KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
An American Bought a French House Through an SCI: What the Company Changes for Taxes, Sale, and Passing It to Your Kids

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

An American Bought a French House Through an SCI: What the Company Changes for Taxes, Sale, and Passing It to Your Kids

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

You are an American buying a house in France, and someone in the process, often the real estate agent or the notaire, suggests that you buy through an SCI. The letters stand for société civile immobilière, a French non-trading property company, and the suggestion usually comes with a confident promise: it will make shared ownership easier, it will simplify passing the house to your children, and it may even save tax. Some of that is true, and some of it is dangerously incomplete. An SCI is a flexible and widely used vehicle for holding French residential property, and for American buyers who purchase as a couple, with siblings, or with an eye on the next generation, it can be the right tool. But it does not shield you from liability the way an American limited liability company does, it does not make French tax disappear, and it adds a full layer of American reporting that many buyers discover too late. This guide explains, in plain English and with the exact French legal texts, how an SCI works from the day you sign, how France and the United States each tax it while you own and when you sell, and how shares in the company pass to your heirs.

I. Buying and Owning a French Home Through an SCI: How It Works for an American

A. Setting Up the Company and Putting the House Inside It

Under French law, a company starts with a simple statutory definition. Article 1832 of the Civil Code states that “La société est instituée par deux ou plusieurs personnes qui conviennent par un contrat d’affecter à une entreprise commune des biens ou leur industrie en vue de partager le bénéfice ou de profiter de l’économie qui pourra en résulter.” In other words, two or more persons agree by contract to put property or effort into a shared enterprise. The SCI is the civil, non-commercial version of that idea: Article 1832 of the Civil Code creates the general company, and Article 1845 of the Civil Code confirms the civil character of the vehicle, since “Ont le caractère civil toutes les sociétés auxquelles la loi n’attribue pas un autre caractère à raison de leur forme, de leur nature, ou de leur objet.” A company whose object is owning and managing residential property, without a commercial trade, is civil by nature, and that is exactly the SCI described for the public by the official business portal at service-public.fr: Société civile immobilière, ce qu’il faut savoir.

The first practical consequence for an American buyer is that an SCI needs at least two partners. There is no such thing as a one-person SCI. A single buyer who wants the structure must bring in a second partner, very often a spouse, an adult child, or a trusted relative, even with a token shareholding. Each partner receives parts sociales, company shares, in proportion to what they contribute, and the same statute adds that “Les associés s’engagent à contribuer aux pertes”, meaning every partner commits to contributing to losses. Keep that sentence in mind, because it already hints at the liability discussion below.

Formation follows a standard sequence that your notaire or attorney coordinates. The partners sign written statutes, called statuts, which name the company, fix its registered office or siège social, state its object, set the capital, and appoint the manager, called the gérant. There is no statutory minimum capital, and family SCIs are routinely formed with a modest cash amount, but the capital must reflect reality: if the partners plan to borrow, banks look at the equity behind the company, and contributions can be cash, called apports en numéraire, or property in kind, called apports en nature. The formation is published in a legal notices newspaper, called a journal d’annonces légales, and the company is registered with the companies register through the single formalities window, after which it receives its SIREN identification number. Only once registered does the SCI legally exist and become able to buy. The purchase deed itself, signed before the notaire, then names the SCI as the buyer, the price is paid from the company bank account, and ownership is recorded in the name of the company, not in your personal name. You own shares in the owner, not the walls directly.

For a buyer signing from the United States, three practical points deserve attention. First, French banks lend to SCIs every day, but the loan file is heavier than for an individual: the bank reads the statutes, checks the partners, and usually asks each partner to guarantee the loan personally, which partly offsets the separation you thought the company gave you. Second, if you cannot attend the signing, you sign a power of attorney, called a procuration, so the notaire can sign for you; under the current practice the procuration for a purchase deed is prepared by the notaire and signed in advance, and foreign buyers arrange it through the notaire before the closing date. Third, budget the full closing picture before you commit: the price, the notaire closing bill with its registration and land-publicity taxes, the formation costs of the SCI itself, and the foreign-exchange timing of your dollar transfer. The closing-bill mechanics are explained in detail in our walkthrough of what an American pays the notaire when buying a French house and what each line of the bill covers, and the same lines apply when the buyer named on the deed is your SCI. None of this is prohibitive, and purchases through SCIs close every week, but every step must be sequenced before the deed date: an unregistered SCI cannot buy, an unfunded SCI cannot pay, and a bank that discovers the structure late can delay the closing.

