KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
I Am an American Living in France: How Do I Become French by Naturalization Decree?

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

I Am an American Living in France: How Do I Become French by Naturalization Decree?

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

You have lived in France for years on a carte de séjour, the residence permit that must be renewed again and again. You pay French taxes, your children go to a French school, your French is decent, and every election reminds you that you cannot vote. A French passport would end the renewals, open every European border without a second thought, and give you the right to vote where you actually live. If you have a French parent or grandparent, another path may fit you better, and our descent and nationality-certificate pillar walks through that bloodline route in detail. If you married a French citizen, the declaration route through marriage has its own shorter clock. But for the American whose claim rests on a life built in France itself, year after year, the road is the naturalization decree, the décret de naturalisation. This guide explains that road as it stands now, after the 2026 tightening that raised the language bar and added a civic exam. It covers who qualifies, what assimilation really means in practice, how the online file moves from the prefecture to the minister’s desk, what the decree changes for you and your minor children, and how to challenge a refusal without missing the short deadlines that kill most appeals.

One warning belongs at the very top, because it shapes every decision below. Naturalization by decree is a favor, not a right. Even when you meet every written condition, the administration may still say no, and the courts give it wide latitude to do so. An appeals court in Nantes recalled in a 2025 ruling on a postponed application, discussed in detail below, that the administration enjoys broad discretion, the large pouvoir d’appréciation, over naturalization files. That principle means the minister’s assessment of whether granting you citizenship serves any useful purpose carries real weight. The practical consequence is simple: a thin file invites refusal, while a thick, documented, patiently prepared file leaves the administration with no good reason to turn you down and gives a judge something to work with if it does. Everything that follows is written in that spirit.

I. Can an American Living in France Be Naturalized by Decree After Five Years?

A. Five Years of Habitual, Lawful Residence in France, and the Shortcuts That Cut the Wait to Two Years or Zero

The starting point is a single sentence of the Civil Code. Article 21-15 of the Civil Code provides: “Hors le cas prévu à l’article 21-14-1 , l’acquisition de la nationalité française par décision de l’autorité publique résulte d’une naturalisation accordée par décret à la demande de l’étranger.” Acquisition of French nationality by decision of the public authority comes from a naturalization granted by decree at the foreigner’s request. Three ideas sit inside that sentence. First, the initiative is yours: nobody is naturalized automatically, and the file starts only when you apply. Second, the decision belongs to the public authority, which is why the whole process feels discretionary. Third, the instrument is a decree, signed at the highest level of the executive and published in the official gazette, which explains both the solemnity of the outcome and the length of the wait.

The residence clock is the first substantive hurdle. Article 21-17 of the Civil Code provides: “Sous réserve des exceptions prévues aux articles 21-18 , 21-19 et 21-20 , la naturalisation ne peut être accordée qu’à l’étranger justifiant d’une résidence habituelle en France pendant les cinq années qui précèdent le dépôt de la demande.” Five years of habitual residence in France before filing. Habitual means real, continuous, settled life, not a mailing address visited twice a year. The prefecture, the préfecture, the local arm of the state that instructs your file, looks at where you actually sleep, work, file taxes, send your children to school, and keep your bank accounts. Long unexplained absences break the picture, and applicants who spent most of each year in the United States while keeping a French apartment routinely discover that their five years do not count. Short trips, family visits, and American work travel do not reset the clock, but the center of your private and professional life must read as French when the investigator opens the file. A companion rule tightens the frame at the other end: Article 21-16 of the Civil Code provides: “Nul ne peut être naturalisé s’il n’a en France sa résidence au moment de la signature du décret de naturalisation.” You must still reside in France when the decree is signed, so the applicant who files after five years and then moves back to Ohio while the file sits in a queue can lose everything at the finish line. Stay put until the decree is published.

Residence alone is not enough; it must be lawful residence. Article 21-27 of the Civil Code closes the door bluntly: “Nul ne peut acquérir la nationalité française ou être réintégré dans cette nationalité s’il a été l’objet soit d’une condamnation pour crimes ou délits constituant une atteinte aux intérêts fondamentaux de la Nation ou un acte de terrorisme, soit, quelle que soit l’infraction considérée, s’il a été condamné à une peine égale ou supérieure à six mois d’emprisonnement, non assortie d’une mesure de sursis. Il en est de même de celui qui a fait l’objet soit d’un arrêté d’expulsion non expressément rapporté ou abrogé, soit d’une interdiction du territoire français non entièrement exécutée. Il en est de même de celui dont le séjour en France est irrégulier au regard des lois et conventions relatives au séjour des étrangers en France.” Anyone whose stay is irregular under the laws on foreigners is barred, and the same article bars people under an unlifted expulsion order or an unexecuted ban from French territory. For Americans this is rarely dramatic, but it has teeth in ordinary situations: a retiree who let a residence permit lapse for months, a remote worker who lived in France on a tourist stamp while waiting for paperwork, or a student who fell out of status between two permits can all face an inadmissibility finding, the irrecevabilité, that stops the file before its merits are even examined. Keep every permit, every renewal receipt, the récépissé handed over while a renewal is processed, and a continuous tax record. The five-year story must read as five lawful years.

