You own a stone house in the Dordogne, you live in Ohio, and your American will leaves everything to your spouse. When you die, your children learn two things that surprise most American families. First, European law lets you choose American law to govern your French succession, including the house. Second, since November 2021, that choice no longer shuts your children out completely: if the American law you chose gives them no forced share at all, each child can levy a make-up share directly against the French assets. This guide explains both moves in order: how an American validly opts for United States law under the European Succession Regulation, what the French forced share still takes from the estate, and how your children or your spouse enforce the result in front of a French notaire, the public officer who alone can transfer French real estate to heirs. Every French term is explained as it appears, every decisive statement is tied to the statute or ruling behind it, and the last section turns the law into a paperwork checklist your family can actually use.
I. Can an American Living in the United States Keep French Law Off a French House?
A. Why Your French House Falls Under a European Default Rule Even When You Live in Ohio
The starting point is not French law at all. It is a European regulation that France applies to every cross-border succession: Regulation (EU) No. 650/2012 of July 4, 2012, on jurisdiction, applicable law, and wills in succession matters. Its default rule is short and mechanical: unless the regulation says otherwise, one single law governs the whole succession, and it is the law of the country where the deceased had habitual residence when death occurred. For an American who lives full time in the United States, that default often points back to the law of an American state, because habitual residence means real, stable, everyday life, not citizenship and not the location of a vacation home. Intent matters, duration matters, and the regulation tells the deciding authority to weigh all the facts: how long you lived somewhere, how regularly, and why. A retiree who spends three weeks a year in Sarlat and eleven months in Columbus is habitually resident in Ohio, not in France, and the default rule designates American law for the whole estate, house included.
That sounds reassuring, but three qualifications change the picture, and each one is the reason Americans need an express choice rather than silence. First, habitual residence is a facts test, and American lives in France are often mixed. A dual national who works in Lyon nine months a year, holds a French lease, sees French doctors, and summers in Florida is habitually resident in France, and the default rule then designates French law with its forced share for children. The Paris trial court applied exactly this kind of full-life analysis in a February 2025 succession judgment, weighing passports against homes, bank accounts, cars, medical follow-up, shareholder agreements, and daily life across two countries before deciding where the deceased really lived. The method travels directly to American files: border stamps alone never decide the question, and a French secondary home with French accounts, a French car, and French medical care can tip the balance toward France when the American ties thin out in the final years.
Second, even when the default designates American law, the French house is still transferred under French procedure. The notaire draws up the deed of notoriety (acte de notoriété), the document that identifies the heirs, publishes the transfer at the land registry, and calculates French inheritance tax. French courts also keep a subsidiary jurisdiction over the whole succession when the deceased held French nationality and owned property in France but lived outside the European Union, under Article 10 of the same regulation. The Court of Cassation confirmed how seriously that safety net must be taken when it referred a question to the Court of Justice of the European Union about whether a French court that sees French nationality and French assets must raise that subsidiary jurisdiction on its own motion (Cass. 1st civ., Nov. 18, 2020, No. 19-15.438). The practical message for Americans is plain: your Ohio will does not self-execute in France. Somebody must carry it to a French notaire, prove what American law says through a foreign-law affidavit (certificat de coutume), and accept that French courts can hear disputes about the estate whenever French assets anchor the case.
Third, American conflict rules do not always return the favor. Some American states send real estate back to the law of the place where the land sits, which for a Dordogne house means French law again through renvoi, the bounce-back mechanism the regulation accepts within limits. Silence therefore produces a lottery: depending on where you lived last, which state law applies, and how that state treats foreign land, your family may or may not land under French forced heirship. An express choice of law replaces that lottery with a sentence. That sentence is the professio juris, the Latin label for the testator’s choice of the law governing the succession, and it is the single most valuable line an American with French property can put in a will.
B. How to Choose American Law in Your Will So the Choice Survives Before a French Notaire
The choice rule sits in Article 22 of the regulation, and its first paragraph sets two propositions: a person may designate, for the succession as a whole, the law of the state whose nationality the person holds, assessed either when the choice is made or at death, and a person holding several nationalities may designate the law of any one of those states, assessed at either of those two moments. An American citizen therefore qualifies by definition, whether domiciled in Texas or in Toulouse. A French-American dual national living in France qualifies twice over and can pick American law even though daily life points to France, which is precisely the family that needs the clause most. What you cannot do is pick a convenient third-country law, the law of your vacation habits, or a patchwork: the choice must be the law of a nationality you hold, and it governs the succession as a whole, house, accounts, and personal effects together, with no splitting of the estate between two systems.
