means the administration says no on the merits. Adjournment, the ajournement, means not now: typically two more years to stabilize work, resources, or language before reapplying. Do not treat an adjournment as a mere delay to wait out passively; use the period to build the exact evidence the decision says is missing, pay stubs, tax notices, language certificates, proof of presence, because the next examiner will read the old file first. And never try to fix a weak file with a convenient omission, because the price of dishonesty is withdrawal after the fact. On March 13, 2025, the Conseil d’Etat upheld the withdrawal of a naturalization decree granted in November 2021 after discovering that the new citizen, who had declared himself divorced and childless, had in fact married in Algeria during the examination of his file and said nothing. The court recalled that “Les décrets portant acquisition, naturalisation ou réintégration peuvent être rapportés sur avis conforme du Conseil d’Etat dans le délai de deux ans à compter de leur publication au Journal officiel si le requérant ne satisfait pas aux conditions légales; si la décision a été obtenue par mensonge ou fraude, ces décrets peuvent être rapportés dans le délai de deux ans à partir de la découverte de la fraude.” Then it drew the consequences: a concealed marriage during the procedure should have been disclosed, the silence counted as a deliberate concealment of the family situation, and the two-year clock for fraud runs from the day the minister actually learns the truth, so the 2024 withdrawal decree was in time. The same ruling confirms the residence test as the court applies it: “la demande de naturalisation n’est pas recevable lorsque l’intéressé n’a pas fixé en France de manière durable le centre de ses intérêts,” assessed notably on personal and family ties in France at the date of the decree, and a marriage kept quiet “doit être regardé comme ayant volontairement dissimulé sa situation familiale.” For Americans, the practical message is direct: report every marriage, divorce, birth, move, and new resource the moment it happens while the file is pending, in writing, with proof of sending, because the administration treats silence as fraud and fraud revives a two-year withdrawal window from discovery.

A refusal is not the end of the road; it is the start of a mapped appeal. French procedure requires a mandatory preliminary review by the minister before any court action, and the minister’s decision replaces the prefect’s: as the Nantes court put it, “les décisions par lesquelles le ministre statue sur les recours préalables obligatoires se substituent à celles des autorités préfectorales qui lui sont déférées.” Only then does the case go to court, and naturalization litigation goes to one court for the whole country, the administrative tribunal of Nantes, with appeal to the Nantes court of appeal and, on points of law, to the Conseil d’Etat. Judges review legal error, factual accuracy, and manifest error of assessment, which is how the residence and language cases quoted in this guide were won or lost by the administration. Build the appeal like a second application: attack each ground separately, attach what was missing, and add what postdates the refusal, because the court judges the administration on the file it had, and a thin record produces a short judgment. Americans in Paris face one local reality worth knowing: the Paris prefecture of police handles high volumes and interviews are scheduled strictly, so answer summons fast, arrive with originals of everything listed on the notice, and keep copies of every receipt. If your file also touches French tax residence, for example because the administration doubts the durability of your establishment while you keep a house and income in the United States, our analysis of when an American becomes a French tax resident and how the treaty tie-breaker works helps you align the immigration story with the tax story before either examiner reads them separately.

B. Do you lose U.S. citizenship, what happens to your children, and what changes on day one?

Start with the fear that stops many Americans from filing: naturalizing French does not strip you of American citizenship. France permits dual nationality without asking you to renounce anything, and the United States does not punish the acquisition. The State Department states the American side plainly: “U.S. law does not impede its citizens’ acquisition of foreign citizenship whether by birth, descent, naturalization or other form of acquisition, by imposing requirements of permission from U.S. courts or any governmental agency.” You will be a dual citizen, owing allegiance to two countries at once, traveling on the American passport to enter the United States and on the French document inside Europe. One caution survives the good news: Washington keeps taxing its citizens wherever they live, so becoming French changes your French life far more than your IRS life. Keep filing U.S. returns, keep reporting French accounts, and read the IRS guidance for citizens living abroad alongside the French-American tax treaty before assuming the French decree simplifies anything American. The decree is published in the Journal officiel, the official gazette where French laws and individual naturalization decrees appear, and from that date “La personne qui a acquis la nationalité française jouit de tous les droits et est tenue à toutes les obligations attachées à la qualité de Français, à dater du jour de cette acquisition.” Voting, consular protection as a French citizen, public-sector jobs reserved to nationals, and an end to residence-permit renewals all start that day, as do the duties, including tax and civic obligations.

Children deserve a paragraph of their own, because the statute gives them a powerful attached benefit and one trap. “L’enfant mineur dont l’un des deux parents acquiert la nationalité française, devient français de plein droit s’il a la même résidence habituelle que ce parent ou s’il réside alternativement avec ce parent dans le cas de séparation ou divorce.” A minor child who shares your habitual residence, or lives alternately with you after separation or divorce, becomes French automatically with you, what lawyers call the collective effect, the effet collectif. But the second sentence of the same provision is a guillotine: “Les dispositions du présent article ne sont applicables à l’enfant d’une personne qui acquiert la nationalité française par décision de l’autorité publique ou par déclaration de nationalité que si son nom est mentionné dans le décret ou dans la déclaration.” If the child’s name is not written into the decree, the collective effect does not operate, and families discover the omission years later when the child applies for a French identity card. When you file, list every minor child, attach every birth certificate with translation and apostille, verify the draft decree when it is notified, and ask for correction immediately if a name is missing or misspelled. Day one also brings two practical files Americans forget: first, have your French civil status drawn up or transcribed so the acte de naissance, the French birth record created for the new citizen, matches your American documents letter for letter, because one inconsistent first name will haunt every later application; second, update banks, employer, health insurance, and voter rolls, since the residence permit you surrendered no longer proves anything and the decree plus the new documents prove everything.

Conclusion

An American becomes French by decree by proving three things together: a durable life in France that satisfies the five-year rule or one of its written exceptions, an assimilation shown in real French at the interview and a visible attachment to republican values, and a clean record with a file that hides nothing. The court decisions in this guide draw the boundaries: time abroad counts only when the work genuinely serves France, the language test is graded and failed in practice, family events concealed during the procedure can unwind a signed decree within two years of discovery, and every refusal can be reviewed first by the minister then by the court in Nantes. Prepare the file the way the judges read it, disclose everything the moment it happens, name every child, and check the decree the day it arrives. Citizenship by decree rewards the applicants who treat it as a legal proceeding from the first form, not as an administrative formality, and that preparation is what turns five years of French life into a French passport kept alongside the American one.

📄 Official circular