The statute then carves out the shortcuts, and two of them matter for Americans. Article 21-18 of the Civil Code provides: “Le stage mentionné à l’article 21-17 est réduit à deux ans : 1° Pour l’étranger qui a accompli avec succès deux années d’études supérieures en vue d’acquérir un diplôme délivré par une université ou un établissement d’enseignement supérieur français ; 2° Pour celui qui a rendu ou qui peut rendre par ses capacités et ses talents des services importants à la France ; 3° Pour l’étranger qui présente un parcours exceptionnel d’intégration, apprécié au regard des activités menées ou des actions accomplies dans les domaines civique, scientifique, économique, culturel ou sportif.” Two years of higher education completed successfully toward a French university degree cuts the wait to two years, which helps the American who earned a master’s in Lyon or Paris and stayed. The talents clause and the exceptional-integration clause help founders, researchers, artists, and athletes with a documented record, though the bar sits high and the file must prove the claim with contracts, publications, prizes, press coverage, or institutional letters, not adjectives. Beyond that, Article 21-19 of the Civil Code lists cases with no waiting period at all, including one worth quoting in full: “4° L’étranger qui a effectivement accompli des services militaires dans une unité de l’armée française ou qui, en temps de guerre, a contracté un engagement volontaire dans les armées françaises ou alliées ;” along with cases of exceptional service to France or an exceptional interest for France, decided after a reasoned opinion of the Council of State. Few Americans qualify, but dual-national veterans and people with a documented record of service should check the list before assuming the five-year rule applies to them.

One last residence trap deserves attention because it hits American retirees hardest. Professional integration counts as part of assimilation, and the service-public guide says plainly that stable and sufficient income to support yourself and your tax household is essential. A retiree with a solid American pension, regular transfers into a French bank account, French tax filings, and a owned or long-leased home paints a convincing picture. A retiree with erratic income, no French tax history, and most assets still managed exclusively from the United States invites the objection that the center of economic life never moved. The fix is administrative rather than legal: file French returns every year, keep the paper trail of transfers and housing, join local life in ways that leave traces, and arrive at the interview with a file that already answers the investigator’s questions. Residence is proved the way everything is proved in French administration, with dated paper, not with sincerity.

B. Assimilation in 2026: Strong French, the New Civic Exam, Republican Values, a Clean Record, and Stable Resources

Assimilation to the French community, the assimilation à la communauté française, is the soul of the file and the ground on which most American applications succeed or fail. Article 21-24 of the Civil Code sets the current standard in full: “Nul ne peut être naturalisé s’il ne justifie de son assimilation à la communauté française, notamment par une connaissance suffisante, selon sa condition, de la langue, de l’histoire, de la culture et de la société françaises, dont le niveau et les modalités d’évaluation sont fixés par décret en Conseil d’Etat, et des droits et devoirs conférés par la nationalité française ainsi que par l’adhésion aux principes et aux valeurs essentiels de la République. L’intéressé justifie d’un niveau de langue lui permettant au moins de comprendre le contenu essentiel de sujets concrets ou abstraits dans un texte complexe, de communiquer avec spontanéité, de s’exprimer de façon claire et détaillée sur une grande variété de sujets. A l’issue du contrôle de son assimilation, l’intéressé signe la charte des droits et devoirs du citoyen français. Cette charte, approuvée par décret en Conseil d’Etat, rappelle les principes, valeurs et symboles essentiels de la République française.” Read that language paragraph carefully: understanding complex texts, communicating with spontaneity, speaking clearly and in detail on a wide range of subjects. That is the statutory portrait of an independent, fluent speaker, and since the start of 2026 the implementing rules treat it as the B2 level of the European reference framework, up from the B1 level that applied for years. The applicant proves it with the diplomas and attestations listed on the official service-public language-proof page, and the file must contain the qualifying diploma or attestation on the day it is filed, not promised for later. An American who studied French for two years at college, speaks tourist French correctly, but cannot sustain a detailed conversation about work, current events, or civic life should treat the language test as the main project of the year, take courses to a documented B2 result, and only then file.

