An American living in France can generally ask a U.S. custodian to convert all or part of a Traditional IRA into a Roth IRA. The difficult question is not whether the financial institution can process the transaction. It is how France classifies the conversion, what the France–U.S. income-tax treaty does with that classification, and what the taxpayer must prove on the French return.
Under U.S. rules, a conversion normally produces a distribution from the Traditional IRA and a contribution to the Roth IRA. The IRS may therefore include untaxed amounts in U.S. gross income even when the money moves directly between trustees. France does not have to copy the label used on Form 1099-R. A French tax resident is ordinarily assessed under French domestic rules first, then the treaty is applied to the properly identified category of income.
The strongest treaty argument is that a qualifying U.S. retirement-plan payment falls under Article 18, which covers payments in a lump sum as well as periodic payments. The strongest caution is that the official French material does not publish a simple rule saying that every Roth conversion is exempt in France. The file must distinguish a Traditional IRA distribution converted to a Roth, an ordinary Roth contribution, a later Roth withdrawal, a rollover, and a non-qualified early distribution. This article explains the evidence, filing method, and response strategy for an American who was already living as a French tax resident when the conversion occurred.
I. Can an American convert a Traditional IRA to a Roth IRA while living in France?
A. What does a Traditional IRA-to-Roth conversion actually do?
A Traditional IRA is a U.S. individual retirement arrangement in which contributions or earnings may receive tax-favored treatment until distribution. A Roth IRA is a different type of individual retirement arrangement: contributions are generally made without a deduction, while a qualified later distribution can receive favorable U.S. treatment. A conversion is the legal and tax event that moves value from the first arrangement into the second. It is not the same thing as simply withdrawing cash for personal spending.
The IRS describes three practical routes: a 60-day rollover in which the distribution is paid to the individual and then contributed to the Roth; a trustee-to-trustee transfer to another institution; and a same-trustee transfer between accounts at the same institution. The official IRS guidance on Traditional IRA-to-Roth conversions confirms that a conversion can be completed by direct transfer, but also states that untaxed amounts in the Traditional IRA are taxed under U.S. rules. The IRS Publication 590-B likewise explains that treating a conversion as a rollover for Roth purposes does not remove the general rule that a Traditional IRA distribution is taxable in the year received.
That U.S. description matters in France because the documents will often show a distribution, a conversion amount, a taxable amount, or a withholding amount. It does not settle the French result. A 1099-R is evidence of how the U.S. payer reported an event. It is not, by itself, a French legal classification. The French analysis must answer five separate questions:
- Was the source account a Traditional IRA, a 401(k), a 403(b), a governmental plan, an annuity, or an ordinary investment account?
- Was the movement a conversion, a direct rollover, a cash distribution followed by a contribution, a recharacterization, or a transfer between Roth accounts?
- Was the account constituted and administered in the United States, and was it connected with past employment or an individual retirement arrangement?
- Was the taxpayer a French domestic tax resident and a French treaty resident on the relevant date?
- What did the United States actually include in gross income, and what tax was paid or withheld?
The distinction between a conversion and a later withdrawal is especially important. A conversion changes the legal status of the account. A later Roth distribution may contain regular contributions, converted amounts, and investment earnings, each with different U.S. consequences. From a French perspective, those events can arrive in different tax years and may require different proof. A document set that proves a Roth withdrawal does not necessarily prove the legal nature of the earlier Traditional IRA conversion. For the separate withdrawal question, see the firm’s guide on how a Roth IRA is taxed in France for an American retiree; this article addresses the earlier conversion event.
The timing of the move to France also matters. Someone who converted before becoming a French tax resident has a different fact pattern from someone who converted after establishing a home and principal stay in France. Someone who moved during the year may need a split-year analysis for French domestic rules, a treaty-residence analysis, and a review of the dates on the account statement. The date of the instruction, the date of the distribution, the date of the Roth contribution, and the date of French residence should not be treated as interchangeable.
