KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
I Am an American in France Ready to Give Up My Passport: the Exit Tax, the French Bill, and the Point of No Return

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

I Am an American in France Ready to Give Up My Passport: the Exit Tax, the French Bill, and the Point of No Return

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

Every year, thousands of Americans living abroad walk into an American consulate, raise their right hand, swear an oath renouncing their United States nationality, and walk out stateless of America but free, they hope, of its worldwide tax net. In France, where American retirees, executives, and dual-national families file two tax returns a year and answer FATCA questionnaires from their banks, the temptation is easy to understand. The paperwork never ends, the penalties for a missed form are severe on both sides, and the consulate in Paris handles these appointments every week. Yet renunciation is the most irreversible decision in this entire field of law, and it rarely produces the clean break people imagine. Past taxes survive it, France keeps taxing you exactly as before, and if your wealth crosses certain lines, America imposes a departure tax on the way out that can dwarf years of compliance costs.

This article explains, in plain English for an American reader with no French legal background, what the American renunciation procedure actually requires, what it changes and does not change in France, how the American exit tax identifies the people it hits hardest, and what French tax France imposes when renunciation is combined with leaving the country. Every French legal proposition below is tied to the official text it comes from, quoted word for word, and every American figure comes from the current official pages of the Internal Revenue Service and the State Department. Read this before booking the consulate appointment, not after, because the appointment itself is the point of no return. The consulate will not advise you on taxes, and neither tax office will remind you of the consulate, so the coordination described below is entirely your responsibility.

I. What Giving Up Your American Passport Really Does

A. The American Procedure: Oath, Certificate, Fee, and No Way Back

American nationality is lost under section 349(a)(5) of the Immigration and Nationality Act when a citizen formally renounces before an American diplomatic or consular officer abroad. The State Department page governing the oath states that once the Department approves the request and issues a Certificate of Loss of Nationality, universally called the CLN, its determination is irrevocable except through a successful administrative or judicial appeal, and the oath cannot be taken back. There is no cooling-off period and no administrative cancellation for regret. The appointment itself is substantive: a consular officer verifies that you act voluntarily, that you understand the consequences, including potential statelessness if you hold no other nationality, and that you intend to relinquish all rights of citizenship. The administrative fee for processing the certificate request is 2,350 dollars, published in the State Department fee schedule, and it is not refunded if you change your mind. Dual French-American nationals should also confirm travel plans in advance, because after renunciation you enter the United States as a foreign visitor, subject to the visa or ESTA rules of your remaining nationality.

The most dangerous misunderstanding is the belief that renunciation wipes the slate clean. The State Department warns in plain terms that renouncing nationality may have no effect whatsoever on American tax or military service obligations, neither escaping past liabilities nor blocking prosecution for past violations. Concretely, every return you owed before the renunciation date remains owed, every FBAR you failed to file for earlier years remains a violation, and the Internal Revenue Service keeps full assessment and collection powers over pre-expatriation periods. The exit-tax system described in Part II adds a further condition that surprises many filers: to avoid the harshest classification, you must certify under penalties of perjury on Form 8854 that you complied with all federal tax obligations for the five preceding tax years. Someone who renounces hoping to escape five years of unfiled returns achieves the opposite, failing the certification test and guaranteeing the covered-expatriate status they wanted to avoid. The correct sequence is always the reverse: become fully compliant first, file the missing returns and FBARs, and only then take the oath, so the certificate test is met on the day it counts.

B. What Does Not Change in France: Nationality, Residence, and Taxation

Start with the reassurance that matters most to dual nationals: giving up American citizenship does not endanger French citizenship. France expressly accepts that its nationals hold other nationalities, and the official public-service information page states it directly: yes, it is possible to have several nationalities in France, for example dual nationality, as confirmed on service-public.fr, the French administration’s official information site. Loss of French nationality requires its own voluntary procedure, a formal declaration before French authorities described on the companion page for voluntary loss of French nationality, and nothing in the American oath triggers it. A Franco-American who renounces in Paris wakes up the next morning solely French, with French passport, French voting rights, and French consular protection intact. The same holds for children: their French nationality, whether acquired by birth in France or through a French parent, is entirely independent of your American decision.

French taxation, likewise, does not move a single euro. France taxes residents on worldwide income and nonresidents on French-source income, and citizenship appears nowhere in either test. Article 4 A of the CGI, on Légifrance, states the foundation: « Les personnes qui ont en France leur domicile fiscal sont passibles de l’impôt sur le revenu en raison de l’ensemble de leurs revenus. » Persons fiscally domiciled in France owe income tax on all their income. Article 4 B of the same code, on Légifrance, defines that domicile by facts, not papers: « Sont considérées comme ayant leur domicile fiscal en France au sens de l’article 4 A : a. Les personnes qui ont en France leur foyer ou le lieu de leur séjour principal ». Your home or principal place of stay in France makes you a French tax resident. An American retiree in Bordeaux who renounces at the consulate keeps the same apartment, the same daily life, and therefore the same French tax residence the day after as the day before. The French income return, the declaration of foreign accounts on form Cerfa 3916, the wealth tax on French real estate above the threshold, and the French social charges all continue unchanged. Renunciation ends American worldwide taxation going forward; it does not reduce French taxation by one cent, and anyone expecting a French tax saving from the oath has misunderstood which country taxes on the basis of citizenship. Only the United States does that.

