KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
I Live in France as an American and Want to Become French: Naturalization by Decree, the 5-Year Rule, the Language Interview, and What to Do If They Say No

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

I Live in France as an American and Want to Become French: Naturalization by Decree, the 5-Year Rule, the Language Interview, and What to Do If They Say No

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

You have lived in France for years. Your children go to a French school, you file a French tax return every spring, and you argue about rugby like a local. Sooner or later the question comes up: can I become French myself? If you are an American with no French parent and no French spouse, the answer runs through a procedure called naturalisation par décret, which means naturalization by decree. It is the standard path for a foreigner who has built a life in France and wants full French citizenship, with a French passport and the right to vote, while in most cases keeping a United States passport too.

French officials call this acquisition of nationality by decision of the public authority. As article 21-15 of the Civil Code puts it: “l’acquisition de la nationalité française par décision de l’autorité publique résulte d’une naturalisation accordée par décret à la demande de l’étranger”. In plain English: you apply, the administration investigates, and the government may grant you citizenship through a formal decree. The word may matters enormously. Unlike citizenship by birth or by marriage declaration, naturalization by decree is a favor the state grants, never a right you can claim automatically, even when you check every box. Courts describe a broad ministerial discretion, exercised, in the words of CAA de Nantes, September 20, 2024, No. 22NT03122, “dans le cadre du large pouvoir d’appréciation de l’opportunité d’accorder ou non la nationalité française à l’étranger qui la sollicite dont il dispose”.

This article explains the whole path in American terms. Part I covers who qualifies: the residence clock you must run, the French language and culture test you must pass, and the clean-record bar you must clear. Part II follows the file itself: where and how to apply, the interview, the eighteen-month wait, the three possible answers, how to challenge a refusal, and what the decree changes for your passport, your children, and your daily life. Every legal claim below is tied to the exact French statute or court decision behind it, quoted word for word, so you can verify everything with your own lawyer.

I. How Long Must an American Live in France, and How French Must You Be, Before Applying for Citizenship by Decree?

A. The five-year residence clock, the two-year shortcut, and the trap for Americans who work abroad

The threshold condition is time spent in France. Article 21-17 of the Civil Code states the rule this way: “la naturalisation ne peut être accordée qu’à l’étranger justifiant d’une résidence habituelle en France pendant les cinq années qui précèdent le dépôt de la demande”. That is the famous five-year stage, and three words in it deserve attention. First, habitual residence means settled life, not a second home you visit in August. You must actually live in France, with your home, your daily life, and usually your tax residence there. Second, the five years run backward from the day you file, so the period that counts is the five years immediately before your application. Third, the clock is only the minimum. Meeting it makes your file receivable, not successful.

A second residence rule is even stricter and surprises many Americans on international careers. Article 21-16 of the Civil Code provides: “Nul ne peut être naturalisé s’il n’a en France sa résidence au moment de la signature du décret de naturalisation”. You must still live in France on the day the decree is signed, which can be a year or more after you apply. Accepting a two-year posting to Singapore or New York while your file is pending can sink it. If your employer moves you abroad mid-procedure, talk to counsel before accepting, because the administration checks your address at the end of the road, not just at the start.

Keep proof of presence for the entire period. Tax notices, leases, electricity bills, pay slips, school certificates for your children, and passport stamps all help. The official service-public guide for French naturalization by decree details the supporting documents tied to stays and travel, so build that folder from day one rather than reconstructing five years of life in a panic.

