KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
My American Father Disinherited Me With a US Will but Owned a House in France: How the 2021 Compensatory Levy Recovers My Forced Share

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

My American Father Disinherited Me With a US Will but Owned a House in France: How the 2021 Compensatory Levy Recovers My Forced Share

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

Your father was an American citizen who lived the last fifteen years of his life in Los Angeles. He never lived in France, but he owned a paid-off apartment in Paris worth about 600,000 euros and kept roughly 80,000 euros in a French bank account. His California will leaves everything to his second wife and names you, his son from a first marriage living in Chicago, for a symbolic one dollar. The Paris notaire (the French public officer who settles every estate that includes French assets) now tells you that French law may guarantee you a fixed minimum share of the estate, and that no American will can take it away. You wonder whether that is real or wishful thinking, how a French rule could override a California will signed in California by a Californian, and what you concretely have to do — and how fast — to recover your share before the Paris apartment is sold and the money leaves France. This guide answers those three questions in order: which law decides whether you have a forced share when an American estate touches France, then how that share is counted and which court action recovers it, and finally how the 2021 French safety net works when American law governs, plus what the estate owes the tax authorities on both sides of the Atlantic.

I. Can An American Father Really Disinherit His Child When French Property Is Involved?

A. Why Your Father’s Last Home — Not The California Will Alone — Decides Who Gets What

American readers usually assume that a valid will controls everything. Under French private international law, the starting question is different: before reading the will, the notaire and the judge ask which country’s succession law applies to the estate as a whole. Since August 17, 2015, that question is answered for France by a European text, Regulation (EU) No 650/2012 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 4 July 2012 on jurisdiction, applicable law, recognition and enforcement of decisions in matters of succession. Its general rule is short and decisive: unless the Regulation provides otherwise, a single law governs the whole succession, namely the law of the country where the deceased had his habitual residence when he died. Habitual residence means the place where your father actually lived his daily life — where his home, his routines, and the center of his interests were — not his passport and not the location of his bank accounts. Search EUR-Lex for Regulation 650/2012 for the official text of the Regulation.

That single sentence reorganizes your whole case. If your father lived his last years in Los Angeles and died there, the default law of the succession is Californian law, and a California will that disinherits a child is in principle valid, because California — like most American states, Louisiana excepted — gives a testator almost complete freedom to choose his heirs. If instead your father had moved back to Paris, rented out the Los Angeles house, joined a Paris medical practice, and died in the Paris apartment, the default law would be French law, and the disinheritance clause would fail against the children’s guaranteed shares described below. Everything therefore starts with proof of daily life: leases, utility bills, tax filings, medical records, airline records, and witness statements showing where your father really lived. The French Cour de cassation (France’s supreme court for civil matters) treats this as a serious factual fight: on November 18, 2020, in case number 19-15.438, the First Civil Chamber paused a succession dispute to send the European Court of Justice a question about how habitual residence works under the Regulation, because the children said their father lived in France while the widow said he lived in London. The lesson for your family is practical — gather the residence file before arguing about the will. Read the decision on Cour de cassation, 18 November 2020, No. 19-15.438.

The Regulation also lets your father choose the applicable law in advance, but only within a narrow menu. Article 22, paragraph 1 provides that a person may choose the law of the country whose nationality he holds, either when he makes the choice or when he dies, to govern his succession as a whole. An American father can therefore elect American law — for example the law of California — in his will, and France will honor that election for the whole estate, including the Paris apartment. But the menu is deliberately closed: he cannot elect the law of a country whose passport he does not hold just because its inheritance rules please him. Recital 38 explains the reason: limiting the choice to the law of one of the nationalities of the deceased keeps a genuine connection between the deceased and the chosen law and prevents a choice designed to defeat the legitimate expectations of persons entitled to a reserved share. In plain English, Europe lets an American father pick American law, but it watches that pick precisely because children may hold expectations to a reserved share. That tension is the heart of your case, and it explains why the election clause in a will must be written expressly — the Regulation requires the choice to be made expressly, in a declaration that takes the form of a will-type disposition of property upon death, or to be clearly demonstrated by the terms of such a disposition — and why even a valid election does not end the story for the children.

One more American reflex needs correcting. Your father could not split the estate by saying the Paris apartment follows French law while the California accounts follow Californian law. The Regulation imposes one single law on the succession as a whole, covering both the Paris bricks and the American accounts together. The old French system used to split them — French law for French buildings, foreign law for everything else — but that split ended in 2015. Today the Paris notaire applies one law to everything, then France adds a targeted correction for children when that law comes from outside Europe and protects them insufficiently. That correction is the 2021 compensatory levy, explained in Part II. For the companion question of what happens when there is no valid election at all and no French will, see our guide on which law gives the Paris apartment to whom when an American dies without a French will.

