KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
I Live in France and Never Filed FBAR or Form 8938 on My French Accounts: Penalties, Streamlined Fix, and French Disclosure

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

I Live in France and Never Filed FBAR or Form 8938 on My French Accounts: Penalties, Streamlined Fix, and French Disclosure

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

You moved to France, opened a French checking account for rent and groceries, maybe a savings account your bank suggested, and kept your American accounts back home. Years pass. Then a friend mentions FBAR, or your French bank asks for a US tax form, or you read that the IRS can charge 10,000 dollars per missed form, and your stomach drops. If that is your situation, this guide is for you. It explains, in plain English, what American taxpayers living in France owe on both sides of the Atlantic when French and American accounts were never reported, how the American penalties are calculated, how the IRS Streamlined fix works for people whose failure was not willful, and how the French disclosure works with its own fines, so you can clean up both files in the right order with proof of everything you file.

Two tax systems apply to you at the same time. The United States taxes its citizens on worldwide income wherever they live, and it requires separate information reports on foreign accounts: the FBAR (FinCEN Form 114, the Report of Foreign Bank and Financial Accounts) and, for many taxpayers, IRS Form 8938 (the FATCA report attached to the tax return). France taxes people whose tax home is in France on worldwide income and requires them to declare foreign accounts on a special schedule, the formulaire 3916, filed with the French income tax return. Missing either side creates its own penalty, and fixing only one side leaves the other exposed, because the two countries automatically exchange account information every year. The good news is that both systems reward taxpayers who come forward voluntarily before an audit starts, and this article walks through the exact sequence: measure the exposure, fix the American file through the Streamlined procedure when you qualify, fix the French file with late 3916 schedules, and keep the receipts that prove good faith on both sides.

I. What Happens If I Never Filed FBAR or Form 8938 on My French Bank Accounts?

An American living in France typically discovers the problem in one of three ways: the French bank sends a letter asking for a self-certification of US tax status under FATCA (the American law that forces foreign banks to identify American clients and report their accounts to the IRS), a tax preparer asks where the FBARs are, or the taxpayer reads about penalties online and realizes several years were missed. The first step is not panic but measurement. You need to list every account, every year, on each side separately, because the American and French rules count different things, punish different things, and accept different excuses. The sections below calculate each exposure and then show the repair path that fits taxpayers whose conduct was a mistake rather than a scheme.

A. How Are FBAR and Form 8938 Penalties Calculated for French Accounts?

The FBAR is the older and broader of the two American reports. Any United States person with a financial interest in, or signature authority over, foreign financial accounts whose combined highest balances exceed 10,000 dollars at any moment during the year must file FinCEN Form 114 electronically. Combined means you add up all your foreign accounts together, including French checking accounts, savings accounts such as the Livret A or LDDS that your banker opened for you, joint accounts with a spouse, and accounts on which you can sign even if the money is not yours. The deadline follows the tax return calendar with an automatic extension to October 15, and there is no tax due with the form itself: it is purely informational, which is exactly why taxpayers miss it and why the penalty still stings.

The standard FBAR penalty for a non-willful violation, meaning a violation caused by negligence or mistake rather than intent, is up to 10,000 dollars per violation, and the IRS has historically treated each unfiled annual FBAR as one violation rather than penalizing account by account. A willful violation carries the greater of 100,000 dollars or half the account balance, plus possible criminal exposure, which is why everything in the repair strategy turns on documenting that your failure was not willful. Keep that word in mind: non-willful does not mean innocent in a moral sense; it is the technical category the IRS uses for negligence, inadvertence, mistake, and good-faith misunderstanding of the law, and the Streamlined procedure described below is built entirely around certifying it under penalty of perjury.