Some applicants get a shorter clock. Article 21-18 of the Civil Code opens with the key sentence: “Le stage mentionné à l’article 21-17 est réduit à deux ans”. The first group covered is defined as follows, and I quote article 21-18 of the Civil Code again: “Pour l’étranger qui a accompli avec succès deux années d’études supérieures en vue d’acquérir un diplôme délivré par une université ou un établissement d’enseignement supérieur français”. If you earned a French university degree after two years of higher studies in France, you can apply after two years of residence instead of five. This helps Americans who came for a master’s degree in Paris or Lyon and stayed for work. The same article also covers people who have rendered or can render major services to France, and a foreigner described, in article 21-18 of the Civil Code, as one “qui présente un parcours exceptionnel d’intégration, apprécié au regard des activités menées ou des actions accomplies dans les domaines civique, scientifique, économique, culturel ou sportif”. A genuinely exceptional civic, scientific, economic, cultural, or sports record can cut the wait to two years, but ordinary professional success does not qualify. Do not confuse a good career with an exceptional integration path. The bar is national-level distinction, documented.

A few categories skip the stage entirely. Article 21-19 of the Civil Code begins: “Peut être naturalisé sans condition de stage”. Among the beneficiaries it lists, and I quote article 21-19 of the Civil Code: “L’étranger qui a obtenu le statut de réfugié en application de la loi n° 52-893 du 25 juillet 1952 portant création d’un Office français de protection des réfugiés et apatrides”. Recognized refugees living in France can therefore apply without waiting five years, which matters for households where one spouse holds refugee status.

What if your work sends you outside France? Certain stays abroad count as residence in France. The opening words of article 21-26 of the Civil Code are: “Est assimilé à la résidence en France lorsque cette résidence constitue une condition de l’acquisition de la nationalité française”. The first case it covers is a stay abroad by a foreigner working, and I quote article 21-26 of the Civil Code again: “pour le compte de l’Etat français ou d’un organisme dont l’activité présente un intérêt particulier pour l’économie ou la culture française”. Working abroad for the French state, or for an organization whose work is specifically important to the French economy or culture, can preserve your clock. But an international career alone does not. A 2023 decision of the Nantes administrative appeal court is the warning. A Malian man educated in France since age six, an engineering graduate working for the World Health Organization in Mozambique and South Africa, argued that his public-health missions served French interests given migration flows toward Europe. The trial judges had held, in words the appeal court reproduced in CAA de Nantes, July 7, 2023, No. 21NT02547, that his work “ne peut entrainer, à elle seule, l’application des dispositions”. His submission that he “participe aux recherches sur le VIH”, in CAA de Nantes, July 7, 2023, No. 21NT02547, “ne suffit pas à le faire regarder comme exerçant une activité professionnelle auprès d’un organisme qui présente un intérêt particulier pour l’économie ou la culture française”. The court upheld the refusal, acting in CAA de Nantes, July 7, 2023, No. 21NT02547 “en déclarant irrecevable, pour le motif énoncé au point 4”. For an American executive posted abroad by a United States company, the lesson is blunt: years outside France usually stop the clock, even with a French home waiting.

Practical bottom line for this section: count five unbroken years of real life in France before filing, stay put until the decree is signed, and if you studied in France, check the two-year shortcut. If your career moves you abroad, get advice before you go, because the file you spent years building can become inadmissible overnight.

B. Speaking French, knowing France, and keeping a clean record: the assimilation test and the criminal-record bar

Time in France is not enough. You must also show that you have become part of the French community. The opening words of article 21-24 of the Civil Code set the bar: “Nul ne peut être naturalisé s’il ne justifie de son assimilation à la communauté française”. The same article explains that assimilation is shown in particular through sufficient knowledge, given your background, and I quote article 21-24 of the Civil Code again: “de la langue, de l’histoire, de la culture et de la société françaises”. Assimilation here does not mean abandoning your American identity. It means demonstrating, in French, that you understand how France works and that you subscribe to the core principles and values of the Republic: liberty, equality, fraternity, secularism, and respect for the institutions that come with citizenship.

The language floor is set by regulation. As the appeal court recalled in CAA de Nantes, March 20, 2026, No. 25NT01434: “Tout demandeur doit justifier d’une connaissance de la langue française à l’oral et à l’écrit au moins égale au niveau B1 du Cadre européen commun de référence pour les langues”. B1 is intermediate. You should handle everyday conversation, understand the main points of clear speech, and write a simple connected text. In practice the administration also tests you live, during a one-on-one assimilation interview, and that interview can fail you even if your diplomas look fine. Bring a file of certificates, but prepare to actually speak.