One common alternative is worth naming so you can compare honestly. An American couple buying a French home together sometimes uses a tontine clause instead of, or inside, a company structure, so that the surviving partner takes the property under specific tax conditions, a mechanism detailed in our guide to how American couples buy a French house with a tontine and what it costs in tax. The tontine protects the survivor, while the SCI organizes shared ownership and gradual gifts; the two tools answer different questions, and some families combine them after advice.

B. Running the Company, and What It Does Not Protect You From

Once the house belongs to the SCI, daily life is deliberately quiet, but it is corporate life. The gérant manages the property, pays the bills from the company account, collects any rent into that same account, and convenes the partners at least once a year for the annual meeting, called the assemblée générale, with written minutes, called a procès-verbal. Keep a clean separation: company money in the company account, personal money outside it, every contribution and every distribution documented. A default SCI that simply holds the family second home has light bookkeeping, but the records must exist, because the bank, the tax office, and one day the heir or the buyer will ask for them. If the SCI rents the property out, the rental accounts must be complete and consistent with the tax returns, and if the SCI elected for corporate tax, full annual accounts are required.

Now the warning that matters most. An SCI is not an American LLC, and it does not cap your liability. Article 1857 of the Civil Code provides that “A l’égard des tiers, les associés répondent indéfiniment des dettes sociales à proportion de leur part dans le capital social à la date de l’exigibilité ou au jour de la cessation des paiements.” Partners answer indefinitely for company debts, each in proportion to their share of the capital. If the SCI defaults on its mortgage, cannot pay a contractor who renovated the roof, or owes a large tax bill, creditors who have unsuccessfully pursued the company can turn to the partners personally, without any ceiling, divided according to their holdings. A partner who holds ninety percent of the shares bears ninety percent of the exposure. This is the opposite of the limited-liability intuition many Americans bring from Delaware or Wyoming entities, and it must be understood before you sign the statutes, not after a dispute arises. Lenders know this perfectly well, which is why they routinely ask partners for personal guarantees on top: the guarantee is a contractual choice, while the indefinite liability of article 1857 is the statutory background that applies whether or not you thought about it.

The second limit concerns what the SCI is allowed to do. A civil company must stay civil. Renting a home unfurnished under a standard residential lease is civil management of property and fits the SCI perfectly. Renting furnished, running a bed-and-breakfast style operation, or holding short-term guests through platforms is treated as a commercial activity, and a civil company that persistently earns commercial income can be pushed out of its default tax regime into corporate tax, with accounting and tax consequences that apply retroactively to the whole structure. The boundary between civil and commercial use is therefore not decorating advice, it is structural: decide before you buy whether the house will ever be rented furnished, tell the drafter of the statutes, and draft the object clause accordingly. Families who plan to rent a Paris apartment furnished or to operate seasonal rentals should get targeted advice on the vehicle before rather than after the first guest arrives, because unwinding the wrong structure costs a multiple of choosing correctly.

The third limit is control over who comes in. Shares in an SCI do not circulate like shares in a listed company. Article 1861 of the Civil Code states that “Les parts sociales ne peuvent être cédées qu’avec l’agrément de tous les associés.” Transfers require the approval, called agrément, of all the partners by default, although the statutes may set a different majority or empower the gérant to grant it, and may waive approval for transfers between existing partners. In practice this means a partner who wants to sell to an outsider, or who divorces and must transfer shares, or whose creditors seize shares, faces a consent gate held by the other partners. That gate is a feature for families who want to keep the house among themselves, and a trap for anyone who assumed shares could be sold freely. Draft the agrément clause, the pre-emption rights, and the valuation method in the statutes on day one, while everyone gets along, because article 1861 will still be there when they do not.