Form 8938 is the second American report and it travels with your tax return under FATCA. It applies to specified foreign financial assets, a wider category that includes not only bank accounts but also French assurance-vie contracts (a French savings and estate-planning wrapper sold by insurers, part investment and part inheritance tool), shares in a French SCI (a société civile immobilière, the family property company many buyers use to hold a French home), and interests in foreign businesses. The filing thresholds are higher than the FBAR: for a taxpayer living abroad, generally 200,000 dollars on the last day of the year or 300,000 dollars at any point during the year for a single filer, double those figures for joint filers, with lower thresholds for taxpayers living in the United States. The penalty starts at 10,000 dollars per missed form with additional penalties after IRS notice, and unreported income sitting inside those assets, such as interest from a French savings account or gains inside an assurance-vie, can draw accuracy penalties on top.

To make this concrete, take Claire, an American teacher living in Lyon since 2021 with a French checking account, a Livret A, and a joint account with her French husband, plus a US checking account. Her combined French balances exceeded 10,000 dollars every year, so she owed four FBARs for 2021 through 2024 and never filed any. Her theoretical non-willful exposure is up to 10,000 dollars per missed year, while her actual exposure under the Streamlined fix below is typically zero penalty if she qualifies as non-willful and lives outside the United States, plus any small unpaid tax on unreported French interest with interest. Contrast Marc, an American executive in Paris with 400,000 dollars across French accounts and an assurance-vie, who also missed Form 8938: his file needs both the FBARs and the 8938s, and the assurance-vie earnings must be analyzed year by year because France and the United States tax that wrapper at different moments. The lesson is the same in both cases: list accounts, find highest balances from December statements, identify unreported income, and only then choose the repair lane, because the right lane depends on the numbers and on willfulness, not on fear.

Three related American filings often surface during the same cleanup and should be checked while the statements are on the table. Owners of shares in French mutual funds or ETFs held outside a US brokerage may face the PFIC regime (passive foreign investment company, the punitive American tax system for foreign pooled investments) with Form 8621; our dedicated guide covers that trap in detail at American in France Holding French ETFs? How to Beat the PFIC Trap. Holders of a French PEA (plan d’épargne en actions, the French stock savings plan with its own tax wrapper) face closure and reporting questions covered at Can an American Keep a French PEA After Returning to the United States?. And taxpayers who already received letters from a French bank about their American status should read My French Bank Refused to Open an Account Because I Am American for the account-access side of FATCA. None of these replaces the FBAR and 8938 analysis; they ride alongside it.

B. How Does the IRS Streamlined Procedure Fix Missed FBAR and Form 8938 Filings?

The IRS Streamlined Filing Compliance Procedures are the main road back for taxpayers whose failure was not willful. The program states its entry condition bluntly: Taxpayers must certify that conduct was not willful. It then defines the category you must fit: Non-willful conduct is conduct that is due to negligence, inadvertence, or mistake or conduct that is the result of a good faith misunderstanding of the requirements of the law. Those two sentences, quoted word for word from the current IRS guidance, decide whether Streamlined is open to you. If you knew about the FBAR, were warned by a preparer, received an IRS notice, or hid the accounts behind structures, do not use Streamlined; the regular voluntary disclosure practice for willful cases, with its higher penalties, is the honest lane and using the wrong lane can turn a civil cleanup into a criminal problem.

Americans living in France normally use the Streamlined Foreign Offshore Procedures, the track for taxpayers who meet a foreign-residency test. The package covers three years of delinquent or amended income tax returns with all required information returns including Form 8938, plus six years of delinquent FBARs, together with a written narrative statement of the facts and the non-willful certification signed under penalties of perjury. The prize for qualifying on the foreign track is simple: no miscellaneous offshore penalty, meaning the 5 percent penalty that applies on the domestic track does not apply to you, and prior programs confirm that the IRS processes these packages without an interview when the story is coherent. Taxpayers who already tried a quiet disclosure, meaning they simply mailed late returns outside any program, should note the warning in the same guidance: Taxpayers eligible to use streamlined procedures who have previously filed delinquent or amended returns must pay previous penalty assessments, so earlier penalties already assessed do not wash away and the package must disclose them.