II. The Two Tax Bills That Decide Whether Renouncing Saves You Money

A. The American Exit Tax: Covered Expatriates, the Deemed Sale, and the Estate Trap

Since mid-2008, section 877A of the Internal Revenue Code imposes a mark-to-market exit tax on so-called covered expatriates: on the day before expatriation, most of your worldwide property is treated as sold at fair market value, and the net gain above an inflation-adjusted exclusion is taxed immediately. For calendar year 2025, the IRS states that the exclusion amount is 890,000 dollars. Below that excluded gain, the deemed sale costs nothing; above it, a lifetime of unrealized appreciation on shares, funds, and business interests becomes taxable in a single year, with no cash proceeds to pay it. You fall into covered-expatriate status if any one of three tests applies, all published on the IRS expatriation tax page. First, your average annual net income tax for the five years before expatriation exceeds the inflation-adjusted threshold, which stands at 206,000 dollars for 2025. Second, your net worth reaches 2 million dollars or more on the expatriation date, counting everything you own worldwide minus debts. Third, you fail to certify on Form 8854 that you met all federal tax obligations for the five preceding years. Any single trigger is enough, and the third catches precisely the people who renounce to escape compliance: non-filers become covered expatriates by definition.

The consequences extend beyond the deemed sale. Covered expatriates face special American gift and inheritance rules on transfers to American recipients, who can owe tax on gifts and bequests that would be tax-free from anyone else. And renunciation permanently changes the American estate-tax math in a way that deserves its own calculation before the oath. An American citizen’s estate benefits from a lifetime exemption worth several million dollars, while the estate of a nonresident non-citizen must file Form 706-NA once American-situated assets pass a filing threshold of 60,000 dollars, a threshold the IRS confirms is not indexed for inflation. A former American who keeps a Florida condominium, American brokerage accounts, or shares in an American company therefore trades a generous citizen exemption for a 60,000-dollar filing threshold on the same American assets, with estate-tax treaties offering only partial relief that must be affirmatively claimed on the return, as the IRS treaty-claim guidance explains. Anyone whose wealth sits mostly in France with modest American holdings may still come out ahead, but the comparison must be computed asset by asset before the oath, because after the certificate issues, the election is final. Readers weighing the American side should also review how the same worldwide logic already follows their French investments today, including French mutual funds treated as American tax traps in our analysis of PFIC reporting for French bank funds, since renunciation ends that running cost only for years after expatriation.

Two administrative details complete the American picture. First, the expatriation return itself: Form 8854 is filed with the final-year return for the year of expatriation, and the Internal Revenue Service publishes yearly instructions adjusting every threshold, so the 206,000-dollar income-tax test and the 890,000-dollar exclusion for 2025 must be rechecked against the instructions for the actual expatriation year rather than memorized. Taxpayers who already renounced in a prior year without filing the form should know that the IRS maintains dedicated relief procedures for certain former citizens who fell out of compliance unknowingly, described on the IRS relief-procedures page, but those procedures are narrow, time-limited, and far less comfortable than filing correctly from the start. Second, the year of expatriation is a split year: income before the expatriation date is taxed under the citizen rules and income after it under the nonresident-alien rules, which means withholding, estimated payments, and treaty positions must be recomputed mid-year rather than carried over from the previous return. Model the deemed sale against ordinary sales spread across the final citizen years: realizing gains before expatriation sometimes beats concentrating them in the single deemed-sale year, depending on rates and the exclusion remaining available. Coordinating that split year with the French calendar, where the departure-year return covers French residence months and specific exit formalities, is where most do-it-yourself renunciations quietly fail.

B. The French Exit Tax If You Also Leave: Latent Gains Taxed at the Border

Renunciation alone triggers no French tax, because France does not tax the loss of a foreign nationality. Leaving France is a different event, and France has taxed departures for decades through its exit tax, now codified at article 167 bis of the CGI, on Légifrance. The mechanism targets taxpayers who were fiscally domiciled in France for at least six of the ten years before moving their tax domicile out of France: « Les contribuables fiscalement domiciliés en France pendant au moins six des dix années précédant le transfert de leur domicile fiscal hors de France sont imposables lors de ce transfert au titre des plus-values latentes constatées sur les droits sociaux, valeurs, titres ou droits mentionnés au 1 du I de l’article 150-0 A détenus, directement ou indirectement, par les membres de leur foyer fiscal à la date de ce transfert lorsque ces mêmes droits sociaux, valeurs, titres ou droits représentent au moins 50 % des bénéfices sociaux d’une société ou lorsque la valeur globale desdits droits sociaux, valeurs, titres ou droits, déterminée dans les conditions prévues au premier alinéa du 2, excède 800 000 € à cette même date. » In practice, an American who lived in France for eight years, renounces, and moves back to Texas with a portfolio of French and American securities worth over 800,000 euros faces immediate French taxation of the unrealized gains on that portfolio at the departure date, even though nothing was sold. Payment can be deferred while the securities are kept, under strict conditions of declaration, designation of a French tax representative, and guarantees securing the Treasury’s claim, with the tax ultimately cancelled if the assets are still held after a statutory holding period or collected if they are sold. The planning consequence is sharp: renounce while staying in France and article 167 bis sleeps; renounce and leave after a long French residence with a large portfolio, and France taxes the gains you have not yet realized.

