KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
I Live in France as an American: How to Become French by Naturalization Decree, From Residence to Fighting a Refusal

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

I Live in France as an American: How to Become French by Naturalization Decree, From Residence to Fighting a Refusal

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

You have lived in France for years as an American. You renew your carte de séjour (residence permit), you file French tax returns, your children go to a French school, and you are tired of queuing at the préfecture (the local state authority office) every time your papers come up for renewal. The question comes up naturally: can you become French while keeping your American passport? For most Americans living in France, the answer runs through naturalisation par décret, naturalization by decree: a discretionary grant of French nationality signed by the Prime Minister and published in the Journal officiel (the official gazette where French laws and decrees are published). It is not a right you claim; it is a favor the French state grants when you prove five years of habitual residence, genuine assimilation to French life, B2-level French since the order of December 22, 2025, stable resources, and a clean record. The filing itself now runs online through the ANEF portal, costs 255 euros in tax stamps, and the administration has 18 months to answer — 12 if you have lived in France for at least ten years. And when the answer is no, you are not finished: rejections, adjournments, and inadmissibility decisions each follow a strict two-step appeal path that ends before the administrative court of Nantes. This guide walks through both halves in order: first, how Americans qualify, then how to file a file that survives and how to fight a refusal.

I. How an American living in France qualifies for naturalization by decree

A. Five years of habitual residence in France, with only narrow shortcuts

The starting point is article 21-15 of the Civil Code, which states that “l’acquisition de la nationalité française par décision de l’autorité publique résulte d’une naturalisation accordée par décret à la demande de l’étranger.” In plain English: apart from special cases, an adult foreigner becomes French by asking the government, which answers with a decree. Everything else is a condition attached to that request, and the heaviest is residence. Article 21-17 of the Civil Code provides that “la naturalisation ne peut être accordée qu’à l’étranger justifiant d’une résidence habituelle en France pendant les cinq années qui précèdent le dépôt de la demande.” You must show five years of habitual, settled, lawful residence in France immediately before you file. Short holidays and business trips to the United States do not break the chain, but the center of your life must be France: your home, your work, your taxes, your daily life. An American who keeps a primary life in New York or San Francisco and merely visits a Paris apartment will fail this test, however long the pattern has lasted.

A second residence rule is less known and purely mechanical. Article 21-16 of the Civil Code states: “Nul ne peut être naturalisé s’il n’a en France sa résidence au moment de la signature du décret de naturalisation.” Even after a perfect five-year record, you must still be resident in France on the day the decree is signed. An American who files, then moves back to the United States while the file sits in the pile for 18 months, loses eligibility at the finish line. If a return to America is under discussion in your household, time the filing so the decision falls while you are still French-resident, and tell the administration of any address change through your online file instead of disappearing.

The five-year period — lawyers call it the stage, the waiting period — can be shortened in a few defined situations. Article 21-18 of the Civil Code cuts it to two years for a foreigner who has completed two years of higher education toward a degree from a French university or higher-education institution, for someone who has rendered or can render important services to France through their abilities and talents, and for a foreigner with an exceptional integration record in civic, scientific, economic, cultural, or sporting life. An American researcher recruited by a French university, an executive whose investment created French jobs, or an artist with a documented French career can realistically aim at this two-year track, but the file must document the contribution rather than assert it.

Full exemption from any waiting period exists but rarely helps Americans. Article 21-19 of the Civil Code lists foreigners who served in a French army unit, refugees recognized by the French refugee office, and foreigners who rendered exceptional services to France or whose naturalization is of exceptional interest to France, the last only with a formal opinion of the Council of State. Article 21-20 of the Civil Code exempts nationals of French-speaking countries and people whose mother tongue is French or who studied at least five years in a French-language school. An American educated at a lycée français abroad for five years can use that provision; an American who simply speaks good French cannot. For everyone else, the five years stand.

Two practical warnings complete the residence picture. First, children do not ride along automatically on a different clock: article 21-22 of the Civil Code keeps naturalization for adults, with a narrow opening for a minor child whose parent became French and who lived in France with that parent for the five preceding years. Second, the administration reads family geography as evidence of where your life really sits. The official English-language guidance warns plainly: if you live in France while your spouse or children live abroad, you may be refused French nationality. An American executive posted to Paris whose family stayed in Texas should either document a genuine Zamoracky transfer of family life or wait until the household follows. Students should note the same logic in a softer form: years on a student permit count toward the five years, but a student file with no work history and no stable income usually stumbles later on the professional-integration test described below.