Form is where American wills most often fail in France. The regulation requires the choice to be express, made in a declaration taking the form of a disposition of property upon death, or else clearly demonstrated by the terms of such a disposition. In practice that means the will itself must say so, clearly, in a clause a French notaire can read without guessing. A model sentence reads, in substance, that the testator declares the law of a named American state, of which the testator is a national, to govern the succession as a whole. References to American legal concepts alone do not count: naming an executor, creating a revocable living trust, or citing a state probate code demonstrates an American flavor but does not demonstrate a choice of law within the meaning of the rule. The Paris trial court made this strictness concrete in its February 2025 ruling when it held that neither a 1998 French lifetime gift nor general testamentary language amounted to an express choice, and it applied the transitional presumption of Article 83 instead, under which a pre-August 17, 2015 testamentary disposition drawn in line with a law the deceased could have chosen is deemed to carry a choice of that law. Wills signed before August 17, 2015 can therefore benefit from a deemed choice; wills signed after that date cannot, and must speak expressly.
Timing and scope complete the picture. You can insert the clause at any age, change it by a later will, and revoke it the same way. The nationality can be assessed either when you sign or when you die, so an American who naturalizes French after signing keeps a valid American choice, and a French resident who naturalizes American can add one late. The choice covers intestacy and testacy alike, gifts made in contemplation of death, and the validity of the will’s substance, while French law keeps control of the mechanics of transfer: land registration, the notaire‘s fees, and French tax filings. One related confusion should be cleared up now. Choosing American law does not choose American courts. Jurisdiction follows separate articles of the regulation, and a French court with subsidiary jurisdiction can perfectly well apply Ohio law to a Dordogne house. Your family should expect a French proceeding conducted in French, applying American substantive rules proved by affidavit, and ending in a French deed. That is normal, and a well-drafted clause anticipates it by naming the state whose law is chosen, identifying your American nationality, and stating that the choice covers the whole succession.
The container of the clause matters as much as its wording. Americans have two reliable options. A holographic will (testament olographe), entirely handwritten, dated, and signed, costs nothing and is fully valid, but every word including the choice clause must be in your hand, and the original should be deposited with a French notaire or registered in the central wills file, the FCDDV, so it is found. Our companion guide walks through those formalities step by step (how Americans write, deposit, and register a French holographic will). An authenticated will (testament authentique) dictated before a notaire with witnesses costs a fee but buys certainty: the notaire checks the clause, keeps the original, and registers it automatically. Either way, revoke earlier inconsistent wills expressly, keep one master original, and send your executor a copy with the notaire‘s details. A choice clause nobody can find is a choice nobody can apply.
II. What Happens When American Law Disinherits a Child Whom French Law Would Have Protected?
A. How the Forced Share Is Computed and How Your Children Reclaim It From French Assets
French forced heirship starts from two definitions that every American should memorize. Under Article 912 of the Civil Code: “La réserve héréditaire est la part des biens et droits successoraux dont la loi assure la dévolution libre de charges à certains héritiers dits réservataires, s’ils sont appelés à la succession et s’ils l’acceptent. La quotité disponible est la part des biens et droits successoraux qui n’est pas réservée par la loi et dont le défunt a pu disposer librement par des libéralités.” In plain terms, the forced share (réserve hériditaire) is the slice of the estate the law guarantees to children, free of conditions, when they accept the inheritance, and the disposable share (quotité disponible) is everything else, the only part you can give freely by gift or will. The fractions sit in Article 913 of the Civil Code: “Les libéralités, soit par actes entre vifs, soit par testament, ne pourront excéder la moitié des biens du disposant, s’il ne laisse à son décès qu’un enfant ; le tiers, s’il laisse deux enfants ; le quart, s’il en laisse trois ou un plus grand nombre.” One child means a one-half forced share, two children mean two-thirds, three or more mean three-quarters. Gifts you made during life count: the notaire rebuilds a fictional mass of everything owned at death plus lifetime gifts under Article 922 of the Civil Code, and any gift or bequest that overshoots the disposable share is cut back through the reduction action (action en réduction), which Article 921 of the Civil Code reserves to the protected heirs, their own heirs, and their successors, never to other beneficiaries or creditors.