Since 2026 a second written hurdle stands beside the language proof: the civic exam, the examen civique. The official service-public exam page explains that the exam applies to nationality by decree and tests assimilation through knowledge of French history, culture, and society plus the rights and duties that citizenship confers. In practice it takes the form of a multiple-choice questionnaire written in French, forty questions mixing pure knowledge with situational judgment, and the file must include the attestation of success. The program, the papers, and the organization were set by the order of 10 October 2025, and preparation materials including the citizen’s booklet, the livret du citoyen, are published through the same official channels. Exemptions and adjustments exist only for health or disability reasons, duly documented, so the ordinary American applicant should simply plan for the exam the way a student plans for a final: read the booklet, work through the published question lists, sit the exam early enough that a failure leaves time to retake before filing, and keep the attestation with the language diploma as the two crown jewels of the file. Candidates who prepared under the old regime, where a prefecture interview alone carried the civic assessment, need to update their expectations: the interview remains, and it still matters enormously, but it no longer stands alone.

The interview itself, the entretien d’assimilation held at the prefecture, is where paper meets person. An officer verifies that the applicant understands everyday and abstract French, can discuss familiar subjects and personal interests coherently, knows the basics of French institutions and values, and adheres to republican principles. Adhesion here is not a loyalty oath to a party or a president; it means accepting equality between women and men, secularism in public life, the laïcité that structures French public institutions, and the authority of republican law over any competing rule, including religious or community rules. At the close of the process the applicant signs the charter of rights and duties of the French citizen, the charte des droits et devoirs du citoyen français, which restates the Republic’s essential principles, values, and symbols. Americans sometimes stumble on two points worth flagging. First, polygamy or a declared refusal of republican values ends the file; the administration treats these as structural incompatibility, not private opinion. Second, the interview is graded against the file: claims of fluent French collapse quickly when the applicant cannot follow the officer’s questions, and claims of integration collapse when the applicant knows nothing of local civic life. Prepare the interview as an oral exam with real stakes, in French, about your actual French life.

Good morals and a clean record form the third pillar, and Americans consistently underestimate how broadly the administration reads them. Article 21-23 of the Civil Code provides: “Nul ne peut être naturalisé s’il n’est pas de bonnes vie et moeurs ou s’il a fait l’objet de l’une des condamnations visées à l’article 21-27 du présent code. Les condamnations prononcées à l’étranger pourront toutefois ne pas être prises en considération ; en ce cas, le décret prononçant la naturalisation ne pourra être pris qu’après avis conforme du Conseil d’Etat.” Good life and morals, the bonnes vie et mœurs, plus the convictions listed in Article 21-27, whose six-month unsuspended-prison threshold and terrorism and national-security bars were quoted above. Foreign convictions may be set aside, but only with the Council of State’s concurring opinion, which adds months and uncertainty. In daily practice the inquiry sweeps wider than criminal court: unpaid taxes, undeclared work, benefit fraud, repeated road offenses, and even a pattern of driving without a license all feed the conduct assessment, the enquête sur le comportement, which expressly examines civic behavior such as paying taxes. The case discussed in the second part below, where a two-year postponement was upheld over a single episode of driving despite an order to surrender the license, shows how a seemingly minor American habit, treating a suspended license as a technicality, reads in a French file. Pay every tax bill on time for the full five years, clear any fine the day it arrives, and if a conviction exists anywhere, disclose it with the judgment and proof of execution rather than letting the administration discover it.

A January 2026 appeals ruling shows exactly how the assimilation standard is applied to a real person, and its lesson is sobering for long-term residents. In CAA Nantes, 6th chamber, 13 January 2026, no. 25NT00015, an applicant with twenty-two years of residence in France challenged the rejection of her file. The court first recalled the framework: “Dans le cadre de cet examen d’opportunité, il peut légalement prendre en compte le degré d’assimilation à la société française du postulant.” The interview record was devastating: “elle n’a ainsi notamment pas su expliquer ce qu’était la Révolution française, ni la signification de la fête nationale, ni donner le nom de l’hymne national.” She could neither explain the French Revolution, nor the meaning of the national holiday, nor the name of the national anthem, and the report rated her French as weak. Health and stress arguments failed for lack of proof, and the court concluded that “le ministre a pu, eu égard au large pouvoir d’appréciation dont il dispose pour apprécier l’opportunité d’accorder la nationalité française au ressortissant étranger qui la sollicite, rejeter la demande de naturalisation de Mme C… pour les motifs mentionnés ci-dessus sans commettre d’erreur manifeste d’appréciation.” Two lessons carry into American files. First, years of residence never compensate for a failed interview: twenty-two years did not save a file with weak French and no civic knowledge. Second, the interview record rules: the prefecture’s written report outweighs every outside testimonial and every excuse raised for the first time on appeal, so the interview and the civic exam must be prepared and passed, never assumed.