Preparation is where these cases are won or lost. For each of the six FBAR years, reconstruct the highest balance of every French account from year-end statements, bank attestations, or screenshots of online archives, and keep a spreadsheet that ties each number to a document, because the certification is signed under oath and the examiner checks arithmetic first. For the three return years, report worldwide income including French bank interest, French rental income if any, and the American-source income already on your returns, then claim the foreign earned income exclusion or foreign tax credits where they genuinely apply; many France-based Americans overpay in the cleanup because they forget the credit for French tax already withheld on French-source interest. File the FBARs electronically through the FinCEN portal and mail or e-file the return package exactly as the current IRS instructions direct, since the procedures change in detail from year to year, and keep certified-mail receipts or electronic acknowledgments for every submission. Expect the IRS to take several months to process the package, to cash any check for tax due quickly, and to send closing letters separately for the returns and, sometimes, nothing at all for the FBARs, which is normal and should be logged rather than feared.

Two traps kill otherwise good Streamlined packages. The first is amending only the returns while forgetting the information forms: an 8938 attached without its underlying income, or FBARs filed with balances that do not match the interest reported, invites questions that a consistent package would never have raised. The second is the narrative statement: one paragraph saying you did not know is not a story, while a dated account of arrival in France, bank visits, language barriers, preparer conversations, and the moment of discovery, each tied to a document, is. Retirees with American pensions taxed in France under the treaty should coordinate this cleanup with the pension reporting explained at How Is a U.S. 401(k) Taxed in France for an American Retiree?, because pension income belongs in the same three return years. And anyone whose French holdings include an assurance-vie used for estate planning should cross-check the beneficiary and reporting analysis at How Can an American Use French Assurance-Vie to Pass Wealth Tax-Efficiently before signing the certification.

II. How Do I Fix My French Disclosure and Prove My Accounts Are Clean?

France runs a mirror-image system with its own logic: every French tax resident declares foreign accounts at the same time as the annual income return, and every failure draws its own fine per account per year, on top of the tax and surcharges on any unreported income. An American who fixes only the IRS file while ignoring the French file remains exposed in the country where she lives, banks, and may one day be audited, and the French administration learns about American accounts automatically through the same FATCA and common-reporting-standard exchanges that send French balances to the IRS. The sections below lay out the French filing duty with its exact legal wording, the French fines with their exact figures, and the evidence kit that satisfies both administrations at once.

A. How Do I File Form 3916 and Declare My US Accounts to France?

French tax residence is the trigger, and it is defined broadly. Les personnes qui ont en France leur domicile fiscal sont passibles de l’impôt sur le revenu en raison de l’ensemble de leurs revenus, provides Article 4 A of the French Tax Code (Code général des impôts, the statute that contains most French tax rules), and Article 4 B treats as French tax residents persons who have their home or principal place of stay in France: Les personnes qui ont en France leur foyer ou le lieu de leur séjour principal. In practice, an American renting a Paris apartment year-round, enrolled in French healthcare, with children in French schools, is a French tax resident from arrival, and the mid-year arrival mechanics are covered in our guide to the first French return. Once resident, the worldwide principle follows: American interest, dividends, and capital gains are reportable in France with treaty relief, not exempt from declaration.

The declaration duty itself is written in Article 1649 A, and its second paragraph is the sentence every American in France should know: Les personnes physiques, les associations, les sociétés n’ayant pas la forme commerciale, domiciliées ou établies en France, sont tenues de déclarer, en même temps que leur déclaration de revenus ou de résultats, les références des comptes ouverts, détenus, utilisés ou clos à l’étranger. The official service-public explainer confirms the scope in everyday terms: any account opened, held, used, or closed abroad during the year, reported with the income return on schedule 3916 (the formulaire 3916, officially the declaration by a resident of an account opened abroad, filed as an annex to the French return), with the 3916-bis schedule for digital-asset accounts, as described at Doit-on déclarer les comptes ouverts à l’étranger ?. The tax office’s own FAQ adds the practical pointer Americans need: La déclaration des comptes se fait en même temps que votre déclaration de revenus, en sélectionnant les formulaires annexes n° 3916 / 3916 bis. Concretely, your American checking account, savings account, brokerage account, and any account on which you hold signature authority are each one line on a 3916, filed every year the account existed, including the year you closed it.