II. Paying Tax, Selling, and Passing the House to Your Kids When an American Owns SCI Shares

A. How France Taxes the Company Each Year and at Sale, and How America Taxes You Again

The default French tax treatment of an SCI is transparency, and the mechanism sits in the Tax Code. Article 1655 ter of the General Tax Code provides that the relevant property companies “sont réputées, quelle que soit leur forme juridique, ne pas avoir de personnalité distincte de celle de leurs membres pour l’application des impôts directs”, meaning they are deemed to have no personality separate from their members for direct taxes. Concretely, the SCI itself does not pay income tax; each partner is taxed personally on their share of the company rental result, at their own rate, as if they had received the rent directly. An American partner who lives in France reports that share on the French income return; an American partner who lives in the United States is taxable in France on that French-source rental income, because Article 164 B of the General Tax Code treats as French-source income “Les revenus d’immeubles sis en France ou de droits relatifs à ces immeubles”, which covers both the building and the rights attached to it, including shares that represent it. The company is invisible for the income computation, but the income itself is unmistakably French and taxable in France first.

The SCI may instead elect for corporate tax, called impôt sur les sociétés, and the election changes everything downstream. Under the election, the company pays tax on its own profit, can deduct depreciation, called amortissements, on the building, carries its own losses, and the partners are taxed only when the company distributes dividends or when they sell their shares. For a family holding its own vacation home with no rental income, the election is usually pointless and sometimes costly, because depreciation of a home nobody rents produces little benefit while the later sale of the shares loses the private real-estate gain regime. For a rental strategy with heavy renovation works, leverage, and a long horizon, the election can smooth taxation and organize reinvestment inside the company. The election is a strategic fork with long-term effects on distributions, sale, and succession, so it should be modeled in numbers with an accountant before the statutes are signed, not discovered in the year of sale.

At sale, two French regimes compete, and which one applies depends on what is sold and which tax option the SCI carries. If the SCI is transparent and sells the building itself, the company computes a private property gain under Article 150 U of the General Tax Code, the partners are each taxed on their share, and the gain benefits from the taper relief for holding period, called abattements pour durée de détention, which progressively erases the taxable gain the longer the property has been held, until full exemption after a long ownership. If instead a partner sells their shares in a transparent property-rich SCI, the gain is also analyzed under the real-estate gain logic, because the shares represent the building. But if the SCI elected for corporate tax, the partner who sells shares sells securities, taxed under the securities regime rather than the real-estate taper, which can be dramatically more expensive for a property held for decades. And in every configuration where the seller lives in America, Article 244 bis A of the General Tax Code applies by its own opening words, “Sous réserve des conventions internationales”, meaning the nonresident levy on French real-estate gains operates subject to tax treaties, with the treaty then deciding whether France keeps a taxing right and how the United States credits it. Nonresident sellers should therefore expect a French levy collected through the notaire or the tax office at closing, plus the American return the following April, and should never assume that paying in one country excuses filing in the other.

The treaty layer is what prevents the same euro of rent or gain from being fully taxed twice. Under the 1994 France-United States income tax treaty as amended, income from real property situated in France, including income flowing through a transparent French property company, may be taxed in France, and the United States, which taxes its citizens on worldwide income wherever they live, then grants a foreign tax credit against the American tax on the same income. Rents, transparent SCI results, and gains on French real estate or on shares that derive their value principally from French real estate follow this pattern: France first under its domestic rules, America second with a credit for the French tax, documented on the American foreign-tax-credit forms. The treaty texts and technical explanations are published in the IRS treaty collection at IRS tax treaties, and the mechanism only works if the paperwork is right: French returns filed, French assessments kept, American returns claiming the credit with matching figures, and exchange rates documented. A frequent and expensive mistake is to report the SCI result in only one country, either because the owner thought transparency meant invisibility, or because the American preparer never saw the French return. Transparency means the income passes through to you, not that it vanishes between two tax systems.