II. What Happens After an American Files on ANEF, and How Do You Fight a Refusal?

A. The Online File, the Interview and Inquiry, the Decree, and What It Changes for You and Your Children

Filing runs through the national digital window, and the service-public naturalization guide describes each step. The request is sent online through the dedicated portal, with the civic-exam attestation, the language diploma or attestation, civil-status records with sworn translations where needed, proof of residence over the full qualifying period, tax notices, employment or pension evidence, and the fee payment attached. Keep the originals: even with an online filing, the summons to the interview requires producing original documents for verification. After sending, the applicant receives an electronic acknowledgment, and the prefecture checks completeness. Missing pieces trigger an online request for supplements with a fixed deadline, and the guide warns that an applicant who lets the deadline pass sees the file closed without examination, the classement sans suite, notified with its avenues of appeal. If the family, work, housing, or address situation changes after the filing receipt, the administration must be informed through the personal online account. Then come the two substantive stages: the assimilation interview at the prefecture and the conduct and integration inquiry, covering taxes, work, housing, and civic behavior. Only a complete, updated, consistent file reaches the minister with a favorable opinion, so treat every administrative letter as urgent and answer inside the stated time.

The decision itself belongs to Paris. The prefect proposes, the minister in charge of naturalizations decides, and a favorable outcome takes the form of a decree published in the official gazette, the Journal officiel. Article 27-1 of the Civil Code adds: “Les décrets portant acquisition, naturalisation ou réintégration, autorisation de perdre la nationalité française, perte ou déchéance de cette nationalité, sont pris et publiés dans des formes fixées par décret. Ils n’ont point d’effet rétroactif.” The decree is not retroactive: you become French on its date, and everything before that date, from past elections to past administrative situations, stays as it was. From publication forward, the change is complete: the right to vote in all French elections, eligibility for the French passport and national identity card through the consulate or the town hall, full establishment rights across the European Union as a Union citizen, and access to public-sector positions reserved to nationals. Minor children ride along when the paperwork anticipates them. Article 22-1 of the Civil Code provides: “L’enfant mineur dont l’un des deux parents acquiert la nationalité française, devient français de plein droit s’il a la même résidence habituelle que ce parent ou s’il réside alternativement avec ce parent dans le cas de séparation ou divorce. Les dispositions du présent article ne sont applicables à l’enfant d’une personne qui acquiert la nationalité française par décision de l’autorité publique ou par déclaration de nationalité que si son nom est mentionné dans le décret ou dans la déclaration.” The collective effect for a decree child is therefore conditional on one administrative detail: the child’s name must appear in the decree. List every minor child living with you in the application, attach their records, and verify the draft details before publication, because a forgotten child gains nothing automatically and needs a separate procedure later. On the American side, the United States guidance on dual nationality confirms that American law does not block citizens from acquiring another citizenship and that dual nationals simply owe allegiance to both countries, so becoming French by decree does not cost you your American passport.

One final warning attaches to the decree, and honesty is the only policy. Article 27-2 of the Civil Code provides: “Les décrets portant acquisition, naturalisation ou réintégration peuvent être rapportés sur avis conforme du Conseil d’Etat dans le délai de deux ans à compter de leur publication au Journal officiel si le requérant ne satisfait pas aux conditions légales ; si la décision a été obtenue par mensonge ou fraude, ces décrets peuvent être rapportés dans le délai de deux ans à partir de la découverte de la fraude.” A decree obtained by lies or fraud can be withdrawn within two years of the fraud’s discovery. Concealed convictions, invented employment, a sham address, or a hidden second household are not shortcuts; they are time bombs that can strip away citizenship years later, with downstream effects on documents issued in the meantime. Disclose the awkward fact with its explanation and proof of correction instead. A decade-old American misdemeanor with the court record and evidence of a clean life since is a paragraph in the file; the same conviction discovered by the investigator is a reason to doubt everything else the file contains.