A direct trustee-to-trustee transfer is usually cleaner administratively, but it does not make the event invisible. The IRS instructions for Form 1099-R state that a Traditional IRA distribution known to be converted to a Roth must be reported even if it is a trustee-to-trustee transfer or occurs with the same trustee. The French file should therefore preserve the conversion confirmation, the pre- and post-transfer statements, the year-end forms, and the U.S. return on which the amount was reported.
The conversion also has an economic effect that should be modeled before the instruction is sent. A U.S. tax charge may be generated in the year of conversion, even though no cash is paid to the taxpayer. France may ask why an amount that appears on a U.S. distribution form did not appear as ordinary taxable income on the French return. The answer should not be a general statement that “Roth is tax-free.” The answer should identify the account, the treaty article, the applicable French declaration, and the documents showing where the taxing right belongs.
A conversion can also be partial. A partial conversion does not eliminate the need to identify the total Traditional IRA basis, the amount transferred, the amount retained, and any withholding. Under U.S. aggregation rules, other Traditional, SEP, or SIMPLE IRAs can affect the taxable portion. A French reviewer will not be able to reconstruct that analysis from a single brokerage screenshot. Obtain the full custodian statement and the U.S. calculation that explains the reported amount.
Finally, do not confuse a Roth conversion with a contribution made from salary or savings. A contribution starts with money outside the retirement arrangement. A conversion starts with a distribution or transfer from a retirement arrangement. The treaty question is therefore tied to the source and character of the converted amount, not merely to the name of the destination account.
B. Does Article 18 of the France–U.S. treaty protect the conversion from French tax?
Article 18 of the France–U.S. income-tax treaty is the central provision, but it must be read in its amended form. The original treaty of 31 August 1994 is published in the French Official Journal on Légifrance. The later French publication of the 2004 protocol replaced Article 18 and must be read with the convention.
The amended text states, in French: « Les sommes payées en application de la législation sur la sécurité sociale ou d’une législation similaire d’un Etat contractant ainsi que les sommes versées dans le cadre d’un régime de retraite et autres rémunérations similaires qui proviennent de l’un des Etats contractants au titre d’un emploi antérieur à un résident de l’autre Etat contractant, sous la forme de versements périodiques ou d’une somme globale, ne sont imposables que dans le premier Etat. » In English, the rule concerns social-security payments and retirement-plan or similar remuneration arising in one contracting state, paid to a resident of the other state, whether periodic or in a lump sum, and allocates the taxing right exclusively to the first state for the payments covered by the paragraph.
The protocol adds a source rule: a retirement payment is treated as coming from a contracting state when it is paid by a retirement plan or other retirement arrangement constituted in that state. That language supports analysis of a U.S.-constituted Traditional IRA or employer plan. The same protocol lists U.S. arrangements that generally correspond to French recognized retirement arrangements, including arrangements under section 401(a), individual retirement accounts and annuities, section 408(p) arrangements, and sections 403(a) and 403(b). It also explains that a retirement arrangement is recognized for this purpose when contributions to it give rise to tax relief in the relevant state.
That last condition is the reason a Roth conversion requires a carefully documented position. The protocol names individual retirement arrangements, but a Roth IRA is funded under U.S. rules without a deduction for the contribution. A Traditional IRA-to-Roth conversion is not an ordinary new Roth contribution, yet the conversion amount is reported as a distribution from the former retirement account. The treaty text therefore creates a serious argument for Article 18 treatment, while the contribution and tax-relief language prevents a responsible analysis from declaring every Roth-related transaction automatically protected.
The official French Senate record is unusually important. In a written question about Roth IRA and Roth 401(k) accounts, the question described the concern that Roth contributions are not deductible during the career and are not taxed in the United States on retirement. The ministerial response published on 27 August 2020 states: « Les sommes provenant de plans de retraite américains, qu’elles soient versées en une seule fois ou de façon périodique, ne sont imposables qu’aux États-Unis en application du paragraphe 1 de l’article 18 de la convention du 31 août 1994. La liste des régimes de retraite figurant au 2 du même article est sans incidence sur cette règle. » The response also says that France may take those sums into account when calculating the income-tax rate on the household’s other income, provided a French tax credit equal to the French tax corresponding to those sums is granted.