The American side adds its own classification and reporting layer, and this is where SCIs surprise buyers. For United States purposes a French SCI with two or more members is a foreign entity whose default classification is generally a partnership, while a single-owner vehicle would be disregarded, and the owners can in many cases elect corporate treatment by filing the entity-classification election, known as Form 8832, described at IRS About Form 8832. The classification drives which American forms the owners file: partnership-type reporting for interests in foreign partnerships, disclosures for disregarded entities, and potentially the controlled-foreign-corporation and passive-foreign-investment-company analyses if an election changed the picture. On top of that, the SCI bank account and the personal accounts used to fund it can trigger the annual foreign-account report, called the FBAR, and the statement of specified foreign financial assets, known as Form 8938, each with its own thresholds and deadlines, presented by the IRS at IRS Report of Foreign Bank and Financial Accounts (FBAR) and in the IRS comparison of the two regimes at IRS Comparison of Form 8938 and FBAR Requirements, while estate and gift treaty relief is catalogued at IRS Estate and Gift Tax Treaties. None of these filings is optional once the thresholds are met, and the penalties for missing them dwarf the cost of the SCI formation. Any American forming an SCI should therefore retain a United States tax preparer experienced with French transparent entities in the same year as the purchase, share the French statutes and the French returns with that preparer, and decide the classification election deliberately rather than defaulting into it by ignorance.

Two further French taxes complete the annual picture. If the property is rented, the partners pay French social charges, called prélèvements sociaux, on the rental result alongside income tax, at the nonresident or resident rate applicable to their situation, and the treaty credit mechanics on the American side treat these charges under their own rules, so the effective burden must be modeled rather than guessed. And if the net French real-estate wealth held through the SCI exceeds the statutory threshold, the partners fall within the French real-estate wealth tax, called impôt sur la fortune immobilière, on the value of their shares to the extent the shares represent French property, with debts deductible under strict conditions; the doctrine is published on the official tax-administration bulletin at BOFiP, the official French tax doctrine database. Neither charge shows up in the agent listing price, and both belong in the spreadsheet before the offer, not after the deed.

B. Handing the Shares to Your Children and Keeping Control of the House

Succession is where the SCI earns its reputation, because shares are easier to move than walls. When a partner dies, the shares do not vanish and the company does not automatically end; what happens depends on the statutes. The statutes may say that surviving partners continue among themselves, that heirs become partners automatically, or that heirs need approval to join. Where the heir does not become a partner, the Code provides a buyout logic: Article 1870-1 of the Civil Code states that “Les héritiers ou légataires qui ne deviennent pas associés n’ont droit qu’à la valeur des parts sociales de leur auteur.” Non-partner heirs receive the value of the deceased shares, paid by the new holders or by the company if it redeems them. Combined with the withdrawal right of Article 1869 of the Civil Code, under which “un associé peut se retirer totalement ou partiellement de la société, dans les conditions prévues par les statuts ou, à défaut, après autorisation donnée par une décision unanime des autres associés”, and the expert-valuation backstop of Article 1843-4 of the Civil Code, where “la valeur de ces droits est déterminée, en cas de contestation, par un expert désigné”, the SCI gives families a private toolkit for exits, redemptions, and buyouts that direct co-ownership, called indivision, handles far more rigidly. A parent who wants one child to keep the house and the others to receive value can organize that outcome through the statutes and lifetime gifts of shares, instead of leaving three heirs locked in an indivision that only a court sale can unlock.

Lifetime gifts of shares are the workhorse of SCI planning. A parent can give shares to each child in stages, keep the manager role as gérant, and even split ownership of the shares themselves between usufruit, the right to use and receive income, and nue-propriété, the bare ownership that becomes full ownership when the usufruit ends, typically at the donor death. The standard French gift-tax allowance between parent and child applies to each gift of shares: Article 779 of the General Tax Code provides that “il est effectué un abattement de 100 000 € sur la part de chacun des ascendants et sur la part de chacun des enfants vivants ou représentés par suite de prédécès ou de renonciation.” Each parent can thus transmit up to 100,000 euros per child under the allowance, the allowance renews under the statutory recall rules so gifts can be staggered across years, and gifts of nue-propriété are valued below full ownership when the donor retains the usufruit, which multiplies the leverage of each allowance. The mechanics and the current thresholds for family gifts are summarized for the public at service-public.fr: Donation. For an American family this planning must be drawn with both tax systems in the room, because a French gift of shares can also be a United States gift-tax event for an American donor, and the estate treaty then coordinates the two charges rather than letting either administration ignore the other.