B. Inadmissibility, Adjournment, or Rejection: the Mandatory Appeal to the Minister, Then the Court in Nantes

An unfavorable answer takes one of three legal forms, and naming it correctly dictates the response. Inadmissibility, the irrecevabilité, says a threshold condition is missing: irregular stay, insufficient residence period, missing diploma, failed civic exam, or defective assimilation at the interview. Adjournment, the ajournement, says the file could succeed later and imposes a waiting period or conditions, typically one to three years to demonstrate stable integration, complete a language program, or confirm good conduct over time. Rejection, the rejet, says no even on the merits, usually for conduct, values, or security reasons. Every one of these decisions must be reasoned. Article 27 of the Civil Code provides: “Toute décision déclarant irrecevable, ajournant ou rejetant une demande d’acquisition, de naturalisation ou de réintégration par décret ainsi qu’une autorisation de perdre la nationalité française doit être motivée.” Read the stated reasons line by line, because the appeal must answer them one by one rather than resubmitting the same file with a cover letter.

The first appeal is mandatory, administrative, and short. Within two months of notification, the applicant files a reasoned hierarchical appeal to the minister in charge of naturalizations, the recours administratif préalable obligatoire, asking for reconsideration and attaching whatever cures the stated reasons: the missing diploma, the new civic-exam attestation, proof of cleared tax arrears, evidence of completed language training, or documents the prefecture overlooked. The governing decree, as recalled in a 2025 ruling examined below, requires the applicant to explain in the appeal why reconsideration is sought. The appeal may be prepared with counsel or any chosen representative, and it is a compulsory gateway: skipping it makes any later court case inadmissible. The same ruling recalls the minister’s answer clock: silence kept for more than four months counts as rejection of the appeal, opening the judicial phase. Docket both dates on receipt of the refusal, day one for the two-month filing deadline and month four for the implied rejection, and use the waiting time to build exhibits rather than to hope.

The same 2025 ruling illustrates how adjournment works and how hard it is to overturn. In CAA Nantes, 5th chamber, 1 April 2025, no. 23NT03872, the minister had postponed a file for two years because the applicant had driven a car despite an order to surrender her license after losing all her points, an offense punished by a 300-euro criminal fine shortly before the decision. The lower court had annulled the postponement, but the appeals court reversed, holding that given the relatively recent and not-insignificant facts, “le ministre pouvait, eu égard au large pouvoir d’appréciation dont il dispose, ajourner à deux ans la demande de naturalisation de Mme B…, sans entacher sa décision d’erreur manifeste d’appréciation.” Even though she held a full license again by decision day, the minister could lawfully impose the two-year wait without manifest error of assessment. For Americans the message is blunt: road and regulatory offenses that feel trivial in the United States read as civic-behavior evidence in France, and a file carrying a fresh conviction should usually wait until the facts age and the conduct record runs clean for a visible period rather than marching into a predictable adjournment. Where the postponement has already been pronounced, the remedy is patience with proof: serve the waiting period impeccably, accumulate tax notices, pay slips or pension statements, language progress, and community ties, then refile with a record that answers the original reasons.

The court phase belongs to Nantes. Challenges to naturalization decisions go to the administrative court of Nantes, the tribunal administratif de Nantes, with appeal to the city’s administrative appeals court and, ultimately, cassation review before the Council of State for legal error. The judge does not regrade the file from scratch or substitute personal judgment for the minister’s; review centers on legality, factual accuracy, and the manifest-error standard for discretionary assessment. That is a narrow window, which is why the strongest cases show either a factual mistake, such as a conviction wrongly attributed or residence years miscounted, a procedural defect, such as a missing interview or an unreasoned decision, or a disproportion between the stated reason and the outcome, such as rejection where a short adjournment would have sufficed. Attach everything in chronological order with translations, number the exhibits, answer each stated reason under its own heading, and file within the two-month litigation deadline running from the express or implied rejection of the ministerial appeal. An applicant who fixes the underlying weakness during the proceedings, passes the civic exam, earns the language diploma, clears the arrears, and documents it, arrives as a different candidate than the one who was refused, and judges notice the difference even when the standard of review stays deferential.

Conclusion

Naturalization by decree rewards the American who treats France as a permanent home and proves it on paper: five years of habitual and lawful residence with the center of life visibly French, strong B2 French documented before filing, the civic-exam attestation in hand, steady income with clean tax records, and conduct that withstands an investigator’s curiosity. The decree itself, published and non-retroactive, confers the vote, the passport, and Union citizenship, extends by right to minor children named in it, and costs nothing on the American side, where dual nationality is accepted. Refusal is never the end, but it starts two clocks, two months for the mandatory appeal to the minister and then two months for the court in Nantes, and only a reason-by-reason answer with fresh exhibits can turn the file around. Prepare the language and the exam first, keep every residence and tax record, list the children, stay in France until publication, and tell the truth throughout. The Republic opens its doors to Americans who have already, quietly, become French in daily life; the file simply asks it to sign the recognition.

📄 Official circular