B. Assimilation, B2 French, and the prefecture interview that decides everything

Residence gets you through the door; assimilation decides whether you stay. Article 21-24 of the Civil Code opens with the blunt rule: “Nul ne peut être naturalisé s’il ne justifie de son assimilation à la communauté française” — nobody may be naturalized without proving assimilation to the French community. The same article defines the test as sufficient knowledge, according to your background, of the French language, history, culture, and society, knowledge of the rights and duties that come with French nationality, and adherence to the essential principles and values of the Republic. At the end of the assimilation check, you sign the charter of the rights and duties of the French citizen, the written statement of Republican principles — liberty, equality, fraternity, secularism (laïcité), equality between women and men — that the prefecture interviewer will have probed. Americans sometimes smile at questions about the Revolution or laïcité; the interviewer does not smile back. Prepare the history and institutions the way you would prepare a professional exam, because a vague performance on values is the single most common reason files fail at the interview stage.

The language bar is now higher than most Americans expect. Since the order of December 22, 2025 on proof of the French level required of nationality candidates, you must show oral and written French at least equal to level B2 of the Common European Framework of Reference for Languages, the CEFR scale used across Europe. B2 is not conversational survival French: the statute describes it as a level where “L’intéressé justifie d’un niveau de langue lui permettant au moins de comprendre le contenu essentiel de sujets concrets ou abstraits dans un texte complexe, de communiquer avec spontanéité, de s’exprimer de façon claire et détaillée sur une grande variété de sujets.” You prove it with accepted diplomas or certificates — the official English-language page on justifying your French level lists state diplomas and approved language certificates at B2 — and the prefecture agent forms a second opinion during the interview itself. An American who speaks fluent dinner-party French but cannot write a structured text should take a certified B2 exam before filing rather than after a refusal. Note that this B2 rule is stricter than the language test for French nationality through marriage to a French citizen, which is a frequent source of confusion for Franco-American couples: the couple that qualified on the marriage track should not assume the same certificate suffices for a decree application, and readers in that situation should also read our guide on claiming French citizenship by marriage declaration, where the declaration logic and its own refusal litigation are explained.

Assimilation also means economic roots. Professional integration is an essential condition: you must have stable and sufficient income to support yourself and your tax household (foyer fiscal, the group of people taxed together on one French return). Salaried Americans show employment contracts, pay slips, and tax notices; freelancers and entrepreneurs show contracts, revenue, and returns; retirees show pensions. There is no published minimum salary, which is exactly what makes the test dangerous: the minister enjoys what the Council of State calls a wide margin of appreciation, weighing your integration into French society, your social and professional insertion, and whether your resources let you durably meet your needs in France. The leading illustration is a Council of State decision of December 14, 2020, no. 432778, which states: “L’autorité administrative dispose, en matière de naturalisation, ou de réintégration dans la nationalité française, d’un large pouvoir d’appréciation.” In that case the administration had weighed, among other things, that the applicant owed a debt to his landlord even though he was respecting a court-ordered repayment schedule, and the Council of State upheld the refusal. The lesson for Americans is concrete: unpaid rent, chronic overdrafts, debts to public bodies, and patchy tax filings are read as failed integration, not as private money troubles. Clean your finances a full year before filing, not the month before.

Finally, the moral and criminal conditions are absolute bars, not balancing factors. Article 21-23 of the Civil Code requires good morals, and article 21-27 of the Civil Code excludes anyone sentenced to six months or more of unsuspended imprisonment — “s’il a été condamné à une peine égale ou supérieure à six mois d’emprisonnement, non assortie d’une mesure de sursis” — anyone convicted of crimes against the fundamental interests of the Nation or terrorism, anyone under a live expulsion order or French-territory ban, and anyone in irregular immigration status. Foreign convictions may be disregarded, but only with a formal conforming opinion of the Council of State, which tells you how rarely it happens. The official guidance adds the operational detail: rehabilitation or removal of the conviction from bulletin no. 2 of your criminal record (casier judiciaire, the national criminal-record file) lifts the bar. Americans with an old US conviction should therefore check two things before filing: what the French bulletin no. 2 shows, and whether rehabilitation has legally erased the mention. A drunk-driving or disorderly-conduct history that seems minor in Ohio can stall a Paris file if the paperwork is left unexplained.