B. Why A Foreign Law That Lets A Parent Disinherit Is No Longer Automatically Thrown Out

For decades, French lawyers told disinherited children that any foreign law ignoring the French forced share was automatically contrary to French international public policy and had to be set aside. That comforting statement died on September 27, 2017, in the case everybody in French succession practice calls the Jarre decision, after the composer Maurice Jarre, who died in California leaving a Californian estate plan that largely excluded two of his children. The children asked the French courts to throw out Californian law and apply French forced-share rules to the French assets. The First Civil Chamber of the Cour de cassation refused, in a ruling published in its official Bulletin under appeal number 16-17.198. Its key sentence deserves to be read word for word: “une loi étrangère désignée par la règle de conflit qui ignore la réserve héréditaire n’est pas en soi contraire à l’ordre public international français et ne peut être écartée que si son application concrète, au cas d’espèce, conduit à une situation incompatible avec les principes du droit français considérés comme essentiels”. In English: a foreign law picked by the conflict rule that ignores the forced share is not by itself contrary to French international public policy, and it can only be pushed aside if applying it in this specific case produces a result incompatible with the principles of French law considered essential. The court then looked at the facts — a man settled in California for decades, married there, no child in economic need — and concluded there was no reason to discard Californian law for French law. Read the ruling on Cour de cassation, First Civil Chamber, 27 September 2017, No. 16-17.198.

That ruling changed the advice every American family with French property should receive. Before Jarre, the strategy was simple: invoke French public policy and expect the judge to apply French shares. After Jarre, the judge applies the foreign law first and only corrects it if the concrete outcome shocks essential French principles — for example children left in genuine economic precariousness. A Chicago son with a stable job who receives one dollar under a valid Californian will, from a father durably settled in California, will generally lose a pure public-policy argument under Jarre. This is exactly why the French Parliament stepped in four years later with a statute rather than leaving children to argue public policy case by case.

But Jarre has a mirror image you should know, because it shows when French forced-share rules still win on their own. On July 4, 2018, in case number 17-16.515, the same First Civil Chamber dealt with a Moroccan father’s will, validated by a Moroccan court and declared enforceable in France, that excluded one son from most of the estate. The estate included buildings in France. The court held that those French buildings were governed by French law under the old conflict rule then still relevant to the dispute, and it approved the appeal court for holding that “la dévolution successorale desdits immeubles devait tenir compte des règles de la réserve héréditaire, laquelle, d’ordre public interne, ne pouvait être écartée par des dispositions testamentaires établies selon la loi du domicile du défunt et régissant son statut personnel”. In English: dividing those buildings had to respect the forced-share rules, which, as a matter of French domestic public policy, could not be brushed aside by testamentary provisions made under the law of the deceased’s domicile governing his personal status. Read it on Légifrance, Cour de cassation, First Civil Chamber, 4 July 2018, No. 17-16.515. The two decisions together draw your battle map: when French law governs the assets, the forced share applies directly and no will defeats it; when a foreign law without forced shares governs, Jarre says the judge keeps that law unless the concrete result is intolerable — and then the 2021 statute gives you a second, mechanical remedy that does not depend on proving intolerability at all.

II. How Does An American Child Actually Recover The Money In Practice?

A. How Much Is Guaranteed: Counting The Reserve, Rebuilding The Pot, And Suing For The Shortfall

First, the vocabulary, because every French term below carries a dollar consequence. The réserve héréditaire (forced share or hereditary reserve) is the slice of the estate the law guarantees to certain heirs — in practice the children, and, only when there is no child, the surviving non-divorced spouse. The quotité disponible (disposable portion) is everything else — the slice your father could freely give to anyone, including a second wife, by gift or by will. The Civil Code defines both in one breath at Article 912: “La réserve héréditaire est la part des biens et droits successoraux dont la loi assure la dévolution libre de charges à certains héritiers dits réservataires, s’ils sont appelés à la succession et s’ils l’acceptent. La quotité disponible est la part des biens et droits successoraux qui n’est pas réservée par la loi et dont le défunt a pu disposer librement par des libéralités.” Read Article 912 of the Civil Code on Légifrance. The official English-language guidance of the French administration says the same thing in plain words — “You can’t disinherit your children” — and gives the same fractions below; keep it bookmarked: on Service-Public.fr, see Can you disinherit your children, English version.