This answer is favorable to a taxpayer whose event is genuinely a sum coming from an American retirement plan within Article 18(1). It is not a specific published ruling on every Traditional IRA-to-Roth conversion. It does not decide whether an account is a retirement plan, whether a transaction is a conversion rather than a new contribution, whether a payment is connected with past employment, or how all social levies apply. It is best used as a principal authority in a written file, together with the treaty, the protocol, account documents, and the U.S. reporting.
The treaty’s Article 24 must also be read. Its credit mechanism can prevent double taxation while allowing France to preserve progressive rates on other household income. This is the difference between “taxable only in the United States” and “irrelevant to every French calculation.” A treaty-exempt or treaty-allocated amount may still have to appear in a French declaration for an effective-rate calculation. Article 24 should therefore be linked from the official treaty text on Légifrance whenever the conversion position is explained to the French tax administration.
Article 29 supplies another limit. The treaty’s saving-clause provision preserves the United States’ ability to tax its citizens and residents under U.S. domestic law, in certain circumstances, « comme si la Convention n’existait pas ». An American who lives in France can consequently have a French residence position for the treaty and a continuing U.S. filing obligation. U.S. citizenship does not by itself give France the right to tax a payment that Article 18 assigns elsewhere, but it does explain why U.S. tax forms and U.S. tax may continue to exist.
The treaty does not replace the French domestic starting point. Article 4 A of the General Tax Code says: « Les personnes qui ont en France leur domicile fiscal sont passibles de l’impôt sur le revenu en raison de l’ensemble de leurs revenus. » In plain English, a person with a French tax domicile is generally assessed on worldwide income, subject to treaty limits. Article 4 B identifies the household or principal stay, professional activity, and center of economic interests as domestic residence tests, while acknowledging that an international treaty can assign residence elsewhere.
French case law illustrates the sequence. In CAA Marseille, 4th chamber, 16 June 2020, no. 19MA01434, the court dealt with retirement payments and an asserted France–U.S. treaty exemption. It wrote: « il incombe au juge de l’impôt de rechercher d’abord si l’imposition contestée a été valablement établie au regard de la loi fiscale nationale ». The case was not about a Roth conversion, and it does not decide the present question. Its practical lesson is relevant: the taxpayer must first establish the nature and source of the payment, then connect that classification to the treaty. A treaty citation without account and residence evidence is vulnerable.
The working conclusion is therefore conditional but usable. If the event is a distribution or similar payment from a U.S.-constituted retirement arrangement, France is the treaty-residence state, and the evidence supports Article 18, the taxpayer has a substantial basis to request that France not impose ordinary income tax on the same amount. If the amount is treaty-allocated to the United States, it may still need to be declared or identified for progression and credit purposes. If the event is an ordinary investment transfer, a non-qualified payment, an unproven source, or a transaction outside Article 18, the result may be different.
Do not ask only, “Is a Roth IRA tax-free?” Ask instead, “What was paid or transferred, from which legal arrangement, to which resident, in which year, and how does Article 18 classify that event?” That question produces a file that can survive review.
II. How should a French tax resident report and challenge a Roth conversion?
A. What should you declare in France and prove to the tax authorities?
The first reporting rule is simple: do not silently omit the conversion because the U.S. custodian called it a Roth conversion. Article 170 of the General Tax Code requires an income-tax taxpayer to provide a detailed declaration. Its current text says that « toute personne imposable audit impôt est tenue de souscrire et de faire parvenir à l’administration une déclaration détaillée de ses revenus et bénéfices ». The same article states that a taxpayer must declare global-income items that are exempt under the Code or an international double-tax treaty when those items must be taken into account in calculating tax on other global-income items.