The French fines are fixed per account and they stack by year. Les infractions aux dispositions du deuxième alinéa de l’article 1649 A et de l’article 1649 A bis sont passibles d’une amende de 1 500 € par compte ou avance non déclaré, states Article 1736, paragraph IV, and the same paragraph continues: ce montant est porté à 10 000 € par compte non déclaré lorsque l’obligation déclarative concerne un Etat ou un territoire qui n’a pas conclu avec la France une convention d’assistance administrative en vue de lutter contre la fraude et l’évasion fiscales permettant l’accès aux renseignements bancaires. For American accounts the 1,500 euro figure normally applies because the France-United States information-exchange relationship exists, and the official service-public page confirms the pair of figures in plain language: Amende forfaitaire de 1 500 € par compte non déclaré, rising to Amende forfaitaire de 10 000 € par compte non déclaré, si le compte est situé dans un État qui n’a pas conclu avec la France de convention de lutte contre la fraude et l’évasion fiscales. Where unreported income sat in the undeclared account, a further surcharge of 80 percent of the tax due can replace the fixed fine, which is why the cleanup must declare both the account and its income together rather than filing a bare 3916.

Late filing is possible and it is far better than waiting for the audit letter. File or amend the French returns for the open years with a 3916 per account per year, pay the tax on any omitted interest or gains, and attach a short letter explaining the discovery, the American cleanup running in parallel, and the request for leniency on penalties for a first spontaneous regularization. The general late-filing surcharges frame the negotiation: Le défaut de production dans les délais prescrits d’une déclaration ou d’un acte comportant l’indication d’éléments à retenir pour l’assiette ou la liquidation de l’impôt entraîne l’application, sur le montant des droits mis à la charge du contribuable ou résultant de la déclaration ou de l’acte déposé tardivement, d’une majoration de : a. 10 % en l’absence de mise en demeure, with 40 percent after a formal demand goes unanswered for thirty days, and deliberate failures drawing 40 % en cas de manquement délibéré up to 80 % en cas de manœuvres frauduleuses ou de dissimulation d’une partie du prix stipulé dans un contrat under Article 1729 (manquement délibéré means a deliberate failure to comply, and manœuvres frauduleuses means fraudulent maneuvers such as concealment). A taxpayer who comes forward spontaneously, before any mise en demeure (a formal demand letter from the administration), with complete statements and consistent American filings, presents the classic profile for penalty moderation, while a taxpayer who files the 3916 but omits the income, or declares the income without the 3916, hands the auditor a contradiction. File both, together, with the bank records attached.

B. What Proof, Deadlines, and Exchange of Information Apply to Americans in France?

The two cleanups must tell the same story because the two administrations compare notes. France and the United States exchange financial-account information automatically every year: French banks report American clients to the IRS through FATCA, and American banks report French residents to France through the common reporting standard and the treaty network. That exchange has teeth inside the audit rules. Lorsque l’administration a, dans le délai initial de reprise, demandé à l’autorité compétente d’un autre Etat ou territoire des renseignements concernant un contribuable, elle peut réparer les omissions ou les insuffisances d’imposition afférentes à cette demande, même si le délai initial de reprise est écoulé, jusqu’à la fin de la deuxième année qui suit celle de la réception de la réponse, provides Article L188 A of the Tax Procedure Book (Livre des procédures fiscales, the statute governing audits and collection), which means a foreign-information request can extend the French audit window for the items it covers. The practical message is direct: undeclared accounts are the category most likely to trigger exactly such a request, so voluntary correction before any request or audit notice is worth far more than the same correction afterwards.