Second, the fractions, which are pure arithmetic. Article 913 of the Civil Code provides: “Les libéralités, soit par actes entre vifs, soit par testament, ne pourront excéder la moitié des biens du disposant, s’il ne laisse à son décès qu’un enfant ; le tiers, s’il laisse deux enfants ; le quart, s’il en laisse trois ou un plus grand nombre.” So gifts and legacies combined cannot exceed one-half of the property if your father leaves one child, one-third if he leaves two children, one-quarter if he leaves three or more. Turned around into children’s guaranteed shares: one child is guaranteed one-half of the estate, two children together are guaranteed two-thirds (one-third each), three or more children together are guaranteed three-quarters. Take your family’s numbers: if you are the only child, your forced share is half of the whole succession pot; if you have one sibling, you and your sibling are each guaranteed one-third. When there is no descendant at all, Article 914-1 adds that gifts and legacies “ne pourront excéder les trois quarts des biens si, à défaut de descendant, le défunt laisse un conjoint survivant, non divorcé” — meaning a surviving non-divorced spouse without competing children is guaranteed one-quarter. Read Article 913 of the Civil Code on Légifrance and Article 914-1 of the Civil Code on Légifrance.

Third, the counting method, which is where American families win or lose real money. Your share is not computed on whatever happens to be left in the bank on the day of death. Article 922 of the Civil Code rebuilds a larger fictitious pot: “La réduction se détermine en formant une masse de tous les biens existant au décès du donateur ou testateur. Les biens dont il a été disposé par donation entre vifs sont fictivement réunis à cette masse, d’après leur état à l’époque de la donation et leur valeur à l’ouverture de la succession, après qu’en ont été déduites les dettes ou les charges les grevant.” In practice the notaire lists everything your father owned at death, then fictitiously adds back everything he gave away during his lifetime — the 150,000 euros wired to the second wife five years ago, the Paris studio donated to her daughter — valued as of the death, minus debts. Only on that rebuilt total does the notaire apply your one-half or one-third. Lifetime gifts to the favored heir therefore do not shrink your guarantee; they inflate the pot on which it is computed. Read Article 922 of the Civil Code on Légifrance.

Fourth, the lawsuit that collects the shortfall. When the rebuilt math shows the gifts and legacies ate into your forced share, you bring an action en réduction (reduction action) asking the court to claw back the excess. Since the 2006 reform, the remedy is normally money, not the bricks themselves: Article 924 states “Lorsque la libéralité excède la quotité disponible, le gratifié, successible ou non successible, doit indemniser les héritiers réservataires à concurrence de la portion excessive de la libéralité, quel que soit cet excédent.” The recipient — heir or stranger — must compensate you in cash up to the excessive part, however large it is. Read Article 924 of the Civil Code on Légifrance. Watch the clock, because this action expires: Article 921 sets the limitation period at “cinq ans à compter de l’ouverture de la succession, ou à deux ans à compter du jour où les héritiers ont eu connaissance de l’atteinte portée à leur réserve, sans jamais pouvoir excéder dix ans à compter du décès” — five years from the opening of the succession, or two years from the day the heirs learned their share was impaired, never more than ten years from the death. The same article forces transparency: “Lorsque le notaire constate, lors du règlement de la succession, que les droits réservataires d’un héritier sont susceptibles d’être atteints par les libéralités effectuées par le défunt, il informe chaque héritier concerné et connu, individuellement et, le cas échéant, avant tout partage, de son droit de demander la réduction des libéralités qui excèdent la quotité disponible.” So the Paris notaire who spots the problem must warn you individually, if needed before any division. Read Article 921 of the Civil Code on Légifrance. Concretely: write to the notaire within weeks of learning of the death, demand the full gift history and the rebuilt computation, and calendar the five-year and ten-year limits on day one.

B. The 2021 Safety Net And The Tax Bill: Taking The Compensatory Levy From French Assets, Then Settling French And American Tax

Everything above assumes French law governs. But your father lived in California, so Californian law presumptively governs the whole succession, and Jarre says a French judge will not discard it on public policy alone. This is where the statute of August 24, 2021 — the law reinforcing respect for the principles of the Republic, which rewrote the final paragraph of Article 913 — gives you a mechanical second route that needs no showing of economic distress. Its new final paragraph of Article 913 reads: “Lorsque le défunt ou au moins l’un de ses enfants est, au moment du décès, ressortissant d’un Etat membre de l’Union européenne ou y réside habituellement et lorsque la loi étrangère applicable à la succession ne permet aucun mécanisme réservataire protecteur des enfants, chaque enfant ou ses héritiers ou ses ayants cause peuvent effectuer un prélèvement compensatoire sur les biens existants situés en France au jour du décès, de façon à être rétablis dans les droits réservataires que leur octroie la loi française, dans la limite de ceux-ci.” Read the current wording on Article 913 of the Civil Code on Légifrance.