The reduction action carries deadlines Americans consistently underestimate. The same Article 921 states: “Le délai de prescription de l’action en réduction est fixé à cinq ans à compter de l’ouverture de la succession, ou à deux ans à compter du jour où les héritiers ont eu connaissance de l’atteinte portée à leur réserve, sans jamais pouvoir excéder dix ans à compter du décès.” Five years from death, or two years from learning of the harm, capped at ten years from death in all cases. The same article adds a procedural safeguard worth knowing: when the notaire settling the estate sees that gifts may have eaten into a forced share, the notaire must individually inform each affected known heir, before any partition if possible, of the right to seek reduction. Children who live in America and hear about a French succession late should therefore move quickly once informed, request the full gift history, and calendar the two-year knowledge limb from the day they receive real figures, not rumors. Reductions operate in kind or in value under Article 924 of the Civil Code, and lifetime partitions among presumptive heirs (donations-partages) authorized by Article 1075 of the Civil Code can freeze values early, which is why advance planning beats post-death litigation.
For decades the central question was whether French courts would even apply a foreign law that lets a parent disinherit a child. The old answer was hostile. In a 2018 ruling on a pre-regulation succession with Paris real estate, the Court of Cassation approved judges who had held that the devolution of the French immovables had to account for forced heirship rules, which being a matter of domestic public policy could not be set aside by testamentary dispositions made under the law of the deceased’s domicile (Cass. 1st civ., July 4, 2018, No. 17-16.515). That hostility no longer governs successions opened after August 2015, because the regulation replaced the old scission system with one applicable law, and a foreign law with no forced share is no longer dismissed as contrary to French international public policy in ordinary cases. The February 2025 Paris judgment proves the new era: the court observed that Israeli law sets an intestate order of succession while also leaving individuals nearly full testamentary freedom, with no forced share for children, then held in its operative part that Israeli law governed the succession, fixed the widow’s and daughters’ shares under that law, and rejected the daughter’s demand for a partition under French law. Substitute Ohio or Florida for Israel and the lesson is identical: a French court can and will apply an American law that gives children no forced share, dividing even French immovables under foreign rules.
That is exactly where the 2021 statute intervenes as a safety net. The second paragraph of Article 913, in force since November 1, 2021, provides: “Lorsque le défunt ou au moins l’un de ses enfants est, au moment du décès, ressortissant d’un Etat membre de l’Union européenne ou y réside habituellement et lorsque la loi étrangère applicable à la succession ne permet aucun mécanisme réservataire protecteur des enfants, chaque enfant ou ses héritiers ou ses ayants cause peuvent effectuer un prélèvement compensatoire sur les biens existants situés en France au jour du décès, de façon à être rétablis dans les droits réservataires que leur octroie la loi française, dans la limite de ceux-ci.” Each condition counts. Somebody, the deceased or at least one child, must be a European Union national or habitually resident in the Union when death occurs. The applicable foreign law must offer no reserve-like protective mechanism for children at all, not merely a smaller one. And the levy, the prélèvement compensatoire, can only bite assets located in France on the day of death, capped at the French forced-share rights. An American father living in Lyon whose Ohio-law will leaves the Dordogne house to his second wife faces the levy from any child; an American father living in Dallas whose only child also lives in Dallas, with no Union nationality or residence on either side, falls outside the device, and the American will then operates uncorrected on the French house. Families straddling the Atlantic should map nationality and residence person by person before assuming either outcome. Our dedicated analysis of the levy, with computation examples and the treaty overlay, is the companion to this section (how disinherited children claim the compensatory levy on a French house), and the broader question of whether any workaround truly defeats the forced share is examined separately (can Americans disinherit a child under French law).
B. How to Make the American Choice Work in Practice: Paperwork, Taxes, and the Notaire File
A valid clause is the beginning, not the end. The French file opens with paper, and American families lose months by arriving with the wrong paper. The notaire will ask for the death certificate with an apostille, the Hague Convention stamp that authenticates American public documents for use in France, plus a sworn French translation; for the will, the original or an authenticated copy with proof of deposit or FCDDV registration; for the marriage, the marriage certificate and any American prenuptial agreement with translation, because the matrimonial property regime decides what actually belongs to the estate before succession law divides it; and for the law itself, a certificat de coutume, a reasoned affidavit from an American-law specialist setting out the applicable state intestacy and will rules, the absence of any forced share, and the effect of the choice clause. Heirs prove identity with passports and birth certificates, also apostilled and translated, and anyone acting under a power of attorney needs a notarized, apostilled, translated mandate that the notaire accepts. Start the apostille chain in America before flying: secretaries of state issue apostilles in weeks, and a file that lands complete settles in months, while a file that lands partial stalls for a season.