A very recent court case shows how strict the interview is. A woman living in France since 2011 applied for naturalization. She is hard of hearing, holds a disability rating of 80 percent or more, and attended her June 2021 assimilation interview accompanied by a friend with whom she spoke Arabic. She could neither understand simple personal questions nor express herself in French. The minister rejected her file because verification of her knowledge had, in the words of CAA de Nantes, March 20, 2026, No. 25NT01434, “a été rendue impossible, lors de l’entretien individuel, en raison de son incapacité manifeste à s’exprimer en français”. She argued that her disability excused the diploma requirement, and the court agreed that disabled applicants are dispensed from producing the standard certificate, but it held, in CAA de Nantes, March 20, 2026, No. 25NT01434, that “une telle circonstance ne fait pas obstacle à ce que le niveau de connaissance de la langue française de ces personnes soit pris en compte”. Because she had lived in France for a decade without showing that her disability had made any French learning impossible, the court validated the rejection, finding it had been made, in CAA de Nantes, March 20, 2026, No. 25NT01434, “sans entacher sa décision d’une erreur de droit ni d’une erreur manifeste d’appréciation”. Annulment, an order granting citizenship, and costs all failed. The message for American applicants is uncomfortable but clear. A decade of residence, a real disability, and sympathy for your situation do not replace demonstrable French. Start serious language study early, aim well above B1, and never walk into the interview planning to rely on a companion or on English.

The interview also covers history, culture, and civic knowledge: the Revolution and the Republic, the meaning of secularism in public life, how voting works, the rights and duties citizenship confers. At the end of the assimilation check, the successful applicant signs the charter of the rights and duties of the French citizen. The statute says, and I quote article 21-24 of the Civil Code: “A l’issue du contrôle de son assimilation, l’intéressé signe la charte des droits et devoirs du citoyen français”. Treat it as a solemn commitment, not a formality.

Then comes the criminal-record and regularity bar, which is mechanical and unforgiving. Article 21-27 of the Civil Code blocks anyone who, and I quote the key passage: “s’il a été condamné à une peine égale ou supérieure à six mois d’emprisonnement, non assortie d’une mesure de sursis”. Any unsuspended prison sentence of six months or more, for any offense, blocks naturalization, as do convictions for offenses against the fundamental interests of the Nation or terrorism. The same article extends the bar to anyone in irregular immigration status, stating, and I quote article 21-27 of the Civil Code: “Il en est de même de celui dont le séjour en France est irrégulier au regard des lois et conventions relatives au séjour des étrangers en France”. An American between visas, or working on an expired residence permit, should regularize first and apply later. Rehabilitation and removal of the conviction from bulletin No. 2 of the criminal record can lift the bar, so old, minor, and expunged matters need individual analysis rather than panic. Disclose everything to your lawyer. The administration will pull your record anyway, and a hidden conviction discovered during the inquiry looks like disloyalty on top of the conviction itself.

One more quiet factor is professional and fiscal integration. The statutes quoted above do not set an income threshold, but investigators look at stable resources, genuine employment or business activity, and clean tax filings as evidence that you participate in French society. File your French returns on time, pay what you owe, and keep contracts and pay slips. For Americans, that means managing both systems at once: French residence plus United States citizenship brings worldwide filing duties back home, and a French tax mess visible in the file never helps.

II. From the Application File to the French Passport: Procedure, Delays, Refusals, and What the Decree Changes for an American

A. Filing, the interview, and the eighteen-month wait: inadmissible, adjourned, or rejected, and how to fight back

Applications are filed with the prefecture of your home department, now largely through the online channel, with a full documentary file: identity, immigration status, proof of the five years of residence, employment and tax evidence, language certificates, family records, and the fee. The prefecture registers the file and issues a receipt that starts the legal clock. Keep that receipt. The official service-public guide for French naturalization by decree gives the administration a maximum of eighteen months from that receipt to answer. Eighteen months is the ceiling, not the average. Many files take a year or more, and silence at the end of the period can itself be challenged. Use the waiting time productively: keep your address updated with the prefecture, keep filing taxes, keep learning French, and do not leave France for long stretches.