This is why “not taxable in France” and “not reportable in France” are not synonyms. The French return may need to show the income, its foreign source, and the treaty position even when the final French income-tax charge is zero. The online forms and instructions change, so confirm the fields for the relevant tax year. A French resident commonly uses Form 2042 as the main income-tax return and Form 2047 for foreign-source income, but the correct line depends on the account, the type of payment, and the treatment claimed. A general article cannot safely assign a single line to every Roth transaction.
Prepare an explanatory attachment in English or French as requested by the receiving service, with a short French summary if the file is being reviewed by the DGFiP, the French tax administration. The attachment should state:
- the taxpayer’s French residence dates and treaty-residence position;
- the name and address of the U.S. custodian;
- the exact account type and whether it was an individual or employer retirement arrangement;
- the transaction date, gross amount, currency, and euro conversion method;
- whether the transfer was direct, paid by check, or partly retained for withholding;
- the Form 1099-R code and the amount reported as taxable in the United States;
- the U.S. return line or Form 8606 calculation that explains the conversion;
- the Article 18 and Article 24 analysis; and
- the French treatment requested, including any amount relevant to progression.
The supporting evidence should be organized in the same order. Keep the original account-opening or plan documents, the custodian’s conversion confirmation, the before-and-after statements, the Form 1099-R, Form 5498 where issued, Form 8606, the federal return, the transcript or payment confirmation, and proof of any U.S. withholding. If the account came from a 401(k) rollover, keep the employment-plan documents and rollover history. If the funds were partly after-tax, preserve the basis calculation. If the transaction involved securities rather than cash, preserve the valuation on the transfer date.
Residence proof belongs in the file as well. A French lease or deed, utility history, family residence, registration evidence, work records, travel calendar, and French assessment notice can help establish the domestic position. If the United States also treats the individual as resident, prepare the treaty tie-breaker analysis rather than relying on a passport, a visa, or a mailing address. The treaty residence conclusion should be stated for the tax year at issue, not assumed from the current year.
The foreign-account question is separate from the income-tax question. Article 1649 A of the General Tax Code provides that French-domiciled individuals must declare the references of foreign accounts that are opened, held, used, or closed abroad. The provision says: « Les personnes physiques, les associations, les sociétés n’ayant pas la forme commerciale, domiciliées ou établies en France, sont tenues de déclarer, en même temps que leur déclaration de revenus ou de résultats, les références des comptes ouverts, détenus, utilisés ou clos à l’étranger. » Whether a particular retirement arrangement falls within the foreign-account filing mechanism depends on its legal and operational facts. Do not assume that a U.S. IRA is automatically exempt from every French information return, and do not assume that account disclosure proves the conversion is French-taxable. Reportability and substantive taxation are different questions.
Currency evidence is often overlooked. The conversion may be stated in U.S. dollars while the French return is prepared in euros. Keep the exchange-rate source, the date used, and the calculation showing the gross amount before withholding. A difference between the custodian’s dollar amount and the euro amount on the French attachment should be explainable. Do not use the net amount that arrived in a bank account if U.S. withholding was taken from the gross conversion.
The file should also identify what did not happen. If the entire amount moved directly to the Roth, say so. If no cash was available for personal use, say so. If part of the Traditional IRA was retained to pay U.S. tax, identify that part. If the custodian issued multiple forms, reconcile them. If a later distribution occurred, place it in a separate year and explain that it was not the conversion itself. This prevents a reviewer from treating the conversion, withholding, and later withdrawal as one payment.
French social contributions require a separate check. The income-tax treaty allocates income-tax taxing rights; it does not answer every question about the contribution sociale généralisée, the contribution pour le remboursement de la dette sociale, or other French social levies. Residence, health-insurance affiliation, the category of payment, and the applicable domestic rules can change the result. A statement that Article 18 eliminates all French charges is too broad. The conversion file should list income tax and social charges separately and avoid applying an unverified current rate.
The French income-tax administration may also ask whether the treaty amount affects the household’s marginal rate. Article 170’s progression rule and Article 24’s credit method are central here. The taxpayer should provide the gross amount and the requested treaty treatment, not merely write “exempt.” If the amount is used only to calculate the rate on other income, the notice should make that mechanism visible. If France has no taxing right over the amount under Article 18, the computation should still be checked for the treaty credit and progression consequences.