II. How to file your application and fight a refusal

A. The ANEF online file, the 255-euro fee, the 18-month clock, and what the decree changes

Filing runs through the ANEF system, the Interior Ministry’s online portal for foreigners in France, via the online naturalization request service. If online filing is genuinely impossible, you may file by post with the naturalization platform covering your home, but you will need proof of the impossibility, such as a message from the citizens contact center or a document from the prefecture. Paris-area Americans file with the Paris platform; the lassitude-inducing part is the same everywhere: the documentary file. Expect to assemble civil-status records in full original form, proof of residence over the whole five-year period, proof of resources and taxes — employment contracts, pay slips, French tax notices (avis d’imposition), business records for the self-employed — the B2 language diploma or certificate, and the 255-euro tax stamp (127.50 euros in Guyana), paid as a fiscal stamp. The administration warns that apart from that stamp, the procedure is free, and private websites selling prefecture appointments have no official status.

American documents need special care. Every document in English must carry a French translation by a certified translator (traducteur assermenté, a translator sworn before a French court), and US civil-status records generally need an apostille, the international authentication stamp the United States issues under the Hague Convention, before the prefecture accepts them. Order a fresh full-copy birth certificate from your US state of birth early: state vital-records offices take weeks, the apostille adds more weeks, and the prefecture can close your file without further examination if you miss the deadline it sets for producing a missing original — a classement sans suite, a closure without examination, which is a distinct decision with its own appeal path discussed below. Keep the originals ready even after uploading scans, because you must bring them to the assimilation interview, and report any change in your situation — new address, new job, marriage, child, or spell of unemployment — through your personal online space as soon as it happens. Files die quietly when the administration learns of a change from someone else.

Once the receipt (récépissé) issues, the clock starts. The administration has 18 months from the receipt to decide, reduced to 12 months if you prove at least ten years of habitual residence in France on the receipt date, according to the official English-language naturalization page. The sequence runs: prefecture investigation and interview, transmission to the central nationality office (SDANF), ministerial decision, and, on success, a naturalization decree signed and published in the Journal officiel, followed by the welcoming ceremony into French citizenship (cérémonie d’accueil dans la citoyenneté française) organized by your prefecture. If the published decree misspells your name or garbles your civil status, report the transcription error to the Interior Ministry by post or email rather than living with it: every later French ID document will copy the error.

Two consequences of success matter specifically to American families. First, the collective effect for minor children (effet collectif): article 22-1 of the Civil Code provides that “L’enfant mineur dont l’un des deux parents acquiert la nationalité française, devient français de plein droit s’il a la même résidence habituelle que ce parent” — a minor child whose parent becomes French automatically becomes French when sharing that parent’s habitual residence — but only “si son nom est mentionné dans le décret”, only if the child’s name appears in the decree. Name every qualifying child in the application and check the published decree; an omitted child is a separate file to rebuild. Second, nothing in the statutory conditions requires you to surrender your American citizenship. The Civil Code lists residence, assimilation, language, morals, and clean-record conditions, and no renunciation oath appears among them, so France naturalizes you alongside your US nationality and you keep both passports. The American side of that duality has its own practical tail: Washington still treats you as a US person, so FBAR declarations, FATCA reporting, and the PFIC rules on French funds follow you into French citizenship exactly as before. Our walkthrough of reporting US-linked accounts from France and our warning on the PFIC trap in French funds stay relevant the day after your ceremony.

B. Rejection, adjournment, and inadmissibility: the two-month appeals that save your case

French naturalization law sorts bad news into four different decisions, and confusing them is how Americans lose their rights. The Council of State’s 2020 decision no. 432778 recalls the framework of article 48 of the decree of December 30, 1993: “Si le ministre chargé des naturalisations estime qu’il n’y a pas lieu d’accorder la naturalisation ou la réintégration sollicitée, il prononce le rejet de la demande” and “Il peut également prononcer l’ajournement en imposant un délai ou des conditions” A rejet (rejection) ends the file on the merits: assimilation judged insufficient, integration unconvincing, record disqualifying. An ajournement (adjournment) postpones the decision and sets a waiting period or conditions — improve your professional integration, stabilize your resources — after which you may reapply with a strengthened file. An irrecevabilité (inadmissibility) says a legal condition was missing from the start, typically the five-year residence, and carries a sharp procedural sting: a fresh application filed less than five years after notification of the refusal may itself be closed without examination, new circumstances considered. A classement sans suite (closure without examination) is the file dying on procedure, usually for documents never produced within the set deadline. The practical consequence is immediate: a rejection calls for an appeal attacking the assessment, an adjournment calls for patience plus evidence-building, and an inadmissibility or closure calls for fixing the missing element first, because re-filing an unchanged file within five years of a refusal invites summary closure.