Taxes run on a parallel track and obey different treaties from succession law. France taxes the Dordogne house because it sits in France, applying French registration duties and allowances, including the standard parent-child allowance and the progressive rate scale set by the General Tax Code, for which Article 777 of the General Tax Code carries the rate table. The United States taxes its citizens and domiciliaries on worldwide assets, house included, with its own exemption thresholds and its own return. Double taxation is relieved by the 1978 France-United States convention on estates, inheritances, and gifts, as amended by the 2004 protocol whose official text is published by the United States Congress, which allocates taxing rights over immovable property to the situs state and provides credit machinery in the residence state. Concretely, the estate pays French duties on the house first, claims a foreign tax credit on the American estate tax return, and documents everything twice: the French déclaration de succession filed with the French tax office within the short statutory deadlines running from death, and the American Form 706 and state filings on the American side. Keep the notaire‘s tax computation, the wire proofs, and the exchange rate used, because the Internal Revenue Service credit and the French payment must reconcile to the euro. Bank accounts follow their own reporting logic, with French account 3916 filings on the French side and FBAR and Form 8938 duties on the American side, a dual-reporting burden our separate guide details for account holders (dual FBAR, 8938, and 3916 reporting for Americans with French accounts). General orientation on who inherits and how the French system frames heirs is also available from the official public service (who inherits under French rules), and its direct answer to the disinheritance question confirms the starting point of this entire guide (can you disinherit your children).
Four American habits cause most of the damage, and each has a clean fix. First, the silent American will: a Florida will that disposes of “all my property wherever situated” with no choice clause leaves the family in the habitual-residence lottery described above. Fix it with the express Article 22 sentence and an FCDDV-registered French-compatible original. Second, the revocable living trust as a cure-all: France has no domestic trust, treats the American trust as a foreign arrangement with specific tax and disclosure consequences, and a trust deed does not replace a choice-of-law clause in a will. Fund the trust for American purposes if your American adviser recommends it, but sign the will clause for French purposes regardless. Third, joint tenancy and transfer-on-death deeds: American survivorship mechanisms do not transfer French land by themselves. The French deed and land registration decide ownership against third parties, and a Payable-on-death designation that works in Maricopa County is paper in Périgueux until the notaire converts the family position into a French deed. Fourth, renunciation surprises under Article 845 of the Civil Code: an heir who renounces keeps lifetime gifts only within the disposable share unless the donor expressly required return on renunciation, so a child who renounces to escape debts can still face accounting. When a renunciation branches to grandchildren by representation, recalculate every share before signing anything.
Two household configurations deserve a final word because Americans meet them constantly. Blended families combine the choice clause with the surviving spouse’s options and the first-family children’s levy rights, a triangle our spouse-focused guide maps from the widow’s side and our first-marriage analysis maps from the children’s side. Unmarried partners get nothing automatic under either system: without marriage, a registered partnership, or a will, the survivor is a stranger to the succession, and the choice clause should be paired with targeted bequests inside the disposable share plus life insurance (assurance-vie) beneficiary designations, which pass outside the estate under their own rules. In every configuration the sequence is the same: sign the express clause, register the will where it will be found, brief the executor on the French file, and tell the children, while there is still time, what the clause does and what the levy restores. The families who fight for years are rarely the families with the most complicated assets. They are the families who discover the clause, or its absence, after the funeral.
Conclusion
An American with a French house holds two powerful tools that must be used together. The professio juris of Article 22 lets you designate American law for the whole succession, and a single express sentence in a properly deposited will replaces the habitual-residence lottery with certainty, including for dual nationals living in France. The French forced share then sets the boundary: children keep a half, two-thirds, or three-quarters of the fictional estate depending on their number, lifetime gifts are pulled back into the mass for computation, and the reduction action enforces the result within five years of death, two years of knowledge, and ten years at most. When the chosen American law offers children no reserve mechanism at all, the compensatory levy of Article 913 lets each qualifying child take the French-share equivalent from assets sitting in France, which means the Dordogne house often pays the balance. Around those two pillars sits the practice: apostilled and translated American documents, a foreign-law affidavit the notaire can apply, a will the FCDDV can find, French duties paid on the house with an American credit claimed at home, and accounts reported on both sides of the Atlantic. Draft the clause now, register it where it will be found, and align the American estate plan with the French deed. Your family will inherit a file that works instead of a lawsuit that lasts.