A written advance position may be useful before a large conversion, especially where the account has a Roth feature, mixed basis, inherited funds, former employer assets, or unusual plan terms. A request for a formal French tax position should describe the transaction completely and attach the treaty provisions. An incomplete question can produce an answer that does not cover the actual event. A private opinion from a cross-border tax lawyer is not a substitute for a French administrative position, but it can identify the missing facts before the transfer is instructed.
B. What should you do if France taxes the conversion or rejects the treaty position?
If a French assessment taxes the conversion as ordinary income, start by identifying the exact line, year, amount, and legal reasoning. Obtain the income-tax notice, the calculation, any message from the DGFiP, and the return that was filed. Compare the amount with the gross 1099-R figure, the conversion confirmation, the French euro calculation, and any amount already included for progression. Many disputes begin with a simple mismatch between a gross distribution, a withheld amount, and a later net transfer.
If the annual return is still open for correction, use the available correction channel or submit a corrected return with a precise explanatory note. Keep the submission receipt. A correction should not replace the treaty analysis. The taxpayer should identify the U.S. plan, the French treaty residence, the payment date, the Article 18 allocation, and the requested treatment on the French forms. If the correction window is closed or an assessment has been issued, the next step is normally a formal administrative tax claim, called a réclamation contentieuse in French.
Article L.190 of the Livre des procédures fiscales defines the contentieux route for claims concerning taxes and penalties. It states: « Les réclamations relatives aux impôts, contributions, droits, taxes, redevances, soultes et pénalités de toute nature, établis ou recouvrés par les agents de l’administration, relèvent de la juridiction contentieuse lorsqu’elles tendent à obtenir soit la réparation d’erreurs commises dans l’assiette ou le calcul des impositions, soit le bénéfice d’un droit résultant d’une disposition législative ou réglementaire. » A claim invoking Article 18 should therefore explain the domestic assessment, the factual classification, the treaty rule, the amount of relief, and the documents proving each step.
The deadline must be calculated rather than guessed. Article R.*196-1 of the Livre des procédures fiscales provides that, for the relevant income taxes, claims generally must be filed by 31 December of the second year following the year of the assessment notice, payment, or event specified by the provision. The article begins: « Pour être recevables, les réclamations relatives aux impôts autres que les impôts directs locaux et les taxes annexes à ces impôts, doivent être présentées à l’administration au plus tard le 31 décembre de la deuxième année suivant celle » before listing the triggering events and exceptions. The official Service-Public.fr guidance on tax claims should be checked alongside the Code for the procedure applicable to the particular notice.
The claim should request the correct remedy. It may seek cancellation or reduction of the French income-tax charge, correction of the income category, recognition of the Article 18 allocation, and recalculation of progression or credit effects. It should not ask France to refund U.S. tax. U.S. tax is addressed on the U.S. return and under U.S. credit rules. The French claim should focus on the French assessment and the treaty allocation.
Late interest is another reason to document the position early. Article 1727 of the General Tax Code states: « Toute créance de nature fiscale, dont l’établissement ou le recouvrement incombe aux administrations fiscales, qui n’a pas été acquittée dans le délai légal donne lieu au versement d’un intérêt de retard. » The same article provides an exception where the taxpayer expressly states on the declaration or in an attached note the legal or factual reasons for not reporting an item fully or for giving it a tax-favorable qualification. That provision is not a guarantee that every treaty position avoids interest or penalties. It is a reason to give a clear, good-faith explanation before the administration has to guess what happened.
The explanatory note should be factual rather than rhetorical. A workable outline is:
“The taxpayer was resident in France for the relevant treaty period. On [date], the taxpayer converted USD [amount] from a U.S. Traditional IRA held with [custodian] into a Roth IRA. The custodian reported the event on Form 1099-R and the U.S. return treats the applicable amount as a conversion distribution. No personal cash was received, except [describe any retained withholding]. The attached plan documents, statements, and U.S. forms establish the source and character of the payment. The taxpayer requests application of Article 18 of the France–U.S. Convention, with any declaration and progression treatment required by Article 24 and Article 170 of the General Tax Code.”