During the inquiry, the police or gendarmerie may visit or summon you, your file circulates between services, and you are called to the individual assimilation interview described above. Then one of four things happens. The best is a favorable proposal transmitted to the ministry and, eventually, your name in a naturalization decree. The other three are negative, and each has a different meaning and remedy. Inadmissibility means you did not meet a legal condition at all, such as the residence stage. The Malian WHO officer discussed in Part I received exactly that: a decision declaring his request inadmissible because his years abroad could not count. Adjournment means the administration postpones its decision and sets a waiting period or conditions, typically two years, during which you should fix the weakness: improve your French, stabilize your employment, or simply demonstrate longer integration. Rejection is a flat no on the merits.

The decree of December 30, 1993, which runs the procedure, gives the prefect and then the minister the same two negative tools. If the prefect finds no reason to grant citizenship even though the file is receivable, in the words quoted by CAA de Nantes, September 20, 2024, No. 22NT03122, “il prononce le rejet de la demande”. And the same ruling recalls the alternative, in CAA de Nantes, September 20, 2024, No. 22NT03122: “Il peut également en prononcer l’ajournement en imposant un délai ou des conditions”. The minister holds the same power at the second level, and the ruling quotes the follow-up rule, in CAA de Nantes, September 20, 2024, No. 22NT03122: “Ce délai une fois expiré ou ces conditions réalisées, il appartient à l’intéressé, s’il le juge opportun, de déposer une nouvelle demande”. An adjournment is therefore not a lifetime ban. It is a timed delay, and once the period expires you may file again with a stronger record.

A 2024 case illustrates adjournment in action and the limits of fighting it. A Turkish applicant in the Doubs saw his request adjourned for two years in 2016, confirmed by the minister in 2017, then adjourned again for two years in November 2019 after a court ordered reexamination. He attacked the second adjournment before the administrative court of Nantes, lost in 2022, appealed to the Nantes appeal court, and lost again on September 20, 2024. The court recalled the minister’s broad discretion, exercised “dans le cadre du large pouvoir d’appréciation de l’opportunité d’accorder ou non la nationalité française à l’étranger qui la sollicite dont il dispose”, as written in CAA de Nantes, September 20, 2024, No. 22NT03122, and held the new two-year adjournment lawful. The lesson is that courts review legality, not generosity. They check competence, procedure, factual accuracy, legal qualification, and manifest error of assessment. They do not substitute their own view of whether you deserve citizenship.

If you receive a negative decision, watch the calendar. Prefect-level decisions can be challenged before the minister within two months of notification. The rule, quoted in CAA de Nantes, September 20, 2024, No. 22NT03122, reads: “Dans les deux mois suivant leur notification, les décisions prises en application des articles 43 et 44 peuvent faire l’objet d’un recours auprès du ministre chargé des naturalisations, à l’exclusion de tout autre recours administratif”. That hierarchical appeal to the minister is exclusive of any other administrative appeal, meaning you do not shop around with side petitions. After the minister decides, or after implied rejection through silence, you can bring the case before the administrative court, asking for annulment and, where appropriate, an order to reexamine. As the cases above show, judges often refuse injunctions that would order the state to grant citizenship or even to decide within a month. Frame your appeal around concrete, provable errors: wrong facts about your residence, a language level documented by fresh certificates, a conviction that was actually expunged, a condition that no longer exists. Abstract fairness arguments lose. And if the answer was an adjournment rather than a rejection, sometimes the smartest appeal is no appeal at all: spend the two years fixing the file and reapply stronger, as the regulation expressly invites you to do.