Two guardrails frame every succession plan and neither can be drafted away. The first is the French reserved share for children, called the réserve héréditaire. Article 913 of the Civil Code provides that “Les libéralités, soit par actes entre vifs, soit par testament, ne pourront excéder la moitié des biens du disposant, s’il ne laisse à son décès qu’un enfant ; le tiers, s’il laisse deux enfants ; le quart, s’il en laisse trois ou un plus grand nombre.” Gifts and wills cannot exceed one-half with one child, one-third with two children, or one-quarter with three or more, and since the 2021 reform a compensatory levy, called the prélèvement compensatoire, lets a child deprived by a foreign applicable law claim compensation from French-situs assets, including the French house or the SCI shares that represent it. An American will that leaves everything to the surviving spouse and nothing to the children works under many American state laws and collides with this rule the moment French assets or French-resident heirs enter the picture. The second guardrail is the applicable-law question itself. Under the European Succession Regulation (Regulation (EU) No 650/2012 on jurisdiction and applicable law in matters of succession), the default law is the law of the last habitual residence, while article 22 of the Regulation lets a person choose the law of their nationality to govern the whole succession. When the heirs must prove their status to a French bank, insurer, or land registry, the cross-border instrument is the European Certificate of Succession: Article 1381-1 of the Code of Civil Procedure provides that the certificate “est délivré à la demande de tout héritier, légataire, exécuteur testamentaire ou administrateur de la succession par un notaire”. An American living in France can therefore elect American law in the will, a choice French notaires record routinely, but the election does not erase the prélèvement compensatoire for children, does not bind the American tax administration, and does not replace the estate-treaty coordination. The bilateral estate and gift treaty mechanism is catalogued by the IRS among the IRS catalogue of United States estate and gift tax treaties, which includes the convention with France: France taxes its real estate and the shares that represent it, the United States taxes its citizens worldwide, and the treaty grants credits so the same value is not fully taxed twice. A final cross-border subtlety is that Article 238 bis K of the General Tax Code and Article 8 of the General Tax Code govern how partnership-type results and share rights flow to corporate or individual holders, which matters when an American estate, trust, or company appears anywhere in the chain; entities layered on top of an SCI change the analysis and should never be improvised.

Put together, the succession playbook for an American-owned SCI has four moves, in order. First, draft statutes that say exactly who becomes a partner on death and who gets bought out, with a valuation method that references the expert procedure rather than a fixed price written a decade earlier. Second, make lifetime gifts of shares within the allowance, staged across years, keeping management through the gérant role and, where appropriate, splitting usufruit and nue-propriété so control and income stay with the parents while value moves to the children. Third, sign a will that elects the applicable law deliberately, coordinates the American dispositions with the French reserved share, and names executors on both sides who can actually act before a French notaire and an American probate court. Fourth, keep the paper that proves it all: registered statutes, share transfer ledger or registre des mouvements de parts, gift deeds, French tax returns, and the American Forms 8832, 8938, and FBAR history. The families who struggle after a death are almost never the ones with the wrong structure; they are the ones with the right structure and no records.

Conclusion

An SCI is neither a miracle nor a trap; it is a tool with a precise job. It lets several people own a French home together through shares instead of direct co-ownership, it moves value to children in slices through gifts of shares within the 100,000 euro allowance, it organizes exits and buyouts through approval, withdrawal, and expert valuation, and it stays tax-transparent in France by default so that rental results and sale gains are taxed at the partner level with France taxing first and the United States crediting second. Against those advantages stand three permanent costs: the partners answer indefinitely for company debts in proportion to their holdings, the company must stay civil and managed with real corporate records, and every American owner adds partnership or disregarded-entity reporting, foreign-account filings, and treaty-credit paperwork on the United States side. If your project is a shared family house with a succession horizon, form the SCI before the purchase, draft the approval and valuation clauses while everyone agrees, model the income-tax versus corporate-tax election in numbers, align the will with the reserved share and the nationality-law election, and put the same file in front of the French notaire and the American preparer. Done in that order, the SCI does exactly what it promises: the house stays in the family, the gifts fit inside the allowances, the sale follows the taper rather than the securities regime, and no tax administration has to be paid twice on the same euro.

📄 Official circular