Replace every bracket with verified facts. Do not file a generic template that says a Roth is tax-free, that the United States is the source, or that Article 18 applies without evidence. If the amount came from several accounts, give a separate schedule. If a portion was not converted, identify it. If the account was inherited or subject to a former employer plan, explain that complication.
A response to a French information request should also address unfavorable facts directly. If the account documentation is incomplete, request it from the custodian. If the U.S. form shows a taxable amount that differs from the conversion confirmation, reconcile it. If France was not the treaty-residence state, say so and explain the domestic French-source analysis. If the payment was made by a governmental plan, analyze Article 19 rather than forcing it into Article 18. If the event was a brokerage transfer, it may not be a retirement-plan payment at all.
The court decision in CAA Marseille no. 19MA01434 is useful for this evidentiary discipline. The court rejected the claimed treaty relief in that case because the taxpayers had not established that the pension payment came from the United States. Again, the decision did not concern an IRA or Roth conversion. It shows why the file must prove the source and category of a payment instead of relying on the taxpayer’s nationality or the word “pension” on a form.
If the French administration rejects the claim, obtain the written response and check whether it addresses the treaty text, the 2004 protocol, the Senate answer, and the evidence. A refusal based only on the idea that France taxes worldwide income may not have addressed the treaty stage. A refusal based only on the word “Roth” may not have addressed whether the conversion was a distribution from a U.S. retirement plan. The next procedural option depends on the notice, the amount, the deadline, and whether the case should be taken to the administrative court after the prior claim.
Do not make a second conversion while the first dispute is unresolved without reviewing the cumulative effect. A second event can create another U.S. distribution form, another French reporting year, another currency calculation, and a new deadline. Keep a transaction register with the account number masked, the legal account type, date, amount, source, destination, U.S. form, French form, and treaty treatment. That register becomes valuable if the French tax administration compares several years of foreign-account declarations.
The safest process for a significant transaction has four stages:
- Before conversion, classify the account, confirm the French and treaty residence positions, model U.S. tax, and obtain a written French analysis of Article 18 and Article 24.
- At conversion, use a traceable custodian instruction, preserve the confirmation, record the gross dollar value and date, and identify any withholding or retained property.
- At filing, reconcile the U.S. and French forms, declare the event or treaty-exempt amount as required, attach the explanation, and preserve proof of submission.
- After assessment, compare the notice with the requested treaty treatment and calculate any correction or Article L.190 claim deadline immediately.
This process does not guarantee that the DGFiP will accept a particular Roth position. It creates the evidence needed to obtain a serious answer and to challenge a misclassification. The key is to treat the conversion as a cross-border legal event with two layers: U.S. reporting and French treaty classification.
Conclusion
An American living in France may be able to convert a Traditional IRA to a Roth IRA, but the transaction should not be described as automatically tax-free in France. Under U.S. rules, the conversion is generally reported as a distribution and may include untaxed amounts in U.S. income. Under the France–U.S. treaty, Article 18 provides a substantial basis for allocating a qualifying payment from a U.S. retirement arrangement to the state identified by the treaty, and the French Senate’s published response supports a broad reading for amounts from American retirement plans.
The result still depends on proof. The taxpayer must establish the account type, the exact event, the source, the relevant residence, the U.S. reporting, and the French declaration. A treaty-allocated amount may remain relevant to French progression or credit calculations. Foreign-account reporting, income tax, and social contributions must be analyzed separately. If France taxes the conversion, a prompt correction or formal claim should identify the domestic assessment, Article 18, Article 24, Article 170, the supporting documents, and the applicable deadline.
The practical answer is therefore: convert only after the French classification is documented; report consistently in both countries; preserve the entire evidence chain; and challenge a French misclassification before the claim period expires.