B. After the decree: the ceremony, keeping your American passport, and what changes for your children

A grant takes the form of a decree published in the Journal officiel, the official gazette. Your name appears on a list, and from the date of that decree you are French. New citizens are invited to a welcoming ceremony, the ceremony of welcome into French citizenship, organized by the prefecture. The official service-public guide for French naturalization by decree points new citizens to the dedicated ceremony page, and you should attend. It is the moment the abstract file becomes a concrete civic bond, and the prefecture uses it to hand over key documents and explanations.

Practically, you then apply for a French national identity card and a French passport at the town hall or consulate, register to vote on the electoral roll, and update your civil records. Young men between sixteen and twenty-five who become French must complete the national census registration promptly, which leads to the defense and citizenship day. If you have teenage sons, plan for that step. Your French taxes, property, and employment contracts continue unchanged, but your administrative life gets simpler: no more residence-permit renewals, no more permit anxiety, full access to public-sector competitions open only to nationals or Europeans, and unrestricted establishment anywhere in France.

The question every American asks next is whether Washington takes your United States passport away. It does not. France fully accepts dual and multiple nationality, and the United States tolerates it in practice. The State Department explains on its dual nationality page that each country has its own nationality laws and that a person can be a national of two countries at once, including by naturalizing in another country later in life. Naturalizing French does not expatriate you. Only a formal renunciation at a United States embassy or consulate, with the oath and the certificate of loss of nationality, ends United States citizenship, and that is a separate, deliberately difficult procedure with its own tax exit analysis. Becoming French changes nothing about your United States tax filings either. You remain a United States person for the IRS, with FBAR and FATCA duties intact, which our office has covered in a companion guide for Americans in France catching up on FBAR penalties through the streamlined fix. Citizenship solves your French immigration status. It does not simplify your American tax life.

Your children may become French automatically with you, through what lawyers call the collective effect of a parent’s naturalization. Article 22-1 of the Civil Code defines it this way: “devient français de plein droit s’il a la même résidence habituelle que ce parent ou s’il réside alternativement avec ce parent dans le cas de séparation ou divorce”. A minor child who lives with you, or alternately with you in a separated family, becomes French by operation of law when you do. But there is a trap that has ruined files. The same article warns, and I quote article 22-1 of the Civil Code: “que si son nom est mentionné dans le décret ou dans la déclaration”. Your child’s name must be written into the decree. List every minor child in the application, attach their birth certificates and proof of shared residence, and verify the published decree line by line. A child forgotten from the decree does not get the automatic effect and must pursue a separate path.

Two neighboring paths deserve a brief comparison so you choose correctly. If you are married to a French citizen, the declaration procedure after four years of marriage is usually faster and closer to a right once conditions are met, as explained in our guide for Americans married to a French citizen and the four-year declaration rule. If you have a French parent or grandparent, claiming citizenship by descent through the chain of filiation may beat naturalization entirely, as in our guide for Americans whose French grandmother gave them a path through an unclaimed maternal line. And if your child was born in the United States to a French parent, the transcription route through Nantes is a different procedure again, covered in our guide for American babies born in New York to a French parent. Naturalization by decree is the path for those with no family shortcut: long residence, real French, clean record, patience.

Conclusion

Becoming French as an American resident is an endurance event with a formal finish line. Five years of genuine life in France, still resident on the day the decree is signed, French at an honest B1 level and beyond, a passed assimilation interview, a signed charter, a clean criminal record, and regular immigration status throughout: those are the tickets to entry. Then comes the file, the interview, and up to eighteen months of waiting, with three possible negative answers that each demand a different response. Inadmissibility means a missing legal condition, adjournment means come back stronger in two years, rejection means fight the legal errors or rebuild. The courts will check that the administration followed the law, as the Nantes decisions show, but they will not grant citizenship in its place.

Start before you think you are ready. Enroll in French classes now, file and keep every proof of residence, regularize any immigration gap, and list your children correctly from the first form. The decree, when it comes, gives you a French passport, the vote, and permanent freedom from residence permits, while your American passport stays in the drawer beside it. That dual future is worth building carefully, one documented year at a time.

📄 Official circular