Unpack that paragraph against your facts, because each condition is a checkpoint. First checkpoint, the European connection: the deceased or at least one of his children must, at the moment of death, be a national of a European Union member state or habitually reside there. Your father was American and lived in California, so his side fails — but if your sibling lives in Lyon, as in many of our files, the sibling’s French habitual residence satisfies the checkpoint for the family, and each child can then claim. If nobody on either side is European by nationality or residence — father in Los Angeles, both children in Chicago — the levy is unavailable and you fall back on the Jarre public-policy argument and negotiation. Second checkpoint, the foreign law must offer children no protective reserved-share mechanism at all; California qualifies, since it lets a parent disinherit. Third checkpoint, the levy bites only “sur les biens existants situés en France au jour du décès” — on assets physically in France on the day of death, meaning the Paris apartment and the French bank balance, not the Ohio brokerage account. Fourth, the top-up restores you only “dans la limite” of your French forced-share rights — it fills your glass to the French level, never above it. Worked example: rebuilt worldwide pot 1,400,000 euros, you are the only child, so your French forced share is 700,000 euros; you actually receive 50,000 euros under the California plan; French-situated assets total 680,000 euros; you levy 650,000 euros from the Paris-side assets and stop there, because 50,000 plus 650,000 equals your 700,000. If the French assets are too small to fill the glass, the remainder stays empty against France — the levy cannot chase the Ohio accounts. For the exact wording, see Article 913 of the Civil Code on Légifrance.

Procedure matters as much as arithmetic. Assert the levy early and in writing to the Paris notaire, before the apartment is sold and the price distributed, because once the money is wired to California your remedy becomes a cross-border collection fight instead of a French set-off. Ask the notaire to freeze distributions pending the rebuilt computation, produce every lifetime gift document, and record your levy claim against the French assets in the settlement deed. If the widow or the notaire contests the European-connection checkpoint or the valuation, the dispute goes to the French courts — typically the judicial court where the French assets sit — and you prove residence with the same file described in Part I: leases, tax notices, school and medical records. Do not sign any American settlement release or any French deed of partition before the levy math is agreed, since a release signed for Californian purposes can be brandished against you in Paris.

Then comes the tax bill, which surprises American families twice. France taxes the transfer itself: the succession must be declared to the French tax authorities, with different deadlines depending on where the death occurred, and French transfer tax is computed per heir on what each receives — with rates climbing steeply for non-relatives and much gentler treatment for children, plus a personal allowance per child that your levy recovery will partly consume. The United States taxes differently: the American estate tax falls on the estate as a whole above a high federal exemption, and you as heir generally receive the assets income-tax-free with a stepped-up basis, while reporting the inheritance to the IRS. The bridge between the two systems is the estate and gift tax treaty signed by France and the United States on November 24, 1978, whose official consolidated text is published by the French tax administration on impots.gouv.fr under France-United States estate and gift tax treaty of 24 November 1978. Its logic is situs-first, credit-second: France taxes the Paris apartment because it sits in France, America taxes its citizen’s worldwide estate, and the treaty lets the estate credit the French tax against the American bill so the same euros are not taxed twice. Keep every French tax receipt, because without proof of French payment the American credit fails. And remember the income-tax afterlife: when you later sell the Paris apartment you recovered through the levy, France will tax the capital gain with the notaire withholding at the sale, while America taxes the gain too and grants a foreign tax credit — the same situs-first, credit-second choreography, one generation later.

Conclusion

An American will that leaves you one dollar does not have the last word when French property exists. First prove where your father really lived, because habitual residence picks the governing law and a written election of American nationality law in the will can confirm it. Then run the French math anyway: rebuild the pot with lifetime gifts, apply your one-half or one-third, and demand the cash shortfall through the reduction action within its five, two, and ten-year limits. If American law governs and protects you insufficiently, check the European-connection checkpoint and take the 2021 compensatory levy directly from the Paris apartment and the French accounts before they are distributed. Finally, declare the succession in France, pay the French transfer tax, and carry the receipts to the American return so the 1978 treaty credit prevents double taxation. Do those five things in that order — residence, election, computation, levy, tax — and a disinheritance written in California becomes, in Paris, a bill to be paid rather than a fate to be accepted.

📄 Official circular