The appeal path is mandatory and calendared. Within two months of notification of the unfavorable decision, you must file a recours administratif préalable obligatoire — a compulsory preliminary administrative appeal — addressed as a hierarchical appeal (recours hiérarchique) to the minister in charge of naturalizations. Only after that step, if the minister says no or stays silent for four months, which counts as an implicit rejection, do you get two months to bring the case before the administrative court of Nantes (tribunal administratif de Nantes), the single court competent for this litigation. Skip the ministerial appeal or miss either two-month window and the court will throw the case out without looking at the merits. The Council of State sits above as the cassation judge, reviewing legal errors in the appeal courts’ rulings, exactly the route taken in decision no. 432778, where a Beninese applicant challenged the refusal through Nantes and lost because the courts found no legal error in weighing his landlord debt. Read that case as a map, not as discouragement: the judges control the legality of the reasoning, the accuracy of the facts, and whether the minister stayed within the wide but not unlimited margin the law grants.

Assimilation findings are reviewable, and the government sometimes loses. On May 29, 2026, the Council of State decided case no. 501856, concerning a Moroccan spouse whose nationality declaration the Prime Minister had blocked for defective assimilation. The Council annulled the decree, holding: “Il ne ressort pas des éléments versés au dossier par le ministre de l’intérieur, en particulier du rapport de synthèse du 26 septembre 2022 des services de la préfecture de l’Oise chargés de l’instruction du dossier et du compte-rendu d’entretien complémentaire du 13 mai 2024, que Mme A… adopte un comportement ou soutient des thèses manifestant un rejet des principes essentiels de la République ou se tient délibérément à l’écart de la communauté nationale.” The technique transfers directly to decree applications: prefecture reports and interview notes are evidence like any other, and a refusal that asserts non-assimilation without material in the file to support it commits a legal error the judge will sanction. Americans refused on vague value grounds should therefore request the file, compare the interview report with what was actually said, and build the hierarchical appeal around the gap between the report and the conclusion.

Procedure can also rescue a file the prefecture tried to bury. In a 2025 dispute over a closure without examination, the prefect of Bouches-du-Rhône had shut down an Algerian applicant’s naturalization request after demanding an original full-copy birth certificate and a divorce judgment within one month; the Marseille administrative court of appeal annulled both the first-instance order and the prefect’s June 7, 2024 closure decision and ordered the prefect to resume examining the file without delay. The message for Americans wrestling with slow US vital-records offices is to never let a deadline pass in silence: ask in writing for an extension before it expires, send what you have, document the pending apostille request, and keep the receipts, because a closure punishes silence far more than lateness. And one final warning runs in the opposite direction. Article 27-2 of the Civil Code provides that “si la décision a été obtenue par mensonge ou fraude, ces décrets peuvent être rapportés dans le délai de deux ans à partir de la découverte de la fraude.” The Council of State applied exactly that in its July 23, 2025 decision no. 498310: a Bangladeshi applicant naturalized by the decree of April 30, 2021 after declaring himself single and childless lost his nationality by the decree of July 24, 2024, once the administration learned he had sought transcription of his minor child’s foreign birth certificate. Concealing a marriage, children, or convictions to smooth the file does not merely risk refusal; it plants a two-year time bomb under a granted decree, measured from the day the fraud is discovered.

Conclusion

Naturalization by decree rewards Americans whose French life is real, documented, and durable: five years of habitual residence with your family life centered in France, B2 French proven by an accepted certificate and confirmed at the interview, stable resources, a clean criminal record, and a file whose every American document arrives translated, apostilled, and on time. Treat the prefecture interview as the examination it is, budget the 255 euros and the 18-month wait, name your minor children so the collective effect reaches them, and keep your US reporting duties in mind for the day after the ceremony. If the answer is no, read which no you received — rejection, adjournment, inadmissibility, or procedural closure — file the compulsory ministerial appeal within two months, then go to the administrative court of Nantes within two months of the minister’s express or four-month silent refusal, asking the judge to check what the Council of State always checks: accurate facts, honest reasoning, and an assimilation finding the file actually supports.

📄 Official circular