The courts have repeatedly upheld this architecture against departing taxpayers. In a recent decision of the Conseil d’Etat, 15 December 2025, case number 495783, published on Légifrance, a couple that had moved its tax domicile to Switzerland in 1998 challenged the recovery of social contributions on deferred securities gains, arguing that the collection was time-barred. The court recalled the governing principle in the exact terms of the former article 167: « Lorsque le contribuable transfère son domicile hors de France, les plus-values de cession ou d’échange de valeurs mobilières ou de droits sociaux dont l’imposition a été reportée sont immédiatement imposables. » Transfer the domicile out, and deferred gains become immediately taxable. The court further noted that the payment deferral suspends the limitation period for collection until the triggering event, and it dismissed the appeal outright: « Le pourvoi de M. et Mme B… est rejeté. » The deferral is therefore a suspension, not an amnesty: the file follows the taxpayer for years, the guarantees must be arranged before departure, and a representative in France must remain reachable. Anyone combining renunciation with a move should set up the deferral file with the French tax office before the plane tickets, not after arrival.

Leaving France also rewrites the taxation of later French disposals. Gains on securities fall under article 150-0 A of the CGI, on Légifrance, which taxes « les gains nets retirés des cessions à titre onéreux, effectuées directement, par personne interposée ou par l’intermédiaire d’une fiducie », net gains from sales for consideration made directly, through an intermediary, or through a trust-like arrangement, a wording that reaches American revocable living trusts holding French assets, as explained in our analysis of American living trusts and French property. Once nonresident, securities gains connected with substantial French holdings fall under article 244 bis B of the CGI, on Légifrance: « les gains mentionnés à l’article 150-0 A résultant de la cession ou du rachat de droits sociaux […] réalisés par des personnes physiques qui ne sont pas domiciliées en France au sens de l’article 4 B » are computed under the standard securities-gains rules and subjected to a final withholding tax when the seller’s family group held over 25 percent of a company’s profit rights at any point in the previous five years. And departure does not end French paperwork for the final year: article 1649 A still requires declaring foreign accounts held during the year of departure, since it covers accounts « ouverts, détenus, utilisés ou clos à l’étranger », opened, held, used, or closed abroad, and article 1736 punishes each omission with « une amende de 1 500 € par compte ou avance non déclaré », 1,500 euros per undeclared account. Readers planning the sale of a French home around their departure will find the holding-period allowances and treaty credit mechanics in our guide to selling a French house as an American, which applies whether the seller stays French-resident or files as a nonresident.

The French deferral then lives or dies on follow-through. The statute grants automatic discharge of the exit-tax claim when the securities are still held after the required period, two years as a baseline and five years where the total value exceeded 2,570,000 euros at departure, provided the taxpayer files the yearly follow-up declaration and claims the discharge or refund for the gains concerned within the standard claim deadlines; missing the annual paperwork makes the deferred tax immediately collectible. Latent losses computed at departure cannot be set against latent gains or any other gains, so a mixed portfolio pays on its winners without relief for its losers. Narrow retirement exceptions exist for taxpayers who claimed pension rights before departure and sell within two years after retirement. And returning to France restarts the clock differently: a taxpayer who comes back does not erase the years abroad, which is why departure planning must model the round trip, not just the exit. Every one of these mechanics runs on French forms, French deadlines, and French-language correspondence with the tax office of the former residence, which is the practical reason departing Americans keep a French-speaking adviser for at least two full years after leaving.

Conclusion

Renunciation is a sequenced operation, and the order of operations is everything. First, reconstruct five years of perfect American compliance, because the certification test on Form 8854 punishes non-filers with the very covered-expatriate status they hoped to escape. Second, compute the American exit tax against the 890,000-dollar exclusion and the estate-tax trade from a generous citizen exemption to a 60,000-dollar nonresident filing threshold, asset by asset, including the Florida property and the American brokerage accounts you intend to keep. Third, confirm that France changes nothing on renunciation day: same nationality, same tax residence, same returns, same account declarations. Fourth, if departure from France follows, open the article 167 bis deferral file before leaving, designate the French representative, post the guarantees, and budget for the final-year declarations and any withholding on later French disposals. Done in this order, renunciation can end the yearly two-country paperwork for the right profile: a fully compliant taxpayer of moderate wealth, living in France indefinitely, holding few American assets. Done backwards, it produces an irrevocable certificate, an immediate deemed-sale bill, a suspended French claim, and the same audits as before. Keep a certified copy of the certificate for your French bank, which will update your file from American reportable person to former American and close the reporting loop opened years earlier. The consulate appointment lasts minutes; its preparation should take months.

📄 Official circular