The French courts apply these fines routinely, and two Conseil d’État rulings (the Conseil d’État is France’s highest court for tax disputes) show the pattern. In a 2019 case about two Luxembourg accounts punished under Article 1736, paragraph IV, the court recorded: M. et Mme B… ont fait l’objet d’un examen contradictoire de situation fiscale personnelle portant sur les années 2008 à 2010 à l’issue duquel l’administration fiscale leur a infligé l’amende prévue par les dispositions du IV de l’article 1736 du code général des impôts pour défaut de déclaration de deux comptes ouverts au Luxembourg auprès de la banque BGL BNP Paribas (Conseil d’État, 10th and 9th chambers combined, March 4, 2019, No. 410492; an examen contradictoire de situation fiscale personnelle is an in-depth personal tax audit in which the administration reconstructs income from bank movements). In a 2018 ruling on the same fine across four years, the court summarized: M. B…a été assujetti, au titre de chacune des années 2008 à 2011, à l’amende prévue au IV de l’article 1736 du code général des impôts, qui réprime notamment les infractions à l’obligation, prévue à l’article 1649 A du même code, de déclarer les références des comptes ouverts, utilisés ou clos à l’étranger (Conseil d’État, February 7, 2018, No. 402034, decided after the 2016 constitutional ruling on the old proportional fine). Both decisions confirm the same architecture you face today: one fixed fine per undeclared account per year, applied mechanically once the omission is established, with constitutional proportionality reviewable only on proper challenge.

Build one evidence kit and use it on both sides. For every year under correction, keep the December statement of each American and French account, the opening and closing letters for accounts opened or closed during the period, the 3916 copies filed in France with the tax-office receipt, the FBAR acknowledgments from the FinCEN portal, the three years of American returns with Forms 8938, and a one-page reconciliation table showing, per account per year, the highest balance, the interest reported in each country, and the document that proves each figure. Note the French safety valve for spontaneous correction of income returns: Le retard ou le défaut de souscription des déclarations qui doivent être déposées en vue de l’établissement de l’impôt sur le revenu ainsi que les inexactitudes ou les omissions relevées dans ces déclarations, qui ont pour effet de minorer l’impôt dû par le contribuable ou de majorer une créance à son profit, donnent lieu au versement d’une majoration égale à 10 % des droits mis à la charge du contribuable ou de la créance indue, with the increase waived for taxpayers who correct spontaneously or within thirty days of a request. Calendar discipline matters: the French income return with 3916 annexes is due each May or June, the FBAR follows the American return calendar to October 15 with automatic extension, and the Streamlined package should go first or simultaneously so the French letter can reference an American file already regularized rather than merely promised.

Order the work to avoid self-inflicted contradictions. First, freeze the facts: download every statement before banks rotate their online archives, and stop moving money between accounts until the highest-balance table is final, because transfers create double-counted peaks that need explanation. Second, prepare the American Streamlined package and the French amended returns from the same spreadsheet so no balance differs between the FBAR, the 8938, and the 3916 for the same account and year. Third, file the American package, file the French corrections, then answer every follow-up letter with the same table updated, never with new numbers invented under pressure. Two common errors ruin cleanups at this stage: certifying non-willfulness while holding an email from a banker who warned about FBAR years ago, which belongs in the willful lane with counsel, and filing French 3916 schedules that list the accounts while the American narrative claims no account existed, which the exchange of information will expose. Consistency across both files is the entire strategy; the penalties reward it and the exchange network punishes its absence.

Conclusion

An American in France who never filed FBAR or Form 8938, and never filed the French 3916 for American accounts, faces two parallel exposures with two parallel remedies. On the American side, non-willful taxpayers living abroad can usually repair three years of returns with Forms 8938 and six years of FBARs through the Streamlined Foreign Offshore Procedures with no offshore penalty, provided the certification of non-willful conduct is truthful, documented, and consistent with the bank records. On the French side, the same taxpayer files late 3916 schedules with the income returns, one per account per year, pays the tax on omitted income, and seeks moderation of the 1,500 euro fixed fine per undeclared account against the profile of a spontaneous first-time correction. The decisions and statutes are mechanical once an audit starts, which is exactly why voluntary action before any notice changes the outcome: file the same numbers on both sides, keep every acknowledgment, and close the file in the year of discovery rather than letting the exchange of information open it for you.

📄 Official circular